Shows / The McShay Show
The McShay Show
Longtime NFL draft and college football analyst Todd McShay brings you inside his unique world as an NFL talent evaluator. From the college football season through draft night, Todd and his cohost, Steve Muench, track the top prospects, share insider intel, and break down their latest mock drafts.New episodes drop every Monday, Wednesday, and Friday as they prepare you for the NFL draft with in-depth analysis, player evaluations, and the latest buzz from around the NFL. Don’t miss special…
Episodes
- The McShay Show
Is Arch Manning the Real Deal? Let’s Check the Tape!
Welcome back to The McShay Show! Todd and Steve are kicking off their Summer Scouting Series, and the first player on the docket is Texas’s Arch Manning. The…
- The McShay Show
Our Favorite Picks From Every Round of the 2025 NFL Draft
Welcome to The McShay Show! Todd and Steve close the door on the 2025 NFL draft with their favorite picks from every round. The guys talk best values…
- The McShay Show
Drafting the Top NFC Impact Offensive Rookies
Welcome back to The McShay Show! The guys are drafting who they think will be the top impact offensive skill position rookies from the NFC! Which players will…
- The McShay Show
Drafting the Top AFC High-Impact Offensive Rookies
Welcome back to The McShay Show! The guys are drafting who they think will be the top high-impact offensive skill position rookies in the AFC! Which players…
- The McShay Show
Self-Scouting the 2025 NFL Draft: Where We Were Wrong (If the NFL Is Right)
Welcome to The McShay Show! Todd and Steve are back with an NFL draft retrospective. Who was drafted earlier than the guys expected? Who went later? They…
- The McShay Show
Way-Too-Early 2026 NFL Mock Draft: Nussmeier Goes No. 1, Rams Trade Up for Their QB of the Future
Welcome back to The McShay Show! The guys are back with a sneak peek of next year’s prospect class. There are quarterbacks, trades, and a handful of…
- The McShay Show
NFL Draft Recap: Favorite Picks and Full Class Breakdowns for All 32 Teams
Welcome back to The McShay Show! The guys go team by team to evaluate every class in the 2025 NFL draft. They give their favorite picks, team fits, and…
- The McShay Show
LIVE: Shedeur Sanders lands in Cleveland and other NFL Draft Reactions with Ryen Russillo | The McShay Show
Join Todd, Muench, and Russillo for their LIVE reactions to Shedeur Sanders being drafted by the Browns and other NFL Draft Reactions with Ryen Russillo The…
- The McShay Show
LIVE NFL Draft Day 2 Recap and Analysis! Reaction to Shedeur Falling to Day 3 | The McShay Show
Join Todd and Muench's LIVE reactions to all of the day 2 picks of the 2025 NFL Draft! We will get started with a few picks left in the third round to recap…
- The McShay Show
LIVE NFL Draft 2nd Round Preview + Analysis!
Todd's LIVE reactions to start the 2nd round of the 2025 NFL Draft!!! We will get started a half hour before round 2 begins and stay online through the firs 50…
- The McShay Show
LIVE NFL Draft 1st Round Analysis! Plus, Bill Simmons Joins! | The McShay Show
Todd and Muench's LIVE reactions to every single pick of the 1st round in the 2025 NFL Draft!!! We will get started an hour before the first pick and stay…
- The McShay Show
Mock Draft 4.0! One Quarterback Trade, Two Top-10 Surprises, and All the Latest Intel.
Welcome back to The McShay Show! The guys are breaking down all 32 first-round picks in Todd’s Mock Draft 4.0, which is free on The McShay Report for everyone…
- The McShay Show
News or Noise, and Todd’s Final Big Board! Plus, Talking Draft Day With Richmond Spider Legend Joe Douglas.
Welcome back to The McShay Show! Todd and Steve open by breaking down the latest draft news, including whether the Browns would consider trading down from no…
- The McShay Show
The Top-10 Domino Effect: How Jalon Walker and a Run on Edge Rushers Could Shake Up the First Round
Welcome back to The McShay Show! Todd and Steve are breaking down all the potential draft scenarios in the top 10, including what it could mean for the Bears…
- The McShay Show
What I’m Hearing: Edge Rushers Rising and Two Top-Five Shake-Ups. Plus, QB2 in Round 2?
Welcome back to The McShay Show! It’s draft week in the NFL, and Todd has plenty of intel from league circles to break down. What’s the latest on the QB…
- The McShay Show
The Draft Mailbag Special!
