Latest / Distillations | Science History Institute / From Hysteria to Long COVID: Invisible Illnesses
Transcript
- 0:01From the Science History Institute.
- 0:03I'm Alexis Pedrick, and this is our new season of Distillations,
- 0:07American Vice: Risk, Science, and the American Experience.
- 0:13This episode is an interview with medical anthropologist Emily Mendenhall
- 0:18about her book, Invisible Illness: A History From Hysteria to Long COVID.
- 0:24We filmed this interview in our studio, and you can watch
- 0:27it on our YouTube channel at youtube.com/sciencehistoryinstitute.
- 0:34We talked with Emily about the long history of dismissing
- 0:37patients with mysterious illnesses.
- 0:40How, when medical symptoms are hard to explain, patients are often
- 0:45told it must be in their head.
- 0:47We also talked about hysteria, neurasthenia, chronic fatigue
- 0:52syndrome, and long COVID denialism.
- 0:59Hi, Emily, thanks for coming.
- 1:01Hi.
- 1:01Thanks for the invitation.
- 1:02Awesome.
- 1:03Well, I'm excited to get into this conversation, but first, I
- 1:08always want to know from people what made you write this book?
- 1:14Oh, that's such a good question.
- 1:16I actually have been studying chronic illness for 20 years.
- 1:20And I started at Cook County Hospital in Chicago even before I started my PhD and
- 1:26I was working on this project on chronic illness among women—Mexican women—often
- 1:31undocumented, living with diabetes.
- 1:34And I started to figure out that their stories weren't just about
- 1:36the illness pretty quickly.
- 1:40And then I traveled around the world studying diabetes.
- 1:42And then when COVID hit, I ended up really focusing on COVID.
- 1:45I wrote a book called Unmasked: COVID, Community, and the Case of Okoboji, which
- 1:49was about my hometown in northwest Iowa.
- 1:51It was a critique of whiteness in COVID denialism.
- 1:54And then I had a student who got really, really sick from long COVID,
- 1:59and it kind of shifted my orientation of what this pandemic was doing.
- 2:04I think that brings up a really good point because I feel like Long
- 2:09COVID is something I've heard a lot.
- 2:11Like I've heard the term, but I realized I didn't really have any idea what that
- 2:16was until I started reading this book.
- 2:19So for our viewers and listeners at home, like what is Long COVID really?
- 2:27I think the reason why it was so hard to name and diagnose and it is hard
- 2:32to diagnose is that there's a lot of heterogeneity of what Long COVID is.
- 2:38It's a post-viral dysregulation of the body.
- 2:41And the virus triggers existing vulnerabilities and causes different
- 2:49types of manifestation of physical, cognitive and psychological
- 2:54dysregulation in sickness.
- 2:57So a lot of people who are athletes and had undercurrent heart conditions went
- 3:02into AFib after getting COVID, right.
- 3:05And that's a manifestation of Long COVID.
- 3:07Some people had more illness manifestation, kind of like myalgic
- 3:11encephalomyelitis—chronic fatigue syndrome—where they had several
- 3:15combinations of cognitive dysfunction, memory issues, fatigue, migraine, all
- 3:22sorts of collections of conditions.
- 3:24And this was especially disabling for people with autoimmune diseases.
- 3:28So it's not easy to measure and identify.
- 3:33Like diabetes, you look at insulin resistance, right?
- 3:35Right.
- 3:36And it's like, okay, you're pre-diabetic or you're diabetic.
- 3:39These are your numbers.
- 3:41But there's not really a test or a rash to identify Long COVID.
- 3:45So it's a little bit less clear.
- 3:47You have a lot of stories from people in the book and I was struck by how
- 3:53different everyone's experience was.
- 3:56And I was thinking, like: oh my gosh, I heard this term and I assumed it was
- 4:01just like, “oh, okay, you have these four things and then that's Long COVID.” So
- 4:06no, this was really, really interesting.
- 4:09And when you started the book, you framed it in a way I
- 4:12thought was really interesting.
- 4:14One of the first things you said really early on was that you hold
- 4:18two things in this book to be true about patients and clinicians.
- 4:23And I was wondering if you could talk a little bit about what those two things
- 4:26were and why they were important, because it struck me that they seemed like
- 4:30they could possibly be opposing things.
- 4:34I think that's what was so striking about the research for this book and about
- 4:40how it's been received a little bit.
- 4:42I wrote the book so it would be an empowering advocacy book for patients.
- 4:47But also in a way that physicians would take it seriously because so many
- 4:51physicians I spoke to in my orbit where like Long COVID isn't really real, right?
- 4:55Again and again and again.
- 4:57And it was really kind of upsetting after a while, after
- 5:00hearing so many patients' stories.
- 5:03And I think that it proves something to us about medicine that they're not training.
- 5:07Medicine doesn't train you to look at complexity, which Long COVID
- 5:12pulls back the curtains to how complex chronic illness really is.
- 5:16And it's a good example and critique of medicine.
- 5:18So the two things I hold true are that when you have a complex chronic
- 5:23illness and one that's not common, you often become one of the most
- 5:27educated person about your condition because you have a primary diagnosis.
- 5:32But there's often a cluster, like a Venn diagram of conditions that co-occur.
- 5:37So you've probably done a ton of research.
- 5:39You've obviously had your unique embodied experience.
- 5:43So bringing that to the clinician really matters.
- 5:45And patients need to be understood, which I argue in the book, but also with
- 5:50some others that patients need to be knowledge partners in the clinical space.
- 5:54But at the same time, I do think that clinicians really want
- 5:57to care for their patients.
- 5:59And I do think they really care.
- 6:00And I think many clinicians feel overwhelmed and kind of at a loss, which
- 6:07is really hard for clinicians who are often used to being the authority figures.
- 6:11And sure, there are many physicians who are humble enough
- 6:14to be like: I just don't know.
- 6:15I need to share this.
- 6:17But I think a lot of clinicians, because of the expectation that they will have
- 6:21an answer, get defensive or punt the patient away and patients feel dismissed.
- 6:27So I think really understanding this vulnerability—there's always more
- 6:31to the story with how people feel.
- 6:33But I think this is really at the heart of the issue, which I call
- 6:37structural silencing, where there are all of these structural issues where
- 6:41people, patients and clinicians have very short periods of time to connect.
