Latest / Distillations | Science History Institute / Mules, Arsenic, and Sesame: Untold Black History in the Americas
Transcript
- 0:01From the Science History Institute, I'm Alexis Pedrick, and this is our new season
- 0:05of Distillations, American Vice: Risk, Science, and the American Experience.
- 0:14Jayson Porter is an environmental writer and assistant professor of history at
- 0:18the University of Maryland, College Park.
- 0:21He's written articles for Distillations magazine.
- 0:24I think you're on your seventh, about to be your seventh article, right?
- 0:28And he writes about the intersection of race and agriculture.
- 0:32So today we're going to talk to you about mules, sesame plots, arsenic.
- 0:38And if you're thinking that's going to take an unexpected turn it is.
- 0:42So Jayson, welcome.
- 0:44Thanks for having me, Alexis.
- 0:45It's a pleasure.
- 0:50One of the through lines in your work is you talk about nature and agriculture
- 1:00as being used by empire, right?
- 1:02By people in power to basically rule over people and whether that's
- 1:07using mules or agrochemicals, the point is to subject people.
- 1:12But what I thought was really interesting is that a lot of times those same
- 1:17people who are being subjected kind of turn around and use these very
- 1:22tools to kind of fight or to thrive.
- 1:24So can we talk about that tension?
- 1:28Yeah.
- 1:29The reason why I get into the kind of questions around material culture
- 1:34is because those kind of provide me material witness into the past.
- 1:40As a historian, one of the things that's really difficult when you go on the
- 1:44archive is it's a lot easier to tell stories of injustice than justice.
- 1:49You know, there's no shortage of records that talk about orders that
- 1:53generals gave or talk about the things that enslaved people had to do.
- 1:58But very few records asked enslaved people what they wanted for themselves
- 2:02or if they had a dream last night.
- 2:05Very few records talk about what soldiers did as opposed
- 2:08to what they were told to do.
- 2:10So there's always gaps and silences in the archive.
- 2:13And to some extent, I rest on these material witnesses, like mules, or
- 2:17arsenic, or porgy fish, or sesame, as an angle into understanding people
- 2:24who didn't have the same benefit to leave their own records behind.
- 2:29So for me, in many ways, in those three pieces is a way for me to better
- 2:33understand the Black experience, not just in the United States, but
- 2:36across the diaspora in the Americas.
- 2:39Yeah, yeah.
- 2:40And it feels like, you know, you're talking about sort of the written word or
- 2:44kind of like what's left in the archives.
- 2:47And I feel like there's a lot of really careful attention
- 2:50to language in your work.
- 2:52So when you were writing about sesame plots, you were mentioning
- 2:56that seeds are diaspores.
- 2:58Am I saying that correct?
- 2:59You can like [correct me]
- 3:01. Sounds good to me.
- 3:01Okay.
- 3:02And that means they're--well, actually, what does that mean?
- 3:06I'm pretty sure it means to like, move across--diaspore--on some way to talk
- 3:12about move or translation across space.
- 3:14So to some extent, the word diaspora, when we talk about like people or other
- 3:19animals moving across space, that comes from the idea of seeds as being diaspores.
- 3:24Usually we imagine plants as being fixed in a particular place, but
- 3:29understanding their seeds as diaspores helps us understand how they move
- 3:32from place to place and continue to succeed generationally and evolve.
- 3:37Interesting.
- 3:38Yeah.
- 3:39I mean, so does it feel like for you, it's important to pay
- 3:44attention to language like that?
- 3:46To words like that?
- 3:48Absolutely.
- 3:49I mean, oftentimes it's again, as Edda Fields Black writes about, sometimes
- 3:54language allows you to kind of upstream backwards to get the sense of origins
- 3:59where you wouldn't necessarily understand otherwise where those origins come from.
- 4:05And when you're oftentimes dealing with a lack of evidence, going
- 4:10to origins helps you kind of see where to find evidence elsewhere.
- 4:15And oftentimes that's going back to this tension that you mentioned, trying to
- 4:19understand the plantation as a space or as an archive--understanding its etymology.
- 4:25But also understanding its physical landscape, its geography helps you
- 4:31understand that power didn't necessarily exist evenly across that landscape.
- 4:36And there were particular spaces where, you know, enslaved people or indigenous
- 4:41people had relative access to more autonomy or, you know, control of their
- 4:47own maybe diets or maybe on some level what recreation might have looked like.
- 4:53So I think oftentimes etymology can help you see these archives as something new.
- 4:59Because if you just follow historical archives that have been written
- 5:02by the quote unquote victors, you know, of history, you oftentimes
- 5:05don't necessarily get to the root.
- 5:08Or to the people who lived out those scenes of violence or life.
- 5:14Yeah.
- 5:14I mean, why would they?
- 5:16Right?
- 5:17They're not concerned with that, right?
- 5:19So I really, I like that a lot.
- 5:21So I want to dive into something we always have to dive into on this
- 5:26show, which is definitions, right?
- 5:29Definitions are important.
- 5:30So I think that would be helpful.
- 5:33So what, what is a mule?
- 5:36I mean, so a mule is essentially kind of a kind of combination: the
- 5:42offspring of a horse and a donkey.
- 5:47And it's particularly the offspring of a female horse and a male donkey.
- 5:54And essentially it was one of the first kind--if you want to
- 5:57say--hybrid technologies that people created to do labor.
- 6:03And now we have AI, which is a new technology that we use to lift
- 6:08things that don't necessarily need lifting, but like it's still labor.
