Latest / Distillations | Science History Institute / Chasing Shiny Things
Transcript
- 0:04From the Science History Institute, I'm Alexis Pedrick and this is
- 0:08Distillations, American Vice: Risk, Science, and the American Experience.
- 0:16Last year, our senior producer, Rigoberto Hernandez, found himself gambling–kind of.
- 0:23Here to tell us about it is Rigo himself.
- 0:26Hi, Rigo.
- 0:27Hi, Alexis.
- 0:28So tell me where this all started for you.
- 0:32Yeah.
- 0:32So this all started when I bought a shiny thing.
- 0:36A shiny thing?
- 0:38Yes, a bar of silver from the internet.
- 0:42Oh, boy.
- 0:44It was kind of nerve-racking.
- 0:45I did read up on reputable sources, but I was kind of taking a leap of faith.
- 0:50Anyway, I ordered ten ounces of silver for $325, and a couple
- 0:56of weeks later, a small, regular looking package arrived at my house.
- 1:01I opened it up and it was this little silver rectangle.
- 1:05It weighed more than a smartphone, but less than a brick for sure.
- 1:09And I just put it on my desk drawer and I didn't think about it for eight months.
- 1:17I feel like we need to back up.
- 1:19Why did you order the silver in the first place?
- 1:22Wait.
- 1:23First of all, you can just buy silver on the internet?
- 1:26And it was just in your desk drawer?
- 1:28Was it–you know what?
- 1:31I feel like this is going to be a long story, and I think you
- 1:35should just take it from here.
- 1:38I bought that bar of silver in a state of panic.
- 1:41It was April 2025, and Trump had just announced new tariffs.
- 1:45…Breaking news on another brutal day on Wall Street.
- 1:49Stocks tumbling across the board.
- 1:50If you have a 401k, if you have a pension, bad day to look at it.
- 1:54An even worse day.
- 1:55If you're trying to sell investments to buy a house in the coming weeks.
- 1:58There's very real concern this will drive up inflation, especially
- 2:02when it comes to cars and foods…
- 2:06I was worried about inflation, about groceries costing more, and I was
- 2:10looking for somewhere safe to park my money and also maybe make some money.
- 2:16I realized I wasn't alone.
- 2:18I stumbled into a whole subculture of silver buyers, sellers, and stackers
- 2:23who had the same hopes and anxieties.
- 2:25Now that I was in the silver business.
- 2:27It made sense to talk to the pros.
- 2:33A local coin shop became my gateway into that world.
- 2:37My name is Andrew Edelman and I am the owner of Edelman's
- 2:40Coins here in Jenkintown.
- 2:42Jenkintown is a suburb just north of Philadelphia.
- 2:45So this year we are celebrating our 100th year in business.
- 2:48Family owned for all 100 years.
- 2:50We started out in a pawnshop actually in West Philly, and we
- 2:54moved here to Jenkintown in 1966.
- 2:58Nowadays, the store is packed to the brim with silver kitchen utensils, gold
- 3:02and silver bars on display cases and art depicting different kinds of currencies.
- 3:07It feels lived in, but not cluttered.
- 3:11…Collectible coins.
- 3:12A lot of silver bullion…
- 3:14That's just when pure silver is pressed into a bar or a coin.
- 3:17In the last couple of years, selling silver is a really
- 3:20big part of our business.
- 3:22So we have trays with 100 different silver products, bars of all different sizes.
- 3:28The main showcases…
- 3:29Andrew Edelman meets a lot of people like me who invest money in silver.
- 3:33I told him what brought me into his store in the first place.
- 3:37Rigoberto Hernandez, on tape: And so then I noticed that the price of the dollar
- 3:40was going down, and then I saw that metals were rising, specifically gold.
- 3:45But I was like, I can't buy gold.
- 3:47It's like $4,000.
- 3:49So then silver look [ed] attractive.
- 3:52Andrew told me that he agrees.
- 3:54When you buy an ounce of silver or like a 100 ounce silver bar, it's not like
- 4:01going out and eating a really fancy meal where you spend all this money and
- 4:05then you are left with an empty plate.
- 4:07It's a good place to have a lot of your wealth just parked there.
- 4:12It has shown over time to be a good, safe, conservative investment.
- 4:18This was my plan too, to put the bar of silver in my desk drawer and
- 4:22leave it there until who knows when.
- 4:24But then something happened.
- 4:26David Brancaccio, Marketplace: Silver hit an all time high last week, and
- 4:28it's gone up more than gold this year.
- 4:31When I bought my silver, it was $33 an ounce, but the price kept going up.
- 4:37I hadn't planned on selling so quickly.
- 4:39It was supposed to be a conservative investment, right?
- 4:42A place to park my money.
- 4:44But I got a little obsessive, and I found myself checking the price of silver,
- 4:49sometimes up to three times a day.
- 4:51Each time the price went up, I got a little dopamine hit.
- 4:55I imagine this is how gambling feels.
- 4:58By early December, silver was $60 an ounce.
- 5:01So eight months after I got it, I took my bar out of the drawer and
- 5:05went to Edelman's Coins to sell it.
- 5:09When I got there, the phones were ringing off the hook.
- 5:12There was literally a line out the door.
- 5:14People wanting to sell silver.
- 5:16From the months of October 2025 to February 2026.
- 5:21We had many, many days where there was never a break.
- 5:25Where it was constantly busy the entire day from open to close.
- 5:30And that was not normal.
- 5:32I don't know if I'll ever be quite that busy again.
- 5:37I sold my silver bar for almost $600.
- 5:40I made $275 and I was elated.
- 5:43I went right to the Jenkintown Trader Joe's, and I bought
- 5:46groceries for the week: Korean fried rice, buffalo-style popcorn.
- 5:51Hell, I even bought ground beef.
