Latest / Distillations | Science History Institute / Cigarettes in America, Part 1: The Rise
Transcript
- 0:01From the Science History Institute, I'm Alexis Petrick.
- 0:05Welcome to the new season of Distillations: American Vice.
- 0:10Over the next eight episodes, we're diving into stories about our appetite for risk,
- 0:16how science plays a role in it, and how it's shaped the American experience.
- 0:22First up, a story about the most American vice of all.
- 0:26It provides no nutrition.
- 0:28It quenches no thirst.
- 0:30It serves no purpose other than being an excuse to take a break from
- 0:34the grind and then get back to it.
- 0:37Relax.
- 0:39It's light up time.
- 0:43I'm talking about the cigarette.
- 0:46Shared a cart with a couple we met.
- 0:48Then took time out for a cigarette.
- 0:50Viceroy?
- 0:51That's right.
- 0:54Pleasure long.
- 0:54Pleasure true.
- 0:56Pleasure filter-free.
- 0:57Chesterfield.
- 0:59We can laugh at these old ads now because we've come a long way from being
- 1:03so happy-go-lucky about cigarettes.
- 1:06We know they're poison now.
- 1:08You can't smoke in restaurants or on airplanes or elevators.
- 1:12Americans just aren't lighting up like they used to.
- 1:16At least, that's what we thought.
- 1:19But then we started noticing something.
- 1:21Are cigarettes cool again?
- 1:23Sabrina Carpenter takes a drag in this music video.
- 1:27Jeremy Allen White's character smokes up a storm in The Bear, and
- 1:30Zendaya puffs on a cig in Euphoria.
- 1:33There's even an Instagram account called CIGfluencers.
- 1:38And then there was this Instagram post that made our jaws drop.
- 1:42We need to smoke again.
- 1:43If you're a young, you don't understand this, but in the 1990s, we smoked.
- 1:49We smoked all the time.
- 1:50We smoked cigarettes behind the school, in our cars, at coffee shops.
- 1:56This was our stimulation.
- 1:58And look, as someone who was a teenager in the '90s, I can confirm she's not wrong.
- 2:04But does she not remember why we stopped smoking?
- 2:09Oh, wait, she does.
- 2:11The death thing is a problem.
- 2:13I acknowledge it being an obstacle here to my plan, but, like, I mean, surely
- 2:19there's a way around that, right?
- 2:20Like, we can figure this out.
- 2:23We're smart.
- 2:24We're capable.
- 2:25How do we bring back a cigarette that doesn't kill us?
- 2:31Trying to wrap your head around that question?
- 2:34Same.
- 2:35So how did we get here?
- 2:38How did we go from cigarettes being a niche product when they debuted
- 2:41in the late 1800s to becoming the quintessential American product
- 2:46by the end of the 20th century?
- 2:49How did that happen despite the fact that cigarettes are poison?
- 2:53What was the thing that finally brought their rise crashing down?
- 2:58And why?
- 2:59Why are they getting popular again?
- 3:02This story is too big for one episode, so make sure to tune
- 3:07in next week for Cigarettes in America Part Two: The Reckoning.
- 3:13Chapter One: How Do You Sell a Poison?
- 3:18Before there were cigarettes, there was just a plant
- 3:21The aromatic annual called tobacco.
- 3:25Humans started using tobacco shortly after they arrived in the Americas.
- 3:30Archeologists have recovered seeds from an ancient hearth that are
- 3:33a little over 12,000 years old.
- 3:36And while we don't know exactly what those Paleolithic campers were
- 3:40doing, researchers believe that the plant could have been smoked
- 3:43or put behind the lip and sucked.
- 3:46But that wasn't the only early use.
- 3:49For centuries, indigenous Americans have used the plant for
- 3:52medicinal and spiritual purposes.
- 3:55And then when Europeans arrived to colonize the Americas, they quickly
- 4:00turned it into a lucrative cash crop.
- 4:03Tobacco's a crop that calls for care, from early spring when the
- 4:06seeds are sown to the time of harvesting the luscious leaves.
- 4:11People smoked the leaves in pipes or they rolled them into cigars and smoked those.
- 4:16And though it had many fans, tobacco also had critics from early on.
- 4:21In 1604, King James I described smoking tobacco as a custom loathsome to the
- 4:28eye, hateful to the nose, harmful to the brain, and dangerous to the lungs.
- 4:34Still, by 1670, half the men in England smoked it daily.
- 4:40Cigarettes, which literally just means little cigars, didn't come along
- 4:45until the middle of the 19th century.
- 4:47They started taking off after inventor James Bonsack patented his game-changing
- 4:53cigarette rolling machine in 1880.