- 6:12And in many ways, the mule was this first kind of hybrid that combined
- 6:15the qualities of a donkey and the qualities of a horse, because they're
- 6:18two very, very different things.
- 6:19Yeah, I was gonna say.
- 6:21What makes the mule special or like, why wouldn't you just get a horse?
- 6:25Right, right.
- 6:26And you know, so there are a lot of different types of horses,
- 6:28but by and large, horses are a little bit more scary than mules.
- 6:32Horses require more food.
- 6:34They're a little bit more finicky.
- 6:36They're much faster than mules, but their steps aren't necessarily as consistent.
- 6:41So if you were trying to, let's say, dredge, or plow a field, for
- 6:47instance, the footsteps of a mule are a little bit more consistent.
- 6:51And in a plantation landscape feeding a mule is a little bit easier.
- 6:55So throughout the colonial period, you see horses and mules and other
- 7:00beasts of burden, including people, you know, moving and shaking things.
- 7:04But it became pretty accepted in the 17th and 18th century that mules
- 7:10were probably the best beasts of burden for plantation landscapes
- 7:14and also for like mining landscapes.
- 7:17Okay, because in the article, you were talking about how they've
- 7:20been around for a while, like they're mentioned in the Bible.
- 7:23There's record of them going all the way back, but where are
- 7:27they mostly concentrated now?
- 7:30So that's a funky story that has a lot to do with imperial context.
- 7:36But essentially, I think the majority of mules today live in the Americas--so in
- 7:43Latin America and in the Caribbean--and I believe almost a third of all mules
- 7:49that exist today live in Mexico.
- 7:51And a lot of that just has to do with historically, the Spanish, because
- 7:56of the relationship with the Moorish Islamic conquest of the Iberian
- 8:00Peninsula back into the 14th century.
- 8:03They had kind of established a relationship with mules--mules
- 8:07that was distinct from what you see in both Europe and Asia.
- 8:10So by and large, the donkey was first domesticated in Africa, whereas the
- 8:14horse was first domesticated in Europe.
- 8:16And this kind of combination of the two, as the mule happened in either Ethiopia,
- 8:21Turkey or other parts of North Africa.
- 8:24And essentially, you know, there was not really a mule culture
- 8:29in Great Britain or in France.
- 8:31So when they established their empires and started moving enslaved people
- 8:35from Africa to the Caribbean to, you know, create tobacco and cotton and
- 8:40sugar plantations, they weren't using mules in the same way the Spanish were.
- 8:45And interestingly enough, the Spanish Jesuit culture was really, really
- 8:49fundamental in kind of connecting this mule breeding to both the plantation
- 8:54landscapes and the mines of Latin America.
- 8:57So there are mules all throughout the world.
- 8:59There are very few countries, I would imagine, that don't have
- 9:02their chunk of mules, but the grand majority are in the Americas.
- 9:08And so about that context: essentially, the Spanish did
- 9:11not allow the trading of mules.
- 9:16One of the funny things, I guess because it's 250 years of celebrating
- 9:20the United States--I have no investment in that celebration whatsoever.
- 9:24But, you know, George Washington became the father of the American mule because
- 9:28after the United States defeated Great Britain, the Spanish king actually
- 9:33presented him with a mule from the Iberian [Peninsula] . And said, now you
- 9:36guys can have mules, and from that point forward, the United States became a
- 9:40breeder of mules to send to the Caribbean throughout the first part of US history.
- 9:46So we became one of the biggest mule breeding populations, mostly in the
- 9:49northeast, until it ended up shifting down to Kentucky and the Midwest.
- 9:56Who knew?
- 9:56So in your Distillations article, you talk about the people who rode
- 10:02and bred mules--the mule tier.
- 10:06And two of the most famous were--let's see if I can remember
- 10:09this and get this right--Vicente Guerrero and Jose Maria Morales.
- 10:15Exactly.
- 10:16So who are they?
- 10:19What did their skills with animals help them do?
- 10:22They're fighting off the Spanish, right?
- 10:25So I don't always know where to start with this, but both Vicente Guerrero
- 10:29and Jose Maria Morelos were what they called Arrieros or Muleteers.
- 10:34And they were both also what's called Afro descendientes.
- 10:36So they were of African descent.
- 10:38They weren't full on African.
- 10:41They were like mestizo and within the kind of the Afro mestizo.
- 10:45So they were a mix of the Spanish, the African and Indigenous ancestries
- 10:50that kind of created what we know as Mexico and a lot of Latin America.
- 10:54And so essentially, Arrieros were the people who connected communities to
- 10:58plantations, plantations to ports, and plantations to each other.
- 11:01So how did products move from place to place, had everything to
- 11:04do with these kind of mule tears that created these mule trains.
- 11:08So they would bound together mules--from 20 mules to 200
- 11:11mules--and they would use them.
- 11:13They would pack on their backs, you know, from 50 lbs to 200 lbs worth of materials.
- 11:18And you were able to bring bales and bales of cotton from, let's say, a cotton
- 11:23plantation on the coast of Guerrero to Acapulco to then be shipped out to,
- 11:28let's say, China, or San Francisco.
- 11:31So that became one of the most accessible occupations for people of
- 11:37African descent across the Americas, both in the Mexican context and the
- 11:41Peruvian context and the Brazilian context and the Colombian context.
- 11:44These kind of Arrieros--people of African descent--oftentimes were able to
- 11:47manumit themselves or buy their freedom through their access to landscape.
