Latest / Friendship IRL: Real Talk About Friendship, Community, and What It Actually Takes / How Deep Friendship Can Impact Radical Change with Priya Vulchi
Transcript
- 0:02Podcast Intro/Outro: All right, gang. Here's to nights that turn into mornings and friends that turn into family. Cheers. Hello, hello, and welcome to the Friendship IRL podcast. I'm your host, Alex Alexander. Each week we talk about what is working(and what is not) in our friendships, community and connections. Have you ever wished you could sit down and have a conversation about what is really going on in your friendships? Well, you found your people. Join us as we dive into real life stories and explore new ways to approach these connections. Together, we're reimagining the rules of friendship
- 0:52Alex Alexander [Narration]: You know how we often talk about friendship like it's just nice to have, like it's this sweet, polite thing we do in our spare time. Well, today's conversation is going to flip that idea completely on its head. I'm really excited to introduce you to Priya Vulchi, who's about to help us explore how friendship isn't just about having someone to grab coffee with. It's actually a powerful force for social and political change, and trust me, she knows what she's talking about. Priya Vulchi is the author of good friends, bonds that change us and the world, and her book offers a resounding cry that friendship is vital, not only for our individual well being, but for humanity itself. Now you may know Priya from her first book, Tell Me Who You Are, which she co-authored with one of her closest friends. They went on this cross country road trip where they talked to people about race and identity. You may also know Priya as the co-founder of Choose, a non-profit that she ran with one of her closest friends for over a decade. She was the youngest TED resident ever and was named one of Teen Vogue's "21 Under
- 2:2421: Young People Changing the World." Her work has been featured everywhere from The New York Times to TIME Magazine, and she's currently pursuing her PhD in African and African American Studies at Harvard University as a Presidential Scholar. But here's why I'm particularly excited about this conversation.
- 2:5021: We're diving into this idea that friendship, real, authentic friendship, is actually radical.
- 2:5521: It's not this demure, apolitical thing we've made it out to be.
- 3:0021: It's about seeing the full real version of our friends and letting that change us. You know how we often hear this idea that, like you should care about a certain issue, or if you were a good person, you would care.
- 3:2121: But what if? What if we cared simply because we knew people who were impacted? What if change doesn't happen because there's some heroic figure out there in the world, but rather with the small daily acts of truly understanding our friends, their identities, their struggles, their experiences.
- 3:4521: Because here's what I've learned and what we're going to explore today, you don't want to know what actually gets people to care friendship. What gets people to act friendship? What sustains people during the exhausting work of creating change friendship? What creates that ripple effect of engagement, of people showing up, of communities working together? You guessed it, friendship. I often say that friendship isn't just a nice to have, it's survival. And this conversation with Priya, it's about to show us exactly why.
- 4:29Alex Alexander: Hi, Priya. Hi.
- 4:29Alex Alexander: Thank you so much for being here today and for coming to talk about such an important topic, something you and I both love friendship.
- 4:41Priya Vulchi: I know what a connection it is.
- 4:45Alex Alexander: It is, and I could talk to people about it all day. You too. Yeah, do you ever have your friends who are like, okay, you know, like your obsession with like you're in the moment with your friends?
- 4:58Alex Alexander: Yeah, and you have this aha moment about something that's work related, or you're just so sometimes I feel like I'm so aware that my gratitude is so intense. And they're like, Okay, listen, I know you love me.
- 5:16Alex Alexander: Like, thank you. Thank you.
- 5:18Priya Vulchi: Absolutely I was at a I did a book talk the other day, and someone in the audience was like, when making friends, you know, how do I get them to see friendship in the same way I do? And I had terrible advice, because I was like, I kind of just go up to my friends or like people I have friend crushes on, and I'm like, I really want to be your friend, but in a serious way, my friends since have been like, you're really lucky. We didn't run like
- 5:44Alex Alexander: I do know. I do know. I think that I kept my friend love, my friend obsession for a long time, a little more under wraps. I had a friend of mine, actually, who also does friendship work. I don't have, like, tons of them. She's Seattle local. She DMed me on Instagram randomly, and was like, Wait, you're in Seattle.
- 6:05Alex Alexander: I'm in Seattle. We both do this work. Anyways, we were together, and she was like, you know, your intensity when it comes to acts of service is like, unparalleled. And I think she was trying to give me a compliment, but it was a an awareness moment, like, I think the way that you were so direct to people, I just did it with, really over the top acts of service for a long time, because I didn't know any different. Now I gush, like all the words, all the words, but that's how I did it for a long time.
- 6:44Priya Vulchi: But I hope you didn't lose that first part either, because that's also backing it up with those acts of service, and that action is just as important. I think,
- 6:51Alex Alexander: yeah, I mean, I wouldn't change anything about it. I just didn't realize that's what I was doing. It was a moment of like, Oh, I see myself a little clearer now. Thank you for that mirror, dear friend. I needed that well. As you mentioned, you were at a book talk event. Was it for good friends? Your book for anybody who's listening. You can't see it, but I am holding Priya's beautiful book, Good Friends: Bonds That Change Us and the World, which I have read right before we hopped on this call, I showed her all the highlights and notes, because I think that's one of the wildest things as an author, is like somebody else is holding this thing that you worked a million hours on.
- 7:34Alex Alexander: So congrats on your book being out in the world.
- 7:39Priya Vulchi: Thank you. And yes, it did floor me right before we started recruiting, I was floored to see your highlights and starred little notes in the margins. And yeah, that means a lot
- 7:51Alex Alexander: well, I'm gonna give you one more like recorded praise, which is that this is a beautiful book. Your writing is beautiful. The way you have woven these stories together is going to leave a lasting impression. And then at the core of all of it, there is such an important message that I hope so many people read it really is like I hope you give yourself some extra moment of reflection for that. It's a beautiful book.
- 8:26Alex Alexander: Congrats.
- 8:27Priya Vulchi: Thank you.
