Shows / Discussions With Dad: Faith, Blood and the In-Between

Discussions With Dad: Faith, Blood and the In-Between
Hosted by Tony Shaffer and Matthew Shaffer, a father and son having the conversations many families avoid. Tony, a lifelong Christian raised in a small rural town in Southern Colorado, brings a traditional, conservative perspective shaped by faith, service, and responsibility. Matthew, his gay son, is a writer, artist, and educator raised in Southern California who leans progressive, guided by creativity, lived experience, and empathy. Together, they explore faith, culture, politics, and…
The show, from its episodes
No episode notes yet. Recurring topics, people and starter picks will appear when notes are available.
Typical episode length
1h · median of 21 episodes with a known length
Solo / guest format
Unknown — existing notes name people mentioned, but do not identify hosts or guests.
Recurring topics
No recurring topics established yet.
Recurring people
No recurring people established yet.
Start here
No starter picks yet — no published episodes with audio and a recorded notes hook.
Episodes
Discussions With Dad: Faith, Blood and the In-BetweenEpisode 21: When Faith Costs Us Belonging
Matthew and Tony explore how faith shapes whom we trust, whom we support, and where we draw the line. Why can shared beliefs lead to opposing choices—and why…
Discussions With Dad: Faith, Blood and the In-BetweenEpisode 20: What Does Our Support Buy?
With elections bringing competing promises into focus, Matthew and Tony explore what they expect from the leaders, alliances, and economic systems they…
Discussions With Dad: Faith, Blood and the In-BetweenEpisode 19: What Are We Taking for Granted?
Matthew and Tony bring unfinished conversations back to the kitchen table, exploring how everyday choices reveal the principles people live by. Through humor…
Discussions With Dad: Faith, Blood and the In-BetweenEpisode 18: Who Is Responsible Before It’s Too Late?
Matthew and Tony examine the gap between recognizing a problem and taking responsibility for it. Through current events, regional differences, and the promise…
Discussions With Dad: Faith, Blood and the In-BetweenEpisode 17: What Happens When Tolerance Challenges Freedom?
Matthew challenges Tony to define where protecting freedom ends and taking justice into your own hands begins. What starts with Tony’s warning that people may…
Discussions With Dad: Faith, Blood and the In-BetweenEpisode 16: When Certainty Feels Safer Than Truth
Matthew asks Tony why people would rather be certain and wrong than uncertain and still thinking. Beginning with their own convictions, father and son examine…
Discussions With Dad: Faith, Blood and the In-BetweenEpisode 15: The Boy You Thought I’d Be
Matthew asks Tony when he first realized his son would not grow up to be like him—and what it meant to raise a boy who loved dance at a time when masculinity…
Discussions With Dad: Faith, Blood and the In-BetweenEpisode 14: When Certainty Gets in the Way
Matthew and Tony examine what happens when confidence in institutions begins to erode. From environmental predictions and political messaging to scientific…
Discussions With Dad: Faith, Blood and the In-BetweenEpisode 13: When Conviction Meets Family
Matthew and Tony revisit one of the most defining conversations of their lives: Matthew's coming out. Sharing the same Christian faith but arriving at…
Discussions With Dad: Faith, Blood and the In-BetweenEpisode 12: Growing Pains: When the Country Outgrows the Family Story
Summary As America approaches its 250th birthday, Matthew and Tony ask what we are called to preserve, what we are being asked to outgrow, and how families…
Discussions With Dad: Faith, Blood and the In-BetweenEpisode 11: When Protection Become Control
As Father's Day approaches, Matthew and Tony discuss what fathers leave behind for the next generation: not inheritance, but values. Along the way, they…
Discussions With Dad: Faith, Blood and the In-BetweenEpisode 10: What Holds Us Together?
Sorry listeners! We're two days late in posting our podcast this week. Dad is on a motorcycle in D.C. and I'm on the island of Maui, without further delay here…
Discussions With Dad: Faith, Blood and the In-BetweenEpisode 9: When Belief Becomes Identity
When belief moves beyond ideas and becomes identity, disagreement can feel less like a difference of opinion and more like a personal threat. Matthew and Tony…
Discussions With Dad: Faith, Blood and the In-BetweenEpisode 8: When Trust Breaks Down
Trust is harder to sustain in a world shaped by competing headlines, social media, and constant outrage. Matthew and Tony explore what happens when…
Discussions With Dad: Faith, Blood and the In-BetweenEpisode 7: When the World Changed Faster Than Our Language
Language is shifting faster than ever—shaped by social media, generational change, and evolving ideas of identity. In this conversation, Matthew and Tony…
Discussions With Dad: Faith, Blood and the In-BetweenEpisode 6: What Makes a Man?
We’ve spent time exploring belief, disagreement, and what we owe each other—but this time, we bring it back to something more personal. As a father and son, we…
Discussions With Dad: Faith, Blood and the In-BetweenEpisode 5: As Americans, What Do We Owe Each Other?
“If freedom means we can live differently, what do we still owe each other as Americans?” We’ve explored why conversations matter, how belief shapes facts, why…
Discussions With Dad: Faith, Blood and the In-BetweenEpisode 4: What Is Freedom?
In Episodes 1–3, we explored why conversations matter, how belief shapes facts, and why disagreement now feels like rejection. This week, we take on a word…
Discussions With Dad: Faith, Blood and the In-BetweenEpisode 3: When Disagreement Didn’t Feel Like Rejection
From Episodes 1 and 2, we’ve explored how disagreement becomes dangerous when facts and beliefs are filtered through fear, lived experience, and identity. What…
Discussions With Dad: Faith, Blood and the In-BetweenEpisode 2: What We Learned Before We Knew What We Believed
In this episode, we unpack how facts don’t exist in a vacuum—they’re filtered through faith, culture, fear, and lived experience. Acknowledging what we don’t…
Discussions With Dad: Faith, Blood and the In-BetweenEpisode 1: Conversations: Why They Matter to Us
In their first episode, Tony Shaffer, a conservative Christian father and his gay son, Matthew Shaffer—an artist and educator—begin an honest dialogue about…