Latest / Distillations | Science History Institute / Jersey City's Secret Water Experiment
Transcript
- 0:03From the Science History Institute.
- 0:05I'm Alexis Pedrick, and this is our new season of Distillations,
- 0:09American Vice: Risk, Science, and the American Experience.
- 0:17Away from the bustling streets of Jersey City lies the Boonton Reservoir.
- 0:25Boonton, if you've never heard of it, is a 700-acre expanse of water fed by the
- 0:29Rockaway River in northern New Jersey.
- 0:32In 1908, two men, John L. Leal and George Warren Fuller, spent 99 days
- 0:39scheming, secretly constructing something that would fundamentally
- 0:44alter the Jersey City water supply.
- 0:47A one-story building containing concrete tanks, pumping devices, boilers,
- 0:53engines, and a storeroom capable of holding three carloads of chemicals.
- 0:59The view inside was somewhere between a factory floor and a mad scientist's lab.
- 1:05On September 26th, 1908, at Leal and Fuller's direction, the valves opened.
- 1:13Water streamed through the contraption, mixing and stirring and
- 1:17whirring before rushing down into a gravity-fed aqueduct 23 miles long.
- 1:24Listeners, it was kind of a big deal.
- 1:28When the people of Jersey City turn on their taps and take a drink,
- 1:33now their water will contain trace amounts of a freshly applied chemical:
- 1:39chlorine.
- 1:43Theoretically, this chlorine, added in powdered form, will destroy
- 1:48the bacteria in the water with no harm to consumers downstream.
- 1:52But these men, water engineers with degrees from MIT and Columbia, sure War
- 1:59have just sent an unsanctioned chemical into the homes of 200,000 people.
- 2:05No large-scale testing, no approvals.
- 2:09This is an experiment on a grand scale.
- 2:12They must have wondered, will this work?
- 2:16Will this be safe?
- 2:18It was a huge gamble, and the people of Jersey City had no idea.
- 2:25Now, spoiler alert: it worked.
- 2:28That decision to add chlorine is one that continues to impact
- 2:32our lives for the better.
- 2:34But the question remains: do the ends justify the means?
- 2:38What if it hadn't worked?
- 2:40And how did people react when they found out?
- 2:44For answers, we're turning to producer Caitlin Faulds, who brought us this story.
- 2:52So, Caitlin, where does this start?
- 2:54Well, like any piece of history, that's a little bit up for interpretation.
- 2:58But to borrow words from historian Claas Kirchhelle:
- 3:01The history of chlorine is, to a certain degree, associated
- 3:04with the history of typhoid.
- 3:05And the history of typhoid is tied to contaminated drinking water.
- 3:10Oof!
- 3:11Well, I guess we'll go there now.
- 3:15Chapter One: Water, Filthy Water.
- 3:19Water, Filthy Water
- 3:21In the late 19th century, increases in industrialization and immigration
- 3:26meant American cities were growing drastically and quickly densifying.
- 3:31Jersey City was one of those boom towns.
- 3:34It was chock-a-block full with folks.
- 3:36This is water engineer, historian, and author Michael McGuire.
- 3:40Every block had a couple of industries on it, or warehouses or whatever.
- 3:45Smoke was belching out of everything, and it was a major railway terminus.
- 3:52All of the railroads from the west came into Jersey City.
- 3:57They then either loaded ships that would go out across the oceans.
- 4:03Or they would take stuff to New York City across the way because if you stand on
- 4:08the docks of Jersey City, the Manhattan skyline is right in front of you.
- 4:16But among other things, this growth put enormous pressure on the city's
- 4:21water infrastructure and increased anxieties about diseases like typhoid.
- 4:26Typhoid is a disease of human civilization.
- 4:28This is Claas Kirchhelle again, historian of "bugs and drugs" and associate
- 4:32professor for the French National Institute of Health and Medical Research.
- 4:36So typhoid, the primary mode of transmission is fecal-oral.
- 4:39Fecal-oral, as in poop.
- 4:42It needs us to be in close contact with other human beings in order
- 4:47to proliferate in order to survive.
- 4:50At first, we didn't really know what typhoid was or how it worked.
- 4:54For a long time, it was nearly indistinguishable from a huge amount
- 4:58of other fevers that would just kill you and that were associated
- 5:01with gastrointestinal symptoms.
- 5:03It's really only in the 19th century that we start getting an understanding
- 5:06of typhoid as a distinct disease.
- 5:09It's a British physician, William Budd, in the 1850s who links
- 5:13typhoid to contaminated water.
- 5:16He actually speaks of the sewer as a kind of extension of the diseased intestine.
- 5:21In this context, he's doing this almost in parallel exactly to John Snow.
- 5:25Game of Thrones, HBO: You know nothing, Jon Snow.
- 5:28Not the illegitimate son of Ned Stark.
- 5:31The 19th-century physician who was considered one of the founders of modern
- 5:36epidemiology and did a lot of work tracing the source of a cholera outbreak.
- 5:42And it's really this kind of joint double punch of cholera and typhoid
- 5:46that really changes perceptions.
- 5:49Although typhoid was first observed under a microscope in 1879 and then isolated and
- 5:55cultivated in 1884, there wasn't really widespread awareness of this disease.
- 6:01Typhoid is only really just becoming visible as this bacterial disease
- 6:06around the turn of the century.
- 6:081896, you get the first point-of-care diagnostic, the
- 6:11Widal test surrounding typhoid.
- 6:13So it's still a very exciting novel public health entity.
