Latest / Technovation with Peter High (CIO, CTO, CDO, CXO Interviews) / Mastering High-Stakes Negotiation: Insights from Former Scotland Yard Detective Scott Walker
Transcript
- 0:00Dealing with the actual client, the customer is
- 0:02relatively
- 0:03straightforward. But internally, within the business within the
- 0:07organization,
- 0:08there are often lots of,
- 0:10competing priorities,
- 0:12internal politics, silo thinking, and there's no different
- 0:15in life or death. Kidnapped that
- 0:18negotiation. Dealing with the kin was relatively
- 0:21straightforward and in easy
- 0:23because they're just businessman
- 0:24looking to get the best deal at the
- 0:26end of the day.
- 0:28Welcome to.
- 0:29I'm your host Peter He. My guest today
- 0:31is Scott Walker. Scott served as a Scotland
- 0:34yard detective for 16 years investigating all aspects
- 0:37of serious and organized crime, including kidnapping and
- 0:40terrorism.
- 0:41He also deployed overseas as part of a
- 0:43military intelligence
- 0:44interrogation team to inter interject and high value
- 0:47targets.
- 0:48When he left the police in 20 15,
- 0:50Scott joined a crisis in risk management consultancy
- 0:53that specialize from kidnapped for ransom negotiations and
- 0:56resolving other similar peril around the world.
- 0:59Scott continues to advise, train, and coach leaders,
- 1:02at all levels, organizations who wish to enhance
- 1:04their resilience,
- 1:05emotional intelligence and communication skills. He helps companies
- 1:09build a culture of resilience and develop engaged,
- 1:12fulfilled, purpose driven and productive teams.
- 1:15In March of 20 24, Scott publishes his
- 1:18first book, order out of chaos, win every
- 1:20negotiation, thrive in a diversity and become a
- 1:23world class communicator.
- 1:25Scott, welcome to. It's great to speak with
- 1:27you today.
- 1:28Thanks, Pete. It's great to be here.
- 1:30Well, I I wanna talk about your beginnings.
- 1:33Mentioned in the introduction there that you were
- 1:36for 16 years a, police detective. And Wonder
- 1:39what inspired you go into that that work.
- 1:41Yeah. I was always
- 1:44attracted
- 1:45to that line of work for some reason
- 1:47really...
- 1:48He was a kid. He was a young
- 1:49kid. I was always asking why
- 1:51much to the
- 1:53frustration probably of parents and grandparents.
- 1:56And I always I've avoid been curious as
- 1:58to what makes
- 2:00human beings do what they do.
- 2:02And as a police officers are detective,
- 2:05you get a a ring side seat into
- 2:08into 1 all of. Into all levels of
- 2:10society,
- 2:11into all manner of behavior,
- 2:14and and particularly from the psychological perspective as
- 2:16well. And I just fascinated.
- 2:18Plus, I mean, I enjoyed it every single
- 2:20day, pretty much I actually got paid
- 2:22to go after bad guys,
- 2:25give
- 2:26innocent good people of voice.
- 2:29To stand up for them, stand up for
- 2:30the victims,
- 2:32and feel as if I was doing something
- 2:34meaningful and worthwhile.
- 2:36And as I said, I loved every moment
- 2:38of it. And
- 2:40yeah, had a very varied and interesting career
- 2:43for sure. That that... That's quite apparent. And
- 2:46toward the end of your time,
- 2:49with Scott Yard, you were invited to participate
- 2:50in kidnapping in ransom cases. And I wonder
- 2:53does that opportunity present itself? What what were
- 2:56you doing previously
- 2:58to to make it clear that that was
- 2:59something that you might be good at? As
- 3:01I I have to imagine that it's not
- 3:03everyone that is invited to do so.
- 3:06Again, Always
- 3:08done jobs
- 3:09within my career the police that I'd really
- 3:11enjoyed, whether or night it was counter terrorism
- 3:13work,
- 3:15intelligence gathering, Covid ops,
- 3:18and 1 of my roles before that was
- 3:21as a
- 3:22inform handler, an agent handler, you know, in
- 3:25America, you call them Cis,
- 3:27confidential inform.
- 3:28My job there was to
- 3:31identify, recruit and handle those kind of individuals.
- 3:34To again it was all about
- 3:37how do you influence and persuade and motivate
- 3:40and and
- 3:41bring about some kind of cooperation with other
- 3:43people?
- 3:44Particularly if they don't don't wanna do so
- 3:46initially.
- 3:47So of that lend me down 1 path
- 3:49and then 1 day I in a in
- 3:50the place canteen,
- 3:52in the police playstation on, I bumped into
- 3:55a a former body of mine,
- 3:57there were known for years.
- 3:59And at this point, I've being promoted a
- 4:01couple of times.
- 4:02And the only danger I was facing
- 4:05was getting paper cuts from all the crime
- 4:08reports.
- 4:09Or
- 4:10a sore side from sat down beyond a
- 4:12desk or day. And he he was just
- 4:14regalia me over a coffee of... He'd spent
- 4:17the last 4 days or so
- 4:19helping to negotiate the release
- 4:22of a young man from the clutches of
- 4:24quite a vicious Albania
- 4:26organized Crime gang.
- 4:28I just sat there, pete over over the
- 4:30coffee thinking.
- 4:31I want I want some of that. I
- 4:33wanna get involved in that.
- 4:35And
- 4:37But graciously, he he made introductions to the
- 4:40unit that's
- 4:42oversaw or the selection and training of of
- 4:44that line of work.
- 4:45And
- 4:47I applied, Went through the process
- 4:49and they came out the other side.
- 4:51And threw myself into those 3AM phone calls
- 4:56when you gotta go and
- 4:58get alongside the family and and help negotiate
- 5:01the lease of their loved ones.
