Shows / The McShay Show
The McShay Show
Longtime NFL draft and college football analyst Todd McShay brings you inside his unique world as an NFL talent evaluator. From the college football season through draft night, Todd and his cohost, Steve Muench, track the top prospects, share insider intel, and break down their latest mock drafts.New episodes drop every Monday, Wednesday, and Friday as they prepare you for the NFL draft with in-depth analysis, player evaluations, and the latest buzz from around the NFL. Don’t miss special…
Episodes
- The McShay Show
Rough Draft: Dante Moore, QB Development, and Rankings With Dan Orlovsky
Dan Orlovsky joins Todd and Muench to break down what's next for Dante Moore and evaluate his traits as an NFL prospect. Then, they share their takeaways about…
- The McShay Show
Week 8 Tape Truths: CFB WR Rankings, Georgia vs. the Field in the SEC, Arizona Respect, J.J. McCarthy Revisited, and More
Todd and Steve are back with another edition of Tape Truths! The guys rank the top wide receivers in college football, debate Georgia vs. the field in the SEC…
- The McShay Show
Week 8 Reactions: Texas Survives! Which Two-Loss Teams Are Contenders?
Todd and Steve react to a wild Week 8, starting with Texas' 34-27 victory over Ole Miss and evaluating "Villain Arch" and Trinidad Chambliss becoming a…
- The McShay Show
Rough Draft: Midseason Risers, Position Power Rankings, and Week 8 CFB Picks
Todd and Steve spotlight their biggest midseason risers, including Tennessee's Xavier Gilliam, Oklahoma State's Drew Mestemaker, Georgia's Chris Cole, Utah's…
- The McShay Show
Midseason Tape Truths: CFP Contenders, Superlatives, and the Best Offenses and Defenses
Todd and Steve kick things off with the latest news surrounding Arch Manning and Texas, the Colts firing GM Chris Ballard, and Jalen Hurts's blood clots. Then…
- The McShay Show
Week 7 Reactions: Five Top-Seven Teams Fall! Plus, Arch’s Texas Future, Sayin’s Injury Fallout, and Believing in BYU.
It was one of the wildest Saturdays in college football history, as five top-seven teams went down in Week 7. Todd and Steve are here to make sense of the…
- The McShay Show
Rough Draft: Mestemaker's Momentum! Week 7 QB Rankings, Advanced Scouting, and CFB Picks.
Todd and Steve kick things off by evaluating Oklahoma State QB Drew Mestemaker's growing momentum, asking where he ranks among the top QB prospects. Then, a…
- The McShay Show
Week 6 Tape Truths: Arch Manning Honesty. Plus, BYU–Notre Dame, Indiana WRs, the 10 Most Important Games of the Second Half, and More.
Todd and Steve preview this weekend’s showdown between BYU and Notre Dame before taking an honest look at Arch Manning’s development. Then, the guys debate…
- The McShay Show
Week 6 Reactions: Georgia Tops Alabama, Texas Trust Issues, Indiana’s Playoff Case, UCLA’s Rise, and More
Todd and Steve react to a wild Week 6 of college football, starting with Georgia’s win over Alabama and what it means for each team. Then, the guys discuss…
- The McShay Show
Rough Draft: FLASH MOCK! Plus, Advanced Scouting, Prospect Cross-Check, and Week 6 CFB Picks.
We’re a quarter of the way through the NFL season, which means it’s time for a FLASH MOCK! Todd and Steve go through the first 12 picks and project what would…
- The McShay Show
Week 5 Tape Truths: SEC QB Rankings, Georgia’s Defense, Rookie Receipts, and More
Todd and Steve go back to the tape after Week 5 to reassess the SEC quarterback hierarchy, break down what they’re seeing from Georgia’s and Oklahoma's…
- The McShay Show
Week 5 Reactions: Another Bama Beatdown, TMS Power Rankings, CFP Buy or Sell, and Jeremiah Smith As the All-Time WR1
Todd and Steve react to a loaded Week 5 slate, starting with the biggest question in college football: Can anyone beat Alabama? Then, they debate whether…
- The McShay Show
Rough Draft: Our Top 10 Prospects, Plus Where Would Kamario Taylor Rank?
