Latest / The Dr. Psych Mom Show with clinical psychologist Dr. Samantha Rodman Whiten / The Difference Between Boundaries And Ultimatums
Transcript
- 0:05Hi everybody, and welcome to the dr.
- 0:07Psych mom show, today, I'm going to be talking about the
- 0:10difference between boundaries and ultimatums and before we do
- 0:16that because I mean I could just not give you the topic sentence
- 0:21and and trust that you will just listen to my 30 seconds and or
- 0:26you could fast-forward it I guess and then pick up with the
- 0:29boundaries and ultimatums afterwards, but the next one
- 0:32coming up is about female arousal.
- 0:34Hazel. So hopefully you did not fast
- 0:36forward over. That, that is the next
- 0:38subscriber only episode and you'll like it.
- 0:41It will elucidate some of your potential sources of confusion,
- 0:48still about responsive vs. Spontaneous, desire and desire,
- 0:51and women versus men and monogamous women versus
- 0:55non-monogamous etcetera. All right, so you will like
- 0:59that, there's not much more, I can say that will make you
- 1:03subscribe besides to literally tell It's about female arousal,
- 1:06which will probably make you subscribe.
- 1:08All right? So moving on, boundaries versus
- 1:10ultimatums ultimatums, get a very bad rap yet.
- 1:13Research has shown interesting research on marriage has shown
- 1:17that when couples get through difficult things ultimatums are
- 1:22not an insignificant portion of the time attributed to why the
- 1:26couple got through it specifically.
- 1:28When men were struggling with substance abuse in this article
- 1:32that God knows I'm probably never going to be able to And
- 1:34again, but I do remember it. Many men said that a woman
- 1:38saying that she was going to leave.
- 1:39Got them actually to go to AA or what have you.
- 1:42And I'm sure many people can understand that, you know, you
- 1:45have to hit rock, bottom and Rock, Bottom is pretty much your
- 1:47wife saying, I'm going to leave you.
- 1:49So then why don't the natives get such a bad rap because
- 1:52they're thought of as manipulative, and they really
- 1:55shouldn't be, you know, because they're not any different than
- 1:59boundaries boundaries are saying.
- 2:01I need this thing. I am unwilling to Move on this
- 2:05thing and ultimatums are saying, I need this thing.
- 2:09I am unwilling to move on this thing.
- 2:10You see my point, they're the same thing.
- 2:14I mean, like boundaries are like really on Trend and everything
- 2:18that against the world to me times.
- 2:19I watch a reality show called the ultimatum now if you want to
- 2:22see some insecurely attached couples, man, you gotta watch
- 2:25that show the entire premise of the show, people are dragging in
- 2:29their spouse who didn't want to marry them.
- 2:31I mean, holy shit, right? I mean, like could You get any
- 2:35more insecurely attached, possibly not.
- 2:37So and and a couple that with the history out of
- 2:41personalities, of people who want to be on reality TV and
- 2:43it's, you know, interesting to put it mildly.
- 2:46So the point here is that boundaries are thought of as
- 2:50healthy ultimatums are thought of as not yet.
- 2:52They're really truly the same thing.
- 2:55The only Regard in which they are not is when they're fake.
- 2:58So a fake ultimatum is manipulative.
- 3:00It's bad. It's a woman saying if you go
- 3:02and to that Bachelor, Already in Vegas, I'm going to leave you.
- 3:07I like both of y'all know she's not gonna leave you so it was
- 3:10just like a way of her saying I am mad.
- 3:12I am anxious, I am scared but she's saying it in a way that is
- 3:16manipulative. So the guys probably going to go
- 3:18to Vegas one day earlier and, you know, conflict will ensue
- 3:22and Ten Years Later, they'll find themselves in my office,
- 3:24with this, being a tremendous empathic rupture.
- 3:28But anyhow, what an ultimatum isn't saying I'm going to leave
- 3:33unless you do Or you don't do X, that's also a boundary so who
- 3:38has trouble with boundaries and calls them?
