Shows / Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
We’re Sarah & Tina—2 divas with a serious true crime obsession.
It all started on our first trip away together, when we realized we could spend hours listening to true crime podcasts, watching documentaries, swapping theories, and talking endlessly about the cases that fascinated us.
So naturally, starting our own true crime podcast seemed like the next logical step!
Join us each week as we dive into cases ranging from infamous crimes and shocking scandals to unsolved mysteries, disappearances…
Episodes
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 48: Lindsay Clancy
Sarah leads this episode as we head to Duxbury, Massachusetts, and the devastating case of Lindsay Clancy, a labor and delivery nurse and mother of three whose…
Deadly Divas True Crime PodcastIn the Headlines: Russell Brand
Tina leads this In the Headlines episode as we dive into the shocking criminal case against British comedian, actor, and television personality Russell Brand…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Halloween Special Short Story: Evil Elsa
Happy Halloween Divas & Dudes. Today we bring you a fun short true story about an Evil Elsa Doll!! Yup! You read that right... This Elsa would not.... Let It…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 47: The Candy Man
Tina leads this episode as we head back to Halloween night, 1974, and the case that helped create one of America’s most enduring Halloween fears…
Deadly Divas True Crime PodcastIn the Headlines: Collin Gosselin
Tina leads this In the Headlines episode about Collin Gosselin, one of the 8 children who grew up in front of millions of viewers on TLC's Jon & Kate Plus 8…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 46: The Devil On Trial
Sarah leads this episode as we dive into one of the scariest murder cases in American history: The Devil on Trial, also known as the infamous “The Devil Made…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 45: The Ouija Board Murder
Tina leads this episode as we travel back to 1930's Arizona for one of the strangest murder cases we’ve covered yet. When 15-year-old Mattie Turley shot her…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 44: The Greenbrier Ghost
Sarah leads the second episode of our Spooktacular as we travel back to 1897 West Virginia for the case often called “the only murder ever solved by a ghost.”…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Christa Pike: Execution Update
Sarah brings us an update following the failed execution of Christa Pike. More drama surrounded this case this week, after a last-minute stay of execution was…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 43: The Watcher
Tina leads our first Spooktacular episode with the chilling true story of The Watcher. When Derek and Maria Broaddus purchased their dream home at 657…
Deadly Divas True Crime PodcastIn the Headlines: The Cornell 7
Tina leads this In the Headlines episode on The Cornell 7. A former Cornell student alleges she was drugged and sexually assaulted by multiple Chi Phi…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 42: The Yogurt Shop Murders
Tina leads this episode about the case that haunted Austin, Texas for more than three decades — The Yogurt Shop Murders. In December 1991, four teenage girls…
Deadly Divas True Crime PodcastIn the Headlines: Caleb Flynn
Tina leads this In the Headlines episode covering the ongoing murder trial of Caleb Flynn, a former American Idol contestant and church worship leader accused…
Deadly Divas True Crime PodcastIn the Headlines: Christa Pike
Sarah leads her first In the Headlines episode as we discuss the disturbing case of Christa Pike — the only woman currently on Tennessee’s death row. In 1995…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 41: Pam Hupp
Sarah leads this episode about the unbelievable case of Pam Hupp. In 2011, Betsy Faria was found murdered inside her Missouri home, and suspicion quickly fell…
Deadly Divas True Crime PodcastIn the Headlines: KJ Biermann
Today on In the Headlines, Tina breaks down the disturbing allegations involving KJ Biermann, the son of Real Housewives of Atlanta star Kim Zolciak and former…
Deadly Divas True Crime PodcastIn the Headlines: Andrew Tate
Andrew and Tristan Tate are facing an increasingly complicated web of criminal allegations and legal proceedings spanning multiple countries. In this episode…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 40: Lizzie Borden
Tina leads this episode about the infamous unsolved double homicide that rocked Fall River, Massachusetts, on August 4, 1892. Andrew and Abby Borden were…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 39: Christina Morris - Labor Day Bonus Episode
Sarah leads this episode about the disappearance of 23-year-old Christina Morris — a Texas woman whose family, friends, and an army of volunteers refused to…
Deadly Divas True Crime PodcastIn the Headlines: Lindsay Clancy
Tina leads another episode of In the Headlines. After 6 weeks of testimony and 7 days of deliberations, the Lindsay Clancy trial has ended in a mistrial. In…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 38: Heather Elvis
Sarah leads this episode about the mysterious disappearance of 20-year-old Heather Elvis, a beautiful, outgoing young woman from Myrtle Beach, South Carolina…
Deadly Divas True Crime PodcastIn the Headlines: The Horsch House of Horrors
Tina is back with another In the Headlines episode covering a disturbing and rapidly developing investigation out of Philadelphia. What began with a routine…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 37: The TikTok Dance Cult
Tina leads this episode into the unsettling world of 7M Films, Shekinah Church, and the man at the center of it all: Robert Shinn. What appeared on social…
Deadly Divas True Crime PodcastIn The Headlines: Laken Snelling
Welcome to Deadly Divas: In The Headlines! Tina brings you something a little different with a shorter episode covering a case making headlines right now. In…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 36: The Idaho 4 Murders
Sarah leads this episode about the murders of four University of Idaho students — Kaylee Goncalves, Madison Mogen, Xana Kernodle, and Ethan Chapin — and the…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 35: Lorena Bobbitt
Tina leads this episode about the infamous case of Lorena Bobbitt (now Lorena Gallo.) You may think you know this story, but we're peeling back the layers on…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 34: Fred & Rose West
Sarah leads this episode about England's most notorious serial killer couple, Fred & Rose West. Fred & Rose West's reign of terror against not just the young…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 33: Shanquella Robinson
Tina leads this episode about the tragic death of a beautiful, successful, kind, and ambitious 25 year old woman named Shanquella Robinson. In October 2022…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 32: Daisy De La O
Sarah leads this episode about a beautiful, talented, sweet, and creative young woman named Daisy, living in Compton. She was tragically murdered at just 19…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 31: Depraved Heart