- 5:03And is there is there an apprentice apprenticeship
- 5:05to this? Is there somebody by your side
- 5:07in the early stages as you're learning how
- 5:09to do this? I mean, I, as I
- 5:10as I think about the the range of
- 5:12of,
- 5:13skills 1 needs, and understanding of human psychology,
- 5:17risk management, calculus of various kinds,
- 5:20and we'll get into some of the of
- 5:21your deeper learnings
- 5:23as we go through this conversation no doubt.
- 5:25III recognize some of this must have been
- 5:28part of what you were doing already,
- 5:30but the application of this must have been
- 5:32different as well.
- 5:35Yeah. Absolutely.
- 5:36Y was assigned
- 5:37a far more experienced
- 5:39negotiator colleague
- 5:41in in these cases. Because like anything. You
- 5:43know, you're gonna get good in business. You
- 5:45need the flying hours. He don't become a
- 5:47Ceo,
- 5:49successful Ceo,
- 5:506 months out of high school. You know,
- 5:52yeah, if you're gonna do a startup up
- 5:53I guess. But if you wanna if you
- 5:55wanna be the Head, a large multinational organization
- 5:58or whatever it is, then you're gonna have
- 6:00to get those flying out. You know, and
- 6:01you normally get mentors
- 6:04along the way who can guide you. Not
- 6:05always remember my
- 6:07very first
- 6:09negotiation. Very first, kidnapping
- 6:11I deployed to. I hadn't quite mastered the
- 6:13skill set completely around
- 6:16about emotional self regulation, for example. You know,
- 6:19you know, if you can regulate
- 6:21what you're feeling,
- 6:23that can help you know the decision making
- 6:25and the actions you take.
- 6:27And to cut up very long story short,
- 6:29I'm with this family, we'd have the
- 6:31their young son taken by a gang, and
- 6:35he was in a pretty bad way. He
- 6:36was being tortured and, you know, the deadline
- 6:39was fast approaching.
- 6:41I I was getting really frustrated with the
- 6:43family.
- 6:44As to why they wouldn't listen to my
- 6:48wise
- 6:49say advice, you know, the old age of
- 6:52on know, 28 or whatever was at the
- 6:54time.
- 6:55And
- 6:56I ended
- 6:57being really direct. Borderline probably very rude actually.
- 7:01And almost shouting with the family.
- 7:04And that is until I found, I felt
- 7:07this hand on my shoulder.
- 7:09And there was an imp unacceptable squeeze
- 7:11of my far more
- 7:14experienced
- 7:15esteem
- 7:16colleague next next to me who
- 7:18thankfully was able to enter interrupt my pattern
- 7:22and then allow me to just sit and
- 7:23watch a real master class as to
- 7:27how do you bring about
- 7:29influence,
- 7:30persuasion,
- 7:31cooperation,
- 7:32collaboration.
- 7:33When the stakes can't get any higher,
- 7:36and the emotions and and everything else are
- 7:38running running super high.
- 7:41Yeah. You've noted
- 7:42that the number 1 skill of of a
- 7:45top negotiator is the ability to self regulate
- 7:47emotions. You've added to that that highly developed
- 7:49sensory acuity is also
- 7:51very important. And clearly, that's a description of
- 7:54that.
- 7:55It's something that... And clearly, as you point
- 7:57out, it's something, and and as your experience
- 7:59bear, bears out,
- 8:01it's something that can be learned as well.
- 8:03Can you talk a bit about some of
- 8:05the steps towards,
- 8:06being able to self regulate one's emotions and
- 8:08also to heighten their sensory acuity, acuity? Practice
- 8:12makes
- 8:12a mate... To make perfect. It makes permanent
- 8:14though. And it's like anything, it's it's a
- 8:17muscle.
- 8:18You know that emotionally intelligence muscle, the sensory
- 8:21acuity, the regulation,
- 8:24You know, just like you go to the
- 8:25gym to get strong or fitting. You don't
- 8:28just go once and then expecting to walk
- 8:30out looking like on arnold Sc and egg
- 8:32or somebody.
- 8:33You have to practice
- 8:35and fail often. And
- 8:37what it really is a couple of principles
- 8:40or concepts that can really help us all
- 8:43to
- 8:44to mask this really.
- 8:45And the first 1 is in any form
- 8:47of
- 8:48communication, particularly when it really counts
- 8:51particularly those difficult
- 8:54conversations. And, you know, we've all got 1
- 8:56of those conversations we put off,
- 8:58or we're quite re to
- 9:00engaging in,
- 9:02and that is really, it's not about you.
- 9:04Again, the Stephen C lion a first seek
- 9:07to understand before being understood.
- 9:10That still stands a test of time decades
- 9:12later from when he pending his book.
- 9:15And it's true though, if we can enter
- 9:17into
- 9:18a situation and
- 9:20negotiation
- 9:21with far more curiosity than of some assumption.
- 9:25If I'm gonna... Like I'm really interested in
- 9:28what's going on for Peter right now.
- 9:31He's at the table for this business deal
- 9:34or he leading on a project or whatever
- 9:36it is. I need to know what he's
- 9:38really going on for Peter. How does he
- 9:40see this situation? How does he see me?
- 9:43Etcetera and how can I best bring about
- 9:45some kind of collaboration cooperation or indeed some
- 9:49behavioral change with Peter?
- 9:51And it's no good if I'm
- 9:53if I'm be like I wasn't in that
- 9:54first, kidnapping case of dealt with,
- 9:57allowing my
- 9:59emotions to overall the common sense in the
- 10:01and the national decision making. Even though we
- 10:04make decisions emotionally and justify them rationally afterwards,
- 10:07we can still look to bring
- 10:10an element of control
- 10:12over that as much as possible. It's not
- 10:14easy,
- 10:15simple, but not easy.
- 10:17And so yet, it's it's looking at it.
- 10:19It's not about me. It's about the other
- 10:20person.
- 10:22Gotta to get my own state where needs
- 10:24to be my own emotions in check, first
- 10:26of all,
- 10:27bring that curiosity
- 10:29while an assumption. And
- 10:31I can elaborate on some of the other
- 10:33steps a bit later on, perhaps,
- 10:34about where where do we go with that?
