Latest / True Crime with Gavin Fish / This Case Looks Like a Slam Dunk, But Is it? | D4vd Segregated | Murder of Celeste Rivas Hernandez
Transcript
- 0:01Well, we've got more and more information trickling in on the
- 0:06circumstances of the arrest and holding of.
- 0:11David Burke, and known as David. He's a singer.
- 0:17Here's his Here's his picture, everybody.
- 0:20I don't need to describe who he is.
- 0:21Here he is. There's Mr. Burke, who has been
- 0:24charged in the murder of this young woman, Celeste Rivas
- 0:30Hernandez. Little information is coming in,
- 0:34including our first doc, a court document there.
- 0:39There's precious little in there, but it is precious.
- 0:43So we're going to get into that tonight.
- 0:45We've also got a couple of pieces of information that I
- 0:49want to share with you in the Nancy Guthrie case, in the Anna
- 0:53Kepner case, we're going to check in on the on Luigi
- 0:57Mangioni today. That and three questions and
- 1:00some good news. We've got it all.
- 1:02So we've got we got a 10 gallon show that we need to pack into a
- 1:075 gallon container. I hope you'll stick with.
- 1:22This video contains mature themes and discussions intended
- 1:25only for adult audiences. Viewer discretion is advised.
- 1:31Well, Hello. There my friend, and welcome.
- 1:33Back to another true crime conversation with me, Gavin
- 1:36Fish. Thank you for being here.
- 1:39Thank you for liking, subscribing, sharing, following,
- 1:44listening to the podcast, going over on Spotify for your
- 1:48patronage over on Patreon. Thank you, thank you, thank you
- 1:51for it all. You.
- 1:52Guys are awesome. I know that there are several of
- 1:55you that are new here. What we like to do here is cut
- 1:59through the fluff. Cut through the sensationalism
- 2:02of true crime and get right down to the nitty gritty.
- 2:04If that is your thing, you found the right place.
- 2:06I hope you stick around because we have fun here too.
- 2:10One of my mantras is that we take victims seriously.
- 2:14We take crime seriously. We take the families of victims
- 2:17seriously. We don't take ourselves
- 2:18seriously. We, we're allowed to have fun.
- 2:21We're allowed to have a little bit of fun.
- 2:23We do that around here. Hey, wherever you're checking in
- 2:26from, wherever you're viewing or listening from, please tell me
- 2:28in the comments. I love that part.
- 2:29I I see that I've I've got some people well trained.
- 2:33We've got Austin, TX in the house.
- 2:35We got the great state of Georgia.
- 2:37Charleston is here. Erie is here.
- 2:40Who else is here? We got Grimsby ON Canada here.
- 2:44North Carolina, a temporary home in the Ozark Mountains.
- 2:49Oregon, Asheville, NC. The Buckeye State is in the
- 2:52house. Ohio, Palm Mom.
- 2:55Salisbury, Tennessee, Vancouver, Canada.
- 2:57Santa Monica is in the house. Southern California from my home
- 3:00state. Sharky Sharona.
- 3:03Let's see, Sharky is from South Lake Tahoe, which is my
- 3:09neighboring to my to my home state.
- 3:12Well, it depends on I guess which side you're on.
- 3:15I don't know where the actual city limits are.
- 3:18I don't spend a lot of time up there.
- 3:20Westminster, MD in the house. Calgary here.
- 3:23Northeastern North Carolina Batty Queen TV is coming to us
- 3:27from NYC. We got Arizona in the house.
- 3:30Thank you guys for checking in. I really appreciate it.
- 3:33JPS is coming to us from Reno. My wife and I spent three years.
- 3:39Three difficult, hard, challenging years that we loved
- 3:49in Reno, NV. Great place to live, great place
- 3:52to have a family, great place to spend outside.
- 3:56Thank you for checking in with us.
- 3:58OK, let's do a little bit of a recap here.
- 4:01OK, this is Celeste. Celeste ran away at the age of
- 4:0713 and she met the end of her life, sorry to say it that way,
- 4:15at the at the young and tender age of 14 years old, her body
- 4:23was discovered in the front trunk of a Tesla.
- 4:28Owned by this man, Mr. David Anthony Burke that had been
- 4:34towed from a Hollywood Hills location outside.
- 4:38The mansion that was being rented for him, the car was
- 4:41registered to him. It was taken to a police impound
- 4:45lot where. They started complaining of the
- 4:51old smell of decomposition. Guys, that is a.
- 4:55Powerful smell, and I know that we all have probably experienced
- 4:58it with, I don't know, animals in the woods, something like
- 5:02that, but I, I was called. This is a bit of a tangent, but
- 5:07not music worthy. I was called one time to a while
- 5:10I was with the. Coroner, our county coroner and
- 5:13I and I went with her on a call to an apartment where somebody
- 5:18had expired and they had been expired for about a week.
- 5:22And it was an apartment, I don't know, 67800 square feet.
- 5:25And boy was it powerful. I can only imagine inside the
- 5:31trunk of of that car, this precious little girl discarded.
- 5:39Disrespectfully and unlovingly. Placed into two bags after being
- 5:44dismembered. Placed into two bags inside this
- 5:47front trunk area. I just can't even imagine.
- 5:50Cannot even imagine. To to go on with the recap, Mr.
- 5:57Burke was was traveling a boat, as our friends from the north
- 6:02might say on his on his tour, supporting his music and.
- 6:10This, this all happened back in September.
- 6:12September 8th is when her body was discovered.
- 6:15And it was just what, Thursday, this past Thursday that he was
- 6:21arrested. Got the news on Friday, you
- 6:25know, and spent the whole weekend wondering what was going
- 6:28to happen. And then there was a press
- 6:30conference yesterday, and Mr. Burke has been charged in her
- 6:34murder along with a couple of other things.
- 6:36We're going to get into that criminal complaint.
- 6:38Unfortunately, we do not yet have the probable cause
- 6:45affidavit that was referred to by Los Angeles County District
- 6:51Attorney Nathan Hawkman. I hope that we will get that
- 6:56sometime soon. That should have a few more
- 6:59details now. His preliminary hearing is
- 7:02scheduled for the 23rd, so that's Thursday.
- 7:06I wouldn't be surprised if it's postponed, but we might be able
- 7:09to get even more details on Thursday.
- 7:12We're going to keep our finger on the pulse of this case and
- 7:17continue to watch it very, very closely.
- 7:20Hey, real quick continuing we've got.
- 7:24Sandwich, Mass in the house we got Bermuda here.
- 7:26Lawrence, KS Michigan, Sharky Santa Love, Reno went there
- 7:30today. Fredericksburg, VA is here.
- 7:36Yeah guys. Thanks so much.
- 7:37Vancouver, Canada is. Here.
- 7:40Awesome, awesome, awesome. Thanks for for checking in.
- 7:44Okie Dokie. First thing that I want to bring
- 7:47to you is actually a report out of the New York Post.
- 7:51If you will. Join me.
- 7:53Over here on Acrobat, this written by Zane Khan came out
- 7:58today. It references ATMZ article.
- 8:02I went to the TMZ article. I just don't want to read it.
- 8:06TMZ broke the news. That's what we need to know.
- 8:08They broke. This, but it's just it's written
- 8:12like it's written for 4th graders who watch reality TV
- 8:20Fahrenheit 451 style with like. TV's all around them.
- 8:25It, it's written like that. So I, I it's not like we're
- 8:30about to read Shakespeare here out of the post, but it's a
- 8:33little bit better, OK. David segregated in jail
- 8:37following Celeste Rivas murder charges, reports Zane Kahn.
- 8:44David has been transferred to a new jail and segregated from
- 8:47other inmates. Due to his high profile after
- 8:50being accused of murdering and SA ING a 14 year old girl, I
- 8:55should. Say this is the continuous essay
- 8:58guys, this is many of you discovered me and we became
- 9:04acquainted because of the Madeline Soto case now obviously
- 9:08that. Beyond the pale, right?
- 9:12I mean, Madeline had been being essayed by Stephen Sterns from
- 9:17the time she was 8. Just so egregious.
- 9:22This is the same thing. This was a. 13 year old child
- 9:28when this started OK, the singer, real name David Burke,
- 9:34was moved. To the Los Angeles County Men's
- 9:37Central Jail just before 10:00 PM Monday.
- 9:41That would be yesterday following his arraignment where
- 9:44he pleaded not guilty to 1st degree murder, sex with a minor
- 9:47and more charges related to the death.
- 9:49Of Celeste Rivas. Once at the jail, he was
- 9:53separated from other inmates for being quote noteworthy.
- 9:57A noteworthy prisoner. And will spend his time in
- 10:00custody alone, TMZ reported in TMZTMZ.
- 10:07Sourced an unnamed source in the jail and then the rest is a
- 10:14little bit of, you know, the background and additional
- 10:20charges. But we're going to, we're going
- 10:22to get into the actual charging document.
