Latest / True Crime with Gavin Fish / D4vd Might Plead Guilty, That Should Worry You | Murder of Celeste Rivas Hernandez
Transcript
- 0:01Well, man, a lot has gone on this week, has it not?
- 0:06It's been a busy, busy week in the world of true crime.
- 0:11And of course, most of our attention right now is on the
- 0:14case against David Anthony Burke, who is charged with the
- 0:18murder of Celeste Rivas. Celeste Rivas Hernandez.
- 0:23And a lot has gone on and I've been doing a lot.
- 0:28I've been doing some research. Today I was going to say a lot
- 0:31of research. I started out doing a lot of
- 0:33research, but I got distracted. In fairness, I got distracted.
- 0:38I got distracted with sentimental and nostalgic
- 0:41things. I started a lot of research.
- 0:44I did AI, did a copious amount, let's say, but not tons.
- 0:51But what I'm worried about in this case is that we're not
- 0:57going to be able to see the details well.
- 1:03And I don't know that that worries me so much because I, I
- 1:05want Celeste's family to not to have to go through that.
- 1:09But I also, like you guys have said in past live streams, I
- 1:15want would be criminals to understand just what could
- 1:21happen. And I know with the plea
- 1:23bargain, what's the bargaining that happens, right?
- 1:27They they save the government some money and some hassle by
- 1:31plea pleading guilty. And then the government says,
- 1:36OK, we'll, we'll, we'll give you a little lighter sentence.
- 1:39And I don't know if something about that kind of pisses me
- 1:42off. Now the other thing I want to
- 1:46say before you really get into this tonight is that I was
- 1:51distracted right before the live stream started with my well, I I
- 1:56don't like to say my cause the children do not.
- 2:00They're not mine. They are ours.
- 2:04They were created through a glorious and beautiful
- 2:08partnership between my snuggly bear, my sweetie pie, my one and
- 2:11only. So they are our children.
- 2:14So I was distracted by our meaning, my wife and I eldest
- 2:22daughter who just sometimes she she just asks things that are
- 2:28really it's it's hurtful. Like today, today, right before
- 2:33we came on, she put whoever can find the Glamour Shot Christmas
- 2:38card photo and send it gets a heart from me.
- 2:43Like how do you not just have that on file?
- 2:46You're really just trying to hurt my feelings.
- 2:47And so I sent it to her. I did get 3 hearts from her that
- 2:50nobody else got to see. It was from 2018.
- 2:54Now do you guys want to see what our Glamour Shots Christmas card
- 2:57looked like in 2018 before we really get into this?
- 3:00Because I'm in a mood today, Robin, you get happy.
- 3:04I'm in a mood. OK, I'm going to show it to you.
- 3:07This is 2018. Boom.
- 3:13Now if you got that Christmas card, if you got that Christmas
- 3:17card, would you say to yourself, wow, that is a glamorous.
- 3:25OK, that's all you get. That's all you get.
- 3:28We're going to close it and close that tab.
- 3:31Not no more glamorous Christmas cards from 2018.
- 3:38Fun fact, I had to Photoshop on a mullet because I didn't have
- 3:42long hair back then and it was Kimberly's idea for me to go
- 3:47shirtless under the Sport coat. You can't tell I'm shirtless
- 3:52because as I always say, I I look like I'm wearing a brown
- 3:57cashmere unitard underneath all my clothing.
- 4:02That's what I look like. Too much information, Robin.
- 4:05Was that TMI? Was that TMI?
- 4:07Tell you what, let's get back. Let's get back to what we're
- 4:11talking about here. And we're talking about serious
- 4:13things. We're talking about Celeste
- 4:15Rivas Hernandez, we're talking about Deformida.
- 4:20David, Anthony Burke and and I have started work on some merch,
- 4:27the Deformida merch. Might as well show you that as
- 4:32well. But yeah, let's get into it.