- 5:53Rigoberto Hernandez, on tape: I was like, wow.
- 5:54I never win at investments.
- 5:56This is me telling Andrew how exciting it was.
- 5:59Rigoberto Hernandez, on tape: But then it's weird because it's like,
- 6:00oh, the reason why I'm winning is because the price is…This is not
- 6:04a good reason why I'm winning.
- 6:07The reason the cost of silver spiked was that the dollar was losing even
- 6:10more value and inflation was going up.
- 6:13It was good for me and my Trader Joe's shopping spree.
- 6:16But big picture, it was a bad indicator.
- 6:20When things are crazy around the world, honestly, when things are
- 6:23bad around the world, business for us is oftentimes really good.
- 6:28I'm like a normal, caring person.
- 6:31I would rather the world be really good and very peaceful and people prospering
- 6:36all over the world and me be not quite as busy because I'll be just fine, right?
- 6:41And so I do feel conflicted when there's a war in Ukraine and a war
- 6:46in Iran and mass tariffs hurting lots and lots of people where I am
- 6:52really busy and benefiting from that.
- 6:56I could have ended my silver journey here, but I work for a history
- 6:59of science podcast and I have a habit of bringing my work home.
- 7:03Of asking questions like: how long have people been pinning their hopes on silver,
- 7:08and how does this connect to the ways that we're thinking about risk this season?
- 7:12And how does science fit in?
- 7:14Where did we first find silver and how did we get it out of the ground?
- 7:18Does silver have any practical uses that made it valuable, or
- 7:22did we just decide it's special because it's shiny and pretty?
- 7:27I learned a lot of things like how Nevada got its nickname as the Silver
- 7:31State, how The Wizard of Oz might have actually been a hidden story about
- 7:35money, and how a trio of billionaire brothers managed to control more than
- 7:40a third of the world's silver supply.
- 7:42I went down a bunch of rabbit holes and they took me in
- 7:45some unexpected directions.
- 7:50The Goldilocks Metal
- 7:56Silver is number 47 on the periodic table.
- 7:59AG.
- 8:00Right smack in the middle, one row above gold.
- 8:03It's a highly malleable metal.
- 8:05It's also resistant to corrosion, which is why it's been used for thousands of years
- 8:09to make jewelry, utensils, and coins.
- 8:12This is Andrew Edelman again.
- 8:14You know, in ancient Greece, they were using gold as the highest
- 8:19denomination of their coinage, followed by the silver coins.
- 8:23And then the third most was the copper and the bronze coins, because they
- 8:27realized even in 500 B.C. that the earth does not have many of these metals.
- 8:34Mining is a one off.
- 8:36You dig in the ground and you find so much silver, and once it's
- 8:40taken out of the ground, that's it.
- 8:42There's no more there.
- 8:43This is Kris Lane, the author of Potosi: The Silver City that Changed the World.
- 8:48Silver has always kind of been in that sweet spot between gold and copper, that
- 8:52it's just rare enough, but not too rare.
- 8:55Could gold have played that role?
- 8:58Probably not.
- 8:59Simply because it's rarer in Earth's crust.
- 9:03Historically, the largest deposits of silver in the world have been
- 9:07in Bolivia and in central Mexico.
- 9:09The chemistry of the underlying crust allowed for high concentrations of silver
- 9:16minerals, some gold as well, but silver in particular, to be more abundant in
- 9:22parts of the Americas and easier to refine than in any other part of the world.
- 9:28So what's special about these places?
- 9:31The short version is that it's a place where there's a lot of
- 9:34connection between the deep parts of the earth and the surface.
- 9:39Eric Nystrom is a historian at the University of Nevada, Reno.
- 9:42So it's not quite volcanoes, although there's maybe some of that,
- 9:46but it's more like hot springs.
- 9:48And these hot springs carry minerals up from deep below the Earth's crust.
- 9:52And they sort of work their way through the cracks in the rock.
- 9:56Well, it helps if the rocks have been, you know, cracked.
- 9:59Obviously faults and things like that.
- 10:04All that shaking brings minerals to the surface, and the places with the most
- 10:08silver also have a lot of earthquakes.
- 10:10The silver in Bolivia and Mexico is also more pure than other parts of the world.
- 10:15So you do have silver deposits in Central Europe, China, and even India.
- 10:19Kris Lane again.
- 10:20But they're usually locked up in sulfur minerals and other
- 10:24compounds with arsenic and antimony.
- 10:27These are elements that, when you add them in a deposit, make it very
- 10:31difficult to get the silver out.
- 10:36In the United States, the realization that the earth has only so much silver
- 10:40drove the same kind of rush that gold did, but it didn't happen in California.
- 10:45It happened in the Silver Hills of Nevada, and it involved a man with
- 10:49a giant ego and a crazy nickname.
- 10:56A Man Called Pancake
- 10:59On the 8th of June, 1859, two prospectors uncovered the rich deposits of ore
- 11:05that changed the destiny of the small settlement and of the state.
- 11:10And it was because of discoveries such as this that Nevada got
- 11:14its nickname, the Silver State.
- 11:17Here's how it happened.
- 11:20In the early days of the California Gold Rush, miners imagined that
- 11:24maybe there would be sort of a heart of gold in the mountain.
- 11:29This is Eric Nystrom again.
- 11:31Like the caramel at the center of a candy or something like that.
- 11:34And from that heart was where all this eroded gold might come from.
- 11:39It's that concept, actually, that gives us the name of the “mother lode” where
- 11:43the California Gold Rush took place.
- 11:46You've probably seen all the photographs from the California Gold Rush.
- 11:50Bushy bearded men panning for gold in riverbeds, waiting for
- 11:54gold flakes to reveal themselves.
- 11:56That's called placer mining, where the gold eroded out of the rock and it appears
- 12:02like Fruity Pebbles in your cereal.
