Shows / Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
What makes a case remain unsolved long after the first questions were asked? Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases explores puzzling events that continue to resist a clear explanation and the details that keep those mysteries alive.
We follow the evidence without forcing an answer where none is confirmed. As you listen with us, you can examine the gaps that matter and see how one overlooked detail can change the way an entire case is understood.
We publish new episodes daily so you can return to…
Episodes
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
A Dry Bag in a Flooded Yard: The Disappearance of Peggy Davis
A Dry Bag in a Flooded Yard: The Disappearance of Peggy Davis A green canvas tote bag, perfectly dry, was found against a cinderblock wall after a storm on…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
Glasses on His Chest: The Bridge That Didn't Tell the Truth
Glasses on His Chest: The Bridge That Didn't Tell the Truth A man's reading glasses, placed open and perfectly level on his sternum and not his prescription…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Bill on Her Back Door: Fraud That Framed a Murder
The Bill on Her Back Door: Fraud That Framed a Murder A utility bill propped against a back door changed the course of a disappearance: a February statement…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Folded Blanket: Neighbor's Calls, A Door That Opened Itself
The Folded Blanket: Neighbor's Calls, A Door That Opened Itself A folded gray wool blanket, corners tucked and edge smoothed, lay over Donna Wallace when a…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Seat Pushed Back: How a Forgotten Ping Broke Silence
The Seat Pushed Back: How a Forgotten Ping Broke Silence A single cell-tower ping from 9:14 PM guided detectives to a storage facility that had been ignored…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
Padlocked Tackle Box: The Finger That Announced Norman Hunt's Disappearance
Padlocked Tackle Box: The Finger That Announced Norman Hunt's Disappearance The chill image of a padlocked tackle box left upright on a cypress root held a…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Watch in the Dirt: How a 1991 Disappearance Unraveled
The Watch in the Dirt: How a 1991 Disappearance Unraveled A frost-covered hand wearing a cracked-crystal watch was unearthed on December 4, 2023 - the single…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The November Receipt: How a Probe Unearthed a Hidden Conviction
The November Receipt: How a Probe Unearthed a Hidden Conviction A vanished nurse, a folded Harwick County Utilities receipt, and a probe that struck something…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
Dry Paper in a Soaking Bag: The Will That Couldn't Sink
Dry Paper in a Soaking Bag: The Will That Couldn't Sink Dry paper inside a soaking leather bag: a eight-page will, crisp in a zip-lock, waited 28 years at the…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
After 23 years inside a harbor wall, a dead man's watch was still keeping time
After 23 years inside a harbor wall, a dead man's watch was still keeping time The idea that a watch could survive twenty-three years sealed inside a granite…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Receipt in the Shoe: How a Quiet Man Hid a Murder
The Receipt in the Shoe: How a Quiet Man Hid a Murder A single canvas sneaker half-buried on County Road 7 held a dry-cleaning receipt addressed to a man who…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Lunchbox in the Creek: Ransom Left to Rot for Decades
The Lunchbox in the Creek: Ransom Left to Rot for Decades A child’s pink lunchbox, fused to a sapling and buried in a dry Millhaven creek bed for roughly…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Upright Shoe: How a Tiny Clue Broke a 19-Year Murder Mystery
The Upright Shoe: How a Tiny Clue Broke a 19-Year Murder Mystery A single pale blue canvas slip-on, size seven, was found perfectly upright in a drainage…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Yellow Lunchbox, a Missing Hand, and a Secret Witness
The Yellow Lunchbox, a Missing Hand, and a Secret Witness A woman's amputated left hand was found inside a yellow barn lunch box left on a back step at 6:47 AM…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Carnation on Her Desk: Poison Hidden in Plain Sight
The Carnation on Her Desk: Poison Hidden in Plain Sight A quiet courthouse visit left a judge dead at her desk with a warm cup of coffee and a single white…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Polaroid That Unmasked a Killer After 51 Years
The Polaroid That Unmasked a Killer After 51 Years A single Polaroid, sealed in wax paper and buried under leaves for fifty-one years, survived weather and…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Amber Bottle That Rewrote a Nurse's Death (Hidden Thallium)
The Amber Bottle That Rewrote a Nurse's Death (Hidden Thallium) A fisherman found an amber prescription bottle looped on his trotline after floodwaters carried…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Watch at the Fence: 35 Years Someone Waited to Be Found
The Watch at the Fence: 35 Years Someone Waited to Be Found A rotten leather watch, its crystal intact and engraved "For Susan - always finding the time. Love…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Purse in the Tank: How 36 Years of Lies Unraveled
The Purse in the Tank: How 36 Years of Lies Unraveled Fear that a lifetime of certainty can collapse in a single discovery: a leather purse upright on the…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Piggy Bank That Proved a Nineteen‑Year Arson Secret
The Piggy Bank That Proved a Nineteen‑Year Arson Secret A single photograph of a pink ceramic piggy bank upright on a concrete slab reopened a case that had…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Gate Open, The Shoe Upright: Who Set Lori Down?