- 4:56Production remained pretty small scale at first, but by the time we got further
- 5:00into the 20th century, things changed.
- 5:04People went from being able to produce a few thousand cigarettes in a day to being
- 5:09able to produce hundreds of thousands.
- 5:12This is Allan Brandt, a historian of science and the author of
- 5:15The Cigarette Century: The Rise, Fall, and Deadly Persistence of
- 5:19the Product That Defined America.
- 5:22And that led the leaders of the tobacco industry to say, "How
- 5:25are we gonna sell this many?
- 5:27How can we invent and expand demand?"
- 5:32Before cigarettes, smoking was mostly relegated to just one part
- 5:36of 19th century American society.
- 5:39It was very much a elite male practice and behavior.
- 5:45But when the mass production of cigarettes made tobacco cheaper and
- 5:49more accessible, suddenly working class boys started smoking too.
- 5:56Still, despite the growing popularity of smoking in the US, there continued
- 6:01to be pockets of strong opposition.
- 6:04In the late 1800s, the cigarette was loathed by the same people fighting
- 6:09for the prohibition of alcohol.
- 6:11To them, both vices trafficked in the same evils: wastefulness, indulgence, and the
- 6:18willful poisoning of oneself and others.
- 6:21Religious organizations made the case very strongly that smoking was
- 6:27a sign of bad character, and it was very bad for your health, and boys
- 6:33should really be restricted from it.
- 6:36And that's kind of the eve of the 20th century.
- 6:42Even though America had come a long way from its Puritanical roots and the pastime
- 6:48of frowning upon worldly pleasures, the concept of leisure was still taboo.
- 6:54The worst thing you can say about somebody, I think, in the
- 6:57late 19th century is that they were idle and pleasure-seeking.
- 7:03And here you had something with no purpose except for the enjoyment
- 7:10of individuals and groups.
- 7:12You'll find a man stops and takes great pleasure when and where he can.
- 7:20Chesterfield.
- 7:23Takes you away.
- 7:24Welcome to sunny California
- 7:26Oasis, fresh
- 7:32as a sunlit day.
- 7:32This struggle between cigarette lovers and cigarette haters continued
- 7:36through the first decade and a half of the 20th century, and there was
- 7:40real momentum behind banning or limiting the sale of cigarettes.
- 7:44By 1909, Kansas, Minnesota, South Dakota, and Washington had all passed
- 7:51some sort of prohibition measure.
- 7:53But everything changed in 1917 when the US entered World War I. It came
- 8:00at last, war.
- 8:02Overnight, the cry was for ships and men, a bridge of ships across the
- 8:07Atlantic and the men to sail them.
- 8:07Any craft that could float- When the
- 8:10risks and deficients of our society become greater, and we're living in a
- 8:16period of violence, division, uncertainty, that's a better environment for selling
- 8:25tobacco and encouraging people to use it.
- 8:28Suddenly, the risks of smoking paled in comparison to the
- 8:32risk of dying in a trench.
- 8:35There was this idea like there's so few pleasures, and smoking
- 8:39produces a short, immediate sense of pleasure and relaxation.
- 8:45And obviously with a time of great anxiety and violence-
- 8:49Suddenly it was a small comfort in an otherwise chaotic and scary world
- 8:55And so, for example, the Young Women's Christian Association, which had
- 9:01always worked very stringently to prohibit smoking, suddenly starts
- 9:07collecting cigarettes and sending them to the American troops in France.
- 9:12Buying cigarettes for troops became a patriotic act.
- 9:17The federal government even got in on the game, at one point claiming Bull
- 9:21Durham's entire output for the military.
- 9:24By this point, if you were still an anti-cigarette
- 9:27crusader, you just seemed petty.
- 9:30As one 1919 opinion piece put it, “As for the poor fellows lying mangled in
- 9:36shell holes with life slowly ebbing away from a body soon to become dreamless
- 9:42dust, who would be heartless enough to prohibit this last and only solace?”
- 9:50I've always felt that that kind of 180 shift from essentially smoking
- 9:55being banned and prohibited in so many places to smoking being
- 10:01seen as positive, cool, manly
- 10:10You don't see many wild stallions anymore.
- 10:14He's one of the last of a wild and very singular breed
- 10:23Come to where the flavor is.
- 10:25Come to Marlboro Country.
- 10:32Many American men came back from the First World War, you
- 10:37know, habitual addicted smokers.
- 10:41War made smoking ubiquitous among American boys and men, but it took a more
- 10:47coordinated effort to get women hooked.