- 11:53And it was really by being Arrieros that they were able to learn like: one, if you
- 11:57have a pack mule train of 200, you need to know where the watering holes are.
- 12:01You need to know what the climate is and the weather.
- 12:04So you see if that watering hole is even going to be filled with water.
- 12:07You need to know that climate and weather to know whether or not to
- 12:10forage or the grasses are going to be available that time of year.
- 12:14If not, you're going to need to know the communities where you can pick
- 12:16up the corn in lieu of such forage.
- 12:18So being an Arrieros meant that you knew the landscape and you knew the languages
- 12:22of the communities in this place.
- 12:24So when the Mexican independence movement started in 1810, Arrieros
- 12:29became these massive important figures because one, a lot of them
- 12:34were of African indigenous descent.
- 12:36So they knew the struggles of living in essentially a caste system where they
- 12:40weren't afforded the same opportunities.
- 12:42But they also had an incredible ecological, economic and linguistic
- 12:46wherewithal that gave them the capacity to undermine Spanish power.
- 12:52So both Vicente and José Maria Morelos were crucial.
- 12:56And when Morelos was killed, Vicente Guerrero and the sharecropping communities
- 13:02of what's now the coast of Guerrero became the only contingent in all of
- 13:07Spanish America to outlast the Spanish.
- 13:09So let me rewind this back.
- 13:11So the Mexican Independence War lasted from 1810 to 1821.
- 13:16From 1814 to 1821, there was only one contingent that was
- 13:20still fighting the Spanish.
- 13:21So we're talking about all the way from present day Guatemala
- 13:24to almost the top of California.
- 13:26All other contingents had lost.
- 13:28There was one.
- 13:29And that was led by an Afro descendant, Guerrillero, and his Afro
- 13:32descendant Arrieros and sharecroppers.
- 13:34They were able to, through their knowledge of where to hide out, where to get
- 13:38the water--this was guerrilla warfare.
- 13:40And by reading through the mule, you can better understand how
- 13:43they were able to take care of a mule that--say it gets scratched.
- 13:46They would need to know how to heal it if it [got] bit by a snake.
- 13:50You know, I've spent time down there, there are lots of snakes, you know.
- 13:52So you can just kind of read that they were veterinarians, they were
- 13:55blacksmiths, they had to fix their hooves.
- 13:57So you could read so much knowledge.
- 14:00When you're writing environmental history, oftentimes, particularly people
- 14:04that don't have records of themselves; ecology and biology help you write
- 14:08about what had to have happened, what could have happened, what might not have
- 14:13happened, what could not have happened.
- 14:16So I can say this could not have happened in a particular area because
- 14:19I know that that plant doesn't exist.
- 14:24So the environment helps you triangulate possibilities where
- 14:27you otherwise might not understand.
- 14:30A lot of "old back in the day" people used to write through what's called
- 14:33environmental determinism, where they used to write that: oh, Chinese people
- 14:36could only do this because they only had access to this and they didn't
- 14:39have coal or something like that.
- 14:41They created these environmental determining factors, but I am more
- 14:45inspired by writers like Case Watkins who think about "environmental
- 14:48possibilism" like what can we write that was possible or not possible
- 14:52through our understandings of ecology?
- 14:55So the Arrieros helps me better understand how people of African descent helped
- 14:59Mexico become independent when it did, how it did, and largely through
- 15:05their multifaceted forms of knowledge.
- 15:08Right, right.
- 15:09So it's like, it's interesting because again, I'm so used to
- 15:13thinking about archives only in terms of literally what's there, right?
- 15:19And you're talking about things that are not there, but that we
- 15:22still have a pathway like into.
- 15:25And I find that really interesting, but also sort of comforting and
- 15:31settling that nothing is completely gone, if that makes sense?
- 15:37So I guess, when you talk about blackness shaping Spanish conquest
- 15:45of America--that's what you're looking at it through, right?
- 15:47Like through the mules and sort of what's left behind in that story.
- 15:51That's one of many ways that you can do it for sure.
- 15:53And that's how I do it in my region in southern Mexico, which is a
- 15:56distinctly difficult place to kind of narrate histories of blackness across
- 16:01time in a consistent, coherent way.
- 16:03But there's no shortage of ways to narrate the importance of black history
- 16:08or the diaspora across the Americas.
- 16:10I think just plants and biology and ecology are one particular one that's
- 16:14fascinating to me and important to me, and I think resonates a lot with students.
- 16:18And I think it resonates in this moment right now where we're dealing with climate
- 16:21and environmental crisis, and black people are taking the lead around the world
- 16:25on that work, particularly black women.
- 16:26So to me,
- 16:30the timing of it makes a lot of sense.
- 16:32Yeah.
- 16:34It is important.
- 16:35Yeah.
- 16:36So another thing you talk about in the article is that there's this caste system
- 16:40in Mexico that's eventually abolished, but the government rallies around the group
- 16:46that's mixed race Spanish and Indigenous.
- 16:49And the result of that is Mexicans of African descent--that history is obscured.
- 16:57So do you feel like the mule or even biology and ecology, those things
- 17:02that you write about--do you feel like that helps you fill in that void?
- 17:06A little bit.
- 17:06A little bit.
- 17:07There's only so much you can do.
- 17:11As someone who is not Mexican and does not have that ancestry, there's only
- 17:15so much I feel comfortable reading into too much because U.S. Black
- 17:21Americans don't have a monopoly on what blackness is like in the Americas.
- 17:25And there's only so much that just my perspective on
- 17:28blackness can lend itself to.
