Shows / Ohio Mysteries

Ohio Mysteries
Each week Ohio Mysteries explores unsolved murders, lost shipwrecks, local legends and more! https://www.ohiomysteries.com. https://www.facebook.com/ohiomysteries https://www.patreon.com/ohiomysteries https://www.twitter.com/mysteriesohio
In any given episode we feature fantastic music by the following music-https://soundcloud.com/davidhydemusic. https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCL0pcAGV4g67jCxGIPWv9iQ https://www.youtube.com/c/WhitesandComposer https://www.youtube.com/user/audionautix…
Episodes
Ohio MysteriesEp. 112 - BCI Cold Cases: Zastudil, Thompson, Hebert
In the summer of 2020, the Ohio Bureau of Criminal Investigation announced a new cold case squad, with an initial 11 cased on its primary target list. We…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Arthur Noske
In 1977, 8-year-old Arthur Noske was beaten to death by his mother's boyfriend, Dr. Stuart Kutler, who had failed at trying to burn his corpse. Kutler…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 111 - The Highland Square Rapist
In 1975 and 1976, a rapist stalked the women of Akron's Highland Square neighborhood. This episode features an interview with one of the victims of that dark…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Charlotte Rexroad
In 1970, Charlotte Rexroad was a mother of four struggling to raise her family in a dilapidated hotel room in downtown Canton. She left with her boyfriend one…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 110 - The missing crew of Ghost Blimp
In the 1942, in an Akron-built Goodyear blimp delivered to the Navy after the start of WWII, a two-man crew set out over the Pacific from San Francisco for a…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 109 - The Donner Party, Part 2
Continuing our story of the 1846 wagon train that met a tragic fate after attempting a shortcut on their way from the midwest to California. In this episode…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 109 - The Donner Party, Part 1
In 1846, a wagon train of nearly 90 people headed from the midwest to California took a newly advertised cutoff that doomed them to a tragic fate. In this…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 108 - Charlie Root and the Babe Ruth controversy
In the 1932 World Series, legendary slugger Babe Ruth reportedly pointed at the bleachers and predicted the homerun he hit a moment later. Or did he? Decades…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Denise Chance
In the early morning hours of a winter night in 1985, 18-year-old Denise Chance said goodnight to the woman she shared a Springfield, Ohio house with and went…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 107 - The Mothman
In 1966, people in the Ohio River communities of Point Pleasant, West Virginia and Gallipolis, Ohio saw a strange flying creature they couldn't identify. When…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Katelyn Markham
In August of 2011, Katelyn Markham vanished from her home in Fairfield, Ohio. The Art Institute of Cincinnati student was two days from her 22nd birthday and…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 106 - What lies beneath Cincinnati's Music Hall
Cincinnati's Music Hall was built over a pauper's cemetery, with victims from a ship explosion, a cholera epidemic, an insane asylum and a military hospital…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Tiffany Papesh
In the summer of 1980, 8-year-old Tiffany Papesh walked to a store half a block away to pick up hamburger buns for a camping trip. She was never seen again…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 105 - Searching for ET: Marjorie Fish and the Hills
In 1961, New Hampshire couple Betty and Barney Hill claimed to have been abducted by aliens, and revealed a star map showing the home of their abductors. After…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Symmes' Hollow Earth Theory
10-Minute Mystery: Symmes' Hollow Earth Theory John Cleves Symmes Jr., who died in Hamilton, Ohio in 1829, spent his later years lecturing about his theory…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 104 - Elizabeth Stiles and the Madison Seminary
Elizabeth Stiles was asked by Abraham Lincoln himself to spy for the Union Army during the Civil War, and she served with distinction through many close calls…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Kenneth A. Roth
In May of 2020, convicted killer Kenneth A. Roth died from the Covid 19 virus at the Marion County Correctional Institution, but authorities said he took…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 103 - Prohibition's "Dry Boss" Wayne Wheeler
How could a freedom-loving country agree to a nationwide ban on alcohol? Historians say if you want to blame Prohibition on someone, look no further than…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Warren G Harding's love child
In 2020, an Oregon man asked an Ohio court for permission to exhume President Harding from his crypt in Marion, Ohio in order to obtain direct DNA evidence…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 102 - Where is Ashley Summers?
Ashley Summers was going through a rebellious phase as many 14-year-olds do when she was sent to live with her grandma in Cleveland's Tremont area in the…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Sandra Kay Young
The year 1963 was a dark one for the stretch of Stark County from Massillon to Canton. Gangland murders and raids on underworld prostitution houses resulted in…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 101 - What happened to Mary Jane Vangilder?
Mary Jane Vangilder was a mother of five and wife of an abusive husband when she walked away from her West Virginia home in 1945 and wound up at a wartime…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: More mysterious graves
Why does the Painesville, Ohio tombstone of Joseph Linhart proclaim him to be "Not Guilty." Why did thousands of people visit the McMorran family plot in a…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 100 - 2nd Anniversary Special: Updates
Ohio Mysteries celebrates its second anniversary. Updates on episodes that made news in 2020; listener questions answered; a year in review…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: The War of 1812 boatyard
When the War of 1812 broke out, a young America had to prove it could defend its borders, this time from a British incursion across Lake Erie. Military…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 99 - What happened to Erica Baker?
It took five years to identify one of the people who was with 9-year-old Erica Baker at the moment she took her last breath. But without a body, police only…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Lori Ann Hill
In 1985, 14-year-old Swanton, Ohio youth Lori Ann Hill got into a fight with her boyfriend at a Halloween party and walked away. She didn't make it home. Her…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 98 - Where is Brian Shaffer?
