How To Play Your Cards: Why Getting Kicked Off My D1 Softball Team Was The Best Thing That Ever Happened To Me

GUT TALK with Jill & Jenna · Feb 3, 2026 · 1h 5m

In this episode, we dive into Jill’s powerful journey through competitive athletics — from being recruited for softball at a young age to playing at the Division 1 level, and ultimately facing the life-altering experience of being kicked off her D1 team. Jill opens up about the identity loss, shame, and resilience that followed, and how that moment became a catalyst for deep personal growth. We unpack the lessons she learned about self-worth, discipline, failure, and rebuilding confidence when everything you’ve worked for falls apart. This conversation is about more than sports — it’s about…