Shows / Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal

Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal
Choosing To Stay After Infidelity & Betrayal is a podcast for couples navigating the aftermath of infidelity, betrayal, and broken trust. Whether you’re a betrayed partner making sense of the pain, or the partner who caused harm and wants to repair what was broken, this show offers trauma-informed tools, honest conversations, and grounded hope. Hosted by Hali Roderick, the podcast explores trust repair, emotional regulation, accountability, boundaries, and discernment—without rushing…
Episodes
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#185 Beyond Sobriety: Accountability, Integrity, and Intimacy with Tryan Stutes
Stopping the behavior matters. But is it recovery? In this episode, Hali sits down with Tryan Stutes, a Certified Sex Addiction Recovery Coach and Christian…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#184 Safe Enough to Fall Apart
Couples often expect that when the partner who broke trust finally starts showing up differently (steadier, less defensive, actually listening), the betrayed…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#183 "Why Men'sGroups Matter in Recovery" with Alonso Pool
A lot of men in recovery are doing the work: therapy, transparency, maybe even a formal disclosure. But many of them are doing it alone. They tell their…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#182 She's Not Coming At You — She's Coming To You
"Why is she coming at me?" It's one of the most common things men say after betrayal — when their partner's pain shows up as tears, anger, a raised voice, or…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#181 Emotional Infidelity: When the Affair Was Never Physical with Jill Pool
What counts as cheating if nothing physical ever happened? In this episode, Hali sits down with Certified Partner Coach, Jill Pool to name what so often goes…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#180 Doing Recovery vs. Living Recovery: What Actually Heals a Relationship After Betrayal with Mike Tiede
You've done the work. So why does healing still feel like something you're performing instead of living? In this episode, Hali sits down with psychologist and…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#179 - 5 Ways to Stay in Your Marriage Without Losing Yourself After Infidelity and Betrayal
When you're trying to heal a marriage after infidelity or betrayal, it's easy for recovery to become the center of everything. In this episode, Hali explores…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#178 Understanding Intimacy Anorexia — with Dr. Janice Caudill, PhD
"Intimacy anorexia" is one of the most talked-about — and most misunderstood — terms in betrayal recovery. In this episode, I set out to understand it…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#177 One Hour a Week Was Never Going to Be Enough
If you're a woman and you’re doing the work — therapy, coaching, reading everything you can get your hands on — and you're still white-knuckling it alone most…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#176 The Fight Under the Fight — Decoding What Betrayal Trauma Does to Your Everyday Arguments
If you're rebuilding trust after infidelity, you've probably noticed something strange: small disagreements can escalate way faster and way bigger than the…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#175 The Separation Plan Guide: Navigating Time Apart After Betrayal Trauma with Shawna Meek, PCC, CPC-S
"Separation" doesn't have to mean divorce. In this episode, I'm joined by Shawna Meek of Living Stones Coaching to talk about the therapeutic separation — a…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal***BONUS Choosing Different Mini Series: What I Wish I'd Done Differently with my daughters, Mataia and Morgan
In this episode of the Choosing Different mini-series, Hali is joined by her daughters, Mataia and Morgan, for an honest conversation about betrayal trauma's…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#174 It's Not Too Late: Healing an Affair You Thought Was Behind You
If the betrayal in your relationship happened years ago — and life moved forward, but the deepest layers of healing never actually happened — this episode is…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#173 Betrayed Men: Why Their Trauma Looks Different — and What Actually Helps with Dr. Laney Knowlton
When we talk about betrayal trauma, the picture most people carry is of a betrayed woman. But men experience betrayal too — and their pain often goes unseen…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#172 Why the Right Words Aren't Enough: Embodied Empathy in Betrayal Recovery
You can say all the right words and still leave your partner feeling completely unsafe. If you're the partner who caused harm, that may be the most frustrating…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal*** BONUS Choosing Different Mini Series: Three Words Every Parent Owes Their Child: "I Believe You"
What happens when a child no longer has to convince their parent that their pain was real? In this episode of Choosing Different Mini Series, Hali sits down…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#171 Elements of Healthy Relationships in Recovery with Randi Gray
What does a truly healthy relationship look like after infidelity and betrayal — and is it even possible to get there? In this episode, Hali sits down with Dr…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal***BONUS: Choosing Different Mini Series: The Conversations I Wish Every Parent and Child Could Have with my 2 Adult Daughters, Mataia and Morgan
This is the first episode of the Choosing Different mini-series of conversations between Hali and her two adult daughters, who were both teenagers when their…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#170 "Why It Sometimes Gets Worse Before It Gets Better — And What Actually Helps After Disclosure"