- 12:05But this is not usually how silver mining goes, at least not in Nevada.
- 12:09Once in a while it looks like that.
- 12:10But most of the time it's trapped in that rock.
- 12:13Where we would imagine that gold sort of looks shiny, there's something
- 12:17attractive about it if you see it there, silver doesn't work like that.
- 12:20Silver oxidizes readily in the presence of the air.
- 12:24So at best it looks kind of dull gray, but it can also look sort of bluish.
- 12:30It can look almost black, depending on what other minerals
- 12:33it's combined with at the time.
- 12:36That was the reality that gold prospectors were walking into when they arrived in a
- 12:39place we now call Virginia City, which is about 35 miles outside of Reno, Nevada.
- 12:45They were looking for gold and were totally unaware of the silver
- 12:48fortunes underneath their feet.
- 12:51That is, until 1859, when they found something promising.
- 12:56In a place called Gold Canyon.
- 12:58They worked their way up these little ravines and eventually found
- 13:00a hill that seemed to be eroding out quite a lot of gold in it.
- 13:04And so they staked claims on this hill, which eventually was called Gold Hill.
- 13:13There they met a Canadian miner named Henry Comstock, who people call “Pancake.”
- 13:18Because he was too lazy to make bread.
- 13:20He would just make pancakes instead.
- 13:23America's relationship with silver started with this man, Pancake.
- 13:28He was maybe a little mentally unstable, according to folks who knew him.
- 13:33And he was kind of a little bit of a bully, a little bit of a braggart, right?
- 13:37He was the best and he was the “this” and he was the “that.”
- 13:43So when Pancake saw the two prospectors, he lived up to his
- 13:47reputation and confronted them.
- 13:49Comstock came rushing up the canyon and said: oh, oh, oh oh,
- 13:52this is--I've claimed this spring.
- 13:53This belongs to me.
- 13:54I've got a ranch.
- 13:57This scene is actually depicted in the classic Western show called Bonanza.
- 14:09Greetings, gentlemen.
- 14:10Henry T.P. Comstock brings you greetings and salutations.
- 14:14Did you gentlemen file a legal claim for this particular piece of land?
- 14:18Legal claim?
- 14:19What kind of a question is that?
- 14:21A simple enough question, friend.
- 14:23You didn't file a claim.
- 14:23You're trespassing on my property.
- 14:26I'm requesting you to move on.
- 14:27Oh, Mr. Comstock, you can't do a thing like that.
- 14:30You only just got here.
- 14:31Son, the law's the law.
- 14:33The law says a man don't file a claim.
- 14:35He ain't got any more right than a tinker.
- 14:36Now, you Wait a minute.
- 14:38You just wait a minute.
- 14:39So he was pushy and he said, you need to cut me in on this discovery.
- 14:44So maybe you're wondering why this Pancake guy was able to lie about
- 14:48owning land and get away with it.
- 14:51Well, the reason was that there were no rules.
- 14:54What I've been calling Nevada was not an official state yet.
- 14:58In 1859, the territory had been part of the US for about a decade,
- 15:02after the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo ended the war with Mexico.
- 15:06Technically, it was part of the Utah Territory, but it was so far away from the
- 15:10seat of power in Salt Lake City that there wasn't really a functional government.
- 15:15They basically said that there's not law in this area.
- 15:18We will form our own.
- 15:19Think of it as little democracies and they would have meetings and write up rules.
- 15:25Most of the rules were about who could claim what.
- 15:29And this worked for a while, because for a long time there
- 15:32wasn't much there people wanted.
- 15:34There was nothing there.
- 15:35Nothing at all prior to the discovery of the mines.
- 15:38And so then Comstock sold his part of it pretty early, but he
- 15:42stuck around for a few years.
- 15:44And he would tell anyone who might listen, and plenty of people who didn't
- 15:47listen: he was the one who discovered it.
- 15:50It was due to his genius, and he deserved the credit.
- 15:54And so enough, people who didn't really know all the backstory heard that, and it
- 15:59was eventually called the Comstock Lode.
- 16:03This mine would become the biggest discovery of silver in America.
- 16:07It transformed the state and the region.
- 16:10Virginia City was created by and for the mines.
- 16:13The real peak is with the discovery of the big Bonanza,
- 16:19which was found in the consolidated Virginia and the California
- 16:23mines, and that was found in 1873.
- 16:28And really it lasted for almost nine years, that part of the lode.
- 16:32Virginia City didn't exist before the discovery of the Comstock Lode.
- 16:37Within a few years, it had a population of 4000, and within a decade it
- 16:42had ballooned to more than 25,000.
- 16:45Many of the people it attracted were immigrants looking to work in the mines.
- 16:49You had a tremendous number of foreign-born in the early
- 16:53part of the Comstock history.
- 16:56In the 1860s, something like a third of the population was
- 17:00born outside the United States.
- 17:03And then by the height of the Comstock in the 1870s, some estimates suggest that it
- 17:09was almost two thirds of the population was not born in the United States.
- 17:13The biggest ethnic groups were from Ireland and from a part of England
- 17:18called Cornwall, which had a long history of underground mining.
- 17:22So they had skills and they were really prized by the mines.
- 17:27But they weren't the ones getting rich.
- 17:30Most of the capital that was available to invest in these
- 17:33mines came from San Francisco.
- 17:36So there's a long-standing understanding that the Comstock
- 17:39really built San Francisco.
- 17:42California investors acted like the venture capitalists of their day.
- 17:45Even if no one used that term back then.
- 17:48Some of them got rich from the 1848 California Gold Rush.
- 17:51Others were merchants or bankers.
- 17:53Remember, San Francisco was the economic engine of the West.
- 17:57By this point they were flush with cash.
- 18:00These investors would front money to the mining companies.
