Shows / True Crime with Gavin Fish
True Crime with Gavin Fish
Gavin Fish delivers in depth true crime analysis, investigative reporting, and real time case updates on the stories that matter most. From breaking developments in active murder investigations to deep dives into controversial deaths, court filings, and wrongful convictions, each episode examines the evidence, the timeline, and the unanswered questions. A journalist and researcher known for his detailed document review and relentless pursuit of clarity, Gavin covers both high profile national…
Episodes
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
The Murder of Windy Buchanan: Penny Doe Has Her Name Back, But Her Case Is Still Unsolved
After more than 36 years, the woman known as Clarion County’s Penny Doe has been identified as 19-year-old Windy Buchanan. Authorities say Buchanan’s remains…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
Ohio 16 Update: Records Show Children’s Services Knew About the Siders Family Years Earlier
Newly obtained Gallia County juvenile court records show child-welfare officials were investigating the Siders family as far back as December 2020, years…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
Ohio 16 Update: HUGE Charges Filed + Here's Why Some Charges Were Reduced in the Siders Family Case
A new indictment in the Siders family case adds another layer to what investigators say led them to the Hamden, Ohio, home where 16 children were found…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
As a New Reporter, I Tried and Failed to Identify Penny Doe. Now Police Say They've Succeeded.
Penny Doe, the unidentified woman found in Monroe Township, Pennsylvania, in 1990, may finally be identified after more than three decades. Hers was the first…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
Lindsay Clancy Trial: The Testimony That Could Decide Criminal Responsibility
Now that the Lindsay Clancy trial has shifted to the defense, it's now focused on the question at the center of the case: whether she was criminally…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
Ohio 16 Update: Prosecutor Says New Felony Charges Are Coming for Elizabeth Siders
New court records in the Ohio 16 case show prosecutors are opposing Elizabeth Siders’ request to modify her bond, arguing she remains a flight risk and a…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
From Lindsay Clancy to Luigi Mangione: A True Crime Week in Review
I'm happy to welcome back Hillbilly Crime for tonight's stream![CONNECT & SUPPORT]Listen on Spotify: https://gvnf.sh/spotifyFollow On my Social media:🌐…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
Lindsay Clancy Trial: Wonderful Mother, Toxicology, and the Real Question for the Jury
Lindsay Clancy Trial: The Searches, The Notes, and Her State of MindDay 13 of the Lindsay Clancy trial put her digital life in front of the jury, with…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
Ohio16 Update: Elizabeth Siders Ordered to Undergo Insanity and Competency Evaluation
New court records in the Ohio 16 case show that Elizabeth Siders has been ordered to undergo an in-person forensic evaluation to determine both whether she’s…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
OnlyFans Model Courtney Clenney Gets Sweetheart Deal After Boyfriend’s Killing
Courtney Clenney, the OnlyFans model once charged with second-degree murder in the stabbing death of Christian “Toby” Obumseli, has now pleaded guilty to…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
Clancy, Celeste, Nolan Wells, Siders Family & More: The True Crime Week We Need to Talk About
Some true crime weeks are shocking. This one was heartbreaking. Lindsay Clancy’s case still leaves a family and a courtroom trying to answer the worst possible…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
Dad Used His Daughter’s TikTok to Lure the Man Police Were Investigating. Now Both Men Are Charged.
Malik Chandler is facing charges after police say he used his 11-year-old daughter’s TikTok account to lure Diego Montoya Gonzalez to his Grove City home…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
Lindsay Clancy Trial: Wonderful Mother, Toxicology, and the Real Question for the Jury
Day 7 of testimony in the Lindsay Clancy murder trial sharpened the central dispute for jurors: whether the killings were deliberate acts of criminal intent or…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
Elizabeth Siders’ Defense Takes a Serious Mental Health Turn. Will Any Siders Adult Stand Trial?
