Latest / The Prompt / Ep. 479 | The Death of Cookies: Is Your Personalization Strategy Doomed?
Transcript
- 0:01This is on base your one stop shop for solving your most
- 0:04pressing B2B go to market challenges.
- 0:07Each week, host Chris Moody and Paul Gibson talk to sales and
- 0:09marketing leaders to get you in depth insights and creative
- 0:12strategies to set your revenue teams up for success.
- 0:17Hey everyone, welcome back. I'm your host, Chris Moody, and
- 0:20this is the second part of our series on the Cookieless Future.
- 0:23Today, I'm very excited to talk to Kara Alcamo and Rachel Karasi
- 0:27on this topic. So, Kara and Rachel, could you
- 0:30please give our listeners a glimpse into your backgrounds?
- 0:33Yeah, sure. I'm Kara.
- 0:35I founded the agency and Congrats, you got my last name
- 0:38right. I I tell everyone you have to do
- 0:40the pizza hands when you say my last name because it's Sicilian.
- 0:43So it's Alcamo. It's the best way to remember
- 0:45it. And the name of our agency
- 0:47Alcamo Marketing. So my background, I spent 15
- 0:51more years in various marketing agencies working across
- 0:54strategy, media, SEO, content, technology.
- 0:58And you know, in the last 8:00-ish years, I really felt
- 1:02like there was a gap between the way that an agency was
- 1:06structured and the services they provide and what consultants do
- 1:10and what B2B brands actually needed.
- 1:12So I started this company as a consultancy, which or consult
- 1:16agency, which is a hybrid of, you know, the big picture,
- 1:20business oriented, thinking of a consultant and the execution
- 1:23capabilities of an agency. It's a professional side,
- 1:26personal side. You have to point out I am a
- 1:29beekeeper, Maryland beekeeper, proud beekeeper.
- 1:31I'm also known as the chicken lady.
- 1:33We're up to 28 right now. So I have a regenerative
- 1:37permaculture style garden farm at my property, bunch of
- 1:41chickens, 2 cats, a dog, four plus beehives and a horse and an
- 1:47adult man which I say with love. My name is Rachel Carassi.
- 1:52I don't have as many hobbies as Cara, but I did start my career
- 1:57out really focused on media buying and planning for about 10
- 2:00or so years and then shifted my focus into B2B media technology
- 2:05and strategy. And since I joined alcohol
- 2:08marketing, I've really been focused on more of overseeing
- 2:11all the operations, client support and still overseeing a
- 2:16lot of that B2B technology piece as well.
- 2:19Awesome. Yeah that those intros that it's
- 2:21hard to follow that one care. I mean we all we both paused and
- 2:24we're just like where do we even go?
- 2:26So much to take care of. I mean I thought 4 kids was
- 2:29busy. I mean, we don't have kids yet,
- 2:31but you know, that would really be the icing, wouldn't it?
- 2:35Yeah, just throw a bunch in the mix.
- 2:37I mean, look, you need farm hands at some point, so.
- 2:39Yes, big fan of child labor there.
- 2:43You go, all right. Well, Speaking of labor and
- 2:47legal issues, no. I I'd love to dive in and
- 2:51understand what has led to the decision to deprecate cookies in
- 2:562024 and how does that align with current privacy and
- 2:59security concerns. Yeah, this is a great question,
- 3:02'cause it is. When you look back, it's hard
- 3:04to, you know, track exactly how we got here.
- 3:07But if, if I had to boil it down, there's really, there's
- 3:09five things. One is just privacy concerns.
- 3:12So on the consumer side, you know, people have become more
- 3:15and more aware and can therefore concerned about the way that
- 3:19their data, their information is being used and the privacy.
- 3:22So, you know, I remember seeing an article back in the day about
- 3:26weather.com and how IBM acquired them and they were able to
- 3:30actually see where someone lived their home address because of
- 3:33the data that was being collected by that app.