- 10:26So we won't worry about that. What we know is that he's being
- 10:29segregated. Probably for his.
- 10:31Safety. I mean, not only is he a high
- 10:33profile person, right, but he is accused of a saying a child.
- 10:43That's not going to make him popular in jail.
- 10:46That's going to make him a target.
- 10:48And you know, I, I know that there are a lot of us,
- 10:53especially those of us in true crime that I mean, well, Stephen
- 10:57Sterns is a prime example, right?
- 10:58I mean, I, I just don't even know how to describe how to
- 11:03verbalize how much, how, how I feel towards Stephen Stearns,
- 11:12right? How does that song?
- 11:14Go old Mr. Webster could never describe whatever it is.
- 11:19Define right there. There's no definition for how I
- 11:22feel toward Mr. Stearns. But I still don't want prison
- 11:28justice. I just don't I, I, I would much
- 11:32rather he suffer in there for the rest of his life then get
- 11:34out the easy way. And I feel the same way about
- 11:39Mr. Burke, who is alleged to have he is charged with essaying
- 11:45a child, a 13 year old, a 14 year old, before he, according
- 11:49to prosecutors, lie in wait, invite her over and took her
- 11:55life, right. So I'm sure, I'm sure they're
- 11:59doing it for his safety and I think that's the appropriate
- 12:01thing, especially considering I mean, I understand the whole.
- 12:05Desire for prison, justice. I just fight that as much as I
- 12:09can. When I feel it within myself, I
- 12:11just. But this is not a person who has
- 12:16been proven guilty. This is a person who has been
- 12:19charged, right? So you know, I guess maybe I am
- 12:24projecting what I think many people are feeling right now and
- 12:29I'm I'm working really hard not to feel it.
- 12:34I did see. Somebody got us started on a
- 12:36super chat. Let me let me head over there,
- 12:40Kim chiming in saying, Gavin, you do great content.
- 12:44Well, thank you and thank you for that super chat.
- 12:46I really appreciate it. Elizabeth says is he in the same
- 12:51jail as Nick Reiner? I noticed the judge was the same
- 12:54yesterday. Yeah, that judge does seem to
- 12:57be. Maybe her docket is all about
- 13:01arraignments. Let's see, where is Nick Reiner
- 13:07being held? Nick Reiner is being held in the
- 13:11Twin Towers Correctional Facility in downtown LA.
- 13:18According to the New York Times, he's also in solitary
- 13:22confinement, so it doesn't look like he is in the same place as
- 13:26Mr. Burke. Mr. Burke, according to TMZ, as
- 13:30reported by the New York Post here, is in the Men's Central
- 13:35Jail. And I think it.
- 13:37Makes me wonder if the twin towers has some sort of mental
- 13:44health unit. Yeah, Mr. Mr. Reiner.
- 13:49He's being held in solitary confinement in the jail's high
- 13:52observation mental Health unit often.
- 13:54Referred to as administrative segregation, where he is checked
- 13:58frequently. And, and I don't know if I don't
- 14:02think that. I don't think that, Mister.
- 14:04Burke here is being segregated because of his mental health, I
- 14:12think. I think it's purely his safety.
- 14:15That's what I think. But I mean, what do I know,
- 14:18right? I'm, I'm, I'm just speculating
- 14:20at this point, OK? Let me bring you over, back over
- 14:26to Acrobat. I want to bring you this
- 14:28document which was released by the district attorney's office.
- 14:33See if we can bring it back so you can see the whole thing.
- 14:37This was released by the district attorney's office last
- 14:40night. I actually, I somebody sent it
- 14:42to me. Several of you sent it to me.
- 14:45It was really funny because Tiff Ritter from Courtroom
- 14:49Confidential was on our live chat yesterday and she said that
- 14:53she would send to me anything that they got and I and I
- 14:57thought, well, anything I get, I'm going to send to them.
- 14:59I'm sure I'm going to be behind them.
- 15:01And I sent it over to her and she she was like I tried to
- 15:05send. It to you.
- 15:05For some reason your e-mail was bouncing.
- 15:07So anyway, thank you to all of you who sent it my way.
- 15:12Hopefully we will. We will get the PCA soon too.
- 15:15But let's see what is in here and there.
- 15:18There are some things that that I think are important and in
- 15:25writing rather than in a media conference.
- 15:28Yeah, press conference. OK.
- 15:30This is the state of California, the people versus David Anthony
- 15:34Burke, who just turned 21 three weeks ago.
- 15:39The undersigned is informed and believes that count 1 on or.
- 15:45About April 23rd, 2025, in the county of Los Angeles, the crime
- 15:50of murder in violation of Penal Code section 187 A, a felony,
- 15:55was committed by David Anthony Burke, who did unlawfully and
- 15:59with malice aforethought murder. Celeste are a human being I
- 16:05think as she is a minor there. They're not saying her full
- 16:10name. I noticed that in the press
- 16:11conference yesterday also. Boy, do they have it narrowed
- 16:15down to the date. I mean, there, there wouldn't be
- 16:19any forensic evidence from the secondary crime scene or?
- 16:23I don't know what they would consider where her body was if
- 16:26that was the primary crime scene or, or whatever, but the, the,
- 16:30the car would not have digital or well, it wouldn't have
- 16:37forensic evidence that would make them say, hey, she was, she
- 16:43died on April 23rd, right? Establishing the time of death
- 16:50is way harder than it is on TV. So that that tells me that they
- 16:56have evidence that directly says April 23rd.
- 17:02What could that evidence be? My guess, if I were just to
- 17:06guess based on the stupidity of this criminal endeavor, my guess
- 17:14is text messages. DMS whatever they tried to do in
- 17:19order to hide their communications.
- 17:22I bet. I bet there were communications
- 17:25it it would be like a what's the name of that documentarian that
- 17:29does like civil war documentaries?
- 17:34My, my dearest David, it has come to my attention that I have
- 17:39committed, that you have committed the egregious act of
- 17:42murder in the first degree on the date of April 23rd.
- 17:46I bet they did. Ken Burns.
- 17:47That's what I'm thinking of. Be like.
- 17:49I bet. I bet there will be able to be a
- 17:51Ken Burns documentary with so many letters, so many emails
- 17:57between so many dill holes, so many idiots that they know.
- 18:01Yeah, it was April 23rd. OK, continue.
- 18:06Notice The above offense is a serious felony within the
- 18:09meaning of Penal Code 1192.7 C and a violent felony within the
- 18:15meaning of Penal Code Section 667.5 C Notice Upon a felony
- 18:21conviction for the above offense, prison custody time is
- 18:24to be served in state prison based upon the above felony
- 18:28offense being a serious felony and or a violent felony or a
- 18:33felony offense requiring registration as sex offender
- 18:38pursuant to Penal Code section 290 C who OK.
- 18:46It is further alleged that the murder of Celeste R was
- 18:50intentional and carried out by the defendant David Anthony
- 18:54Burke for financial gain. Within the meaning of Penal Code
- 18:59section 190 dot 2A1. I want to look that up.
- 19:08Give me, give me. Just a second here real quick.
- 19:20OK 190.2 A1 The penalty for a defendant who was found guilty
- 19:27of murder in the first degree is death or imprisonment in state
- 19:31prison or for life without the possibility of parole if one or
- 19:35more of the. Following circumstances has been
- 19:37found to be true and we need to go to a OK robbery.
- 19:46Is a is that where we're going? We're going to 190.2.
- 19:52A. One OK, sorry.
- 19:59The The penalty for a defendant who was found guilty of murder
- 20:02in the first degree is death or imprisonment in the state prison
- 20:05for life without the possibility of parole if one of the
- 20:07following special circumstances is found under section 190.4 to
- 20:12be true. That that's paragraph a
- 20:15paragraph. A1 is the murder was intentional
- 20:18and carried out for financial gain and I'm just sorry I'm on
- 20:22find law over here. So it's for financial gain that
- 20:27means death or life imprisonment without the possibility of
- 20:32parole. OK.
- 20:35It is further alleged. Make sure I don't miss something
- 20:39here. Yeah, it is further.
- 20:44Alleged that pursuant to Penal Code Code section PC-192-A10
- 20:51that Celeste R was a witness to a crime and was intentionally
- 20:55killed because of that fact. Let me go back over to find law
- 20:59real quick. Go down to a 10.
- 21:04The victim was a witness to a crime who was intentionally
- 21:07killed for the purpose of present preventing his or her
- 21:10testimony and any criminal or juvenile proceeding.
- 21:14And the killing was not committed during the Commission
- 21:16or attempted Commission of the crime to which he or she was a
- 21:19witness, so it had to be separate or The victim was a
- 21:22witness to a crime and was intentionally killed in
- 21:25retaliation for his or her testimony and any criminal or
- 21:28juvenile proceeding. As used in this paragraph,
- 21:31juvenile proceeding means proceeding brought.
