Shows / Audio Arguendo

Audio Arguendo
Audio Arguendo provides unedited recordings of oral arguments from the Supreme Court and interesting cases from around the globe. If you have a case that you think we should broadcast, just send us a message on X (@AudioArguendo) or Bluesky (@audioarguendo.bsky.social) with the name of the case, a short description of the issue, and a link to where the audio can be found. We assert no claim of copyright over any of the recordings and have posted them in podcast form to make them more widely and…
The show, from its episodes
No episode notes yet. Recurring topics, people and starter picks will appear when notes are available.
Typical episode length
Unknown — no recorded episode lengths.
Solo / guest format
Unknown — existing notes name people mentioned, but do not identify hosts or guests.
Recurring topics
No recurring topics established yet.
Recurring people
No recurring people established yet.
Start here
No starter picks yet — no published episodes with audio and a recorded notes hook.
Episodes
Audio ArguendoU.S. Supreme Court Department of Labor v. Sun Valley Orchards, Case No. 25-966
Administrative Law: May the Department of Labor adjudicate proceedings to collect monetary remedies from employers alleged to have violated the terms and…
Audio ArguendoHawaii Supreme Court Nonhuman Rights Project v. Honolulu, Case No. SCWC-24-0000323
Habeas Corpus: May elephants use habeas corpus to challenge their confinement at a zoo? - Argued November 9, 2026 Arguing Counsel Patricia Sendao (deputy…
Audio ArguendoU.S. Supreme Court Hoffmann v. WBI Energy Transmission, Case No. 25-159
Takings: In private condemnations under the Natural Gas Act, should just compensation be determined by reference to state law? - Argued November 9, 2026
Audio ArguendoU.S. Supreme Court Nielsen v. Watanabe, Case No. 25-417
Torts: May an inmate sue prison officials under Bivens for non-emergency medical neglect? - Argued November 9, 2026
Audio ArguendoUSCA, Third Circuit United States v. Bowers, Case No. 24-9002
Death Penalty: Is the federal hate crimes law unconstitutional as applied to hate crimes rooted in religious animus? - Argued November 4, 2026
Audio ArguendoUSCA, D.C. Circuit Afghan and Iraqi Allies v. Rubio, Case No. 25-5279
Immigration: May Afghan and Iraqi allies keep class status to challenge years-long delays in special immigrant visa applications? - Argued November 6, 2026…
Audio ArguendoUSCA, Seventh Circuit Lun v. Milwaukee Electric Tool, Case No. 25-3347
Labor: May a former Chinese prisoner sue Milwaukee Tool for allegedly selling gloves made with forced prison labor in China? - Argued November 4, 2026 Panel…
Audio ArguendoUSCA, Fifth Circuit Fisher v. Texas Tech Regents, Case No. 26-10536
First Amendment: May a public law school discipline and report a student to the bar for allegedly celebrating Charlie Kirk’s assassination? - Argued November…
Audio ArguendoUSCA, Fifth Circuit Huang v. Paxton, Case No. 25-51034
Property: May Chinese citizens living abroad challenge Texas’s ban on land purchases by people linked to China? - Argued November 2, 2026 Panel Chief Judge…
Audio ArguendoU.S. Supreme Court Maxwell v. Dinis, Case No. 25-5930
Habeas Corpus: Whether disputes regarding the calculation of an inmate's earned First Step Act time credits are actionable under 28 U.S.C. §2241? - Argued…
Audio ArguendoU.S. Supreme Court Younge v. Fulton Judicial Circuit Dist. Attorneys Office, Case No. 25-352
Civil Procedure: Where a defendant has filed an answer without pleading an affirmative defense, may the defendant nonetheless assert that affirmative defense…
Audio ArguendoU.S. Supreme Court St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy, Case No. 25-581
Religious Freedom: Whether proving a lack of general applicability under Employment Division v. Smith requires showing unfettered discretion or categorical…
Audio ArguendoU.S. Supreme Court Guerrero v. Johnson, Case No. 25-1003
Death Penalty: May a death-row prisoner file a second federal habeas petition based on intellectual-disability standards that changed after his first petition?…
Audio ArguendoUSCA, Fourth Circuit Penn National v. Generali-US Branch, Case No. 25-2144
Insurance: May an insurer recover defense costs from another insurer that allegedly shirked its duty to defend a settled injury suit? - Argued October 29, 2026…
Audio ArguendoUSCA, Fourth Circuit Summit Church v. Chatham County, Case No. 25-1832
Religious Liberty: May a federal court block a county from denying a church’s rezoning request that allegedly burdens religious exercise? - Argued October 27…
Audio ArguendoUSCA, Fourth Circuit United States v. Russell, Case No. 25-2004
Separation of Powers: May the executive branch sue an entire federal district court for briefly pausing deportations after habeas petitions? - Argued October…
Audio ArguendoUSCA, Fourth Circuit Martins v. United States, Case No. 26-1099