- 17:29But I would say that from 1829, when Vicente Guerrero abolished slavery--he
- 17:36was the first president of Afro and Indigenous descent in Mexico--to 2020,
- 17:41after decades of local grassroots organizing, between those almost
- 17:46200 years, there was no official demarcation of blackness in Mexico.
- 17:50So in archives unless someone spoke an indigenous language to say Amusco
- 17:57or Tlapanec or Nahua, that might show up as a distinction like this
- 18:00is a Nahuatl speaking Mexican.
- 18:02And that might they might call them then Nahua, right?
- 18:05But a lot of people of African descent that didn't necessarily
- 18:08speak an indigenous language.
- 18:10They weren't necessarily marked as mulatto after 1829.
- 18:12They were just marked as mestizo.
- 18:14So it's really hard to demarcate individual black folks and to isolate what
- 18:21they went through as something distinct.
- 18:24So by looking through the environment and particularly the different types
- 18:28of oil seeds, like sesame that black people worked on it allows me to
- 18:32like triangulate a little bit more.
- 18:34To talk about what people went through at the community level,
- 18:37even if I can't necessarily say that at the individual level, you know,
- 18:41"Danielle" went through this, right?
- 18:43Exactly.
- 18:44You can't get that specific.
- 18:46It's interesting because you said that word: mulatto.
- 18:48And I think people have heard it before, but don't always like know
- 18:52what it means--that someone who's African descent and European descent.
- 18:57But it comes from the word mule, right?
- 18:59They are related.
- 19:00They are related.
- 19:01Absolutely.
- 19:02So just like the first, again, it's this idea of like a
- 19:07labor oriented hybrid, right?
- 19:09That's like it's a hybrid for particular, you know, it's, and how
- 19:14we can understand its capacity to do work or its capacity to think.
- 19:18So there are all these racist, white supremacist ways to define a mulatto
- 19:24as someone that was not as intelligent as a "blanco," but maybe stronger.
- 19:30But not or more intelligent than someone who had even more like a
- 19:35"quadroon" or something like that.
- 19:36They had all these levels to it.
- 19:39And if you look across time, there are a lot of different mules.
- 19:43So the first hybrid that predated the cotton gin was combining--I think I
- 19:50go into the article a little bit--with two cotton spinning technologies to
- 19:54created the mule Jenny, which was this new kind of hybrid technology
- 19:58that could do something faster.
- 20:00So if you look across history, there was a lot of different mules
- 20:04technologies that were essentially just kind of hybrids, if you will.
- 20:08Right.
- 20:10I mean, again, that's like that theme of like language coming back up.
- 20:13But you got to be careful with it because I do think historically white
- 20:17supremacy has used a lot of references to animals to depict black people.
- 20:22There's no shortage of that in the archive.
- 20:24So I do think that scholars have to be careful not to reinforce these kind
- 20:28[s] of associations as they're writing.
- 20:31So again, you have to be careful with the language and show where
- 20:35associations may or may not be.
- 20:37Zora Neale Hurston famously said that black women are the
- 20:39mules of the world, right?
- 20:41But she meant that in a very distinct way, right?
- 20:44She definitely wasn't calling black women mules.
- 20:47So I think there's a fine line of, you know, using the analogy in painting the
- 20:51pictures and showing these connections.
- 20:53But I do think there's a fine line between talking about how animals were
- 20:56treated and how people were treated.
- 20:58Right, we want to definitely approach it with nuance for sure.
- 21:04It makes me think of this other term or phrase that we hear all
- 21:07the time: the 40 acres and a mule.
- 21:10And it's funny, I think I've always understood obviously like the emotional
- 21:13meaning of what that is, but I realized that, it's something I grew up hearing
- 21:19and the thought--I just was like a mule?
- 21:21I don't know, I guess mules are there.
- 21:23I never really understood what mules actually represented to free black
- 21:28people so I'm wondering if we can like talk about that for a little bit.
- 21:34So one again, a lot of it goes back to that first question you mentioned
- 21:39about tensions between the materials that both undermine power and
- 21:46create potential for resistance too.
- 21:49So one of the main reasons why black people had proximity to
- 21:52livestock in general was this racist notion that indigenous
- 21:56people would succumb to diseases.
- 22:00Which has some truth to it.
- 22:02The way diseases spread from Africa and Europe and Asia into the Americas
- 22:07had a lot to do with diseases--zoonotic diseases, essentially that were
- 22:11coming from pigs and horses and cows.
- 22:14But it's still--there was an association that black people weren't succumbing
- 22:18to these diseases in the same way.
- 22:19So similar to like how black people were put in like malarial zones
- 22:22because they didn't think that black people get malaria in the same way.
- 22:28So historically black people were given those tasks as the muleteers And as the
- 22:35cowboys, because they were trusted in a way that indigenous people weren't.
- 22:40Plus, the idea was that indigenous people knew the landscape better, and that you
- 22:44give an indigenous person a horse and they already know where the waterhole [is]
- 22:48, they lived in this place for millennia.
- 22:50Right?
- 22:50So again, I mean, that's just a history of plantations.
- 22:52Plantations work better with labor that's been removed from their home and plants
- 22:57that have been removed from their home.
- 22:59For very different reasons, but for reasons that are very similar, right?
- 23:03So again, this kind of notion, this racist notion controlling the
- 23:08black experience and black bodies led to 200 years later, a really
- 23:13widespread muleteer kind of culture.
- 23:16A lot of places, black people were not allowed to ride horses, but
- 23:20they were allowed to ride mules.
- 23:21That kind of creates an association.