- 3:36And I think those kinds of things have led to just more
- 3:38awareness. I know Rachel also is going to
- 3:41talk about some of the regulatory changes that have
- 3:44come up. Yeah, we've seen a lot over the
- 3:46years. There's, if you look back,
- 3:48there's really been a timeline of changes starting with those
- 3:52initial controversies back I think in 20/12/2013 with Safari
- 3:57and Chrome. And then we went into the
- 4:00Cambridge Analytica scandal that we all know about.
- 4:03And that kind of snowballed over time to what we're seeing
- 4:07happening today across all of the different browsers and where
- 4:11we are with with Chrome now. Yeah.
- 4:13So privacy concerns, regulatory changes like JDPRRCCPA, you
- 4:19know, that has in turn led to the technology shifts and
- 4:22browser changes and a rise of alternative technologies, you
- 4:27know, somewhat as a reaction to that, but also consumer
- 4:30preferences for personalization versus privacy.
- 4:32So as they become more aware and concerned, you know, there's
- 4:36this desire to balance like, I don't want to see, you know, I'm
- 4:40not a mechanic. My partner is, but I'm not.
- 4:42So I don't want to see the motorcycle part ads that he
- 4:45gets. I want to see my chicken ads and
- 4:47my, you know, homesteading content.
- 4:50And so you know that you got to balance that with the desire and
- 4:53requirement for privacy. Right.
- 4:55It's really interesting. People want a personalized
- 4:58experience, but at the same time they don't want it to
- 5:01personalize. They almost feel like it gets to
- 5:03a point where it gets a little creepy.
- 5:05So how do we find that perfect mix as marketers?
- 5:10Yeah, I love that. I I was going to the creepy
- 5:12place too, because I think that's always the word that we
- 5:16use in the profession to say we want, we want to be as
- 5:19personalized as possible without being creepy.
- 5:22So there's always that Gray area that everyone's paying attention
- 5:25to. And you know, I know that that
- 5:28for the marketers listening to this and the advertisers
- 5:31listening to this, there are challenges that come about
- 5:34without having cookies. So as cookies go away and we are
- 5:37trying to be personalized, how should we be adapting our
- 5:41strategies? Yeah.
- 5:43So there's definitely quite a few challenges as marketers that
- 5:47we're seeing in the industry. So one is the precision in
- 5:50targeting that we're losing. So without those third party
- 5:54cookies, we're essentially losing that additional piece of
- 5:57targeting that we rely heavily on when we're advertising on the
- 6:02digital side. So we're facing this piece where
- 6:06we no longer can target how we have in the past focused on
- 6:10behaviors and focused on all of this third party data that we've
- 6:14so heavily on. And then, Karen, there's also a
- 6:17measurement piece as well, right?
- 6:19You know, this one's near and dear to me being a big data
- 6:22nerd, but yeah, this really effects our measurement
- 6:25accuracy, right? Because cookies are what are
- 6:27often used to determine, oh, someone has been here before or
- 6:31they were over there before and now they're here.
- 6:33And without those cookies to track people across different,
- 6:38at different sites, we can't attribute the activities in one
- 6:41domain to another as accurately. And, and I think this is a
- 6:45little bit of a blessing and a curse, if I can be honest,
- 6:47because I, I do think that in a lot of cases B2B more so maybe
- 6:52then like ACPG space has become overly reliant or overly
- 6:56confident in some of the cracking and attribution that's
- 7:01out there. And to and and ignoring some of
- 7:04the more inferential type of information you can get from non
- 7:08deterministic tracking. Yeah, yeah, exactly.
- 7:13And similarly, there's also going to be a large reliance on
- 7:181st party data, which I also think of as a blessing and a
- 7:20curse where this going back to the conversation around third
- 7:25party data and not being readily available and using it in the
- 7:29same way, we're going to have to lean heavy on the 1st party data
- 7:33that we have. And so that is definitely going
- 7:36to be a challenge for a lot of marketers, but also something
- 7:41that we can look at as an opportunity when we're thinking
- 7:45about the path forward and how we can come up with some unique
- 7:48solutions. Yeah, and there's also, you
- 7:52know, just things like compliance with privacy
- 7:54regulations. So with third party cookies
- 7:57going away or with more regulations, you know, you're
- 8:01going to have to be considering in the same way that we all have
- 8:03with GDPR and CCPA. OK, what do I need to do as a
- 8:06marketer to stay compliant and make sure that, you know, this
- 8:09business is protected? You look at GDPRI think it's 5%
- 8:12of revenue is a potential penalty.