Welcome back to The McShay Show! Todd and Steve open up the mailbag and answer questions from listeners on Instagram, Twitter, and The McShay Report…
- The McShay Show
The Team Needs Dueling Mock Draft! Three Rounds, 102 Picks, Endless Chaos.
Welcome back to The McShay Show! Todd and Steve are matching players and teams in their inaugural dueling mock draft. The guys go through all 32 teams…
- The McShay Show
What I’m Hearing on Shedeur Sanders and Will Johnson. Plus, Offensive Line Tiers, Comps, and Tape Study.
Welcome back to The McShay Show! Todd and Steve open by reacting to Michigan CB Will Johnson’s predraft workout and what it could mean for his draft stock…
- The McShay Show
Mock Draft 3.0! A New Orleans Dart Throw, the Colorado-to-Cleveland Pipeline, and Todd’s Favorite Team Fits.
Welcome back to The McShay Show! The guys go pick-by-pick in the first round, talking quarterback trades, team fits, best values, and the most surprising…
- The McShay Show
Todd’s All-Satellite Team, the Latest NFL Draft Buzz, and a Defensive Back Deep Dive
Welcome back to The McShay Show! Todd and Steve open by reacting to the latest NFL draft buzz, including Jalen Milroe’s reported draft day plan and why Travis…
- The McShay Show
Colorado Pro Day Instant Reactions: A Shedeur Sanders Stock Watch and the Great Travis Hunter Debate
Welcome back to The McShay Show! Todd and Steve fire up the mics for a quick 20 minutes to break down every angle of Shedeur Sanders’s workout at the Colorado…
- The McShay Show
Todd’s Top 150 Big Board! Risers, Fallers, Team Fits, and More. Plus, a Linebacker Deep Dive.
Welcome back to The McShay Show! Todd's updated Top 150 Big Board is out! He and Steve kick off with a look into his top 15 players, Shedeur Sanders’s status…
- The McShay Show
Breaking Down the Latest QB Draft Buzz. Plus, a Defensive Line Deep Dive.
Welcome back to The McShay Show! Todd and Steve open by discussing the latest quarterback draft rumors and making sense of the betting odds for Jaxson Dart and…
- The McShay Show
The Quarterback Deep Dive: Tiers, Traits, Comps, and Tape Study. Plus, Could the Giants Still Draft a QB After Signing Russell Wilson?
Welcome back to The McShay Show! Todd and Steve open by breaking down the Giants’ Russell Wilson signing and what the move could mean for New York’s draft…
- The McShay Show
The Pass Catcher Deep Dive: Tiers, Comps, and Tape Study
Welcome back to ‘The McShay Show’! Todd and Steve open by analyzing some of the latest smoke in the draft world, including whether the Giants brass attending…
- The McShay Show
Mock Draft 2.0! Talking Top Five Picks, Jaxson Dart’s First-Round Buzz, and More!
Welcome back to ‘The McShay Show’! The guys are back to break down Todd’s post-combine mock draft. They start by breaking down different scenarios in the top…
- The McShay Show
Shedeur to the Browns? Plus, the 2025 Running Back Deep Dive
Welcome back to The McShay Show! Todd and Steve open by breaking down Shedeur Sanders’s fit with the Browns, and whether the team would be smart to select him…
- The McShay Show
Todd’s Updated Top 100 Big Board! Cam, Shedeur, and the QB Carousel
Welcome back to ‘The McShay Show’! Todd kicks off the show with the latest rumblings he’s hearing about the quarterback market and how it might shake up where…
- The McShay Show
NFL Free Agency First Impressions! Breaking Down the Latest Quarterback Moves, Trades, and More.
Welcome back to ‘The McShay Show’! Todd opens by reacting to the Geno Smith trade and what the move means for the Raiders and the Seahawks. Then, the guys sift…
- The McShay Show
Todd’s Updated Top 32 Big Board! QBs Rise, Team Needs, and Where are the DTs?!
Welcome back to ‘The McShay Show’! Todd and Muench start the show with the Bears’ trading for offensive lineman Joe Thuney and Jonah Jackson and what it means…
- The McShay Show
Risers, Fallers, and Understanding the Quarterback Landscape After the NFL Combine. Plus, Talking Life After the Super Bowl With Eagles GM Howie Roseman.
Welcome back to ‘The McShay Show’! Todd opens by sharing some intel from the NFL combine, including what teams are saying about Shedeur Sanders, Cam Ward, and…
- The McShay Show
NFL Combine WR & RB Reactions: Is Matthew Golden the New WR1? Plus, The Running Back Class Shows Out.