- 4:35It's a it's as they say. Oh, I, I'm, I'm trying to do
- 4:38this before we start. OK, so tonight we're going to
- 4:41talk about Celeste. We're going to do some three
- 4:44questions. Got some good questions tonight.
- 4:46We got some true crime headlines, including the Robin
- 4:50Michelle Reiner case, Nancy Guthrie.
- 4:53We got some good news to go through.
- 4:56We got, we got a 10 gallon show to put in a 5 gallon bucket.
- 4:59That is for sure. Stick with.
- 5:13This video contains mature themes and discussions intended
- 5:16only for adult audiences. Viewer discretion is advised.
- 5:22Hello there, my friend. Welcome back to another true
- 5:24crime conversation with me, Gavin Fish.
- 5:28I so glad that you're joining me on this channel.
- 5:31We like to cut through the fluff and sensationalism of true
- 5:34crime, get into the nitty gritty, and if that's your
- 5:38thing, then you're in the right place.
- 5:42You found us. I'm glad you did.
- 5:44I hope you stick around and I hope you tell me where you're
- 5:47watching from. That's one of my favorite
- 5:48things. Put it in the comments where you
- 5:50watch it from. I like to.
- 5:53I like to know. Now let's go ahead and show you
- 5:57what we've come up with here. This is just this is just our
- 6:00first round. OK, This isn't this is a first
- 6:03draft, but it's Deformada and Jaforio with no Beforeio IL I'll
- 6:12I don't know. I don't know how to say it, but
- 6:15I'm thinking to put that on, on maybe a black coffee mug, maybe
- 6:22put that on a T-shirt some sort. It's just a thought.
- 6:26It's just just our thoughts. But let's get serious for a
- 6:30second. And, and keep in mind my mantra,
- 6:32guys, my mantra. We take ourselves not so
- 6:35seriously, right? We take victims, their families
- 6:38and crime seriously. We don't take ourselves
- 6:41seriously. So, yeah, what are we doing?
- 6:44We're we are talking about this beautiful young woman who at the
- 6:50age of 11 or 12 was lured allegedly by by this man into
- 7:04his orbit and over the course of a few years was C aid and
- 7:14essayed. Now I want to bring up something
- 7:17real quick. The last two videos that we've
- 7:20done that I've done have been demonetized by by YouTube.
- 7:25And that's not that big of a deal.
- 7:26It's fine. It's fine.
- 7:29But what it does, one, it it, it takes away my incentive to do
- 7:35these kinds of things. But two, it it has fewer viewers
- 7:40learning what is actually happening in this case of this
- 7:44young girl who is lured ultimately to her death of
- 7:49violent, painful death. So if you would, one of the
- 7:56indicators, one of one of the things that tells YouTube, hey,
- 8:00send this out to more people is if it makes YouTube money.
- 8:04So if you have been holding back, you've been thinking about
- 8:07a super chat or a super sticker and you haven't done it in the
- 8:11past. I don't I this is just an
- 8:12invitation, no guilt, but I would deeply appreciate it.
- 8:16It helps me, It helps the channel, it helps my family.
- 8:20So thank you for considering that.
- 8:23Javi, I'm feeling a sneeze. Come on.
- 8:25So we're going to need like the cough button pressed feeling do
- 8:29it. I should look into the light.
- 8:32I don't know me rub my nose. OK.
- 8:34This young woman at the age of 11 or 12 started talking online
- 8:40with this man known as well he's David Anthony Burke.
- 8:48I am. I'm following Pascal's league
- 8:52lead. Not calling him David anymore.
- 8:55It's Deformada for me is stupid. So dumb.
- 9:01This guy known as Deformada, a grown man, and he apparently was
- 9:08all about all about little ones, little kids and sick and gross.
- 9:19And these youngsters are not equipped to be able to defend
- 9:29themselves against somebody who is a very, very, very good
- 9:36predator, a trained and practiced predator, which I
- 9:43believe Mr. Deforvida is. You know what I just realized?
- 9:49I didn't bring up my give me just one second.