- 8:30Alex Alexander: So with that, I want to talk about this book, about some of the things that moved me. So much of what you've written here aligns with things I talk about. But gosh, over 125 episodes in, I don't know if it's a less direct way, it's just like sprinkled in, and that is that friendship is political, like the act of friendship, in and of itself, is revolutionary in the world we live in right now. But I think to understand that what we need to start off with is, can you talk a little bit about kind of the current, modern day definition of friendship, or like, how we approach friendship most people today, not your definition.
- 9:30Alex Alexander: Like, societally, how are people approaching friendship?
- 9:36Priya Vulchi: So with this one, we can go to Aristotle in Nicomachean Ethics, he lays out three kinds of friendship.
- 9:46Priya Vulchi: There's friends of utility, friends of pleasure and friends of virtue, which some translations also translate as perfect friendship. We can get to that later, but the first two friends of utility and friends of pleasure are what he says are most common. In and I think they're still most common today.
- 10:02Priya Vulchi: And so friends of utility could be maybe when people mistake friendship for networking, these people are useful to you. You know, you borrow something from them, then friends of pleasure or friends you party with, hang out with. The bond is like easy and fun and gratifies you in those ways. There's this New Yorker comic that I saw and that I write about in the book where, you know, there's two friends who are meeting after a long time, and they're like, Oh, it was wonderful. They're hugging each other in the comic. And then they say, if you're ever in my borough, on my street, you know, right next to my house, then let's hang out again, you know. And so what friends of utility and friends of pleasure do is their circumstantial and stipulatory relationships. So you might have many people who you call friends, but they only kind of operate out of convenience. An example of that would be if your partner comes visits you and is at the airport, and their flight lands at like, 3am you will go and pick them up. Likely, your kid, your partner, your family member, your friend comes you might just be, like, so excited to see you. I set up the couch for you, you know, let me know when you get in the Uber and so it's this idea that we have friends, but none in the way.
- 11:21Priya Vulchi: Usually we don't love them in the same way we love our people who are biologically and legally fastened to us. So I think that's a common kind of way most people have friends in their life.
- 11:34Alex Alexander: Yeah, you used I'm going to scroll back through my notes now, because I have, in addition to all those notes you saw in the book, Priya, I have pages. I've written notes, but you just used some really direct words. You know, you said, like, friendship today is supposed to be warm and cozy, like demure and polite. And I think that what you're saying perfectly encapsulates that, right? It's like, well, I'm providing the couch and the place to stay, but I won't quite push myself out of my comfort zone enough to go pick you up at the airport at 3am the way I would my partner and I just think for so many people, that's such a reflection point on what are the lengths you'll go in today's definition of friendship,
- 12:34Priya Vulchi: right? And to your point about friendship being political, so we live in a very hyper individualistic and capitalistic society, right? And so the way we're socialized is our self interest really increases over time and gets very strong and bulky. And so the Friends of utility and friends of pleasure, they don't challenge your self interest, right? You're not going to go you're only going to go so far for friends. I mentioned this in the book too, referencing Amelia montuth, who described how, you know, back in the day, if you needed sugar or to borrow a dress or a ride from the airport, you would call on friends to do this, right? But now, if you need sugar, you use Postmates. If you need to borrow a dress, you'll maybe just get one on Amazon. If you need a ride from the airport, you'll go to Uber and so friendship actually relying on friends instead challenges capitalistic models of overconsumption and self reliance and asking friends for those favors. You know, we say no worries, if not like, that's my most common phrase when I text friends like, no worries. Like, can you do this very basic thing, but no worries, you know, can you just respond to this message? No worries, no worries if not. No worries if not. But like, these experiences with friends, leaning on friends in this way and in return, like, showing up for friends in that way. It's a small favorite economy that actually deepens relationships.
- 14:02Priya Vulchi: You know?
- 14:03Alex Alexander: No, I mean, this is exactly where we are going in this episode. Is that, gosh, we're taking such a big topic and trying to distill it down into an hour, as we always do.
- 14:15Alex Alexander: But I think, you know, you read this book that you wrote, and there are multiple places in the book that you talk about how, whether it is in friendship or in politics, it is the small, everyday actions that are adding up over time. You have another phrase that I can't remember.
- 14:38Alex Alexander: I'm using my phrase, but you have another phrase that I underlined like four times in the book. It's this idea that, you know, we're sold these stories. You talk about this in the book of heroes and icons and big, pivotal moments that did it all. And when you were talking about that, I kept thinking. Of, I mean, a million photos from the Civil Rights Movement. I could think of any photo where my eyes go to one political figure, right to Martin Luther King, Jr, but there could be 1000 people in that photo who are all taking little actions.
- 15:14Alex Alexander: And I think there's such a parallel here between those little actions adding up in our friendships and in the way we're approaching politics in general.
- 16:43Priya Vulchi: You pointed that out beautifully, and especially thinking about the photos. When I was writing this book, I had photos of these individual kind of social justice icons we see in our textbooks. And I had photos where the frame was just broadened a bit, as you said.
- 16:58Priya Vulchi: And Martin Luther King Jr is sitting with his friend Ralph Abernathy. Malcolm X is with Yuri Kochiyama. Toni Morrison is with Fran Leibowitz. You know, all these people who we Rosa Parks is with Johnny Car, all these people we know as solo names like these huge, big brands. You know, we're actually really good friends. And as we started this conversation, talking about how most people how we're taught to engage with friendship in this superficial and kind of shallow way and in a way that doesn't challenge our self interest. The consequence of that is that we become more atomized and self interested and isolated over time, right? And if you just visualize it, the more alone you are, the more politically vulnerable you are.
- 17:44Priya Vulchi: And the more alone you are, the more politically vulnerable other people are right. And so, of course, when we were talking about the Ubers and the Amazons and the way we're systematically torn from friends, of course, that's by design. You know, it's in no one's interest if we have strong Plato has a quote even back then, like 300-350 BCE, he says, it's in no interest for the Persian Empire for its people to have strong bonds of friendship with one another, paraphrasing, but it makes sense as a strategy to keep us apart.