- 10:51It had long been a taboo for women to smoke, but cigarette companies
- 10:56realized they were missing out on half of the American market, so
- 11:00they decided to change the culture.
- 11:03In 1929, Lucky Strike tapped a man named Edward Bernays to do just that.
- 11:09Bernays was an early pioneer in public relations.
- 11:12Some call him the father of the field.
- 11:16He was crafty.
- 11:18He also happened to be the nephew of Sigmund Freud, which might have had
- 11:23something to do with why he consulted a psychoanalyst about his project.
- 11:27I went to Dr. Brill and I said, "Can you tell me what cigarettes mean to women?"
- 11:35This is Bernays in a documentary called Showdown on Tobacco Road.
- 11:41He said, "Cigarettes to women are torches of freedom, and they titillate
- 11:47the erogenous zones of the lips."
- 11:51He also told Bernays that if he could find a way to connect cigarettes to
- 11:55the idea of challenging male power, then women would smoke because they,
- 12:01insert big sigh here, would have their own representation of an appendage.
- 12:07You, you get the idea.
- 12:09So I left and wondered what to do with that information
- 12:18Bernays hired a group of young women specifying that they be good-looking,
- 12:24but not model-y according to his notes, to march in the New York Easter Parade.
- 12:31At his signal, they were to start smoking cigarettes.
- 12:35Bernays acted like the whole thing was completely spontaneous, and
- 12:39that's how newspapers around the world reported it the next day.
- 12:43Within six weeks, smoking became an accepted pattern for women
- 12:50throughout the United States.
- 12:52Bernays called this tactic the engineering of consent.
- 12:56The goal was to make it seem like the consumer had come up with the idea
- 13:01on their own, but really he was in the background pulling the strings.
- 13:06Cigarettes' social acceptance and popularity continued to grow
- 13:10until, by the middle of the 20th century, cigarettes were everywhere.
- 13:21Even if we had the sense they weren't great for us, there was no clear
- 13:25evidence to point to confirming that, but proof was coming.
- 13:30Chapter two: The proof and the conspiracy.
- 13:38There had always been people, especially doctors, who thought, "Of
- 13:42course smoking can't be good for you."
- 13:46But it's very hard to separate that from the moral categorizations.
- 13:51Like, is it bad for you because we think it's wasteful, you know, it makes
- 13:55your teeth yellow or smells in a funny way, but is this bad for everyone?
- 14:02Before 1950, if a patient complained to their doctor of a chronic cough,
- 14:08it was common to be told that for some people smoking wasn't healthy.
- 14:13And that's a radical difference than saying smoking causes lung cancer.
- 14:22But then in 1950, two studies came out one after the other showing that
- 14:28cigarettes likely caused lung cancer.
- 14:31The first was co-authored by an American surgeon and a medical student in St.
- 14:35Louis, Evarts Graham and Ernest Wynder.
- 14:40By necessity, they had to take a creative approach.
- 14:43It's almost certainly unethical to say to two groups of, you know, 12-year-olds,
- 14:49"Half of you are gonna become smokers, half of you are not, and in 30 years
- 14:54we'll see what your health is like."
- 14:56Yeah, no one was gonna sign up for a study like that.
- 15:00So they had to figure out another way, and that other way turned
- 15:04out to be looking backwards.
- 15:06And so they would find people with lung cancer and they would say, you know,
- 15:11"Did you smoke or didn't you smoke?"
- 15:15Graham and Wynder collected extensive data on 684 lung cancer patients
- 15:21across the United States, and it turned out that smokers made up
- 15:25a large percentage of the group.
- 15:27Not only that, the sharp increase in lung cancer rates followed the same
- 15:32line as the increase in smoking.
- 15:35The second study was conducted by two British medical statisticians,
- 15:39A. Bradford Hill and Richard Doll, and it also had a unique approach.
- 15:45They were really interested in statistics and, um, they were
- 15:50really prepared to build a model for how we think about causality, not
- 15:56just for cigarettes, but for other environmental toxins, for other products.
- 16:04But there was a problem with both of these studies.
- 16:07They were really different from how we studied infectious diseases.
- 16:12This wasn't like looking at tuberculosis, for example, where you could isolate
- 16:17a bacterium under a microscope.
- 16:19These studies couldn't be conducted in a lab, and they didn't address what
- 16:24in cigarettes was causing lung cancer.
- 16:27And so a lot of people would say, "Well, you know, all of the statistics are really
- 16:32pretty meaningless. We don't really know, and we won't know till we know what it is
- 16:37in the cigarette that changes the cell."
- 16:41It was a convenient argument for cigarette companies who wanted
- 16:45to keep selling cigarettes.
