Latest / Friendship IRL: Real Talk About Friendship, Community, and What It Actually Takes / The Hidden Costs of Being the “Strong Friend”
Transcript
- 0:02Podcast Intro/Outro: All right, gang. Here's to nights that turn into mornings and friends that turn into family. Cheers. Hello, hello, and welcome to the Friendship IRL podcast. I'm your host, Alex Alexander. Each week we talk about what is working(and what is not) in our friendships, community and connections. Have you ever wished you could sit down and have a conversation about what is really going on in your friendships? Well, you found your people. Join us as we dive into real life stories and explore new ways to approach these connections. Together, we're reimagining the rules of friendship
- 0:58Alex Alexander: I remember the exact moment that I felt so proud, over the top, proud of a trait of mine that I thought was my greatest strength. I was driving home from a client meeting. This is back in my wedding planning days. I don't remember exactly what year this is, but I would guess somewhere between 2016 to 2018 - was this condo we owned back in the day - I remember that I had been driving home and I've been listening to some podcasts. I don't know what the podcast was, but I think the podcast, or the audio book was all about tapping into your greatest strength, right, leaning into whatever comes naturally to you. I remember parking my car in our carport and getting out, and I'm reflecting, and I'm like, gosh, what is my greatest strength?
- 1:55Alex Alexander: What am I the best at? What should I do more of? I'm walking towards the elevator, and it hit me. I thought, I am the best, like the absolute best, at dropping everything and helping my friends and my family and my people when they're in crisis. I am the best. I was so proud in that moment that it turns out that strength, the thing I was so proud of, was actually costing me way more than I realized. You see, if I look back, I'm an eldest daughter. I come from a very complex, traumatic childhood. I had to be a caregiver at a very young age.
- 2:37Alex Alexander: I had to deal with lot of unpredictable circumstances. So I have always been the type of person who drops everything to deal with a crisis, hence why I am, and always have been very, very, very good at doing this.
- 2:55Alex Alexander: And I put myself in situations like if I look back in I think so much of this is going to make sense to a lot of you, but if I look back at, let's say, elementary school, I was always in student body, like ASB. I was ASB president, I think in fifth grade, I want to say maybe also in fourth grade, or maybe I was just as Vice President, I don't remember, but I was always in leadership. Middle School was a weird time, because that's my mom passed away, and then in high school again, I was always in student body. I was class president, I think every year, most years, I think every year.
- 3:34Alex Alexander: And I was the varsity coxswain on the men's crew team, right? I always put myself in leadership positions where positions were at the end of the day, the buck stopped with me. I had to find the solution. So in a lot of my friendships, even from a very young age, I was always the friend or the person that everyone would go to in crisis.
- 4:00Alex Alexander: I just really thought that was a strength. Now, in college, I still had this persona like the will drop everything. I'll fix everything in a crisis, the strong friend, right? I still had that strong friend complex, but it was getting harder because the problems were getting more complex. I was also just trying to balance, like learning how to adult passing my classes, which, by the way, did not go so well freshman year, I failed a lot of classes Freshman year, trying to be the strong person, holding it all together, like some ball had to drop. And for me, that was my GPA at the beginning of freshman year, after being like Top Student Honor Roll, right? It was "too much." I couldn't handle it all, but I had really, really built myself as this persona for myself, but also for the people around me. It really had become a part of my identity, at least as far as I saw it, right, I started having this belief that this was a strength of mine, right? This is why people came to me. I couldn't quite separate the fact that I was a leader in certain situations, but I didn't always need to be the person that cleaned up the mess everywhere, like my value was being the strong friend, the one that would drop everything, the one that would do anything. I think there's also some allure to finding yourself in this position, because you feel needed, you feel valuable, you feel irreplaceable, right? I never gave anybody else a chance to solve the complex problems. I always had to get in there first and do it. So what would they do without me? They couldn't replace me. And I would say that, you know, it wasn't like I was coming in there and doing the small, sustainable actions that I talk about now and I do now, we'll get there. But a lot of times they were big grand gestures, right? I was blowing up my life. I was ignoring everything that I actually needed to do for myself, or anything. I promised any habits I had, I would ignore all of those to be the strong friend and solve the problem. And sometimes that looked like pretty grand gestures, and then I would get praise for that. I was really, really caught in a situation here, wasn't I? Now this episode is all about the hidden costs of being the strong friend, so I want to share some of those costs with you, and for the rest of the episode, I want to talk about realizing, basically, I couldn't be the strong friend anymore, how I've gotten myself out of it, and where I am now. Because, as you've been listening to me talk about my past as the strong friend, I would imagine that there are a lot of you who identify with this, like I know I'm not the only one, so some of these hidden costs might sound familiar to you, and I definitely don't think these are all the hidden costs. I'm sure that there are more, and I'm sure that there are costs that maybe I haven't experienced, but you or a friend or someone you know has experienced, but I'm gonna share some of mine today.