- 21:33Pursuant to blah blah blah, OK, and and they described that a
- 21:37little bit yesterday that the crime that she was a witness to
- 21:43was was Mr. Burke's essay of her his.
- 21:48Continuous essay of her. It is further alleged that the
- 21:54murder of Celeste Aure was committed by defendant David
- 21:58Anthony Burke and that the defendant intentionally killed
- 22:00the victim by means of lying in wait within the meaning of Penal
- 22:05Code section 190.2 A 15. Let's go down to paragraph 15.
- 22:13It just says the defendant intentionally killed the victim
- 22:16by means of lying in wait. Let me look up lying in wait
- 22:21legal definition in California. OK, Lying in wait is a form of
- 22:36first degree murder or a special circumstance requiring proof
- 22:40that the defendant concealed their purpose, watched and
- 22:43waited for an opportunity to act, and launched a surprise
- 22:47attack from a position of advantage with the intent to
- 22:50kill in California. Lying in wait.
- 22:55Is a form of first degree murder or a special circumstance
- 22:57requiring proof. So the prosecution has to prove
- 23:02this, that the defendant concealed their purpose, watched
- 23:06and waited. For an opportunity to act, and
- 23:10then launched a surprise attack from a position of advantage
- 23:13with the intent to kill. Hey sweetie, come on over to the
- 23:18house. We're playing whatever.
- 23:21We're watching whatever we can do whatever.
- 23:24And then sneaking up, walking behind her, something like that.
- 23:30That's that's what lying in wait means in California, OK.
- 23:36It is further. Alleged.
- 23:38Listen, it is further alleged intentional is further alleged
- 23:45that it that she was a witness and she was killed because of
- 23:48that. It's further alleged that he was
- 23:50lying in wait. And then it is further alleged
- 23:52that that in the Commission and attempted Commission of the
- 23:55above offense, the said defendant, David Anthony Burke,
- 23:59personally used a deadly and dangerous weapon, to wit, sharp
- 24:03instrument. Now, do you guys remember in the
- 24:09in the arraignment yesterday, Mr. Burke's attorneys?
- 24:15Took umbrage. I would, I would characterize it
- 24:17as that they took umbrage with the with the prosecution
- 24:23releasing the cause of death when the cause of death was
- 24:27sealed. But I mean, the prosecution
- 24:33didn't really take that bait. They're just like.
- 24:35We will we will make a motion to unseal that, but it's not sealed
- 24:39in this document because it is part of it is part of the charge
- 24:44right So that the defendant personally used a deadly and
- 24:48dangerous weapon. To wit, sharp instrument said
- 24:52use not being an element of the above offense, meaning the
- 24:57within the Penal Code Section 1 2022 B 1 and causing the above
- 25:06offenses to be a serious felony within the meaning of Penal Code
- 25:1111927 C 23. I'm not going to look those up,
- 25:14but basically it's a sharp instrument makes I'm, I
- 25:19shouldn't say I'm looking. Forward to it but I am curious
- 25:22to find out did is it one of these situations where he went
- 25:28behind her and did one of these motions with a sharp instrument
- 25:34caused her to I actually if like if somebody how do I say this I.
- 25:41I want to be, I want to temper my speculation with humanity and
- 25:47compassion, right? Don't want to just be putting
- 25:51out, you know, horribly hurtful, speculative things to loved ones
- 25:57of Celeste. So I'm going to temper my
- 26:01comments here just a little bit. But what I was going to say is
- 26:05that I hope. That it was something that was
- 26:12quick, that poor little Celeste being a 14 year old girl, not
- 26:15knowing the violence that was about to fall on her, didn't
- 26:22have to suffer for a long period of time because like, because
- 26:29she was stabbed, 20 * 10 of which were in the back of the
- 26:32head and neck like Alan Greenberg, right?
- 26:34I am hopeful that it was swift, decisive, and that it cut off
- 26:43blood flow to her brain before she could even feel it.
- 26:46That that's what I hope and I, I think we probably will find out
- 26:51these these details at some point.
- 26:55I just the one of the things that has really bothered me
- 26:59about the Ellen Greenberg case. If you guys don't know this one,
- 27:01go to my website. There is that she, she had to go
- 27:06through very, very painful blows before the final blow in her
- 27:17heart took her life and, and I and knowing that she bled out
- 27:24slowly internally, right? I, I, I really, really hope that
- 27:30Celeste lost consciousness quickly.
- 27:35I mean, what I really hope is none of this had ever happened,
- 27:38obviously. But anyway, OK, count 2 now
- 27:45let's check in to see. What you guys are saying over
- 27:46here real quick, I did see that there was another.
- 27:53Super chat Patricia, thank you very much for your super chat,
- 27:57Patricia says justice for Celeste.
- 28:00Poor girl. Yeah, I was.
- 28:02Really. Impressed that chief of police
- 28:10who his name is escaping me right now, said yesterday that.
- 28:16He. He did say that they wanted to
- 28:17seek justice for Celeste, but the first thing he said was we
- 28:21want to seek a measure of accountability because we
- 28:26probably, we, we, we will seek the most justice that we can
- 28:31get. But it will never be enough,
- 28:35right? It won't be enough for her.
- 28:37It won't be enough for her family, the people who cared
- 28:40about her and loved her. I I my mind kind of goes to like
- 28:46her friends. I lost a friend at the age of
- 28:5014, not to anything. Violent like this it was, it was
- 28:54expected, but so life shattering for a 14 year old little boy
- 29:05little boy version of Gavin and so many others.
- 29:13And Celeste was a runaway, right?
- 29:15She was described as a runaway, and I I am confident in my
- 29:21suspicion that there were many of her friends who knew exactly
- 29:26where she went, who knew exactly where she was, knew what she was
- 29:30doing, and didn't have. The emotional maturity or the
- 29:38experience that that maturity might come from to understand.
- 29:42Just what danger she was in. And now now they have learned
- 29:48that really, really difficult and terrible lesson.
- 29:51And I I just feel for all of them.
- 29:55Yeah. Elizabeth News.
- 29:57Ken Burns. It was Ken Burns.
- 30:01Archangel. Did this guy have any kind of
- 30:03criminal history before this? To my knowledge, no, but I do
- 30:08not. I do not know for sure.
- 30:15Let's see. Arielle, Iwana says.
- 30:20I thought that lying in wait was just another way of saying it
- 30:23was planned, not necessarily that he actually came from
- 30:25behind or anything like that. No, I think.
- 30:28That. Malice aforethought indicates
- 30:32planning, but lying in wait indicates advantage.
- 30:35Setting yourself up for advantage like.
- 30:40This happens by the way, and I know that I'm referencing other
- 30:44cases. I've referenced Ellen Greenberg
- 30:47so far today, but if you go to my website, I've got a cases
- 30:50page. These are cases that I'll that I
- 30:52care deeply about. Ellen is on here.
- 30:56Ellen is right here. This is the Ellen Greenberg
- 30:58case. There is another case.
- 31:00Let me find her. Shelby Thornburg.
- 31:03OK with Shelby Thornburg, she was a woman who was a sex
- 31:10worker. She was doing very dangerous
- 31:12things. I I even think that she was the.
- 31:16Like she was the Madam in in this criminal enterprise, but a
- 31:21a man was caught on video coming and going out of her apartment
- 31:26building. He yet he still hasn't been
- 31:29identified, but he did exactly that.
- 31:34He was behind her. He sliced her neck and she fell
- 31:39forward and she was gone, right. That I mean, the the crime scene
- 31:44photos, I won't scroll, but if you go to my website, you will
- 31:47see the crime scene photos and let me just real quick see
- 31:51what's here. So I don't I'm just going to
- 31:55Scroll down to here, but there are some case documents here
- 32:00that you can that you can check out.
- 32:02It's but that is a lying in wait kind of a crime establishing an
- 32:08advantage by I mean, it doesn't necessarily have to be come from
- 32:14behind, right, But you've established an advantage and
- 32:18that's what that's what the the the definition that I read was
- 32:25from Justia. It's.
- 32:29Lying in wait requires proof that a defendant concealed their
- 32:32purpose. Watched and waited for an
- 32:35opportunity to act and launched a surprise attack from a
- 32:38position of advantage with an intent to kill.
- 32:43That's what Justia says and I can I can I can bring this up
- 32:52here but that that's what it says.
- 32:55Great. Great question.
- 32:57The the lying yeah so lying and wait does not mean it was pre
- 33:01planned. It already said with malice
- 33:07aforethought right. So that was did with malice
- 33:14aforethought murder Celeste that that is pre planning.
- 33:17And of course, you know, and I know because we've been part of
- 33:21this community for so long that. The pre planning can happen in
- 33:26the moment. It can be.
- 33:28There's no minimum time for pre planning.