- 10:37How do we really then bring about
- 10:39Peter, for example, to make a decision or
- 10:42change mind or do some kind of behavioral
- 10:44change.
- 10:45I I know that the,
- 10:47the insight enjoyable Taylor from her,
- 10:50stroke for from her her Ted talk that
- 10:52we're feeling creatures that think as opposed to
- 10:55the opposite as meaningful for you and and
- 10:58and certainly, you're describing that
- 11:00just there. Yeah. That's. Do We you know,
- 11:02we're emotional creatures that think.
- 11:04Not thinking creatures that feel. And you rightly
- 11:07said that Peter it's,
- 11:08we're designed as as the species as an
- 11:10organism so to speak. We're designed to experience
- 11:14emotion. It's it's how we interpret the world
- 11:17around us. And unilaterally could experience exactly the
- 11:20same situation or set of circumstances.
- 11:23But we could experience different completely different
- 11:27emotions,
- 11:28which will then impact
- 11:29our decision making, which then impacts the actions
- 11:32that we take as a
- 11:33So the more we can get ahead of
- 11:35that curve so to speak. The more we
- 11:38can
- 11:39identify and get to tune with what we're
- 11:41feeling what we what we're experiencing.
- 11:44And crucially what the other person is,
- 11:47then we can start to think about... Well,
- 11:50I we could bring about so form of
- 11:52success here where
- 11:54everybody can walk away you fitting, like, they've
- 11:56got what they need from this conversation or
- 11:58it. Stable or whatever it is.
- 12:00And you've spoken about and and even alluded
- 12:03already in the story
- 12:04of that excruciating, first negotiation managing the chaos
- 12:08within the chaos.
- 12:11That's... When you're going through your negotiations, naturally
- 12:13they are chaotic.
- 12:14But but even, the the your your clients,
- 12:18the the the who are you... Who you
- 12:20are negotiating on behalf of or who you
- 12:22are counseling for the negotiation, there's chaos on
- 12:25that side as well. And so it almost
- 12:27feels like, you know, 3 or 4 dimensional
- 12:29chess as you think about, the moves of
- 12:31the person across the table, but also the
- 12:33move on your side of the table as
- 12:35well and managing across all of that. Talk
- 12:37a bit about that that insight, the managing
- 12:39of the chaos within the chaos.
- 12:42Yeah. And I'm sure your your views and
- 12:45listeners will relate to this, dealing with the
- 12:47actual client, the customer is relatively
- 12:50straightforward.
- 12:51Relatively easy.
- 12:53But internally, within the business within the
- 12:56organization, there are often lots of egos
- 12:59competing priorities,
- 13:01internal politics, silo thinking,
- 13:04all of that stuff that can get in
- 13:06the way
- 13:07a really
- 13:08effective
- 13:10providing value to the customer to the client.
- 13:12And there's no different in life or death
- 13:14kidnapped
- 13:15negotiations.
- 13:16Dealing with the kin was relatively and, relatively
- 13:20straightforward and easy
- 13:22because they're just businessman
- 13:23looking to get the best deal at the
- 13:25end of the day.
- 13:26But 80 percent of my time at least
- 13:29was spent on the crisis within the crisis
- 13:32was
- 13:33usually the crisis management team, the senior leadership
- 13:36team, the board,
- 13:37the exec level team,
- 13:40that that was where my
- 13:42skills and my ability and my energy and
- 13:45my attention was really brought to bear there,
- 13:48was being able to navigate
- 13:51through, as I said, the ego, the internal
- 13:54politics, the
- 13:55the the the shifting energies, the the things
- 13:58that are unspoken
- 14:00the culture in the
- 14:01organization.
- 14:02And,
- 14:04yeah. There's sometimes I was just happy and
- 14:06glad to get on the call with the
- 14:08bad guys, because I thought, right, this... I
- 14:10can kinda of control that,
- 14:12but navigating that that crisis within the crisis
- 14:15is
- 14:16Yeah. It's something that's across every industry and
- 14:20sector. I'm sure. And anyone listening as I
- 14:22said, in their business. I'm sure most of
- 14:24their time will be spent
- 14:26dealing whether, firefight fighting or more, longer term
- 14:29issues
- 14:30internally more than externally facing.
- 14:331 of the things that shines through through
- 14:35so many of your stories, Scott as the
- 14:36importance of empathy. I mean, so often, the
- 14:39negotiations that you're part of are really black
- 14:41and white. There is crystal clear as to
- 14:43who was good and who was bad, who
- 14:45was who is wrong.
- 14:47And yet finding empathy
- 14:50and using Empathy rather, but in finding out
- 14:52the motivation, is so critically important. If you
- 14:55get carried away with the fact that the
- 14:56person on the other side is a bad
- 14:58person,
- 14:59then your ability to negotiate is is hindered
- 15:02at a minimum.
- 15:03Talk a bit about the necessity for for
- 15:06for the even in situations where, you know,
- 15:08on the face of it, it might be
- 15:09might seem so difficult to to find it.
- 15:11What if
- 15:13emotional self regulation is the number 1 skill,
- 15:16of all the best negotiators in the world
- 15:18irrespective of what you're negotiating over.
- 15:22The the step that's just closer all the
- 15:24skill that's just closely follows that is the
- 15:27ability to empathize
- 15:29effectively.
- 15:30And people sometimes
- 15:32misunderstand what empathy is and what it isn't.
- 15:35It's a doing word. We do empathy.
- 15:38It's not where we take on the emotions
- 15:40or the feeling of the other side or
- 15:42the other person.
- 15:44And it's certainly not about
- 15:46agreeing with
- 15:48a qui,
- 15:49honing or supporting
- 15:51whatever it is you're looking to empathize.
- 15:53Or who with. For example,
- 15:56I would have to empathize and I did
- 15:57on every single
- 16:00kidnapping or cyber or other form of distortion
- 16:03case. That to empathize with the other side.