You finally know the truth. So why do you feel worse? If you're the betrayed partner and your fear, anger, and grief have grown rather than shrunk since…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#169 The Spiritual Intelligence Behind Real Change After Betrayal with Dr. Yosi Amram
When someone betrays a partner and then starts doing "the work," the person who was hurt is left with an exhausting question: is this real, or is he just…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#168 Apology vs. Amends: Why "I'm Sorry" Isn't Enough After Betrayal
An apology is a moment. Making amends is a process - and confusing the two is one of the most common places betrayal recovery gets stuck. In this solo episode…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#167 Masculine and Feminine: Why Getting the Balance Right in Your Relationship Matters with Tyler Patrick
There's a dynamic underneath a lot of disconnected relationships that almost nobody names — and when it collapses, it can quietly erode intimacy. In this…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#166 Why Shame Is the Enemy of Accountability — And What to Do About It with Jacob Fletcher, CMCH, CSAT
One of the biggest obstacles to healing after betrayal isn't a lack of love — it's shame. When the person in recovery floods with shame, they lose the ability…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#165 The Groundhog Day of Disclosure: Why the Same Questions Keep Coming
After betrayal, one of the most exhausting patterns couples hit is what I call the Groundhog Day of disclosure: the betrayed partner asking the same questions…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#164 The Children in the Room: Navigating Divorce and Betrayal Without Breaking Your Kids with Katie Padilla, Certified Family Law Specialist
When a marriage is in crisis, the conversation almost always centers on the couple. But what about the children sitting in the middle of it? In this episode…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#163 Control Isn't Safety: Understanding the Parent-Child Dynamic After Betrayal
If you've been checking your partner's location for the fifth time in an hour - or waiting for your spouse to hand you a roadmap to your own recovery - this…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#162 When ADHD Meets Betrayal Trauma: Understanding Recovery for the Whole Family System with Monifa Ellis-Addie, LMFT, CSAT, CCSP and Morgan Ellsworth, LAMFT, CCSP
What happens when ADHD and betrayal trauma collide in the same family? This episode is one of the most important conversations we've had on the podcast — and…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#161 Why Can’t We Connect Deeper? Exploring the Hidden Struggles of Connection After Betrayal
One of the most confusing parts of healing after betrayal is that couples can do “all the right things” and still feel emotionally disconnected. In this…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#160 When Your Body Decides the Relationship Is No Longer Safe" Understanding the Nervous System Trauma Loop in Betrayal Recovery
Have you ever wondered why you and your partner keep having the same painful conversations — even when you both want things to be different? The answer might…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal***BONUS EPISODE*** You’re Invited: Becoming Together Mother-Daughter Retreat with my daughters, Mataia and Morgan
What does it look like when a mother and daughter do the healing work together? In this special episode, I'm joined by my daughters to pull back the curtain on…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#159 Why Every Conversation Feels So Hard After Betrayal
After infidelity or betrayal, even simple conversations can feel loaded, tense, or unsafe. You may feel like: You’re trying to connect… but it keeps going…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#158 What Actually Changes When Healing Is Happening
After betrayal, one of the most common questions couples ask is: “How do we know if we’re actually healing?” Are we moving forward… or just surviving? Is this…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#157 Boundaries That Heal vs. Boundaries That Punish
After betrayal, boundaries become one of the most talked about — and most misunderstood — parts of healing. Many couples find themselves stuck in painful…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#156 Anger After Betrayal — What It Really Means & How to Work With It with Matt Wenger, LPC, CSAT, CCPS
Anger is one of the most misunderstood emotions in betrayal trauma — but still shapes every interaction, every conversation, and every attempt at repair. In…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#155 Resolving the Push-Pull Dynamic of the Trauma Bond with Dr. Nima Rahmany
In this episode, I sit down with Dr. Nima Rahmany to unpack the push-pull dynamic that so many couples experience after betrayal or relational trauma. He…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#154 Healing Fatigue After Betrayal: When You’re Both Just Tired
After betrayal, many couples expect the hardest part to be the initial crisis. But what often comes next is something quieter—and just as real: healing…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#153 Staying or Leaving After Betrayal — Discernment for Both Partners
After betrayal, one of the most painful questions couples face is: Do we stay… or do we leave? In this episode, we explore why that question feels so urgent…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#152 The Individual Healing That Saved Our Marriage with Chance and Crystal
Today we’re talking about something that can feel counterintuitive when a relationship is in crisis: slowing down and focusing on individual healing first. So…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#151 Why Apologies Aren’t Enough to Heal Betrayal Trauma