- 6:46Which is a structural problem of our profit-based medical system.
- 6:49At the same time, clinicians don't have the education to really
- 6:54understand in a deep way what these patients are going through.
- 6:58So that confluence really makes people feel completely dismissed.
- 7:03You have this other term and I'm hoping that you can define it for us.
- 7:07You talk about “mind-body.”
- 7:09Yeah.
- 7:09Well, I mean, the mind is of the body and the body is of the mind.
- 7:13And when you think about the gut, where a lot of people have symptoms,
- 7:17the gut is the enteric nervous system.
- 7:19It is the second brain.
- 7:21So I think it's easy, especially in American culture, to kind of think about
- 7:25the mind and body as different things.
- 7:27And I mean, there's stigmas around mental illness, for example, that people
- 7:32want to dismiss, but it's impossible to untangle the complexities of complex
- 7:38chronic illness without realizing how deeply embedded psycho-physiologically
- 7:43these conditions are.
- 7:44We know that there are theories that SARS-CoV-2 sits just like
- 7:49herpes virus or Epstein Barr virus.
- 7:51The virus sits on the nervous system, and that's one of the places it hides
- 7:55or it hides in the tissues, which is why we can't measure it in the blood.
- 7:59And it dysregulates the nervous system, which explains some of the symptoms.
- 8:03It's one of many theories.
- 8:04There's all sorts of biological theories and therapies that are emerging for
- 8:09different manifestations of Long COVID.
- 8:11Some people have been able to get better and some people are still struggling.
- 8:15And it just shows the depth of complexity, but also the breadth of
- 8:20symptomatology that people are having.
- 8:22For sure.
- 8:23You had this really great metaphor around thresholds that COVID is the
- 8:28thing that once you're over that threshold, then it's like all of
- 8:32these other things start to erupt.
- 8:35And I thought that was really, really interesting because again, I guess I'm
- 8:40just so used to thinking of illness as like: you have these four symptoms.
- 8:45They're checked on this list.
- 8:47And once you have all of them or three out of four, then you've got it.
- 8:51We give you the medicine, you're done.
- 8:53And that's not the case in any of this, really.
- 8:57Nothing is quite that straightforward.
- 9:00Yeah.
- 9:00And you know, there are some people who are so severely disabled from
- 9:04this condition that whatever they do or have done, they're still
- 9:08bed bound and absolutely forgotten by the medical establishment.
- 9:12Which is really severe and horrifying.
- 9:15There are others who have gotten well.
- 9:19It's not by eliminating COVID, SARS-CoV-2 from the body.
- 9:23We don't have a way—like herpes virus, for example—we don't have
- 9:25a way of getting rid of it or directly necessarily minimizing it.
- 9:31Although for sure Valcyclovir and other medications can push it down.
- 9:36Some people have found ways to overcome the condition.
- 9:39Sometimes it's time, sometimes it's multiple therapies—physical therapies of
- 9:45the body attacking different symptoms.
- 9:47And sometimes it is mind-body interventions.
- 9:50And actually the influence of mind-body I think is something that
- 9:55some really, really sick patients are quite frustrated about talking about.
- 10:00They don't want to recognize that some people have gotten
- 10:03well through this kind of complex array, specifically targeting the
- 10:07psychophysiology, because they haven't.
- 10:09And I think that conflation is really, really hard.
- 10:15So there's a lot in here that I think for me as a history person/nerd
- 10:22person was really fascinating and helped me wrap my head around this.
- 10:30You have this really great quote where you say: part of the myths we
- 10:34believe about Long COVID, in fact, are rooted in centuries old misogyny
- 10:40encapsulated in theories of hysteria.
- 10:43And so I'm wondering, for people who are unfamiliar, what really is hysteria?
- 10:48Because I think it's permeated pop culture.
- 10:50I feel like people have heard it.
- 10:52But when we say “hysteria,” what did that diagnosis [mean]
- 10:59? I mean, if we think 4000 years ago when women would be sick their sickness
- 11:04would be attributed to their womb.
- 11:06Or one's “wandering uterus” is a favorite saying.
- 11:09As it does.
- 11:11But because such little attention and really legitimacy has been given to
- 11:15women and women's suffering, women for so long have been dismissed and
- 11:21undermined in what is actually going on.
- 11:24And that is part of the reason why we don't actually know how a
- 11:27lot of medicines affect women in older age, as well as in pregnancy,
- 11:32because they're dismissed or ignored.
- 11:34But the hysteria diagnostic and cultural frame, which we know has
- 11:40long just been used to dismiss women and undermine women's realities
- 11:44because women and men are different.
- 11:46Women of all different backgrounds are different and really taking seriously
- 11:51women's legitimacy requires us to confront this really misogynistic framework.
- 11:57Right.
- 11:58Because there's this—it blew my mind when I read this—you were
- 12:03talking about how MS in women was originally just called hysteria.
- 12:10Like it was just diagnosed as hysteria.
- 12:12And I was struggling to wrap my head around that because it seems like there
- 12:17are so many clear physical symptoms.
- 12:20There are so many clear things that tell you this is not someone who's
- 12:24just overwhelmed by their feelings or thinking too many thoughts.
- 12:31And I've been wondering, like, why our first instinct—and I think you've sort
- 12:36of touched on this already, we dismiss women—wasn't to say, “oh, this is a real
- 12:43disease?” Like this is a real thing that's happening instead of MS is just hysteria?
- 12:51Well, I think hysteria is linked to this idea of an imagined condition, something
- 12:56that's functional, something that is real and physical but has no biological origin.
- 13:01And I think that's why MS is a great example.
- 13:03I'm glad you brought that up.
- 13:05Where MS transitioned within the field of medicine?
- 13:08When they were able to actually see plaques in the brain.
- 13:12And it shows you the power of what a diagnostic and a physical
- 13:15marker of the condition does.
- 13:17Now, many Long COVID patients will tell you that they have multiple
- 13:21physical markers of dysregulation that reveals how sick they are.
- 13:25I mean, there's even some tests that show that people's mitochondria
- 13:28are lagging who have Long COVID.
- 13:30Like mitochondria is the energy, the battery of the cell, right?