- 8:15It's, it's crazy when you think about the actual risk involved
- 8:18in something that seems like a really simple, you know, update
- 8:21to the website or, or whatever. And then there's just
- 8:24complexity, you know, fragmented ecosystems.
- 8:26Everybody has already started implementing different privacy
- 8:31controls differently, right, for GDPR and it's going to just
- 8:34continue and explode even more with cookies, you know, being
- 8:38depreciated. So we're going to have to
- 8:40navigate that. Yeah.
- 8:41And I think one last piece here is the cost of an all rate.
- 8:45So we're very mindful of CPMS of cost per conversions of cost per
- 8:51all of these different even lower funnel actions and
- 8:54pipeline data. And everything's going to get
- 8:57more expensive as this targeting becomes a bit trickier.
- 9:01So we're going to have to lean heavier on different
- 9:04technologies and platforms and and the partners that do have
- 9:08that data like let's say LinkedIn for example, has a lot
- 9:11of that first party data that we can leverage.
- 9:14They are going to make it more expensive as well because they
- 9:17know that we have to rely on that data.
- 9:19So there's a lot of different pieces there that people are
- 9:23going to see a big increase in what they're spending for the
- 9:27same thing that they were getting previously for cheaper.
- 9:30Yeah, I mean, Linkedin's the perfect example.
- 9:32Think about five years ago, what was the normal CPM on LinkedIn,
- 9:37you know, and what is it now? It's exploded 10100 X in some
- 9:41cases. So that's not going to change.
- 9:43It's actually going to get even more expensive because it's a
- 9:46limited inventory, limited pool of publishers that have that
- 9:50first party data that you can use and trust to reach that
- 9:53audience. I'd love to jump into some of
- 9:56the strategies, but I do have a question about that increase in
- 9:59costs, right? When we think about CPMS, I know
- 10:03plenty of marketing leaders that have a number they pull out of
- 10:07their hat and they're used to, hey, we, our CPM needs to be
- 10:10around here. And with this, this is a big
- 10:13change. This is not just a small
- 10:15incremental change, it's a big change.
- 10:17What would you say to the marketers listening that may
- 10:21need to completely re evaluate benchmarks, baselines, how they
- 10:26think of their advertising costs?
- 10:28Because it sounds like it's a whole new world as we go forward
- 10:33in this. Like if you could put your arms
- 10:34around them and shake them just a little bit, what would you
- 10:37say? Yeah.
- 10:39I mean it's, it's a good question and I think it's a
- 10:41similar conversation to one that we have currently with a cost
- 10:45per conversion or cost per lead or cost per MQL metric, right.
- 10:49So it's the same type of thing that happens when you shift from
- 10:53a lead based measurement framework to an account based
- 10:56measurement framework. You're not going to look at cost
- 10:59per MQL in the same way that you did previously.
- 11:02It just isn't used the same in the same manner.
- 11:04So the way that we kind of look at it is more of a work back
- 11:07from your revenue and pipeline target.
- 11:09It's less about, oh, what is an acceptable CPM and it's more
- 11:12about how many times what's the total size of my audience that
- 11:16I'm trying to reach? How many times do I need to
- 11:17reach them to be effective and how much is that potentially
- 11:20going to cost me? And, and kind of working through
- 11:23the whole buying journey in that way and making sure that that
- 11:27fits with your revenue, you know the financial model for revenue
- 11:30because even if you got a $5 CPM, if that doesn't translate
- 11:34ultimately into your pipeline and revenue target, it doesn't
- 11:37really matter. Great.
- 11:39Totally get it. On the first session with
- 11:42Gareth, we talked about how many folks are surprised and I'm
- 11:46using your surprise that cookies are going away because it they
- 11:50were kicking the can down farther and farther and further.
