Shows / All Fantasy Everything
All Fantasy Everything
All Fantasy Everything is a show where funny people and experts come together to fantasy draft pop culture, from music to movies to sandwiches, everything is in play.
This is a Headgum podcast. Follow Headgum on Twitter, Instagram, and Tiktok. Advertise on All Fantasy Everything via Gumball.fm.
Episodes
- All Fantasy Everything
Florida (w/ Dan Hernandez)
It’s time to cut some nuts. Guest: Dan Hernandez (@cubanmissiledh) Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at patreon.com/allfantasy for ad-free episodes…
- All Fantasy Everything
2026 Halloween Costumes (w/ Rachel Bonnetta)
BOO! Guest: Rachel Bonnetta (@rachelbonnetta) Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at patreon.com/allfantasy for ad-free episodes, mailbags, auction drafts…
- All Fantasy Everything
Horses (w/ Serra Naiman)
[loud neighing] Guest: Serra Naiman (@serra.naiman) Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at patreon.com/allfantasy for ad-free episodes, mailbags, auction…
- All Fantasy Everything
A Team of Horror Movie Villains to Rescue the President's Daughter (w/ Jonah Ray)
Something(s) got cut! Guest: Jonah Ray (@jonahray) Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at patreon.com/allfantasy for ad-free episodes, mailbags, auction…
- All Fantasy Everything
Movies You Only Watch Once (w/ Tom Thakkar)
Happy anniversary. Guest: Tom Thakkar (@tomthakkar) Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at patreon.com/allfantasy for ad-free episodes, mailbags, auction…
- All Fantasy Everything
Commercial Jingles (w/ Steven Castillo)
Count this as the unofficially official 500th episode of AFE. Guest: Steven Castillo (@steezus_castillo) Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at…
- All Fantasy Everything
Sitcom Moms (w/ Jamel Johnson)
Mother’s Day is not limited to May here at AFE — we celebrate it every week. Guest: Jamel Johnson (@broccolihouse) Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at…
- All Fantasy Everything
Board Games (w/ Chris Fairbanks)
Not to be confused with bored games, which are the games you play when you're bored. Guest: Chris Fairbanks (@chris_fairbanks) Support the show! Join the AFE…
- All Fantasy Everything
Movies That Start With “The” (w/ Open Mike Eagle)
If you are not already familiar with the song ‘Too Close’ by Next, it is imperative that you make yourself so for maximum enjoyment of this episode. Guest…
- All Fantasy Everything
Shower Thoughts (w/ Blair Socci)
Rejoice, All Family, for the Big Dog is back. Guest: Blair Socci (@blairsocci) Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at patreon.com/allfantasy for ad-free…
- All Fantasy Everything
Recess
Who ate all the pussy? Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at patreon.com/allfantasy for ad-free episodes, mailbags, auction drafts, and other exclusive…
- All Fantasy Everything
Italians (w/ Albertina Rizzo)
[hand gestures intensify] Guest: Albertina Rizzo (@albzrizz) Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at patreon.com/allfantasy for ad-free episodes, mailbags…
- All Fantasy Everything
Things That Fly (w/ Zach Harper)
This is a bad episode, but "bad" in the way we used it in the 90s. Guest: Zach Harper (@talkhoops) Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at…
- All Fantasy Everything
Textiles (w/ Jamel Johnson, Zach Harper)
What exactly are textiles? No one knows what it means, but it's provocative. Guests: Jamel Johnson (@broccolihouse) Zach Harper (@talkhoops) Support the show!…
- All Fantasy Everything
Harrison Ford Movies (w/ Zach Harper)
Never tell me the pods! Guest: Zach Harper (@talkhoops) Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at patreon.com/allfantasy for ad-free episodes, mailbags…
- All Fantasy Everything
Ocean Movies (w/ Daniel Van Kirk)
We're gonna need a bigger podcast studio! Guest: Daniel Van Kirk (@danielvankirk) Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at patreon.com/allfantasy for ad-free…
- All Fantasy Everything
Ways to End a Long Conversation (w/ Serra Naiman)
Have you ever been in a long conversation that you wanted to end? Of course not, you listen to this podcast! Guest: Serra Naiman (@serra.naiman) Support the…
- All Fantasy Everything
Places to People-watch
Just the boys hanging out, watching people (but not in a creepy way). Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at patreon.com/allfantasy for ad-free episodes…
- All Fantasy Everything
Pop Princesses (w/ Sophie Buddle)
Hope you like it! Guest: Sophie Buddle (@sophbuds) Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at patreon.com/allfantasy for ad-free episodes, mailbags, auction…
