Shows / Underline That
Underline That
Welcome to Underline That—the podcast where we go beyond the page. From powerful fiction to industry insights, creative leaders to real-life stories, we explore the things worth underlining. Each week, join author Stephanie Mack + guests for conversations about books, the business, womanhood, life, pop culture, and the quiet challenges we don't always speak out loud. If you've ever underlined a sentence and felt seen, this is for you. Get ready for real books, bold talks, and big underlines!
Episodes
- Underline That
The Lowdown on High Exposure with Kelly Borjas & Lynette Eason
What happens when a debut novelist and her brilliant agent sit down to talk books, publishing, and the writing life? One can’t-miss conversation, that’s what!…
- Underline That
This Episode Might Save Your Life | NYT Bestselling Author Tiffany Crum
Twenty years of writing, rejection, and perseverance. Two genres blended brilliantly. One literary success story even its author never saw coming! This week on…
- Underline That
Secrets of a Master Storyteller | New York Times Bestselling Author Rhys Bowen
What makes a story impossible to put down—and how do you keep crafting them over decades (and decades!) of a thriving career? Steph welcomes iconic New York…
- Underline That
Falling for Peachtree Bluff (All Over Again) with Kristy Woodson Harvey
Welcome back, bookish besties! It's here: Season Two of Underline That. It's a thrill and honor to have you! We're kicking things off with a charming fall…
- Underline That
Season One Finale: Celebrating Twenty Something Else
What better way to close out Season One of Underline That than with a celebration of TWENTY SOMETHING ELSE? This week, we're marking the fresh release with a…
- Underline That
How Real is Twenty Something Else? The Stories Behind the Story
With just days until Twenty Something Else releases, Steph is pulling back the curtain on the real-life inspirations behind her debut novel with Tyndale House…
- Underline That
Courtney Walsh on Writing 40-Something Heroines & Why It’s Never Too Late
Join Steph in welcoming beloved New York Times bestselling author Courtney Walsh to Underline That! What a total joy to discuss her brand-new novel, Brighter…
- Underline That
Both Can Be True | Fiction, Truth & Contradictions with Jessica Guerrieri
Today on Underline That, Jessica Guerrieri rejoins Steph for a conversation about motherhood, sobriety, sisterhood, publishing, reviews, recovery, generational…
- Underline That
Bookmarked for Love & Vulnerability with Sarah Monzon
This week on Underline That, Steph chats with bestselling Christian romance author Sarah Monzon about her adorable upcoming release, Bookmarked for Love—a…
- Underline That
Road Trips, Real Lives & Trad Wives with USA Today Bestselling Author Eliza Knight
This week on Underline That, Steph is joined by Eliza Knight—USA Today bestselling author of the upcoming novel Lost in the Summer of ’69, releasing June 9…
- Underline That
Magical Realism, Meet-Cutes & The Roman Holiday Rule
In today’s episode, Steph is joined by rom-com author Andra Loy to talk about her delightful, magical rom-com debut, The Roman Holiday Rule from Haven…
- Underline That
Balboa Island, Buried Secrets & A Book You’ll Devour
Today on Underline That, Steph sits down with historical fiction author Nicola Harrison to talk about her dazzling new novel, The Island Club—a layered…
- Underline That
Why I'm Obsessed with StoryGraph Lately
Welcome back, listeners! This week’s episode is a quick little bookish life update and personal reflection. After years of publicly reviewing books online, I’m…
- Underline That
Hot Takes with Heidi McCahan: AI, Boat Books & What's Actually Selling
Join two authors as we dive headfirst into AI, book trends, and the piping-hot publishing tea! This week, Steph puts award-winning romance author Heidi McCahan…
- Underline That
Spring Break Shelfies: The Stack to Pack
Packing your spring break bags? Don’t forget the most important item: BOOKS! In this sunshine-filled episode, Steph is joined by fellow voracious reader +…
- Underline That
From Elite Runner to Breakout Novelist: Sarah Crouch on the Power of Grit
How many people can say they’ve gone from Team USA to USA Today bestselling author? At least one unstoppable, inspiring force—and we’re so lucky to hear from…
- Underline That
Welcome to Haven: The New Clean Fiction Era with Editor Kelsey Bowen
In this episode of Underline That, it’s a massive treat to have an editor in the hot seat! Today I’m joined by Kelsey Bowen—senior acquisitions editor at Baker…
- Underline That