- 6:17In the 1900s, people's awareness of typhoid and its transmission grew.
- 6:22Typhoid Mary or, you know, the really sad story, really, of Mary Mallon is one
- 6:26of the iconic stories of public health.
- 6:30Mary was an Irish immigrant working as a cook for some of the wealthy families
- 6:34in New York City, and she was found to be the common denominator in 47 typhoid
- 6:39cases, some that even resulted in deaths.
- 6:42You don't necessarily need to show clinical symptoms to be infected with
- 6:46typhoid, and she was a healthy carrier.
- 6:48She's found to be the cause of typhoid outbreaks that have been
- 6:51ongoing in the New York area.
- 6:53She's arrested because she resists public health authorities.
- 6:56And the first thing people do is they just lock her away for not
- 7:00an inconsiderable amount of time.
- 7:03She was far from the only asymptomatic carrier in the city, but she was
- 7:08a woman and an immigrant, and perhaps doubly suspect to the
- 7:12epidemiologists at the time, who were:
- 7:14Quote-unquote, male microbe hunters.
- 7:18So the person gets reduced to the presence or absence of a microbe in this context.
- 7:23On the one hand side, it's a story of a triumph, right?
- 7:25You are able to track down a carrier and shut down that public health risk.
- 7:29And another one raises really uncomfortable questions about
- 7:32who is being blamed for disease.
- 7:38Nevertheless, some good may have come from her story and that of others.
- 7:42Each headline expanded awareness of typhoid transmission, germ theory, and
- 7:46larger-scale mitigation strategies, including ones that focus on water
- 7:50supply, filtration, and treatment.
- 7:52People got interested in getting their water from a new, cleaner source?
- 7:57This is David Sedlak, a professor at UC Berkeley.
- 8:00Historically, the approach was: if your water supply became fouled by some nearby
- 8:05activity, you found another water supply.
- 8:08You built a canal from a pristine watershed, or you put in a well
- 8:11in a new place, maybe deeper underground to make it safe.
- 8:15But in some places, that just wasn't possible.
- 8:18And so that forced people to get creative and find ways of treating water.
- 8:23This was true in Jersey City, where typhoid fever cases were high.
- 8:27The death rates were regularly above 60 per 100,000 between 1880 and 1895.
- 8:33A state Board of Health report in 1900 showed that they had 44 typhoid deaths,
- 8:37the most of any city in the state.
- 8:39For comparison, Newark, a city of approximately the same size, had
- 8:43only 25 deaths, and sourcing clean water in Jersey City was already a
- 8:47challenge because of its location.
- 8:51Jersey City spent a lot of money to develop a new water
- 8:54supply on the Passaic River.
- 8:55This is Michael McGuire again.
- 8:57And they built it, and they were operating it.
- 9:00But that was downstream of all the sewage discharges for Paterson, New Jersey.
- 9:05And that's how people got sick.
- 9:07So they had to get off of the Passaic River where they were, and
- 9:13go way upstream to a tributary of the Passaic River called, I think it
- 9:19was, Rockaway, and build a reservoir.
- 9:23So in 1899, the city contracted with a New Jersey businessman, Patrick H.
- 9:29Flynn, who would eventually create the Jersey City Water Supply Company.
- 9:34The contract was for building a new reservoir that could supply
- 9:3750 million gallons of water daily as part of the project.
- 9:42The company had to undertake a multiyear process of clearing part of the land
- 9:46in Boonton, New Jersey, shifting the location of the old village.
- 9:50Private homes, churches, and factories were either relocated or destroyed.
- 9:56It was the largest project ever undertaken by the city, and it
- 9:59faced challenge after challenge.
- 10:02The city was wary of the company's cost-saving measures, like tunnels
- 10:06lined in gravel rather than concrete.
- 10:08But the reservoir began filling in early 1904, and despite some
- 10:13setbacks, by late May, Boonton water was fresh in Jersey City taps.
- 10:19But there were problems.
- 10:21Although the engineer in charge reported excellent quality at the top,
- 10:24some initial complaints emerged about muddy, sediment-filled water, and
- 10:29worries seemed to multiply over time.
- 10:32The city took notice, suing the water company in 1905.
- 10:37So there was the first trial to determine whether or not the water
- 10:41was pure and wholesome, and the judge decided that it was not--that there was
- 10:46bacteria in there, and that bacteria everybody knew could make people sick.
- 10:51So he said: put sewers up in the watershed.
- 10:55Which would theoretically help keep pathogens out.
- 10:58But the water company did not love this idea.
- 11:01It was an extremely expensive proposal.
- 11:04We're talking a large-scale project outside the scope of the original
- 11:08agreement to build the reservoir, and there was warranted concern that this
- 11:11would not be a foolproof solution, since bacteria and other pollutants
- 11:16would still have an opportunity to enter during storm runoff events.
- 11:20So intentionally or not, the judge added a clause with just enough room for
- 11:25interpretation, allowing for sewers or, quote-unquote, other plans or devices
- 11:31to correct the state of the water.
- 11:33Term of art, right?
- 11:34That's what Leal took and ran with.
- 11:37As he was doing research for his book, The Chlorine Revolution.
- 11:41Mike thought about writing a screenplay about this moment.
- 11:44I could just see it.
- 11:46The judge goes into his chambers.
- 11:49He's taking off his robe.
- 11:51The defendants come into his chambers.
- 11:54Leal and the lawyers—a guy by the name of Corbin, by the way.
- 11:58And they come into his chambers, and he says, “Boys, you've got a real problem.
