Latest / Friendship IRL: Real Talk About Friendship, Community, and What It Actually Takes / All About Fringe Friends
Transcript
- 0:02Podcast Intro/Outro: All right, gang. Here's to nights that turn into mornings and friends that turn into family. Cheers. Hello, hello, and welcome to the Friendship IRL podcast. I'm your host, Alex Alexander. Each week we talk about what is working(and what is not) in our friendships, community and connections. Have you ever wished you could sit down and have a conversation about what is really going on in your friendships? Well, you found your people. Join us as we dive into real life stories and explore new ways to approach these connections. Together, we're reimagining the rules of friendship
- 0:57Alex Alexander: We all know. I talk to a lot of people about their friendships. And I have this thing where I really firmly believe that once I kind of tell people my take on friendship, this idea that it's different for everyone, and there's no right way to do it, and that a lot of people are struggling with friendship in one way or another, on some level, I swear the floodgates open, like people are desperate to talk about their friendships. And I will never forget this thing that a friend of mine actually said to me. She said, You know, I just always feel like I'm the extra invite, and I think that's one way to describe exactly what we're talking about today, which is this idea of being a fringe friend or a filler friend.
- 1:48Alex Alexander: That's another term I've heard used for this, you know, what it might be that extra invite, but it might just be that you feel like you're never anybody's closest friend, or you feel like you're just, you know, like always on the periphery. You always get invited to the big events, but never the intimate gatherings. You know, if the dinner is for four people, somehow you're always the fifth person. And I get why that can feel incredibly frustrating. I do, you know, I would say that I am the fringe friend in some friendship groups that I'm in.
- 2:26Alex Alexander: In others I'm not, but I definitely understand this experience. There have been moments where I have sat there at the table and heard everyone else talking about how they maybe got together the weekend before, and you have this moment of like, Oh, but I wasn't there.
- 2:43Alex Alexander: The three of you were there, but I wasn't there. So I just want to say, on some level, I do get this experience, and I want to say that because today's take on being the fringe friend or the filler friend is probably not what you're going to hear other places. I really sat down for today's episode, and I thought about my Wheel of Connection Framework. If you have never seen that before, it is all over my website. I deep dive into it in Episode 100 so go back and listen to that episode, but I really try to think about like, what is a fringe friend and how does it work in that framework that I created, I try to think about the behaviors that you might be doing that are keeping you there. I tried to think about life changes that might be happening where it caused a shift in your friendship, and maybe you even went from feeling like you were really close friend, and now you're on the outskirts, and you don't know how you got there. And then finally, after all of that, I want to talk about if this just isn't the right fit of a group or a friendship for you, but notice I've got three whole sections I'm going to cover before we get to that fourth and final one, because I do want in this episode to show you that there actually are some benefits to being a French friend, like sometimes I'm really okay being kind of that second tier friendship, and I think that it's the understanding of why I'm there that makes me feel okay about it. And if you don't have that understanding, I can see why you'd be really frustrated, but we're going to try and find some that understanding today. So with that, let's kind of dive into the first reason that you might be on. Fringe and that is because you feel like the fringe friend, because either you have a lot of newer friendships, or perhaps you have a lot of established friendships, but they maybe don't live nearby, or there was some big life shift.
- 4:58Alex Alexander: So these are newer friendships, like they were friendships that you had a lot of hope for being those kind of present friendships in your life. And if you don't know what a present friendship is, again, go listen to episode 100 but a present friendship is the most basic way I can describe it, is kind of the people you're doing multiple areas of life with. And so I think that's important for us all to remember, because you might be sitting in a room or in a group with a bunch of people who are kind of doing multiple areas of life together, and you realize that you're not a part of that, and that can be really hard. Okay, let me back up. So these newer friendships, right?
- 5:46Alex Alexander: One reason that you might be kind of sitting in this fringe friend situation is because you are newer to a group dynamic.
- 5:54Alex Alexander: Whether you moved you got invited by a co worker to this friend gathering a neighbor or something like that, maybe you moved to a new neighborhood.
