Latest / Reasonably Safir: Florida Criminal & Injury Caselaw

Excluded Defense Evidence and Medical Examiner Hearsay: What the Jury Hears (Florida Caselaw, Sept. 25, 2026)
This week’s Florida appellate decisions, covered case by case: a Sarasota sexual battery conviction reversed because the jury heard that the complainant accused her stepfather of abuse but never heard that the abuse was sexual, the one word the Second District said carried the defense. Plus PTSD evidence that needed an expert after Oquendo, the First District openly disagreeing with the Fourth on the abnormal mental condition instruction, a medical examiner allowed to relay an absent analyst’s toxicology, two traffic-stop decisions on exit orders and burned cannabis, a surcharge the State…
The skinny
The skinny isn't ready yet — notes appear once the transcript is processed.