- 12:03You're gonna have to do something.
- 12:05I'll put some language in there.
- 12:07But if you can do something that's better than a sewer, yeah, go ahead.
- 12:10But I'm only going to give you three months.”
- 12:14That's right.
- 12:15Three months.
- 12:16Three months to correct whatever was wrong with the system, create a whole
- 12:21new sewer or method, and make the water certifiably pure and wholesome.
- 12:26Three months, of course, is insane.
- 12:28You can't take out a permit now in three months.
- 12:31Forget building a treatment plant that had never been built before, you know?
- 12:37The clock was ticking for John Leal.
- 12:43Chapter Two: Betting on Lives.
- 12:47Betting on Lives
- 12:48Before John Leal changed American water.
- 12:51He was a physician.
- 12:53As was his father.
- 12:54And he grew up in a small town in southern New York State.
- 12:58Andes, New York, actually, at the edge of the Catskills.
- 13:01His father went to serve in the Civil War, came back from the Civil War, and
- 13:06they moved to Paterson, New Jersey.
- 13:08And the father, who was again a doctor, opened up a practice in Paterson.
- 13:13Leal would go on to graduate from Princeton in 1880 and Columbia's College
- 13:19of Physicians and Surgeons in 1884.
- 13:22So this guy had a couple of smarts to rub together.
- 13:26It was obviously very, very bright.
- 13:28And he grew up at a time and went to school at a time when microbiology
- 13:32in water, especially, was exploding.
- 13:35In Germany and other places.
- 13:37They were developing these microbiological techniques, some
- 13:41of which we still use today.
- 13:43And Leal was learning them at a lab that he had put together
- 13:47when he returned to Paterson.
- 13:48He eventually became a public health officer, which meant dealing with
- 13:52typhoid fever epidemics, so he knew what contaminated drinking water could do.
- 13:57At some point in the 1890s, he began advising water companies
- 14:02serving cities and townships in the New York and New Jersey area.
- 14:06And that's where he got involved in the lawsuit for the Jersey City Water Supply
- 14:10Company and the city of Jersey City.
- 14:13So that's John Leal.
- 14:17But remember, John was not the only one involved in the reservoir project
- 14:21at the beginning of our story.
- 14:24There was another man, George Warren Fuller, and he was
- 14:27more of a water scientist.
- 14:29The finest sanitary engineer in that period.
- 14:34There's no question.
- 14:36Fuller was born in Franklin, Massachusetts, and had trained
- 14:39in germ theory and chemistry at MIT before spending time studying
- 14:43bacteriology in Berlin and working at the Berlin Waterworks.
- 14:47In 1890, Fuller brought those European techniques back to the
- 14:52US to begin designing major waste and wastewater treatment plants.
- 14:57What European techniques, you ask?
- 14:59Well, first, it might be helpful to understand chlorine, our real main
- 15:03character, a little bit better.
- 15:06First of all, let's not get confused with chloride, which is
- 15:10the element in the periodic table.
- 15:11That is David Sedlak.
- 15:13Again, chlorine refers to, at its most basic, the molecule Cl2, or diatomic
- 15:21chlorine, as you might have learned if you took high school chemistry.
- 15:24That's two of these chlorine atoms just attached to each other, the
- 15:27way our air is full of two nitrogen atoms attached together and two
- 15:31oxygen atoms attached together.
- 15:34I fear I remember little of this from high school chemistry, but
- 15:38David, in addition to being a UC Berkeley professor and director of
- 15:42the Berkeley Water Center, is a:
- 15:44Water chemist through and through.
- 15:46If someone asks me what I'm qualified to do.
- 15:48That's all I'm qualified to do in this world.
- 15:50So we've come to the right person.
- 15:53David says when you attach two chlorine atoms together, you
- 15:56get a very reactive molecule.
- 15:58This is different from nitrogen, which is almost completely inert, and oxygen, which
- 16:03is somewhat reactive, but basically stays as oxygen when it goes inside our bodies.
- 16:09Chlorine is relatively unstable.
- 16:12When chlorine goes into water, it undergoes a chemical reaction to produce
- 16:17something called hypochlorous acid.
- 16:21If you remove a proton from hypochlorous acid, you get
- 16:25hypochlorite, and you've actually encountered this pretty regularly.
- 16:29If you've ever bought a bottle of bleach, you bought a bottle of chlorine, but the
- 16:34form you bought was sodium hypochlorite.
- 16:37Chlorine can be manipulated into many forms.
- 16:40Household bleach is one tool; tablets are another.
- 16:46"The ABC’s of Pool Care": A beautiful warm day, and the water
- 16:47looks clean, clear, and sparkling.
- 16:50But hold it right there.
- 16:51There are no swimming pool chemicals on the market that kill bacteria
- 16:55faster than Perchloron or ChlorTabs.
- 16:59Back in 1908, a common form of chlorine was a powder called chloride of lime.
- 17:05You could find it advertised in newspapers or buy it in a store.
- 17:09Its use is—
- 17:11Fairly old, actually.
- 17:12I mean, people are using chloride of lime for a really long time in order to ward
- 17:17off infection risks, even though they don't have any concept of bacteria for
- 17:21loads of different forms of infection.
- 17:24Here's our "bugs and drugs" guy, Claas again.
- 17:26So we already see this in 1892 where, for example, the city of Hamburg,
- 17:32following the cholera epidemics, they disinfect the entire sewage system,
- 17:36they disinfect water canals, etc..