- 6:02Alex Alexander: There are a million reasons that you could be new to a group dynamic, and if that's the case, you're definitely gonna feel like a fringe friend, and you might feel that way for a little while, if I'm being honest with you, because you have to remember that every group within the group, let's say there's four people that is like Person A has a relationship with Person B, Person A has relationship with Person C, Person A has relationship with person D, and that continues, like, B to C, B to D, C to D, right? We have so many individual relationships in that dynamic, and they're all going to be various levels of closeness. Like from the outside, you might think that everyone is equally as close, but I don't honestly, normally think that's the case. In most friendships, if you really get in there, into the nitty gritty, there are varying levels, and there's nothing wrong with that.
- 7:07Alex Alexander: Some people just connect more, maybe about a certain experience in life, or they've been friends longer, so they have different history. An example of this would be, if you had a friend that you've maybe there's a group of four people. Two of those friends have been friends since high school, and so when that person's family comes into town, they invite that friend they've had since high school, because they know their parents, they know their siblings, right?
- 7:37Alex Alexander: They have that history. That's a different level of connection, even if, from the outside, that group looks like it is, like the tightest knit equal friendship.
- 7:50Alex Alexander: That may not be the case, but I can understand how when you sit in this room with these four people, you really feel like you're the fringe friend. Now I know that it's hard not to compare. I get it, but my suggestion in this situation would be to actually just really try and understand how you connect with each person in the group. What shared interests do you have, what shared experiences do you have?
- 9:22Alex Alexander: Are you in the same seasons of life? Did you grow up in the same area of the country or the same town, or play the same sports, find those common grounds with each person, and spend your energy trying to develop a friendship with one or two of those people. Because when you join a group with four people that is developing four new friendships, it's a lot of work. I'm not saying you can't do it equally, but just showing up over and over and over again to the group gathering is not going to get you the level of closeness you want. You're going to have to branch out and try and develop individual friendships with each of these people. Now, another way that you might find that you are a newer friend is something that I call a defined friend. Again. Go listen to episode 100 but a defined friend is kind of one of these simpler friendships in our life. They might be someone that we actually have a lot of emotional closeness with, but it's normally just around one area of life, right? A defined friend is someone like a work friend, a gym friend, a neighbor friend, I mean, a family friend could be an example of this.
- 10:38Alex Alexander: It's somebody and you generally see them in the same place, right? So at work now, you might share a lot with them. You might tell them about your weekend and the problems going on with your remodel, whatever it is that you're having issues with in life, like they may know more about you than work, but they don't experience it with you, right? You come into the office and you tell them about your weekend, about that family vacation. One, but you're not inviting them on family vacation. So this could be a way that you're feeling like a fringe friend. It actually could just be that you're a defined friend at the moment. And if you go listen to episode 100 I have all sorts of tips on how to be closer, like how to deepen that friendship. If it's something you want but you don't have to you can also just appreciate that friendship for what it is, and really find the value in it.
- 11:30Alex Alexander: Now, something that happens, I think, to a number of people, is you might kind of be a serial collector of defined friends.
- 11:38Alex Alexander: You might have all these friends in different areas of your life.
- 11:43Alex Alexander: You know you might have your school friends and your work friends and your neighbors and your, hmm, what other your bird watching friends? I don't know your running group friends, but you don't really mix them or invite them out of those areas of life. And if that's what you're doing, you're gonna feel like the fringe friend. I'm just saying especially, like, let's say there's a running group, and you've kind of gotten close with a few people in that group, but they aren't really inviting you to things outside of that group.
- 12:19Alex Alexander: It could be because you're just kind of stuck in this defined friendship, and they don't quite feel comfortable inviting you to things that aren't related to the running group yet, and that's not to say they won't ever, but you might have to take a leap, have a little courage and initiate starting to do things outside the running group where you're all comfortable spending time together. Now, another thing that might happen when you are kind of stuck in this newer friendship category.
- 12:52Alex Alexander: Is this idea of kind of an event hierarchy, right? You are invited to people's bigger events, but you're not necessarily invited to their intimate gatherings. I know you want to be invited to the intimate gatherings, but what I would tell you here is you might have to initiate. You might have to be the one that plans an intimate gathering and invites people, because at the end of the day, we all have kind of those closest people that we think about inviting over. Or it might be that this friend doesn't even know, because you're a newer friend that you, let's say, have an interest in movies, and you would be willing to go to their movie group.