In 2006, Ohio State University medical student Brian Shaffer vanished into thin air. A grainy image captured on a camera at the Ugly Tuna Saloona bar showed…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Sojourner Truth
In 1851, at the second National Woman's Rights Convention held in Akron, Ohio, a runaway slave named Sojourner Truth used her compelling life as an argument in…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 97 - The Cave: An Underground Railroad story
In 1892, a man named John wrote a three-part series for the local Middletown, Ohio newspaper detailing two tragic events that led to at least 25 deaths in a…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Elisha Gray and the telephone
In 1876, Alexander Graham Bell was awarded the patent for the telephone. But historical evidence suggests the design Bell used was actually the invention of…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 95 - What sunk the GP Griffith?
In 1850, the passenger ship GP Griffith set sail with its new owner and more than 300 travelers hoping to start their new lives in America's growing midwest…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Janice and Brandon Beidleman
In 1981, young mom Janice Beidleman and her 18-month old son Brandon were on their way home after visiting relatives when they disappeared. That night…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 94 - Who killed Michael Williams?
In 2005, troopers responded to a call about a car that had driven off Greenwood Road near Rogers, Ohio in Columbiana County. The driver, 37-year-old Michael…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: David Evans
In 1975, 13-year-old David Evans never returned home after heading out to skate at a local park in Boardman, Ohio. He was found dead days later, killed by a…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 93 - The unsolved murder of Brad Bellino
In 1972, 12-year-old Brad Bellino was walking from his buddy's home in Boardman, Ohio to his own home when he vanished. His brutalized body was found a few…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Lynn Vest and Jeremy Pickens
In 1980, Lynn Vest and her 2-year-old nephew Jeremy Pickens left her Columbus home to run some errands - and never returned. They were found later that night…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Susan Wolff Cappel
In 1982, Susan Wolff Cappel was walking to her car after work when a blue car cut her off. After a brief conversation with the driver, she slipped into the…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 91 - From hunter to prey
There is an inherent danger to hunting, with an average of 75 people killed in the U.S. and Canada every year while in the act of hunting everything from deer…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Dorothea Irwin
In 1983, Wyoming, Ohio businesswoman Dorothea Irwin was found dead in the home she was trying to sell. She had been slashed and stabbed repeatedly, and had…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 90 - The Lost Ones: Searching for identities
In June of 2020, the national database NAMUS included 105 unidentified remains in the custody of various agencies across Ohio. We share the stories behind five…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Carrie Culberson
In 1997, Clinton County prosecutors pulled off the nearly impossible. They won conviction of a man for a murder in which they could not produce a body. Vince…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 89 - The final days of Harriet Kaltenbach
A few days after Christmas In 1981, Chillicothe police found Harriet Kaltenbach shot dead in a running car. As they pieced together the erratic timeline of her…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Leon Moncer
In 1982, 21-year-old Leon Moncer started acting paranoid, especially after a letter arrived with glossy magazine letters pasted into a warning: "Leave it alone…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 88 - Who killed Agatha Reichlin?
In 1903, Agatha Reichlin, the pretty and popular sister of a Lorain priest, was murdered in her own bed. A community anxious for a quick resolution to the…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Michael Swango, Doctor of Death
At least half a dozen people died mysteriously when Dr. Michael Swango began his surgical internship at Ohio State University Medical Center. By the time…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 87 - The secret life of Lawrence Bader
In 1957, Akron father and cookware salesman Lawrence Bader failed to return from a Lake Erie fishing trip, and after his damaged boat washed ashore, he was…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Brian Foguth
In 1994, Brian Foguth offered to fill in for another employee where he worked as a clerk at the Duke and Duchess convenience store in Portage County's…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 86 - The brutal killing of Beverly Jarosz
Three days after Christmas in 1964, Beverly Jarosz - a 16-year-old junior in Garfield Heights - would wake up for her last morning in the bedroom where someone…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Murray Griffin and Phyllis Mullet
In 1986, the part-time town marshall of Belle Center took a call from someone who feared for the safety of another town resident. Murray Griffin responded to…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 85 - Marietta: And then there was one.
Between 1990 and 1992, three young women who had attended the Washington County Career Center together were murdered . A decade after the death of Ronda…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: The New London Skeleton
Episode Notes: In this episode we discuss the exciting news about Barbara Blatnik's murder being solved with the help of the Porchlight Project. Then we…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 84 - The Mansfield Reformatory
The Ohio State Reformatory is nationally famous for its role in movies like The Shawshank Redemption, Tango and Cash, and Air Force One. But the abandoned…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: The furniture store murders
On July 30, 1973 in East Liverpool, an antique shopper came across a gruesome scene: Three bludgeoned bodies in a used furniture shop. Although witnesses saw a…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 83 - The killing of Isabel Cordle
In 1988, Bellevue wife and mother Isabel Cordle fell asleep on the living room couch watching television. She was found the next morning, a large gash in her…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Permon Gilbert
Permon Gilbert was a popular and respected husband, father and GE appliance repairman in Hamersville, Ohio when he disappeared after making house calls on May…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 82 - Phenomenon
Four strange events that either science has trouble explaining, or Ohioans have trouble believing: A town besieged by falling worms, another pelted with a rain…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Jill Holzbach
On February 6, 1991, Jill Holzbach was in the race of her life. With someone chasing her car, she made the decision to drive to the Stark County parking lot of…
Ohio MysteriesEp. 81 - Gangsters and the Dynamite Murder
In 1952, a Wyandot County farmer taking his trash into the woods near his home came across a gruesome sight: Body parts blasted into the trees. Detectives…
Ohio Mysteries10-Minute Mystery: Where are John Hundley and James McQueary?
John Hundley and James McQueary were 9-year-old inseparable best friends in 1964 when they vanished from their neighborhood. No trace of them or evidence of…