- 17:38Glass actually traces chlorine application to drinking water in typhoid
- 17:42epidemics to around that time, too.
- 17:45The technology is first used to chlorinate drinking water in the
- 17:49Austrian-Hungarian Empire on the Adriatic.
- 17:51But one year later, in the context of a large-scale typhoid outbreak
- 17:54in Maidstone, it's also used in the UK for the first time.
- 17:58But in these instances, chlorine was more of a reactionary measure.
- 18:03The chlorine-heavy water was pumped through systems temporarily
- 18:07to kill any bacteria, but it was not meant for people to drink.
- 18:12They would have noticed that it was treated with chemicals, and the levels
- 18:15being used were actually dangerous.
- 18:19At this point, there was still a lot more work on physical infrastructure
- 18:23and dosage required to make chlorine a viable long-term solution.
- 18:29In Louisville, Kentucky, Fuller had witnessed an early experiment with a
- 18:33device that could create chlorine gas, and he had also learned the basics of
- 18:37how to create a chemical feed system.
- 18:40Historian Michael McGuire speculates that Leal must have had some
- 18:43experiments up his sleeve, too.
- 18:45Maybe that's why when Leal showed up at his New York office one
- 18:48day after the court's mandate, Fuller agreed to join the project.
- 18:52He would never have done it on his own, though he was an engineer.
- 18:55Engineers don't do stuff like this.
- 18:57Engineers do what the client wants them to do.
- 19:00However, Leal had the vision and the courage to make it happen.
- 19:05And that vision?
- 19:07To create a delivery system for chlorine and use that to
- 19:11treat the water in Jersey City.
- 19:13But for this project, they needed a reliable system capable of adding chloride
- 19:17of lime to roughly 50 million gallons of water per day, enough for 200,000 people.
- 19:24No blueprints existed for a project of this scale.
- 19:27But they drew on their broad experience and used feed systems designed for
- 19:31other chemical additives as a guide.
- 19:35They also tracked down pipes, tanks, boilers, and engines all the stuff
- 19:39needed to channel heavy water flow and introduce precise chlorine dosages.
- 19:45They built a whole building right next to what they call the valve house, and
- 19:49that's where they put all the equipment.
- 19:50And there was a whole bunch of equipment.
- 19:53Passerbys must have known that something was afoot, but exactly what the
- 19:58project entailed was still a mystery.
- 20:01On September 26th, 1908, with just a couple days left on the countdown,
- 20:07Leal and Fuller said the word.
- 20:10Water from the Boonton Reservoir moved through the dam intake, met the chlorine,
- 20:15and followed gravity through the 23 miles of aqueduct into Jersey City.
- 20:20There was no certainty in what would happen next, but also no one knew
- 20:25about it, and so no one could stop it.
- 20:30Chapter Three: Chemistry versus Chemophobia.
- 20:34Chemistry vs.
- 20:36Chemophobia
- 20:37Today, chlorine treatment has become so commonplace in the US that many
- 20:42of us hardly even think about it.
- 20:44But what it does do is it changes the flavor profile of your water.
- 20:47This is Christy Spackman, an associate professor at Arizona State University who
- 20:52studies the sensory perception of water.
- 20:55Whether we acknowledge it or not, chlorine fundamentally alters
- 20:58our experience of each sip.
- 21:00It can essentially wipe out a lot of tastes and smells.
- 21:04Christy says that is basically due to its role as an oxidizing agent.
- 21:09For example, some water has organic compounds called phenols,
- 21:14which get introduced through plant and animal decomposition.
- 21:18In some cases, if you add chlorine to water containing these phenols—
- 21:23It's going to make those phenols free, which means your water's going to get
- 21:26this really medicinal smell and it's going to be really, really unpleasant.
- 21:30Safe, perhaps, but not that tasty.
- 21:33And that flavor, Christy argues, really matters.
- 21:37As people use their bodies to evaluate, is this water good or not?
- 21:42They're also making judgments that are a lot like, is this water safe?
- 21:45Which then becomes a judgment of: Do I trust the people producing water?
- 21:49Because if my body tells me that the water is not good and not safe,
- 21:55then no matter how much science you throw at me, I'm still going to
- 21:58trust my body in 99% of the cases.
- 22:06So back to Jersey City in 1908.
- 22:11The lack of regulation allowed Leal and Fuller to take this risk and add chlorine,
- 22:17but it also allowed them to risk making people reject it because their senses
- 22:22might tell them something was off.
- 22:25People hated chemicals because they were being put in their food
- 22:28and medicine at very, very high concentrations and making people sick.
- 22:32This is Michael McGuire again.
- 22:34There was this fear of chemicals in drinking water, and nobody wanted to do
- 22:38anything, even though they knew it was causing typhoid fever and killing people.
- 22:44So they were very untrusting; the citizens were.
- 22:48But the water utilities.
- 22:50I mean, as long as nobody ever found out about it, they could do anything
- 22:53pretty much they could get away with.
- 22:55We don't know if the public was tipped off through their sensory experience.
- 23:00If the initial dose was small, as Leland Fuller reported,
- 23:05people may not have noticed.
- 23:06Or they might have associated some slight chemical note with cleaning products of
- 23:12the day as a subconscious sign of safety.
- 23:15But if phenols and other chlorine-reactive materials were high, their water
- 23:20may have turned more foul, while, counterintuitively, being safer.
- 23:26Mike's research didn't show any obvious instantaneous reaction.