- 18:03If the company struck gold, or silver rather, then they reap the profits.
- 18:09But when things didn't go well, they had to fund the companies so
- 18:12they could survive and try again.
- 18:14Sometimes it paid off, sometimes it didn't.
- 18:21If you wanted to invest in the companies that owned these mines, you had a
- 18:25difficult time figuring out who you could trust to give you an honest assessment
- 18:29of what was going on with the mine.
- 18:31And a lot of stockbrokers took advantage of that.
- 18:34They might claim to own ground right next to a famous mine, but that
- 18:38didn't necessarily mean anything.
- 18:40The fact is that the Comstock lode, the mineralization, was uneven.
- 18:46It was chocolate chips.
- 18:48It wasn't a chocolate cake.
- 18:50You could have a really rich, productive mine located right next door to a
- 18:56piece of ground that was worth nothing whatsoever except for on the stock market.
- 18:59And they would sell this really worthless stock.
- 19:04And this really gets to the heart of it.
- 19:06Mining towns are about hope and hype.
- 19:09This is Kris Lane again.
- 19:11There's just enough hope that we can do this.
- 19:14But we need the hype or else we won't make that extra jump.
- 19:17Eventually, the whole thing started slowing down.
- 19:20By 1878, there was hardly any aura left.
- 19:23Because remember, silver is a finite resource.
- 19:27It doesn't matter whether that was 150 years ago.
- 19:29Or if that's yesterday.
- 19:31You can't grow more ore.
- 19:33So these mines simply got worked out.
- 19:35And so eventually Virginia City declined permanently.
- 19:38The mining never completely disappears.
- 19:40But it's nothing at all like it once was.
- 19:43The Comstock Lode Bonanza reminded me about my own silver speculation journey
- 19:48when I saw my bar for a nifty $275 profit.
- 19:52I felt like a financial genius.
- 19:55I felt like I was capitalizing on hype, but this wasn't new.
- 19:59160 years ago, more than 20,000 people felt it too, and they chased
- 20:04the hype to the mountains of Nevada.
- 20:06And it wasn't just miners who pinned their hopes on silver.
- 20:09Farmers and industrial workers also chased silver down a yellow brick road.
- 20:18The Wonderful Wizard of Oz
- 20:26One of my favorite discoveries I made in the Silver Rabbit hole is its
- 20:29connection to an iconic American film.
- 20:32Toto, I've a feeling we're not in Kansas anymore.
- 20:37The Wizard of Oz has inspired countless Dorothy costumes, a gingham blue
- 20:41dress, a picnic basket, and a tiny dog.
- 20:45Aren't you forgetting the ruby slippers?
- 20:47The slippers?
- 20:48Yes.
- 20:58The slippers.
- 20:59But in the 1900 book that the film was based on, Dorothy's
- 21:01slippers are silver, not Ruby.
- 21:03The Wizard of Oz was one of the first color films so it makes sense that
- 21:08they went with red, sparkly shoes that would look great on screen.
- 21:12But the shoes might have been silver in the book for a reason.
- 21:15One theory, created by a former high school history teacher named
- 21:18Henry Littlefield, argued that the book's author, L. Frank Baum, was
- 21:22selling a story about money and class struggle in the late 1800s.
- 21:25Henry Littlefield published an essay in 1964 called “The Wizard
- 21:31of Oz Parable on Populism.”
- 21:34This is Mitch Sanders, a coin collector and columnist who does market research.
- 21:38It could operate at a couple of different levels, right?
- 21:40Like The Wizard of Oz–it's a story about friendship.
- 21:43It's a story about perseverance.
- 21:44It's a story about self-reliance.
- 21:46But Littlefield's thesis was that it's also operating at another level.
- 21:50He argued that it was a story about American economics.
- 21:53Littlefield worked out who each character represented.
- 21:57You have Dorothy, who sort of represents the American public as a whole.
- 22:02It's her journey.
- 22:03I am Dorothy, the small and meek.
- 22:08But along the way, she encounters Scarecrow.
- 22:11So, you know, an agricultural figure.
- 22:14I haven't got a brain, only straw.
- 22:17She encounters the Tin man representing industry.
- 22:20The tinsmith forgot to give me a heart.
- 22:23No heart?
- 22:25No, heart.
- 22:28And the allegory keeps going.
- 22:30But first, we need a little economic history.
- 22:36In 1873, the US adopted what was called the gold standard.
- 22:40Imagine your paper money is like a ticket.
- 22:43You could take that ticket to the bank and trade it for
- 22:45real gold anytime you want it.
- 22:48And because of that, the mint could only print as much paper money
- 22:51as they had gold to back it up.
- 22:53And the idea–this goes back to ancient times–is that monetary
- 22:58stability comes through a constraint.
- 23:01We cannot create more gold.
- 23:03We cannot create more silver.
- 23:03We can find it, but it's fundamentally constrained as a physical commodity.
- 23:09This system prevented inflation, and it worked pretty well until the Civil
- 23:13War, when all of a sudden we needed a lot of money more than we had backed
- 23:18up in gold, because war is expensive.
- 23:21And so to help finance the war.
- 23:23One of the things they do is they basically printed money.
- 23:25This is Bradley Hansen, a professor of economics at the University
- 23:29of Mary Washington in Virginia.
- 23:31And during that time, you couldn't stay really on the gold standard
- 23:36because you were saying: this is money.
- 23:37But you couldn't convert it into gold.
- 23:43After the war, we went back to the gold standard.
- 23:46But this caused deflation, which was especially hard for farmers.
- 23:51Farmers typically relied upon debt, and they're constantly repaying
- 23:57loans with money that is worth more than the money that they
- 24:01borrowed when deflation takes place.
- 24:05Imagine you're a farmer and you take out a loan for $100 to buy seeds.