Today, Elizabeth Siders became the latest grown-up in the Ohio 16 case to face a formal mental-health question in court. In an August 4, 2026 filing, her…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
D4vd Will Blame Celeste Rivas Hernandez at Murder Trial
D4vd is headed toward trial after a Los Angeles judge found enough evidence to move forward in the killing of 14-year-old Celeste Rivas Hernandez, but new…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
Ohio 16, Lindsay Clancy & Celeste Rivas: The True Crime Week We Need to Talk About
This true crime week brought major developments in several cases, from the Ohio 16 custody fight to Lindsay Clancy’s murder trial and the Celeste Rivas…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
Ohio 16: Judge Denies Sealing Request as Competency Fight Heats Up in Siders Case
New court filings in the Siders family case show the legal fight is moving into a new phase. A Vinton County judge denied Gary Siders Jr.’s request to seal his…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
Did Lindsay Clancy Know What She Was Doing? Murder, Mental Illness, and the Evidence
Lindsay Clancy is on trial in Massachusetts for the deaths of her three children, Cora, Dawson, and Callan, after prosecutors say she strangled them inside the…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
Ohio 16: Competency Evaluations for Three Siders Adults. Is Elizabeth Next?
New court filings add yet another turn in the Ohio 16 case: Christina Siders is now asking for a competency evaluation and a bond modification, meaning three…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
Ohio 16 Update: The Ballooning Cost Of Care And A Permanent State Custody Fight Begins
Ohio is reportedly seeking permanent custody of the 16 Siders kids as Vinton County asks for more money to handle the massive case, while Elizabeth Siders’…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
Ohio 16 Update: Gag Orders, Elizabeth Siders’ Custody Fight, and $1MM for the Kids
The Siders family case has moved into a new stage as gag orders limit what key people can say publicly, Elizabeth Siders has reportedly said she wants to…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
Elizabeth Siders Wants Her Children—The Ohio 16 Custody Fight Might Be Getting Started Already
Elizabeth Siders’ bond request has put a new question at the center of the Ohio “House of Horrors” case: what would have to happen before any kind of…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
D4vd Hearing: the Evidence Prosecutors Say Connects Him to Celeste Rivas Hernandez' Murder
The preliminary hearing in the case against David Anthony Burke, aka D4vd, is giving the public its first detailed look at the evidence prosecutors say ties…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
Siders Family Case: A New Jail Intake Detail Changes the Conversation Around Gary Siders Jr.'s Tox
New jail intake paperwork in the Siders family case includes a checked “yes” beside the question asking whether Gary Siders Jr. was under the influence or…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
Siders Family Case: Elizabeth Siders Walked Into Jail Unrestrained While the Others Were Shackled
Newly released sallyport video shows Elizabeth Siders walking into jail with no visible restraints while the other Siders defendants arrived in shackles…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
True Crime Catch-Up with Elizabeth Jones: Ellen Greenberg, Siders Family, Nolan Wells & More
Elizabeth Jones joins me for a true crime catch-up on the cases still raising the biggest questions this week, including the Siders family case, the Nolan…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
Nolan Wells Went on a July 4 Boating Trip. His Friends Came Back Without Him. So Suspicious!
Nolan Wells went on a July Fourth boating trip with friends to an uninhabited barrier island off the Mississippi coast, but the group returned without him, and…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
Fresh Look Inside the Siders' Home: New Images and Video Show the Conditions Investigators Found
Newly released images and video are giving a closer look inside the Siders family home in Hamden, Ohio. The footage adds new detail to the conditions…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
Siders Family Case: Judge Signs Gag Order Prohibiting Any More Public Comments
A judge has signed a gag order in the Siders family case after Gary Siders II’s defense argued that public comments from officials could prejudice his right to…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
Ohio 16 Update: A Timeline of How 16 Children Were Hidden From Family and Authorities
The investigation into the Siders family continues as new reporting lays out a timeline of where the family lived before authorities found 16 children in…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
Ohio 16 Update: Inside the Siders Home | Disturbing Photos Reveal the Conditions Investigators Found
The investigation into the Siders family continues to raise difficult questions as new details emerge about the conditions inside the Ohio home where…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
Ohio 16 Update: Elizabeth Siders Filed for Bond Modification. Here’s What the Motion Actually Says
New developments in the Ohio 16 case are drawing attention to a new bond filing from Elizabeth Siders, one of four family members charged after 16 children…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
Ohio 16 Update: Why Is Gary Siders “The Grandfather” Suddenly Out of Jail?