- 23:30I did not find any, you know, of citizens with torches and pitchforks, you know,
- 23:37marching on City Hall or, you know, raising a ruckus in the newspaper.
- 23:41But as he said, people were very untrusting, and that chemophobia,
- 23:46that fear of chemicals, especially unknown chemicals, could be
- 23:51deep-set and difficult to undo.
- 23:54We have, over the 20th century, created a world that is a chemical playland.
- 23:54If you're a chemist, where like, there's been all these amazing advances
- 23:54in chemistry and these discoveries.
- 23:54But that doesn't necessarily mean that just because we can make something, it's
- 23:54safe for the bodies that are ingesting it.
- 23:54And there's been plenty of evidence emerging over the
- 23:5520th century around that.
- 23:55When I think of chemophobia, I think of the idea that you shouldn't buy a
- 23:59food that has something listed on it, that you don't know how to pronounce
- 24:03that word or you don't recognize it.
- 24:05So some of it's a familiarity question like, what are the things
- 24:09that I feel safe and comfortable around and that I'm familiar with?
- 24:13Whether or not an initial change was noticed.
- 24:15The news gradually broke out.
- 24:18By early December, papers had headlines like "A New Method of Purification"
- 24:23and "Secret Experiments at the Rockaway Intake." And you might be thinking
- 24:28that after getting a surprise chemical in their water, after everything
- 24:32we told you about Chemophobia, that people started to freak out.
- 24:38But you would be wrong.
- 24:40If the papers are an indication, they mostly seem to withhold judgment.
- 24:45Some noted the water companies claim that chlorine, or chloride of
- 24:49lime, was an effective way to clear microorganisms and fungus from the supply.
- 24:54One article even pointed out that although the exact effects on consumers were
- 24:59not known, lime water in small doses was said to be good for the stomach.
- 25:04So the chlorine treatment might be all right.
- 25:08So what was going on here?
- 25:10Maybe the level of familiarity with chloride of lime really did help.
- 25:15Or maybe after many years of debate, delay, and dirty sourcing, people
- 25:21were just ready for clean water.
- 25:24Plus, pure speculation on my part.
- 25:26But there was a legal process going on, and probably people were waiting
- 25:31to see what the resolution of that was.
- 25:33It's not like they had to pick up the phone and call the police.
- 25:35I mean, the courts were already involved.
- 25:39Right.
- 25:40Remember when the reservoir project started in 1899, and the Jersey City Water
- 25:45Supply Company faced all those challenges?
- 25:49Well, one of them was that Patrick H. Flynn was a pretty shady business owner.
- 25:54He was out of the picture by the time the court cases started,
- 25:57giving Leal and Fuller their chance to chlorinate the water.
- 26:01But the damage was done.
- 26:02The project had been long drawn out and cumbersome.
- 26:06The city wanted out of paying so much money.
- 26:08Or maybe they wanted to get more out of the company.
- 26:11Either way.
- 26:12Besides the initial case to determine the quality of the water, there is a
- 26:17second case to find out if the company had met expectations and what obligation
- 26:22the city had to pay their dues.
- 26:25And that is where Chemophobia was really on display.
- 26:28The lawyers for the city were trying everything they could
- 26:32in order to win their case.
- 26:35Specialists were brought in from the community and from
- 26:37renowned institutes like MIT.
- 26:40Some scientists showed concern that it was too soon for an experimental system
- 26:44to be rolled out at such a large scale.
- 26:47Others cited doctors in Lincolnshire, England, who had reported cases of
- 26:51colic, diarrhea, skin irritation and conjunctivitis in an area
- 26:55where limited chlorination had also been done, thus insinuating that
- 26:59chlorine might be a health hazard.
- 27:02It seems most of the doubt disappeared in cross-examination.
- 27:06But beyond the courtroom, scientific debate about the method
- 27:09also raged at water conferences around the country; scientists
- 27:13presented evidence for and against.
- 27:16You know, it was pretty brutal.
- 27:17One guy you just said, hey, we might consider this or here's
- 27:21some of the possibilities.
- 27:23And he was practically drawn and quartered as a result.
- 27:28All of this meant that chlorine was getting a thorough examination, even
- 27:32without a public call for review.
- 27:34In the end, basic but extensive testing proved chlorine's worth.
- 27:39The methods that they had, which were pretty basic, showed that the water
- 27:43was free of all of the disease-causing organisms and the organisms that
- 27:47we call indicator organisms.
- 27:50They were gone too.
- 27:51So that means that there was no indication of fecal contamination because the
- 27:56chlorine had killed all of those bacteria.
- 28:03Through the court proceedings, details on the exact dosage of chlorine came
- 28:07out: less than one milligram per liter.
- 28:10When you compare that to the modern recommendation from the
- 28:14EPA of 4 milligrams per liter—
- 28:16There's no indication of any problems.
- 28:18There hasn't been.
- 28:19And back then I don't think there was.
- 28:22You know, people get very upset, as they should, when they think government's
- 28:26not doing anything to protect them.
- 28:29But in this case, there was a mechanism ongoing that was testing the degree
- 28:34of protection that the citizens had.
- 28:36So on May 9th, 1910, nearly two years after Leal hatched his plan, the judge
- 28:42issued his decision: "I do therefore find and report that this device is
- 28:48capable of rendering the water delivered to Jersey City pure and wholesome for
- 28:53the purposes for which it is intended and is effective in removing from the
- 28:58water those dangerous germs." The city appealed, but the ruling was upheld.
- 29:05Chlorination officially had its stamp of approval.