- 16:05And just like in business,
- 16:08you have to be able to empathize with
- 16:09people who you don't get on with or
- 16:11share anything in common.
- 16:13And particularly with the the clients or the
- 16:16customers.
- 16:17And it's really
- 16:19simply a case of
- 16:21you being able
- 16:23to
- 16:24demonstrate your understanding
- 16:26of where
- 16:27near the side is at.
- 16:30And that is particularly powerful
- 16:32if you disagree
- 16:34on something. Or there's a bit of a
- 16:36gap there.
- 16:37Maybe you and I are on opposite size
- 16:39of the negotiating table, Peter.
- 16:42And we're... We've hit a bit of an
- 16:43impasse where we can't quite agree on how
- 16:46to close this deal. And so
- 16:49empathy and action here would look something like
- 16:51Peter is okay for just share with you
- 16:53where I think you're at right now with
- 16:55this deal.
- 16:56You're not gonna say no. You're gonna say,
- 16:58yeah, sure. And I'll say semi on the
- 17:01lines of...
- 17:02Well, for from my perspective, it it seems
- 17:04like you think that we're dragging our heels
- 17:06on this. And that we're looking to the
- 17:08cut you
- 17:10and maybe almost trying to pull a fast
- 17:121 and do out of a significant part
- 17:15of the market share here. Mean I've just
- 17:17made that up, but you can kinda get
- 17:18a sense of and you'll either go, yes,
- 17:20no or maybe.
- 17:22If you go maybe, okay great. Well, I
- 17:25can kind of elaborate a bit if it's
- 17:27no, that's fine, You're gonna tell me what
- 17:28it really is. And if I am spot
- 17:30on,
- 17:31well we've kind of dealt with that, you
- 17:33then feel
- 17:35see and heard and understood that I'm taking
- 17:38the effort, the the energy to
- 17:41understand the world, the situation, this particular
- 17:45negotiation
- 17:45from your perspective.
- 17:47Even if I think Peter, you're being an
- 17:50absolute pain
- 17:51and you're overthinking it, and you've been unreasonable
- 17:55yourself.
- 17:56It doesn't matter.
- 17:58I need to park my own
- 18:00desire to to prove I'm right and you're
- 18:02wrong
- 18:03to allow my ego to call the shots.
- 18:05I need to put that 1 sign to
- 18:06go, peter... I'm gonna demonstrate. I'm just gonna
- 18:09show you
- 18:11that I understand
- 18:13the the... Through your lens so to speak
- 18:15where we find. Cells. And it's so powerful,
- 18:18particularly
- 18:20if you're with where they're at.
- 18:22Honestly, but it's... Again it's like then the
- 18:24things it's it's a muscle. You've gotta trade
- 18:27it
- 18:28and the more you do it the easier
- 18:29it becomes.
- 18:31Great insights this
- 18:33necessity to ensure that the person across the
- 18:35the table
- 18:37is seen heard understood. These are the basic
- 18:39ingredients ultimately for trust, which you notice is
- 18:42the the currency
- 18:43for for these kinds of discussions that establishing
- 18:46trust is the pathway towards a successful
- 18:49negotiation. Can you maybe elaborate further on that
- 18:51as well?
- 18:52Yeah. And again, I... What I found so
- 18:54intriguing about the stories you tell is,
- 18:57again, the necessity to build trust in all
- 19:00sorts of scenarios, including where we're, in so
- 19:03many of your negotiations,
- 19:05it would seem like it would be very
- 19:06difficult to find a a pathway to trust.
- 19:10Without trust,
- 19:11the hostages don't come out alive. And yet,
- 19:14let let's just have a look at look
- 19:16at the scenario.
- 19:18Hidden that for ransom
- 19:19negotiations,
- 19:20and
- 19:21in indeed cyber ex as well, and are
- 19:24the similar peril.
- 19:26It's the most level day the most unregulated
- 19:29un governed
- 19:30industries in the world.
- 19:32You could ever think of.
- 19:34If it can go wrong, it does go
- 19:36wrong and if we mess up ultimately sending
- 19:39the kidnapped side of things, people can die.
- 19:42So tends to focus the mind a little
- 19:44bit on what works and what doesn't.
- 19:47And yet,
- 19:48there is a 93
- 19:50percent chance of success
- 19:52of the hostages coming back
- 19:54if we
- 19:56enter into and follow
- 19:58the
- 19:59negotiation.
- 20:0093 percent. Now they're there... Not a hundred
- 20:02percent, but there's still really good odds
- 20:06for success in what is
- 20:08unregulated
- 20:09uncovered, highly dangerous
- 20:11type of situation. And the reason why such
- 20:13a high success rate and consistently so
- 20:17over many, many, many decades
- 20:19is because the trust is in place. For
- 20:22example, if I hand over,
- 20:254000000 dollars
- 20:26for the release of Peter,
- 20:29I need a trust that the connectors are
- 20:30going to stick to their part of the
- 20:32bargain and release you.
- 20:34As supposed to just take the money and
- 20:36kill you.
- 20:37Or or release you then can you again
- 20:40a week later.
- 20:41But equally trust works the other way where
- 20:43they need to trust me that I'm not
- 20:46going to look to craft the money,
- 20:49ambush them,
- 20:50kill them,
- 20:51even arrest them, this is in the private
- 20:53sector in in the when I was in
- 20:54the police, we would absolutely go after the
- 20:57bad guys and look to arrest them. But
- 20:58in the private sector where most of my
- 21:00experience
- 21:01actually was, we weren't interested in that. That
- 21:03was just about
- 21:05working and supporting the families and the companies
- 21:08for the safe and time and release of
- 21:10of the host.
- 21:11But that trust, it takes time.