- 33:31OK, count #2 and I'm going to use YouTube friendly language
- 33:38here. Not because I feel like we can't
- 33:42handle it, but because I know YouTube.
- 33:43Can't count #2 On or between September 7th, 2023 and
- 33:49September 7th, 2024, in the County of Los Angeles, the crime
- 33:56of continuous essay in violation of Penal Code section 288.5 a a
- 34:03felony was committed by David Anthony Burke, who did
- 34:08unlawfully engage in three and more acts of substantial sexual
- 34:15content. Substantial sexual conduct as
- 34:19defined in Penal Code section 1203. .066 B and three or more
- 34:26lewd and lascivious acts as defined in Penal Code section
- 34:30288, with Celeste R, a child under the age of 14 years while
- 34:35the defendant resided with and had recurring access to the
- 34:39child. OK, I.
- 34:41Had to check the dates there as a reading that.
- 34:44Wait a minute, she died in April.
- 34:45But no, they're talking from September 7th, 2023.
- 34:50To September 7th of 2024, six months ending six months before
- 34:56she was murdered, they lived together.
- 35:02They resided together. He had recurring access to her.
- 35:07He unlawfully engaged in three or more.
- 35:11Well, it says in three and more acts of substantial sexual
- 35:16conduct and lewd and lascivious acts.
- 35:20So reading between the lines that they're they're sexually
- 35:24active for a year, right? So in 2024.
- 35:28Let's say September 7th, 2023. He was born on March 28th, 2005.
- 35:38So he was 18 years old. Am I reading that right?
- 35:432005 to 2023. Check the math.
- 35:47Carry the one. He's 18, she is 13 at the time.
- 35:54Five year difference. Notice the above offense is a
- 36:00serious felony within the meaning of Penal Code section
- 36:031192.7 C and a violent felony within the meaning of Penal.
- 36:08Code 6067.5 C Notice Conviction of this offense will require you
- 36:14to register pursuant to Penal Code section 290 Will for
- 36:18willful failure to register is a crime.
- 36:22Oh, so that's like sex offender registration?
- 36:25Notice Conviction of this offense will require the court
- 36:28to order you to submit to a blood test for evidence of
- 36:31antibodies to the probable causative agent of acquired
- 36:36immune deficiency syndrome. AIDS.
- 36:39Penal Code section 12 O 2.1 notice.
- 36:43Being charged with this criminal offense can result in mandatory
- 36:47pre conviction HIV AIDS testing and disclosure.
- 36:52Of the results to a victim and the chief medical examiner of
- 36:55the jail or prison facility where you are incarcerated
- 36:58pursuant Penal Code section 1524.1 and Health and Safety
- 37:03Code section 121055. Following a probable cause
- 37:07hearing resulting in a court order.
- 37:10So just the charge if, if there's if there's a finding of
- 37:15probable cause, just with the charge before being convicted.
- 37:20They have to do a HIV AIDS screening.
- 37:26Interesting notice upon a. Felony conviction for the above
- 37:32offense, prison custody time is to be served in state prison
- 37:36based upon the above felony offense being a serious felony
- 37:40and a or a violent felony or a felony offense requiring
- 37:44registration as a sex offender within the meaning of all this,
- 37:48blah, blah, blah. So prison time for sure.
- 37:52And then count #3 and again, this is very specific.
- 37:58May 5th on or about May 5th, 2025 in the County of Los
- 38:03Angeles, the crime of unlawful mutilation of human remains in
- 38:08violation of Health and Safety Code Section 7052, a felony was
- 38:13committed by David Anthony Burke who did willfully and unlawfully
- 38:17mutilate remains known to be human.
- 38:20Specifically the remains of Celeste are This is where we're
- 38:23going into speculation town one more time here, right?
- 38:26How do they know this? How do they know that he did it?
- 38:30How do they know that it was done on May 5th?
- 38:33My guess is I bet they have witness testimony.
- 38:38I bet they have witness testimony here.
- 38:41I bet they have traded immunity for for testimony in this case
- 38:47because Burke did not do this alone in my opinion.
- 38:53I just don't see how it could have been done alone.
- 38:56I either before, during and or after the fact, I think that he
- 39:05had conspirators accomplices. So how do they know that on May
- 39:115th he mutilated Celeste's body? We know from court records that
- 39:18she was found in 2 bags. We know that one bag was a
- 39:21cadaver bag with a zipper. We know the that was black and
- 39:26we know another black bag. We know that her limbs were in
- 39:29the second black bag and that her head and torso were in the
- 39:34cadaver bag. How do they know that Burke did
- 39:39it? My guess is witness.
- 39:43I bet there was a witness. Either that or I mean based on
- 39:48the stupidity of this criminal, there's there's digital evidence
- 39:55of it talking about it again, Ken Burns documentary style.
- 39:59My dearest Constance, I have missed the greatly.
- 40:04Why, just yesterday, as I was a dismember in the corpse of my
- 40:08once beloved Celeste, I I bet, I bet.
- 40:11He wrote. And I'm sorry to be irreverent
- 40:13about that, because that's dumb. But I bet that there is.
- 40:18I I bet he was stupid enough to to create like a trail of
- 40:25digital evidence, but I bet there are.
- 40:30Witnesses, I think the witnesses are most likely OK Can notice
- 40:34conviction of this offense Will require the defendant to provide
- 40:37DNA samples and print impressions.
- 40:40Notice the people of the State of California intend to present
- 40:44evidence and seek jury findings regarding all applicable
- 40:47circumstances. Notice A suspected child, or
- 40:53we'll call it CA Report, may have been generated within the
- 40:57meaning of these penal codes involving the charges alleged in
- 41:02this complaint. Dissemination of a SCAR is
- 41:06limited and a court order is required for Full disclosure of
- 41:09the contents of a SCAR. Notice Any allegation making a
- 41:14defendant ineligible to serve a state prison sentence in the
- 41:17county jail should not be, shall not be subject to dismissal.
- 41:22OK Notice Conviction of this offense prohibits you from
- 41:27owning, purchasing, receiving, possessing or having under your
- 41:29custody and control any firearms.
- 41:33I think that he will be in prison for the rest of his life.
- 41:36I wonder what you guys think I put.
- 41:38This in the in the title like how strong is the case?
- 41:43How strong is the case against? Mr. Burke here, we heard they
- 41:50have like 40 terabytes of evidence.
- 41:55Is this one open and shut case or or is this one that that he
- 42:03can get he could beat the rap. Is it possible?
- 42:10I mean? Anything's possible with the
- 42:12jury of 12 people, man, anything's possible.
- 42:15But I hope they've got this case buttoned up tightly and then
- 42:20this is signed by Joshua Byers. The declarant and complainant,
- 42:29and I think that is. Yeah, no bail for Mr. Burke.
- 42:36Because of the special. Circumstances no bail and then
- 42:44pursuant to Penal Code 1054.5 B. The People are hereby informally
- 42:48requesting that defense counsel provide discovery to the People
- 42:52as required by Penal. Code section blah blah blah.
- 42:54Yeah, yeah. So here are here are the charges
- 43:02right? Count 1, which was murder, the
- 43:06what he's looking at is 123 life without the possibility of
- 43:12parole or death in a state prison, plus one year in state
- 43:16prison. And then for count 2, what,
- 43:2261216 state prison? I don't even know what that
- 43:25means. Count 3 is 1623 prison plus up
- 43:30to $10,000 that these are abbreviations that I really
- 43:33can't follow. But there is the felony
- 43:38complaint and hopefully we'll be getting the affidavit of
- 43:42probable cause. I hope.
- 43:44I hope tomorrow. I'm not going to count on it,
- 43:46but I hope. Tomorrow and and then the
- 43:50hearing, which I doubt will happen on Thursday, but possibly
- 43:55on Thursday. Let's get.
- 43:59Let's get. Over to your comments here.
- 44:01See what you guys are saying over here.
- 44:03Just ducky. Let's bring up Celeste.
- 44:06Just Ducky. Do you think it has anything to
- 44:08do with him going on tour? Maybe she wanted to go.
- 44:11Oh, as far as like. Luring him.
- 44:13And hey, we're going on tour. Do you want to be with us?
- 44:17Do you want to go with us? Yeah, it'd be fun.
- 44:19Come on over. I mean, that's that's just as
- 44:23plausible as anything else, right.
- 44:25There would have to be alluring a reason for her to come over.
- 44:28Maybe she still wanted to come over.
- 44:30Maybe they still had a a good relationship, though.
- 44:33Maybe they weren't living together anymore.
- 44:35And and it makes me wonder did like, OK, there are people in my
- 44:40life that I love them to death, but they just.
- 44:46Have fewer brain cells than the rest of.
- 44:48Us right or those cells are so widely spaced apart that they
- 44:53just the the the electricity doesn't fire through them the
- 44:58way it is is David one of these people?
