Shows / Ohio Mysteries

Ohio Mysteries
Each week Ohio Mysteries explores unsolved murders, lost shipwrecks, local legends and more! https://www.ohiomysteries.com. https://www.facebook.com/ohiomysteries https://www.patreon.com/ohiomysteries https://www.twitter.com/mysteriesohio
In any given episode we feature fantastic music by the following music-https://soundcloud.com/davidhydemusic. https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCL0pcAGV4g67jCxGIPWv9iQ https://www.youtube.com/c/WhitesandComposer https://www.youtube.com/user/audionautix…
Episodes
Ohio MysteriesEp. 80 - The search for Nancy Theobald's killer
In 1977, there was more than one serial killer stalking young women in the Hamilton County area. Police still hope to learn which one was responsible for…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Belle in the Well
An old homicide out of Lawrence County that last year took a step closer to being solved when authorities were finally able to reveal the identity of a woman…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 79 - What happened to the Markleys?
In 1995, the five Markley children returned from school to find their parents, John and Shelly, missing from their Trumbull County home. The couple was never…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 78 - The unsolved murder of Elizabeth Andes
It was the first murder Oxford police had seen in a quarter century when they arrived at the apartment shared by Miami University grad Elizabeth Andes and her…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Warlock's Grave
It's taken 150 years to build a frightening legend around an old, vandalized grave near New Philadelphia. But if we peel away the years, what will we find?…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 77 - Who ambushed Kevin Brame?
In 1999, Dayton police officer Kevin Brame dropped off his boys at his estranged wife's house, and then was shot in the back by a stalker hidden in the shadows…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Ottawa County's Jane Doe
The young woman - a new mother, by the coroner's estimation - was found dead in Muddy Creek in 1975. But police say it'll be hard to find her killer if they…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 76 - Conspirator? The Edwin Stanton story.
Ohio attorney Edwin Stanton rose from a humble start in Steubenville, Ohio to become President Abraham Lincoln's war secretary. But was he also a conspirator…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Ambrose Bierce
Ohio native Ambrose Bierce became one of the most famous literary stars of his day, as well as a renowned investigative journalist. Still, people raised an…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 75 - Where is Patti Adkins?
Patricia Adkins was a woman in love when she and her married boyfriend planned a romantic getaway to a Canadian cabin in 2001. They were supposed to leave…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Mickey Wilson and Edward Rhodes
On Mother's Day in 2000, someone walked into the Barberton home of Michelli "Mickey" Wilson and Edward Rhodes and shot them in their bed. It turned out to be…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 74 - The Angela Hicks case
Angela Hicks was 14 years old when she disappeared from her Elyria home in 1990. Her stepfather, Samuel Legg III, told police they'd had an argument and she…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: How old is Ohio?
Ohio has been treated like a state since 1803, when Congress extended federal laws to the land. But in 1953, researchers preparing for Ohio's 150th birthday…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 73 - Baseball star Ed Delahanty: Suicide or accident?
Some called Cleveland-born Ed Delahanty baseball's 19th century Babe Ruth. The MLB Hall of Famer is the only slugger to have topped the batting field in both…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: The McAdams Family Mystery
In 1848, Alexander and Rachel McAdams were raising their six children on a farm outside Ashtabula when the first of their children died. Over the next two…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 72 - Who killed Peggy Andrews?
Peggy Andrews was just a dozen steps from the door of the boarding house where the Columbus Business School student was living when she was likely forced at…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Kelly Camargo
The 16-year-old Hamilton, Ohio teen was sweet and kind, but she was also attracted to a rowdy crowd. It led her to the parking lot of a biker bar, where she…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 71 - The Lake Erie Monster
Since the 1700s, Ohio settlers have been reporting sightings of an unusual aquatic species, describing it as 17- to 60-feet long with a sleek body. In the 90s…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Sweetest Day
10-Minute Mystery: Sweetest DayIf you're outside of Ohio, good chance you've never heard of Sweetest Day. If you're in Ohio, good chance you're not doing it…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 70 - The mysterious death of Kurt Sova
A story out of Newburgh Heights in 1981, authorities have never been confident on how to classify the case of 17-year-old Kurt Sova. Did he die in an accident…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Charlotte Nagy Pollis
If Charlotte Nagi Pollis is alive, she'd be 54 years old today. But her family is convinced the mother of two died at the age of 28, when she was reported…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 69 - The harassment of Bill and Dorothy Wacker
A story of torment, Bill and Dorothy Wacker of Massillon, Ohio spent a decade fearing every knock on the door and every ring of their phone. From 1984 through…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 68 - The curious case of Margaret Dodd
Margaret Dodd left Akron soon after marrying, and settled into a contented life with her husband in West Virginia. That is, until 1977, when witnesses saw her…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Alana Gwinner
Dec. 10, 1977 began with a lot of promise for 23-year-old Alana Gwinner, who finished the last exam she needed for her associate's degree in business from the…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 67 - Eugene the Mummy
Authorities never learned the identity of the man who was found dead of natural causes along a road outside Sabina, Ohio in 1929. But he would become the…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Donald Martin
Cincinnati police officer Donald Martin, a young husband and father-to-be, was cut down in the line of duty in 1961 by an unknown assailant. In 2005, two…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 66 - Sam Sheppard. Guilty or not?
In one of the most famous criminal trials of the 20th century, Cleveland physician Sam Sheppard was accused in the brutal beating death of his wife, Marilyn…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Ohio Farmers Insurance - The great robbery
When Ohio Farmers Insurance (the predecessor to Westfield Insurance Companies) was robbed of $60,000 in 1865, the famed detective Alan Pinkerton thought he had…
Ohio MysteriesSpecial: Update Edition
We looked for recent news on previous episodes, and also received mail from people associated with podcasts we've done. This special edition will offer updates…
Ohio MysteriesHoliday rerun: The First Christmas Tree
Episode Notes: For more than 50 years, the country accepted without question that Wooster, Ohio immigrant August Imgard was the first to decorate a Christmas…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 65 - Who killed the Hoods?