- 13:30Alex Alexander: You've never really talked about it. They don't know, so they don't think about you. And I know that's hard to hear, but part of that is just talking more and sharing that you'd love to be invited and that you have an interest in that. So when it comes to throwing a bigger gathering, they might think of you because they're really thinking broadly about all the people they might want to invite to their Fourth of July party, for example. But if they're just hosting a couple of couples together or a game night, they may not know if you even really like games. If you're one of those newer friends, that's just an opportunity for you to voice the areas and the ways you'd like to hang out. And again, I would really, really suggest, if that's where you find yourself stuck, plan something and make an invite. Everybody loves to be invited, so take the initiative and start hosting the types of gatherings that you wish you were invited to. Now, if you find yourself stuck on the periphery in a fringe friendship in some other way, that's like a newer friendship, reach out. I want to hear about your scenario if you don't feel like it was covered here. I tried to think of as many scenarios as I could, but there's definitely no way I can cover every single one in this episode. So I want to hear about it if you feel like there is another way that you're stuck on the periphery. Now the next thing I want to talk about is being a fringe friend, because you're keeping yourself there.
- 14:56Alex Alexander: So check in with yourself on this. If you have made some friends in your running group, for example, or at work, maybe they are inviting you. Now, those invites may not be things you normally would want to go to, like, maybe you're not a movie person, for example, and so they've invited you to do that, and you've said no, and you feel like you're on the fringe. So this is a great place to check in on, like, where are you potentially holding yourself back to step into that more present friendship. You might have to try some things you don't normally do. You might have to initiate the types of connection that you want. That's what I was just talking about with the making the invites piece. You might have to go to a group gathering that you were invited to and actually be really intentional about focusing on, let's say one person that you feel like you connect with. And I say that one because I think a lot of times what happens is people get invited to, like a big group thing, and they almost spread themselves too thin, if you know what I mean, like, maybe you're at this party. For two, three hours, and you're trying to get around and, like, talk to every single person that's there, but you're not really getting any depth, right. You're just hopping around talking about the weather or your job or what are your plans this weekend, just a lot of small talk, and you're not actually getting into any Convos where you're learning about that person, what their interests are, what common activities you might both want to go to. You know, if you ask somebody like, what's been the most exciting thing that's happened to you recently, they might tell you about how they want a chess competition, and then suddenly you're saying, hey, you know, I've always wanted to learn chess, and now you found a way to connect with that person. So if you are again at this bigger party, and you're kind of just hopping around, consider being really intentional about trying to have longer conversations with one or two people, and that might mean that all you do is say hello and goodbye to some of the other people that are there, and that's okay. You don't need to spread yourself thin at every single gathering. Now, another way you might be holding yourself back. Kind of mentioned this earlier, but this idea of like mismatched interests, if you have connected with a group of people or a singular friend, and there's something about them that really drew you in initially, and then you get in there and you find out that these people, I don't know, really love to go clubbing. They love to go clubbing, and that's not your thing, but that's how they all hang out. You know, maybe this is a gym friend, and they invited you to a gathering at their house, and they're inviting you to something else, but it's going to go dancing at 1am because I'm just saying that, because I'd really have to be putting myself out there to go dancing at 1am at this point.
- 18:05Alex Alexander: So there might be some sort of a mismatch there where, like, you align on a certain interest, right? Like, gym friends, I think is what I said, but you don't align on other interests.
- 18:18Alex Alexander: And I think that can be hard.
- 18:18Alex Alexander: You have a choice here, like, do you lean in and try something new? Do you go dancing? I don't know. Maybe you have fun. Maybe it's not what you do all the time, but maybe a couple times a year you do go with them, or do you continue to just say no, and that's great, and that's fine.
- 18:38Alex Alexander: Have those boundaries, make your choices, but you have to recognize that that's what's happening here, and it's not them trying to exclude you. It's just that there's a mismatch in the interest that you have.
- 18:51Alex Alexander: The final thing I wrote down here for ways that you might be holding yourself back is comparison. This is kind of a two parter, because I think there are two comparison traps you can get yourself caught in.