- 21:14You. And the only way you build that
- 21:16trust
- 21:17is
- 21:18through
- 21:19empathy,
- 21:20and you really can empathize properly
- 21:23if you take the time to listen,
- 21:26to listen deeply
- 21:28without judgment
- 21:30to suspend your own... As I said your
- 21:31own assumptions, your own judgment,
- 21:34and really looked to understand where the site
- 21:37is coming from. And so I call it
- 21:38level 5 listening. And that listening is you're
- 21:42not waiting
- 21:43to speak. I mean, I'm I'm guilty that
- 21:45just as much as the next person, but
- 21:47I'm conscious of it is when someone's talking,
- 21:50you're already framing your
- 21:52your follow on, and sometimes you're leaving interrupt
- 21:55the other person so you could get your
- 21:57point across.
- 21:58Or you're just
- 22:00waiting or you're listening so you can re
- 22:02butt their arguments
- 22:04or maybe you... You're not really listening at
- 22:06all and you're thinking about the Amazon delivery
- 22:09that you're waiting for or what you've gotta
- 22:11do after this conversation. And so if we
- 22:13can get all the way down to to
- 22:15till level 5 and then in the book,
- 22:16I actually talk
- 22:18in lots more detail about those levels.
- 22:21At level 5,
- 22:23you're listening to their point of view.
- 22:26You're listening to almost what is not being
- 22:28said.
- 22:29Just as much as what is being said,
- 22:31such as is an inc
- 22:34between the words and the tone and the
- 22:36Behavior perhaps. Is something not quite right there,
- 22:40but you're never gonna pick that up. Those
- 22:42subtle
- 22:43if you're just waiting
- 22:45to talk yourself. And by listening at that
- 22:48level, it's hard work.
- 22:50But if listening at that level, not just
- 22:52with kid, but maybe
- 22:54you give some really constructive,
- 22:57directs,
- 22:59feedback in the workplace, perhaps.
- 23:01Or some other form of
- 23:03challenging
- 23:04conversation you have to have,
- 23:06in the office. It's that listening, deem em
- 23:09emphasizing
- 23:10which enables you to build rapport.
- 23:13And then and only then you earn the
- 23:15right
- 23:16to start influencing and persuading because you've built
- 23:19that trust up. You haven't just rushed to
- 23:21try and problem solve.
- 23:23And so it does take, better a time
- 23:25to get there, but it's well worth spending
- 23:27the time
- 23:28because then because the when you've earn the
- 23:30trust,
- 23:31it gives you that currency with which
- 23:33to then,
- 23:35not unless it make demands, but make requests
- 23:37of the other side. And to start looking
- 23:39to maybe nudge or influence or persuade them
- 23:42to do something.
- 23:43And I I found your your 5 levels
- 23:45of listening super saying It just to to
- 23:48to
- 23:49enlighten our listeners and viewers,
- 23:51the the 5 levels are listening for gist.
- 23:54Listening to rebuke, and and often, we... It's
- 23:56sort of this first 2 where we linger
- 23:58too often as we are quote unquote listening.
- 24:00Then listening for logic is level 3, level
- 24:034 listening for emotion. And then finally, as
- 24:05you mentioned, level 5, listening for points of
- 24:08view. And III
- 24:10really enjoyed the way in which you describe
- 24:12those in the book and then Necessity to
- 24:14get to level 5, especially when when talking
- 24:16about critical
- 24:17negotiations such as this.
- 24:19As you as you've gone through,
- 24:21negotiations and hostage situations, I realize every 1
- 24:24of them is a bit different, but these
- 24:25are not fast
- 24:27negotiations. They take time. And can you talk
- 24:29of bit about the element of time
- 24:32when it comes to negotiations. I think for,
- 24:34you, almost anyone who goes into it? 1
- 24:35hopes that of course that it is both
- 24:37fast and and that our point of view
- 24:39wins needless to say. But, neither of those
- 24:42should be seen as fore on conclusions and
- 24:44probably even are going to be possible. So
- 24:47can you talk a bit about the element
- 24:47of time as part of this?
- 24:49Time can be your friend in a negotiation.
- 24:52When it's business or for for hostages,
- 24:55what we'd always need to do is by
- 24:56time because if we can...
- 24:58Well, first of all, let me take a
- 24:59step back. With... There's a saying hurry up
- 25:01from wait.
- 25:03Anyone who's ever said the military will understand.
- 25:06Quick quick, quick hurry Hurry up. Alright. And
- 25:08now we just need to wait. It's someone,
- 25:09why did we have to hurry in the
- 25:10first place. But the logic behind that is,
- 25:14in the certainly the first 20 hours of
- 25:15a kidnapping,
- 25:17we wanna get everything in place. We wanna
- 25:19get alongside the family, the company, we wanna
- 25:22set up the phone
- 25:23and
- 25:24discuss a strategy,
- 25:26etcetera, etcetera. And that puts us in a
- 25:28great place.
- 25:29Even if just from a a nervous system
- 25:33perspective feeling we've got an element of control
- 25:35there. It enables us to then have far
- 25:38better
- 25:39negotiation.
- 25:40So
- 25:41we wanna buy time
- 25:43because
- 25:44all the research. All the research shows that
- 25:48our emotions can
- 25:51particularly high emotions,
- 25:53can be reduced. So particularly if we're angry
- 25:56if we highly emo,
- 25:58time allows us to
- 26:00to reduce.
- 26:01And the more we can reduce the anxiety
- 26:04stress
- 26:05overwhelm.
- 26:06I over days and weeks.
- 26:09That then enables objective rational
- 26:13thinking
- 26:14feeling and decision making and action taking
- 26:17to to come to to the forefront.
- 26:20And so
- 26:22That's that's the strategy that's the approach.
- 26:25But when
- 26:26negotiations lasts
- 26:28many weeks,
- 26:30and even a few months,
- 26:31you can't do this
- 26:3312/14/1618
- 26:35hours a day. You just burn out
- 26:38And so 1 of the things I would
- 26:39emphasize and my very first
- 26:41conversations when I sit down with a client
- 26:44would be
- 26:45we need to come up with a sustainable
- 26:47battle with.