- 7:24Alex Alexander: So the first hidden cost I feel like I had of being the strong friend was that I was constantly betraying myself. This was actually one of the biggest Wake Up Calls as I realized I was betraying myself. Because when you're the strong friend who is just always the one to drop everything for somebody, the crisis, they just keep coming in, one after another after another, and it's really hard to develop any state of stability or normalcy. So what I mean when I say I was betraying myself is that, let's say I had a habit of sleeping better, and then someone would have a crisis, and I would stay up with them. I would show up at the hospital or pick them up from jail. That happened one time, I would just completely ignore whatever promise I had made to myself about sleep, feeding myself when you're in crisis after crisis, cooking myself nutritious meals went out the window, and I would just survive on coffee and Starbucks sandwiches for extended periods of time. Career goals, what were those? I had them. They were big, but when it came to actually making things happen, I felt like I was always just trying to shove weeks of work into a few days, a few hours, right? Because by the time I came down from whatever crisis or situation where I was the strong friend, then I was still trying to get back to some sense of normalcy. Couldn't actually do that. Would try and cram in all the work that I felt like I had missed. And then here I was with another crisis. And if it wasn't a crisis, it was still just constantly being pulled in one direction or another. Mind you, I'm also having my own life situations I have to deal with, and those were all mixed in here, too. And because I was the strong friend, I definitely couldn't depend on anyone else. Couldn't ask anyone for help with that. I had to do it all on my own. The second hidden cost was denying the other people in my life the chance to show up. And this was a big one, because not only, like this is kind of a two parter, like the first one, is that. I was denying my friends the chance to show up for me, because I believed right that part of my value to them as a friend was not only that I could show up for them and handle any crisis, but also that I could show up for myself, like I could solve all my things on my own, and I have a lot of vivid memories, like, I think my friends knew I have memories of them kind of calling me out, you know, saying, like, Hey, you won't let anybody help you.
- 10:19Alex Alexander: Like, I want to help you, and I really appreciate them, but I used to just shut them down and be like, no, no. Like, thank you so much for saying that. But I don't need help, right? I was denying them the chance to show up for me. But the second part of this is I was denying them the chance to show up for each other, because I always jumped in. I was always the midnight phone call or the person that had to be there for the crisis or would get them out of it, right, that initial person and I had made myself indispensable. I always said yes. I always dropped everything. They never had a doubt that if they called me I would say no. I denied them the opportunity to show up for each other, right? I didn't need to be the indispensable one or the star of the show. I didn't.
- 11:11Alex Alexander: I didn't need to be the only person on their web. It's kind of what I did back in the day, in my young 20s, I wanted them all to have each other. Don't get me wrong, I wasn't trying to deny them each other's friendships. In fact, I really encouraged them, but I really felt like this was kind of my role, and I would do anything to keep it. But it just meant that, like, what if I wasn't available? They never really had to call each other, and I'm sure they did, and I maybe just didn't know about it, but I really thought that this was my role, and it denied the chance to strengthen all the connections in the web. Now, the third hidden cost was that I had created unsustainable patterns, the ways in which I was showing up were so reactionary, so grand, so over the top, that I was not living the show up in small ways that I talk about now. I was just going from one big grand gesture to another.