- 45:00Is David just like a musical savant but really not all that
- 45:03bright and came to a senses after a year of essaying this
- 45:09girl when she's 1314 years old that I really shouldn't be doing
- 45:14this. You really should find another
- 45:15place. Or is it more likely that he's
- 45:18like, I'm sick of you or they get got in a fight?
- 45:22You have lots of drama, you know.
- 45:24Is it like stupid? Teenager stuff either way.
- 45:29I mean, what what they're basically alleging is that,
- 45:32well, what I get from reading. Between the lines is that.
- 45:37She held the key to destroying his financial future by telling
- 45:46the world that she was his victim and had been for a year,
- 45:50right? And so he, he just.
- 45:54He couldn't. He couldn't have.
- 45:56That and so he decided to lure her in.
- 45:59Yeah, maybe she wanted to go on tour and he and that was the
- 46:02bait. Maybe it was Sherri says or
- 46:09Shari says, this guy is a monster of monsters.
- 46:14I will add, allegedly it is alleged that he is now, I
- 46:19believe the allegations. But yeah.
- 46:23AC says Gavin as a runaway minor living with him.
- 46:27How was she not removed from his home by the police and he not
- 46:30arrested for harboring a minor? Seems the police knew about this
- 46:34while it was taking place. I don't know if they did.
- 46:39I don't know that it's possible that they did.
- 46:45So let's just, let's just devil's advocate this.
- 46:47This is, this is me quibbling because you are asking the
- 46:51question, not because I disagree with anything that you're
- 46:55saying, but because I'm a professional Quibbler, right?
- 46:58Where's my professional Quibbler audio?
- 47:00I am a professional Yeah, that's nice.
- 47:19From my experience as, as like somebody from the audience in
- 47:25the gallery, right, that when there is a child in a place of
- 47:33danger, whether it be physical danger or danger of emotional
- 47:38abuse or anything, let's just say danger.
- 47:44It takes way too long for the system to be able to to catch up
- 47:52like I am. I'm aware of a, I'm aware of a
- 47:55situation. I won't say where who, but.
- 48:00Child and Youth Services on multiple occasions found
- 48:04findings of you know what, what do they call it?
- 48:09They call it. It's not a conviction, it's it's
- 48:13that they that that the. They found that the allegations
- 48:18were were true, right. And allegations of abuse were
- 48:22true. And they found it at least two,
- 48:26I think 3, but at least two separate times.
- 48:30And yet that child was not taken out of the house.
- 48:34And so, yeah, we got, you're right.
- 48:37I mean, AC, you're right. You got a runaway minor living
- 48:40with an adult, be in a home where you're like, those are
- 48:47two. Those are two people opposite
- 48:50sex. There's two straight people.
- 48:52They're living in a mansion in the Hollywood Hills.
- 48:55We can read between the lines here.
- 48:57Plus, she's a runaway. Yeah, you're totally right.
- 49:00But our system sucks. It's the best system, but it
- 49:06it's not good. It's just the best, right?
- 49:10And yeah, I, I. Don't know if they knew it and
- 49:13couldn't do anything about it, or if it had been referred to
- 49:17CPS or I don't know. I don't know.
- 49:21What a but I mean a a terrific observation and a terrific
- 49:26question. Thank you for that.
- 49:31Carrots and other veg. Let's bring up.
- 49:35Yeah. There we go.
- 49:36Let's bring up Celeste Gavin. He dropped a preview of a song
- 49:39the day after her passing. In the preview, there is a AV
- 49:45mail. It sounds like a AV mail.
- 49:50Sounds like Celeste. She is saying.
- 49:52I am sorry. Can I come over?
- 49:54I can give. Can I can give you more info?
- 49:57Yeah, Send it. Send it to through my website if
- 50:01you if you wouldn't mind. Go to Gavin.
- 50:04Fish.com and click on the envelope icon and you can.
- 50:13Shoot that info over to me through the form that opens up
- 50:16slowly on my site. I've got an overburdened server.
- 50:19But I would, I would love, I would love to, to hear that.
- 50:25Let's see, got a super chat coming in.
- 50:28This is diddly squat, thank you. Diddly.
- 50:30I don't think he suddenly developed a conscious or
- 50:34conscience. He's a dill.
- 50:36Bag, who thinks he's getting away with it.
- 50:38He looks way too smug right now. I'm concerned his lawyers have
- 50:41found a way to let him beat this.
- 50:45But yeah, it's possible. And thank you.
- 50:49Thank you for that comment. Thank you very much for the
- 50:51Super chat. Deeply appreciate you.
- 50:53Let me just keep on going here. Eileen, says Gavin, as sad as
- 51:00this is for her. Family it's good he's off the
- 51:02streets and doesn't have the opportunity to do this for
- 51:05decades. I I agree it is sad that sorry
- 51:09Emmy, let's let's bring Celeste back up.
- 51:14It is sad, but yeah, if he's off the streets, that's I.
- 51:18Mean that's the. Point right that the rest of
- 51:20society is safe. Thank you for that.
- 51:30Diane says Gavin, is there any mention of her family?
- 51:33She was so young, same age as my granddaughter.
- 51:36The only stuff that I have heard about her family is that.
- 51:39They lived in Riverside County in the in the Inland Empire and
- 51:44that she had run away multiple times.
- 51:46This picture that we're looking at is at a graduation ceremony
- 51:49with family. I I do remember that there were
- 51:52candlelight vigils and there were there was a private service
- 51:56for her. I just.
- 52:00You know, it's good that most teenagers don't discover until
- 52:07they're adults. Just how?
- 52:09Little power adults have over them, That the only power.
- 52:15The only authority the adults have over teenagers is that
- 52:19which the teenagers cede to them, right?
- 52:23And most of us. You know, that works out well
- 52:25for all of most of us. For most of us, I mean you.
- 52:31You get to the point where you're like, hey, wait a minute
- 52:34all. They don't really have any power
- 52:37here, right? And some kids come to that early
- 52:40and they come to it too early. I was thinking about what was
- 52:47the name of the young woman? She was murdered in Houston.
- 52:59She was a young girl. Jocelyn Nungary.
- 53:08I think about Jocelyn Nungary, 12 years old, right?
- 53:13She wasn't a runaway, but she was out and about in the middle
- 53:16of the night without her parents knowing, right?
- 53:21Some kids just learn too early. I think that parents really
- 53:28don't have all that much control.
- 53:31And I think that's the case with young Celeste here.
- 53:34She figured it out early. She was she either she was
- 53:37bright and came to that conclusion real early, or she
- 53:41tested the limits a lot, which is another form of brightness,
- 53:46right? And and came to that conclusion,
- 53:50but ultimately ran away 60 miles to a grown adults famous man's
- 53:56mansion where she was repeatedly and continuously essayed by him
- 54:01and and ultimately murdered and mutilated by him, according to
- 54:11according to the prosecution and the police right.
- 54:16She just didn't understand the the, the violence that that
- 54:22people are capable of. And how could she?
- 54:25She's 1314 years old, how could she know that?
- 54:28Sadly, at that age, you only can learn it through experience.
- 54:34And that is, I mean, that is, that is that's one of the more
- 54:41troubling parts of this, right? Carrots and other veg says.
- 54:46It would seem there's a lot of evidence on the day of on the
- 54:52day of he went live. Waving a knife around and saying
- 54:56this is a great knife in the same feed his in the same feed.
- 55:03He has seeming defense wounds, too.
- 55:06Wow, Yeah, he. Interesting First liberties
- 55:12podcast The 612 and 16 is the sentencing for the continuous
- 55:15essay. Yeah, but it does it mean six
- 55:17years? 12 years. 16 years or does it
- 55:19mean months? Not sure.
- 55:23Mrs. Pugh says she was on tour with him.
- 55:25She was seen going backstage with David's brother.
- 55:32Yeah, Autumn. Autumn is echoing.
- 55:36She probably said it before I did.
- 55:38I'm probably echoing her. But I hear a lot of people
- 55:40accusing the parents. But knowing how I was as a
- 55:43teenager, there's nothing they could do.
- 55:46Yeah, I I I know several people who grew up that way.
- 55:52Sherry says no, you had it right.
- 55:53It's pronounced Sherry. OK, Good, good, good, good.
- 55:56Let's see. Ohio Paul.
- 55:59Mom says unfortunately it takes sometimes it takes a horrible
- 56:02tragedy and lawsuits for CPS to act.
- 56:05Yeah, Yep, it is. It is sad.
- 56:10See if there's anything else you guys are saying over here.
- 56:15Ford Donnington disagrees with me, Says parents have power,
- 56:19It's called. Juvie, I don't know, man.
- 56:22I don't know for a willful child, I don't know, like, and
- 56:31thankfully, Kimberly and I so far, knock on wood, knock on.
- 56:36IKEA pressed wood covered in plastic.