- 26:50And that means
- 26:51eventually, we wanna get to the place the
- 26:53point where we'll say to the kin,
- 26:56we will be available between,
- 26:58I dunno let's say, 2 and 4PM every
- 27:01afternoon to speak to.
- 27:03But outside of that time, the phone is
- 27:05gonna be switched off. And the and people
- 27:07go 1 you... We can't turn the phone
- 27:09off, yes, we can This this is a
- 27:11business deal
- 27:13just like you could do this in your
- 27:14wider business sense.
- 27:16You... Because when you're not on the phone
- 27:18in that 2 hour window.
- 27:20It enables you to
- 27:22get some rest, recover, exercise, sleep, eat,
- 27:26have
- 27:27conversations about the strategy? Has it going
- 27:29what are our outcomes and objectives.
- 27:31And again, it just balances
- 27:34from, you know, rather than the fight flight
- 27:36or freeze
- 27:38element of the nervous system,
- 27:40and we wanna calm be down into the...
- 27:42Reapply the brake pedal and just balance it
- 27:44out a bit more really.
- 27:46And that just means we can
- 27:49go for longer.
- 27:50We can have a more sustainable
- 27:54negotiation rather than just burning again. And I've
- 27:56been there where
- 27:57where the the the brother of a, hostage
- 28:00He wanted to he was a younger brother,
- 28:02and he obviously saw this as his moment
- 28:04to shine that his elder brother being taken.
- 28:06And he wanted to
- 28:08Head up, the Crisis management team. He was
- 28:11head of the family business, and he also
- 28:13wanted to be the communicator he was speaking
- 28:14with the kid kidnapping.
- 28:16And he was using his own personal mobile
- 28:18phone. As you can see whether this is
- 28:19probably going out is every
- 28:22notification, every ping, every message. Your email, on
- 28:25his phone thoughts on the kid.
- 28:27And because he couldn't
- 28:29switch off.
- 28:31He just burnt out very quickly, and
- 28:34it immediately ended in tragedy because he turned
- 28:36around to the kidnapping as 1 day they
- 28:38really really
- 28:39burnt out and threaten the kidnapping. Now, I
- 28:42about
- 28:43you Peter. That's never a good idea in
- 28:46my book. I I don't know if if.
- 28:48If anybody would thinking it would be and
- 28:51the kenneth has just turned around and said,
- 28:52right. We're gonna kill your brother and they
- 28:54hung up.
- 28:55And we didn't hear anything for 6 months.
- 28:596 months.
- 29:00Can imagine the family dynamics, the
- 29:03the meal times, the rec elimination, the the
- 29:06the the emotions swirling,
- 29:09having made made that call.
- 29:11In the end,
- 29:13they they do reach back out. We do
- 29:14get get the brother back. But the point
- 29:16of that story is,
- 29:18is there unless you get a battle rhythm?
- 29:20Unless you look at this long term, it's
- 29:22not gonna end well for anybody, and this
- 29:24doesn't have to be up this be everyday
- 29:26business.
- 29:27Yes, you wanna be able to expand the
- 29:29window of tolerance.
- 29:31You know where you can be as
- 29:33calm as grounded as balanced
- 29:36centered as grounded as possible in the eye
- 29:39of the storm around you, make those decisions
- 29:43embrace the challenges
- 29:45and the objections and and the obstacles in
- 29:47your way.
- 29:48But know that if you go too far
- 29:50outside of that you need to bring it
- 29:52back, you need that time
- 29:54within which to
- 29:56recharge, rejuvenate,
- 29:58catch your breath and and take stock of
- 30:00where where you're at.
- 30:02What a powerful example that is thank you
- 30:03for sharing it Scott.
- 30:06Your book also gets into
- 30:08some of the misconceptions in your mind between
- 30:11the the normal right brain, let brain characteristics,
- 30:15you you actually talk about, they're being left
- 30:17brain characteristics in the right brain and vice
- 30:19versa as well. Can you talk a bit
- 30:21about some of your your analysis of that,
- 30:23and it's it's
- 30:24pertinent to our conversation here.
- 30:27Yeah. Was was fascinated when I discovered it,
- 30:29and hey for 10:15 years also a bit
- 30:32more... I was
- 30:34I had a practical
- 30:35understanding of this without knowing the neuroscience all
- 30:38the or the sides behind it. And it's
- 30:40only 1 I
- 30:42really kinda stepped away from
- 30:44doing the negotiations and my interest in neuroscience
- 30:48really developed. And. I came cross. Again, J
- 30:50bulk Taylor, as you mentioned.
- 30:53Who talks about these,
- 30:56basically, the brain is divided to 4 parts.
- 30:59You know, she had a stroke.
- 31:02And she realized that actually, it's not as
- 31:05as simple as left brain, right brain one's
- 31:08rational, one's emotional.
- 31:10You know, both sides of the brain have
- 31:13both elements.
- 31:15And the point that she was making and
- 31:17I found fascinating was
- 31:19you can almost choose
- 31:21your archetype. You can choose what part of
- 31:24your brain is in charge in that moment.
- 31:26For example,
- 31:28you know, you could read something called social
- 31:30media,
- 31:31or there could be something happening in the
- 31:33workplace and you'll go, okay. Well,
- 31:36Am I am I being driven by emotions
- 31:38to? Which part of my
- 31:40brain is really calling the shots here. Do
- 31:42I need to bring some more rational
- 31:46attention to this. And it and her in
- 31:48a book,
- 31:50whole brain living, she actually names these 4
- 31:52parts of her brain. Now I'm not saying
- 31:56everybody's gonna do that. I mean, the the
- 31:57the principles behind this are.
- 31:59If you can
- 32:01just spend the time to
- 32:03again get curious
- 32:05as to
- 32:07what are your triggers really? How do you...
- 32:09What are what are the patterns, What are
- 32:11the themes and patterns that when x happens,
- 32:15how does that show up for you? Is
- 32:17there always a
- 32:19tension in the shoulders, for example, or
- 32:23a churning in the stomach.
- 32:25It'll show in your body somewhere usually.