- 24:09But then deflation happens, and the price of the crops you're selling drops.
- 24:14You still have to pay back the original $100, but now you can
- 24:17only sell your crops for $70.
- 24:20This created a lot of anxiety.
- 24:22So some people started thinking about how silver could help.
- 24:26Because silver might not be as valuable as gold, but there's a lot more of it.
- 24:30What about a system where the paper currency was backed
- 24:33by both gold and silver?
- 24:35This was known as bimetallism.
- 24:38You could still print a ton of money, but there'd be less deflation.
- 24:43But not everyone was on board.
- 24:44The bimetallism side was backed by populists, and they argued that it was
- 24:48the big banks that wanted to keep the gold standard in place because it benefited
- 24:53them, but it hurt regular people.
- 24:55And this hit a nerve because the 1890s was a time of extreme economic upheaval.
- 25:00Estimates suggest that unemployment was relatively high, probably double digit
- 25:04unemployment during parts of the 1890s.
- 25:06Some people actually referred to it as the Great Depression before
- 25:09the Great Depression of the 1930s.
- 25:13This all came to a head in the 1896 presidential elections.
- 25:19Money was such a big deal.
- 25:20It was the first thing on the party platforms of both the Democratic Party and
- 25:25the People's Party, and it was second only to tariffs in the Republican platform.
- 25:33Rigoberto Hernandez, on tape: It's all coming together.
- 25:36The Democratic nominee was William Jennings Bryan, a bimetallism advocate.
- 25:41William Jennings Bryan.
- 25:42He's known for being young.
- 25:43He's known for losing the presidency three times.
- 25:46This is Mitch Sanders again.
- 25:47But he's also known for one of the most famous political
- 25:51speeches in American history, which is the cross of gold speech.
- 25:55You shall not press down upon the brow of labor this crown of thorns.
- 26:00You shall not press down upon the brow of labor, this crown of thorns.
- 26:04You shall not crucify mankind upon a cross of gold.
- 26:09You shall not crucify mankind upon a cross of gold.
- 26:14Bryan lost the election.
- 26:16Some people called him a coward, likely because of his antiwar stance.
- 26:20But there's a popular belief that it was also because he didn't take a
- 26:23stronger stand against the gold standard.
- 26:26And all of this brings us back to The Wizard of Oz.
- 26:29Lions and tigers and bears.
- 26:34She encounters a cowardly lion.
- 26:36Oh my!
- 26:37And the Cowardly Lion is considered to be William Jennings Bryan himself.
- 26:42And this makes sense once you know more about the real
- 26:44life William Jennings Bryan.
- 26:46He was sometimes compared to a lion.
- 26:48This is Ranjit Dighe, a professor emeritus in economics at SUNY Oswego.
- 26:53Even looked a little bit like a lion with his hair flowing right out and everything.
- 26:57And then there was the silver itself represented by Dorothy's shoes, which,
- 27:02remember, were silver in the book.
- 27:03And then, of course, there was the yellow brick road.
- 27:06Follow the yellow brick road.
- 27:08Follow the yellow brick road…
- 27:10The yellow brick road represented the gold standard.
- 27:16The yellow brick road gets you to the seat of power, which could be Oz, could
- 27:22be like Washington, D.C. And the yellow brick road is not easy to walk on.
- 27:27Parts of it are a bit patchy, but Dorothy gets these silver shoes and the munchkins
- 27:31tell her they have this incredible power that we don't quite understand.
- 27:35And then Dorothy, walking on her silver shoes along the yellow brick
- 27:39road, you know, is able to walk much better than she could otherwise.
- 27:43We're off to see the wizard, the wonderful wizard of Oz. We hear he is a
- 27:48whiz of a wiz, if ever a wiz there was.
- 27:50If ever…
- 27:51And ultimately, when they get to the Emerald City, she encounters a wizard
- 27:55who is a pretty ineffective politician.
- 27:59You know, pay no attention to that man behind the curtain.
- 28:01Pay no attention to that man behind the curtain.
- 28:05He's a figurehead, whereas it's the witches who have all the power.
- 28:09So, you know, that sort of represents political power being
- 28:12secondary to economic power in the United States at the time.
- 28:18Did The Wizard of Oz author really intend to comment on bimetallism?
- 28:22Probably not, but it's a nice, tidy story.
- 28:26According to the theory, there's even a reference to the silver
- 28:30and gold connection in the title.
- 28:31The Wizard of Oz. Oz, which is a, you know, abbreviation for ounce.
- 28:37As in gold and silver are measured in ounces.
- 28:40And it's a great story for teaching.
- 28:43Economics had a reputation as being very sort of focused on mathematical models.
- 28:50And here was a story, a narrative to spice things up.
- 28:53People didn't really bother to check out whether the story was and
- 28:57the intentions were there or not.
- 28:59They just thought it was a good story with memorable
- 29:02characters, with a memorable plot.
- 29:04And it's not surprising that a lot of people would want to use it.
- 29:12And just like people projected meaning onto The Wizard of Oz, people have
- 29:16been projecting meaning onto silver that is perhaps also misplaced.
- 29:21But remember, it always comes back to economic anxiety.
- 29:25Like farmers who are scared that the government was going to take their money
- 29:28away, or a rich, famous Texas family who didn't trust the government at all.
- 29:38The Whale
- 29:42Peter Thomas is a longtime metals trader whose love of shiny objects
- 29:46goes back to his childhood.
- 29:48It was my 13th birthday.
- 29:49I'm laying in bed and I figured I'm going to sleep late.
- 29:53No school today.
- 29:55But his dad ruined that plan when he came into his room and smacked him on the head.
- 30:00I'm sleeping, he goes.
- 30:02It's time to get a job.
- 30:03What do you mean you're sleeping?