- All Fantasy Everything
Food Scenes in Movies (w/ Noah Galuten)
"Mmm, this is a tasty podcast!" Guest: Noah Galuten (@galuten) » Get Noah's new book 'Grill Time' wherever books are sold! Support the show! Join the AFE…
- All Fantasy Everything
Little Guys (w/ Jamie Loftus)
Flawless? More like flawmore. Guest: Jamie Loftus (@jamiechristsuperstar) Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at patreon.com/allfantasy for ad-free…
- All Fantasy Everything
Movies to Remake, Muppets-style
[insert Kermit meme here] Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at patreon.com/allfantasy for ad-free episodes, mailbags, auction drafts, and other exclusive…
- All Fantasy Everything
Sexy Cartoon Characters (w/ Langston Kerman)
This episode really highlights how vast and diverse the sexuality spectrum truly is. Guest: Langston Kerman (@langstonkerman) Support the show! Join the AFE…
- All Fantasy Everything
Magical Powers (w/ Dana Schwartz)
Which power would you use to dominate the WNBA? Guest: Dana Schwartz (@danaschwartzzz) » Dana's new novel, 'The Arcane Arts' by S.D. Coverly, is out now! Get…
- All Fantasy Everything
Discontinued Snacks (w/ Zak Toscani)
You know what's never been discontinued? AFE, on the shelves every Thursday since 2016. Guest: Zak Toscani (@zaktoscani) Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon…
- All Fantasy Everything
Washed Hobbies (w/ Mina Kimes)
Remember hittin' it? Yeah, us neither, we're washed now. Guest: Mina Kimes (@mina_kimes) Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at patreon.com/allfantasy for…
- All Fantasy Everything
Balls (w/ Clare O'Kane)
Balls — you know, of "don't lie" fame. Guest: Clare O'Kane (@clareisokane) Shop for exclusive AFE merch, old and new! https://trillblazin.net Support the show!…
- All Fantasy Everything
Old People Sayings (w/ Will Miles)
All of our picks are hypothetical, of course, because we are all cool young Gen Z kids. Guest: Will Miles (@mrwillmiles) Shop for exclusive AFE merch, old and…
- All Fantasy Everything
Giant Stuff (w/ Alex Falcone)
You know what else is giant? Our love for you, the All Family. Guest: Alex Falcone (@alexfalcone) Shop for exclusive AFE merch, old and new!…
- All Fantasy Everything
Things to Say Before Putting Sunglasses On (w/ Laura Peek)
Part one of a whole series of sunglasses-themed episodes (unless we abandon it like we've done every time before). P.S. I can't stress to you enough how much…
- All Fantasy Everything
'Jackass' Stunts (w/ Spencer Bland)
No podcasters were harmed in the making of this episode. Guest: Spencer Bland (@spencerspicy) Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at patreon.com/allfantasy…
- All Fantasy Everything
Famous Dogs
Woof woof. Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at patreon.com/allfantasy for ad-free episodes, mailbags, auction drafts, and other exclusive content. Watch…
- All Fantasy Everything
Mythical Creatures (w/ Troy Walker)
Or if you're Sean, creatures that could exist within the vast expanse of the universe. Guest: Troy Walker (@troywalkeresq) Support the show! Join the AFE…
- All Fantasy Everything
Items from 'Seinfeld' (w/ Jay Larson)
['90s bassline intensifies] Guest: Jay Larson (@jaylarsoncomedy) Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at patreon.com/allfantasy for ad-free episodes…
- All Fantasy Everything
Things That Go Bad (w/ Katherine Blanford, Shane Torres)
There's A LOT of hand-holding in this one. If you're just listening, I'm sure you can feel it through the audio. Guests: Katherine Blanford…
- All Fantasy Everything
Places You Feel Dumb At (w/ Rob Haze)
How old do you think Rob is? Comment below. Guest: Rob Haze (@robhaze) Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at patreon.com/allfantasy for ad-free episodes…
- All Fantasy Everything
Mom Jams (w/ Jason Concepcion)
Just a bunch of sons drafting the music our moms jammed to. Guest: Jason Concepcion (@x_netw3rk_x) Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at…
- All Fantasy Everything
Things You Call Someone When You Forgot Their Name (w/ Jamel Johnson)
We're wearing short sets in New Orleans, and so should you. Guest: Jamel Johnson (@broccolihouse) Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at…
- All Fantasy Everything
The Winter Olympics (w/ Shaker Samman)
5.1 inches. Guest: Shaker Samman (@shakersamman) Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at patreon.com/allfantasy for ad-free episodes, mailbags, auction…
- All Fantasy Everything
'90s Cultural Icons (w/ Blair Socci)