Todd and Steve share their latest top 10 Big Board rankings and discuss why Jeremiah Smith and Leonard Moore are the clear top two prospects, plus which…
- The McShay Show
Week 4 Tape Truths: Baugh’s Rise, Stewart’s Slide, the Best Defenses in CFB, and Rookie Receipts
Todd and Steve are back with their Week 4 Tape Truths, starting with Jadan Baugh’s emergence as a potential top-10 pick and growing concerns about Dylan…
- The McShay Show
Ranked-Game Roundup, Prospect Pass-Fail, 2027 QB Letdowns, and McShay After Dark
Todd and Steve break down the biggest ranked games of the weekend, put top 2027 NFL draft prospects through a pass-fail test, and examine the disappointing…
- The McShay Show
QB Stock Watch and Previewing the Biggest Week 4 Matchups and Prospects to Know
Rough Draft is back! Todd and Steve share their latest QB stock rankings and the potential impacts from the biggest games of this week. They dive into (20)…
- The McShay Show
Moore’s Tape, Mateer’s Decline, SEC Playoff Long Shots, and Rookie Receipts
Todd and Steve go back to the tape from Week 3 and share their biggest scouting takeaways, starting with Michigan’s dominant defensive line, why Dante Moore…
- The McShay Show
Trinidad Takes Over, Kiffin’s Humble Pie, Super Kamario, and McShay After Dark
Todd and Steve break down Trinidad Chambliss’s statement performance against LSU, Lane Kiffin’s return to Oxford, and why Kamario Taylor is becoming one of the…
- The McShay Show
The Inaugural September Mock Draft: Muench’s Red Lines and Top-10 Dominoes
Todd unveils his inaugural September mock for the 2027 class, breaking down the biggest decisions inside the top 10 and the picks that could reshape the entire…
- The McShay Show
Our 2027 Big Board, NFL Week 1 Rookie Reactions, and the SEC Is BACK! Plus, Are Oregon and Oklahoma Cooked?
Todd and Steve put their first 2027 NFL draft top 50 under the microscope, debating which prospects they’re willing to fight for, which quarterbacks could go…
- The McShay Show
Manning's Moment, Oregon's Fall, More Michigan Magic, and Other Week 2 Reactions
Todd and Steve break down the biggest story lines in Week 2 of college football, from Arch Manning’s performance in a comeback thriller over Ohio State to…
- The McShay Show
Ohio State vs. Texas Preview, Prospects Who Grabbed Our Attention, and NFL Rookie Watch
Todd and Muench preview (1) Ohio State vs. (5) Texas, give a scouting breakdown of Arch Manning vs. Julian Sayin, and go through the biggest positional battles…
- The McShay Show
Buying Chambliss, Selling Ole Miss in the Top 10, Holding Carr, and More CFB Sunday Reactions
Todd and Steve break down the Sunday of college football, starting with Trinidad Chambliss and Ole Miss surviving a scare against Louisville. They also dig…
- The McShay Show
Michigan’s “Miracle,” Kiffin’s Revenge, Dabo’s Inferno, and 2027 QB Overreactions
Todd and Steve break down Michigan’s controversial “miracle” finish, Lane Kiffin’s revenge game, and what LSU’s blowout of Clemson means for Dabo Swinney. Then…
- The McShay Show
The SEC Sues LSU: Making Sense of the Chaos With Bruce Feldman
Bruce Feldman joins Todd and Muench to break down the latest in the battle between the SEC, LSU, and athletes trying to return to CFB from the NFL. Plus, the…
- The McShay Show
Ranking Week 1 CFB Matchups, a 2023 NFL Re-Draft, QB Start-Bench-Cut, and Debuting First Tape
Welcome back to The McShay Show! Today, Todd and Steve are drafting their favorite games from a loaded Week 1 college football slate. Then, they’re playing…
- The McShay Show
Todd’s CFB Power Rankings: Is Muench Buying the Hype or Calling BS?