- 30:05I'm like, yeah.
- 30:06He goes: let's go.
- 30:06You're going to exchange.
- 30:08I'm like, it's 5:00 in the morning.
- 30:09He goes, yeah, we're a little late.
- 30:11Let's go.
- 30:15His dad worked at the Chicago Board of Trade, where he was in charge
- 30:18of trading silver and gold futures.
- 30:21Futures trading involves actual assets like gold or silver or beef.
- 30:26Whereas the stock market sells shares of a company, futures trading is
- 30:30basically where you buy a contract to buy or sell a commodity at a
- 30:34particular price in the future.
- 30:37So Pete started his new job as a runner on the trading floor.
- 30:41At just 13 years old, he was in charge of grabbing orders that came in and
- 30:45giving them to the floor traders.
- 30:48All those guys standing in a circle, screaming and hollering at one another.
- 30:52Those were the floor traders.
- 30:54And I would hand one of those screaming and hollering individuals the order.
- 30:58He would make a hand signal–thousand, whatever it happened to be.
- 31:03And he would then execute the order, write it on the piece of paper and
- 31:10either throw it on the floor if it was busy, because they would have stacks of
- 31:13them, or he would hand it back to me.
- 31:15And that's how it was executed and that's how I started.
- 31:22After college, Peter became one of those traders on the floor.
- 31:26Now on the floor, you only have one thing: that's your word.
- 31:31Nothing else matters.
- 31:33One day he spotted a mistake on an order.
- 31:36So he called the man who placed it.
- 31:38So I get this guy on the phone, big southern drawl, and I'm like, okay.
- 31:43You know, I go, sir, listen, I'm Pete Thomas, I'm the filling broker for
- 31:48this house, and the order is incorrect.
- 31:52Pete told him he fixed it right away.
- 31:54And he goes, that sounds really good.
- 31:55He goes, I don't know you, but I'm going to trust you.
- 31:58Peter didn't know it at the time, but that simple fix was about to change his life.
- 32:03He goes, this, that was a nice job you did with that.
- 32:06He says you're working for me now, I said, I said I got a badge on my chest.
- 32:10It's mine.
- 32:11Okay.
- 32:12Nobody owns me.
- 32:14Send all your orders to me.
- 32:15I'll execute for you.
- 32:16But I'm not working for you.
- 32:18But I will execute for you.
- 32:19And he goes, he goes: okay.
- 32:21And he kind of chuckles.
- 32:22Right?
- 32:22And we hang up.
- 32:24And then the head of the silver pit comes running over to me
- 32:28with these big saucer eyes.
- 32:30And he goes, Bunker Hunt's asking for you to fill his paper.
- 32:34I go, who the hell is Bunker Hunt?
- 32:36He goes, this is the whale.
- 32:38He's the wealthiest man in the world.
- 32:44Nelson Bunker Hunt was the man Peter was talking to on the phone.
- 32:47He was one of 15 children of the legendary Texas oil tycoon Haroldson
- 32:52Lafayette Hunt Jr, or H.L. Hunt.
- 32:56The father was as wealthy as he was eccentric.
- 32:58H.L. Hunt: The Richest and the Rightest: In Dallas, Texas, where
- 33:00millionaires are not at all unusual.
- 33:02This man, carrying part of his lunch to work in a paper bag is something special.
- 33:08For among those who have amassed great wealth from petroleum.
- 33:11He has amassed by far the most.
- 33:14This is from a documentary called H.L. Hunt: The Richest and the Rightest.
- 33:18H.L. Hunt: The Richest and the Rightest: The richest man in America, the richest
- 33:22and one of the most controversial.
- 33:27The Hunts were deeply distrustful of the government.
- 33:29H.L. Hunt: The Richest and the Rightest: What motivates him to
- 33:31wage the battle of the far right?
- 33:34Perhaps it's super patriotism, a simplistic view of the
- 33:38American way of life.
- 33:40Perhaps it's love of his wealth.
- 33:43The fear that the communist or socialist, or even the liberals are
- 33:47plotting to take it away from him.
- 33:49In the late 1970s, inflation was rampant, and the Hunts didn't trust
- 33:54the government to do anything about it.
- 33:56Inflation has cost us dearly in the last year.
- 33:59One hidden cost is to our sense of freedom.
- 34:03Freedom in the marketplace, for one thing.
- 34:05Some things we cannot get anymore.
- 34:07Other things we cannot pay for anymore.
- 34:10Freedom of movement, too— limited by the cost of a new
- 34:13house, by the cost of gasoline.
- 34:16Even our freedom to dream.
- 34:18Our normal expectations of getting ahead are being reduced to hopes of holding on.
- 34:23Many of us are falling behind.
- 34:26So the Hunt brothers did what I did when I freaked out and bought a bar of silver.
- 34:31Except, of course, they did it on a much bigger scale.
- 34:34Bunker Hunt partnered with his brothers, William Herbert and Lamar Hunt, to
- 34:39buy as much silver as they could.
- 34:41They had been doing this since the early 1970s, but their
- 34:44efforts really ramped up in 1979.
- 34:47They had a crazy plan to monopolize silver, drive the price up, and
- 34:52be the only silver game in town.
- 34:54And this is where Peter Thomas came in.
- 34:57Peter executed most of the Hunt brothers' trades, but unlike other buyers, they
- 35:02weren't satisfied with just a piece of paper that said they owned the silver.
- 35:06They wanted the actual silver.
- 35:08I want it.
- 35:09Okay.
- 35:10Yeah.
- 35:10It sold.
- 35:10No, no, I want it.
- 35:13When Peter started out, silver futures were about $5 an ounce.
- 35:17The Hunt's single handedly drove the price up.
- 35:21I didn't realize the magnitude of it until we were at $7 or $8.