In 1991, Margaret and Howard Hood returned home late at night from a card party at their daughter's home. An hour later, a killer entered their New Franklin…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: James Brown, vampire sailor
In 1892, newspapers around the country printed the stunning account of a Portuguese sailor serving time in the Ohio Penitentiary for killing and drinking the…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 64 - Agnes Moorehead and The Conqueror
Actress Agnes Moorehead was a two-time Oscar nominee perhaps best known for playing Endora on the television series Bewitched. When she died in 1974, she…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 63 - Mysterious gravesites (The Merchant family, Joc-O-Sot, Gloria Pressman, H.R. Penney, Philip Cody)
Five mysteries in Ohio that involve the gravesite of notable Ohioans. We explore the strange habits of the granite ball over the Charles Merchant Family plot…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Paula Payne
The morning of Aug. 9, 1977, Paula Payne left her Dayton home and started her walk to where she worked, teaching nature classes to children at the local…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 62 - Gus Sapharas
Gus Sapharas, an Akron native with a long history of attacks against women and a "not guilty" verdict for killing one, is awaiting trial in the deaths of two…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: The Crosswick Monster
The people who lived in the hamlet of Crosswick in southwest Ohio didn't want to question the strange tracks that crossed the dirt road through town, figuring…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 61 - The death of William Henry Harrison
History says President William Henry Harrison - one of eight presidents Ohio gave our country - died from a cold he caught while delivering his lengthy…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Helen Brach
Helen Vorhees Brach is the story of an Ohio farm girl who became an heiress to the Brach candy empire. But as a wealthy widow, her American dream ended in a…
Ohio MysteriesOhio History (Free Patreon Episode)
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Mary Yocono
On Nov. 4, 1985, Mary Yocono, the 79-year-old matriarch of a family that owned a popular Akron restaurant, was struck, killed and abandoned by a motorist on a…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 60 - The miracles of Rhoda Wise
Ep. 58 - The miracles of Rhoda Wise The Catholic Diocese of Youngstown has been on a mission to have the pope recognize a Stark County homemaker for a handful…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: The Franklin Castle
Franklin Castle, built in 1883 in Cleveland's Ohio City neighborhood, was built by banker Hannes Tiedemann. His wife, his mother and four of his children died…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 59 - The Coyne UFO incident
In 1973, four Army Reservists in a helicopter on their way from Columbus to Cleveland had a close encounter with a cigar-shaped metallic object that they…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: The Loveland Frog
In 1972, two Loveland, Ohio police officers, on two separate weeks, spotted a large, strange lizard-like creature on the side of the road, near the banks of…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 58 - Cryptids: The Melonheads & Kenmore Grassman
In a rite of passage, young folks in and around Lake County often make pilgrimages down Wisner Road in Kirtland in search of the Melonheads, mythical humanoid…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Virgil Cates
In Mansfield, businessman Virgil Cates ended up in the news three times in 1983 - first as the victim of a burglary, then arrested as a member of a regional…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 57 - The hazing of Stuart Pierson
In the first case to bring the fraternity tradition of hazing to national consciousness, 18-year-old Stuart Pierson is found decapitated next to train tracks…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: The Ohio Witchcraft Trial
Ohio became a state more than 100 years after all the witchcraft frenzy that made Salem, Mass. famous. And yet superstitions lingered into the 19th century. We…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 56 - The unsolved murder of Michael Klitch
12-year-old Michael Klitch left home one summer day to go practice his tennis serve at the municipal courts in Grandview Heights. A single tennis ball was all…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Knockemstiff
How did the hamlet of Knockemstiff, Ohio get it's name? It's a mystery, but the historical record suggests its a name that is well-earned. We explore the kinds…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 55 - What happened to Sharon Pretorius
Sharon Lynn Pretorius was 13 years old when she left her Dayton home in 1973 to collect from customers on her newspaper route. She never even made it to her…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Lincoln Ellsworth and the North Pole controversy
In 1926, Rear Admiral Richard Byrd became a household name after being the first to fly over the North Pole. But after his diary from the trip was…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 54 - The Mad Butcher of Kingsbury Run
In the 1930s, Cleveland had its own gruesome version of Jack the Ripper. The Mad Butcher of Kingsbury Run - also known as the Torso Murderer - targeted men and…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: The disappearance of the tug Cornell
Lake Erie has a reputation for swallowing ships whole in a storm, but what reason did it have for taking the tug Cornell? The boat left Cleveland for Buffalo…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 53 - The Athens Lunatic Asylum
Some say Athens is one of the most haunted places in the world. If true, much of it is owed to an old asylum that spent a century using barbaric practices on…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: The mysterious death of a Titanic survivor
Elizabeth Hocking, a British mother who was relocating her entire family to Ohio from Cornwall, England, boarded the Titanic for the move. Six family members…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 52 - The death of Tiffin Ofc. Patrick Sweeney
Tiffin Officer Patrick Sweeney was at Marshall August Shultz's side when a shooter cut Shultz down in 1895, an event that stunned the small town and made…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: The Great Serpent Mound
The Great Serpent Mound in Adams County is the largest effigy mound on the face of the planet, a 1,348 earthen sculpture of a snake swallowing an egg. But who…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 51 - The mystery of Richard Colvin Cox
In 1950, Mansfield native Richard Cox was in his second year at the United States Military Academy in West Point, NY when he was visited several times by an…