It’s that time of year. On the eve of Week 1 in college football, Todd’s debuting his top 10 teams, and Muench has his red pen ready. Come for the Miami hype…
- The McShay Show
The 17 Players We Think Could Go No. 1 in the 2027 NFL Draft
At this time last year, no one would have predicted that Fernando Mendoza would go no. 1 overall. So how many players are reasonably in play for the first pick…
- The McShay Show
Stanford GM Andrew Luck on Life After Football, Harbaugh Stories, 2027 QB Advice, and More
Welcome back to The McShay Show! Todd and Steve open by reacting to the news that the Big Ten and SEC voted to ban NFL players from returning to college after…
- The McShay Show
The 10 Most Interesting Players in College Football, and the Curious Case of Dae’Quan Wright.
Welcome back to The McShay Show! Today, the guys are revealing the players they’re most intrigued by to start the 2026 college football season. (00:00) Welcome…
- The McShay Show
The Best Wide Receivers in College Football Not Named Jeremiah Smith
Welcome back to The McShay Show! It’s a simple formula today: The guys reveal who their top non-Jeremiah-Smith college receivers are for the 2026 season, and…
- The McShay Show
Heisman Picks, Breakout Coaches, and AP Poll Takeaways With Stanford Steve
Welcome back to The McShay Show! The guys are joined by "Stanford Steve" Coughlin to discuss the preseason AP poll rankings, the head coaches who could take a…
- The McShay Show
SEC and Big Ten QB Rankings, Ty Simpson’s Debut, and More NFL Preseason Rookie Reactions
Welcome back to The McShay Show! Summer’s over, and the guys are dusting off the mics to reveal their Big Ten and SEC QB rankings. They also dip their toes…
- The McShay Show
Can Indiana Become a Dynasty? Plus, Scouting QB Josh Hoover.
Welcome back to The McShay Show! The guys are wrapping up the first leg of their summer scouting series by answering the following question: Can Indiana become…
- The McShay Show
Demond Williams Jr. vs. Drew Mestemaker: Who’s the Better NFL Prospect?
Welcome back to The McShay Show! Today, the guys are concluding their Building the Board series with Washington QB Demond Williams Jr. and Oklahoma State QB…
- The McShay Show
Nico Iamaleava vs. Jayden Maiava. Plus, Our Rough Draft 2027 QB Rankings.
Welcome back to The McShay Show! Today, the guys are continuing their Building the Board series with UCLA QB Nico Iamaleava and USC QB Jayden Maiava. To close…
- The McShay Show
John Mateer vs. Trinidad Chambliss: Making the Case for Smaller QBs
Welcome back to The McShay Show! Today, the guys are continuing their Building the Board series with Oklahoma QB John Mateer and Ole Miss QB Trinidad…
- The McShay Show
Sam Leavitt vs. Darian Mensah: Which QB Transfer Is the Better NFL Prospect?
Welcome back to The McShay Show! Today, the guys are continuing their Building the Board series with LSU QB Sam Leavitt and Miami QB Darian Mensah. Todd shares…
- The McShay Show
CJ Carr vs. Julian Sayin: Talking Traits, NFL Comps, Ceilings, and More
Welcome back to the McShay Show! In the aftermath of CJ Carr’s impressive Manning Passing Academy showing, Todd and Steve are rewinding the game tape and…
- The McShay Show
The Manning Passing Academy: MVPs, 2027 QB Lessons, Camp Surprises, and More
Welcome back to The McShay Show! Todd’s back from his trip to the Manning Passing Academy in Thibodaux, Louisiana, and he’s sharing his big-picture takeaways…
- The McShay Show
A Brendan Sorsby Supplemental Draft PSA. Plus, Scouting LaNorris Sellers.
Welcome back to The McShay Show! Todd and Steve open the episode by reacting to the news that the NFL will not be holding a supplemental draft for quarterback…
- The McShay Show
Building the Board: Arch Manning vs. Dante Moore for 2027 QB1
Welcome back to The McShay Show! Todd and Steve are kicking off their summer scouting series by sharing their early impressions of Arch Manning and Dante…
- The McShay Show
Brendan Sorsby to the NFL?! Breaking Down Every Angle With Albert Breer.