- 35:28And all of a sudden, you know, the Wall Street Journal is calling
- 35:32me going, hey, you know, we'd like to do an interview with you.
- 35:36And I'm like, oh, no way.
- 35:37I'm not talking about anything my customers are doing, you know?
- 35:43Things are going well for Peter.
- 35:44He was working with the richest men in America, making a nice commission.
- 35:48It was the right place, right time.
- 35:49He started investing in silver, too.
- 35:52And he got his family and friends involved.
- 35:55As the price of silver kept going up, more and more people wanted in on the game.
- 36:001979 was an absolute silver frenzy.
- 36:04ABC News, 1980: When the price of silver shot up toward $50 an ounce last year.
- 36:09Americans lined up in thousands to sell their silver bowls, candlesticks, knives,
- 36:14and forks to be melted down into bullion.
- 36:18And everybody had silver and, you know, they were buying
- 36:22or selling silver tea sets.
- 36:24They were accumulating coins.
- 36:27They were going to the owners of laundromats and buying
- 36:32silver coins from them.
- 36:34It was just a lot of fun.
- 36:36At its height, the price of silver reached $48 an ounce, up from
- 36:41just five, and then hit the fan.
- 36:45Government regulators saw it as market manipulation and
- 36:48decided to clamp down on it.
- 36:50Peter remembers a day when everything changed.
- 36:55I was standing on the pit and this kid comes in and says,
- 36:59we have a stop trade order.
- 37:02Regulators decided that they didn't like what the Hunts were doing, so they
- 37:05clamped down on the amount of silver you could buy with borrowed money.
- 37:09Government came in and said: sell only.
- 37:13It was bedlam.
- 37:16It was just like somebody set a bomb off in there, you know.
- 37:19It was just like everybody was in shock.
- 37:21It was scary.
- 37:24And when the market closed, it just dripping wet.
- 37:27You know, just covered in sweat.
- 37:29As soon as he started selling, the price of silver went down.
- 37:33And as it kept going down, people started panic-selling.
- 37:41This all culminated on March 27th, 1980, a day that became known as Silver Thursday.
- 37:48On that day, the price of silver dropped more than 50%.
- 37:52ABC News, 1980: That drove the price down and cost the Hunts more than $1 billion.
- 37:57And nobody knows how much was lost by small investors who jumped
- 38:00on the Hunt silver bandwagon.
- 38:02And it wasn't just devastating to companies and investors, but also for him.
- 38:07He had invested heavily into silver.
- 38:10Peter lost millions of dollars in 20 minutes.
- 38:13You know, everybody effectively went bust.
- 38:16It was kind of like going home.
- 38:17And you and you look at your wife, you go: honey?
- 38:19Yeah.
- 38:20You know that Mercedes I bought you.
- 38:21She goes, oh, I love that car.
- 38:22I go, you're going to love your new Toyota.
- 38:25Some people never recovered.
- 38:27You know, never.
- 38:28It was a brutal day.
- 38:30The Hunt brothers, meanwhile, lost billions of dollars.
- 38:33And this is 1980s money.
- 38:37In 1988, the federal government sued the Hunts for conspiring to corner the market.
- 38:42They were found responsible, and they had to pay $134 million to a
- 38:46mineral company that lost money.
- 38:48Because of their actions, the Hunts declared bankruptcy in one of the
- 38:52biggest filings in Texas history.
- 38:56Peter eventually recovered financially and he still sells precious metals today.
- 39:01The Hunt brothers are dead, but their heist lives on in metal collectors lore.
- 39:06Peter thinks of Bunker Hunt fondly.
- 39:08He wasn't being sneaky or doing something unethical.
- 39:12No, he was just buying the market and receiving the product.
- 39:17The Hunt brothers exploited a system that already existed.
- 39:21They saw economic volatility and pounced on silver, just like
- 39:25people are still doing today.
- 39:38When I started my silver journey, I was told it was a reliable investment.
- 39:42But after hearing this whale's story, I started thinking that it was more
- 39:46volatile than I was comfortable with.
- 39:51The Hot Potato
- 39:55Remember when Bunker Hunt demanded the actual silver he was buying?
- 39:59I want it.
- 40:00Okay.
- 40:00Yeah.
- 40:01Sold.
- 40:01No, no, I want it.
- 40:04It was very unusual because when it comes to storing wealth, silver's
- 40:08value is so hypothetical, so abstract, which makes it easy to forget that
- 40:13silver actually has long had real world value, including medicinal uses.
- 40:20There is an old phrase that said, born with a silver spoon in their mouth, right?
- 40:26This is Michael DiRienzo, the president and CEO of the Silver
- 40:30Institute, an industry group that represents the leading silver mining
- 40:33companies and refiners in the world.
- 40:36That did not necessarily translate to wealth, as people like to think.
- 40:42In many cases, it translated to the fact that they would put a silver
- 40:47spoon in the baby's mouth to ward off infection or any bacteria.
- 40:53We are not recommending that you do this with your baby, but there
- 40:56is a sliver of truth in this.
- 40:59Silver acts as an antimicrobial agent.
- 41:02It can get inside bacteria and mess with the chemistry that keeps it alive.
- 41:06It jams up the proteins that bacteria need to survive and multiply.
- 41:11There are much better methods of killing bacteria these days, but it
- 41:14does point to the range of uses the shiny metal has outside of money.
- 41:19Silver is the best electrical conductor of all the metals.
- 41:24It's one of the best that can store energy.
- 41:28If it has an on and off switch, there's a really high likelihood
- 41:33that silver will be a component.
- 41:35So it's in your cellphone, your computers, your laptops.
- 41:40It's in the light switches.
- 41:41It's all over your automobile washing machine, refrigerators.
- 41:46It really does surround us all.
- 41:53Electricity is made of tiny, invisible packets of energy called electrons that
- 41:57love to move around from atom to atom.