- 16:47But Allan Brandt argues that the evidence of danger was clear,
- 16:51and that should have been enough.
- 16:54I sometimes compare this to taking the pump off the handle during the
- 16:59cholera epidemics of the 1850s.
- 17:02You know, you could say, "We don't know what's in the water, but we better
- 17:05stop drinking that water now because we understand that cholera is coming
- 17:11from this particular well." And you know, how much information do you need?
- 17:17But there were people who said this kind of information is faulty to begin with.
- 17:22And of course, that's the essential argument that the tobacco companies
- 17:27took for many, many years.
- 17:30Wynder and Graham were aware of the merely statistical critique of their
- 17:35study, but it didn't stop their work.
- 17:38In fact, they backed up their claims with a lab study where they spent a
- 17:42year painting mice with tobacco tar.
- 17:45In the end, 44% of the mice developed cancer.
- 17:50On November 30th, 1953, Time Magazine wrote that the case against tobacco
- 17:55had now been proven beyond any doubt.
- 17:59The response from cigarette companies was immediate, but also secret.
- 18:06The very next day, CEOs from the six largest tobacco manufacturers
- 18:11in the US met at the Plaza Hotel in New York City, where they privately
- 18:16freaked out and then made a plan.
- 18:20Beneath the Plaza chandeliers in a scene straight out of a mobster movie,
- 18:25the most powerful tobacco tycoons in the world hatched a conspiracy
- 18:30to publicly deny smoking's hazards and defraud the American people.
- 18:36They hire a really great public relations expert, one of the giants
- 18:40of the 20th century named John Hill, and he essentially says to them, "You
- 18:46know, you don't like the science that's coming out, and it's gonna hurt your
- 18:51industry across all the companies.
- 18:54If you don't like their science, get your own science."
- 18:58And believe me, th- they tried, but their own science didn't say anything different
- 19:08So the companies did something very clever.
- 19:11They said, "We need more research. This is unresolved." And so people
- 19:17were able to use uncertainty as a defense for continuing to smoke.
- 19:25From this point forward, the industry would focus on one word: doubt.
- 19:31After that Plaza Hotel meeting, the tobacco CEOs decided to form the Tobacco
- 19:37Industry Research Committee, or TIRC.
- 19:42Publicly, it was advertised as a research arm of the tobacco companies trying
- 19:47to get to the bottom of the issue.
- 19:49If there are bad elements, through our laboratories, through acts of God and
- 19:53luck, we hope we may find them, and if they are found, they will be removed.
- 19:58But the TIRC was really a PR machine spinning the wheels of uncertainty.
- 20:05But at this point, we do not know.
- 20:08As the years went on, cigarette companies repeated this claim over and
- 20:13over again, despite a growing mountain of evidence that said otherwise.
- 20:18In 1964, the surgeon general gave his damning report on
- 20:23the dangers of cigarettes.
- 20:25Cigarette smoking is a health hazard of sufficient importance to the United
- 20:30States to warrant remedial action.
- 20:34Cigarette smoking contributes substantially to mortality
- 20:38from certain specific diseases and to the overall death rate
- 20:47The reaction was immediate.
- 20:50The following clip is from an interview with a man who was in the audience.
- 20:54Smoking in auditoriums was universal in those days.
- 20:58In fact, there were ashtrays on the back of each seat.
- 21:02But as the two hours wore on, you could see cigarettes
- 21:07going out all over the room.
- 21:11Cigarette smoking declined immediately and abruptly, and
- 21:18this was a worldwide phenomenon.
- 21:21It was the great foreswearing, which was followed a week or two later by the
- 21:27great relapse, and cigarette sales went right back to where they had been before.
- 21:33There was this assumption, I think, at the time of the '64 report:
- 21:36Let's tell people it's dangerous.
- 21:38People are intelligent.
- 21:39They'll quit.
- 21:41This is Alan Brandt from that same documentary.
- 21:44What we found at that moment when we really said smoking causes harm was
- 21:49that it was very difficult to quit, and this led to a full reevaluation of what
- 21:54was the nature of cigarette smoking.
- 21:57Was it a habit?
- 21:58Was it an addiction?
- 21:59It was an important distinction because a habit is a choice, but an
- 22:04addiction, by definition, is not.
- 22:07So you can guess which one the cigarette companies went with.
- 22:11They did everything in their power to make sure cigarettes embody what is
- 22:16arguably the most American of values, personal freedom, and personal freedom's
- 22:22flip side, personal responsibility.
- 22:25And so the quintessential American industry used the quintessential
- 22:30American value as a shield to protect itself from accusations
- 22:34that cigarettes were killing people.