- 12:16Alex Alexander: Like, if you were having a new baby added to your family, I would go and fill your entire freezer. I would cook like 20 recipes, and that would take a days out of my life, right? Like that's a big, grand gesture. I would drop everything in the middle of the night. If you had a medical situation or whatever, I would demand that you moved in with me, slash us, because Michael and I lived together at the time. I would do all the things, all of them, there's never a place where I would say no. Now that's not to say that certain things were that disruptive to my life. Like, for example, when I talk about I've already covered on the podcast, like, I love having people stay with us. That one, to me, doesn't feel like that grand of a gesture. I get that it might be to a lot of people, but we have the space we have. Like, we love to do it, but doing that and all the other things I did, like, if you want to do a grand gesture that just feels easy and natural to you, then do it. But I was doing things that I knew, that I knew were way more than I really had the capabilities to do like I knew they were messing up all my promises to myself, all my habits, and I would do them anyways. And that really created an unsustainable pattern where every single time something was happening, I felt like I had to completely upend my life to help my friend. Now the next hidden cost was that I was building resentment. This didn't happen at first, but the longer I allowed myself into this pattern, the longer I told myself that right, I was the strong friend. I was the best at dropping everything, the more I did these big, grand, unsustainable gestures, I started to feel like I had to stay at that level. So if I was going to cook 20 recipes and freeze them all individually for somebody, I had to do that for everyone. And then, as we all know, as you grow, you have more people that have simultaneous crises going on. So at that point, it's like, well, am I just is that all I do now, right? Three days a week, I have no time for anything else, and so I really started to build up this resentment, because I felt like I had to maintain the patterns and the levels that I had created for myself and as I went through this, especially my young 20s, it just kind of created this cycle of these big, grand gestures that felt fulfilling, because like, Wow, I can't believe you did that for your friends. Are you? You're so nice, or, I mean, people praise you for this, let me tell you.
- 16:35Alex Alexander: And on the back end, so much burnout, over and over and over again. And as the frustrations built, I really found myself at this turning point where I started to reflect on what was happening here, like what was going on? Were my friends asking too much? Was I part of the problem? I don't think that there was one exact moment, but what I did start to realize over time, especially in, I think late 2018 is that I had taken this thing that I felt like I was the best at, and I had let it infiltrate all the parts of my life. It had infiltrated my friendships. I've talked about that, but it also had infiltrated my job. It's a huge reason I stopped wedding planning is that I realized that the way I was wedding planning, especially at like these high stakes events I was doing, required me to constantly betray myself and be the strong friend, right, be the best planner, do the impossible, make grand things happen. So I'd let it infiltrate my work life. In some ways, I had let it infiltrate my relationship with Michael, like I had really just taken on that I could do all these things, and I got myself in quite a pickle, because I really had absorbed a lot of the work of our life as I started to notice that this had infiltrated all these different areas of my life. It became very clear that although sometimes I maybe would resent my friends or be frustrated that they would ask me to do something that they had seen me do a million times for them or for other people, that I could only be so mad at them, if at all, because really, I had created this pattern, and in fact, I had begged for this pattern. I had pushed for this pattern. Like, if I look back, there are a number of times where a friend would tell me, I don't know that they had to have surgery. It's a good one. They had to have surgery. And I would be like, Okay, well, what day is the surgery? I'll come. Do you have someone to drive you? You don't? Okay, well, I will come wait in the waiting room, and I will drive you home, and while you sleep, I will cook all these meals. And when they'd say no, no, that's too much, I'd be like, No, but I will do that. I want to do that. I need to do that like I almost demanded and pushed my way into this situation. And then because of that, it just kept repeating, like I had created the pattern.