- 3:40Ultimatums people who don't want to kind of look in it
- 3:45themselves. So a people who are people
- 3:48Pleasers have trouble with both boundaries and ultimatums.
- 3:51They have trouble with ever saying that they're worth
- 3:53anything at all, so it would be Preposterous for them to say I
- 3:57will leave if x, they're not going to leave anyway because
- 4:00they have terrible self-esteem and they don't value themselves.
- 4:03And this Say it with me. It's situated in your family of
- 4:09origin, you should know that. If there's one thing you should
- 4:11leave this podcast, knowing it's been like, hundreds of episodes.
- 4:16You listen to, if there's one thing you should know, it is
- 4:19just like a dog is trained in its early life.
- 4:23If you had an abused Pitbull, right?
- 4:25You, you would be an advocate. You would say, it's not the
- 4:27breed. It's the dog.
- 4:29The dog was heard by people, right?
- 4:31Well, shit is the same thing you're up.
- 4:34A bringing trains you to be a certain way.
- 4:37And unfortunately, for many people it's more like the abused
- 4:40Pitbull then than anything else. And that's very sad.
- 4:43But to say that it shouldn't shape you as an adult is
- 4:45nonsensical, any organism is shaped by its early life
- 4:49experiences, at least any mammal is, you know, or probably all of
- 4:54them are. So anyway, my point is this, if
- 4:58it is a boundary, that sounds good but it is the same as an
- 5:02ultimatum. Which sounds bad people who are
- 5:04People places aren't going to want to do them and people who
- 5:07don't want to really be intimate are going to hate to both of
- 5:10them. So narcissists or people who
- 5:14have, who are extremely self-absorbed hate when other
- 5:17people said boundaries or ultimatums because they want to
- 5:20do what they want to do and usually their interactions with
- 5:24other people are some sort of test to prove that the other
- 5:26person loves them sufficiently. And if the person erect a
- 5:29boundary, then the person who is self-absorbed, has to conclude
- 5:33that the person loves. Is themselves and respects
- 5:37themselves. At least as much as they love
- 5:40the narcissistic person, which does not sit well.
- 5:42So then they try to burrow past boundaries like some sort of a
- 5:46vole, you know, underground or like whichever way they can and,
- 5:50and push past boundaries or ultimatums right?
- 5:54And and that should and does feel upsetting an uncomfortable
- 5:58to the person who's just trying to set a goddamn, boundary on
- 6:02the other end of the extreme, though, as I discussed.
- 6:04In my podcast, The Cult of boundaries or preferences is the
- 6:10people who have way too many boundaries because they are
- 6:12avoidant attachment people. So that's another type of person
- 6:16who is really has a weird or dysfunctional perspective about
- 6:23boundaries, right? So, so first are people, who are
- 6:26people Pleasers, they have a dysfunctional view on boundaries
- 6:29because they refused to set any and they think that if they said
- 6:32any nobody will love them anymore because Basically what
- 6:35they're writing on here. As a basic tenet of why they
- 6:38should be loved. Is that they never have a
- 6:39boundary. Woohoo me, I have no boundaries
- 6:42at all. Don't worry about it.
- 6:43I let you do anything. And if that is the sum total of
- 6:46what you believe, you have to offer in the world as a partner
- 6:49as a parent as anybody, then a you should read my pot.
- 6:53You should listen to my podcast on why how not to let your kids
- 6:57treat you like garbage and be you got to assume that in your
- 7:01early life and I'm sure you could remember this.
- 7:03If you try for a Split, Second, you were never allowed to have
- 7:07any sense of self that you were proud of you were never allowed
- 7:09privacy. You were never allowed
- 7:11boundaries. If you told your mother, not to
- 7:13knock, she had a history Onyx should fit or took your door off
- 7:16the hinges, you know, based on how insane your house was.
- 7:20And you know, if you seriously think that your main worthiness
- 7:28as a person partner friend, worker, whatever is that you
- 7:33will never tell. Tell anybody that they can't
- 7:36tell you to do anything, without the double negatives.
- 7:40You will do anything. You, you know, those people that
- 7:42are like well I know I could outwork anyone.