- 56:43Our kids have been easy that way.
- 56:45But but there are kids that are not kids that I grew up with,
- 56:50you know? Yeah, it's it's tough.
- 56:55It's it's tough. Wrong button.
- 56:59Wrong button. Let's do this.
- 57:01There we go. OK, And that seems to be all of
- 57:06the comments that are coming in that you guys want to see me,
- 57:08you want me to see. So we will leave it at that.
- 57:11I I personally answering my question in the in the thumbnail
- 57:16and in the title of this, I do think that the prosecution has a
- 57:20good case. I was watching Josh Ritter last
- 57:23night on Courtroom Confidential. Obviously, he is a former
- 57:26prosecutor, current defense attorney on, I can't remember
- 57:30the name of his guest, but he was awesome, like 2 1/2.
- 57:33Decades of prosecutorial experience.
- 57:39They both said, oh, yeah, they got them.
- 57:41They've got them on this one. And you know, they would know
- 57:44better than me. But, you know, they pointed to
- 57:47signals like they convene the grand jury.
- 57:50They investigated, they took their time, They've got him on
- 57:53this one. The question then just remains,
- 57:56will they get a jury to believe them?
- 58:01And that? That's the question in my mind
- 58:06anyway. OK guys, so that's what I have
- 58:08on the case for tonight and I will continue to keep you
- 58:11updated on it now, but but despair not my friends.
- 58:15We are not done. We are not yet done.
- 58:18We have a couple more things that we want to go through.
- 58:21The 1st we call 3 headlines. Here we go now 3 questions.
- 58:29You know what I want to do over on that hobby I want to do over.
- 58:32I want you to to edit that out in post.
- 58:36It's not 3 headlines, it's three questions.
- 58:39It's three questions with Gavin Fish, Okie Dokie.
- 58:48In this segment, guys, I answer three of your questions that you
- 58:51e-mail in to me to the e-mail address that you see on your
- 58:54screen, which is 3 questions at gavinfish.com.
- 58:56It's spelled out 3TH REE questions at gavinfish.com.
- 59:01These questions tend to be like personal questions, questions
- 59:05about me kind of makes me a little uncomfortable, but I have
- 59:09solemnly pledged that I will answer all the questions that
- 59:12you send in. I will not dodge anything.
- 59:15I will do, you know, answer these questions to the best of
- 59:19my ability and they could be what's my favorite color to
- 59:22what's the meaning of the. Universe, Who knows what is the
- 59:25universe expanding into? That's a question, but I will
- 59:29answer them all the the caveat of course is that I get to
- 59:32choose the order in which I answer them.
- 59:34And coming up. After this segment, we are going
- 59:36to do a couple more headlines, true crime headlines.
- 59:40Going to look into Nancy Guthrie, the Anna Kepner case,
- 59:44Luigi Mangione, and we've got a little good news as well.
- 59:48But let's get into question #1 coming in from Cindy, what is
- 59:54your family's favorite holiday and why?
- 59:57Well, I don't know. I can tell you my favorite
- 1:00:00holiday. Actually, you know, my favorite
- 1:00:03holiday growing up was Christmas because it was gifts, right?
- 1:00:07And then my birthday was second to that because why?
- 1:00:10Because gifts. But I really just like, you know
- 1:00:15what I like the the holiday I like the most.
- 1:00:18I think it's Thanksgiving because it's on Thursday.
- 1:00:23We can arrange to have Friday off.
- 1:00:24We've got a nice four day weekend.
- 1:00:27The kids are off of school, We can all get together.
- 1:00:30And we have been really fortunate with this house where
- 1:00:35we have a, you know, I grew up in, in.
- 1:00:40A very A. Very nice middle class
- 1:00:43neighborhood and home. But like most people, when we
- 1:00:49would have a meal with the entire family, that typically
- 1:00:54meant getting out folding tables, you know, and putting
- 1:00:58them in the living room. There's the adults table, there
- 1:01:00the kids table. There that kind of stuff in
- 1:01:02order to fit everybody, because that's the way that's the way
- 1:01:06normal houses are, right? This house has been.
- 1:01:09Glorious. Because we have what we We have
- 1:01:11a dining room with the table in it that we call the Bruce Wayne
- 1:01:14table. You know that scene in Tim
- 1:01:16Burton's Batman where Vicki Vale is like, Could you?
- 1:01:19Pass the salt. And then it backs up and they're
- 1:01:21like on opposite sides of this giant long table.
- 1:01:25That's the kind of dining room that we have and we seldom have
- 1:01:33to in. In fact, if we have family over,
- 1:01:37we don't have to. We seldom have to add anything
- 1:01:41else right now. There have been sometimes.
- 1:01:44Where we've had people over where we had multiple families
- 1:01:49coming over and we would put, you know, 2 tables in that
- 1:01:54dining room or you know, whatever.
- 1:01:57But anyway, what am I getting at?
- 1:01:59I. Love.
- 1:02:00Thanksgiving that we all can come into one room.
- 1:02:04We can sit down, we can share a meal around our giant Bruce
- 1:02:07Wayne table. We don't have to go, you know,
- 1:02:12anywhere to go, anywhere to be. I mean, other than Kimberly
- 1:02:16being a bit of what should we call her?
- 1:02:21Kind of a health nut, which I I appreciate.
- 1:02:25She wants us to be active on Thanksgiving, too.
- 1:02:28She wants us. When the kids were little, we'd
- 1:02:29go and do kickball or or football or whatever.
- 1:02:34We would run a, a neighborhood, you know, race with the kids.
- 1:02:39We'd set up like a, it wasn't a 5K, but like a family 5K running
- 1:02:43through the neighborhood and that sort of stuff.
- 1:02:45But there's nowhere to be. We've got a big.
- 1:02:49Place and a comfortable place that we can all hang out.
- 1:02:51We can visit now we've got comfortable chairs in there.
- 1:02:54My wife, my amazing, beautiful wife, my snuggly bear, my
- 1:02:57sweetie pie, my one and only just furnished.
- 1:03:00Replaced all of our chairs with really comfortable chairs.
- 1:03:03Awesome. So I I guess Thanksgiving is my
- 1:03:06favorite holiday and that is why.
- 1:03:08So I would love to hear your comments in the.
- 1:03:11In the chat question #2 Christina asking Gavin, what is
- 1:03:16the biggest accomplishment you have done in your life?
- 1:03:24So I don't know that I'm terribly accomplished at
- 1:03:29anything at all, especially my, my personality is one of finding
- 1:03:36diversion in many different things, many different
- 1:03:40interests. And I've talked about this
- 1:03:43before. I go from interest to interest
- 1:03:45to interest very, very easily. So I've never, I, I, I don't
- 1:03:50think that I have like, like I'm, I'm never going to be
- 1:03:55thought of as like a profound thinker or, you know,
- 1:03:59philosopher. I'm never going to be thought of
- 1:04:03as some Titan of industry or business or a finance.
- 1:04:09I, you know, you know, the father of nations.
- 1:04:13I'm not Abraham, Isaac and Jacob over here, right?
- 1:04:15I'm not, I'm not a super accomplished person, but I am
- 1:04:20extremely happy that I found the woman that I did that I.
- 1:04:27I don't think I don't want to take, I don't want.
- 1:04:29To use the word I or the phrase I convinced her because that
- 1:04:32means that I had something to do with it.
- 1:04:33For some reason she took pity on me and decided to to combine her
- 1:04:39life with mine. And we have made a beautiful
- 1:04:42life with one another and we have beautiful children and the
- 1:04:46families expanding. Our oldest is now married and
- 1:04:49doing their thing together and it's just, it's just wonderful.
- 1:04:52So I think maybe my. And and it's.
- 1:04:55It's, it would be our biggest, biggest accomplishment, me and
- 1:04:59Kimberly, Kimberly and me is that we have a big, healthy,
- 1:05:07beautiful, loving family. That gets along.
- 1:05:11We all like each other. We all love each other.
- 1:05:13I guess that's it There's there's everything else I'm I'm
- 1:05:17just kind of Fair to middling. I think I'm OK and the things
- 1:05:21that I do and. Try.
- 1:05:24But nobody's going to go. Oh, that Gavin fish.
- 1:05:26Yeah, he was, he was an excellent Goldsmith.
- 1:05:29You know, there's there's not going to be.
- 1:05:31Oh, you should have. Seen the the crazy artwork or
- 1:05:34the OR the craftsmanship or whatever.
- 1:05:39That is never going to be said about me, ever.
- 1:05:42His singing voice was just amazing.
- 1:05:45That will never happen and, and I'm I'm content with that.
- 1:05:51Question number three, I would love to hear your
- 1:05:53accomplishments. By the way, tell me in the live
- 1:05:56chat, Kelly asks, what is your love language?
- 1:06:01I actually had to go to Kimberly and and ask her about this.
