Shows / Conspiring to Argue

Conspiring to Argue
Home to Conspiring to Argue Podcast! Best friends debate and laugh about aliens, murder, government cover-ups and more. Listen and Subscribe
The show, from its episodes
No episode notes yet. Recurring topics, people and starter picks will appear when notes are available.
Typical episode length
1h 24m · median of 102 episodes with a known length
Solo / guest format
Unknown — existing notes name people mentioned, but do not identify hosts or guests.
Recurring topics
No recurring topics established yet.
Recurring people
No recurring people established yet.
Start here
No starter picks yet — no published episodes with audio and a recorded notes hook.
Episodes
Conspiring to ArgueEp. 80 - Clinton Family Conspiracies
Ted and JJ discuss numerous conspiracy theories that have been circulated about the Clinton family throughout the years. Some are completely ridiculous and…
Conspiring to ArgueEp. 79 - The Phoenix Lights
Time for some ALIENS. Ted and JJ discuss what is considered to be one of the most compelling cases of possible extraterrestrial contact in history. Thousands…
Conspiring to ArguePokeMini Episode: Starter Pokemon Tournament
The boys run through an absurd tournament bracket to crown the best starter Pokemon of all.
Conspiring to ArgueEp. 77 - Oakville Blobs
The boys discuss the strange case of the Oakville Blobs, in which strange, gelatinous material seemingly rained from the sky in the Pacific Northwest.
Conspiring to ArgueEp. 76 - The Death of Vincent Van Gogh
The boys discuss the life and (possibly) mysterious death of Vincent Van Gogh.

Conspiring to ArgueEp. 74 - The Disappearance of Maura Murray (Pt. 2)
Ted and JJ discuss the various theories of what may have happened to Maura Murray.
Conspiring to ArgueEp. 73 - The Disappearance of Maura Murray (Pt. 1)
Ted and JJ begin discussing the tragic 2004 disappearance of 21 year old Maura Murray.

Conspiring to ArgueMini Episode - Mitch McConnell
The boys discuss the conspiracy surrounding Mitch McConnell’s health condition.

Conspiring to ArgueEp. 70 - The MLK Jr. Conspiracy (Pt. 2)
Ted and JJ conclude discussing whether or not the US government tried to murder Dr. King
Conspiring to ArgueEp. 69 - The MLK Jr. Conspiracy (Pt. 1)
Ted and JJ discuss the possibility that the United States government may have been responsible for the assassination of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.
Conspiring to ArgueEp. 68 - Cryptids & Cocktails (Pt. 1)
In what may possibly become a series, Ted and JJ try and blindly convince one another of the existence of a cryptid. (While becoming increasingly intoxicated.)
Conspiring to ArgueEp. 67 - The Murder of Mary Pinchot Meyer
The boys discuss the tragic 1964 murder of Mary Pinchot Meyer, a Washington D.C. artist.
Conspiring to ArgueEp. 66 - The Tylenol Murders
Ted and JJ discuss the bizarre tragedy of the 1982 Chicago Tylenol Murders.
Conspiring to ArgueEp. 65 - The Rendelsham Forest Incident
The boys discuss the Rendelsham Forest Incident, considered by many to be the most defensible UFO incident of all time.
Conspiring to ArgueEp. 64 - Madeleine McCann
Quite a long time ago, the boys tried to tackle the case of the tragic death of Madeleine McCann. That episode was lost to time, so, here we are. Rerun.
Conspiring to ArgueEp. 63 - Why Holocaust Denialism is Harmful
In what may be the heaviest subject matter so far on the show, Ted and JJ discuss the logical fallacies used by Holocaust deniers.
Conspiring to ArgueEp. 62 - The Titanic Conspiracy: F*ck Ice
This week, the boys discuss whether or not the tragic sinking of the Titanic could have been premeditated.