- 13:35So yeah, there's amazing biological evidence that shows that
- 13:39people's bodies are dysregulated.
- 13:42But the difference with MS is that there is a clear marker in the brain
- 13:46that can be used as a diagnostic.
- 13:49And going into the clinical setting, we don't have that yet for Long
- 13:53COVID, which makes it really hard for patients to be taken seriously.
- 13:57Right, right.
- 14:01You talked about—I thought this was really interesting—Jean-Martin Charcot
- 14:09and Freud and the impact of their theories on hysteria.
- 14:15Because I feel like Charcot sort of did this 180 and went from like: oh, this has
- 14:22some shape, this has some reality to it, there must be something going on here.
- 14:26To defaulting to: oh, it's in your mind, it's in your brain.
- 14:32It's not really real.
- 14:33And I guess women were not considered reliable reporters of their own symptoms.
- 14:42Like if you said you felt something, no one took it seriously?
- 14:47Which I still think happens.
- 14:50I think that piece of the book is really interesting as a cultural framework to
- 14:54think about how—let's be honest—there were probably women working on the
- 14:59team who were never recognized and whose ideas were probably stolen.
- 15:03And Charcot started off by actually thinking about the neurology.
- 15:07He's a neurologist and was really interested in looking
- 15:09at biological markers.
- 15:11And Freud, when he started working with him, really shifted this
- 15:15narrative to focus on trauma, right?
- 15:17And to focus on the kind of social and psychological aspects that
- 15:22contribute to this framework and this experience—this embodied experience.
- 15:26So it's interesting to look at the power and influence of Freud in that framework.
- 15:31But I'm not the expert on this area.
- 15:35I told that part of the story, in part because thinking about how the
- 15:39cultural framework around hysteria has shifted—between biological reality
- 15:44and social phenomenon or psychological phenomenon—is really important to
- 15:48understand how people have been trying to understand this condition.
- 15:52And how the shift to "misbelieving" or undermining women's truth,
- 15:57to trying to identify this real biological reality has a long history.
- 16:05We're doing that now with Long COVID.
- 16:07We're still doing it.
- 16:09And with more sophisticated tests there
- 16:13is real biological [evidence] . Long COVID is a real condition.
- 16:16It's just not the same for everyone.
- 16:18And it gets us back to this idea of medicine.
- 16:21And, you know, in the 1800s, medicine was obviously still developing,
- 16:25but there were more broader inclusive, holistic frameworks.
- 16:28And medicine itself as a practice has consistently become more narrow.
- 16:34Yeah.
- 16:36You talk about this guy George Miller Beard and he—first of all,
- 16:42it's kind of like hysteria, but I guess men can get it now too?
- 16:47And then he says that parts of it are specific to America
- 16:53or the American experience.
- 16:55And so I'm wondering if we could talk a little bit about what this
- 16:59illness is and why it was so closely connected to the American experience.
- 17:07I think this one reason you and I are connecting on this
- 17:10is because you're a historian.
- 17:11I'm an anthropologist, right?
- 17:13And, you know, I never think about illness in terms of just biology or psychology.
- 17:20It's interesting to see as illnesses emerge.
- 17:23So I studied diabetes for years, I was still interested in diabetes.
- 17:27You know, it emerged in the West post-World War Two with the surge
- 17:31of processed foods and the changing of the way we live in the world.
- 17:36And, you know, in the 80s and 90s as international corporate targeting of
- 17:41processed foods shifted to lower end and middle income countries, we also
- 17:45saw those shifts in disease there.
- 17:47So as we saw these shifts in industrialization, the ways in
- 17:52which we lived in our bodies and our minds shifted, too.
- 17:55And I think that's why this American way of stress is really important
- 17:58to think about because we're such an individualistic culture.
- 18:04It's so deeply ingrained in how this culture is framed.
- 18:08Although there's the American way of stress, but what
- 18:11does it mean to be American?
- 18:14We're such a multiethnic community—democracy, hopefully—that we
- 18:18believe in and that's the beauty of it.
- 18:21But there is this overarching frame of hustle, and especially in a country
- 18:27that has such a minimal safety net.
- 18:29And such increasingly independent expectations of
- 18:35what it means to be successful.
- 18:38This culture and hustle has really undermined people's well-being.
- 18:43So that's why the neurasthenia story matters so much is that, you know,
- 18:47hysteria specifically rooted in European frames of neurology from the biological
- 18:53to the social frameworks, then shifted.
- 18:55And neurasthenia was really focused on this American way of stress and “how does
- 18:59this manifest?” But recognizing that it was also—post-conflict—how men as well
- 19:06as women, although of course it was quite differentiated, we're experiencing
- 19:12these deeply psycho-physiological responses to a changing world.
- 19:16Yeah.
- 19:18You bring this up with Long COVID too, because you say that it's sort
- 19:24of revisiting that conversation of: what does it mean to be
- 19:29American and to be part of America?
- 19:33I think you have this great line: when your engine is depleted, right?
- 19:36Like if you can't be a cog in the machine, if you can't be part of this industrial
- 19:43revolution then what are you really?
- 19:48I mean, there's so many interesting metaphors with that.
- 19:51As I was reading that work, I was just kind of struck by the mechanization
- 19:55and building and history of America, as well as the framework in
- 20:00medicine [of] the body as a machine.
- 20:02And those parallels show how biomedicine is a reflection of culture.
- 20:09And how biomedicine has adapted to function in a way to interpret
- 20:13our bodies to keep going.
- 20:14Right?
- 20:15How do you fix this ailment, fix this symptom to patch you
- 20:20up, but not to get to the root?
- 20:22And I think that's why in biomedicine, there's such an undermining of other
- 20:27systemic practices of medicine, like Chinese medicine or Ayurvedic medicine.
- 20:31And dismissal of that kind of slow systemic healing is because
- 20:38medicine is “hurry up and fix it.” And that is a cultural reflection
- 20:43of what it means to be American.
- 20:45And I feel like there's a class element too.
- 20:48Because I was struck when you were talking about this broader
- 20:54frame in 19th century medicine.
- 20:59You talk about S. Weir Mitchell prescribing things like art and literature
- 21:04and nature and like taking long rests.
- 21:07And it just struck me.