- 18:20Priya Vulchi: And to your point about how we learn social change happens.
- 18:24Priya Vulchi: Have you heard of the difference between organizing and mobilizing.
- 18:28Alex Alexander: Remind us all, I did read your books. I think I know where this is going, but like, Let's talk it out.
- 18:35Priya Vulchi: I didn't write about it explicitly in the book.
- 18:38Priya Vulchi: Actually, I'm a grad student at Harvard, and with all the censorship that is happening, have been thinking about ways we actually can stay connected. And the scholar, Robin DG Kelly, was here giving a talk off campus recently, and he was reminding us about mobilizing and organizing. And essentially, mobilizing is when you mobilize for a short term kind of protest. Everyone gathers and you go and you go back home and close the door. Organizing is more sustained long term change.
- 19:08Priya Vulchi: When we think of social change, we usually think of mobilizing those like quick shows of resistance, but organizing is just as impossible or just as critical, but it's also a lost art and friendship like those, actually having strong bonds with one another is what embeds us into relational networks that make something like organizing possible. You know, the continuing to meet, to discuss, to study together, to challenge one another, to form connections, to care enough about other people beyond your self interest to show up for their political well being right? And so organizing is how you know, the civil rights movement, thinking about SNCC, the Student Non-violent Coordinating Committee, all these really profound movements for change were actually enabled.
- 19:58Alex Alexander: There is a quote that you have in the book, and I'm going to paraphrase it, because I'm looking at my notes here. You know you talk about how the sparseness of political action today and the short lived nature is because of, or maybe directly related to, again, I paraphrase this, the loss of friendships, which I think is what you're talking about here.
- 20:24Alex Alexander: Can you expand on that?
- 20:27Priya Vulchi: Yeah, this is going to be a weird way to approach this question, but Toni Morrison went clubbing with her friends and the chapter laughing with friends. We have this idea that, Okay, so first of all, if you know, wherever you are, if you're want to engage with the political crises of this world, we have this template, as you mentioned, that I need to be this charismatic leader. I need to go to these one time, things like these protests. And you might be feeling dissatisfied.
- 20:57Priya Vulchi: We just talked about this. You might be feeling dissatisfied because that's not actually how change happens. First of all, it's not just the charismatic leader, because. That's a false narrative. These charismatic leaders were actually good friends, right? So you don't need to do anything alone.
- 21:13Priya Vulchi: Second of all, protesting and such are important. But you also need to be in community. You need to do the kind of more ordinary day to day work of connecting with people, talking, thinking, your neighbors, local community organizations, organizing groups, that kind of thing. The third thing that I'm getting at when I say Toni Morrison went clubbing might seem weird. You also might have an idea that you have to be this like very serious person when you do the organizing work, when you're meeting and talking about politics and change, and you might have to do it in this very serious tone. But part of the beautiful aspect of my research was the book focuses a lot on June Jordan, who passed away in 2002 black queer feminist, poet educator, incredible friend, incredible activist, one of the most published African American writers ever. And when I was interviewing her friends, her friends include people like Angela Davis, Toni Morrison, Adrienne Rich, I was interviewing some of her friends who are still alive. And every single one of them, when talking about how they would, of course, they did social change together, would go in a tangent, unprompted, I wouldn't ask them go on a tangent describing June's laughter, this sound that like peppered her sentences.
- 22:33Priya Vulchi: They said everyone would talk about it. And I'm sitting there in the midst of this friendship research, sort of feeling like an imposter, because when I'm writing about all these, like, beautiful, serious, historical, political friendships, because I'm like me and my friends are really goofy, like we're really silly, we're really goofy. I don't know if we qualify, but it's important we know that these iconic activists were actually good friends, and that they laughed a lot together, and they found so much joy with one another, because that idea welcomes us into social movements and action. You know,
- 23:07Alex Alexander: One of the biggest questions I had reading your book, like to the point of the joy, was that idea you addressed this in the book, this idea of like, well, do all my friendships need to be this serious, intense, like, version of themselves to spark change, to right, to move the world forward, to care enough about each other that we would show up for each other. And I really loved your chapter on joy, because it was such a reminder that at the end of the day, that's what keeps us going, like, that's what keeps us showing up. And not to minimize that. But in fact, as you write in the book, to make that as big a part of your friendships as you possibly can.
- 24:08Priya Vulchi: Yes, yes. Like, I mean, I'm sure, when you think about your friendships, the pull to them and you let me know if that's true, but for me, the pull to them is, is like the belly laughs and all that joy and how wonderful is it to know that again, that doesn't disqualify you from the more serious and robustly political parts of friendship too.
- 24:30Alex Alexander: Yeah. I mean, it is a huge draw for me, right? I do this work. We talked about that starting on. We both like we're both deep in this. But I do think that sometimes there is this narrative out there, especially as adults, especially for people that identify as women, that the value of friendship is the care, like we're so desperate for the care and the help and the support, that that is the value and that the joy is just like extra. It's just a bonus. You know, if you can find that like, what you need is someone who to help you, and if you also laugh, that's fun, but I don't agree with that. I'm not saying that is correct. I think it's a balance.
- 25:23Alex Alexander: But I just I loved your chapter because it's a reminder that, if I'm begging for help and my friend is begging for help, and we both want to care for each other, show up for each other, right? That's more work that is can feel like this pull, and the thing that keeps us coming back is the joy, yeah, so like, lean into that. I mean, this is what your chapter says. Lean into that, because that is what is going to be. I think you say something like the bomb to bring you back together.
- 26:00Priya Vulchi: Yeah, that's a great point. And going back to the Friends of utility, right?
- 26:04Priya Vulchi: Like materially. How are these people going to care for you?
- 26:07Priya Vulchi: Like, you need someone to have your back, which is part of it.