- 29:09All the water utilities and engineers across the country
- 29:12were watching Jersey City.
- 29:14They were waiting for someone to say, it's okay.
- 29:18Once that came through with the decision by the New Jersey Supreme
- 29:22Court, everybody started putting it in.
- 29:24And I don't mean within ten years; I mean within ten days.
- 29:31Chlorine was inexpensive and, as Leal and Fuller had shown, could
- 29:35be set up and implemented at speed.
- 29:37Some turned it on.
- 29:39Honestly, you know, within weeks, at the most, after Jersey City, they were
- 29:44just waiting because they knew it would cause so much public health benefit.
- 29:49Children weren't going to be dying in the hundreds of thousands.
- 29:54Can you imagine?
- 29:55To be an engineer with the responsibility of the public health of the city,
- 29:59and you can't do something that you know is going to solve the problem?
- 30:04But the question remains: if the people of Jersey City knew, would they
- 30:09have consented to this experiment?
- 30:12Is the moral of the story that it's all right to do something this big
- 30:15without public approval if it works?
- 30:22Chapter Four: A Monument to Chlorine.
- 30:26A Monument to Chlorine
- 30:28Speculation again, but the proof of protection probably went pretty far
- 30:32in securing the public's approval.
- 30:34As our sensory scientist Christie Spackman says:
- 30:37Our municipal water systems put us in these relationships of trust
- 30:41with people we may never encounter.
- 30:43And they put us in relationships of trust with material infrastructures like pipes
- 30:48and pumps and even the ground around us.
- 30:52And saying all of that is being monitored well and managed
- 30:56well, and that those are safe.
- 30:58Then and now, we're required to have faith that these systems will
- 31:02function, and the people behind them have our best interests at heart.
- 31:06And sometimes that feels difficult, especially as science and technology
- 31:11evolve to improve our options while also revealing the flaws
- 31:14of the systems that came before.
- 31:16There's this ongoing history of the 20th century that says,
- 31:20yeah, you should be nervous.
- 31:21It used to be pipes were made with lead.
- 31:23And lead pipes can result in lead in your water, which can result in damage
- 31:27to your brain or your child's brain.
- 31:29The biggest, most spectacular one, of course, is if you go back and you
- 31:34look in the early 20th century at the discovery of radioactivity; there
- 31:38are all these amazing advertisements.
- 31:40My favorite is an advertisement from Evian that I saw in my
- 31:45archival work that says Evian a radioactive Water good for your baby.
- 31:50From a 21st-century perspective, we all think if I saw an advertisement
- 31:55for water saying it was radioactive, I would run screaming because
- 31:59our understanding of what those chemicals do in the body has shifted.
- 32:05And so we've gone from seeing this as a miraculous thing that can help heal
- 32:09lesions in the body to yes, but the dose is really important to pay attention to.
- 32:23As we saw in the case of chlorine, Leal and Fuller did get the dose right.
- 32:28And although the acceptance of chlorine's biochemical safety may
- 32:32have taken time, the impact on public health was detectable within months.
- 32:38Their detection methods were pretty, uh, not great at the time.
- 32:41Well, we had telephones back then, so maybe they get on the phone
- 32:44and call doctors and say: hey, do you have any typhoid fever cases?
- 32:46I don't know how they collected the data, but it decreased within months.
- 32:53If any water company or municipality hadn't taken notice of the chlorine
- 32:57experiment itself, this disease drop off made an impact and the
- 33:02method spread like wildfire.
- 33:04Within a few years, like 75%, 80% of all municipal water supplies were
- 33:10using chlorine, which is remarkable.
- 33:14Now, typhoid was not the only thing that water sanitation improved.
- 33:19Dysentery, cholera, legionnaires' disease, and other illnesses caused
- 33:23by bacteria, viruses, and parasites.
- 33:25But typhoid was generally accepted as a benchmark for public health success.
- 33:31As Claas explained, it had turned into a notifiable disease.
- 33:35So there are legal requirements to report it.
- 33:38And this means that in already very wealthy contexts where you have
- 33:41investment in the ability to collect data, etc., it is one of the indicators
- 33:46that you can track over time.
- 33:48Public health officials could see the typhoid rate was dropping
- 33:52from around 50 per 100,000 in the late 19th century to less than 5
- 33:58in 100,000 in just a few decades.
- 34:01But of course, chlorination was not happening in isolation either.
- 34:06The sanitary awakening of the 19th century meant broad attention on
- 34:10public health concerns into the 20th, and a slew of advances.
- 34:14Clearly, investment in sand-based water filtration, chlorination, pressurized pipe
- 34:20water supplies do make a huge difference, together with sewage treatment and then
- 34:24also in parallel food hygiene measures.
- 34:28So I think it is fair to say that investment in a series of measures—there's
- 34:33no one golden or magic bullet against this—do lead to sustained reductions
- 34:38of typhoid incidence, specifically initially in urban high-income settings.
- 34:44This is an important note from Claas because these advances
- 34:49certainly weren't universal.
- 34:50And typhoid continues to be a major global health challenge impacting
- 34:55millions around the world each year.
- 34:57But at least in the U.S., those early 20th-century
- 35:00investments proved their worth.
- 35:03Disease rates plummeted and then remained low.
- 35:06As I recall, it was pretty clear that water treatment, filtration,
- 35:10and chlorination really were the main thing that was resolving the typhoid
- 35:16fever epidemics because they were known to be a waterborne disease.
- 35:20And so this was a very direct measure.