- 7:45Like okay but you know what that always means.
- 7:48It means I will put up with so much shit.
- 7:51There will be a shit pile sitting on top of my head and I
- 7:54will not complain. This is not necessarily
- 7:56potentially the good thing that you think it is.
- 7:59Yeah. There's the people who will
- 8:00genuinely quote outwork anybody but that's not too good either
- 8:04because You need a goddamn break.
- 8:06You're a person. You're not a pack animal.
- 8:08So, you know, just as a side note, you can interrogate that
- 8:11if you're a person is predicated your whole life on, I can
- 8:13outwork anybody and you're not a terribly happy person.
- 8:17This potentially is why perhaps it's not healthy to quote
- 8:19outwork anybody. And you should refer back to my
- 8:23posts on being a work horse or a people-pleaser of a whole post
- 8:27on people-pleasing, Daughters of covertly narcissistic mothers,
- 8:30which really is going to apply when you're thinking about
- 8:33boundaries. And if you About them in a
- 8:35healthy or unhealthy way. And the other party that is
- 8:40upset by boundaries or or narcissist.
- 8:44And that's when other people have boundaries.
- 8:46So narcissus cannot boundaries up the Wazoo, but they get very
- 8:49upset when other people have boundaries because that means
- 8:52that they cannot then do anything.
- 8:53They want with that person. Take any of their time, any of
- 8:56their energy, constantly call them on the phone and he our ask
- 9:00them to, you know, give them money as some to give them a
- 9:04child. Or whatever the hell so people
- 9:06who are self-absorbed hate, when other people have boundaries but
- 9:09then who loves boundaries too much avoidant attachment people.
- 9:13They're like here's my boundary I go out with my friends every
- 9:16Friday. Here's my boundary, I keep my
- 9:19own separate bank account. Here's my boundary, I do
- 9:22everything that I want all the time.
- 9:24Here's my other boundary you're not allowed to say anything
- 9:26about it. Here's my up, you know?
- 9:28I mean it's like it's like a boundary Factory and if there's
- 9:32too many boundaries / preferences, You got to think
- 9:35this person really want to be in a relationship and God's honest.
- 9:38Truth is probably not, Oh, I thought of another category of
- 9:41people that have way too many boundaries people with sex
- 9:43issues, people who are very closed-minded about sex or oral
- 9:47sex is a boundary anal, sex is a boundary sex in a different
- 9:51position is a boundary sex. When we're looking at each other
- 9:53as a boundary sex without, you know, both of us literally, like
- 9:56zipping ourselves into hazmat suits as a boundary.
- 9:59So by the time you get done with those boundaries, you're
- 10:01basically, you know, procreating like, you know, I don't know,
- 10:05two robots, and that's too many boundaries, so there could be
- 10:08too many boundaries which I call pathological self-reliance.
- 10:13And just, as there can be two few boundaries.
- 10:15So, what is this Concord with? Well, if you're an expert
- 10:18listener, at this point, you are you already know.
- 10:20It's a pursuer, distance, sir or preoccupied?
- 10:24Avoidant Dynamic. The preoccupied person.
- 10:26They have a desire to merge with a partner and to have no
- 10:30boundaries at all and the avoidant wants to have
- 10:32everything, be a boundary Because they basically want to
- 10:35be single with somebody to fuck, and that's not a relationship
- 10:38either. So it and and back to the
- 10:42ultimatum thing. An ultimatum is just like a
- 10:44fancy boundaries, like a boundary with a top hat.
- 10:47It's like very dramatic tap-dancing boundary.
- 10:51So it's like if you do eggs I will leave.
- 10:54Or if you do X, I will do Y and Y is a, similarly, dramatic sort
- 10:59of thing. So it's the same people who
- 11:02don't like boundaries, don't like ultimatums Items the same
- 11:04people who have you know too many boundaries have too many
- 11:08ultimatums and etc. Etc.
- 11:11When should you use a boundary then?
- 11:13So you don't want to use a too little.
- 11:15You do want to use it too much. You got to.