- 21:10He says this thing about people getting sick from this because of
- 21:14things that are inherent to them, like “being thin” and “lacking blood.” And
- 21:24I guess it struck me—the sort of classism in it—because, well, yes, if you're a
- 21:30wealthy person, probably a woman who's ill, okay, well, yes, take some rest.
- 21:38Go look at some art.
- 21:39Go look at some literature.
- 21:40But I don't think it was being evenly done across the board.
- 21:45If you were a poor woman and had those same symptoms, you—
- 21:48Were just completely dismissed.
- 21:50Right.
- 21:50Well, that element was so interesting, which I do juxtapose later in the book
- 21:55when I talk about the current moment, because I interviewed an old friend
- 21:58of mine who's a nurse practitioner.
- 22:01And I was asking her about Long COVID and she serves a wide gamut from high,
- 22:05middle, and low income folks in Chicago.
- 22:08And she's like: Long COVID isn't really real.
- 22:11I mean, what can you do for people?
- 22:13She's like: most people, especially poor folks who are really struggling,
- 22:17they can't afford to rest.
- 22:19They can't afford to stop hustling.
- 22:21They don't have a safety net to get better.
- 22:24So they're going to work hard until they can't anymore.
- 22:28And she's like: so what good does it do to give them a Long COVID diagnosis?
- 22:32And so I think of the class framing because of our lack of safety net
- 22:36and it's so hard to get disability.
- 22:38One woman I interviewed was staying with her dad, who was pretty abusive to her
- 22:42because he didn't believe she was sick.
- 22:43She was like: you know what?
- 22:45My lawyer keeps telling me that I should just be homeless because
- 22:48then I could get disability.
- 22:50But I can't imagine being this sick on the streets.
- 22:52I mean, that's America.
- 22:54And that's a problem.
- 22:56Yeah.
- 22:57I mean, I found it interesting how so often we're talking about science.
- 23:04We're talking about medicine, right?
- 23:05We're talking about all these things with disease and tests
- 23:08and bodies and what happens.
- 23:10And yet money and class keeps coming back into the conversation.
- 23:17You have a section that's really interesting on chronic fatigue syndrome.
- 23:21And I felt like class came back up in that again as well.
- 23:25I'm wondering if maybe we could talk about that for a minute?
- 23:28Yeah, I think the really huge challenge with chronic fatigue is simply the fact
- 23:34that insurance companies completely undermine people's suffering.
- 23:39And those who are able to continuously pay out of pocket for treatments are
- 23:46able to be on a journey to get better.
- 23:49And those who can't are really suffering because insurance companies do not cover
- 23:53most things that will help you get better.
- 23:55So those who can try different treatments and experiment and pay out of pocket
- 24:00have more opportunity to get better.
- 24:02And I was actually just speaking with a friend of mine yesterday whose
- 24:07daughter is doing a new treatment.
- 24:09She's like: it's just we couldn't do it earlier because we've been
- 24:12saving up money to pay for it.
- 24:13It's thousands and thousands of dollars.
- 24:16It's also like the chronic Lyme chapter where insurance companies are the
- 24:21invisible partner in the clinical space that's saying: we'll pay for treatment
- 24:26if you go by these guidelines, but not if you go by these guidelines.
- 24:30And that undermines people's ability to try everything to get better and
- 24:36live in this really intense culture.
- 24:38Absolutely.
- 24:39And it also felt like almost from jump—because it starts with a girls
- 24:47basketball team, right, that gets sick?
- 24:49Is that the first?
- 24:51And so it seemed like from jump, they weren't really inclined
- 24:56to take it very seriously.
- 24:58I'm not sure if people know the story, but it felt like from the very beginning, they
- 25:06were like: this is probably hysterical.
- 25:09Like this is probably a little “made up.”
- 25:12Well, even in the CDC, and I think the CDC was built and
- 25:16framed around infectious disease.
- 25:18So it's understanding of the acute, of outbreak, of immediate
- 25:22response—obviously it's changed and they do all sorts of complex chronic
- 25:26conditions, food, all sorts of work, really, really important work.
- 25:31But there was a culture of medicine and clinicians who were working
- 25:35in outbreak response in the Epidemic Intelligence Service, who
- 25:37didn't believe that it was real.
- 25:40So there was a lot of joking.
- 25:41So these young practitioners kind of went there without knowledge or already having
- 25:47a bias, but this is how the story is told.
- 25:51And this is actually just one story of outbreaks that have shown great evidence
- 25:58of post-viral disabling conditions.
- 26:01But this story specifically has cultural significance because of the EIS officers.
- 26:07And because it led to the CDC working group around chronic fatigue syndrome and
- 26:13the fact that very few women had voices at that time, very few women were consulted.
- 26:18And that particular study that was the basis of the diagnosis didn't include
- 26:23anyone who had comorbidities, which we know from post-viral conditions
- 26:27that those with comorbidities have more severe presentations.
- 26:30And it was just this small collection of sick white women
- 26:35who didn't have comorbidities.
- 26:37And so that sort of framing was really limiting when there were 200 people and
- 26:42they included like 15 in their study.
- 26:47You talk about it being sort of like a disease or a descriptor that nobody wants.
- 26:53And I love how in the book you weave between the history and
- 26:58between these current cases.
- 27:00And that struck me when you were talking about the case about Lena and FND.
- 27:04And so I was wondering if you could talk a little bit about her experience
- 27:08and what FND is or why she might not want to have it be applied to her.
- 27:15I ended up including this in the book because so many women at
- 27:19some point were told they had functional neurological disorder.
- 27:23And a functional conditions indicates that there's no biological cause,
- 27:27that it's a kind of somatic expression of social or psychological distress.
- 27:32And many patients with ME or Long COVID or Lyme are told at some
- 27:39point that it's probably functional, meaning it's not of biological origin.
- 27:42And why that's so upsetting is because people know their own illness trajectory.
- 27:48And as I said, patients are probably the most knowledgeable about their
- 27:51condition than any clinician.
- 27:52And so they know that things started to dysregulate after having an infection
- 27:57and they know the physical symptoms.
- 27:59And, you know, people living with chronic illness often do get anxiety
- 28:03and depression or some or PTSD due to their social experiences
- 28:07of living with the illness.