New developments in the Ohio 16 case are raising fresh questions about what happens next for the Siders family and the criminal cases now moving through Vinton…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
The Ohio House of Horror Wasn't the Beginning. It Started Years Earlier.
Newly uncovered records and interviews are providing a clearer picture of the Siders family long before authorities discovered 16 children living in horrific…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
16 Children, One House: The Ohio Family Horror That No One Saw Happening
Authorities in southeastern Ohio say they discovered 16 children living in shocking conditions inside a Vinton County home, leading to felony child…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
The Ransom Notes Were Fake? Everything Is Up for Debate. | The Nancy Guthrie Kidnapping
The investigation into Nancy Guthrie's disappearance has taken a major turn after the FBI concluded that the ransom notes at the center of the case were not…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
These Cases Shouldn't Be Connected, But They Are | Anna Kepner and Lynette Hooker
Two cases. Two very different circumstances. One disturbing thread that raises important questions about risk, violence, and the warning signs that are too…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
Anonymous Sender Claims Hidden Phone Has Video and Names in Nancy Guthrie Case
An anonymous sender has reportedly contacted TMZ claiming a hidden phone contains evidence in the Nancy Guthrie abduction case, including alleged video…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
Have We Been Duped? Experts Say Even 'Authenticated' Nancy Guthrie Ransom Notes Could Be Fake
Get in at https://www.fanathem.com/gavinfishDEADLINE “6/28/2026” @ 11:59 PM PSTExperts are challenging one of the most talked-about pieces of the Nancy Guthrie…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
It's Over: Ohio Supreme Court Rejects Mackenzie Shirilla's Final Appeal
Get in at https://www.fanathem.com/gavinfishDEADLINE “6/28/2026” @ 11:59 PM PSTThe Ohio Supreme Court has declined to hear Mackenzie Shirilla's latest appeal…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
Closing In on 'Porch Guy.' Did Investigators Miss Their Best Chance? | Nancy Guthrie Update
Get in at https://www.fanathem.com/gavinfishDEADLINE “6/28/2026” @ 11:59 PM PSTNew details in the Nancy Guthrie case are raising sharp questions about the…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
Brian Hooker in the Spotlight: Will Lynette Hooker Get Justice Without Knowing What Really Happened?
[CONNECT & SUPPORT]Listen on Spotify: https://gvnf.sh/spotifyFollow On my Social media:🌐 Website: https://gavinfish.com📸 Instagram…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
New Evidence Exposes Brian Hooker's Lies as the US Coast Guard Seizes Dinghy | Lynette Hooker Murder
The 8-foot dinghy that Brian Hooker says he and his wife, Lynette Hooker, were aboard when she disappeared in the Bahamas in early April has been seized by…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
Karen Read Files Explosive Lawsuit Against the Massachusetts State & Canton Police Departments
Karen Read’s new civil lawsuit accuses the Massachusetts State Police and Canton Police of negligence, bias, failed supervision, and a corrupt investigation…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
Coast Guard Searches for Lynette Hooker as Murder Case Deepens
The Lynette Hooker case may have started as a reported boating accident in the Bahamas, but the latest reporting suggests U.S. investigators are now treating…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
'Punch in the Gut' — Kouri Richins' Team Wants a New Trial, But They Say They Need More Time.