Conspiring to ArgueEp. 59 - Ellen Greenberg (pt. 3)
The boys cover the 2025 independent investigation of Ellen Greenberg’s death.
Conspiring to ArgueEp. 58 - Ellen Greenberg (pt. 2)
The boys continue covering the death of Ellen Greenberg.
Conspiring to ArgueEp. 57 - Ellen Greenberg (pt. 1)
The boys cover the mysterious, and (somewhat) controversial tragedy of the 2011 death of Philadelphia teacher, Ellen Greenberg.
Conspiring to ArgueEp. 56 - Stonehenge
The boys discuss the possible mysteries of Stonehenge. Also, Woodhenge (no, really, that exists.)
Conspiring to ArgueEp. 55 - Ed Gein (Pretty Much a Monster?)
Ted and JJ tackle the crimes of Ed Gein… HAPPY HALLOWEEN!


Conspiring to ArgueOttis Toole & Henry Lee Lucas pt. 2 (feat. Courtney from Book of the Dead)
We’re joined by a special guest this time to discuss how absolutely terrible Toole and Lucas were.
Conspiring to ArgueThe Death of Adam Walsh (Ottis Toole Pt. 1)
Ted and JJ discuss the tragic death of Adam Walsh, while regretting their drink choices…
Conspiring to ArgueArtificial Intelligence - The Most Irritating Potential Apocalypse…
The boys from IA discuss AI.
Conspiring to ArgueDyatlov Pass Incident
Ooooooh this was a lot of fun honestly. Ted and JJ look into the Dyatlov Pass Incident, a tragedy that occurred in the Ural Mountains in the 1950s.

Conspiring to ArgueThe Mysterious Death of Edgar Allen Poe - Poe Drinks, Poe Problems
This week we discuss the (kind of) mysterious death of American author, Edgar Allen Poe. JJ like really doesn't like Poe?
Conspiring to ArgueZombie Apocalypse (feat. Ash from F**k That)
We're joined by a special guest to discuss all things zombies.
Conspiring to ArgueIlluminati - Let's Get Illuminaughty...
We've never had to make more sober edits than we did in this episode. Yikes...






Conspiring to ArgueLIVE at River Ridge Brewing - Cryptid Madness Tournament
We had a great time at our first live show! Big thanks to River Ridge Brewing and The Man Stream Podcasts!
Conspiring to ArgueRay Lewis - Occam's Champagne Bottle
Ted and JJ discuss former NFL all-star Ray Lewis, and just how involved he might or might not have been in a double-murder.
Conspiring to ArgueThe Chappaquiddick Incident - He’s the Bad Ted
On this episode, we discuss the tragic death of Mary Jo Kopechne.
Conspiring to ArgueKurt Cobain (Pt. 2) - Ted Also Has A Bad Taste In Music...
Warning: This episode deals with suicidal ideation and drug abuse. Like, a lot! Happy New Year and thank you all for listening!
Conspiring to ArgueKurt Cobain (Pt. 1) - JJ Has A Really Bad Taste In Music
In this episode, Ted and JJ discuss the background of the (possibly) mysterious death of Nirvana frontman, Kurt Cobain.
Conspiring to ArgueMen in Black - Wakka Wakka
Ted and JJ discuss MIBs and Ted literally can’t stop making Pac-Man sounds. Some say he’s still wakkaing to this day…


Conspiring to ArgueFrom Elvis to Coca-Cola (Random Theories Pt. 2)
This episode is a slightly less fun one. Ted presents JJ with some conspiracy theories, and makes JJ debate them with no preparation.
Conspiring to ArgueMK Ultra - McUltra
Conspiracy heavy-hitter this week. Ted and JJ discuss the covert, mid-20th century CIA project known as MK Ultra.
Conspiring to ArgueThe Lead Masks Case - Currency Conversion is Difficult
This was just sort of fun. It’s also very dumb! Enjoy!
Conspiring to ArgueMenendez Brothers - Part 2: Menendeuce
Ted and JJ try and make sense of the Menendez Brothers’ trial. And scream at each other.
Conspiring to ArgueMenendez Brothers - Part 1
Ted and JJ discuss the background of the murders of Jose and Kitty Menendez by their sons, Lyle and Erik.
Conspiring to ArgueAokigahara - The Sea of Mispronunciations
Often referred to as the "suicide forest" Aokigahara just might be supernatural - or probably not.
Conspiring to ArgueThe Mattress Conspiracy - It's a Soft Theory
The boys attempt to answer the question: "why are there SO MANY mattress stores?!"