- 19:03Alex Alexander: The first one is being really focused on kind of your overall friendship lack right scarcity mindset overall. If you're going to a party and all these people seem to know each other and feel really connected, and that's something you'd like in your life, but you feel like you're on the fringe. You might spend that entire gathering feeling this sense of scarcity about the fact that you don't have this friend community that you wish you had. And if that's the case, you may be not very present in the conversations you're having with people. You might be isolating yourself in the corner by the drink table all night and not actually really talking to anyone. The other way you might be comparing yourself is just sitting there realizing that everyone else feels closer than you do. Maybe you've been hanging out with this group for a while, six months a year, I don't know. And other people just feel really close, and you don't feel like you have developed that with anyone, and so you might be holding back because you just don't right.
- 20:11Alex Alexander: You're comparing your new relationships in this group to other people's potentially very established relationships. And if this is the case, my suggestion to you would be to actually start asking people about their history. You know, how did you two meet? How long have you been friends? Because what you might come to find is you're comparing yourself and feeling like you're on the fringe. But these other people have known each other for a decade. Two decades. There's a lot of history there. Now, there are a lot of messages and narratives out there about how, like, a friendship that's been around longer is better. And I always want to challenge that, because what you have to remember is that you as the new friend. You might be bringing something like fresh and fun and different. You might be the person that that. Newer friend of yours has always wanted maybe you share an interest that none of their other established friends do. And although they love the history and they have other things they connect with people about in that group, you might be the one that they connect with about something super specific. Gosh, I'm trying to think of an example of this.
- 21:28Alex Alexander: You know, this episode is going to release right before the Fourth of July, and we're hosting a big Fourth of July gathering, because you can see the fireworks from our place.
- 21:39Alex Alexander: And it's going to be a lot of my very established, long standing friends that are coming, you know, people I've known for, gosh, a decade plus, like a lot of my chosen family is gonna be in this room on the Fourth of July. There are a couple things we did, though, we told anybody who's coming that they could bring friends, like, if there's somebody you wanted to spend Fourth of July with, they can come on over, right? So that could create a lot of fringe friends, but I specifically invited two separate couples that are friends of mine, but aren't necessarily as connected into this group. One couple has been to various gatherings, like they're good friends with me and Michael, but they are not tied in. Everybody knows them, has heard of them, has seen them at different functions. They don't know them very well. The other friends are friends that I've made in the past couple years.
- 22:36Alex Alexander: It's a couple but her and I have become friends in the past couple years, and they have not met a single other person coming to this party. So they're for sure, gonna feel like fringe friends here. And it would be very easy for her, maybe, to walk in the room and compare all the history that is in this room, all the connection, all the depth she's heard me talk about these people that she's never met them, and she could be so focused on what she's not now. I hope she doesn't do that, because what she has brought to my life is this playfulness. We go on really silly adventures together. I could do really silly things with her, and I love that, and that's something I was really looking for in friendships in recent years. So instead of comparing herself to these more established friendships, I hope she can see what she does bring what I do love about our friendship, and that's on me a little bit to tell her. That's also on us to just communicate about that. But I'm just telling you that story because, gosh, can that feel overwhelming, to feel like the fringe friend, to feel like the extra invite, but it's not to say there's not beauty in that, because there is. Sometimes it's you know, you're the friend that somebody desperately needed, even if you're the newer friend that isn't necessarily super tied into the group, hopefully, just something for you to think about. Okay, so the next thing I want to talk about is when some like, life changes have happened, and maybe this was somebody you feel really close to, like you might have been present friends with this person for a really long time, historic friends again, go listen to episode 100 to understand those terms better. And now something has changed. So this could be a move, it could be a career change. It could be a big lifestyle change, like becoming a new parent. It could be a change to your income level that's impacted maybe the activities you can take part in, like things you used to do with friends, going out to dinners or traveling you don't have the budget for that anymore. There could be all sorts of life transitions and circumstances that happen that suddenly make it so that somewhere that you felt like you really belonged you now feel on the fringe, and that can feel really hard because it can feel really confusing. It can feel like your friends, I don't know, left you behind, or are doing things without you. But I guess my suggestion to you here is I'm not trying to downplay like that is incredibly hard, but I do think trying to understand what changed is the most important thing you can do here, because if you can pinpoint what changed, you can start to understand what you might be able to do to bring yourselves closer together. So if maybe you became a parent and that really changed your friendships, then this would be a great moment for you to really lean in and try and initiate new ways to connect that are different than the ways you used to connect, ways that feel more aligned in this new stage. Life. Now, another circumstance that might happen is if there was a big life change, or maybe there wasn't for you, maybe it was actually for other people. At the end of the day, your friends might feel closer to each other than you do, right? Maybe at one point you had like a trio, and it felt really equal. And now something's changed, and it doesn't. Maybe two people started working at the same company. They would spend spending a lot of time together.