- 11:17I mean there's no one-size-fits-all answer.
- 11:18I can't be like well if you write out 20 boundaries,
- 11:21boundary number 12 is going to be the one that you should
- 11:23preserve and the other ones you should interrogate.
- 11:26No. But I mean, the list is a pretty
- 11:28good idea. You should write out all your
- 11:30boundaries, it would be it would be really instructive quite
- 11:33honestly, it would Really transformational if you'd like
- 11:36to have, if you're a homework assignment type of person, you
- 11:39want to get your bang for your buck of this free podcast.
- 11:42So it's a pretty good bang for the no buck.
- 11:45You can write out a list of your boundaries and different domains
- 11:48and if you're writing so much that your hands hurts which had
- 11:51frequently does in the age of typing I can barely even like
- 11:54hold a pen anymore. Then you have too many
- 11:57boundaries so like for example my funny I thought it was funny
- 12:02hazmat suit thing if somebody she has way it.
- 12:05So if you're writing out your boundaries during sex you're
- 12:07like I can't do this. I won't do this, I can't do
- 12:09this, I won't do this, I won't do that.
- 12:10If you got like, 5 10 things, you won't do that.
- 12:13Just like flow out of you like magically as soon as you put
- 12:16your pen to the paper, why don't you like think about that?
- 12:19Like is this a fun open-minded way to go about sex?
- 12:24You know, it's probable that it's not similarly, what are
- 12:27your emotional boundaries? You know if you can't think of
- 12:30literally any you know like like oror even Like, forget about.
- 12:35Okay, well, I don't forget about it because people be like,
- 12:37what's an emotional boundaries, she never told me and then I
- 12:39died of curiosity. So what an emotional boundary
- 12:43would be? Is for example, let's say you
- 12:46had a bad day at work, right? And you come home and you do
- 12:49want to talk about it right away because it's so fucking
- 12:52upsetting and you got the goddamn children up your ass and
- 12:55you got to make dinner and whatever.
- 12:57So you have a frown on your face because you're not a robot and
- 13:01your partner comes over and they're like, what's wrong?
- 13:03You're like I don't know. Talk about it right now.
- 13:04I'll tell you later and your partner's like No, you got to
- 13:07tell me right now. You got to tell me right now
- 13:09because this is why we're not closed.
- 13:11Well, that's a bunch of bullshit.
- 13:12You know, you have a frown on. Now I'm going to be worried,
- 13:15right? So you should be able to keep
- 13:17your emotional boundaries, totally healthy to say, listen,
- 13:21I'm upset about something nothing to do with you.
- 13:24I don't want to talk about it right now, but I'll tell you
- 13:26later, that is an emotional boundaries, you do not have to
- 13:29turn yourself inside out like, you know, like like Like, at the
- 13:35very at the mercy of the person who is curious about you, you
- 13:39don't have to do that. You could say I have this
- 13:42boundary up. Now what's the boundary that's
- 13:44to excessive saying? I'm never going to tell you
- 13:47saying saying, yeah, I'm upset and I don't want to talk about
- 13:50it ever. I never want to talk about it
- 13:52because it's nothing. So that shit is crazy making.
- 13:55So that's how the avoidant person would respond, right.
- 13:57The preoccupied person is the person who's like, yeah, I can't
- 14:01believe you would take you away like an hour before telling me
- 14:03now, How am I going to get through dinner?
- 14:05Like that is preoccupied. The avoid a is, like nothing,
- 14:09nothing's wrong. What do you mean?
- 14:10You always think something's wrong, right?
- 14:12When they're like frowning like somebody just died.
- 14:14So emotional boundaries are possible.
- 14:18Also to have, you know, then there's physical self care
- 14:21boundaries, which are particularly difficult for
- 14:23people who grew up in neglectful homes where there was no self
- 14:27care. So, the idea for many people who
- 14:29grew up in Dysfunctional homes that they could tell somebody a
- 14:33partner who wants to have, Fight that they're going to sleep.