- 32:28And the more awareness is self awareness she
- 32:30can bring.
- 32:32Means you go, okay. I notice every time,
- 32:34I have a phone call or Zoom meeting,
- 32:37whatever it is, with this particular client.
- 32:40I just feel the same
- 32:42thing of frustration, my eager brain kicks in,
- 32:46I'm already looking There's almost like a conflict
- 32:49underneath the surface here
- 32:50and get curious of what, how interesting.
- 32:53Alright. Well, what does that mean? Okay. Well,
- 32:55how do I need to approach this
- 32:58conversation this meeting that's called
- 33:01differently.
- 33:02And that's essentially what what the principles are
- 33:05about what she was mentioning, in know a
- 33:07book. And I just found that fascinating about,
- 33:09we can almost bring a different part of
- 33:11our personality
- 33:13to that situation depending on the context and
- 33:15what's required.
- 33:17I I wanna pivot towards cyber ex another
- 33:20area in which you are expert, Scott.
- 33:22And talk a bit about how some of
- 33:24these ideas apply to that realm. And maybe
- 33:26you can talk a bit about the evolution
- 33:27of cyber
- 33:29your experience as well. Yeah. What what what
- 33:32are some of the nuances associated with that
- 33:34perhaps a a little bit different from some
- 33:36of the, you know, kidnapping situations, and other
- 33:38negotiations we described?
- 33:39I I know the
- 33:42cyber s world although also need the response
- 33:44to it. There there's it's it's divided. Some
- 33:48people believe
- 33:49yes,
- 33:50you need to enter into negotiation with the
- 33:53threat actor
- 33:55And there's other of people who firmly of
- 33:56the belief that,
- 33:58no, you don't. That's the last you never
- 34:00ever
- 34:01engage with any of the these
- 34:03trade actors at at all. Particularly,
- 34:06I mean, the classic 1 study my experience
- 34:08would be, you know, a ransom wear attack,
- 34:11for example. It's it's far gray.
- 34:14Then either, yes or no in terms of
- 34:16engaging with a threat actor. The end of
- 34:18day, you got a human being on the
- 34:20other end of the
- 34:21email or whatever means a communication you're using.
- 34:24And
- 34:26you still need to engage with them potential
- 34:28or have a decision within your crisis management
- 34:31team as to
- 34:32are we willing
- 34:35unable to enter into a conversation with the
- 34:38ex list? But that depends on what the
- 34:41situation you're facing because I remember,
- 34:44seen back a couple of years now, people
- 34:46businesses are certainly becoming far more
- 34:49aware of this.
- 34:51Somebody would have a
- 34:52a denial service attack or ransom attack. And
- 34:57I'd get on the phone
- 34:59with them. And I'd say, well, okay. How
- 35:01much is the...
- 35:03How much is the demand for? Oh, we
- 35:05we don't know.
- 35:06Okay.
- 35:07And how much it is costing you in
- 35:10lost revenue a day and an opportunity costs
- 35:12and everything else.
- 35:13Oh,
- 35:15about 12000000 dollars.
- 35:17Okay. And how long is it gonna be
- 35:19before you could
- 35:21potentially get backup and running.
- 35:24Oh, I don't know it's gonna be probably
- 35:25least another the week or so. Okay. And
- 35:27how the backups well,
- 35:29the backups we're not quite sure how successful
- 35:31the backups have been from the servers.
- 35:34Okay.
- 35:35And in quite a few cases,
- 35:37the demand will be in the early days
- 35:39would be for maybe 4 or 5000 euros
- 35:41or dollars. 1 of the considerations has to
- 35:44be there of,
- 35:45well,
- 35:47even though there's no guarantees.
- 35:49It may be worth considering paying the 4
- 35:515000 euros, the alicia you get the the
- 35:54keys back that you can start to
- 35:56decrypt,
- 35:58your your data again, and that might help.
- 36:00Again, there's no guarantees.
- 36:02Particularly it's costing you of quote million dollars
- 36:04a day. It's having that conversation. It depends
- 36:06also in my experience of the risk appetite
- 36:08of the company. What does its really mean?
- 36:10If it's a law firm,
- 36:12and we've had a few cases of that.
- 36:14Where
- 36:15confidential client sensitive
- 36:17information
- 36:18had been stolen
- 36:20or medical data.
- 36:22Now that that that's a different ballgame than
- 36:24if it's, you know, you're making widgets in
- 36:26a factory somewhere, Not discounting that. But obviously,
- 36:29hey, And has different implications. And again, when
- 36:32we do negotiate when we do into into
- 36:34the conversation with the ex.
- 36:37Again, it's to buy time.
- 36:39What we wanna do is wanna buy time,
- 36:41we wanna slow everything down,
- 36:43so the company so the organization can
- 36:46look at.
- 36:48Okay. Can we lay terms, can we sweep
- 36:51the system and plug the gap and make
- 36:53sure there's there's nothing left in there? That's
- 36:55gonna he that's gonna harm us as well
- 36:58as preventing anything else from happening a gate,
- 37:00and we can resume businesses as as usual.
- 37:04And I think the other factor
- 37:06miss Cyber distortion compared to kidnapping
- 37:09negotiations
- 37:10is
- 37:11reputation matters
- 37:13perhaps
- 37:14more in a cyber ex
- 37:17than the kidnapping.
- 37:19I think the General public shareholders
- 37:22customers
- 37:23would accept their company being hacked.
- 37:26But how they deal with it, they don't
- 37:29have long
- 37:30to prove to demonstrate their credibility and capability
- 37:33to resolve it.
- 37:35And I think if you mess up
- 37:38a cyber ex
- 37:40then your credibility, your reputation is more likely
- 37:44to be impact and say cannot
- 37:47negotiation goes slightly wrong because people don't necessarily
- 37:49expect no, somebody gets working gets kidnapped,
- 37:53and they and they don't come back.
- 37:55Accurate in a in a bizarre way, that's
- 37:57almost...