- 23:23And if you go up to in the wake of slavery--you know, Tuskegee,
- 23:28before it became a big agricultural school, it started with a mule.
- 23:31But again, a mule was something that could get a black person out of debt.
- 23:34But it's also something [that] could put a black person in debt.
- 23:36So again, it's a very, very fine line.
- 23:39But because we're in Nick's Orange right now, shout out to Spike Lee
- 23:42because Spike Lee's I believe his movie or film company has been "40
- 23:49acres and a mule" for my whole life.
- 23:51Again, it's a symbol.
- 23:54And, you know, oftentimes it was one of the first things
- 23:57that black people had access to.
- 23:58They might not have owned the land, but they might have owned the mule.
- 24:02And that went a long way.
- 24:04It was never enough.
- 24:05Like I said, it's something that could have put a person in debt as well.
- 24:08But it was, I do think, across the Americas, black people have
- 24:12really, really close associations with these animals that were also
- 24:17part of the plantation landscape.
- 24:19So I want to pick up on something you mentioned earlier.
- 24:21You mentioned sesame plots, right?
- 24:24So who introduced sesame seeds to America?
- 24:31I mean, I think it was a mix of things.
- 24:33I think by and large, sesame is something that's been growing in
- 24:37Western Africa for a long time.
- 24:38So it's one of the plants like hibiscus and okra and millet and oil palm that
- 24:44crossed the Atlantic with enslaved people.
- 24:48Scholars like Judith Kearney have [written in] really, really
- 24:51complicated and beautiful ways, like how this these histories took place.
- 24:56So I think it was probably a mixture of enslaved people
- 25:00bringing things over by themselves.
- 25:02But then also enslavers were invested in their captured labor, and they
- 25:10oftentimes, established plantations in the coast of Africa to feed people.
- 25:16So they were intentional about bringing crops oil palm and sesame
- 25:21on the ships to make sure that people can make it across the ocean.
- 25:26And by no means extended great care or anything along the lines, but
- 25:29basic [ally] , they wanted them for their labor, and they had to both
- 25:32fatten them up and bring them across.
- 25:34So it was definitely a mix.
- 25:36Going back to again this tension right?
- 25:40You go to any community of diaspora be it in Jamaica or Colombia or Cuba, and black
- 25:46people are going to talk about how rice was hidden in hair and brought across.
- 25:51And, you know, Judith Kearney, who writes about that, received a lot of
- 25:55backlash from academics who questioned whether or not there was evidence for
- 26:01that that was undeniable in the archive.
- 26:03And I think, you know, begging the question, if that's what communities
- 26:07believed and if the plants got over here.
- 26:09So it's always a question on who.
- 26:11But I do think that it's important to know that sesame wasn't something
- 26:14that in most places outside of South Carolina planters didn't grow
- 26:19in row crops for commercial value.
- 26:21It was something that enslaved peoples could grow in their dooryard
- 26:24gardens or in their small kind of like provision grounds to feed themselves.
- 26:29And sesame had many, many purposes.
- 26:32So it had spiritual ones--planting it to like ward away bad spirits
- 26:37and things along those lines.
- 26:39So sesame is definitely something that people of African descent planted on their
- 26:44own once in the context of the Americas.
- 26:47So I think they helped the proliferation more than any other community for sure.
- 26:53It's interesting because you mentioned their own plots that they
- 26:57might [have] planted on their own.
- 26:59And I'm curious because you talk about this a lot: how do you look at something
- 27:05like an enslaved persons garden, right?
- 27:08And use that to teach you about how they navigated racism?
- 27:14I mean, a lot of it is for me is asking questions.
- 27:18So one of the things I've been really kind of thinking about quite a bit
- 27:22was if you look at bird feed today, a lot of bird feed has sesame in it.
- 27:27And I kept on finding these records from the early 20th century hunting guides
- 27:32that were talking about finding wild- occurring sesame in Louisiana and South
- 27:36Carolina and North Carolina, because it's where doves and quails concentrated.
- 27:41Because they were hunting these birds.
- 27:43And so it made me want to ask the question: one, how wild occurring
- 27:46is sesame in the Americas?
- 27:48Because sesame doesn't grow here.
- 27:50So like one: could you map out plantation zones or plot spaces through what they're
- 27:56calling wild-occurring sesame seeds?
- 27:59And then two: if sesame attracted edible birds, is it possible that
- 28:05sesame wasn't just good luck?
- 28:07It actually brought more calories to the life of enslaved peoples.
- 28:13Now do I or will I know this?
- 28:14No.
- 28:14Is there archaeology that's being done now and trying to understand
- 28:19looking at the types of bird fragments and bones that are around plots?
- 28:23Absolutely.
- 28:23So I do think as the records and the studies get thicker and thicker and
- 28:29thicker, it gets easier to do comparative work and build off other people's work.
- 28:35I even have a colleague at my university that does a lot of
- 28:38archaeological work around bones and former plots to understand the
- 28:42meat that enslaved people consumed.
- 28:45So I do think there are ways.
- 28:48It's just starting by asking these questions because every generation of
- 28:51scholar gets to ask questions together to improve what questions we ask.
- 28:56So that's kind of where I'm at--a very preliminary stage.
- 28:59But sesame in Mexico very much follows a different kind of trajectory,
- 29:04as it does in the United States.
- 29:07Okay, so I'm going to shift us a little bit or maybe a lot actually,
- 29:11given where we're going next.
- 29:13I want to talk about arsenic.