The Gate Open, The Shoe Upright: Who Set Lori Down? A small, pale yellow sneaker sat perfectly upright on a dock while a padlocked gate stood open and Lori…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
Sneaker in Concrete: How a Packing Plant Hid a Girl for 36 Years
Sneaker in Concrete: How a Packing Plant Hid a Girl for 36 Years A single child’s sneaker stopped a grader blade at 2:07 p.m., revealing remains that would…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Single Monogrammed Shoe: What It Hid For Nineteen Years
The Single Monogrammed Shoe: What It Hid For Nineteen Years The sight of a single brown leather dress shoe, size eleven, monogrammed D.P., perched alone on a…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Shoes on the Culvert: Why the Insulin Vanished and Murderwaits
The Shoes on the Culvert: Why the Insulin Vanished and Murderwaits A neat pair of white canvas shoes, laces tucked, toes pointed toward the trail - placed on a…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Steaming Mug and the Letter That Confessed Two Murders
The Steaming Mug and the Letter That Confessed Two Murders A cold kitchen, a white ceramic mug still steaming on the porch, and a handwritten letter that…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Red Bowl: How One Object Broke a Closed Death Mystery
The Red Bowl: How One Object Broke a Closed Death Mystery A single red ceramic mixing bowl sat perfectly centered on the roof of a car angled nose-down into a…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Shoes That Weren't Hers: A 16-Year Unanswered Goodbye
The Shoes That Weren't Hers: A 16-Year Unanswered Goodbye An ordinary goodnight call, a body six feet from two carefully placed tan shoes that did not belong…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The House Knew: Nineteen Years Hidden in a Crawlspace Panel
The House Knew: Nineteen Years Hidden in a Crawlspace Panel The first detail that jolts you: Gloria Dalton's coffee was still warm at 6:45 AM on March 3, 2003…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
Watch on the Cedar Post: The Nurse Who Vanished at Dawn
Watch on the Cedar Post: The Nurse Who Vanished at Dawn A running brown leather wristwatch was found wound in two loops on a gray cedar post, its face frozen…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Badge That Shouldn't Exist: How Shelby Creek Lied to Killers
The Badge That Shouldn't Exist: How Shelby Creek Lied to Killers A laminated badge found on a murder victim’s chest in 1973 carried a name and a lamination…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
Skull in the Clay: The 32‑Year Secret on Cellar Road
Skull in the Clay: The 32‑Year Secret on Cellar Road A skull sitting upright in fresh clay, forty feet from a construction road, waited thirty-two years for…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Forgotten Tape That Sent a Killer to Prison After 33 Years
The Forgotten Tape That Sent a Killer to Prison After 33 Years A single four-minute twenty-second microcassette sat untouched in a detective's box for…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Purse in the Snow: How a Notary's Stamp Brought Her Home
The Purse in the Snow: How a Notary's Stamp Brought Her Home Cold proof in deep snow: a burgundy leather handbag with a Missouri driver's license for Rebecca…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Harbor's Hidden Skeleton: Lobsterman Found Sealed in Wall
The Harbor's Hidden Skeleton: Lobsterman Found Sealed in Wall The calm of a Maine harbor hid a 23-year secret until Tropical Storm Bette peeled open a seawall…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
Watch Stopped at 11:47: The Jar That Reopened a Murder
Watch Stopped at 11:47: The Jar That Reopened a Murder The discovery of a mason jar on a roadside marker in August 2022 held a crisp 1991 document and a Seiko…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Dry Shoe on Birchmore Lane: What It Hid for 31 Years
The Dry Shoe on Birchmore Lane: What It Hid for 31 Years A dry pink canvas sneaker with a hand-drawn yellow daisy and a folded $400 bill tucked under the…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Barn Watch: 17 Years, One Key, A Ruled Accident Reopened
The Barn Watch: 17 Years, One Key, A Ruled Accident Reopened A perfectly preserved Seiko watch, hands stopped at 10:02, is found in the dirt of a barn that had…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Brass Key: How One Odd Clue Broke a Cold Murder
The Brass Key: How One Odd Clue Broke a Cold Murder A dead woman found with a brass key standing upright between her fingers - a detail so precise it froze a…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Calendar That Proved a Judge's "Suicide" Was Murder
The Calendar That Proved a Judge's "Suicide" Was Murder A river returned a clean, unreadable-by-water leather calendar that belonged to a judge declared dead…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Door Left Four Inches Open: A Payroll Bag's Cold Truth
The Door Left Four Inches Open: A Payroll Bag's Cold Truth A rusted chain, a steel door ajar by four inches, and a payroll bag stamped HARWICK COUNTY PAYROLL…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
Buried Ledger, Secret Dose: Who Killed Denise Gardner?