Immigration: May the government deport someone without a hearing based on a waiver he allegedly signed as an unaccompanied child? - Argued October 30, 2026…
Audio ArguendoUSCA, Seventh Circuit Anderson v. Raoul, Case No. 25-2642
Second Amendment: Does the Second Amendment allow Illinois to ban firearm silencers? - Argued October 28, 2026 Panel Circuit Judge Candace Jackson-Akiwumi…
Audio ArguendoUSCA, Fourth Circuit Bryant v. Moore, Case No. 24-1576
Abortion: May North Carolina enforce abortion-pill restrictions that go beyond the FDA’s rules for mifepristone? - Argued October 28, 2026 Panel Robert B…
Audio ArguendoUSCA, Fourth Circuit NetChoice v. Jones, Case No. 26-1252
First Amendment: May Virginia require social media platforms to limit minors to one hour per day unless parents consent? - Argued October 28, 2026
Audio ArguendoUSCA, Ninth Circuit United States v. California, Case No. 26-7070
Election Law: May the federal government force California to segregate ballots from voters it suspects are noncitizens during an ongoing election? - Argued…
Audio ArguendoUSCA, Ninth Circuit Rogoff v. Trump, Case No. 26-6445
Separation of Powers: May the president fire a court-appointed U.S. attorney before a Senate-confirmed replacement takes office? - Argued October 23, 2026…
Audio ArguendoUSCA, Sixth Circuit Hallman v. Reeds, Case No. 25-2166
First Amendment: Does the First Amendment give the public a right to obtain audio and video recordings of court proceedings? - Argued October 21, 2026
Audio ArguendoUSCA, D.C. Circuit Ali v. Rubio, Case No. 25-5082
Immigration: When may the government rely on hearsay in de-naturalization proceedings? - Argued October 20, 2026
Audio ArguendoUSCA, D.C. Circuit American Historical Association v. Trump, Case No. 26-5185
Administrative Law: Is the Presidential Records Act unconstitutional? - Argued October 20, 2026 Panel Millett, Pillard, Walker Arguing Counsel John Bailey…
Audio ArguendoUSCA, Tenth Circuit Wisne v. NCAA, Case No. 26-1309
Antitrust: May the NCAA enforce its new five-year eligibility rule against Division I athletes seeking a fifth season? - Argued October 13, 2026
Audio ArguendoUSCA, Ninth Circuit De Ridder v. Selinger, Case No. 25-6635
Arbitration: May a Roblox gambling-site operator get a trial on whether minors agreed to arbitrate illegal-gambling claims? - Argued October 19, 2026 Panel…
Audio ArguendoUSCA, D.C. Circuit DC v. Trump, Case No. 25-5418
Federalism: May the president deploy the National Guard in Washington, D.C., for local crime-fighting without a request from the mayor? - Argued October 14…
Audio ArguendoUSCA, Third Circuit Laureano v. Attorney General, Case No. 24-2433
Immigration: May federal appeals courts review protection claims by noncitizens facing deportation under reinstated removal orders? - Argued October 14, 2026
Audio ArguendoU.S. Supreme Court Salazar v. Paramount Global, Case No. 25-459
Torts: Are streaming services liable under the Video Privacy Protection Act when they reveal users’ private streaming history? - Argued October 14, 2026
Audio ArguendoUtah Supreme Court Planned Parenthood v. Stormont, Case No. 26-0235
Separation of Powers: May Utah send constitutional challenges to state laws to a special three-judge court created by the Legislature? - Argued October 5, 2026
Audio ArguendoU.S. Supreme Court Beaird v. United States, Case No. 25-5343
Criminal Procedure: What level of deference is owed to the Commentaries to the Sentencing Guidelines? - Argued October 13, 2026
Audio ArguendoSupreme Court of Canada Atlantic Lottery v. Ontario, Case No. 26-42141
International Law: May Ontario let online poker players compete against players in regulated gambling markets outside Canada? - Argued October 7, 2026
Audio ArguendoUSCA, Second Circuit In re Terrorist Attacks on September 11, 2001, Case No. 25-2355
International Law: May 9/11 victims’ families sue Saudi Arabia for allegedly helping the hijackers despite foreign sovereign immunity? - Argued October 7, 2026
Audio ArguendoUSCA, Fifth Circuit United States v. Brownlee, Case No. 25-10855
Fourth Amendment: May police use Flock license-plate cameras to track a suspect’s movements without a warrant? - Argued October 5, 2026
Audio ArguendoUSCA, First Circuit Rhode Island Latino Arts v. NEA, Case No. 25-2113
First Amendment: May the NEA disfavor arts grants for projects that promote “gender ideology”? - Argued October 7, 2026
Audio ArguendoUSCA, First Circuit Community Economic Development Center v. Bessent, Case No. 26-1329
Privacy: May the IRS share noncitizens’ tax-return information with ICE to support criminal immigration investigations? - Argued October 7, 2026
Audio ArguendoU.S. Supreme Court Department of Air Force v. Guahan, Case No. 25-579
Environmental Law: Whether the federal government must comply with the National Environmental Policy Act before submitting a permit-renewal application under…
Audio ArguendoU.S. Supreme Court Anderson v. Intel Corp. Investment Policy Committee, Case No. 25-498