- 35:24The number one public health achievement, the thing that has had more impact,
- 35:28perhaps, than anything else on extending human life, has been the discovery
- 35:35of an ability to treat water in a way that people don't get sick anymore
- 35:41from the microbes present in it.
- 35:43Take away cholera, you take away dysentery, you take away all these things,
- 35:48and people's lifespans just went way up.
- 35:51But when you look back at it, this progress seems precarious.
- 35:55There was still no safeguard behind the scenes, and the effects, while
- 35:58positive, still happened after the fact.
- 36:01Leal did something incredible, but it was still a public health
- 36:04risk that no one knew about.
- 36:06He didn't ask permission from EPA because EPA didn't exist.
- 36:10There was no state health department.
- 36:12There was no local health department.
- 36:14And he didn't even tell Jersey City he was doing it.
- 36:18And when it comes down to it, we ultimately did decide that
- 36:22it's not okay to do something like this without oversight.
- 36:26The first attempt at National water regulations came in 1914 with the Public
- 36:31Health Service drinking water standards.
- 36:33These were extremely limited in scope.
- 36:36They applied microbiological quality standards, but only to water served on
- 36:41interstate carriers like trains or buses.
- 36:44Over the years, these standards were reshaped to include some
- 36:47physical and chemical parameters.
- 36:50But prior to the Safe Drinking Water Act of 1974, science-based standards were a
- 36:55patchwork of state and local initiatives.
- 36:59The 1974 Safe Drinking Water Act gave the federal government the
- 37:03power to regulate drinking water systems throughout the United
- 37:07States, and that changed everything.
- 37:10They would set the standards, and then they would require the states
- 37:15to implement those regulations.
- 37:18Even then, chlorine wasn't part of this broad regulatory move.
- 37:22It did not come into play until the Coliform Rule in 1989, I'm pretty sure.
- 37:30So it took a while.
- 37:32It took some time also to do the toxicity studies.
- 37:35And they discovered that chlorine up to 4mg/l was safe, no two ways about it.
- 37:43As long as you keep your concentration below four, you're good.
- 37:48And that brings us to today.
- 37:53As a 2017 report from the American Water Works Association shows, chlorine is still
- 37:58by far the most commonly used Disinfectant in drinking water treatment plants.
- 38:03This isn't true all over the world.
- 38:06In parts of Europe, for instance, countries rely more heavily on
- 38:09ultraviolet sanitation and deep aquifers.
- 38:12But in the U.S., roughly 70% of community water systems rely on chlorine.
- 38:18And these systems work in ways not so different from Leal and Fuller's
- 38:22prototype more than a century ago.
- 38:24So I'm going to use the Phoenix, Arizona region, where I live at
- 38:27the moment, as my case study.
- 38:29So with Phoenix, we're largely served by either the Colorado
- 38:33River or the Salt River.
- 38:36This is water fish are swimming in.
- 38:38This is water.
- 38:38Horses are standing in.
- 38:40It's an amazing resource, but it's also not water that you or I should be drinking
- 38:44without some additional treatment.
- 38:46So, you know, when it comes into the water treatment facility, the first
- 38:52thing that folks working there have to do is kind of evaluate what's going on
- 38:56with the water today and have a pretty good idea how things change seasonally.
- 39:00But then it's just the standard processes of filtration, of testing for different
- 39:06things and treating appropriately.
- 39:08And in fact, the municipal water we get from these water systems
- 39:14has been tested so many more times and for so many more things than
- 39:17the water you ever buy in a bottle.
- 39:19So bottled water tends to fall under the Food and Drug Administration, and
- 39:25our municipal water falls under the EPA.
- 39:27And so the EPA has a much larger set of things that are tested for
- 39:33and much more stringent requirements around making certain that water
- 39:38that's coming to you is safe.
- 39:42Tap water at this point is so standardized and regulated that
- 39:46Christie sees it as an industrialized beverage, something overseen by a
- 39:50broad regulatory body and produced, packaged, and delivered at scale.
- 39:55And in the case of water, what I think is so interesting is it is the
- 39:59only food that's, at least in large cities, produced at scale, that is sent
- 40:05directly into someone's home via pipes.
- 40:07This gives it real value and influence over people's lives and health.
- 40:12Here's "through and through water guy" David Sedlak again.
- 40:15The water systems that we built in the 20th century, and even some of the
- 40:18ones that we continue to build in the 21st century, are the unappreciated
- 40:24monuments of modern civilization.
- 40:26When the National Academies of Engineering was asked to identify
- 40:31the top ten innovations of the 20th century, they put water treatment
- 40:35forth after electrification, automobiles, and airplanes.
- 40:40And so it even came out ahead of the internet.
- 40:45In 1928, William Orchard, a general manager of a company that
- 40:50manufactured chemicals and equipment for water treatment, gave a speech
- 40:54at the Belleville Rotary Club.
- 40:56“I could imagine some sculptor creating a memorial to gold, to the element lead.
- 41:01Or I can imagine the building of a monument to iron.
- 41:04But to imagine the appearance of a monument building to the
- 41:07element chlorine is more difficult.
- 41:10Such a monument would have to be built of 270,000 living persons.
- 41:15Persons who are alive today because their lives have been saved through the
- 41:19purification of drinking water.” Today that count must be closer to millions.
- 41:26All lives that have been saved, lengthened, or exist because of chlorine.
- 41:31But that doesn't mean this history has been without incident.
- 41:34One of the coolest things that did happen in the 20th century was
- 41:38this idea of saying, we want our entire community to be healthy.