- 11:53It's been talked about for so long, I think folks almost
- 11:56didn't expect it to happen. But what are you seeing the best
- 12:00digital marketers doing? So how are they adapting their
- 12:03targeting and advertising strategies to make sure they're
- 12:05still reaching their audience? I think going back to that,
- 12:09those original challenges, really investing in their first
- 12:13party data is a huge opportunity.
- 12:15So finding ways to bring in, for example, your CRM data into your
- 12:20performance reporting and into your strategies where you can
- 12:24build some similar audiences and really leverage that data and
- 12:27information to understand how it's performing.
- 12:31That will continue to be a huge strategy as we're moving away
- 12:34from some of the additional capabilities.
- 12:37And then Kara there, there's definitely an opportunity around
- 12:40new technologies as well. Yeah, yeah.
- 12:43And sometimes I think of it not even as a new technology.
- 12:46Some of these have been around for a long time.
- 12:48It's just that they haven't been as commonplace in B2B as they
- 12:51have in say, retail CPG or more consumer based marketing, you
- 12:55know, so I think of something like live ramp, for example,
- 12:58hugely used in retail and hasn't really been leveraged as much in
- 13:02B2B unless it's by a big enterprise brand.
- 13:05But you really are going to need, you know, to to use your
- 13:08first party data. Think about the match rates,
- 13:11right? When you upload a list of work
- 13:13emails or you're thinking over a list of contacts from demand
- 13:18base to LinkedIn, the match rate on a work e-mail is gonna be
- 13:22very low, no matter if it's demand based or market or
- 13:24whatever you're using. Because 90% of people have their
- 13:27personal e-mail in LinkedIn, not their work e-mail.
- 13:30So in that case, you really need a tool, an identity resolution
- 13:34provider who can take that work, e-mail that work identity and
- 13:39match it to their identity graph so that it also includes the
- 13:42consumer ID and that is what's going to get your match right
- 13:45up, right. So this that in particular is
- 13:48not new technology, but it's just not really been leveraged.
- 13:51And you know, that's why I love some of the things that demand
- 13:53base is doing with, with the partnerships that you have and
- 13:56sort of having your own identity graph that also leverages other
- 13:59ones. One thing that's important to
- 14:01consider too, when we're thinking about identity
- 14:04resolution partners is the concept of an account in the
- 14:07graph. So there's a lot of data
- 14:09providers out there who, you know, if you went to them and
- 14:12you said, oh, I want to, you know, target a list of people
- 14:14who are this job title and these companies, whatever, they may be
- 14:19able to do that, but they don't have the concept of an account
- 14:22in their graph, right? They only have people,
- 14:24individuals. And so it would be like if you
- 14:27had Salesforce without an account object in it, Yeah,
- 14:30technically you could have a field on the person that says
- 14:33this is the company they're at, but it's just a very different
- 14:36looking sort of infrastructure. And so, you know, these new
- 14:40technologies or new uses or new applications of technologies are
- 14:44going to be critical for getting the full power and value out of
- 14:50that first party data. It's already there and it's just
- 14:52so under leveraged. Even if cookies weren't going
- 14:55away, you still would want to do it.
- 14:58All right. So then also, you know, in terms
- 15:00of strategies, there's some privacy.
- 15:02First things that are, you know, Google's Privacy Sandbox, for
- 15:06example, is a big topic of discussion.
- 15:10It remains to be seen how effective it is.
- 15:13I know there was that recent article, I think IAB years was
- 15:17put out that basically said, no, it doesn't do what we need it to
- 15:22do. And now Google's saying, oh,
- 15:23yes, it does. You just didn't look at the
- 15:24right thing. So it will remain to be seen,
- 15:27but you know, we'll still look at those and how we can apply
- 15:31them. One other thing though, if
- 15:33you're thinking about, OK, first party data, that's, that's
- 15:35really a big component of this and, and of the strategies, how
- 15:40do we, in addition to using an identity partner, we need to
- 15:44collect as much as we can. And how do we, how do we collect
- 15:47and build our first party data? And it's really by enhancing the
- 15:50customer experience. What is the value that you're
- 15:53offering to someone to precipitate that exchange of
- 15:56information? What do you have that actually
- 15:58makes them want to provide that to you and, and take the risk in
- 16:02some cases of giving you the ability to e-mail them or market
- 16:05to them. And so I think that, you know,
- 16:08personalizing the experience, building loyalty programs, just
- 16:12content that actually engages and provides value versus just,
- 16:15hey, give me your e-mail and here's a, a white paper that,
- 16:17you know, doesn't actually help you in any way.
