Shows / Reasonably Safir: Florida Criminal & Injury Caselaw

Reasonably Safir: Florida Criminal & Injury Caselaw
Every week Florida's appellate courts hand down decisions that change how your next case goes, and most of them slip by while you're in court. Reasonably Safir catches them.
Host Rory Safir is a Florida criminal defense and injury trial lawyer, and one of only six attorneys in the state designated a Forensic Lawyer-Scientist by the American Chemical Society's Chemistry and the Law Division. Each week he walks the newest rulings from the Florida Supreme Court and all six District Courts of…
Episodes
Reasonably Safir: Florida Criminal & Injury CaselawFirst Things First: Florida Caselaw, Week of November 13, 2026
This week’s Florida appellate decisions, covered case by case: the Florida Supreme Court receding from State v. Williams and reinstating a twenty-year…
Reasonably Safir: Florida Criminal & Injury CaselawSpeedy Trial, Separate Criminal Episodes and Bicycle Stops: Watch the Conduct (Florida Caselaw, Nov. 6, 2026)
This week’s Florida appellate decisions, covered case by case: a speedy trial discharge reversed because a cup of purple liquid within reach and drugs hidden…
Reasonably Safir: Florida Criminal & Injury CaselawMelbourne Jury Strike Reversed: Prove It on the Record (Florida Caselaw, Oct. 30, 2026)
This week’s Florida appellate decisions, covered case by case: a conviction reversed for a new trial because the State’s accepted reason for striking a Black…
Reasonably Safir: Florida Criminal & Injury CaselawWrongful Incarceration Claims and Punitive Damages Deadlines: Say It on Time (Florida Caselaw, Oct. 23, 2026)
This week’s Florida appellate decisions, covered case by case: a man sentenced to death in 2006 and acquitted by the Florida Supreme Court in 2009 gets his…
Reasonably Safir: Florida Criminal & Injury CaselawConstructive Possession in a Trafficking Case: Whose Is It (Florida Caselaw, Oct. 16, 2026)
This week’s Florida appellate decisions, covered case by case: trafficking convictions reversed with discharge because a key to someone else’s house and a key…
Reasonably Safir: Florida Criminal & Injury CaselawCrash Reconstruction Without an Expert in Vehicular Homicide: The Side Door (Florida Caselaw, Oct. 9, 2026)
This week’s Florida appellate decisions, covered case by case: two vehicular homicide convictions reversed because a detective’s speed calculation, built on…
Reasonably Safir: Florida Criminal & Injury CaselawResisting Without Violence and a Stop With No Basis: The Missing Element (Florida Caselaw, Oct. 2, 2026)
This week’s Florida appellate decisions, covered case by case: a man walking his two snakes, convicted of resisting a stop the deputies never had grounds to…
Reasonably Safir: Florida Criminal & Injury CaselawExcluded Defense Evidence and Medical Examiner Hearsay: What the Jury Hears (Florida Caselaw, Sept. 25, 2026)
This week’s Florida appellate decisions, covered case by case: a Sarasota sexual battery conviction reversed because the jury heard that the complainant…
Reasonably Safir: Florida Criminal & Injury CaselawProving a Probation Violation and a Life Care Plan: Show Your Work (Florida Caselaw, Sept. 18, 2026)
Two probation officers knocked at a Sarasota rooming house. Nobody answered, and a man received forty-five months in prison. Smith leads this week’s Florida…
Reasonably Safir: Florida Criminal & Injury CaselawWelfare Check or Seizure in a Sleeping Driver DUI: The Second Question (Florida Caselaw, Sept. 11, 2026)
This week’s Florida appellate decisions, covered case by case: deputies found a man asleep behind the wheel in a Hillsborough parking lot, and the whole case…
Reasonably Safir: Florida Criminal & Injury CaselawDUI Blood Draw Suppression Affirmed in State v. Marlin: The Shortcut Week (Florida Caselaw, Sept. 4, 2026)
This week's Florida appellate decisions, covered case by case: a driver refused a blood draw after a fatal Turnpike crash and the Fourth District affirmed…
Reasonably Safir: Florida Criminal & Injury CaselawErlinger and the Prison Releasee Reoffender Statute: The Wrong Door Week (Florida Caselaw, Aug. 28, 2026)
This week's Florida appellate decisions, covered case by case: the same Sixth Amendment sentencing argument turned away at two different doors in two different…
Reasonably Safir: Florida Criminal & Injury CaselawDouble Jeopardy and Blockburger in Florida: The Counting Week (Florida Caselaw, Aug. 21, 2026)
This week's Florida District Court of Appeal decisions, covered case by case: two counts of resisting arrest out of one continuous act at a high school, a…
Reasonably Safir: Florida Criminal & Injury CaselawHGN in Florida DUI Cases, Part 3: Three Days in a Classroom
What is actually inside the course that qualifies officers to give this test. I sat through it twice. If you're a defense lawyer and any of this is useful…
Reasonably Safir: Florida Criminal & Injury CaselawMissing Charging Documents and Good Faith Warrants: The Paperwork Week (Florida Caselaw, Aug. 14, 2026)
This week's Florida District Court of Appeal decisions, covered case by case: a conviction with no valid charging document behind it, a community control…
Reasonably Safir: Florida Criminal & Injury CaselawHGN in Florida DUI Cases, Part 2: Eighty Eight Percent, or Thirty Seven
One figure in one study produces both numbers. Which one gets said in court depends on who is talking. CHAPTERS 0:00 A number that decides these cases 0:35 The…
Reasonably Safir: Florida Criminal & Injury CaselawHGN in Florida DUI Cases, Part 1: The Eyes
The strangest piece of evidence in a Florida DUI case, and the only one nobody can review. Part one: what nystagmus actually is, the three clues, the…
Reasonably Safir: Florida Criminal & Injury CaselawThe One Who Checks: Cross-Examining an Officer on HGN and a Lazy Eye
A cop is on the witness stand, and I'm asking him to define a lazy eye. He can't. He's the government's expert on my client's eyes, and my client has one. This…