Why doesn’t an apology fix betrayal trauma? If you’ve experienced infidelity, pornography addiction, or relational betrayal, you may have heard the words “I’m…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#150 What Accountability Actually Means After Betrayal (And What It Doesn’t)
Accountability is one of the most talked-about — and most misunderstood — parts of betrayal recovery. For many couples healing after infidelity or sexual…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#149 The Inner Child Model™: Understanding Pain, Behavior, and Healing with Dr. Eddie Capparucci
In this episode, I’m joined by Dr. Eddie Capparucci, a licensed professional counselor and creator of the Inner Child Model™, to explore how emotional…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#148: Don’t Forget the Children: Betrayal Trauma’s Impact on the Family System
Betrayal trauma is often talked about as a couple’s crisis, but betrayal is never contained to the marriage alone. In this episode, Hali Roderick and her…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#147 We’re Both Grieving — But Not the Same Way: How Couples Navigate Grief Together After Betrayal
Grief is one of the most misunderstood parts of betrayal recovery — especially for couples who are choosing to stay. In this episode, Hali Roderick explores…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#146 Grief After Betrayal: What Men Lose—and Why It Matters for Healing
Grief after betrayal is rarely talked about—especially when it comes to men. In this episode, we explore grief after betrayal for men, including men in…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#145 Nutrition, Trauma, and Recovery: Using Food as an Ally, Not Another Battleground with Dr. David Wiss
Today’s conversation sits at the intersection of trauma, recovery, and compassion for the body. Many listeners of Choosing to Stay are navigating betrayal…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#144 When Love Becomes a Threat: How Betrayal Rewires the Nervous System—and What Helps
After betrayal, many couples believe they’re struggling with communication—but what’s really happening is much deeper. Betrayal doesn’t just break trust; it…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#143 Staying When You’re the Only One Doing the Work — with Tammy Gustafson, MA, LPC
What does it really mean to stay grounded in yourself when you’re the one doing the emotional work in the relationship? In this episode, I’m joined by Tammy…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#142 Why Your Body Doesn’t Trust Yet (Even If Your Brain Wants To)
“One of the most painful places couples get stuck after betrayal is right here: One partner is thinking, ‘We’re okay. Why can’t we move on?’ And the other is…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and BetrayalBONUS Episode Rise, Renew Restore: A Transformative Women’s Retreat in Costa Rica
In this special bonus episode, Hali Roderick is joined by her friends and trusted colleagues Amie Woolsey and Alana Gordon for a shared conversation about the…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#141 When “We’re Still Together” Isn’t the Same as Healing
Many couples stay together after infidelity—but staying together isn’t the same as healing. In this episode of Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#140 Can You Really Heal After Betrayal?
Can a relationship really heal after infidelity—or does staying just mean learning how to live with the pain? In this relaunch episode of Choosing To Stay…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#139 Renewed Commitment — Doing Whatever It Takes to Mend Betrayal
This episode is one of the early conversations that shaped the heart of this podcast, and we’re bringing it back because its message is just as important today…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#138 Trauma Triage: What Couples Need in the Early Days After Betrayal
This special re-release revisits one of the most important conversations from our early episodes — an episode so foundational that we felt it needed to be…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#137 Looking Back, Looking Forward: A Special Episode About Transition & Growth
This special episode of Choosing to Stay marks a heartfelt transition and an important moment for our community. Hali and Stephanie sit down for one final…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#136 Emotional Recovery in Relationship Repair
Stopping destructive behaviors is only the beginning. In recovery after betrayal, many partners achieve behavioral sobriety but struggle with emotional…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#135 Healing Is the Gift You Give to Yourself (and Everyone You Love)
In this episode, we share a core truth of couples' recovery: healing starts with honoring yourself — and that personal work naturally becomes a gift to your…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#134 Supporting Children Through the Holidays After Betrayal
In this episode, Hali welcomes her daughter, Morgan Ellsworth, BCC, MFT-I to talk about how to help children feel secure, loved, and grounded during the…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#133 Meeting Your Betrayed Spouse in the Mess: Empathy, Patience, and Presence Through the Holidays
In this honest and compassionate episode, Hali and Stephanie speak directly to those who have betrayed trust and are navigating the deep discomfort of the…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal#132 When the Season Doesn’t Feel Merry: Honoring Grief, Creating Boundaries, and Finding Grace
In this heartfelt episode, When the Season Doesn’t Feel Merry: Honoring Grief, Creating Boundaries, and Finding Grace, Hali and Stephanie talk about how to…
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal***BONUS EPISODE*** Rooted & Rising: A New Space for Women Healing After Betrayal
In this special episode, Hali shares from the heart about her next chapter — the creation of Rooted & Rising After Betrayal, a new podcast and healing…