Behind the Book: Inside My Four-Release Year
Hi, friends! In this cozy Behind the Book episode, I’m sharing what my writing life looks like right now as I gear up for my traditional debut, Twenty…
- Underline That
Small Press, Big Story: Diving Deep with Author Allison Nance
In today’s episode of Underline That, Steph sits down with author Allison Nance, whose stunning debut novel Deep Cries Out explores womanhood, faith, love…
- Underline That
Heart, Hope & Hockey Romance with Toni Shiloh
This week on Underline That, Steph sits down with award-winning author Toni Shiloh to talk about her newest novel, Hearts on the Fly—a heartfelt hockey romance…
- Underline That
Walking with Giants: Lessons from Mister Rogers with Lori Melton
What if you could walk through life guided by someone wise, steady, and deeply faithful—a giant whose footsteps show you the way? Great news: anyone can. This…
- Underline That
From Finance to Fiction: Trading Lies & Telling Truths with Kristine Delano
What happens when a Wall Street veteran swaps spreadsheets for storytelling? In this energizing conversation, Steph sits down with Kristine Delano, former…
- Underline That
Welcome Back | The Reset Episode
Welcome back to Underline That with Stephanie Mack! We’re kicking off the second half of Season 1 with a short and sweet reset episode straight from the soul…
- Underline That
Underline That | Best Books of 2025 with Lexi of @LexintheStacks
Today’s episode is the final drop before a cozy winter break—and we’re wrapping up the year with one of my favorite conversations yet. Not to mention, more…
- Underline That
Europe with Kids: The Magic + The Must-Dos (with Travel Designer Kelly Greer)
Today’s episode is a true travel-lover’s treat! I’m giving you the full scoop on our family’s Paris + London adventure—the magic, the mishaps, the bucket-list…
- Underline That
Sheila Roberts on The Man Next Door, Christmas Magic & Staying True
Today on Underline That, I’m joined by the one and only Sheila Roberts—USA Today and Publishers Weekly bestselling author of more than fifty novels, with…
- Underline That
Bookish & Bright: Our Five-Star Holiday Reading Guide
Let Steph + Stef stack your stockings! In this festive episode of Underline That, host Stephanie Mack and special guest bookstagrammer Stefanie Zerbe…
- Underline That
Love & Pickleball: A Conversation with Author Victoria Schade
Grab your paddle and your pup—this episode has it all! Romance, pickleball, dog training, and the heart behind writing stories that make us smile. Stephanie…
- Underline That
Chapter 40: Birthday Reflections with Steph
It's Steph's birthday episode! I turn forty this weekend, and I’m celebrating with a very special episode: me, interviewing… myself! LOL. That’s right—you can…
- Underline That
Running Into 40: Steph’s Ode to Her Favorite (Real) Sport
Lace up with Steph for her reflections and real talk on running—one constant that’s carried her through many seasons of womanhood, writing, and rediscovery…
- Underline That
Staying Sane in the Season: Advent Wisdom + Agent Advice with Cynthia Ruchti
The holidays can be the most wonderful—and also crazy, stressful, and overwhelming. In this special Underline That episode, Steph is joined by Kelly Borjas of…
- Underline That
Star-Crossed Secrets: What Really Happens in Trad Publishing?
Publishing tea, anyone?! In this super-fun + juicy conversation, Stephanie Mack sits down with friend + fellow author Devon Daniels (Meet You in the Middle…
- Underline That
Plot Twists + Power Moves: Ashley Manley Unpacks Indie Publishing
What does it really take to succeed as a self-published author? Don’t miss this deep dive with indie powerhouse Ashley Manley, where I ask everything—and she…
- Underline That
Highs, Hurdles, and Hulu: No Lies with Sophie Stava
What happens when your debut novel sells at auction, gets scooped up by a dream imprint, and is chosen for the Good Morning America Book Club and Book of the…
- Underline That
Library Confidential: Secrets of a Real-Life Book Matchmaker
Ever wonder what really goes on behind the desk at your local library? In this episode of Underline That, Steph chats with Jordan Abitz, a rural branch…
- Underline That
Girl Mom Goals: Raising Strong Daughters with Kari Kampakis
Today Steph sits down with one of her girl-mom heroes, Kari Kampakis—bestselling author, speaker, and leader known for her life-changing work on the topic of…
- Underline That
Welcome to Underline That!
It’s a brand-new season, a brand-new podcast—welcome to Underline That with Stephanie Mack! In this first-ever episode, Steph shares her heart and vision for…