ERISA: Whether claims against an ERISA fiduciary predicated on fund underperformance must allege a "meaningful benchmark" for the requisite "care, skill…
Audio ArguendoU.S. Supreme Court Johnson v. United States Congress, Case No. 25-735
Veterans: Did the Veterans' Judicial Review Act strip district courts of the jurisdiction to hear challenges to the constitutionality of acts of Congress…
Audio ArguendoU.S. Supreme Court Suncor Energy (U.S.A) Inc. v. Commissioners of Boulder County, Case No. 25-170
Environmental Law: Does federal law precludes state-law claims seeking relief for injuries allegedly caused by the effects of climate change? - Argued October…
Audio ArguendoUSCA, Fifth Circuit Jackson Federation of Teachers v. Fitch, Case No. 25-60496
Civil Rights: Should a judge be removed from a civil rights case after issuing an order containing AI hallucinations? - Argued August 31, 2026
Audio ArguendoUSCA, Ninth Circuit X v. Center for Countering Digital Hate, Case No. 24-2643
First Amendment: May X sue a nonprofit hate-speech monitor for scraping public posts and publishing reports that drove away advertisers? - Argued September 30…
Audio ArguendoNebraska Supreme Court Ullman v. Evnen, Case No. S-26-0753
Election Law: May Nebraska put a ballot measure limiting girls’ school sports to biologically female students before voters? - Argued September 30, 2026
Audio ArguendoUSCA, Seventh Circuit Scholl v. Illinois State Police, Case No. 25-1847
Fourth Amendment: Does Illinois violate the Fourth Amendment by using license-plate cameras to track and store drivers’ movements? - Argued September 29, 2026
Audio ArguendoUSCA, Ninth Circuit Sedlik v. Von Drachenberg (en banc), Case No. 24-3367
Intellectual Property: Should the Ninth Circuit change how juries decide whether an allegedly copied tattoo is too similar to a copyrighted photograph? -…
Audio ArguendoUSCA, D.C. Circuit In re Trump, Case No. 25-5452
Separation of Powers: May a district judge investigate whether officials committed criminal contempt by deporting Venezuelan migrants despite an order to stop…
Audio ArguendoUSCA, Fifth Circuit Texas A&M Queer Empowerment Council v. Mahomes, Case No. 25-20108
Free Speech: May public universities ban drag shows on campus? - Argued September 23, 2026
Audio ArguendoDelaware Supreme Court ACLU v. Town of Fenwick Island, Case No. 26-229
Voting Rights: May towns give corporations the right to vote in municipal elections? - Argued September 23, 2026
Audio ArguendoUSCA, Fourth Circuit Bluestar Operations v. DEA, Case No. 26-1691
Administrative Law: May the DEA classify hemp-derived HHC as a Schedule I controlled substance? - Argued September 18, 2026
Audio ArguendoUSCA, Ninth Circuit Seyb v. Labrador, Case No. 26-5360
Abortion: May Idaho enforce its abortion ban when an abortion is needed to protect a patient’s health or prevent self-harm? - Argued September 22, 2026
Audio ArguendoUSCA, Eighth Circuit Mizzou Students for Justice in Palestine v. Choi, Case No. 25-3317
Free Speech: May a public university exclude a pro-Palestinian student group from its homecoming parade because of safety concerns? - Argued September 23, 2026
Audio ArguendoIllinois Supreme Court Chicago John Dineen Lodge No. 7 v. City of Chicago, Case No. 132241
Labor: May Chicago police officers accused of serious misconduct have their disciplinary cases heard in private arbitration? - Argued September 24, 2026
Audio ArguendoUSCA, D.C. Circuit J.G.G. v. Trump, Case No. 26-5074
Immigration: Must Venezuelan men sent to an El Salvador prison under the Alien Enemies Act get hearings to challenge their removal? - Argued September 25, 2026
Audio ArguendoUSCA, Fifth Circuit Rodriguez v. Ortega, Case No. 26-50183
Immigration: Must the government give bond hearings to unauthorized immigrants detained for more than 90 days while removal proceedings are pending? - Argued…
Audio ArguendoUSCA, Tenth Circuit Holtmeier v. Kappa Kappa Gamma, Case No. 25-8058
Civil Rights: May a national sorority interpret its women-only membership rules to include transgender women without a vote of all members? - Argued September…
Audio ArguendoUSCA, Eighth Circuit Stinson v. Arkansas, Case No. 26-1722
Establishment Clause: May Arkansas require public schools to display the Ten Commandments in classrooms? - Argued September 22, 2026
Audio ArguendoUSCA, Fourth Circuit Hogarth v. Hayes, Case No. 26-1328
Free Speech: May North Carolina ban voters from taking and sharing photos of their marked ballots? - Argued September 15, 2026
Audio ArguendoUSCA, Fourth Circuit United States v. James, Case No. 25-4673
Separation of Powers: May the Attorney General make a second interim U.S. Attorney appointment after the prior interim appointment expires? - Argued September…
Audio ArguendoUSCA, Seventh Circuit American Alliance for Equal Rights v. Illinois, Case No. 25-2461
Free Speech: May a state require charities to release the demographic information about their leadership? - Argued September 11, 2026