- 29:16Arsenic is definitely the one of these three that I've studied
- 29:19the longest and most closely.
- 29:20Oh, good.
- 29:21I'm excited.
- 29:22So we know it's an element on the periodic table.
- 29:25It occurs naturally, which I think is sort of surprising for a lot of
- 29:29people because it's famously a poison.
- 29:32It kind of seems like it's something that would be made, but it's not made.
- 29:37So what drew you to arsenic?
- 29:39Well, I think I knew I wanted to study pesticides because another
- 29:43one of my dad's brothers passed away because of Agent Orange complications.
- 29:47And Agent Orange was one of many rainbow chemicals that we use to
- 29:52fight in quotations in Vietnam.
- 29:54And I think Agent Blue and Agent White were all derivatives of
- 29:57arsenic, so there were other agents and they were arsenic-based.
- 30:02And arsenic to me,
- 30:06it kept on coming up.
- 30:08So my PhD is in Mexican history--Mexican agriculture in particular.
- 30:12And we talk about the green revolution in the United States.
- 30:16And it was kind of the way the United States spread a postwar, Cold War way
- 30:21of capital-intensive, chemical-intensive agriculture to demonstrate to
- 30:25developing countries if they were between communism and capitalism,
- 30:29that we can make sure you stay full.
- 30:31So the whole idea of the Green Revolution has nothing to do with photosynthesis or
- 30:36chlorophyll or green things associated with plants and had everything to do in
- 30:39contrast with the red of the Soviet Union.
- 30:43I argue in a lot of my work that the Green Revolution's origin is in Mexico, because
- 30:48it was very much a US-Mexico project that started in 1943 in the Pacific coast.
- 30:52Mexico had everything to do with long-standing relations between the United
- 30:54States and Mexico through arsenic, because arsenic is naturally occurring, but
- 30:59it's usually pretty faraway from people.
- 31:01So how it's brought into people's lives is oftentimes as a byproduct of mining.
- 31:05So as we started to expand copper mining and silver mining in the American West
- 31:10and down in Mexico, and we were burning off the ore… Because as our technology
- 31:14has gotten better and we can get deeper and deeper and deeper into mountains,
- 31:17we're getting ore that has a has less and less concentration of what we want.
- 31:21So as a higher and higher concentration of things, we have to burn off.
- 31:24So as the technology gets better to get deeper into mountains, we're getting
- 31:27more toxins that we're actually burning off as we're smelting them, right?
- 31:32And that kind of created a problem because everything
- 31:35around these smelters was dying.
- 31:37People talk about Theodore Roosevelt all the time and his national parks.
- 31:41And I'm not getting into those because those things were racist and violent.
- 31:45But he did one thing that was interesting: he forced mining companies to actually
- 31:48capture their sulfur and their arsenic in like 1907, 1909, to stop it [from] killing
- 31:54surrounding farms, livestock, and plants.
- 31:57And it wasn't until World War I that really became clear.
- 32:04And Adam Romero writes about this.
- 32:06I'm very grateful I just got to publish with him about how people realize
- 32:11that arsenic didn't just kill things, but it could also be bio selective.
- 32:14So you can bio-selectively choose what you want to kill.
- 32:17In many ways that's what agriculture is.
- 32:19It's a simplified landscape that says that we don't want these weeds to live.
- 32:23We want these plants to live.
- 32:24We don't want those trees to live.
- 32:26We don't want that to get water.
- 32:27We want the water to come here.
- 32:28Like everything about agriculture is a simplified landscape
- 32:30of necropolitics essentially saying what lives and what dies.
- 32:34And to some extent, arsenic becomes this first kind of
- 32:38byproduct that becomes a product.
- 32:40And by and large--actually, I remember talking about this here in this building
- 32:44at a huge science conference with science industry: is that the whole chemical
- 32:48industry in the United States is all turning byproducts into commodities.
- 32:52Because when you're making a chemical, you're oftentimes your byproduct.
- 32:55Are these really harmful chemicals that have nuance value or nuisance value?
- 32:59Excuse me.
- 33:00They're essentially these big, toxic, harmful things that you either need
- 33:03to hold on to and store separate from everything else, or you find a place
- 33:07to put it and make money from it.
- 33:08So if you hold on to it, it costs you money.
- 33:11If you sell it, it makes you money.
- 33:13So it has double-money of selling it, right?
- 33:15So arsenic became this kind of byproduct that made double value
- 33:19by getting rid of it and kind of sinking it into agriculture.
- 33:22So agriculture became a sink through which we dumped our chemical wastes.
- 33:26And we still do this.
- 33:27Agriculture is still a huge sink through which we dump chemicals.
- 33:30So arsenic was kind of the first one that helped me narrate why the Green
- 33:34Revolution started in Mexico when it did, how it did, and how agriculture became
- 33:39an extension of US mining and expansion.
- 33:43I guess that makes me ask, really, what is agrochemical racism?
- 33:49Because you write about this.
- 33:51How does arsenic tie into that and help shape agriculture in the US?
- 33:57Well, one, I think it starts the precedent of agriculture being a place where farm
- 34:02labor are going to be exposed to harm.
- 34:06So historically, agricultural labor has been exposed to harm as enslaved
- 34:09people or as indentured servants or as just undervalued laborers.
- 34:15But with the rise of chemical-intensive agriculture, it became clear
- 34:19that some people are going to just be exposed to harm.
- 34:22Through chemical harm.
- 34:23And arsenic kind of set that tone.