- 19:29Alex Alexander: And the more I felt it in my life, I just noticed the pattern again and again and again and again. I saw that this role of being the strong friend who dropped everything, this thing that I thought was my greatest superpower in so many areas of my life, not only was it harming me, but it really wasn't serving anyone else, at least not at the level I was doing it at, like there's a difference between genuinely wanting to help and feel like you have capacity to help and continuing to take care of yourself. And what I was doing was kind of identifying as the strong friend the crisis, friend the drop anything, friend and putting that identity above all else, including my health, my other relationships, my people's relationships with each other, which I really wanted to encourage, but actively was not encouraging them through my actions in this way. Now if you're wondering, okay, so you you got here, you realize that you are a huge part of the problem. How have you made shifts to change this? Then I'm here to give you some of my examples, some of my process, which was just me trying to change these patterns, really, in that 2018 time period. So it's now 2025 so we are, and I don't remember like when in 2018 but we'll just say in those five-ish years....Years! It has been a slow unraveling process. It has been a bunch of shifts over time. The first piece was just recognizing the pattern. It was noticing what people were calling me for, what I was offering, the grand gesture would come out of my mouth and I would hear it. I didn't feel like I could backtrack it. Yet it was sometimes being in the middle of, let's say, cooking 20 meals, and then realizing, like, oh, wow, I've done it again. I am doing this again. Like, that's why I'm frustrated. I have done this again. So the first step was just awareness. I was probably six months to a year of that. The next piece was kind of calling it out in the moment. So as I started to build awareness for it, especially when there would be asks or I would offer.
- 21:57Alex Alexander: So let's say somebody, you know, if we use the surgery example, somebody mentions they have surgery, and I would notice myself start to push as I was doing it. I would actually stop myself and say, like, Actually, hold on. Can I circle back with you about this in the moment, I would actually just try and acknowledge, out loud, to the other person, almost, that this pattern was happening, right? I would say something like, Oh, wow. That was a really big task I offered to take on. And now that I'm saying it out loud, I actually don't know if I'm gonna have capacity for that. So can I think about how to make that more manageable? Because I do want to show up for you. So that was me managing myself. Now I think where a lot of people get caught up, a lot of the stories I hear right is you want to make these shifts, you set a bunch of boundaries, and your friends have an adjustment, right?
- 23:00Alex Alexander: Because they're very used to this identity I had of being the strong friend, whether that's me opening up to them or them asking for my help, or me pushing my help on them, to be all honest. And I want to remind you that this will also probably a small shift, like people will probably still come to you for things, and it's not going to feel right because you're trying to make this transition. So I think what I did here. The biggest thing I did was this idea of bridge boundaries, not wall boundaries. So what I mean by that is, if somebody asked me, like, Hey, can you pick me up from surgery? Can you stay the night? And actually, can you, like, stop by a couple times that week? You're like, that's a lot. But guys, I really did stuff like that. If somebody asked me that, instead of just saying no, which is a wall like, no, no, no, no, no, which I think is what a lot of people do often when you're trying to make these transitions, I would offer what I call bridge boundaries.
- 24:08Alex Alexander: So I'd be like, hey, that's really not just something I'm capable of doing this week, but I can what would be a good bridge here, like something more manageable. Let's see. I can drive you to the appointment and wait and bring you home. I can stay with you for an hour or two, and I can definitely call you and check in a couple times that week. And if you need support, we can figure out how to find you that. And that feels more accessible to me, right?
- 24:37Alex Alexander: I'm not promising that I will drop everything all the time. So I really did want to help. I just scaled back. But it took time. It was wired in me. It was my gut reaction, especially, I think, like, this is a huge therapy piece when it's kind of that, like, fight or flight response, right? You want to help your people. I talked about this last week, and so I would just go into overdrive, like, what actions do I take? What do I do? I want to help you. And it took a little while for me to rework that. Now, something I want to just bring up here, something I'm still working on is being okay with this kind of like imperfect journey, making little bits of progress, I definitely fall back into the pattern every once in a while, even five years down the road, I also have a big struggle with places where I know that, like In the past, I showed up in a certain way, right? I did those big, grand gestures, and in my brain, I'm like, Well, you did that for Friend A, and now friend B is asking you, and they're in the same situation, and I feel guilty that I'm not showing up in the same ways. So that's been a really big struggle. Should I be honest? I have to remind myself that, in the end, it's not that I'm a bad friend. I'm not a lesser friend.
- 26:04Alex Alexander: I'm just trying to build more sustainable patterns, and that can look like supporting my friends in small ways over a long period of time, rather than diving in in the moment of crisis and absorbing all of it.