Welcome back to ‘The McShay Show’! Todd and Steve open the show by breaking down the record-breaking combine results from this year’s running back class…
- The McShay Show
NFL Combine Day 3 Reactions: Nick Emmanwori’s Historic Performance and Maxwell Hairston’s Big Day. Plus, An Exclusive Interview with Louisville QB Tyler Shough.
Welcome back to ‘The McShay Show’! Todd and Steve open by reacting to South Carolina safety Nick Emmanwori’s all-time workout and what it could mean for his…
- The McShay Show
Day 2 NFL Combine Reactions: Defensive Line Winners and What to Make of Abdul Carter’s Injury.
Welcome back to ‘The McShay Show’! Todd and Steve are LIVE from Indianapolis to talk all the latest news from around the NFL. They open by discussing Abdul…
- The McShay Show
Day 1 from the NFL Scouting Combine: Shedeur Sitting Out, Stafford’s Next Move, and Pre-Workout Draft Tiers
Welcome back to ‘The McShay Show’! Todd and Steve are LIVE from Indianapolis to talk all the latest news from around the NFL. They open by breaking down the…
- The McShay Show
Todd’s Mock Draft 1.0: Abdul Carter to Tennessee and the Giants Find Their QB of the Future
Welcome back to ‘The McShay Show’! The day is finally here: Todd has released his Mock Draft 1.0! Todd and Steve start by talking through each of the top three…
- The McShay Show
Defensive Line NFL Draft Tiers: Ranking Abdul Carter, Mason Graham, the Georgia Pass Rushers, and More
Welcome back to ‘The McShay Show’! The guys open by discussing what makes this defensive line group one of the deepest in recent memory. Then, Todd and Steve…
- The McShay Show
Scouting the Loaded Running Back Class + Is Tyler Shough a 1st Round Pick?
Welcome back to ‘The McShay Show”! The guys open by breaking down the tape of Louisville QB Tyler Shough, what surprised them the most about his play, and how…
- The McShay Show
Tale of the Tape: Shedeur Sanders vs. Jaxson Dart for QB2. Plus, Breaking Down the Eagles’ Winning Formula.
Welcome back to ‘The McShay Show’! The guys open by reacting to the Eagles’ dominant performance in the Super Bowl and discussing the biggest roster-building…
- The McShay Show
Super Bowl Roster Lessons, a Travis Hunter Draft Debate, and Texans GM Nick Caserio on Working With Bill Belichick and Building Around C.J. Stroud
Welcome back to ‘The McShay Show’! The guys open by discussing Travis Hunter’s draft stock and whether he could fall out of the top five picks. Then, they…
- The McShay Show
Who’s Rising in Todd’s Updated Top 100 Prospects? Plus: Talking Team Building and Scouting Lamar Jackson With Ravens GM Eric DeCosta.
Welcome back to ‘The McShay Show’! The guys open by reflecting on the Senior Bowl and how their past few weeks of scouting and reporting have affected the…
- The McShay Show
Senior Bowl, Day 3 Takeaways
Welcome back to ‘The McShay Show’! McShay and Muench are back for Day 3 of Senior Bowl week! They start the show with their breakdowns of the quarterbacks…
- The McShay Show
Senior Bowl, Day 2: Mike Green vs. Josh Conerly Jr., Small Schools Show Out, and Is Jack Bech the next Puka Nacua?