- 34:26And so in the wake of enslavement in the US South, cotton was kind
- 34:30of the first big guzzler of arsenic because arsenic is still--for the
- 34:35first part of its history--it's still what's called phytotoxic.
- 34:38So in the sense that it still harms the vegetation it touches, and it took
- 34:42awhile for them to create a delayed mechanism through lead to connect to
- 34:46arsenic so the release of the toxin didn't happen when it touched the plant.
- 34:50But it happened when it was chewed by an insect and it released their
- 34:53stomach and then it released.
- 34:55And that's called a delayed, you know, when you take an aspirin?
- 34:58And the release is delayed so it doesn't hit you all at once, but it delays
- 35:01over a course of like four hours?
- 35:03That was kind of started with arsenic to create something that was phytotoxic
- 35:07through the combination of another chemical to like delay its reaction.
- 35:12But initially for the first 30 years,
- 35:18not just the USDA, but farmers in general are trying to teach formerly
- 35:22enslaved Africans and sharecroppers how to use arsenic to now catch boll weevil.
- 35:27Which was a huge agricultural pest that came from Mexico.
- 35:31There was all racism there about it coming from Mexico.
- 35:34And it's an immigrant creating all these problems.
- 35:36But no longer did you have enslaved people to pick off all the bugs or chop down
- 35:41new trees to create new plantation land.
- 35:43They had to reckon with how to one resuscitate exhausted
- 35:47soils through fertilizers.
- 35:49And two: cotton.
- 35:51It simplified agriculture in a way that attracted a lot of pests so they had
- 35:55to figure out how to reckon with that.
- 35:56And black people were some of the first to do that.
- 35:58So in the 1920s, Bryan Williams writes about this--about how USDA
- 36:04puts out films on how to train black people to use arsenic.
- 36:08And before that, you had some planters that were elected officials that got young
- 36:14black children with molasses combined with arsenic to go and pick up bugs by hand.
- 36:20But then you see anti-Blackness figure into the narratives around whether
- 36:27or not you could even trust black people to use arsenic or whether they
- 36:29hurt themselves or harm each other or harm white people--consumers.
- 36:34And interestingly enough, there was a company in the 1920s, 1924 in particular
- 36:40called Huff-Daland that became a crop dusting company because it tried to
- 36:46teach farmers: don't worry about training black people and using mules to spread
- 36:51arsenic across your cotton fields when you could just hire an airplane to do it.
- 36:55So Huff-Dahlan became a big crop duster traveling around the south, eventually
- 37:01getting hired by California cotton growers to go into Mexico and the same
- 37:06places where the Green Revolution started and experiment with cotton and arsenic.
- 37:10And then they went to Peru by invitation in 1927.
- 37:13So Huff-Dahlan from 1924 to 1927 is making this whole tour across country.
- 37:19I don't know exactly when they changed their name, but today we
- 37:21call this company Delta Airlines.
- 37:24So the term "delta" actually comes from their relationship
- 37:27with working in the Delta.
- 37:30And within these landscapes of racially-divided labor and
- 37:35they used arguments like: why train black people to do this?
- 37:39Why even feed them to do this?
- 37:40They used this kind of language of anti-Blackness to say: you can move beyond
- 37:44that and use arsenic in a different way.
- 37:49We talk a lot about how the cotton harvester--the mechanical
- 37:52harvester--displaced a lot of cotton sharecroppers, right?
- 37:56And it was a big component of the Great Migration.
- 37:59But if you look at those records, you also see people feeling like they
- 38:02were displaced by these airplanes.
- 38:05So black people became a fixture within this agrochemical kind of divide.
- 38:11And to this day, people of African descent, particularly in this unit
- 38:16in the United States, Guatemalan and Mexicans are exposed to harmful
- 38:21chemicals at a much higher rate.
- 38:23And if you look around the world, I think it's tens of thousands of people
- 38:26commit suicide every year through their own pesticides because of the debt
- 38:30that they're in, through pesticides and the exposure that they have.
- 38:32So there's still a very racialized divide between who
- 38:36gets harmed by these chemicals.
- 38:38And I think a lot of that starts with arsenic.
- 38:39And the last thing I'll say on this is, you know, today when you go out into
- 38:42agricultural field, there are hundreds of different agrochemicals being used.
- 38:47And starting in the 40s, you had the rise of DDT and other organochlorines, which
- 38:51were a type of neurotoxin that instead of hurting a bug through contact, it
- 38:57actually neurologically impacted them.
- 39:00And you start seeing a shift from organochlorines to organophosphates.
- 39:04But now you have so many different generations of chemicals, right?
- 39:08But between the 1870 and 1930, you really only have one.
- 39:13You only have one chemical that's really establishing, by and large the
- 39:17precedence for what the agrochemical industry is going to look like.
- 39:19And that's arsenic.
- 39:20So that's why I really focus on that period.
- 39:24It's such this dominant thing in a way that, again, is not
- 39:29something we like talk about a lot.
- 39:34So I'm interested in this idea.
- 39:38You were talking about the boll weevil and it feels like it's
- 39:42part of this cycle of blame.
- 39:45But I'm curious because the arsenic that they were using to kill the boll
- 39:50weevil was coming from Mexico, right?
- 39:54But at the same time, they were also insisting that this was a Mexican problem.
- 39:59And that's how it was coming to us.
- 40:01So is that more of just that tension, that cycle of: it will
- 40:05be someone's fault, but not ours?
- 40:09It still exists today.
- 40:11There's a divide between places that produce raw materials and
- 40:14places that manufacture them.
