Shows / Critical Lit

Critical Lit
Critical Lit is a podcast where we revisit and retool (and lambast and lampoon) classic tabletop RPG adventures. Part book review, part heckling commentary, all in good fun. Hosted by industry veterans Dan Dillon (Legends of Avantris, formerly WotC), I-Hsien Sherwood (Total Party Thrill), Amelia Som (Unprepared Casters), and Sal Tamarkin (Cloud Curio).
Episodes
Critical LitWarhammer 40K Edge of Darkness Walkthrough 02: It's Not Exactly Brain Churgery
The GM advice flows like leaking promethium, in a neo-Gygaxian tone that's as refreshing as it is informative. Which is good because this system is a lot to…
Critical LitWarhammer 40K Edge of Darkness Walkthrough 01: Heresy After Dark
In the grim darkness of the far future, there is only pointed critique, an eternity of trenchant analysis, and the laughter of satirical excess. We're finally…
Critical LitCurse of Strahd Deep Dive 27: You Will Be Mist
Pour out a little Red Dragon Crush for all our mist connections. As we walk out of Barovia for good, we leave this land and this book changed, and we don't…
Critical LitCurse of Strahd Deep Dive 26: Question Everything
You had questions about Curse of Strahd, both thought-provoking and simply provocative. Some mechanical, some hypothetical, some satirical, even some…
Critical LitCurse of Strahd Deep Dive 25: Mod Squad
Is this sandbox too spooky? Parties looking for a less grim take on Barovia have a host of more heroic (and more linear) options. They can be used to spice up…
Critical LitCurse of Strahd Deep Dive 24: Slaughter Rinse Repeat
Strahd gets knocked down, but he gets up again. And again. The "final" battle is a tricky needle to thread, but victory earns a literal Pandora's box of…
Critical LitCurse of Strahd Deep Dive 23: The Real Housewolves of Barovia
While Kiril's away, the pups will play! The pack really sinks their claws into each other this time, but the real question is which of the lucky young…
Critical LitCurse of Strahd Deep Dive 22: Reverse of Strahd New Game Plus
Visit Yester Hill, a planned community for retired berserkers with absolutely no secrets hidden beneath a thin layer of sod. Evil druids seek to unleash their…
Critical LitCurse of Strahd Deep Dive 21: Would You Still Love Me If I Was a Wisp of Utter Darkness No More Than a Few Inches Long?
The final vaults in the basement of the Amber Temple hold the best rewards in all of Barovia. If it's wrong to murder your loved one and drink their blood or…
Critical LitCurse of Strahd Deep Dive 20: Vestigial Tales
Deep within the Amber Temple, alone in the dark, lurks the most helpful lich in the multiverse. Play your cards right and there's free drinks and body…
Critical LitCurse of Strahd Deep Dive 19: Anyway, Here's Fireball
It's back to Barovia for Chapter 13, and the Amber Temple is sending mixed messages. Does it want us to freeze to death? Burn to a crisp? Get possessed by…
Critical LitKeep on the Borderlands Deep Dive 04: Color-Coded Chaos
Our final look at the Caves of Chaos takes 17 man-turns to unpack. The cult fit is very Queen of Hearts and matches the canonically evil furnishings. But the…
Critical LitKeep on the Borderlands Deep Dive 03: Throuple Trouble
Many yawning orifices await as the spelunking finally begins in earnest! The myriad tribes of the Caves of Chaos have complex social hierarchies, tight-knit…
Critical LitKeep on the Borderlands Deep Dive 02: An Officer and a Normalman
Dammit granite! If these walls could talk, they'd blush and tell you "murder hole" is not the preferred nomenclature. Gygax continues to wow us with his…
Critical LitKeep on the Borderlands Deep Dive 01: Miserly Business
What if "Do as I say, not as I do" was a D&D module? In 1979 Gary Gygax wrote The Keep on the Borderlands, cribbing plenty of useful GM advice from TSR…
Critical LitCurse of Strahd Deep Dive 18: This Little Blight of Mine
Everything's vine down at the Wizard of Wines! Chapter 12 is the nexus of nearly every plot hook in this book, but the wine won't flow until this gemless…
Critical LitCurse of Strahd Deep Dive 17: Knockin' on Khazan's Door
It's a Dance Dance Execution at the door of this wizard tower. The wagon nearby is as volatile as a meth lab, and werewolves wait to finish off any survivors…