- 42:00Silver's atoms have a loose grip on these electrons, so they break
- 42:04easily and start moving around.
- 42:06This creates kind of like a highway of electricity where atoms can travel freely.
- 42:11But silver's expensive, so electricians usually prefer the second best
- 42:16conductor of electricity, copper.
- 42:19However, copper has a weakness.
- 42:21It corrodes, which means that there has always been a tiny amount of
- 42:25silver in most electronics for the bits where you can't afford corrosion.
- 42:29So more than 95% of the time, copper uses the conductor of electricity, and
- 42:35the rest of the time they use silver.
- 42:37This has been the balance for more than 100 years, until just recently.
- 42:43This is Ed Hipps.
- 42:44He runs another coin shop outside of Philadelphia.
- 42:47AI data centers needing silver was obviously the big story.
- 42:52Every AI data center has many thousands of ounces of silver
- 42:55across its electrical equipment.
- 42:58And with every data center that comes online, the demand for silver goes up.
- 43:03A survey from 2026 says that the data centers alone will use more than 10% of
- 43:07all silver that goes into electronics.
- 43:10When I bought my silver back in April 2025, the price was $33 an ounce.
- 43:15By December, it went up to $60 and I kept checking the price.
- 43:19And I was floored when just a month later, it was up to $120 an ounce.
- 43:24What happened?
- 43:25It was the AI data centers.
- 43:27That's what drove silver up.
- 43:29That's what brought that speculation into where we went from $44 in
- 43:33October, up to $120 in January.
- 43:39The demand for silver and data centers, combined with inflation fears, drove
- 43:43up the price of silver, which created speculation which then drove the
- 43:47price higher when it got to $120.
- 43:50It created the ultimate game of hot potato and people lost money.
- 43:57In July 2026, I went to a coin show outside of Philadelphia
- 44:01to talk to silver enthusiasts.
- 44:03There I met a guy named Caden Schneibel who told me what
- 44:06happened at his coin shop.
- 44:08My boss–I work at a coin shop–he had 110oz that he bought, no, 300oz
- 44:15that he bought at $110 a piece.
- 44:18He lost $9,000 in a few days.
- 44:21I mean, it's just crazy.
- 44:24People don't know what to do.
- 44:25It's a little bit of decision paralysis, gambling addiction, and FOMO.
- 44:32In other words, people got caught up in the hype.
- 44:35I didn't think it was a good thing.
- 44:37I thought it was very unhealthy.
- 44:38This is Andrew Edelman again.
- 44:40I like to see precious metals as a safe and steady investment, not a
- 44:47speculative investment, and it felt to me like it had become speculative.
- 44:52I had people coming in and buying because they thought it was going
- 44:56to be worth more in a week or two.
- 44:58Not because they thought it was a good sound investment.
- 45:02Since that peak of $120, silver has dropped back down to the original
- 45:07$60 per ounce and has held steady.
- 45:11And logically, you'd think the price is lower and it's going to be higher.
- 45:16You would think people are buying now, but they're not.
- 45:20This is Timothy Royer, who was selling silver and gold coins at the coin show.
- 45:24So they're scared also.
- 45:26That's going to go even lower.
- 45:28So they're waiting.
- 45:29They're waiting.
- 45:30They're waiting.
- 45:30Everybody's waiting.
- 45:32So it's just a big waiting game right now.
- 45:39If silver has taught us anything, it’s that hype and speculation don't
- 45:43always lead to the best outcomes.
- 45:45It becomes a game of hot potato, and you don't want to be the one that gets burned.
- 45:52So, Rigo, now that the silver mania has passed have you learned anything?
- 46:01I think I learned that I shouldn't be making investment decisions based on an
- 46:06asset that has a history of volatility.
- 46:09And actually, something really good came out of this.
- 46:12I started to research the best ways to invest, and now I have a very conservative
- 46:17retirement and savings account.
- 46:19I still like silver, but not the same way I used to.
- 46:25I think if I were to buy it again, it would be for sentimental or
- 46:30emotional reasons, because it's just pretty to look at for me.
- 46:34And I can't think of it as like some sort of something that I can, like,
- 46:40count on, like making me money again.
- 46:43And, and there's nothing wrong with that.
- 46:44And you're okay with maybe not making any money from it, but I think it's important
- 46:49to understand that before buying it.
- 46:52And sometimes people come in here and they just look around, they're
- 46:55like, oh, I really like that.
- 46:56I'm going to buy it because I really like that.
- 46:58And that's awesome.
- 46:59I love when people do that.
- 47:02The instinct to search for something solid when the world feels uncertain
- 47:06is as old as civilization itself.
- 47:09And I think Kris Lane says it best.
- 47:11There's a human desire for these shiny things.
- 47:16We chase these shiny things, and yet they cause us problems.
- 47:21They don't solve the problems we think they'll solve, and they usually
- 47:25bring us more than we bargained for.
- 47:35Distillations podcast is produced by the Science History Institute
- 47:39and recorded in the Laurie J. Landau Digital Production studios.
- 47:44Our executive producer is Mariel Carr.
- 47:47Our senior producer is Rigoberto Hernandez.
- 47:50This episode was produced by Rigoberto Hernandez.
- 47:54It was fact checked by Alexandra Atiya, and the sound design was by Seth Samuel.
- 48:00Support for Distillations has been provided by the Middleton Foundation
- 48:04and the Wyncote Foundation.
- 48:06You can find all of our podcasts, as well as our videos and articles on
- 48:11our website at sciencehistory.org.
- 48:14And you can follow us on social media at @scihistoryorg for news about our
- 48:19podcasts and everything else that goes on in our free museum and library.
- 48:24For Distillations, I'm Alexis Pedrick.
- 48:27Thanks for listening.