- 14:36This is like, oh my God. They're like this is like the
- 14:38best thing I ever told them. They're like wait but he wants
- 14:41to talk like this D. He wants to talk until 2.
- 14:44A.m. what are you going to stay up till 2:00 a.m. they're like,
- 14:46well yes he want he wants to talk.
- 14:49If you didn't hear me wants to talk, I don't give a shit if he
- 14:51wants to talk, how you going to stay up till 2 a.m.
- 14:54Then it's 6:00 a.m. You're going to get up with your
- 14:56kids, then you're going to go to work.
- 14:57Is this what you do? And they say oh yes because he
- 15:00wants to talk. I don't like it but then again
- 15:02he does want to talk. This is what people We'll say
- 15:04when they've grown up in homes or nobody takes care of them or
- 15:07prioritises, are their health or their basic needs for a sleep
- 15:13for rest for privacy etcetera. So if you're listening to this,
- 15:17if you get one thing out of this, you're always allowed to
- 15:19go to sleep. Always unless it's like 2:00
- 15:21p.m. and you're going to sleep, you're like, fuck you.
- 15:24I'm taking a nap because I do want to talk about this.
- 15:26Yes, that's crazy. But if it is out, if it is like
- 15:30after 9:30 and you want to go to sleep, A parent as a human
- 15:35being, you, you basically allowed to go to sleep.
- 15:37You know what if it's before, 9:30, go to sleep.
- 15:39Do you get your kids off to sleep?
- 15:40You're allowed to go to sleep. Now, if you do this every single
- 15:43day and you do not give any alternate time to talk, well,
- 15:47then you're avoided. But in the people that are the
- 15:50ones, staying up till 2:00 a.m. are usually the people that you
- 15:54know are too much on the other end of the extreme that are not
- 15:57going to all of a sudden be like, fuck you, I'm ever going
- 15:59to talk again. So need to do and this is a
- 16:02thing to do with a therapist because I can A not so much as I
- 16:05would love to talk to all of the hundreds of people who are going
- 16:08to listen to this podcast and be like, no, this is normal, that's
- 16:13not normal. So this is a reason to get a
- 16:15therapist, especially if you grew up in a dysfunctional home
- 16:19is to say, what is a normal boundary to said?
- 16:21So for example, my partner, you know, constantly looks at my
- 16:25phone and tells me I'm cheating even though I have never cheated
- 16:28ever. But I mean, that's normal,
- 16:30right? I mean I gotta like reassuring.
- 16:32That's being a loving partner. No.
- 16:34No, that's not being a loving partner.
- 16:36So, I don't know what other example, you know, is exactly
- 16:39the one you're thinking about, this is why people need to get
- 16:41their individual therapist. So that if you grew up in a
- 16:43dysfunctional home, you can be like, oh, shit.
- 16:46This and this is happening, you mean?
- 16:48That's not normal and that can be very helpful in your life.
- 16:51So and you should set an ultimatum.
- 16:54If somebody's doing something that's bad for you very bad for
- 16:57you. If somebody's drinking all the
- 16:58time and they won't stop if they're cheating on you and they
- 17:00don't stop. If they curse at you and yell at
- 17:03you and they don't stop. If they hit you ever if they are
- 17:08stealing from you. If they are doing anything that
- 17:10people would consider a moral, if they're doing any sort of
- 17:13criminal act, then you leave you leave.
- 17:17I know it's easier said than done but just sometimes people
- 17:19have to hear things a bunch. Maybe this is the second time,
- 17:22third time hundredth time. First time that you may have
- 17:24heard any of that, think about it.
- 17:26If somebody's doing something to you, that they could get
- 17:29arrested for like a salt or that they would get fired for doing
- 17:33like you. Looking at somebody, in berating
- 17:35them leave that is when you should be setting your ultimatum
- 17:39and saying, if you don't do this I will leave.
- 17:40And then you gotta leave an ultimatum is healthy.
- 17:42If you really mean you're going to leave, so that means if you
- 17:45tell somebody you're going to get a divorce, it is only
- 17:47healthy. If you have thought about
- 17:49getting a divorce and you are willing to get a divorce.