Welcome to The McShay Show! Todd, Steve, and special guest Albert Breer are back early from vacation to react to the news that Texas Tech and Brendan Sorsby…
- The McShay Show
Our Way-Too-Early 2027 QB Preview: The Highest Ceilings, Floors, and More
Welcome back to The McShay Show! Today, the guys are diving into the 2027 QB class, with a rough-draft ranking of the top 13 prospects and discussions about…
- The McShay Show
A 2027 Draft Primer: The Best Position Groups, Prospects, and Names to Know
Welcome back to The McShay Show! Today, the guys are giving an early primer on the 2027 draft class. They discuss generational prospects, the best position…
- The McShay Show
Mailbag! Ohio State WR Rankings, the Rams’ Plans, a Sorsby Update, and More.
Welcome back to The McShay Show! Today, the guys are answering listener-submitted questions from subscribers of The McShay Report. (00:00) Welcome to The…
- The McShay Show
A Rookie Class Fantasy Football Preview. Plus, Hypothetical Over/Unders.
Welcome back to The McShay Show! Today, the guys are sharing their rookie class fantasy football expectations for 2026. They each rank their top three RBs…
- The McShay Show
Rookie Class Predictions, Award Winners, and Superlatives
Welcome back to The McShay Show! Today, the guys are spinning the rookie-class conversation forward with bold predictions, award winners, and superlatives…
- The McShay Show
What We Got Wrong About the 2026 NFL Draft
Welcome back to The McShay Show! Today, the guys are self-scouting their prospect evaluations and pre-draft predictions, beginning with a behind-the-scenes…
- The McShay Show
Our Favorite Picks From Every Round of the 2026 NFL Draft
Welcome to The McShay Show! It’s a simple concept today: Todd and Steve share their favorite picks from every round of the 2026 NFL draft. To read scouting…
- The McShay Show
Talking Brendan Sorsby, Arch Manning, and the 2027 Class With Albert Breer
Welcome back to The McShay Show! Todd and Steve open by breaking down the tape on Texas Tech QB Brendan Sorsby and debating whether he's worth a first-round…
- The McShay Show
The Way-Too-Early 2027 Mock Draft: Arch Manning Vs. Dante Moore
Welcome to The McShay Show! Todd and Steve start with grading their 2026 mock draft against how the draft actually shook out, and react to the uncertainty…
- The McShay Show
The Best NFL Draft Classes, Biggest Steals, Boom or Bust Picks, and More
Welcome to The McShay Show! Todd and Steve are back for a 2026 draft recap featuring superlatives, biggest steals, boom-or-bust picks, and more. Check out…
- The McShay Show
Our Favorite Day-Three Steals and QB Landing Spots
Welcome to The McShay Show! Todd and Steve are recapping all the action from day three of the NFL draft, including their favorite value picks and quarterback…
- The McShay Show
NFL Draft Second & Third Round Live Coverage
Todd McShay and Steve Muench are back for Day 2 of the 2026 NFL Draft. They’ll share all their latest intel and analysis for every pick of the second and third…
- The McShay Show
NFL Draft First Round Live Coverage
Join Todd McShay and Steve Muench live throughout the first round of the 2026 NFL Draft. They’ll share all their latest intel and analysis for every pick 1-32…
- The McShay Show
Mock 5.0: Todd’s Strongest Leans, Muench’s Favorite Picks, and Wild Cards
Welcome to The McShay Show! Todd’s Mock 5.0 is out, and the guys are discussing their strongest takes and favorite picks from Round 1. They also share which…
- The McShay Show
The Latest Top-12 Intel vs. What We Would Do in the First Round
Welcome to The McShay Show! The guys are back to break down Todd’s latest intel on the first 12 picks of the 2026 NFL draft—and how league decision-makers’…
- The McShay Show
NFL Draft Week Buzz: Everything I’m Hearing and a Top-10 Flash Mock
Draft week is finally here! Todd and Steve open by reacting to the Dexter Lawrence II trade news and discussing what it could mean for the Giants’ plans in the…
- The McShay Show
The Muench Mock! Plus, Why Did the Jets Cancel David Bailey’s Visit?
Welcome back to The McShay Show! The guys open by reacting to the news that the Jets canceled their visit with Texas Tech edge David Bailey. Todd shares some…