- 1:06:04If you guys ever heard of the I I brought this up before, it was
- 1:06:07brought up on smarter everyday, the Jahari window, which is
- 1:06:11something that you it's a it's a mechanism that you used to for
- 1:06:15self discovery. So that so today was a a moment
- 1:06:19of self discovery for me. My love language the way that
- 1:06:24are are you asking? How do I express love or how do
- 1:06:28I receive love the best? The way I receive it is language
- 1:06:36I I like. I like to be told that I'm
- 1:06:39loved, and I like to be. I like to be given attaboys and
- 1:06:44I like to be given. I don't care about accolades or
- 1:06:48recognition, but I like thank yous, you know, and, and stuff
- 1:06:53like that. I think that's.
- 1:06:55Now how do I express love? I think a lot of it is through
- 1:06:59language. Yeah, I it's probably both on
- 1:07:05both sides. Language is my love language.
- 1:07:08I'd love to hear your thoughts on that.
- 1:07:10Now, if you have a question that you would like me to answer,
- 1:07:14please send it to three questions at gavinfish.com.
- 1:07:18I will add it to my list and while you guys are answering
- 1:07:21these questions in the chat, let us check out.
- 1:07:27Let's see what else is. Happening in the world of true
- 1:07:29crimes headlines, true. Crime headlines.
- 1:07:39Okey dokey come with me over to Acrobat.
- 1:07:43This written on foxnews.com by our pal Michael Ruiz.
- 1:07:49Michael writes gilgo beach DNA lab may aid Nancy Guthrie
- 1:07:54abduction investigation. I love Michael's work I love
- 1:07:57Michael's writing let's see what he has to say.
- 1:08:01A San Francisco forensics lab that helped crack the Long
- 1:08:04Island serial killer case is now believed to be involved in the
- 1:08:08search for answers after the suspected abduction of Nancy
- 1:08:11Guthrie. In Tucson, AZ.
- 1:08:13Gilgo Beach killer Rick Scheuerman, who admitted to
- 1:08:16killing eight women between 1993 and 2010, pleaded guilty earlier
- 1:08:20this month after his defense failed to overcome
- 1:08:23groundbreaking DNA evidence. Collected from rootless hair
- 1:08:27samples. Quote I'm pretty confident that
- 1:08:30they will want to use the lab that they have been extremely
- 1:08:34successful with, which is Astria, said CC Moore, one of
- 1:08:38the nation's leading genetic genealogists.
- 1:08:41At Parabon Nanolabs in Virginia, DLI has been working to refine
- 1:08:47their own rootless hair analysis, but I haven't.
- 1:08:51Seen any successful cases from them yet?
- 1:08:56She was referring to DNA Labs International, the Florida lab
- 1:09:00that the Pima County Sheriff's Department initially sent the
- 1:09:02samples to in the days after Guthrie's suspected abduction.
- 1:09:07Now that the FBI has the materials, Astria Forensics
- 1:09:10could be on the short list of specialized private labs that
- 1:09:13could help. The lab developed ADNA profile
- 1:09:16from rootless hair evidence in the human case.
- 1:09:19And Moore said she's personally been involved in six successful
- 1:09:24cases in which Astria did similar work.
- 1:09:28Quote, the FBI used them for the Gilgo case, she told Fox News
- 1:09:31Digital. So they have a lot of confidence
- 1:09:33in Astria. So this is just CC Moore
- 1:09:35speculating, but it's an educated speculation.
- 1:09:40We may see Austria involved in the Nancy Guthrie case in the
- 1:09:45case of the prosecution of the young man named Timothy Hudson,
- 1:09:51who is known in court records as TH, who is accused of killing
- 1:09:58his step sister Anna Kepner. This reported on FOX 35 Orlando
- 1:10:04by their digital staff. Headline attorneys for
- 1:10:07stepbrother Timothy Hudson argue he should remain free on bond.
- 1:10:13Orlando, FL Prosecutors are asking a judge to order a 16
- 1:10:17year old held in custody as he awaits trial in the alleged
- 1:10:21killing of Anna Kepner. Whose body was found aboard a
- 1:10:24cruise ship in November. Let's I've got we'll bring up
- 1:10:30Anna here. Intensifying A closely watched
- 1:10:35case involving serious charges against a minor, the Team
- 1:10:40Timothy Hudson, Kepner's stepbrother, is charged as an
- 1:10:44adult with first degree murder and is also accused of SA.
- 1:10:49ING her let me get through the back story and everything blah
- 1:10:56blah blah the. Case is continuing to move
- 1:10:59through the court system, with Hudson expected to return to
- 1:11:02court in the coming weeks as a judge weighs whether to grant
- 1:11:05prosecutor's request as both. Sides prepare for trial.
- 1:11:09So that is actually I consider that an article with nothing
- 1:11:13new. They're just writing something
- 1:11:15because their readers want to read something.
- 1:11:20But because the case has been transferred from juvenile court
- 1:11:23to adult court. Now there should be a bond
- 1:11:26hearing. We read this in the court
- 1:11:27documents. The defense is obviously going
- 1:11:29to argue for bond. The prosecution is obviously
- 1:11:32going to argue for no bond. We shall see in the coming weeks
- 1:11:36what happens there. This is a quick article on
- 1:11:39Newser, which concatenates a longer opinion piece from the
- 1:11:44Washington Post. But because it's so long and
- 1:11:48behind a pay wall, I thought that I would bring you this one.
- 1:11:53Folkheroinquotesmangioniisfuelingrealworldviolencewrittenbyardendeer@newser.com Luigi Mangioni, the man awaiting
- 1:12:02trial in the December 2024 killing of United Healthcare CEO
- 1:12:06Brian Thompson, is fast becoming a symbol of a new wave of
- 1:12:10ideologically motivated violence, argues The Washington
- 1:12:14Post's editorial board. Investigators say his case
- 1:12:17inspired last year's deadly shooting at the Manhattan
- 1:12:20skyscraper home to the NFL headquarters.
- 1:12:24The editorial board highlights other cases, including a
- 1:12:27California warehouse arson. That caused an estimated $500
- 1:12:31million in damage and a firebomb attempt at.
- 1:12:35Open AICEO Sam Altman's Texas home in which suspects allegedly
- 1:12:40referenced Mangione. The post notes the 27 year old
- 1:12:44who has. Pleaded not guilty in Thompson's
- 1:12:46murder and awaits a trial this fall has taken on folk hero
- 1:12:50status among some on the radical left.
- 1:12:53With a legal defense fund pulling in 1.46 million from
- 1:12:58more than 40,000 donors, federal prosecutors say his supporters
- 1:13:01increasingly see violence. As a substitute for political.
- 1:13:05And ideological argument supercharged by online anonymity
- 1:13:09and social media. The editorial insists there's no
- 1:13:13justification for such attacks against tech leaders, health
- 1:13:17executives or anyone. Else for full argument, you can
- 1:13:20read the editorial there. I've put a link to this article.
- 1:13:24And and yeah, I, I am concerned about this as well.
- 1:13:29Fact, the whole, the whole epidemic, probably starting with
- 1:13:35Columbine. I, I don't know the history on
- 1:13:38this very well, but at least in my memory, starting with
- 1:13:41Columbine, this epidemic of violence in schools, gun
- 1:13:48violence in schools is AI mean. It's like a pathogen, right?
- 1:13:55It is contagious. And people who can't use their
- 1:13:59words or you know, people who who have, I don't know, convince
- 1:14:06themselves the violence is the answer.
- 1:14:08Like I think Mr. Mangione did go in and shoot up innocent people
- 1:14:15who in their mind, they think are guilty.
- 1:14:18And I think this has to stop. We need to not be part of this
- 1:14:21problem, guys. Need to be.
- 1:14:23We need to be part of the solution.
- 1:14:27Those are your headlines. Except, except, except we do
- 1:14:33have some good news this coming out of Australia.
- 1:14:35Our friends down under. Guys, this was a fun art.
- 1:14:40I we got to do good news, right? We got to do Good news, this one
- 1:14:44coming from calminer.com dot AU, written by Isabella Davis.
- 1:14:50New volunteers spark reopening of Salvation Army's free weekly
- 1:14:54community lunch program. No.
- 1:14:58Now listen, if you are in Australia, you just are going to
- 1:15:02have to extend some grace to me. I'm going to butcher names.
- 1:15:06I think that most of your town names are based on some sort of
- 1:15:10a dare. I can't pronounce them, but I'm
- 1:15:13going to do my best and just know that I love you as I trip
- 1:15:18over these words. OK, here we go.
- 1:15:20An amazing community response means Calgoorly Boulder
- 1:15:24Salvation Army's free weekly lunch will be back up and
- 1:15:27running just two weeks after a lack of volunteers forced its
- 1:15:30closure. A surge of locals put their hand
- 1:15:33up to serve to help serve meals to those who need it most, and
- 1:15:37there are now enough volunteers to continue the service.