- 41:43And one of the fastest ways we can do that is to make sure everyone has good water.
- 41:47And one of the biggest heartbreaks, perhaps, of the 20th century are
- 41:50the failures when that happened, when certain parts of cities
- 41:53didn't get access to good water.
- 41:55Like it took longer for the infrastructure to get built, or
- 41:59when that infrastructure was built, maybe it wasn't serviced as well.
- 42:05There are also the situations where high-profile failures happen because
- 42:10science was the thing that was discounted.
- 42:12When Flint, Michigan, changed its water sourcing in 2014 and neglected proper
- 42:17treatment and testing, lead levels skyrocketed, exposing more than 100,000
- 42:22people to long-term health risks.
- 42:24"Flint's Water Crisis Explained," Vox: The images of the water are shocking enough.
- 42:28"Flint's Water Crisis Explained," Vox: Would you drink that?
- 42:29People have dumped in this river forever.
- 42:31It's like we're in this cesspool.
- 42:33"Flint's Water Crisis Explained," Vox: My tub.
- 42:33You should see it.
- 42:33It's brown.
- 42:33"Flint's Water Crisis Explained," Vox: And then come the headlines.
- 42:36An American city failed to provide basic protections to its citizens.
- 42:40And now the children of Flint have much higher than normal
- 42:43levels of lead in their blood.
- 42:46Rick Snyder, governor of Michigan, has apologized.
- 42:47"Flint's Water Crisis Explained," Vox: I am sorry, and I will fix it.
- 42:47"Flint's Water Crisis Explained," Vox: President Obama
- 42:47declared a national emergency.
- 42:47"Flint's Water Crisis Explained," Vox: You can't shortchange basic
- 42:47services that we provide to our people.
- 42:47Just recently, close to my home in Austin, Texas.
- 42:50Water samples in one neighborhood showed contaminants, including lead
- 42:53and arsenic, likely introduced through some combination of the neighborhood's
- 42:57plumbing and water sourcing.
- 43:01Things like this make us—make me hesitate at the tap and question our
- 43:06trust in those behind the scenes.
- 43:08Maybe that's why some of us form these little rituals, little habits,
- 43:13moving water from tap to fridge, or adding a faucet-mounted filter to gain
- 43:18some sense of agency in the process.
- 43:22Maybe it sounds silly, but in many cases, a very real history
- 43:26of government inattention.
- 43:28Divestment and discrimination may make people decide that
- 43:33interactions with industrialized tap water just aren't worth the risk.
- 43:38Sure, regulation and follow-through on regulation may help ease the
- 43:43sentiment, but not everyone has that privilege of trusting their systems
- 43:48will secure their safety and well-being.
- 43:50The reason policymakers and politicians, and even everyday folks, should want to
- 43:56pay attention to the tastes and smells of their municipal water is because those
- 44:01tastes and smells link us together as communities and invite us into investing
- 44:07in or divesting from the systems that make available healthful water to everyone.
- 44:14At the top of the story.
- 44:16We asked if the ends justify the means, if it was okay to do things without public
- 44:22approval, if the public really needed it.
- 44:25And an argument could be made that drinking poopy water and dying from
- 44:30typhoid is certainly something that the public needed science to step in and fix.
- 44:36Everyone who is in public service, who is involved in drinking water, has the
- 44:41potential to do great harm or great good.
- 44:45There are going to be situations when you just have to stand your ground and
- 44:50risk your job to protect public health.
- 44:54Will you have the courage, like Doctor Leal, to do the right thing today?
- 44:58No one in their right mind would do something like this.
- 44:59You know, add a whole new treatment process, a whole new chemical to
- 44:59drinking water, and not get it approved.
- 44:59Some people call him courageous.
- 45:00Some people call him reckless.
- 45:02But hundreds of thousands of people were dying all across the
- 45:06country due to contaminated water.
- 45:19But still, when people voiced concern about their water, it's worth listening.
- 45:26It's worth the extra explanation or revisiting the data because
- 45:27these systems are not stagnant.
- 45:30Science is always advancing, and technology is forever changing.
- 45:35Yes, sometimes we need someone like Leal to step out ahead, to take a
- 45:38calculated risk and pull society forward.
- 45:42But
- 45:56we shouldn't make a habit of risk without reanalysis.
- 45:56Thanks to producer Caitlin Faulds for bringing us this story.
- 46:01In our next episode, we'll talk about pinning our hopes and dreams
- 46:05for society on a different chemical.
- 46:08There was this belief that not only could psychedelics change the
- 46:11individual, it could change society.
- 46:13Certain people believed that psychedelics could end war.
- 46:20Tune in next week on October 6th.
- 46:22Distillations
- 46:25podcast is produced by the Science History Institute and recorded in the Laurie
- 46:31J. Landau Digital Production Studios.
- 46:34Our executive producer is Mariel Carr.
- 46:37Our producer is Rigoberto Hernandez.
- 46:40This episode was fact-checked by Alexandra Atiya, and the
- 46:44sound design was by Seth Samuel.
- 46:47Support for Distillations has been provided by the Middleton Foundation
- 46:50and the Wyncote Foundation.
- 46:53You can find all of our podcasts, as well as our videos and articles on
- 46:57our website at sciencehistory.org.
- 47:00And you can follow us on social media @SciHistoryOrg
- 47:04for news about our podcasts and everything else that goes on
- 47:08in our free museum and library.
- 47:11For Distillations, I'm Alexis Pedrick.
- 47:14Thanks for listening.