- 16:19That's going to be critical. And then, I mean, this is a kind
- 16:22of a more general, general strategy, but just
- 16:25collaboration. I think within, you know,
- 16:27anytime there's a big change like this in an industry, I
- 16:31think it's critical for people to collaborate, to talk to each
- 16:35other, other people in the industry.
- 16:37How are you adapting to this? What are you doing?
- 16:39What are some solutions? And so I think that happens
- 16:42organically within people's networks.
- 16:44And it also happens at an industry level with different
- 16:47industry groups, you know, like IAB working to sort of define
- 16:52and design the future of this digital advertising world.
- 16:55Post cookies. And then, Kara, I do think we're
- 16:58going to start seeing a resurgence in contextual
- 17:00targeting too, including relying more heavily on direct publisher
- 17:06buys. And then in general, just
- 17:08focusing on the content and using that either as intent data
- 17:13or really personalizing the messaging around relevant
- 17:18content will really start to be the focus with targeting when
- 17:24available. I love this too, because I think
- 17:26that we've become, so it's been an interesting shift in the last
- 17:31like, you know, 15 years or so to go from site direct buys and
- 17:35then the advent, you know, programmatic was like the new
- 17:38hot thing and you know it Now it's, it's the only thing.
- 17:41It's like, if you're not buying on an audience, what are you
- 17:44doing? And not the only thing.
- 17:45Obviously we still do a good bit of publisher buying, but I think
- 17:49in a lot of cases we've lost sight of the fact that we're
- 17:52buying not just on a job title or a company size, right?
- 17:57The person in an account that is your buyer is not necessarily
- 18:03always the one with the title. You think, especially when you
- 18:05get into Enterprise Oregon, when you look at the difference
- 18:07between a mid market buying group versus an enterprise
- 18:10buying group. And so I love the idea of using,
- 18:14I usually say behaviors, but in this case, the behavior of
- 18:17consuming some content that is only content that the buyer
- 18:22who's in that, you know, champion role is going to be
- 18:25consuming rather than focusing just on, oh, well, do they have
- 18:28that title? It's like, well, no, not
- 18:30necessarily, but it could be an intern or someone that's been
- 18:33deputized by a SISO. And the CSO said, all right, go
- 18:37out, do some research, put a report together for me.
- 18:39And so they're the ones looking at that publisher, looking at
- 18:42that content. And if you're targeting
- 18:44contextually, you're going to be there.
- 18:46But if you were only a targeting in that same inventory off of a
- 18:49title for CSO's only you're not going to be there and you're not
- 18:52going to be in that report. So I like this as a way, as a
- 18:56kind of forcing mechanism for people to rethink their
- 18:59targeting. Yeah, I like it too.
- 19:01But Chris, back to your question around pricing, this is
- 19:05definitely one of the reasons why we're going to start to see
- 19:08that uptick in pricing because a direct buy with you know, dark
- 19:14reading, the Washington Post, Wall Street Journal, those are
- 19:18those are not cheap. So we'll start to see that
- 19:20increase there too. Definitely.
- 19:23And I love the word curmudgeon. OK, I'm I'm going to embrace it.
- 19:27I've been kind of a curmudgeon in marketing for a very long
- 19:31time. And I do feel there's some irony
- 19:36of what's happening in our industry right now, right?
- 19:39Like I think most are talking about AI as it relates to
- 19:43content as a means of faster production, producing more
- 19:47content. But if we think about a lot of
- 19:50the strategies you just talked about where we need more
- 19:52information and we need more first party data and we need
- 19:56that context of the buying group and not maybe one individual
- 20:00person or title. It seems like we may be
- 20:05oversimplifying how we should approach content and going back
- 20:09to the early days of pure content marketing.