- 28:09It's a very common experience, but rarely is that the cause
- 28:14of this kind of dysregulation.
- 28:16And so people get really frustrated because if you put
- 28:18FND in your medical chart.
- 28:20Doctors later will not take you seriously, and they will not take your
- 28:24search for a biological resolution.
- 28:26And the one thing that patients want is to figure out a one
- 28:29size fits all intervention.
- 28:32And I talk in the second part of the book a lot about how ME activists
- 28:36and Long COVID activists have framed their struggle around HIV activism.
- 28:41And HIV was incredible because the AIDS activist movement was able within five
- 28:47years to get antiretroviral therapy.
- 28:49And that's what a lot of people want is this type of therapy or intervention
- 28:54that can help them get out of bed and actually live in the world.
- 28:59Especially the most severe patients.
- 29:03So that's why the FND diagnosis is so devastating.
- 29:07It's because it can mean that clinicians will no longer take your chart seriously.
- 29:12So it can be really a harmful diagnosis for someone in this position.
- 29:17And it's interesting because you even talked about cases
- 29:21where people had cancer, right?
- 29:27So I lost my mother to breast cancer.
- 29:31And I was thinking about it as I was reading.
- 29:33Because there were a couple cases where people either had previously been sick or
- 29:38when they got Long COVID—I think there was one guy in particular who also then got
- 29:42stage four cancer while he was also sick.
- 29:46But cancer is “real” for lack of a better term, right?
- 29:50We take that as like: oh, yes, okay, we know what cancer is.
- 29:53We understand what that is.
- 29:55That's a real thing that we can give you treatment for.
- 29:58And it just struck me—the dichotomy of those two things next to each other.
- 30:02That here's something where you're suffering, but there's no mechanism
- 30:07really to treat you for it, not because nothing's happening to you, but because
- 30:12we don't have a diagnosis or I guess our system isn't set up for that or…
- 30:17Well, first, I'm sorry about your mother.
- 30:19[It] must have been difficult.
- 30:22The increasing number of cancer diagnoses among Long COVID patients
- 30:28is a conversation that's happening in the Long COVID community.
- 30:33And we don't really understand why.
- 30:35But Ty, the story you brought up, he was one of the first people who I spoke
- 30:41with who was diagnosed with cancer.
- 30:44I spoke with him many times and he's a very public figure.
- 30:46He has his own blog about his Long COVID experience and
- 30:49he's a really interesting guy.
- 30:52But he was like: you know, we don't really know what's happening, why so
- 30:56many of us are developing advanced cancers, most likely because our
- 31:00immune systems are so depleted.
- 31:02And you know, who knows, maybe therapies are causing it?
- 31:05Maybe underlying conditions.
- 31:08But I think there needs to be—and I know people are starting to pay attention to
- 31:11intense studies about what is happening.
- 31:14But besides the biology and understanding what happens, there is
- 31:17a very different social experience, which you were talking about.
- 31:20Because with cancer, it's easy to identify and diagnose.
- 31:23And there's also—because of that diagnosis and because of our extensive exposure and
- 31:27understanding of cancer—we have treatment that is funded by insurance, right?
- 31:33So if you have cancer, you can get treated.
- 31:36And it's kind of like early on in studies, actually in work on HIV if you were
- 31:43able to be diagnosed with HIV, then like all of your other care could be funded.
- 31:50Or if you have a diagnosis of diabetes, for example.
- 31:53And at Cook County, some people were really relieved to get a
- 31:57diagnosis of diabetes because they didn't have health insurance.
- 32:00They had Medicaid or maybe nothing, but they would be cared for at the
- 32:03public hospital because they had a diagnostic that was recognized and
- 32:07covered under insurance or some sort of system that could pay for their care.
- 32:11And so the cancer diagnosis provided that.
- 32:14And I think that's really troubling.
- 32:17And it's another example of the mechanisms of American medicine that
- 32:22is so focused on money that we are unable to care for people, right?
- 32:27That it's a very it's a very stratified system.
- 32:31It's so difficult.
- 32:32Yeah.
- 32:36And you kind of touched on this in the beginning, but people with chronic
- 32:41illness—it's not really like you're cured in most cases, you're kind of
- 32:47just living with a lot of symptoms.
- 32:50And it strikes me that we don't really know what to do with that.
- 32:56If you're just sort of living with illness, where's the magic button?
- 33:01How do we fix that machine?
- 33:04And I was wondering, how does that tie people?
- 33:08Because you have a really robust section about activism, living with that—how
- 33:13does that tie people to medical activism?
- 33:16Yeah.
- 33:16Well, I think actually the activism part is really interesting.
- 33:19And I was so struck by the incredible support that people were able to
- 33:24receive and provide digitally.
- 33:27Actually, not in the book, but I have done some of the first
- 33:29studies on Long COVID in Kenya.
- 33:31I have a really close colleague, Edna Bosire, who's a medical anthropologist.
- 33:35She's Kenyan, and she led the studies I supported.
- 33:38And there was this woman, who was part of the body politic organizing from
- 33:44early on in the pandemic, from Nairobi.
- 33:46She was U.S. educated and engaged in these international networks.
- 33:51And she actually started a Long COVID support group for
- 33:53those who were sick in Kenya.
- 33:56But it was a very closed private group because the social experience of living
- 34:00with the condition is very misunderstood and also kind of underground.
- 34:06That's like an extraordinary, beautiful case where someone was able to connect
- 34:10digitally in a way that they probably would have felt really isolated before.
- 34:15And that digital connection, which you can connect from your home,
- 34:18for example, rather than needing to go out and be in a specific
- 34:25place can be really transformative.
- 34:27And I also argue in the book that although it's incredibly supportive,
- 34:32there's definitely—like all activist movements—there's infighting and
- 34:37there's a struggle for legitimacy or who's better at organizing.
- 34:41But there's also some difficulty I think, in the discussions that
- 34:45happen when people feel really legitimized within that digital
- 34:48space and they feel really empowered.
- 34:51They bring all of their knowledge and reflection and understanding to the
- 34:56clinic and the doctor is not ready for it.
- 34:59And that's why if we were to actually provide care, we need
- 35:02doctors—clinical spaces—and maybe these are brokers, maybe the people
- 35:08really leading this care are nurses.