- 26:10Priya Vulchi: But like you said exactly, not all of it. And the joy concept also is related to love too. I think, like, I have this, like, kind of corny line that friendship is the greatest love story we've been looking for, but the depth of it going past that superficiality, I'm sure you feel this way too, being so deep in this study, but like I can think about the greatest kind of experiences of love in my life have happened in friendships. You know, when you look back and Aristotle, he has these three categories of love, agape, Eros and philia. And Agape is kind of love for something bigger than you, like community, or, god, maybe. And Philia is love for non-sexual relationships, which he you know, that's how he qualifies friendships. And then Eros is for sexual kind of relationships. But that's a useful framework, because today, too, we only authorize and validate love if it's in that arrow slain. You know, we don't recognize that friendships if we allow it. You know, if our imaginations are big enough, can be such huge sources of just simply love, joy, laughter in our lives, you know?
- 27:35Alex Alexander [Narration]: I mean, yes, kudos, like applause, shout it louder. Can we both get a megaphone? Yeah, we're talking about friendship as if it is that separate side thing. I wasn't really planning to necessarily go here in the episode, but let's do it, because you and I have a similar take, and I would love to just talk about it, which is this idea that currently, in the current model of how we talk about friendship, especially as we become adults, friendship is this outside entity. It's on the sidelines of familial and romantic relationships that those become the center. Now, I think some people will be like, Oh, okay, we'll bring friendship in. So we got like a little party here in the middle, but you and I have the same take, which is that at the core of all of it, every relationship is a friendship. My sister and I had a conversation a few years ago.
- 28:32Alex Alexander [Narration]: So something to know about my sister is that she is eight and a half years younger than me, and we've kind of navigated that my whole life, and a few years ago, we've just always been in different milestones, right? She was into the age gap. Yeah, it was just always hard to relate and to be friends and to have similar experiences or just a level of understanding. It's not even anyways, we had this conversation a few years ago in which we were talking about our relationship her and I, and I told her, I was like, listen, we are sisters, and that's how we show up for each other. But I actually think we need to work on being friends. How beautiful.
- 29:21Alex Alexander [Narration]: We need to figure out what our friendship connectors are, because currently, everything that pulls us together is really just because we're family and I love her, but we actually need to do the work to be using your term good friends to each other.
- 29:43Priya Vulchi: How did that change your relationship after you know,
- 29:48Alex Alexander: I think it's still something we're working on. She lives in a different city, and that's not an excuse.
- 29:55Alex Alexander: It just requires even more work.
- 29:55Alex Alexander: I think that we've done a really good job, but I still think there's some areas for improvement, and I think a huge piece of that is just that our natural reason to connect often is still that because we're sisters and being more intentional about connecting because we're good friends, like less out of obligation and more out of really wanting to know and care for the current versions of ourselves. I'm talking like really high level here, but I get it, I think, more than anything, it's it has given, actually, kind of a peace to our relationship, because that's beautiful. It's given this understanding of what we can do to feel closer at this point in our life, and then acknowledgement that like nothing's wrong with us as sisters, but we know what we can both do to deepen that relationship and to be good friends to each other.
- 31:07Priya Vulchi: I had a moment like that with my parents, where I, you know, I was operating exactly as you were saying, in this as I have been my whole life, because I'm their child in the relationship of parent and child, you know. And I am 25 now, and when I go home, my parents still, like on my end, I think I still had an expectation for us to be in that dynamic of parent and child, and I felt bad because I wasn't being super kind to them, you know, and when I was thinking through friendship, like you said, If friendship is the aspiration, not just, let's bring friends into the model of how we treat our those biologically or legally linked to us, but like, let's actually treat friendship as the aspiration like what all other relationships, no matter what they're called, should aspire to be like that. It transformed my relationship with my parents, just even in my head, because I was like, oh, friendship requires reciprocity, respect. I'm older now. Let me exit that mold that I've been operating in all my life, and let me try to bring some friendship into it, and that also returned a lot of peace into the relationship. Like you said,
- 32:28Alex Alexander: I also think I mean something. I've had to unpack familial relationships extensively, and something I often think about is, are we good friends to each other? If this person was just my friend, how would I feel about that? And that's not to say you completely ignore the legal or blood bonds, but I do think it's a good check in.
- 33:00Priya Vulchi: Yes, honestly,
- 33:01Alex Alexander: I think it takes people out of autopilot, a little bit like, if you do that check in, that's one of the joys of friendship, right? Is we are actively choosing to engage in that relationship. So when we take the autopilot away, then you're basically asking like, am I actively choosing to engage in this relationship? Is the other person actively choosing to engage in the relationship? And it creates so much more awareness of what's actually happening there
- 33:30Priya Vulchi: That's brilliant.
- 33:30Priya Vulchi: I think framing it as like removing people out of the kind of autopilot way we operate on a daily with those who are close to us is that clears things in my head too. Because, you know, sometimes people are not going to accept the invitation of, hey, we're sisters, hey, we're parent and child. Let's evolve our relationship into to also resemble a friendship, just so that we have some respect and reciprocity in our bond that we've taken for granted. Maybe there are going to be people like cousins, siblings, who are not going to want to meet you there. And I think, like you said, that's a good moment of clarity, because you can realize that, oh, you know, this person is my sister, not my sister friend, you know, and it helps you accept maybe the not great ways you've been feeling in that relationship, and clarify actually, my friend is my friend, you know, and that's the kind of chosen family too, that is just as important,
- 34:36Alex Alexander: you know. Priya, I've never said this, I think directly on the podcast, I've recorded some like social content, and then I never post it. But let's just say it here, let me, let me put this like stake in the ground, right? If there was a hill I was going to die on, it's actually this hill, and that hill is I care more who somebody's chosen family is than anything else. Now, I believe that your legal and blood family can be a part of your chosen family, but I care about who you think will show up for you, and who you are actively showing up for more than anything else.
- 35:13Alex Alexander: That's my Hill, but I will die.
- 35:21Priya Vulchi: I'll die next to you on that hill. Yeah, you can't see me, but I'm like nodding my head really vigorously. It's, it's absolutely true, because, and to your point too, like your kind of blood, legal, biological, what those people can enter that space. Yes they're welcome to, yes they're welcome to.