- 20:12Let's create amazing experiences with extremely valuable content
- 20:17where we can capture that data ourselves and understand like,
- 20:21hey, do they want this benchmark or how are you thinking about
- 20:25that? Because I always go into
- 20:27curmudgeon mode a little bit and think that sometimes we're
- 20:30chasing the next shiny object or squirrel when really the common
- 20:35sense answers punching us in the face over and over and over.
- 20:38Yeah, first of all, I love the use of the word curmudgeon as a
- 20:42as an English major, which somehow led me to this
- 20:45inexplicably love the use of the word curmudgeon.
- 20:48So thank you for that. But yeah, I agree.
- 20:50I think, I think that it's easy to get attracted by the latest
- 20:55and greatest and in time lose the foundations, right, because
- 21:01I see this happen a lot too with companies that are using I'll
- 21:04just use LinkedIn, for example. They're they're so caught up in
- 21:07the targeting that they can use that they're not thinking as
- 21:10much about what are they offering, right?
- 21:13Is what their is the creative? Is the offer actually
- 21:17compelling? Does do people care about it?
- 21:19You know, they're as something as foundational as just what's
- 21:22the hook, right? The one of the most foundational
- 21:26concepts in marketing, what's the hook?
- 21:29And it isn't there because it's, there's so much focus on the
- 21:32technology and the targeting piece.
- 21:34And so, yeah, I think that I think you're right.
- 21:36I think that there's, it's, you've got to get the
- 21:39foundations right. That's 80% of it.
- 21:42And then the 20% is how do I enhance and accelerate on those
- 21:48foundations using things like AI and and big data and technology?
- 21:53About that and Carrie, you may want to tackle this one first
- 21:56and then I'm sure Rachel, you'll have some thoughts too.
- 21:59But last question before we kind of close out with some fun
- 22:02questions. How are marketers adjusting
- 22:05their approach to tracking and analyzing campaign performance
- 22:10without traditional cookie based metrics?
- 22:13Yeah. I mean, I think to Rachel's
- 22:14point earlier, there is more use of first party data, so more
- 22:19focus on collecting and analyzing data directly.
- 22:23You know that they have like website visits, app usage, CRM,
- 22:27you know, things that's collected in CRM.
- 22:29And I think to again, to get the most out of that, having an
- 22:32identity based partner who can de anonymize a lot of those
- 22:37touch points, at least at the account level is going to be
- 22:40critical. So for example, one of the
- 22:43things we love doing with demand base is using the account
- 22:47activity reports to then analyze the impact of different types of
- 22:53touch points or different tactics or campaigns to say, all
- 22:56right, control. You know, this group of accounts
- 23:00was exposed to this campaign, This group of accounts wasn't is
- 23:04there a statistically significant lift in conversion
- 23:07to opportunity or in close rate or in velocity?
- 23:10And in that case, you don't need the last click direct
- 23:14attribution, but you do need so those anonymized or deanonymized
- 23:19account activities like simple as a page view, right?
- 23:23And so I think those two are are critical for analysis, track
- 23:27tracking and analysis. Certainly, you know, utilizing
- 23:31some privacy preserving AP is again like the privacy sandbox.
- 23:36I don't know. Are they still saying using
- 23:38Flock? I feel like everyone's talking
- 23:41Privacy sandbox now, but you know, we'll see how that we'll
- 23:44see how that goes. I know we'll, we'll be
- 23:46interested in getting our hands on on some of that CRMI think.
- 23:51I know a lot of people are building out more robust objects
- 23:56and fields in CRMI. See a lot of people using
- 24:01Visible, which which I like and I have issues with because I
- 24:06love that it unifies a lot of the touch points and it gives
- 24:11you the ability to analyze more data.
- 24:15What I don't like is that it doesn't account for all of those
- 24:18touch points. So an anonymous visit to the
- 24:19site by an account that's not coming up as a visible touch
- 24:22point and it's going to get zero revenue, an impression on
- 24:26LinkedIn, you know, or a set of impressions on LinkedIn.