- 37:58Okay. Well, it's just 1 of those things
- 38:00because it's so highly dangerous. You know, a
- 38:02company messes a per poseidon
- 38:04negotiation,
- 38:05then actually, they have less
- 38:08room to
- 38:10to come
- 38:11lead
- 38:12some kind of innocence there.
- 38:15Given how stressful these negotiations are certainly certainly
- 38:19for you as well I would imagine.
- 38:20What what sorts of practices do you follow
- 38:22in order to
- 38:24of try to relieve the the stress or
- 38:26what do you recommend to others, to do
- 38:28the same. You you mentioned it is important
- 38:30to get rest and and not be... Happens
- 38:32to be all consuming
- 38:34that that to use time in some ways
- 38:36to to renew oneself even in in in
- 38:39what might seem like a constant storm.
- 38:42Talk about a bit about some of the
- 38:43this that you use that that have been
- 38:45effective for you to relieve stress.
- 38:471 of the
- 38:48tools or techniques that
- 38:51I've used over the years and again. I
- 38:52learned the hardware.
- 38:54I've went things missing work out.
- 38:56It's a 3 step process
- 38:59that I used regularly in my personal life
- 39:01as well as professionally. And I call it
- 39:03the immediate action drill, the I a drill.
- 39:07To 3 step process that can be used
- 39:09proactively so say you're about to go and
- 39:11give a big key
- 39:13or you're gonna give a presentation to the
- 39:14board or you're looking for pitching for some
- 39:16work or whatever it is. So you can
- 39:17do it proactively,
- 39:19or in the heat the moment,
- 39:22a colleague,
- 39:23or or some you're read that in the
- 39:25media just happen or or and you've noticed
- 39:27it and it really triggers you. It really
- 39:29kind of winds you up. So you can
- 39:31do it reactive as well. And the 3
- 39:33step process is this.
- 39:35Step 1,
- 39:36it's interrupt the pattern.
- 39:38Just like my colleague in the very first
- 39:40case I was involved in. He interrupted my
- 39:43pattern by putting his hand on my shoulder.
- 39:46And for me now, it could be something
- 39:48as simple as
- 39:50taking a couple of breaths or if I'm
- 39:52sat down or stand up, maybe go outside
- 39:55is whatever works for you, but it's it's
- 39:57preventing you from
- 39:59go down that rabbit warren
- 40:01of blaming naming and shaming and they're going
- 40:03on the loop inside your head about
- 40:06how dare
- 40:07Peter say this or do this. And I
- 40:09can't believe they've not done that and
- 40:12it doesn't serve anybody
- 40:14really long term. However, justified you may feel
- 40:17that you are. We could come on say
- 40:18a second. So the first thing is interrupt
- 40:20the pattern. It could be you doing some
- 40:22jumping jacks in the corner.
- 40:24Whatever it is
- 40:25to to shift your state.
- 40:28The second step
- 40:30is to ride the wave
- 40:33So any surfers listening or any skier
- 40:36where
- 40:38for about 90 seconds, 2 minutes.
- 40:40From that stimulus.
- 40:42You've got the cortisol all, You've got the
- 40:44adrenaline pumping around your body, and that's the
- 40:46vital flight. Freeze kicking in. You can't really
- 40:49do much about that.
- 40:51But that month, those 90 seconds, 2 minutes
- 40:54are usually where
- 40:56unless it's just me, obviously, by doubt it
- 40:58is, where you've settled or done something thinking
- 41:00you use later regret. Usually,
- 41:03It's in those first couple of minutes of
- 41:05something happening.
- 41:06What I've learned to do is
- 41:08be the feeling
- 41:10but drop the story.
- 41:12It doesn't matter why it's happening in that
- 41:14moment.
- 41:16I just need to feel the emotion what
- 41:18I'm feeling not judging and not push it
- 41:20away
- 41:22not kind of wish it was different.
- 41:24I just need to feel it. And I
- 41:25after about 90 seconds, 2 minutes,
- 41:28allow it to subside allow it to dissipate
- 41:31and then I can move on to step
- 41:323
- 41:34because my nervous system is been more regulated
- 41:36and balanced,
- 41:38I can ask better questions.
- 41:41So I'll interrupt the pattern.
- 41:43I'll ride the wave and I ask better
- 41:45questions. And those questions can be
- 41:48Well they need to be empowering ones, but
- 41:50it can be something like,
- 41:52okay. What was all that about? What what
- 41:54what does this mean now? Where
- 41:56where I am right now. What's the opportunity?
- 41:58What am I missing?
- 41:59What Our Need to find out perhaps? What's
- 42:02another way I'm looking at this? What's the
- 42:03opportunity?
- 42:05But I wouldn't never be able to ask
- 42:07those questions genuinely
- 42:09if I'm stuck in my story
- 42:12on a dis disappearing mindset
- 42:14at step 2.
- 42:15So interrupt the pattern,
- 42:18feel the feeling dropped the story by riding
- 42:20the wave for 90 seconds, 2 minutes.
- 42:22And then then only when we get into
- 42:24a better mindset,
- 42:26can we ask those better questions?
- 42:28And I guarantee it literally every time
- 42:32it brings you the clarity,
- 42:35and even the certainty
- 42:36that I would never get, the people would
- 42:38never get it. If they hadn't to had
- 42:40a... I guess the discipline to to follow
- 42:42those 3 steps. But, again, as I mentioned
- 42:44several times now, it's like a muscle.
- 42:46You know, it's really hard
- 42:48the first few 10:50, 20, 50, hundred times
- 42:51you do it, but the more you do
- 42:52it, these becomes.
- 42:55Scott Walker. Thank you so much for for
- 42:56joining me today. I would have a fascinating
- 42:58conversation emblem Of the remarkable career you've you've
- 43:01had so far and the the great work
- 43:03that you're doing on the behalf of individuals
- 43:05families,
- 43:06corporations.
- 43:07Thank you for sharing our insights with me
- 43:08today.
- 43:09You're welcome. Thank you.