- 35:41Alex Alexander: And they might have actively been doing that work this whole time, like I know people whose family of origins have worked very hard their entire life to stay in that like chosen family space.
- 35:54Alex Alexander: They could have been there, but they also could stop doing that work and exit at any time in my mind,
- 36:06Priya Vulchi: Exactly. Exactly, exactly. There's people who do research on families and chosen families who talk about this idea of like families are like a lottery, like the family you're born into, yeah, don't I know?
- 36:15Priya Vulchi: Yeah, yeah. So you have no say in the family that you're born into. And what friendship does like you're saying, it just unlocks this idea that, Oh, I can actually build my own family. It comes from, like, queer and trans practices. And how freeing and peaceful is that you know that you're not condemned to your circumstances.
- 36:41Alex Alexander [Narration]: I mean, you don't know enough of my story, but, like, the ultimate peace? Yeah, the ultimate piece is the answer to that question for me. Hence why I do all this work is literally that,
- 36:53Priya Vulchi: yeah, and that's why I'm always like, you know, friends giving should be the main event.
- 36:58Alex Alexander: I mean, it is friends. It is mine,
- 37:00Priya Vulchi: exactly, exactly, exactly, you know, like,
- 37:05Alex Alexander: oh, so this is going to feel, I'm going to have to set this up a little bit because to I think some people, this is going to feel a little bit like a hard pivot. I don't think it is. I don't think it is. When you talk about friendship in the very beginning of your book, you talk about how, gosh, am I going to get this right? I don't have your exact words, so bear with me here people, but you know, you talk about how we have to embrace, embrace and explore people's political identities, and we can't separate those from the person in our friendships.
- 37:44Alex Alexander: And the reason, to me, this is a flow through is because we were talking about how anybody can enter into your chosen family, but circumstances could change and somebody could exit. And what came to mind when I said that was, well, you know somebody, your family of origin, your romantic partner, your friends, whoever could have spent your entire friendship, maybe separating your political identity, or maybe somebody has a new part of themselves, maybe not a new part, but they open up, Right? Somebody comes out as queer, for example, and that changes that, right? Some people are going to want to sweep that under the rug, ignore it, separate that. Can you talk a little bit about how important our political identities are in our friendships? Like, what's actually at stake here?
- 38:46Priya Vulchi: I think love is at stake, and so it's related. It wasn't a hard pivot. I thought it was seamless, because we were talking about earlier, because, and just to bear with me, because I'm going to go back to Aristotle, but this is how we we've internalized a lot of his models of friendship, because he's so prominent in the Western canon. He talks about this word philia again, which is like love for friends. And he has this word called heteros, which is more of a like comradeship, political kind of friendship, which he also acknowledges as, like, astonishingly important heteros like this idea of like political relations, but he distinguishes it from philia. So he says, friends don't do politics. Heteros do politics.
- 39:40Priya Vulchi: Both are as important. And I'm sitting there like I don't know what to do with this, you know, because, and I realize, of course, he had this idea, because he excluded whole categories of people from the relationship of friendship. He didn't believe women could be friends. Friendship was this kind of elite category. So of course, there's no room for politics, because there were very few political differences in his friendship to begin with, you know, but for the rest of us, what do we do? So there's this June Jordan anecdote that I share in the book that I think captures how friendship, our political identities, are implicated in the relationship of friendship. June is really good friends with this woman named Frances Fox Piven, who's a sociologist, they meet for lunch one day, and June kind of writes like their friendship has been getting along fine, so long as she collaborates in her self silencing, you know. So if she's doing all these acrobatics to kind of avoid parts of herself, the friendship operates smoothly, but during that lunch, she kind of reaches a breaking point. She feels that she can't fully express her bisexuality, and that Francis doesn't really accept that part of her, understand that part of her, and that they have a fight and, you know, they don't talk for several years later, they reconcile and they're lifelong friends. In that moment, right?
- 41:07Priya Vulchi: Like she says, not accepting all parts of her, including her bisexuality, is a form of suicide. It's kind of like severing one limb and going to the friendship and expecting your whole body not to bleed out, right? Like you have to accept someone and love someone entirely for who they are. And so when, when Aristotle says Philia is different from heteros, you know, like friends are not political bonds, that doesn't make sense to me, because you see in that June Jordan example, right? Like you have to converge the two to fully love a person. So that's where it comes together for me.
- 41:45Alex Alexander [Narration]: And then to take this further, because in many, not all, we can find some friendships, but many friendships today, not your definition. I don't want to use your words. Many people see peak friendship. I don't want to say good friendship, because I I want to keep that for your work and your definition. But many people see the friendship they're seeking. That's why to put it today as being apolitical, as going back to the beginning, that quiet and demure and tiptoe around it and don't get into those conversations.
- 42:28Alex Alexander [Narration]: Can we talk about how that is then impacting this idea of your political identity and fully being yourself?
- 42:37Priya Vulchi: Well, a lot of people can't afford to hide, just like June, right? You can't like the consequences almost death like you can't afford to silence parts of yourself. Some people can, but a lot of us, a lot of queer people of color, like you, just can't be in a friendship that operates on that kind of neglect. If you break it down to what you were saying, like people expect care from friendships, like you show up for a friend. I was just speaking to someone the other day who, similar to June, is a cancer survivor and not in a kind of nuclear household structure, so doesn't have like a typical like spouse is going to take you to whatever medical needs. But she told me her name is Reshma. She told me she was never alone, like someone was there for her doctor appointments at home when she was low food, like that kind of thing. And June Jordan writes similarly, right about how her friends really took care of her, like physical needs. In that aspect, most people understand that, but what you have to also understand is, and I write about this, like, in the same way diseases and illnesses make people sick, injustice does too, right? And so if you're picking and choosing the ways you're going to show up for a friend.
- 43:48Priya Vulchi: It just doesn't work like that.