- 35:11But we need spaces where people can be open to how patients are
- 35:14understanding their illness in a deep way and without judgment.
- 35:18Because clinicians are like: “stop, this doesn't make sense,” because
- 35:22they don't understand what the patient is going through, not only
- 35:26physically or psychologically or emotionally or socially, but also
- 35:29their deep struggle to understand.
- 35:32And that is a huge part of having a rare disease or a less visible condition.
- 35:38It's harder to explain and engage around your condition with your clinician.
- 35:44And I think that really is a form of subjugation for a lot of patients.
- 35:48I mean, it feels like legitimacy is such a huge part of diagnosis, of
- 35:57getting care, of this story overall.
- 36:00And I was thinking about the section [where] you write a lot about pain.
- 36:05And pain is kind of subjective in a way, right?
- 36:10Like pain is inside you.
- 36:11We kind of feel like we have a sense that we can tell from the outside
- 36:15looking in how much pain is going on.
- 36:19But you were talking about a jury case you were on.
- 36:25And I'm wondering if you can tell that story because I think it really
- 36:30exemplifies some of the things about pain that we struggle with.
- 36:33Yeah.
- 36:34I thought it was really interesting because I was at the
- 36:36tail end of writing the book.
- 36:38And I was called in for jury duty and I was still on sabbatical.
- 36:42So I was like: Oh?
- 36:42Fun.
- 36:43Like, I'm a very nosy, interested person in everything.
- 36:46So I was like: Oh, what's this gonna be?
- 36:48And everyone was like: No, they never put PhDs on a jury.
- 36:51You're never gonna get picked.
- 36:52But I went and I was really excited and I was picked and I was like, yes—
- 36:55This is my time.
- 36:56I was very excited.
- 36:58And I think that they picked me because I was like: well, I do health equity work.
- 37:04And it was a woman who had a kind of an equity issue.
- 37:09And the case is really interesting because she worked in corrections for most of
- 37:15her career and she had many injuries.
- 37:19She was thrown against the wall.
- 37:20She had fallen, she had back injuries, neck injuries, arm
- 37:24injuries, you know, it's a tough job.
- 37:26It's a very physical job.
- 37:28And then after a while, she's like: I can't do this.
- 37:32But she still wanted to work for the county and so she got a job driving a bus.
- 37:38And she got in a car accident and she suffered.
- 37:42She had really intense pain and sciatica and took a really long time to heal.
- 37:48And she still was in pain.
- 37:50And she was basically saying: I want Worker's Compensation.
- 37:56And the defense, who was trying to not give her Worker's
- 38:01Compensation had an image of the accident and it was a subtle hit.
- 38:07And she hit and went like this and then afterward got up and walked away.
- 38:12And they're like: look, she's not even hurt.
- 38:14When we were in deliberation, I was like: but we don't know
- 38:19what she's carrying with her.
- 38:20That kind of subtle hit could really cause extraordinary pain and could have
- 38:25unveiled something or pushed her spine, let's say, off in such a deep way.
- 38:31It could have been the straw that broke the camel's back or whatever
- 38:34it is that did cause this deep pain and her inability to do her job.
- 38:38And people are like: oh, but it looks so bad.
- 38:40And I was like: well, why?
- 38:41Literally, can we have a conversation?
- 38:42Why don't we just believe her?
- 38:45Why would she be making this up?
- 38:47And we had this beautiful conversation and it was almost all women.
- 38:51And there's this one guy who was holding out and we all looked at him and were
- 38:54like: do you want to die on this?
- 38:56Why don't you just believe her?
- 38:58And then he was like: let's just believe her.
- 39:01And that was a powerful moment.
- 39:02I thought about what I would have said if I hadn't been spending
- 39:06two years researching this book.
- 39:09But yeah, it was a powerful moment.
- 39:11And then she won the case.
- 39:13Just great.
- 39:14I mean, but it strikes me that so much is built around—and
- 39:20that makes sense for science.
- 39:22So much is built around what's testable, what's verifiable.
- 39:27As you said, what fits a diagnostic criteria and there are lots of reasons,
- 39:32obviously, why that's the case.
- 39:33And that makes sense.
- 39:34And I think, you know, we love science, right?
- 39:37But at the same time, when you're in these sort of in-between areas, then
- 39:42it's like: okay, how do we navigate that?
- 39:47And this struck me as one of those sort of in-between areas where we
- 39:53didn't really, as you said, there was no way to go in and break apart a body
- 39:58and be like: Oh, there's the spot.
- 40:01Her spine was realigned, so okay, we understand what happened here.
- 40:06And I think so much of your book is about this in-between area,
- 40:13but also it seems like it really matters who is asking to be believed.
- 40:22Like that feels like a core part of the book.
- 40:25Particularly, the Lyme disease chapter is really interesting in that way.
- 40:29And I'm wondering if, from a historical standpoint, that seems
- 40:34like something you've always seen.
- 40:36Does it ebb and flow?
- 40:38Are we at a moment where we're sort of back at the height of looking
- 40:45at who's asking questions and whether or not they're legitimate?
- 40:48I guess I sort of assumed we live in the future and the
- 40:52future would be less judgmental.
- 40:54The future will be—fantastical thinking, right?
- 41:01But I—
- 41:02I thought that a few years ago.
- 41:05But does that feel like something that we've sort of always done in
- 41:09like medical diagnosis is think about who the patient is, who's asking?
- 41:14I think the struggle is centuries long.
- 41:17And I would say that racial, gender, class discrimination based on
- 41:24ability, disability, nationality.
- 41:29All of these complexities that build and influence who people are and how they're
- 41:33perceived in that moment really matters.
- 41:36And there's a whole world that envelopes one clinical engagement.
- 41:42It influences who that person is, who's a clinician, who's coming in to care for you
- 41:46and who you are yourself and what you're bringing into the clinical space, right?
- 41:50So it's hard to just say it is one way or it is another way, because who
- 41:55you're seeing plays a fundamental role in how you're believed and cared for.
- 42:01But I think the one thing that we can critique in a very clear way is
- 42:06how profit-driven medicine completely continues to make medicine worse.