- 24:28They're getting zero credit in the visible attribution model.
- 24:32So, you know, I take a little issue with that.
- 24:35And I think that's where that, you know, applying more advanced
- 24:38analytics and AI and even not advanced, to be honest, that is,
- 24:43is the key to to adjusting the approach for measurement, right?
- 24:47I think that even just basic statistical analysis is hugely
- 24:52under leveraged right now in marketing.
- 24:54And in some cases because the data is just not there, either
- 24:57it's not actionable, it's not clean or there's not enough of
- 25:02it. But in a lot of cases, I think
- 25:03it's also just a lot of marketers don't have that skill
- 25:07set and they don't have access in their team to a data
- 25:11scientist who can do this type of work for them.
- 25:13Even it's funny too, because we work with a lot of tech
- 25:16companies and their, their whole business is data and technology.
- 25:22And they might have an army of data scientists and the
- 25:25marketing team doesn't get access to them.
- 25:27Or they're, you know, they're last in the queue because
- 25:29they're busy working on the product.
- 25:31But I think that, you know, basic statistical analysis like
- 25:34A2 tail test, right? Like the example I gave earlier,
- 25:37two sets of accounts exposed in control.
- 25:40If I want to analyse is there a statistically significant lift
- 25:43if an account saw a campaign or not, or did a certain activity
- 25:47or not? That's a pretty basic analysis
- 25:50that you can do that doesn't require third party cookies.
- 25:53I. Think the big take away here is
- 25:56that you really, really from the analytic side need to bring in
- 26:01some experts to get you through this phase.
- 26:04And in the past, if you have just been kind of piercing it
- 26:08together, you know, trying your best, working with the team that
- 26:12you have, but maybe don't have that background in advanced
- 26:16analytics, AI statistics. Now is the time to really bring
- 26:20in some experts because you're going to you're, if you're you
- 26:23are already struggling with data before this, you're definitely
- 26:27going to struggle with it now. Yeah, It reminds me of, you
- 26:31know, where maybe digital was, I don't know, 1520 years ago where
- 26:37you had a lot of marketers who are like, it's a fad, it's a
- 26:40phase. Maybe they would bring in like a
- 26:42digital person and they just didn't see the need to learn
- 26:46anything about digital. And now it's like, who even are
- 26:50you? If you, if you have zero
- 26:51knowledge, there's no way you're going to progress.
- 26:54You can't be a CMO today and not know anything about digital.
- 26:57I mean, I'm sorry, you just you can't.
- 26:59And I think that that's happening now with data and
- 27:02technology expertise, right? Marketers who to date have, to
- 27:07Rachel's point, sort of gotten by with a very basic kind of
- 27:11basic Excel skills and thinking that they're doing an analysis
- 27:16of a campaign, they're going to need to up level or they're
- 27:21going to be old news because it's so much more compelling and
- 27:25actionable. If I come in and I say, you
- 27:27know, one person says, oh, this creative is better because the
- 27:31click through rate is higher, it's much different.
- 27:33If I come in and I say, well, I did a, you know, 2 tail test and
- 27:37the P value of you know, .05 tells me that this creative is a
- 27:43hot has a better click through rate.
- 27:46You know, just using the language in the actual
- 27:48statistics. I did a terrible job at it,
- 27:50which I just took a whole data science course too.
- 27:53I would absolutely horrify my professors, but you can see the
- 27:57language is very different. And when you make decisions off
- 28:01of real, true, statistically grounded analysis, the outputs
- 28:05and the results are going to be so much different than when you
- 28:08think you're doing making a decision off of an analysis.
- 28:12But really, it's almost worse than than not using the data at
- 28:17all. Yeah, great advice.
- 28:19I think we need to avoid our typical marketing throw an
- 28:23intern solution which happened with digital social content.
- 28:28I mean pretty much every new function that started to get a
- 28:32lot of time and attention, it was we'll get an intern for
- 28:34that. And yeah, definitely not the
- 28:36case with analytics and understanding this new world
- 28:40without cookies. So thank you both for tons of
- 28:43amazing content. This has been extremely helpful.
