Latest / Inflation and Your Money with Fexingo: Protecting Purchasing Power and Beating Inflation / How Inflation Is Quietly Eating Your Life Insurance Premium
Transcript
- Lucas: Luna, I got my annual life insurance statement last week — 20-year level term policy, I'm about eight years in — and my premium went up twelve percent. Not a typo. Luna: Wait, level term. The premium is supposed to stay flat for the whole term. How can they raise it? Lucas: That's what I thought. But read the fine print: 'level' means the rate per thousand dollars of coverage doesn't change — unless the insurer files for a classwide rate increase on an entire block of policies. And that's exactly what happened. Several major carriers have done it in the past eighteen months. Luna: So it's not just you. This is an industry-wide thing tied to inflation. Lucas: Exactly. And it's the kind of quiet erosion we talk about on this show — the stuff that doesn't make headlines but hits your budget. If our money conversations have helped you think about a decision differently, one way to keep this show ad-free and independent is to support it at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No pressure, just a mention. Back to the numbers — the policy I'm talking about is from a mutual company, aa rated, and they still raised rates. Luna: Yeah, that's worth unpacking. Why would a rock-solid insurer need to hike term life premiums right now? Lucas: Two main reasons. First, the money they hold in reserves — the pot they pay claims from — is heavily invested in bonds. And bond yields have been elevated, sure, but insurers are sitting on older, lower-yielding bonds from years ago. They can't just swap everything overnight. So their investment income hasn't kept pace with inflation. Luna: Right. And the second reason has to be claims costs. Everything medical is more expensive. Lucas: Bingo. Mortality costs — what insurers pay out when someone dies — are rising because hospital and funeral expenses have gone up. The CDC just reported that the average cost of a funeral hit ten thousand dollars last year, up eight percent from 2024. Insurers factor that into their pricing models. Luna: So it's a double squeeze: lower real returns on their investments and higher payouts per claim. Lucas: Exactly. And the data bears this out. Look at the core PCE price index, which is the Fed's preferred inflation gauge. It was 130.1 in May, up from 129.67 in April. Still creeping. The Fed's holding the effective federal funds rate at 3.63 percent, so no relief on the interest-rate front for insurers who are borrowing to manage cash flow. Luna: And the ten-year breakeven inflation rate is at 2.25 percent — markets expect inflation to stay above the Fed's 2 percent target for a while. Lucas: That means insurers expect to keep paying more for claims and earning less in real terms on their bond portfolios. So they're repricing policies for new customers and, increasingly, for existing blocks of policies where they have the contractual right to do so. Luna: Let's talk about who gets hit hardest. Young families buying term life for the first time? Lucas: They're the most exposed, because they're entering the market at peak premiums. A thirty-five-year-old healthy nonsmoker might pay about forty dollars a month for a five-hundred-thousand-dollar, twenty-year term policy today. That same policy probably cost thirty-two dollars three years ago. That's a twenty-five percent increase. Luna: And whole life is even more sensitive because it's a longer-duration liability for the insurer. Lucas: Right. Whole life policies have a cash-value component that the insurer guarantees a minimum return on. If inflation eats into that return, the insurer has to charge a higher premium upfront to compensate. I've seen whole life quotes up fifteen to twenty percent over the last two years. Luna: So what's the practical move for someone who needs coverage and is feeling the pinch? Lucas: First, don't delay. Premiums are only going one direction while inflation stays sticky. If you're healthy now, lock in a rate. Second, compare quotes every two or three years — your health might have improved, or a new competitor might have entered your state with lower rates. The market is still competitive. Luna: And what about people who already have a policy — should they switch? Lucas: It depends. If you have a guaranteed level-premium term policy — meaning the contract explicitly says the premium can't change — hold it. Don't cancel it. But check if your policy is 'renewable term' or 'adjustable premium.' Those are the ones where the insurer can hike rates on the whole pool. In that case, it might be worth shopping for a new level-term policy now, while you're still insurable. Luna: One more thing — group life insurance through an employer. Is that affected? Lucas: Indirectly. Group term life is usually priced annually based on the group's claims experience. If the whole pool is seeing higher mortality costs, the employer's premium goes up, and they may pass some of that to employees. I've seen several large companies increase the employee-paid portion of basic life coverage by five to ten percent this year. Luna: So it's everywhere. The same inflation that's hitting your grocery bill is quietly hitting your life insurance premium. Lucas: And because life insurance is a long-term contract, the effects compound. A twelve percent increase this year, followed by another eight percent next year — over a twenty-year term, that's a significant total cost. Luna: Let's put a number on it. For a forty-year-old who buys a five-hundred-thousand-dollar, twenty-year term policy today at, say, fifty dollars a month, versus three years ago at thirty-eight dollars a month — over the full term that's almost three thousand dollars more. Lucas: Exactly. And that's assuming rates don't go up again. So the takeaway is: if you need life insurance, buy it sooner rather than later. If you have a policy, understand what kind it is and whether your premium can change. And if you're renewing, shop around. Luna: It's one of those inflation blind spots that doesn't show up in the CPI but hits your household budget just as hard. Lucas: Well, the CPI actually does include life insurance in the 'personal care and insurance' category, but it's a small weighting — less than half a percent of the overall index. So even a big jump in life insurance premiums barely moves the headline number. That's why it's a quiet eroder. Luna: Good reminder to check your own statements. I know I will after this conversation. Lucas: Same here. Maybe I'll find a better rate and switch.