- 43:52Priya Vulchi: And to your point of, like, peak friendships are, like, these kind of silent friendships.
- 43:58Alex Alexander: I don't know if that's the best term. I was just trying to Yeah. I don't want to say, right? I think, I do think people would say, like, a good friendship, right? Is that easy?
- 44:06Alex Alexander: A political you're able to put it aside. And I don't want to use good friendship, because the way you use good friendship is the way we should be using it.
- 44:11Alex Alexander: So I just picked towards peak, but like, yeah, yeah, that,
- 44:18Priya Vulchi: yeah, right. And if we really are practicing again friendship, not in the superficial, like, virtue of pleasure way, but like, in a way that really does challenge our self interest like so June has this again. June Jordan, you know, like she's walking in North Berkeley, and this random person runs up to her random person, and he's like, help.
- 44:40Priya Vulchi: There's this anti semitic pamphlet, like someone dropped it on my front lawn. My wife is Jewish. Like, I'm scared. Have you seen anyone? Immediately, June Jordan is like, I haven't seen anyone, but here's my phone number. Here's the phone number of people who can help, you know, like, stay in touch, keep me posted. Like, I'm gonna and it was, I was so moved when I read that, because I don't know if someone ran up to me, I might be like, who, you know? Who are you like, you know? Oh, I'm sorry, but I might keep walking right with my dog. But June really like, That's a profound display of friendship. To me.
- 45:11Priya Vulchi: She doesn't know this person, but she's showing this friendliness, this friendship, and that's love like, that's good friendship. And so I understand it as always being inherently political. You don't shy away from it to love someone, you have to, like, dig deep into it.
- 45:25Alex Alexander: When I read this section of the book, I had two stories of my own pop up, and one is people showing me care, and the other one is me showing someone care, and it's actually the same friend, but I was thinking of our political identities, and these are both stories of privileges. Well, I guess, in my case, more I guess, like the lack of an invisible privilege, I lack family privilege, which, in the way that society is currently structured, actually, shockingly like rams up against you all the time. And I have this friend, Caitlin. Yeah, she grew up in an amazing family, like one of those families I was talking about that, like, constantly is working to be chosen family, something that growing up, I just was always like, wow, that actually exists. That's crazy, right? She has really no understanding of my experience of lacking that family privilege. But when I tell you that she is one of the first people to bring it up, to advocate for it, to stand up for me, to do some small form of action about it, and right, that is an act of care, that is an act of love, that is like an act of seeing me very deeply, and even though she has no real understanding, like I've asked her before, why? Why are you so maybe passionate about this, like she's told me, like she's gotten into debates with family about it, like it's really reshaped how she goes about things. And she just told me, you know, I believe you, I believe you, and I tell that story because just like, what a simple, radical act of love and care and friendship that is challenging the systems we live in is what came to mind when I read your book.
- 47:38Priya Vulchi: That brings me to tears, because it's so profound, you know, if you think about it, that she said that to you, and anytime a friend loves you in that way, it blows me away, because they don't have to like societally, structurally, they could ghost. They could leave with very few consequences. You know what I mean. But when friends choose to go out of their way. Also thinking, as we were talking earlier, friendship is inconvenient because it's designed to be so, you know. So when they go through the inconvenience of being a good friend, talk about love, you know?
- 48:20Alex Alexander: Yeah, that example that I gave you happened. I mean, it happens all the time, because she does it in small ways, right? It's just woven in. It's those seemingly inconsequential actions that we talked about earlier, but the first time she told me about kind of one of these big conversations she had with a loved one, I just remember being like overcome with emotion, because to me, it was so meaningful, but to her, it was just a conversation she had for 30 minutes in the kitchen. The flip side of that the same friend has a medically complex kiddo, right we live in a world right now where social security is at risk. And although many people think of Social Security as something you get when you're over 65 I think it's 65 her kiddo, most of his treatments and medicine and doctors are paid for by Social Security, right? Special Education. I mean, just I could go on and on with 20 other examples. And I love this little kiddo with all my heart, and that is something I think about daily in the ways that I am talking to people and talking to candidates and voting and having conversations, and what I am paying attention to, and that is also an example of the little things being political. And that, that deep care I have for my friend, you know you write in the book again, like, do I have the exact quote written down? I don't know. I'm gonna paraphrase it again, right? Like, society doesn't support deep friendship because it's dangerous to society. I guess what I'm trying to get across in this episode to everybody is that, yes, it can be big things, but as I think you're trying to say in the book, it also can just be the way we are moving through the world in small ways, with care for another person,
- 50:37Priya Vulchi: right? First of all, how your friendships are beautiful, you know?
- 50:41Alex Alexander [Narration]: Thank you. And truly, the thing I value most in this
- 50:44Priya Vulchi: world, yeah, and the way that having a friend and thinking about this friend's kid is changing the way your politics are expressing themselves, like you're now more attentive to what this kid needs and how the decisions you're making are going to circle back and impact this kid's life.
- 51:06Priya Vulchi: Yeah. This idea of cumulative change. So we were talking about, like the social justice icons and the civil rights here, like that we grow up idolizing, but this idea of cumulative change that June Jordan says, paraphrasing her quote, that it's not like a battlefield or like this big legislative win that is going to speak to political victory. Political victory actually starts with each interpersonal episode. You know, that's how we build up to these more dramatic and obvious political victories, because it starts with, if you love a friend in that way and allow yourself to be loved in that way, friends can really change your minds and your heart, you know, with like tremendous political repercussions.
- 51:56Alex Alexander [Narration]: There are so many parts of this book that I wanted to bring up in my conversation with Priya, but we didn't have time for a three hour conversation, so I had to leave some things out. But there's a part of Prius book that talks about the concept of allyship, right, the process where somebody like me who is not part of a marginalized group actively supports and advocates for the rights and well being of that group. And this story you just heard about my friend Caitlin and her son, I think illustrates what Priya is talking about in the book. You see, I have always believed that people with special needs deserve proper care and access that has always felt like a given. Now, did I have exact stories to tell you? No, but that just aligns with my values.