Oh, the 90s, when the Big Dog was just a Small Pup. Guest: Blair Socci (@blairsocci) Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at patreon.com/allfantasy for…
- All Fantasy Everything
Things You Do Alone (w/ Laura Peek)
We get nasty on this one, but what else do you expect from a Peekisode? Guest: Laura Peek (@laurapeeklive) Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at…
- All Fantasy Everything
2025 Pop Culture (w/ Alison Herman)
It's our proudest tradition, and 2025 is no exception. Guest: Alison Herman (@aherman2006) Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at patreon.com/allfantasy for…
- All Fantasy Everything
Predictions for 2026
Happy New Year! We predict only good things for the All Family in 2026. Everyone else? Well, let's see about them. Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at…
- All Fantasy Everything
Things in the Sky (w/ Laura Sams, Shane Torres)
Or if you're Shane, things in the air. Guests: Laura Sams (@lauramsams) Shane Torres (@shanetorres) Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at…
- All Fantasy Everything
Holiday Traditions (w/ Shane Torres)
Feliz Navidad to those of you who celebrate. Feliz jueves to those of you who don't. Guest: Shane Torres (@shanetorres) Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon…
- All Fantasy Everything
Luxury Home Amenities (w/ Daniel Van Kirk)
Want to help us obtain these draft picks? Sign up for our Patreon! Guest: Daniel Van Kirk (@danielvankirk) Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at…
- All Fantasy Everything
Letters of the Alphabet (w/ Tyler Parker)
This episode gets racial very quickly and then just stays that way. Guest: Tyler Parker (@tparker30) Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at…
- All Fantasy Everything
Embarrassing Things (That Shouldn't Be) (w/ Laura Peek)
This might be the funniest episode we've ever recorded. It's peak Peek. Guest: Laura Peek (@laurapeeklive) Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at…
- All Fantasy Everything
Male Divas (w/ Guy Branum)
Are male divas just called divos? Anyhow, we're here to draft them. Guest: Guy Branum (@guybranum) Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at…
- All Fantasy Everything
Australian Wildlife (w/ Jay Jurden)
We sincerely apologize to our Aussie listeners for the accents we attempt in this episode. We do NOT, however, apologize for all of the penis talk in this…
- All Fantasy Everything
TV Shows to Fall Asleep to (w/ Chris Estrada)
Have you ever fallen asleep to the sweet, sweet sound of AFE? You'd have some weird dreams. Guest: Chris Estrada (@chrisestradacomic) Support the show! Join…
- All Fantasy Everything
Things That Come Out of the Ground (w/ Allen Strickland Williams)
Potato is more important than water. Guest: Allen Strickland Williams (@allenstricklandwilliams) Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at…
- All Fantasy Everything
Old-Fashioned Ways To Die (w/ Amy Silverberg)
This is what can only be described as an astonishingly educational episode. Guest: Amy Silverberg (@amysilverberg) Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at…
- All Fantasy Everything
Mini Things (w/ Rory Scovel) + Movies Directed By Actors (w/ Doug Benson)
An unprecedented two-part episode! This makes up for every time we promised a part 2 and didn't follow through. Guests: Rory Scovel (@roryscovel) Doug Benson…
- All Fantasy Everything
Trucks (w/ River Butcher)
Hell yeah, (gender-neutral) brother. Guest: River Butcher (@rivbutcher) Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at patreon.com/allfantasy for ad-free episodes…
- All Fantasy Everything
Drugs (w/ Will Miles)
Not listening to AFE? Buddy, that ain't tough. Guest: Will Miles (@mrwillmiles) Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at patreon.com/allfantasy for ad-free…
- All Fantasy Everything
Steves (w/ Jon Gabrus)
Only Steves — no Stevens, Stephens, Stefans, or Stevies allowed. Guest: Jon Gabrus (@gabrus) Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at patreon.com/allfantasy…
- All Fantasy Everything
Conspiracy Theories We Kind of Believe (w/ Dana Schwartz)
A lot more Michael Jordan talk in this episode than you might think. Guest: Dana Schwartz (@danaschwartzzz) Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at…
- All Fantasy Everything
Nicknames for Body Parts (w/ Beth Stelling)
Welcome back to AFE, your premier poetry podcast. Guest: Beth Stelling (@bethstelling) Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at patreon.com/allfantasy for…
- All Fantasy Everything
Sequels
The thing that comes after the thing. Support the show! Join the AFE Patreon at patreon.com/allfantasy for ad-free episodes, mailbags, auction drafts, and…