- 26:16Alex Alexander: But sometimes I have to tell myself that on repeat, because I feel really bad. That's been quite the process as I make this shift. Now there have definitely been, I mean, I want to acknowledge like there have been friendships, connections, relationships, big relationships in my life that have fallen away or like this transition, they couldn't make it work, no matter how much I communicated, no matter how many bridge boundaries I set, no matter how much I told them I was trying to do this and it wasn't sustainable for me, and I talked about the costs. There have definitely been relationships lost. That's just what it is.
- 27:01Alex Alexander: And so I don't want to make it sound like every single person in my life adjusted to this well, because some people didn't, some people it was easy, some people it was not bad, not hard, but like, a process, right? It was me either falling back into this pattern with them, or them making requests from me, and then us having to, like, navigate the conversation when I would say no or I'd offer a bridge boundary. And I definitely don't want it to sound like it's done. Like, I guess that's how I want to close out this episode is. I want to tell you that this is by no means a perfect transition.
- 27:42Alex Alexander: Like, I am still working on this. I probably still will be working on this. But if you are listening to this episode and you are the strong friend, then I guess, by recording this episode, I hope that it's just permission to start making small shifts, that it doesn't have to be a bunch of hard boundaries and overnight changes, but it really can just be a bunch of little shifts and changes and Moments of Awareness, and that they do add up over time, because I would say that as much as I sometimes fall back into an old pattern or say yes when I should have said no or initially offer a little bit grander of a gesture, For the most part, I am now in a place where the ways that I show up feel way more sustainable, way more sustainable. And I talked about this, if you go back and listen to last week's episode about showing up, one of the biggest things I would suggest, if you are the strong friend, is listening to last week's episode, because one of the biggest things that has helped me is kind of breaking down, showing up in support into the four initial phases. Right, the initial, like, safety phase, immediate needs, basic needs, and then kind of that secondary, we're still in crisis phase, and then the third phase of kind of getting people more stable a little bit, and then the fourth phase of that longer term support as everything kind of reintegrates. And the reason I'm telling you to think about those phases is because if you are the strong friend, you are probably coming in hot in those initial two at least I did. You are jumping into action, you are ready to fight. You are ready to make things happen. And what I've found is there are definitely times where I still need to do that right. I need to, like, get somebody to safety. Something is wrong. But for the most part, I've actually shifted a lot of my support into more of the final two phases- the ongoing because it allows me to take myself out of that reactionary piece and create something way more sustainable that integrates into my life.
- 29:58Alex Alexander: And it's also a place where a lot of people don't get the support they need. So even though it may not be the initial like jump to action solve all the problems. Be the person who does the crisis thing. It still adds up. It's still valuable and important support. Now, if you're listening to this, and you are the strong friend, and there is a piece of this I did not cover, I would love to hear your experience. This is my experience of being the strong friend. It is by no means everybody's experience. And actually, I would really, really suggest, if you haven't already, one of my favorite episodes is Episode 85 - it's called shifting people pleasing habits with Deb Blum. And although it's not exactly about being the strong friend, it kind of is.
- 30:45Alex Alexander: She talks about how she's always the friend that's there for everybody else, right, that can listen to everyone else, that can be there for everyone else, but she never lets anybody else see her or know her or show up for her, which is, I think, just kind of another version of being the strong friend. So whatever your version is, I'd love to hear about it, since I'm kind of on this connection support train, done a little series here next week's episode is about asking for and receiving support. So be sure to tune in next week to hear about that.
- 31:26Podcast Intro/Outro: Thank you for listening to this episode of Friendship IRL. I am so honored to have these conversations with you. But don't let the chat die here. Send me a voice message. I created a special website just to chat with you. You can find it at alexalex.chat. You can also find me on Instagram. My handle, @itsalexalexander. Or go ahead and leave a review wherever you prefer to listen to podcasts. Now if you want to take this conversation a step further, send this episode to a friend. Tell them you found it interesting. And use what we just talked about as a conversation starter the next time you and your friend hang out. No need for a teary goodbye. I'll be back with a new episode next week.