- 52:59Alex Alexander [Narration]: Now I have stories to tell you.
- 52:59Alex Alexander [Narration]: I can tell you about my friends experience in the NICU. I can tell you about their experience with caring at home. I can tell you about all the medical procedures they've had to learn.
- 53:14Alex Alexander [Narration]: I can tell you about how private insurance isn't enough, how important social security is for kids and adults under the age of 65 I'm tracking legislation. I'm paying attention to political candidates and their positions on this issue, and in maybe the smallest, simplest example, when somebody is talking about Social Security, even if it's just a simple statement of like, oh, I can't wait until I'm 65 or like, I will educate anybody and everybody on the fact that there are people under the age of 65 who are very, very dependent on Social Security for their health and well being. Because now I know more because of my friends.
- 54:09Alex Alexander [Narration]: And when people ask, like, how maybe am I helping my friends?
- 54:16Alex Alexander [Narration]: How have I showed up for them?
- 54:20Alex Alexander [Narration]: This one's hard to explain, guys, but this is it, like part of doing. This is the voting, the writing, the representatives, the speaking up in a society that tells us to stay quiet and apolitical, because that's what real friendship does, as I hope you can see in my example, it transforms that abstract I should care I am an ally into something completely different, because now I care deeply, personally and actively every single day.
- 54:58Alex Alexander: The examples I'm giving, I want to point this out. The examples I'm giving are both with a friend I've had, gosh, for 18-years. At some point we're gonna have to wrap up this episode, because we could record, I think, an entire seminar. I do have a couple more things I want to cover, so I'm just gonna like highlight over this. But you have an entire chapter in your in your book, where you talk about likeness and wanting to like that pull to seek out friends who are similar to you. And the reason I'm bringing that up, right is this friendship. When we met, for the most part, on the surface, we looked very similar, like we met in college, where we came from similar economic backgrounds, obviously our family privilege was different, like there was a lot of overlap, a lot over the 18-years, I have opened up like she didn't know about my family stuff back then, right? She has had her son recently. That has changed. Certain areas of our of our likeness, right? But you talk about in the book, this idea of being just really mindful of that, and when you're seeking out new friends, be mindful of seeking out differences. This is something I talk about a lot, and honestly it's a huge piece of just like my beliefs overall, which is that so many people are out there talking about how to make friends, right? Like everybody wants me to talk about how to make friends with women in your 30s, because I'm a woman in my 30s, and I get really mad because I'm like, the problem is, one of the problems in this world is that I need to be friends with people in their 20s, people in their 60s, people of color. I'm a white woman, if you are listening to this and you've never seen me before, I need to be friends with men. I need to be friends with people in the queer community, like I need to be friends with different people, and so I refuse to just talk about how to make friends with women in their 30s. I said I didn't want to make some big thing out of this.
- 57:27Alex Alexander: But can you just talk a little bit about what happened? About what happens when we only seek out likeness in our friendships?
- 57:36Priya Vulchi: Yeah, and, you know, that's a fascinating thing to me, that that's the request you get. Because exactly, you know, that's not the lens we should be.
- 57:45Alex Alexander: It drives me nuts. I fight so hard and like this isn't like to me. It's just keeping us in the same pattern we're in which is obviously not working for people
- 57:57Priya Vulchi: right to this point of like, likeness and homophily. And so the concept of cronyism is when you give jobs and like favors to friends, and if you look at the current administration, the cabinet, like, you know, I personally wouldn't qualify it as good friendship, but there's something like friendship that's there operating in these spheres of like, in these circles of power, right? It's just friendship is also incubating a lot of privilege. And so there's this is not at all to say, which is why I write about it in the book, like, friendship is inherently a good thing. So long as you're being a friend like you're off the hook. You're doing it matters who you are friends with, you know? And there's this study that I mentioned in the book of this woman who was a part of the woman's KKK, and she kind of claims to be oblivious to the KKK is larger action. She kind of just goes, Oh, I was in it for the friendship with other white Protestant women, you know. So friendship itself is not inherently a good thing, like you were saying. It matters who we are friends with, like, cross class friendships, interracial friendships, all of these things on the flip side of it, I talked about, like the current administration friendship operating these very insidious ways to keep certain people in power. That kind of also just proves that friendship is very politically powerful, right? But we can use it too for us, and we can wield it in a different way, one where we're connecting with people through these political barriers and becoming stronger together. We don't always have to be on the other side of like a friendship that or a kind of friendship.
- 59:33Priya Vulchi: Again, I don't think it's actually good friendship, but a kind of friendship, like nepotism, cronyism, that's attacking us and hurting our political well being.
- 59:42Alex Alexander: The reason I went down this pivot is because I guess what I'm trying to show people is that even when you are seeking out friendships because of likeness, if that friendship survives a length of time, you will diverge. Things will change, like you said, so you can be so hyper focused, so many people come to me and they want to make like this certain type of friend who just perfectly aligns with their life. And I'm like, you can do that, and I see why you would do that. Maybe for certain people, understanding a certain you know, parenting is a big one that comes to mind. Does people want other parent friends with a kid of a similar age?
- 1:00:17Alex Alexander: Like, I get it. I get it. You want somebody who understands the situation you're in, and I think you should have those friends. But I also think that you shouldn't close yourself off to other people. And in fact, for people out here who want to see change in the world we live in, you should be mindful of seeking out different friendships, at least part of the time, like that is a small way to cause political change, to weaken the system, to develop political resistance, all the above,
- 1:01:01Priya Vulchi: yes, and a few add ons to that, like you said exactly with your 18 -year old friendship.
- 1:01:07Alex Alexander: I sounds about, right?
- 1:01:08Priya Vulchi: Yeah, yeah. So if you actually, and again, we were talking earlier about there's this idea that, like, oh, friends actually don't talk about politics, but if you do love a person fully and completely, including, like, their identities, all of their identities, you do see that likeness is kind of like a fake concept. You know, if you go deeper into the relationship, you'll see how, like, it doesn't last. Like, it's not a sustainable way of connecting with someone. I want to qualify this by saying that for many people, like, likeness is also a means of survival, right? Like, I'm going to connect with other women of color in the academy.