Tina leads this episode as we dive into the disturbing case featured on 48 Hours: The Depraved Heart Murder—the death of 25-year-old Sarah Harris and the case…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 30: Maternal Instinct
Sarah leads this episode as we dive into Netflix’s Maternal Instinct and the horrifying case of Taylor Parker, whose elaborate web of lies about being pregnant…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
BONUS July 4th Episode: The Kunz Family Murders
Sarah leads this episode about the unsettling events that occurred in Athens, Wisconsin on July 4th, 1987. Five members of the Kunz family tragically lost…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 29: Tonda Dickerson
Tina leads this episode as we dive into the absolutely bonkers story of Tonda Dickerson, an Alabama Waffle House waitress whose life changed when a regular…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 28: Gabby Petito
Sarah leads this episode as we dive into the heartbreaking case of Gabby Petito, the 22-year-old whose disappearance during a cross-country “van life” trip…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 27: Barry Morphew
Tina leads this episode as we dive into the disappearance and death of Suzanne Morphew and the complicated case against her husband, Barry Morphew. Suzanne…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
BONUS Episode 26: Karmelo Anthony & Austin Metcalf
Tina leads this episode as we dive into the case that sparked a massive national debate: the fatal stabbing of 17-year-old Austin Metcalf by 17-year-old…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 25: Drew Peterson
Sarah leads this episode as we dive into the disturbing case of Drew Peterson, the former Illinois police sergeant whose third wife was found dead—and whose…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 24: Betty Broderick
Tina leads this episode as we dive into the infamous case of Betty Broderick—a bitter divorce, an affair, years of escalating hostility, and a double murder…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
BONUS Episode 23: The Crash
Sarah leads this episode as we dive into the shocking case of Mackenzie Shirilla and the early-morning crash that killed her boyfriend, Dominic Russo, and…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 22: After Show
We discuss all the different theories and characters involved in the Staircase, such a lot to delve into! Don't miss this after show!! Support the show Don't…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 22: The Staircase
Sarah leads this episode as we dive into the infamous case known simply as “The Staircase”—the mysterious death of Kathleen Peterson and the sensational murder…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 21: The Gilgo Beach Killer
Tina leads this episode as we dive into the haunting Gilgo Beach serial killings—a case that began with the search for one missing woman and ultimately…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 19: FREE After Show
After shows are usually for subscribers only, but we have made this one available for everyone! Enjoy! Support the show Don't forget to send us your feedback…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 19: The Grizzly Grannies of LA
Sarah leads this episode as we dive into the absolutely wild case of Helen Golay and Olga Rutterschmidt—two elderly Los Angeles women who met at a health spa…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 18: Kouri Richins
Tina leads this episode about one of our most recent favorite villains - Kouri Richins. Is Kouri the grieving widow who wrote a children's book for her kids to…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 17: Scott Peterson
Sarah leads this episode as we take a deep dive into one of the most infamous true crime cases in America: Scott Peterson and the murders of his pregnant wife…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 16: The Hypnotist Principal
Tina leads this episode as we dive into one of the strangest stories we’ve ever covered: the Florida high school principal who hypnotized his students. Yes…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 15: Misook Wang
Sarah leads this episode as we dive into the twisted case of Misook Wang, a woman convicted of murdering her 70-year-old mother-in-law, Linda Tyda—and who…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 14: What Jennifer Did
Tina leads this episode as we dive into Netflix’s What Jennifer Did and the unbelievable case of Jennifer Pan—a young Canadian woman whose carefully…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 13: Skylar Neese
Sarah leads this episode as we dive into the heartbreaking and almost unbelievable murder of 16-year-old Skylar Neese—a West Virginia teenager betrayed by the…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 12: Sherri Papini
Tina leads this episode as we dive into the absolutely bonkers case of Sherri Papini, the California mother whose disappearance sparked a massive search and…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 11: Casey Anthony
Sarah leads this episode as we dive into one of the most infamous and heavily publicized true crime cases in modern American history: the death of two-year-old…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 8: Funeral Home of Horrors
Tina leads this episode about another 'HBO Curious Case Of...' episode, and this one is absolutely VILE. Join us as we dive into The Funeral Home of…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Friday the 13th Bonus: Glenn Milner
Tina leads this Friday the 13th bonus episode about a horrific murder that occurred on Friday, July 13, 1990. On Friday the 13th, 19-year-old Kenneth Glenn…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Bonus Episode: The Death Cap Mushroom Murders
Sarah leads this surprise bonus episode, Death Cap: The Mushroom Murders—a wild true crime documentary she discovered on UK Netflix while she was visiting. A…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 6: Queenpins
Sarah leads this episode as we break down the wild true story behind the 2021 movie Queenpins and compare Hollywood vs. reality. What sounds like a harmless…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 5: The Scream Murder
Tina leads this episode as we break down Hulu’s The Scream Murder: A True Teen Horror Story—the disturbing case of a teenage girl whose brutal murder drew…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 4: Unknown Number
Sarah leads this episode as we dive into Netflix's Unknown Number: The High School Catfish. Follow along with us as we dissect the truly shocking case of high…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 1: Get to Know Your Divas!
Welcome to Deadly Divas - a true crime podcast with big diva energy! We're so grateful you're here! Wanna know how we are, what we're about, and what to expect…
- Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
Episode 2: Kurt & Courtney
Sarah leads us on our first ever in-depth episode of a true crime documentary, "Kurt & Coutney" a film by Nick Broomfield released in 1998. In our intro…