- 40:16And I still think there was that idea that even if people knew that raw
- 40:20arsenic--white arsenic--was coming from Mexico, what they saw as the new lead
- 40:24arsenic and the calcium arsenates that were being used against boll weevil
- 40:28were something that was modern, didn't necessarily come from the mountain.
- 40:31And even if they did, they would maybe think that, well, the United
- 40:34States owned the mining industries in the first place that were
- 40:37driving it out and smelting it out.
- 40:38So again, I just think that there was a lot of ethnocentric notions
- 40:43around and we still have this.
- 40:44We use terms like the "global North" and "global South" and "developing countries"
- 40:48and "undeveloped countries." We still have these kind of temporal ways of talking
- 40:54about places like we're not all in 2026.
- 40:57And we don't often situate our understanding that the modern
- 41:01is literally filled with what we might think are un-modern.
- 41:07Violences is still.
- 41:09There's still child slavery right now.
- 41:10There's still all these things that are, you know, our modern world
- 41:13is a gilded un-modern one, right?
- 41:16And I think we don't always acknowledge that.
- 41:19So there was tons of blame.
- 41:22So once the US kind of loses its dominance around cotton and especially around the
- 41:30racialized labor for cotton in the US South, cotton producers in the South start
- 41:34spreading cotton production throughout Texas and eventually into northern Mexico.
- 41:38And it's through northern Mexico that the cotton boll weevil, which
- 41:41is originally from Mexico, is able to move from cotton plantations
- 41:45that the United States planters established up into the United States.
- 41:49So it had everything to do with the expansion of cotton
- 41:53plantations in the wake of slavery.
- 41:56But they didn't blame themselves for that.
- 41:59They created these images of a Mexican immigrant who crossed the border and had
- 42:05millions of cotton boll weevil children.
- 42:07They used this violent, anti-immigrant, anti-Mexican language.
- 42:11That is not that different than what you see today.
- 42:15So I am curious because you write for Distillations magazine.
- 42:19You've written some really great articles and we've been talking about insecticides.
- 42:24But you have written about fertilizers in a way that's actually
- 42:27very local here to Philadelphia.
- 42:29So can you talk to us for a second about that story?
- 42:32Yeah.
- 42:33So I wrote about Porgy.
- 42:34Anybody from Philly who've been to either Acme or Shoprite,
- 42:38you've probably gotten Porgy Fish.
- 42:41And that word actually comes from Narragansett word pokagon, which means
- 42:47I believe it's "oily fish" or "fish with many bones." But essentially porgy
- 42:51was a fish that was used to fertilize fields because they multiply in such
- 42:56masses on the eastern seaboard and estuaries, and they can be caught in mass.
- 43:01They're really easy to catch and they're kind of thrown out.
- 43:04And so interestingly enough, a lot of the early big fertilizer industries
- 43:08coming out of first New England and eventually down to South Carolina--have
- 43:13you ever heard of fish guano?
- 43:16That was mostly Porgy.
- 43:19And here in Philly it's a really popular fish, particularly in the black community.
- 43:24And it's also not a very expensive fish.
- 43:25So it's one of those kinds of foods like oysters and lobster [that] went
- 43:29from food for enslaved people and indigenous communities and was kind
- 43:34of frowned upon by white community.
- 43:36And now it's something that everyone eats.
- 43:39But my grandfather, who would have turned 100 next month, lived most
- 43:44of his life in Philadelphia when he worked for the Nation of Islam.
- 43:52The Nation of Islam used to have these fish trucks that used to
- 43:55sell Porgy in the community.
- 43:56And once he retired, he would get black men together to go out fishing together
- 44:02in either Atlantic City or Cape Cod.
- 44:05And what they would do is they would bring all their sons and nieces and nephews
- 44:11with these coolers, and we'd go out and we'd catch as many Porgy as possible.
- 44:15And they would then sell those fish as hacks.
- 44:18So my grandfather used to sit outside of Shoprite before Uber and Lyft.
- 44:23And when people would take public transportation to the grocery store,
- 44:26but didn't want to like take public transportation with all the grocery stores
- 44:28back home, he would drive them home.
- 44:30But he would always tell people: hey, I got you some Porgy.
- 44:32I got Porgy, and the fish.
- 44:33Already cleaned them.
- 44:34I got Porgy in the car.
- 44:36You don't have to go buy that, I got you.
- 44:39So he was a fish hack.
- 44:41So that was kind of how I wrote about him here.
- 44:45And it was really cool to have my first piece for Distillations that's rooted
- 44:51here in Philly to be about my grandfather.
- 44:55Look at that.
- 44:55You did it.
- 44:57You survived.
- 44:59Yep.
- 45:00Thank you so much.
- 45:05Distillations podcast is produced by the Science History Institute
- 45:10and recorded in the Laurie J. Landau Digital Production Studios.
- 45:14Our executive producer is Mariel Carr.
- 45:17Our senior producer is Rigoberto Hernandez.
- 45:20This episode was produced by Mariel Carr.
- 45:23It was fact checked by Alexandra Atiya, and the sound design
- 45:27was done by Samia Bouzid.
- 45:31Support for Distillations has been provided by the Middleton Foundation
- 45:35and the Wyncote Foundation.
- 45:37You can find all of our podcasts, as well as our videos and articles on
- 45:41our website at sciencehistory.org.
- 45:44And you can follow us on social media at @scihistoryorg for news about our
- 45:49podcast and everything else going on in our free museum and library.
- 45:54For Distillations, I'm Alexis Pedrick.
- 45:57Thanks for listening.