- 42:12And that we see again and again how when we monetize certain tests or abilities
- 42:20or diagnostics, it just means we're more limited in how we can really see
- 42:25people and how we can care for them and take their suffering seriously.
- 42:30So I think we need to start by reimagining health insurance.
- 42:34And this is such a radical idea in America, because
- 42:39America is all about profit.
- 42:42But there are so many models of health care innovation or structures,
- 42:47health financing structures such as nonprofit insurance
- 42:51companies that could be radically transformative for our health system.
- 42:57And I think that kind of non-monetizing clinical care would dramatically
- 43:03shift how we even see people.
- 43:06And it's hard to imagine things getting better until some of these
- 43:11structural issues really change.
- 43:15So what is the role of capitalism in America's response to COVID-19
- 43:26and then to Long COVID as well?
- 43:30I think it's really interesting to see how Americans responded to
- 43:33COVID-19 to instruct us about how people are responding to Long COVID.
- 43:40There's a story in almost a meta-narrative of my book, Unmasked:
- 43:45COVID, Community, and the Case of Okoboji, which is about how a small town
- 43:49in northwest Iowa responded to COVID.
- 43:52I grew up in Okoboji, Iowa, the small town in the middle of
- 43:55nowhere, and my brother-in-law, who actually grew up in Connecticut, was
- 43:58leading the public health response.
- 44:00He's a family doc and has an MPH, and he's the head of public health.
- 44:06And I got there in the middle of an outbreak.
- 44:08And having come from D.C. where, you know, there were actually
- 44:11police outside the grocery store.
- 44:14You couldn't go in without having a mask on.
- 44:18And arriving in a place where some people actually never went into quarantine.
- 44:23And people were pretty angry about quarantine and wanted to
- 44:27just kind of get on with life.
- 44:29And arriving in the middle of an outbreak, I was struck by the differences.
- 44:32And being someone who works a lot in the public health space,
- 44:35I was like: what is happening?
- 44:36So my brother-in-law was doing all this hard work and it felt
- 44:39like no one was listening.
- 44:40So you know what I did?
- 44:41I threw together a study, I got IRB [approval] , and I started
- 44:45interviewing everyone I knew because I wanted to get to the heart of it.
- 44:48And the objective was to understand what the heck was happening.
- 44:52So I did over 100 interviews.
- 44:54I think most people talked to me because we hadn't talked
- 44:56since high school graduation.
- 44:57And they're like: What's going on with you?
- 44:59And I'm like: What do you think about COVID?
- 45:00They're like: Can we talk about something else?
- 45:04Which was actually just really a fun thing.
- 45:06But what I learned over time, and I didn't end up thinking about writing
- 45:11a book until much later, I was thinking about it in this broader way.
- 45:15I found out that actually people did come together.
- 45:17It's a small tourist town and they always talk about the 100 days of summer.
- 45:23And so many people rely on those 100 days to make money to feed
- 45:29their families for the whole year.
- 45:30So if you take a step back and think about it, sure, people did
- 45:34not come together for the health and for the most vulnerable among us.
- 45:38And there are several people who I interviewed who said: you know, “I
- 45:41got sick,” or “I went to the bars to get sick, to build my own immunity.
- 45:45But then I got my grandpa sick, or my brother sick or my dad's
- 45:47sick and they died.” Or they became extraordinarily sick.
- 45:53And I felt bad.
- 45:54But what I realized, taking a step back, and this was something that
- 45:57Trump was saying again and again.
- 46:00And I think the local political and business leaders were
- 46:02echoing that—was that we need to protect our economic security.
- 46:06And so I think the whole community did come together around the economy.
- 46:10And some people were even protecting people's lack of regulation
- 46:15around masking, in part to protect those 100 days of summer.
- 46:19And so it's not that people didn't care for each other, but they
- 46:24didn't care about the virus more than they did economic survival.
- 46:27And in a capitalist system with a very limited safety net,
- 46:31I understand those concerns.
- 46:34Those are not the concerns I had at the time.
- 46:37I'm in the field of public health.
- 46:39It was an urgency and I took it very, very seriously.
- 46:43And I also was staying in the basement of my elderly parents home
- 46:48and didn't want to get them sick.
- 46:50And I have two small children, so it was like that whole juggle.
- 46:54So at the time when I was experiencing it, as so many people
- 46:58did, I felt very angry and I didn't understand what was happening.
- 47:02But when you take a step back, it's very clear what was happening.
- 47:06And I think something similar is happening with Long COVID.
- 47:10Our lack of a safety net and our continual, I mean, now we're even
- 47:14withdrawing in profoundly harmful ways funding for Medicaid, for disability, for
- 47:22those people who are most vulnerable among us, just like what happened with COVID.
- 47:27Kind of forgetting those most vulnerable among us to really prioritize the economy.
- 47:32So if we think about how many people are disabled from Long COVID and who's missing
- 47:36from the economy, that's one story.
- 47:39But I think the government is perceiving it as: Who can they carry?
- 47:43And they're not really interested in carrying the sick and the vulnerable
- 47:45just like, increasingly, there were conflicts around caring for the
- 47:50sick and vulnerable during COVID.
- 47:51And so there's a lot of similarities around what it means to be
- 47:54American and what the American government and leaders will do.
- 47:58And I think as we pull to the right, the ideas of individualism and the
- 48:02lack of collectivism continuously puts money above people, profit over people.
- 48:08So this is just something that we have increasingly the tug between
- 48:13this collectivist acceptance of a multi-ethnic democracy and the tug
- 48:19between who we are as bootstrap individualists who can make it on our own.
- 48:24Which is a complete fiction, right?
- 48:26But those two polarized groups within what it means to be a capitalist
- 48:30society is completely intentional, a constant form of tension in America
- 48:37and what it means to be American.
- 48:39So that's what I've observed.
- 48:40And I think that's one of the most instructive observations
- 48:43from COVID and Long COVID.
- 48:45You have this line in the book that I can't stop thinking about.
- 48:49You say something about how COVID is like the lighter fluid that brings everything
- 48:56else out or something like that.
- 48:57Yeah.
- 48:58One of the things that I think is striking and transformative of the
- 49:01Long COVID experience is how many clinicians, nurses, doctors, PAs
- 49:07have become sick with the condition.
