Shows / What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Pop your corn 🍿 light a candle 🕯️ double check your locks 🔑 and snuggle in for What’s Your Favorite Scary Movie—the cozy horror podcast that feels like movie night with your best friends.
Hosted by journalist and horror fanatic Parker Herren alongside former scary-skeptics turned genre-lovers Caroline and Ian Hoyt, we’re on a continuous quest to rank, review, and discuss cinema’s best (and worst) spooky flicks. What started in 2019 as an attempt to convert two scaredy-cats evolved into a cozy…
Episodes
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Breeder (2026) Reviewed | Dot Marie Jones carries this wild Halloween horror 🎃
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Breeder has one of the wildest horror premises of the year, and Dot Marie Jones is the reason it works, even if we think it…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Crystal Lake Eps 1-4 & Carrie (2026) Eps 1-2 Reviewed | Horror TV is winning 😱
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! 👑 UPDATE (Oct 22): Prime Video renewed Carrie for Season 2, and it's going beyond the book. Enjoy our review of Eps 1-2 in…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Other Mommy (2026) Review | The Trailer Was Scarier Than the Movie 🔪
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Other Mommy (2026) review: Jessica Chastain stars in Rob Savage's adaptation of Josh Malerman's Incidents Around the House…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Widow’s Bay, IT: Welcome to Derry, Frankenstein & The Streaming Horror We Missed | Resurrected
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! In episode 3 of our Resurrected miniseries, Parker, Caroline, and Ian catch up on the streaming horror that took over while…
What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror PodcastHorrorHound Weekend: Our first convention (vlog)
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! We’re taking you with us to our very first horror convention: HorrorHound Weekend! ⚠️This one’s a little different from our…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Onslaught & Fall 2: Deadpoint Reviewed | New Release Horror Movie Double Feature
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Your killer hosts are back with a sickening double feature: Onslaught and Fall 2: Deadpoint. We put them head-to-head after…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Faves We Missed: Weapons, Barbarian, The Monkey & More | Resurrected
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! We're back 😱 and we've got 4 years of horror movies to catch up on. In the first episode of our Resurrected miniseries…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Halloween Hype Ranking: Resident Evil, Other Mommy, Carrie & More | Resurrected
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! It's officially spooky season 🎃 We watched 14 horror trailers and ranked how hyped we are for the movies (shows, video game…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Welcome to What's Your Favorite Scary Movie: the cozy horror review podcast
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Your killer hosts are back! Welcome to What's Your Favorite Scary Movie, a cozy horror podcast where Parker, Ian, and…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Ranking Scream 1-4 | From the Vault
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! From the vault: We're curating our greatest hits ahead of our September 3rd relaunch 😱 Throwback to one of our most chaotic…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
The Cabin in the Woods review | From the Vault
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! From the vault: We're curating our greatest hits ahead of our September 3rd relaunch 😱 This one's extra special—it's our…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
I Know What You Did Last Summer review | From the Vault
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! From the vault: We’re curating our greatest hits and pulling them from our archive ahead of our September 3rd relaunch. 😱…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
X (Freaky Favs)
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Let's talk about sex, baby! Tune in for the debut of our new segment Freaky Favs, where we share our top recommendations of…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Texas Chainsaw Massacre (2022)
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! The buzz is back, baby ⛓ We're a few weeks late, but couldn't let our favorite Leatherbaby slash us by without discussing!…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Scream (2022) feat. Marley Shelton, Matt Bettinelli-Olpin, Tyler Gillett and Chad Villella
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! The question isn't WHO am I, the question is WHERE am I streaming? Stream our spoiler review of Scream (2022) now 🔪 featuring…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Scream (2022) SPOILER FREE feat. Matt Bettinelli-Olpin, Tyler Gillett & Chad Villella
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Hello, Sidney. It's an honor 🔪 Scream (2022) is FINALLY here! Listen now for our spoiler-free review of the latest Ghostface…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Scream-A-Thon (Scream 1-4)
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Surprise, Sidney 🔪 What's Your Favorite Scary Movie has returned just in time for the biggest horror event of the new year 😱…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
The Cabin in the Woods
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! WELCOME TO OUR 100TH EPISODE 🥳🎉🍾🎊 To celebrate, we're finally covering the much-requested film THE CABIN IN THE WOODS 🌲 Enjoy…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Spiral: From the Book of Saw feat. Marisol Nichols
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Do you want to play a game Enjoy our review of SPIRAL: FROM THE BOOK OF SAW featuring an exclusive interview with lead actor…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Urban Legend feat. Julieann Marie
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Okay listen up guys, 'cause this is how the story really goes. We've got the truth about URBAN LEGEND - tune in now 🔪 We…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Honeydew
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Get lost with us in the bizarre world of HONEYDEW 🍈 In this episode, we're talking melons, butt meat, and perhaps Ian's new…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
The Toll feat. Michael Nader
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Pay up! It's time to talk about THE TOLL 💸 Enjoy our review featuring an interview with Michael Nader, writer/director of THE…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Pet Sematary (1989) feat. Julieann Marie
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Sometimes dead is better, but we can't stop digging up PET SEMATARY 🐈⬛ This time we're trucking back to the original to…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Leprechaun
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Try as they will, and try as they might, who listens to me podcast won't live through the night 🌈 Let's celebrate horror's…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Wrong Turn (2021)
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Pack your bags 🎒We're hiking into the killer woods of WRONG TURN (2021) 🌲Enjoy our discussion of Caroline and Ian living…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Willy's Wonderland
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Playtime's over now, girlfriend 🔪 Feast on our killer review of WILLY'S WONDERLAND - listen now to find out if this murderous…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Saint Maud feat. Julieann Marie
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! She is risen ✝️ After almost a year in the tomb, SAINT MAUD is finally gracing our eyes. Now let her bless your ears in our…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
The Blackcoat's Daughter feat. Julieann Marie