- 1:15:40The two course meal is given every Tuesday to about 50
- 1:15:44people, often vulnerable members of the community, to offer them
- 1:15:47food and some connection. The Salvation Army announced
- 1:15:51last Thursday that the service had been forced to shut its
- 1:15:54doors because there were not enough volunteers.
- 1:15:56Major Shirley Spooner told the Cal Gorley Minor last Friday
- 1:16:01that the service had been running off the efforts of three
- 1:16:05people, herself, her husband Major Craig Spooner, and the
- 1:16:08branch's receptionist. Quote.
- 1:16:10It's breaking our heart that we've had to do this, she said.
- 1:16:12Unfortunately, we don't have the volunteers that we need to
- 1:16:15assist us. But after the announcement, the
- 1:16:18branch received multiple phone calls from community members
- 1:16:21willing to lend a hand. Less than a week later, the
- 1:16:24Salvation Army announced the program now had enough hands on
- 1:16:27deck for the program to continue.
- 1:16:30Major Shirley Spooner said she had received an amazing response
- 1:16:34from the community to the closure.
- 1:16:35I think it says a lot about the community that they care for
- 1:16:38each other. She said also the community
- 1:16:39realizes the need for the program.
- 1:16:43So yeah, that's, that's that's great news.
- 1:16:47You know, people are good. Right, you guys know that I am a
- 1:16:54big fan of Mr. Fred Rogers, that I grew up watching his program.
- 1:16:59Indeed, Kimberly and I named one of our children after Mr.
- 1:17:02Rogers. He has been a hero of mine from
- 1:17:05the time I was a little kid and that the the whole story that he
- 1:17:11would share. I think it was his grandfather
- 1:17:13or maybe his mother that told him when he was a child and he
- 1:17:17saw bad things happening in the world, right?
- 1:17:21War and stuff like that. He was told to look in the
- 1:17:25background for the helpers. There are always helpers, right?
- 1:17:28You're watching the news and some war-torn country far, far
- 1:17:32away and, and there are always helpers or there was an
- 1:17:37earthquake or some natural disaster, man, they're always
- 1:17:40helpers, right? And this feeds into my belief
- 1:17:43that. People are good.
- 1:17:47In fact, this little hobby of ours of true crime, it is an
- 1:17:52indication that people are good, right?
- 1:17:54That we recognize bad things are happening and that offends.
- 1:17:59US. And that, that is an indication
- 1:18:02that people are good. And when I read a story like
- 1:18:05this, it just tickles me. It reminds me, hey, remember
- 1:18:09what Mr. Rogers said? Look for the helpers.
- 1:18:13And here were three people doing God's work helping people out.
- 1:18:17Couldn't quite, couldn't quite do it.
- 1:18:19They're like, so sad I have to shut this down.
- 1:18:22But as soon as people found out, oh.
- 1:18:23They're going to shut this down. I can help.
- 1:18:25I will stand up and I can help. I love, love, love stories like
- 1:18:31this. It makes me want to be a better
- 1:18:32person. So good Anya Calgorli Boulder
- 1:18:37area. And the Salvation Army and the
- 1:18:39volunteers that are helping there, you guys are awesome.
- 1:18:44Thank you for doing that, guys. Those are your headlines.
- 1:18:48True crime headlines. OK, let us finish out the day
- 1:18:59with some of your comments, Sherry, says Gavin.
- 1:19:02Luckily I never got in any trouble because I was a good
- 1:19:05kid, but I emancipated myself at 16.
- 1:19:09It all could. Have gone a completely different
- 1:19:11direction. Good for you Sherry, good for
- 1:19:14you. That is awesome.
- 1:19:18The bean and I said Gavin, it's always 42.
- 1:19:22It's always 42. What was it that I said?
- 1:19:25I don't know. It's always 42, OK, Freda says.
- 1:19:30Gavin, Thanksgiving for me, too. Awesome food.
- 1:19:33And it's awesome to have a national holiday for giving
- 1:19:35thanks. Yes, indeed.
- 1:19:37Cabling says that's what Love Is All about.
- 1:19:41Sherry says you do not give yourself enough credit there,
- 1:19:44Mr. Gavin. You are a freaking pilot, for
- 1:19:46gosh sake. That's a huge accomplishment in
- 1:19:48my book. Yeah.
- 1:19:49I'm just a private pilot, though.
- 1:19:50I'm not like I'm, I'm not like a commercial pilot or a fire deer
- 1:19:54pilot or anything like that. It in fact, that that is one of
- 1:19:57the things that like I'm interested in it.
- 1:20:01So I will do it. I'm a good pilot, I'm a good
- 1:20:03pilot and I'm a I'm an experienced pilot.
- 1:20:05I'm a safe pilot. I'm.
- 1:20:07Happy to put people that I know and love in a plane with me and
- 1:20:10I'm confident that we're going to take off, fly and land
- 1:20:14safely, that I will make good decisions.
- 1:20:16As I as I do those things. So it's not that I'm a bad
- 1:20:19pilot. I am definitely a good pilot,
- 1:20:22but but it's just another one of the things that I'm interested
- 1:20:25in and I'm one of hundreds of thousands of people, right, that
- 1:20:30are good pilots. But thank you.
- 1:20:33Thank you, Sherry. That does make me feel good.
- 1:20:36Robin says Gavin, I'm calling BS, Let's be honest and say
- 1:20:39you're doing a great job being you and doing all of your
- 1:20:41wonderful things. End of story.
- 1:20:43OK, well thank you I you guys, I wasn't fishing for compliments,
- 1:20:47but I but I appreciate my love language is language.
- 1:20:50So this is making me feel good. Diane Fair says I love
- 1:20:54Thanksgiving. No presents, just loads of food,
- 1:20:57love and cheer. Yes, Freda says I love making
- 1:21:03people laugh. That is a good feeling to make a
- 1:21:05person laugh, isn't it? That does feel good.
- 1:21:09Gavin 42 The meaning of life, I guess, I guess cabling folk
- 1:21:17hero. What the actual HE double hockey
- 1:21:21sticks is happening in this country.
- 1:21:22It's it's a sad thing. It's a sad thing, sad thing that
- 1:21:27one person, Luigi Mangioni, believed that he needed to do
- 1:21:32what he allegedly did. And that there are like 40,000
- 1:21:36others that are cheering him on. It's, it's just, it's sad.
- 1:21:41It is sad. 42 is the answer and no one provided the meaning.
- 1:21:47OK, I, I, I'm not following the 42 thing, but Robin will help me
- 1:21:51out in Slack. Guys, thank you so much for
- 1:21:53spending some time with me tonight.
- 1:21:56Thank you for doing it on YouTube.
- 1:21:57Thank you to the rewatch crew. Thank you to the Spotify viewers
- 1:22:00and listeners, podcast listeners, thank you to my
- 1:22:03patrons. Thank you to those that are
- 1:22:05sharing my program with people who you think would enjoy the
- 1:22:09content. Thank you for the Super chats.
- 1:22:12Thanks for visiting the website. Thanks for joining us in the
- 1:22:15Fish Tank on Facebook, which you can.
- 1:22:17Always do, you're always invited.
- 1:22:19Y'all are the best, Robin says. It's this 42.
- 1:22:24Is the secret of the universe. OK?
- 1:22:27Is that from like Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy or something
- 1:22:29like that? I'll have to look it up.
- 1:22:31I'm going to look it up. I feel out of the know, but
- 1:22:34anyway, we'll be back tomorrow, 6:00 PM Eastern Time right here
- 1:22:40on this very channel. And then it will be distributed
- 1:22:44out to to our friends on Spotify and wherever you get your
- 1:22:50podcasts. Oh, tomorrow we will be doing
- 1:22:54our program. But I believe I've been invited
- 1:22:57and I have accepted. Things can change, but I believe
- 1:23:00I will also be joining Josh Ritter on Courtroom Confidential
- 1:23:04tomorrow at 8:00 PM Eastern. So we'll finish out the show and
- 1:23:08then half an hour later. So I will be joining Josh.
- 1:23:12I don't know if I'll be the only guest or one of many.
- 1:23:14Could be a panel, I don't know. But if you haven't subscribed to
- 1:23:18Courtroom Confidential, I invite you to do that.
- 1:23:20It's great, great channel. Josh and Tiff are terrific so.
- 1:23:26Check that out tomorrow. In fact, I will try to remember
- 1:23:29that to make my. Video auto forward over to
- 1:23:32Josh's video. OK with that, I shall bid you
- 1:23:37adieu and I hope you take care of yourselves.
- 1:23:40I'll see you on the next one. Thank you very much for watching
- 1:23:44this video. If you liked what you saw,
- 1:23:46please consider subscribing. And if you have any questions or
- 1:23:49comments, please leave them below.