Critical LitCurse of Strahd Deep Dive 16: The Other Mother
Sure, Strahd had one mother, but what about second mother? In Chapter 10, Baba Lysaga is a boy-mom wannabe, with a parasocial fixation on our titular vamp. To…
Critical LitCurse of Strahd Deep Dive 15: Fowl Play
For want of a dress, Krezk was lost. The Abbot gets serious about playing dress-up, Ireena takes a dive, fine feathered fiends guard the pass, and the roc just…
Critical LitCurse of Strahd Deep Dive 14: Build-a-Bride Workshop
Mutual aid! In my D&D? The Krezkites share everything: food, labor, and a growing horror at the screams emanating from the Abbey above. The empty graves strewn…
Critical LitCurse of Strahd Deep Dive 13: Eight Crazy Knights
Strahd may have tried to bury these gays, but they refused to stay down. In Chapter 7 we meet a goodly order of knights and their defeated dragon lord. What…
Critical LitCurse of Strahd Deep Dive 12: Baker's Coven
Dream Pastries™ are Pediatrically Delicious! Uhh, Tragically Suspicious? Chapter 6 of Curse of Strahd is a bigger deal than its page count lets on. Looks can…
Critical LitWhite Plume Mountain Deep Dive 02 - Weapon of Choice
Consider us Schick-pilled. We wrap up both our holiday hiatus and the 1979 TSR adventure White Plume Mountain in surprisingly high spirits: arms adorned with…
Critical LitWhite Plume Mountain Deep Dive 01 - Deranged and Fanatical Evil Gnomes
It's an old school holiday hiatus! We're tackling the first half of S2, the 1979 TSR adventure White Plume Mountain, written exactly one time (to his eternal…
Critical LitCurse of Strahd Deep Dive 11 - Til Decay Do Us Part
As we wrap up Chapter 5, all is not well in Vallaki! Never mind the devil cult hobbyists or the rampaging tiger. The coffin maker has six secrets buried in the…
Critical LitCritical Lit: Curse of Strahd 10 - That's So Wereraven
All will be well! Provided you avoid the murderous man with the barbed devil arm and his eerie collection of identical dolls. Or the incel wizard. The bone…
Critical LitCritical Lit: Curse of Strahd 09 - Crypt Walk
Castle Ravenloft Final Level: Exit here for Entombed Enemies, Plot Devices, Bat Guano, and Bridal Returns. Trust me, you don't want to talk to customer…
Critical LitCritical Lit: Curse of Strahd 08 - Innocents and Insensibility
A cape a day keeps the Dark Powers at bay! Never mind the young woman of indeterminate age in the King's Bedchamber. Just don't use the bathroom if you value…
Critical LitCritical Lit: Curse of Strahd 07 - Working Stiffs
Now hiring at Castle Ravenloft! Feeling chained to your desk? Make it more than just a feeling, with a career that will last the rest of your life. Maybe even…
Critical LitCritical Lit: Curse of Strahd 06 - Velcome to ze Dollhouse
It turns out life (and unlife) at Castle Ravenloft is as zany as the town of Barovia is dour. Trade the gloomy mists for the crack of lightning, chanting…
Critical LitCritical Lit: Curse of Strahd 05 - Kids These Days
It's 10pm in Barovia. Do you know where you children are? Strahd does, and he has plans for them. Or maybe the hags will get to them first. If only you could…
Critical LitCritical Lit: Curse of Strahd 04 - Gnostic Nosferatu
Only some listeners will be able to comprehend the mysteries laid bare in this episode. And only some of those will be compelled to pursue the eternal truth…
Critical LitCritical Lit: Curse of Strahd 03 - Lacrimo Ergo Sum
There once was a peasant named Vlad / Who felt neither happy nor sad / With no soul inside / T'wasn't grim when they died / Though the dirt nap did drive them…
Critical LitCritical Lit: Curse of Strahd 02 - You Got Fogged
Curiosity gets the best of us, and any one of Strahd’s ploys would be enough to drag us into the prison plane of Ravenloft. But three out of five adventure…
Critical LitCritical Lit: Curse of Strahd 01
Ravenloft history, Tracy Hickman's Foreword, Introduction, Chapter 1. The mists spirit us away to Barovia, a pastiche of gothic horror tropes and modern…
Critical LitCritical Lit: Tomb of Horrors
We begin at the beginning, with two false entrances and a green devil face. Grab a 10-foot pole and a spare character sheet and join us as we plumb the depths…