Shows / Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
What makes a case remain unsolved long after the first questions were asked? Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases explores puzzling events that continue to resist a clear explanation and the details that keep those mysteries alive.
We follow the evidence without forcing an answer where none is confirmed. As you listen with us, you can examine the gaps that matter and see how one overlooked detail can change the way an entire case is understood.
We publish new episodes daily so you can return to…
Episodes
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Letter in the Ditch: Twenty Years That Hid a Grave
The Letter in the Ditch: Twenty Years That Hid a Grave A sealed letter describing a grave sat in a roadside ditch for nearly twenty years, postmarked June 3…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Folded Hands Nobody Could Explain - The Missing Binder Clue
The Folded Hands Nobody Could Explain - The Missing Binder Clue A woman was found upright in two feet of water with her hands folded palm-over-palm - a posture…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Dry Sock, The Sealed Envelope, and the Man Who Came Back
The Dry Sock, The Sealed Envelope, and the Man Who Came Back A dry white business envelope stood upright on a dead man's foot inside a drainage culvert…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Basket, The Keychain, The Woman Who Lied at Dawn
The Basket, The Keychain, The Woman Who Lied at Dawn A staged wicker basket with a stopped Timex and a brass compass keychain was found tucked in a hidden…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Shoe on the Bumper: How a Clay Smear Cracked Silence
The Shoe on the Bumper: How a Clay Smear Cracked Silence A single brown leather shoe was found standing upright on a van bumper in eleven-degree air on…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Watch on the Ice: Who Laid the Board Over Pelham Reservoir?
The Watch on the Ice: Who Laid the Board Over Pelham Reservoir? A man’s watch was found running on the ice, crystal unscratched and band buckled, surrounded by…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
placement - noted by Nelson as unexplainable by materials expert
placement - noted by Nelson as unexplainable by materials expert A preserved leather handbag sat in river silt for roughly thirty-two years with a Missouri…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
A Watch Still Running: The Disappearance of Gordon Meyer
A Watch Still Running: The Disappearance of Gordon Meyer A stainless Seiko wristwatch was found face up on a limestone shelf in Shelter Basin State Forest, its…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Well That Hid a Son: How a Codicil Covered a Murder
The Well That Hid a Son: How a Codicil Covered a Murder The silence that kept a man missing for twenty-three years began with a will and a codicil that…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
They Hid a Man in the Harbor Wall - Eighteen Years of Silence
They Hid a Man in the Harbor Wall - Eighteen Years of Silence A cold, wrong-colored patch of mortar in a nineteenth-century harbor wall hid a secret for…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Shoe on the Desk: How Kelly's Walk Became a Murder Trail
The Shoe on the Desk: How Kelly's Walk Became a Murder Trail A single canvas sneaker sat upright on a reception desk at 5:40 a.m. on August 9, 1991, while…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Strawberry Purse on County Road 14: A Hidden Fingerprint
The Strawberry Purse on County Road 14: A Hidden Fingerprint A child's strawberry-shaped purse turned up on the shoulder of County Road 14 in February 1990…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
Ledger in the Culvert: The Hidden Debt That Buried Lauren Ford
Ledger in the Culvert: The Hidden Debt That Buried Lauren Ford A dry, cloth-covered ledger stood upright inside a 36-inch concrete culvert weeks after Lauren…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Dry Shoe on the Sluice Gate: Secret Prep, Two Murders
The Dry Shoe on the Sluice Gate: Secret Prep, Two Murders A dry white sneaker with a pink stripe sat upright on a sluice gate six feet above the water, its…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Glass King: How a Pale Chess Piece Framed a Judge's Murder
The Glass King: How a Pale Chess Piece Framed a Judge's Murder A small pale green hand-blown glass chess king sat between the dead judge's hands while the…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Night the Flashlight Stayed On: Unlocking a 1971 Murder Mystery
The Night the Flashlight Stayed On: Unlocking a 1971 Murder Mystery A cold flashlight beam left pointing at the baseboard, a payroll disbursement box opened…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Green Ledger: Names, Doses, and a Mechanic Called Wayne
The Green Ledger: Names, Doses, and a Mechanic Called Wayne Cold clay, a three-year-old dog, and a warped green ledger that recorded nineteen entries from 1988…