After Kouri Richins was convicted in her husband's murder, her team told Judge Mrazik they need more time to prepare a motion for a new trial. The defense says…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
The Timeline Problem—The Defense's SECRET WEAPON—Hidden in Sealed Court Doc | Murder of Anna Kepner
A newly unsealed court transcript in the federal case against Timothy Hudson shows the defense pushing hard on what may become one of the central problems in…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
Unsealed Doc Reveals Exactly What Prosecutors Say Happened to Anna Kepner on the Carnival Horizon
A newly unsealed court transcript in the federal case against Timothy Hudson lays out some of the clearest details yet about the murder of Anna Kepner aboard…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
It's More Personal Than Money—Why is this case still unsolved? | What Happened to Nancy Guthrie?
The disappearance of 84-year-old Nancy Guthrie, mother of TODAY co-anchor Savannah Guthrie, remains unsolved nearly four months after investigators say she was…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
Mackenzie Shirilla and the Attention Machine Behind Netflix's 'The Crash'
Tonight, I’m digging into Netflix’s The Crash, the documentary about Mackenzie Shirilla, the Ohio teenager convicted of murdering Dominic Russo and Davion…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
Live True Crime Conversation + Q&A with Special Guest Elizabeth Jones from Hillbilly Crime
Elizabeth Jones from Hillbilly Crime returns to the show for a live true crime conversation covering some of the biggest and most talked-about cases making…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
Judge Tosses All Charges Against Ebony Parker for School Shooting | Shooting of Abigail Zwerner
This is your last chance to get in at: https://fanathem.com/gavinfishDEADLINE: May 21, 2026 at 11:59 p.m. PST⬆️ ⬆️ I’m really excited to be teaming up with…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
Kouri Richins' Continued Deliberate Jailhouse Smear Campaign
Get in here: https://fanathem.com/gavinfishDEADLINE: May 21, 2026 at 11:59 p.m. PST⬆️ ⬆️ I’m really excited to be teaming up with veteran-owned small business…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
A Pregnant Woman Dead, Her Husband Missing, and an International Manhunt | Murder of Christa Gilley
Get in here: https://fanathem.com/gavinfishDEADLINE: May 21, 2026 at 11:59 p.m. PST⬆️ ⬆️ I’m really excited to be teaming up with veteran-owned small business…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
'Most Wanted Mom' Fled the Country While Her Son Was Missing | Murder of Noel Rodriguez-Alvarez
Get in here: https://fanathem.com/gavinfishDEADLINE: May 21, 2026 at 11:59 p.m. PST⬆️ ⬆️ I’m really excited to be teaming up with veteran-owned small business…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
D4vd's 'Friends' Lived a Fantasy as Celeste Decomposed Nearby | Murder of Celeste Rivas Hernandez
Get in here: https://fanathem.com/gavinfishDEADLINE: May 21, 2026 at 11:59 p.m. PST⬆️ ⬆️ I’m really excited to be teaming up with veteran-owned small business…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
Alex Murdaugh's Double Murder Conviction Overturned | SC Supreme Court: “Shocking Jury Interference”
Alex Murdaugh’s murder convictions have been overturned after the South Carolina Supreme Court unanimously ruled that jury interference by former Clerk of…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
D4vd Returns to Court as the Murder Case Moves Closer to Trial | Murder of Celeste Rivas Hernandez
Get in here: https://fanathem.com/gavinfishDEADLINE: May 21, 2026 at 11:59 p.m. PST⬆️ ⬆️ I’m really excited to be teaming up with veteran-owned small business…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
The JLR Investigates/Magnolia D.V. Case Looks Way Worse After Seeing the Bodycam Footage
Get in here: https://fanathem.com/gavinfishDEADLINE: May 21, 2026 at 11:59 p.m. PST⬆️ ⬆️ I’m really excited to be teaming up with veteran-owned small business…
- True Crime with Gavin Fish
D4vd’s Post Murder Interviews Sound Completely Different Now | Murder of Celeste Rivas Hernandez
D4vd went from making songs in a closet to becoming one of the fastest rising artists on the internet almost overnight. Now, people are revisiting an interview…