- 26:42Alex Alexander: Maybe two of your friends made a pact to travel to certain places this year, and so they're going on all these adventures together. Maybe they both decided to join a book club that you weren't interested in. It's just not your thing. That's okay, but it might make you feel like you're on the fringe. And again, my suggestion would be try and figure out what has changed, because then you can understand where you can put your energy and your effort if you so choose, to find new ways to build roots and connect with those friends. So as you can see, we have spent a lot of time. We've spent a lot of time talking about different dynamics and situations where you might be the fringe friend, but I would say you're not down and out like you're not being excluded. There's either been a change. You are kind of holding yourself back in these friendships, or maybe it's just a newer friendship. None of those make this like a bad friendship, even if you're sitting in that maybe tier two position, that can be okay, but what I want to talk about now is where everybody jumps, which is just like they're bad friends.
- 27:53Alex Alexander: They're excluding me. They're not the right friends for me, and that might be the case.
- 28:02Alex Alexander: Note, I gave you three things to explore, first, because I think that can save a lot of friendships, but they might not be right. You might be correct, like it might truly be exclusion. Maybe they don't invite you at all to things that you would have liked to go to, things that you actually would be interested in, and they know that maybe they are inviting you to things, but then when you get there, they're ignoring you.
- 28:29Alex Alexander: Maybe it's just not the right fit, because you are going to this party or this get together, and when you get there, you just feel like you don't really have anything to talk about with anybody. And therefore you feel like you know you might as well be standing against the wall and be a wallflower. What does it matter? Maybe you are somebody who is sending the invites you're trying to initiate, and people just keep rejecting those invites. Or another thing is you might be going to the gatherings. Maybe this group gets together for like picnics once or twice a month, let's say, and you keep going, you keep going, and you just go every time you feel like you aren't getting closer to anyone.
- 29:18Alex Alexander: Now, if that's the case, I would go back and listen to the section about holding back. But if you don't feel like you're holding back, like you're showing up and you're trying to engage with people and find common interests, but it just doesn't seem like it's clicking.
- 29:34Alex Alexander: If any of those things I've just mentioned are happening, it's time to go. That is okay. It is not you, it is not a failure.
- 29:42Alex Alexander: It's just that sometimes you don't connect with people. You know, it might be that some people do have a clicky behavior. Maybe they're in a life situation where they're just really not open to making friends. There are a million situations here, like, I can't cover every single one. I would love to hear your story, so please reach out if you have experienced this, so you can tell me what happened to you.
- 30:10Alex Alexander: But the moral of the moral the story here, if you find yourself in this situation, is it's okay to move on. It is okay to move on. It is okay to put your energy elsewhere, whether they are newer friends or maybe they are those more established friends where things have changed and you just can't seem to get it back to a place that feels good for you. There are plenty of other people and connections out there. You are not done making new friends until you're in the grave. It's okay to let it go and put your energy elsewhere. Okay? So to pull this episode together, I want to give you just a couple final reframes. I want to be just really direct with you about ways to think about being the fringe friend, maybe a new mindset. And if you try these out, I want to hear about it.