Welcome back to ‘The McShay Show’! It’s Day 2 of Senior Bowl week, and the guys break down everything they saw at practice. They start with the trenches…
- The McShay Show
Senior Bowl Day One Takeaways: Could Jaxson Dart Rise? Plus, Azareye'h Thomas Shines
Welcome back to ‘The McShay Show’! The guys are in Mobile, Alabama, for the first day of practices at the Senior Bowl! They start with their day-one…
- The McShay Show
Senior Bowl Primer: Finding QB3, Ranking Position Players in Mobile, and an Unforgettable Tim Tebow Story
Welcome back to ‘The McShay Show’! Todd and Steve open by sharing some of their favorite Senior Bowl memories, including Todd’s experience covering Tim Tebow…
- The McShay Show
Ohio State’s Dominant CFP Run and Ben Johnson’s Fit in Chicago
Welcome back to ‘The McShay Show’! Todd and Steve open by reacting LIVE to Ohio State’s 34-23 win over Notre Dame in the CFP national championship. Then, the…
- The McShay Show
An Ohio State᠆Notre Dame National Championship Preview With Kirk Herbstreit, Plus Quinn Ewers Declares and Other Draft-Decision Reactions
Welcome back to The McShay Show! The guys open by discussing Texas’s Quinn Ewers and Matthew Golden declaring for the draft, and what to make of Penn State’s…
- The McShay Show
Coach Prime’s Cowboys Connection, Jayden Daniels Draft Lessons, and Ranking NFL GM Vacancies
Welcome back to ‘The McShay Show’! Todd and Steve open by reacting to news that Deion Sanders has spoken to Jerry Jones about the Cowboys’ head coaching…
- The McShay Show
Cotton Bowl Instant Reactions: An Ohio State–Notre Dame Natty, Jack Sawyer’s Signature Moment, and Quinn Ewers’s Next Move
Welcome back to ‘The McShay Show’! Todd and Steve kick off with their live reactions to Ohio State’s 28-14 win over Texas. Then, they talk Quinn Ewers’s draft…
- The McShay Show
Orange Bowl Instant Reactions: Natty-Bound Notre Dame, Drew Allar’s Draft Decision, and Abdul Carter NFL Comps
Welcome back to ‘The McShay Show’! Todd and Steve kick off with their live reactions to Notre Dame’s comeback win over Penn State in the Orange Bowl. Then…
- The McShay Show
CFP Semifinal Preview: Penn State–Notre Dame and Texas–Ohio State. Plus, the Patriots Fumble the Top Pick and Talking Titans QB Options
Welcome back to ‘The McShay Show’! Todd and Steve kick off by reacting to the Patriots falling in the draft order and the timing of their decision to fire…
- The McShay Show
CFP Quarterfinal Recap: Ohio State Routs Oregon, Texas Survives OT Thriller, and Penn State Slows Ashton Jeanty
Welcome back to ‘The McShay Show’! Todd and Steve kick off by reacting to Ohio State’s big win over Oregon. Then, they talk Texas’s close call vs. Arizona…
- The McShay Show
CFP Quarterfinal Preview: Ohio State–Oregon, Notre Dame–Georgia, Texas–Arizona State, and Penn State–Boise State. Plus, Quarterback Draft Thoughts.
Welcome back to ‘The McShay Show’! Todd opens by reacting to Carson Beck’s NFL draft decision, breaking down whether NFL teams should care about Cam Ward…
- The McShay Show
Todd’s 2024 NFL Redraft: Daniels Vs. Maye at 1, Nabers Over Harrison Jr., and Bo Nix What-Ifs
Welcome back to ‘The McShay Show’! With the College Football Playoff breaking for a week and the NFL season winding down, the guys evaluate this year’s rookie…
- The McShay Show
CFP Reactions: Ohio State’s Second Act, The Dominant Nittany Lions, and Texas Holds The Line. Plus, Notre Dame Cruises to 11th Straight Win
Todd and Muench react to the first round of the College Football Playoff! They kick off with Ohio State’s dominant win over Tennessee, then talk Texas’s close…
- The McShay Show
CFP Picks: Indiana-Notre Dame, SMU-Penn State, Clemson-Texas, and Tennessee-Ohio State. Plus, Florida HC Billy Napier | The McShay Show
Welcome back to ‘The McShay Show’! Todd and Steve open with a first-round College Football Playoff preview, breaking down the key players and matchups to watch…
- The McShay Show
Pre-Playoff Draft Buzz: QB Decisions, Weak WR and Loaded RB Classes | The McShay Show
Todd and Muench run through the NFL draft buzz they've been hearing, including whether Jalen Milroe will stay at Alabama or declare and Travis Hunter's draft…
- The McShay Show
Bill Belichick as a College Coach, Todd’s Flash Mock, and CFP Prospect Rankings
Welcome back to ‘The McShay Show’! Todd and Steve open by reacting to news that Bill Belichick will be the next head coach at North Carolina. Then, they…
- The McShay Show
Playoff QB Confidence Rankings: Dillon Gabriel the Consensus No. 1, Texas’s Dynamic Duo, and Carson Beck Injury Concerns
Welcome back to ‘The McShay Show’! With the dust settled on the College Football Playoff bracket reveal, the guys go team by team and rank each quarterback…
- The McShay Show
Conference Championship Reactions, CFP Predictions with Ryen Russillo
Todd and Muench welcome Ryen Russillo to react to the SEC, Big Ten and ACC championships games. They also compare the College Football Playoff resumes of SMU…