- 17:51If x y z does not change. If you're just throwing it out,
- 17:54there is some kind of game playing manipulation because
- 17:57this is what you saw between your parents growing up,
- 17:59everybody yelling, everybody threatening.
- 18:02I mean, been there And you you it's very very stressful for
- 18:07children listening to that, but unfortunately, they also learn
- 18:11how to do it. And so if you grew up hearing a
- 18:13lot of threats, then that's your go-to when you grow up.
- 18:17Is you threaten you say, if you don't do this, then I'm not
- 18:21going to do that. If you don't do this, I'm going
- 18:23to leave. If you do this, I'm going to
- 18:24leave. If you do this, I'm going to do
- 18:26this, you know, because you heard it all the time.
- 18:29So that could also be another Epiphany from this.
- 18:32Is that where did you get your Yeah of constantly throwing out
- 18:35ultimatums from your dramatic history on a childhood of
- 18:40course. So an ultimatum is only ethical
- 18:43to give if you really stand by delivering it.
- 18:45If you want to say I'm going to get a divorce if you don't ex
- 18:48you better have looked up at least divorce laws in your state
- 18:51you know and be willing to actually go and do it.
- 18:55If the person doesn't change that is an ethical honest
- 18:58ultimatum, right? And a boundary should be
- 19:02something that is done too. Protect you while not hurting
- 19:06the other person, right? If they happen to get hurt and
- 19:10it is a real strong boundary, so if it's like their emotions, get
- 19:13hurt but you physically are safe or then.
- 19:16Yes. If it's like your emotions
- 19:18versus their emotions as a case-by-case situation.
- 19:21So like if they are stopping you from eating your meal because
- 19:25they have to just say one more thing, then your physical health
- 19:30is being compromised because of their emotional health, and then
- 19:34You win, you know, this is just a real quick, little way to
- 19:38think about it, for people, that struggle with it, who never
- 19:40understood boundaries, but if it's your emotion versus their
- 19:43emotion, they want to talk and you don't want to talk then, you
- 19:47know, I mean, flip for it, you know, no coin, you know, or go
- 19:51to couples counseling, right? Go to couples counseling.
- 19:54But remember if they want to keep talking and you have to go
- 19:57to sleep, you go to sleep. If they have to keep two, if
- 20:00they want to keep talking and you feel sick, or you have I've
- 20:04to go pee and you literally will not go pee because that might
- 20:08upset them. You are in a very dysfunctional
- 20:10situation and you need to go to therapy to figure out how to
- 20:13assert yourself. If you're in a situation where
- 20:16your husband wants a blow job and you don't like to give
- 20:17blowjobs. Well you know, I mean like you
- 20:20want something, he doesn't want something, there's got to be
- 20:23some sort of compromise somewhere.
- 20:25This is not a situation in which you are a health is going to get
- 20:28damaged, nor is his. So that's the sort of situation
- 20:31where people compromise. So you see my point Have
- 20:34individual questions about a boundary versus an ultimatum.
- 20:37Why don't you just send it on a voicemail?
- 20:39People love to listen to podcasts where somebody sends in
- 20:42a voice message and you could do that on an anchor apps a with
- 20:45this via boundary or an ultimatum but you know, that
- 20:48could be fun and exciting something for you to do and fun
- 20:52and exciting for my listeners. Anyway.
- 20:54Hopefully this was useful and possibly even for at least one
- 20:59person made you realize that you are in a crazy situation where
- 21:02you actually do need to set more.
- 21:04He's or for another sort of person that they're setting Me
- 21:07Maybe too many boundaries and remember where would that come
- 21:10from setting too many boundaries being pathologically
- 21:12self-reliant, family of origin like everything else.
- 21:17So you probably saw a parent that's too many boundaries it is
- 21:20overly cold overly self-reliant that you never really felt that
- 21:24you could access deeply emotionally and had no
- 21:26vulnerability, etc, etc. So hopefully you got something
- 21:30out of this and I will talk to you soon.
- 21:32Bye, bye.