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Is it hot in here or is it just Satan 𖤐 In this episode, Julieann brands sad girl horror and we take a brave stance against…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Black Swan
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! What happened to my sweet pod? She's gone! I'm the pod queen now 👑 Enjoy our discussion of sex, swans, and everything ballet…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Tucker & Dale vs Evil
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Are you okay? Not until you've listened to our killer review of TUCKER & DALE VS EVIL 🔪 We would die if you rated and…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Promising Young Woman feat. Julieann Marie
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Just call me angel of the podcast, baby 🎶 Enjoy our discussion of the movie on everyone's cherry-glossed lips - Promising…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Possessor
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Instead of dwelling on 2020, let's bring the good parts with us! Enjoy our discussion of one of last year's best horrors…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Orphan feat. Julieann Marie
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! There may be something wrong with Esther, but we think everything about Orphan is oh so right 🖤 Enjoy our discussion of the…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Gremlins
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Hi ho, hi ho, it's off to watch Gremlins we go 🎄 Join our celebration of the most wonderful time of the year - horror style!…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Better Watch Out
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! He knows if you've been bad or good 🎄 Get on our nice list and enjoy our holiday review of BETTER WATCH OUT 🔪 We would die if…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Freaky feat. Julieann Marie
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Happy LOLidays ✨ We're feeling merry and bright after watching horror's hottest new comedy! Enjoy our review of Blumhouse's…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Run feat. Aneesh Chaganty
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! We've caught a mean case of RUN-fever 🤒 Join the fun and stream our review of RUN featuring an interview with writer/director…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Kristy
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Happy Thanksgiving week 🍗 Let's dig into Kristy and have a little Turkey Day scream! We would die if you rated and reviewed…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Sinister
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Some believe that Bughuul actually lived in the podcast itself and was a gateway into his realm 👹 Listen to our review of…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Kindred
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! The holidays approach and you know what that means: 'tis the season for family horror 🔪 Enjoy Parker's review of new horror…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Halloween Hangover (The Craft: Legacy, The Haunting of Bly Manor, The Mortuary Collection, Nightstream Film Festival) feat. Julieann Marie
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! RIP HALLOWEEN 2020 ☠️ To cure our post-Halloween sadness, Julieann and Parker are flash reviewing all of October's buzziest…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Terrifier
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! 🎃HAPPY HALLOWEEK🎃 Start the scariest week of the year with our review of Terrifier! Let the fun continue at our virtual…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Hell House LLC
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Send in the clowns 🤡 Our Halloween celebration continues with the very spooky and very seasonal Hell House LLC! Buy tickets…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Halloween (2007) feat. Julieann Marie
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! IT'S THE BOOGEYMAN! Halloween starts now and Rob Zombie is taking us there! Join Julieann and Parker to discuss the remake of…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Death of Me feat. Darren Lynn Bousman
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! 🔪WELCOME BACK🔪 What's Your Favorite Scary Movie returns from hiatus with special guest Darren Lynn Bousman! Tune in to hear…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Piranha 3D
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! BOOBS! BLOOD! MORE BOOBS! Piranha 3D checks all three boxes and more! Join us for the season 2 finale of What's Your Favorite…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Ju-On: Origins
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! It's gory! It's grisly! It's grim! It's ghostly goodness 👻 Stream Ju-On: Origins on Netflix 🔪 We would die if you rated and…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Relic
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! It's here, under the bed...Jump (scare) into our review of Relic, the hot new horror that's being called one of the best of…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
The Beach House (SPOILER-FREE)
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Come on in, the water's fine 🌊 Dive into our SPOILER-FREE review of Shudder's newest horror The Beach House! Catch the movie…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Hellbent feat. Ryan Bloomquist
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Killer abs, cruising, leather bars, and Halloween 🌈 Does it get much gayer than that? Celebrate pride this week by slicing…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Jennifer's Body feat. Julieann Marie
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Boys beware: this week's episode is killer 🔪 We've got such a wettie for Jennifer's Body! JUSTICE FOR MEGAN FOX 🖤 We would…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
The Human Centipede (First Sequence)
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! No shit - our new episode will FEED you 💩 Join your favorite Scary Movie triplet as we digest the infamous The Human…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Candyman
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! podcast...podcast...podcast...podcast...PODCAST! We're terrorizing your podcast feed with our review of 1992's Candyman 🍬…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
The Lure feat. Rachael Montgomery
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Eat your heart out Ariel 🧜♀️ Get caught in the captivating net of our review of The Lure 🐟 We would die if you rated and…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
The House of the Devil feat. Julieann Marie
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Grab a delicious slice of pizza and dance around your house because Julieann Marie is back for a devilishly thrilling…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Drag Me to Hell
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Hide you kittens, hide your souls! Parker is back to drag your ears to our 🔥 new review of Sam Raimi's Drag Me to Hell! We…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
It Follows
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! It listens to our podcast and so should you! The Scary Movie gang reunites to discuss the contemporary classic It Follows 🔪…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Re-Animator feat. Cody Wimmer
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Give yourself life - Cody Wimmer returns to discuss the cult classic Re-Animator 🧪 We would die if you rated and reviewed us…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Unfriended
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! What's Your Favorite Scary Movie is online 🟢 Login to your podcast feed for a killer chat on Unfriended 👤 We would die if you…
- What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
We Summon the Darkness feat. Julieann Marie
Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Heaven is a place on Earth when you're listening to this week's episode 🤘 Julieann returns to rock out about the new VOD…