- 49:09And I was already thinking about this more generally, but I interviewed
- 49:15this physician who became a Long COVID activist in the science
- 49:19community, leading several of the conversations at the national academies.
- 49:23And when I interviewed her specifically, she said to me: you know, COVID is
- 49:28the lighter fluid that enacts whatever is underlying under the surface.
- 49:33And that had a profound impact on how I thought about the
- 49:37heterogeneity of Long COVID.
- 49:40And I think it was so interesting to interview physicians and
- 49:44clinicians in general with Long COVID, because their perspective
- 49:47was deeply scientific and embodied.
- 49:51And thinking about my own cousin who had COVID-19 and then he went into AFib.
- 49:57His story is so different than someone who I interviewed—a woman,
- 50:01Sam—whose lungs collapsed and she was on a ventilator for a month.
- 50:05And it took her four years to rehabilitate her limbs, her lungs, her cardio.
- 50:14To be able to just live normally and also to reconstruct her emotional
- 50:20well-being because she lost her social life and professional life that she had
- 50:24been on a beautiful journey towards.
- 50:27So the “lighter fluid” comment, I think, is so broad and useful
- 50:32to think about why there's such diversity in how people present.
- 50:37Absolutely.
- 50:39So it strikes me in this book, you talk a lot about [how] Long COVID is
- 50:45not the first time we've had a chronic illness follow up after an outbreak.
- 50:53And so despite the fact that we have many, many years of history of this
- 50:59happening, whether it's Long Flu or these other sorts of examples, despite
- 51:04the fact that we have clinical and scientific evidence that it happened.
- 51:10It seems so odd to me that we would say today: What do you mean Long COVID?
- 51:16That can't possibly be real.
- 51:18That's impossible.
- 51:19I don't understand how that would be the case.
- 51:24I think many ME activists would tell you that it's a cultural problem.
- 51:28I would agree that it's a cultural problem.
- 51:31But I think that it's such a profound cultural problem that is embedded in
- 51:37the training of physicians which then becomes manifest in cultural lore
- 51:43about: what is it to be a clinician?
- 51:45If you look at all these doctor shows, it's all emergent and discrete and clear.
- 51:50And in medicine, I have a mentee who's in medical school now and you know what?
- 51:56One of the things I didn't realize is that people are in
- 52:00medical school to pass the boards.
- 52:02And so they go only to the lectures that they need, that they don't understand,
- 52:06that's going to be on the Boards.
- 52:07Gotcha.
- 52:08But this isn't on the Boards, right?
- 52:10These are the special lectures that people go to that are additionally informative.
- 52:16And that is horrifying because it indicates how deeply broken our training
- 52:24is and how it's really compartmentalized.
- 52:27How do you put the pieces of the machine back together?
- 52:30What is the machine and how do you put it together?
- 52:32I mean, thinking about the cadaver: what is the machine?
- 52:35What are all these parts?
- 52:37And there are spiritual and beautiful parts of that learning process.
- 52:42But the lack of recognition of the complexity in our training
- 52:47systems is a huge problem.
- 52:49And so one of the things that ME Action—this activist organization—has
- 52:54done is they've created a great Teach ME, Treat ME movement where
- 53:00they go into medical schools.
- 53:01And I think they're working with the Mayo Clinic to develop a training
- 53:06session for clinicians to learn how to identify, understand and
- 53:10treat people with these conditions.
- 53:13Wow.
- 53:14So I think that is really the most important thing is to shift the culture
- 53:19because we do have a lot of evidence.
- 53:21And actually a lot of the evidence on the Great Influenza, for example,
- 53:25there's the Famine of the Corns.
- 53:28I think [it's] a really interesting example where after the Great
- 53:30Influenza, there was a whole community who was affected by the
- 53:33virus brought in through transport.
- 53:36So someone who was driving a truck through the countryside—that was a very
- 53:41rural community that got influenza and so many people were disabled from it
- 53:45they couldn't plant the following year.
- 53:48So they call it “Famine of the Corns” because there was a famine
- 53:51due to an extraordinary disability caused from the Great Influenza, and
- 53:56so much so that they couldn't eat.
- 53:58So thinking about how these conditions are measured and understood in certain
- 54:04contexts and made visible, right?
- 54:07Like the Famine of the Corns was made visible by someone
- 54:09identifying it and writing about it and recognizing what it was.
- 54:14So how do we make visible these experiences?
- 54:18Well, it's one of the reasons I wrote the book: really identifying
- 54:23and understanding this long history to shift the culture of medicine.
- 54:27Actually my cousin, John Bowers, is an internal medicine doc in Nashville.
- 54:33And he's like: I just bought a whole stack of books.
- 54:36So when someone has a condition I can't understand, I just give them your book.
- 54:39There you go.
- 54:42That works.
- 54:42So touching.
- 54:44I was like: Thank you so much.
- 54:46But he was also one of those who read the early version of the book.
- 54:49And he's like: I don't see myself here.
- 54:50It has to speak to not just patients, but clinicians.
- 54:53It has to be measured and accessible to clinicians who really don't understand.
- 55:00And so I really tried to write the book for that audience as well as patients.
- 55:04So it means it's not perfect for either community, but it's such a
- 55:09divided and polarized narrative that I tried to find that middle ground.
- 55:16Well, thank you for coming.
- 55:18Thank you.
- 55:19I had so much fun.
- 55:19Good.
- 55:23Distillations podcast is produced by the Science History Institute
- 55:27and recorded in the Laurie J. Landau Digital Production Studios.
- 55:32Our executive producer is Mariel Carr.
- 55:34Our senior producer is Rigoberto Hernandez.
- 55:38This episode was produced by Mariel Carr.
- 55:41It was fact checked by Alexandra Atiya, and the sound design
- 55:45was done by Samia Bouzid.
- 55:48Support for Distillations has been provided by the Middleton Foundation
- 55:52and the Wyncote Foundation.
- 55:54You can find all of our podcasts, as well as our videos and articles on
- 55:58our website at sciencehistory.org.
- 56:01And you can follow us on social media at @scihistoryorg for news about our
- 56:06podcast and everything else going on in our free museum and library.
- 56:11For Distillations, I'm Alexis Pedrick.
- 56:14Thanks for listening.