- 28:46And you know this, but we like to close out the show with two
- 28:49consistent questions. So the first is about good
- 28:52reads. Is there a book, blog,
- 28:54newsletter, or podcast that you'd recommend to our
- 28:56listeners? Yes, I just got back from
- 28:59vacation and I was voraciously reading the entire time.
- 29:03And one that I really enjoyed is A World Without e-mail by Vino
- 29:08Cal Newport. He also wrote Deep Work, Which
- 29:11is a concept that we are. So we are so into the concept of
- 29:15deep work. It's in our company handbook.
- 29:17But essentially it's reimagining how business can work and get
- 29:22out of the what he calls the hyperactive hive mind of Slack
- 29:26and e-mail and just sort of context switching 600 times a
- 29:30day and actually do good quality work, but still communicate
- 29:37effectively. And I just found it fascinating.
- 29:39I'm Rachel's probably terrified because she's the one that
- 29:43implements all of our processes and I'm about to come in with
- 29:46some new ones. I'm ready for it.
- 29:49Yeah, we're pretty sure you may have to get books.
- 29:52I recommend. That's a counterpoint to that.
- 29:57That could be your recommendation.
- 29:58Next, Rachel, if you want to add a book, you can add a book too.
- 30:01But the other question we usually ask is about good
- 30:05people. Could you share the names of
- 30:06three inspirational people in the B2B space that you recommend
- 30:09we bring to the show? Yeah.
- 30:11I mean, Renee, Asus is a good personal friend of mine, but he
- 30:15also probably because I've latched on to him after meeting
- 30:20him in a professional context. He's just, he's probably taught
- 30:23me everything I know about B2B ad tech and measurement.
- 30:27He is a brilliant mind. The way he understands the
- 30:30technical components of what's happening in the back end is
- 30:33really impressive. And especially when you talk
- 30:36about cookie lists, he's just off keep we run run circles
- 30:41around us. Jen Lever, she is a friend as
- 30:45well and a client and just a great mind.
- 30:48We we kind of joke. We have similar brains, you
- 30:50know, just really great mind when it comes to B2B creative,
- 30:53inventive in the weeds. And she just joined one of our
- 30:57clients, Cloudball, I don't know, December maybe.
- 31:01And she's already just really pushing and and doing some great
- 31:05things. So she's also just fun to riff
- 31:08with. And then someone I think you
- 31:10know too, Sophia Augustina, who is just the most fun human being
- 31:15and so warm and intelligent and and also very impressive.
- 31:20You know, she's over at IBM and, and doing some really
- 31:23interesting things with demand base, I believe actually
- 31:26specifically, but she's a great speaker as well.
- 31:30I saw her at Forrester B2B last year and man, I could sit.
- 31:34I could listen to her and chat with her for hours.
- 31:38Definitely. Yeah, she is high energy too.
- 31:41She always brings the energy, which is awesome.
- 31:44And Rachel, maybe you can tackle the very last question.
- 31:47How can people get in touch with both of you after the podcast?
- 31:51Yeah, absolutely. You can go to
- 31:53alcamomarketing.com and fill out a form.
- 31:57ALCAMO is spelled ALCAMO and you can also get in touch with us
- 32:02through LinkedIn. Feel free to find us and we'd
- 32:06love to connect with you. Awesome.
- 32:08Well, Cara and Rachel, thank you so much for your time.
- 32:11Thanks for all the great content fighting the good fight on this
- 32:14to help everyone get this right. So thank you both.
- 32:17Yeah, Thanks, Chris. It was super fun.
- 32:19You know I always love talking about this so appreciate you
- 32:22having us on. All right, enjoy the bees and
- 32:24animals and everything you mentioned before.
- 32:27I will. Thanks for joining us for On
- 32:32Base. If you enjoyed this episode,
- 32:33please be sure to share, rate, review and subscribe on Spotify,
- 32:37Apple, YouTube, or wherever you get your podcasts.
- 32:40The show is brought to you by Demand Base, the only account
- 32:43based experience platform built for sales and marketing
- 32:46alignment.