- 31:02Alex Alexander: Because what I want to remind you is, if you feel like you are the fringe friend, that's actually a superpower, and that's because you bring a newness and a fresh perspective to friendships that have maybe been established for a really long time, maybe friendships that feel kind of stale, or they're doing the same things, or, you know, somebody who's looking for, let's say, a playful energy. There can be a real benefit to mixing it up in a group of people. So don't hold yourself back. Show who you are and how you might fit into the group. The second one is that it's really okay to kind of be the tier two friend. It really is. Some people actually really prefer this. And if that's you, I love that. For you, some people like not being a part of the group, right? They have these really close friendships, and their close friends are in different groups that don't overlap, and they might invite you in and you're really close to this one friend, but not really everybody else. That's okay. You don't have to be a part of the group. You can be what did I see like the other day, like the friend in law. You can be the friend in law, just the same way as I love when my friends invite their siblings, and I'm not necessarily the closest to them, but I love seeing them, or they're high school friends, and we didn't go to high school together, and I love like, I love that, so you can be okay with being that person. Now, if you feel like you are the tier two friend everywhere, and that's not what you want, then my suggestion would be to continue what I talked about earlier in the episode, continue to focus instead of like befriending the group, really focus on your individual friendships within the group. Put your energy there and see what happens now.
- 33:03Alex Alexander: Another reframe is that you might just have a lot of defined friends. You might have a lot of work friends and gym friends and kids, parents, friends and soccer friends and running group friends. You might really be a collector of defined friends.
- 33:20Alex Alexander: And if you like that, there's nothing wrong with that. But if you feel frustrated because you feel like you're stuck kind of on this fringe where you can only connect with your friends in one way, and you want to go further, then what you got to do is put yourself out there. You got to take some risks, and you got to make some invites to try and break out of say, like the gym friend category, invite them over to your house for a barbecue, have them meet your other friends, ask them if they want to go away on a trip, if they want to get together and just walk in your neighborhood.
- 33:57Alex Alexander: You want to, like, walk the dogs together, find new ways outside of that one way you hang out.
- 34:05Alex Alexander: Now, another reframe for you is that I really do think, you know, there's this whole idea of like, quality versus quantity, and that's could be its own episode, but I really do think you can find quality in your fringe connections. The quality may not be that this person is some all encompassing friendship that understands every area of your life and things like that, but the quality might be that they just really, really get you in one area of life, like you want to write a book, and they also have written a book, or they're writing a book, or they want to write a book, and none of your other friends understand that, and that could be quality, even if you aren't Their closest friend. I think I could ramble on about the benefits of being a fringe friend all night long. I mean, obviously I've been pretty passionate in this entire episode. I guess what I'm trying to say is it's not all bad. It's not all bad. These can actually be really beautiful friendships in your life, but but your feelings are what matters. So if you want deeper friendships, if you want to be a part of the intimate gatherings, you can change this. You know that friend that I opened talking about how she said she's always the plus one, when she had that realization, she decided to really make a change, and I can tell you now her friendships are completely different. She has lost some friends. She has gained a lot of other ones. She has friends that are like very present in all the areas of her life, but she also has friends in every kind of little pocket of her interests, right? I live in one pocket. I'm not an all consuming friend for her, I'm not a present friend, and I'm okay with that. And if she invites me to something, I would be on the fringe, and I would have fun being there. But overall, her. Friendship landscape. If she looks at her Wheel of Connection, she's put energy and effort in over the past few years to really remake her Wheel of Connection so that she doesn't always feel like she is the French friend and when she is, she understands why, and she appreciates it. So it's all to say you aren't stuck. If you feel like you're always the fringe friend, you don't have to be the fringe friend anymore.
- 36:34Alex Alexander: You really can change this, and part of that is just understanding some of the categories and areas we've broken down in this episode. But I would also highly, highly, highly suggest, because I've said it at least eight times in this episode already. Go listen to to Episode 100 about the Wheel of Connection, so you can understand how you can impact your own with that. I'll see you next week.
- 37:04Podcast Intro/Outro: Thank you for listening to this episode of Friendship IRL. I am so honored to have these conversations with you. But don't let the chat die here. Send me a voice message. I created a special website just to chat with you. You can find it at alexalex.chat. You can also find me on Instagram. My handle, @itsalexalexander. Or go ahead and leave a review wherever you prefer to listen to podcasts. Now if you want to take this conversation a step further, send this episode to a friend. Tell them you found it interesting. And use what we just talked about as a conversation starter the next time you and your friend hang out. No need for a teary goodbye. I'll be back with a new episode next week.