- 22:38The
- 22:39tobacco industry was quite effective at talking out of at least two sides
- 22:46of its mouth for a very long time.
- 22:48So they sort of say, "First, we want you to know, and we've been investigating
- 22:53this, we know of nothing in cigarettes that could cause cancer." If they
- 22:57admitted that it was harmful, that would be the end of the industry.
- 23:02Okay.
- 23:03And then they say, "You should also know it's entirely up to
- 23:08you whether you smoke or not
- 23:16Cigarettes are safe, but even if they aren't, you can't blame us if you get sick
- 23:21because it was your own choice to smoke.
- 23:24It was a nice accompaniment to doubt.
- 23:27So even when we get to the '80s and there was a consensus that cigarettes
- 23:31were addictive because of nicotine-
- 23:34The Surgeon General's report released this morning is the 20th dealing
- 23:37with the health effects of smoking.
- 23:38One, tobacco is addictive.
- 23:40Two, nicotine is the ingredient in tobacco that causes addiction.
- 23:44And three, tobacco addiction is similar in many respects to addiction
- 23:48to alcohol, heroin, and cocaine
- 23:51Publicly, the companies described nicotine like an afterthought.
- 23:55It just happened to be in tobacco, or they said it helped with flavor.
- 24:01But no cigarette executive ever openly admitted the truth, that nicotine was
- 24:06the drug that cigarettes deliver, that it was the whole point of smoking.
- 24:12In 1994, the CEOs of seven tobacco companies testified under oath
- 24:19on the question of nicotine and addiction before Congress.
- 24:22I'd like to just go down the row, uh, whether each of you believes,
- 24:26uh, that nicotine is not addictive.
- 24:29Just yes or no.
- 24:29Do you believe nicotine is not addictive?
- 24:32I believe nicotine is not addictive, yes.
- 24:34Mr. Johnston?
- 24:35Uh, Congressman, cigarettes and nicotine clearly do not meet the
- 24:41classic definitions of addiction.
- 24:43There is no intoxication.
- 24:44All right.
- 24:44We'll,
- 24:44we'll take that as a no.
- 24:45And again, time is short.
- 24:47If you could just…
- 24:48I think each of you believe nicotine is not addictive.
- 24:50We just would like to have this for the record.
- 24:53One by one, they answered in the negative.
- 24:58I believe
- 24:59nicotine is not addictive.
- 25:02Nicotine is not addictive.
- 25:02Case closed.
- 25:04I believe nicotine is not addictive.
- 25:07But, and there is a but, we told you this story was about the
- 25:12rise and fall of cigarettes.
- 25:14Something was about to turn all those wins for the cigarette industry into
- 25:19liabilities, and we'll get into it in part two, dropping on September 22nd.
- 25:27When a mysterious box was delivered to an office at the
- 25:30UC San Francisco Medical School-
- 25:33The return address was Mr. Butts, the Doonesbury cartoon character.
- 25:41One unlikely man found himself on the front lines of the
- 25:45war against big tobacco.
- 25:47They said, "Boy, you have just the perfect credentials if you had a decent suit."
- 25:52Because at that point, the only suit I had was orange, and they didn't think
- 25:57that would play too well on television.
- 25:59So they went out and picked out a suit for me, and that's how my career got launched.
- 26:08And the dominoes would start to fall.
- 26:11The thing that was most important overall was that it was the
- 26:14industry speaking in its own words.
- 26:18You know, when I first got the box and looked through it, the thing that
- 26:22struck me just immediately was that, boy, you know, all these things we
- 26:27thought about these guys are true.
- 26:30In fact, it was even worse than a lot of the things we thought.
- 26:36Tune in next week to Cigarettes in America Part Two: The Reckoning
- 26:48Distillations podcast is produced by the Science History Institute
- 26:51and recorded in the Laurie J. Landau Digital Production Studios.
- 26:56Our executive producer is Mariel Carr.
- 26:59Our senior producer is Rigoberto Hernandez.
- 27:02This episode was produced by Mariel Carr.
- 27:05It was fact-checked by Alexandra Attia, and the sound design
- 27:09was done by Seth Samuel.
- 27:11Support for Distillations has been provided by the Middleton Foundation
- 27:15and the Wyncote Foundation.
- 27:17You can find all of our podcasts as well as our videos and articles on
- 27:21our website at sciencehistory.org.
- 27:24And you can follow us on social media,
- 27:28@SciHistoryOrg for news about our podcast and everything else going
- 27:31on in our free museum and library.
- 27:34For Distillations, I'm Alexis Patrick.
- 27:37Thanks for listening.