- 1:01:46Priya Vulchi: I'm pursuing a PhD and to like look out for one another. And while that's true, June Jordan has this quote of like, it's not who you are, but what you do that will determine the connection. So I think while it can be a reason why you click at first, it can't be the reason why you like last in the friendship. And so being mindful of that I learned through June is also very important.
- 1:02:14Alex Alexander: I think that brings me to something I have been dancing around this whole episode, and I think a beautiful way to kind of close it up, which is, you know, I read your book, The reason I haven't wanted to use the term good friends is because I think the way you frame it is just such a mindset reframe for people like how to approach this in their life. And what I took away is that good friendship is a practice. Can you talk a little bit about how you would, I guess, define good friendship for people?
- 1:02:52Priya Vulchi: Yes. So I talk about it being a practice, not a destination. And so Aristotle that third category friendships of virtue. A lot of translations, translated as perfect friendships. It's this idea that you arrive in your friendship kind of without a speck of dust. Unquestionably good, but I'm not a perfect friend. You know? Like, we mess up all the time. We hurt friends. Friendship is improvisational. There's no template. We don't learn how to be a good friend. You know, it's so neglected, you know this, right? Like, that's part of the effort of your podcast to to give us a vocabulary to give us build that template, flesh it out, right? So of course, we're going to mess up. And friendship does require, again, that like continuous mutual forgiveness in that way. And I think to normalize that, because we normalize that love takes work with family and other people.
- 1:03:44Priya Vulchi: But when friendships get hard, we want the relationship to be fun and easy, and so we like run away, we like end you know, Oh, this isn't friendship. Shouldn't be hard. What the fuck is this like? I'm gonna back out, right?
- 1:03:53Priya Vulchi: But actually, if you stay with the difficulty your bond, it shows a respect for that person and your bond can kind of transcend into this place of good friendship. The concept of like, good friendship requires some bad friendship too. You know, I wanted to make it just make that louder so we don't feel any shame and don't feel again like we're locked out of a potential for this bond.
- 1:04:18Alex Alexander [Narration]: Yeah, you know, I read your book, obviously, I talk about this stuff all the time, and like I said, you have some beautiful writing in there, the way you phrase things, the way you lay things out for people. What really hit me was this idea that good friendship is a journey, not a destination. And I guess what I took away from it is that good friendship is the way I move through the world, whether like, it's not one friend is a good friendship. It is that, like I am trying to show up in a way that is focused on care and joy and doing the work to see somebody as a full person, and rinse and repeat over and over and over again that like even when I have a moment where maybe I feel like I've reached some peak good friendship moment, that journey is never over.
- 1:05:20Alex Alexander [Narration]: Right world, circumstances change, new friendships appear like I said. I had a lot of thoughts about your book, Priya, can you tell?
- 1:05:28Priya Vulchi: Makes me so happy?
- 1:05:30Alex Alexander: Well, I just want to thank you for coming on here for I mean, gosh, all your time writing good friends. I think that this is such a foundational read for anybody who is trying to like you said, you know, we don't learn about friendship. Nobody really teaches this. So there's a bunch of us out here who are trying to teach ourselves, and if that's you, then you should go read good friendship, because I think it's just a really foundational text. I can't wait to see where it goes.
- 1:06:03Priya Vulchi: Thank you so much, and I'm happy to be in this kind of. Arena friendship. Study with you. I write about like, I think understanding friendship is kind of just understanding what it means to be human. So I think it's big work that you're doing, and I'm grateful for it as well.
- 1:06:21Alex Alexander: Thank you. You too.
- 1:06:23Alex Alexander [Narration]: Before we wrap up, I want to encourage you to get your hands on Good Friends. You can find the link in the show notes below, but I realized today that I should give you a second option, one that actually authors love just as much, and that is request Good Friends at your local library at the end of the day, authors just want to get the books into your hands. Whether you purchase it or you rent to the library, doesn't matter, but go search for it at your library, and if it's not there, request it, because there is so much more in this book that we didn't even touch today. Now in thinking about this episode, here is what I hope you take away from this conversation. It is time to let go of this idea that friendship needs to be nice and easy and always comfortable and apolitical, where everyone needs to just get along or think exactly the same or feel like it's just easy breezy, that's not real friendship. Like, I think you could actually say that's small talk with a fancy name real friendship. It's about seeing and understanding what your friends are actually experiencing as they move through the world. And yes, that act itself is political. But here's the beautiful part, this kind of friendship naturally leads to other political acts.
- 1:07:55Alex Alexander [Narration]: And I'm not talking about leading movements or being some iconic figure of change that'll be in the history books that could be a very overwhelming thing to think about. What I'm talking about is just having deeper conversations, sharing your friends, stories about why political choices matter, writing to your representatives and hundreds of other small but meaningful actions that add up to real change. You know, when I started friendship IRL, something I wrote down was that I hoped that this podcast would spark conversations that would lead to millions of other conversations like that ripple effect, and that feels like the perfect way to end this episode, because I hope that you'll take this conversation as an invitation to start slowly leaning into learning more about your friends political identities, get curious about their experiences and see where that takes you, because sometimes the biggest changes start with The smallest conversations with that. I'll see you next week.
- 1:09:09Podcast Intro/Outro: Thank you for listening to this episode of Friendship IRL. I am so honored to have these conversations with you. But don't let the chat die here. Send me a voice message. I created a special website just to chat with you. You can find it at alexalex.chat. You can also find me on Instagram. My handle, @itsalexalexander. Or go ahead and leave a review wherever you prefer to listen to podcasts. Now if you want to take this conversation a step further, send this episode to a friend. Tell them you found it interesting. And use what we just talked about as a conversation starter the next time you and your friend hang out. No need for a teary goodbye. I'll be back with a new episode next week.