Buried Ledger, Secret Dose: Who Killed Denise Gardner? A buried pharmacy ledger held in a plastic container for decades names patients, compounds and a…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Library Tote in the Maple: Proof of a Hidden Killer
The Library Tote in the Maple: Proof of a Hidden Killer A pale blue Millhaven Public Library tote was found eight feet up a silver maple over unbroken…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Purse on the Stoop: Who Kept Amy Mueller's Secret 40 Years
The Purse on the Stoop: Who Kept Amy Mueller's Secret 40 Years A dry burgundy handbag, upright and undamaged after forty years, appears on the stoop of an…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Upright Boot: Why a Standing Shoe Haunted a Burned Depot
The Upright Boot: Why a Standing Shoe Haunted a Burned Depot A single work boot - size eleven, right foot only, laces double-knotted and standing upright on…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Purse on the Spillway: How a 27-Year Secret Broke Open
The Purse on the Spillway: How a 27-Year Secret Broke Open Something deliberate and precise broke a 27-year silence: a dark burgundy purse, open and bone-dry…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Sneaker in the Crack: How Kellerman Hid Rachel for 37 Years
The Sneaker in the Crack: How Kellerman Hid Rachel for 37 Years A single white sneaker, standing upright with laces tucked in, led a runner to a concrete crack…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Coffee on the Roof and the Glasses That Screamed Murder
The Coffee on the Roof and the Glasses That Screamed Murder A half-full cup of coffee left on a car roof, a dead flip phone on the floor, and a woman who…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
A Watch Inside a Sealed Pipe: The Murder of Julie Johnson
A Watch Inside a Sealed Pipe: The Murder of Julie Johnson A yellow-gold Seiko watch, face-up and unscratched, sits inside a bolted corrugated culvert four…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Letter That Waited 20 Years Above Sable Creek
The Letter That Waited 20 Years Above Sable Creek An anonymous letter postmarked June 2002 arrived in March 2022 describing, in precise detail, a dead man, a…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Shoe on the Trotline: Coin-Sized Bruise That Broke Delray
The Shoe on the Trotline: Coin-Sized Bruise That Broke Delray A single white canvas sneaker, size seven, with a seam repaired in purple thread turned up on a…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Shoe, The Key, and the Secret They Hid Nineteen Years
The Shoe, The Key, and the Secret They Hid Nineteen Years A canvas shoe stood upright in an Illinois field for nineteen years with a brass house key tied…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Watch in the Septic Shaft: Who Buried Dawn Fisher?
The Watch in the Septic Shaft: Who Buried Dawn Fisher? A gold-toned dress watch sat four feet below ground on a concrete shelf inside a septic access shaft…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Technician Who Knocked Twice: A Quiet Life, Brutally Taken
The Technician Who Knocked Twice: A Quiet Life, Brutally Taken A routine Tuesday rescheduled to a safety inspection, a woman with $47 in her wallet and every…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Glove That Stayed Silent for Thirty-One Years
The Glove That Stayed Silent for Thirty-One Years Cold alley, a neatly placed men's dress glove, and a fourteen-year-old paperboy who ran four blocks to the…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
Library Card in Clay: Murder, a Missing Wrench, and a 32-Year Silence
Library Card in Clay: Murder, a Missing Wrench, and a 32-Year Silence A human femur turned up in clay during a road expansion, pressed with a laminated library…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Dry Shoe at Dawn: How a Storm Hid a Killer's Return
The Dry Shoe at Dawn: How a Storm Hid a Killer's Return A single dry navy-blue woman's dress shoe, size seven, sat on a field frozen under six millimeters of…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Wallet in the Ditch: How a Will Hid a Murder
The Wallet in the Ditch: How a Will Hid a Murder The same four-mile loop, the same 5:45 start, and a leather wallet half-buried in a four-foot-wide…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
Sealed Purse, Unopened Bandages: The Harbor Secret Revealed
Sealed Purse, Unopened Bandages: The Harbor Secret Revealed A sealed pharmacy bag dated September 14, 1993 sat untouched inside a burgundy purse found behind a…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Key on Her Chest: Land, Lies, and a 29-Year Cover-Up
The Key on Her Chest: Land, Lies, and a 29-Year Cover-Up A young woman found face-up in tall grass with a rental car key on her chest and no visible marks - a…
- Mystery Stories and Unsolved Cases
The Shoe in the Drain: Why He Waited Thirty Years
The Shoe in the Drain: Why He Waited Thirty Years A child's red-and-white canvas shoe, laces white and clean, stood upright in a storm drain after thirty-one…