- 9:55I want to be able to get your comments and I need to be able
- 10:01to pop this out. There we go.
- 10:09Okie, Dokie, I want to say thank you first to let's just see if
- 10:19it'll come. UI didn't get it ready.
- 10:21There we go. Jamie, thank you very much for
- 10:23the Super chat, for getting us ready, getting us going.
- 10:27Deeply appreciate that. Christine Meadows, thank you
- 10:30very much for your super chat and I, I deeply, deeply
- 10:35appreciate you guys taking care of me while I'm over here.
- 10:38Let's just check in where you guys are coming from.
- 10:40We got Jacksonville, FL in the house.
- 10:42We got New Bedford, MA, Ontario, Canada's here, British Columbia,
- 10:46southern Vancouver Island in British Columbia.
- 10:48Thank you very much. The Appalachian Mountains, which
- 10:53is where I currently reside. El Segundo, you are here.
- 10:59Vancouver is here. San Antonio, TX is here.
- 11:02The volunteer stayed in the house watching from the possible
- 11:06humor. Future home of the Bears.
- 11:09South Georgia is here. Oh, justice for Jane that.
- 11:14That's a great. Hey, that is a great point.
- 11:17Wouldn't wear a T-shirt with Deformada on it.
- 11:19That a great point. OK, we're going to go back to
- 11:21the drawing board. Long Beach is in the house.
- 11:24Thank you so much. We got a couple more super chats
- 11:28coming in. Thank you very much. 1 lucky
- 11:30girl for that sticker. Thank you to analytical one.
- 11:34May we always remember. Beautiful, beautiful.
- 11:37Celeste. Thank you for that.
- 11:42Erie, PA is here. Yeah.
- 11:44Paulie saying the same thing. I don't want that man's face on
- 11:47my chest. No, Sir.
- 11:48That's a good point. That is a good point.
- 11:51Tennessee is here. Thank you.
- 11:54What do we got? Ohio Paw Mom, thank you very
- 11:57much. And for saying that, that's,
- 12:00that's awfully nice of you. I appreciate that.
- 12:04Queensland, Australia coming in #1 for distance from where I am
- 12:09here in western Pennsylvania. Thank you for being here.
- 12:13Let me just keep on going. Yeah.
- 12:18A lot of, lot of creators have been demonetized this week over
- 12:22the case. Indeed, that has been the case.
- 12:25Jenny, thank you lurking, but wanted to help.
- 12:28Thanks, Gavin and mods, appreciate you so much.
- 12:33Yeah, the demonetization comes because we're talking about SA
- 12:38and CA, we're talking about the DP, we're talking about hard
- 12:43things that YouTube deems not advertiser friendly.
- 12:48And I respect it, man. I respect it.
- 12:50It's cool. I just, you know, I, I, I just
- 12:56appreciate you guys. Thank you for doing that, for
- 12:58taking care of me. The not so great, great state of
- 13:04Texas. I don't know, Texas is pretty
- 13:05great. Houston is here.
- 13:09Let's see anybody else. Yeah.
- 13:12Anyway, thank you. Thank you for checking in, guys.
- 13:14Appreciate it. Appreciate it.
- 13:16OK. There are a couple things that
- 13:18have happened in the news. I think I want to start off with
- 13:24a couple of stories that have have come out recently.
- 13:29And then I want to talk a little bit about plea bargaining.
- 13:33We're going to we're going to do our best to keep Celeste's face
- 13:36up on the screen tonight because we just we want to remember that
- 13:42we've got a real victim here, right?
- 13:45Got a real victim. And we want, we want to remember
- 13:49her. Don't want to, don't want to
- 13:54forget that. And, and everything that we do
- 13:57here tonight, we're all entering into a covenant with one
- 14:02another, right? We're going to temper our
- 14:04speculation with humanity, with compassion, as was asked of us
- 14:08by the family of Robin Michelle Reiner.
- 14:11And we are just going to do we're we're, we're going to be
- 14:16sensitive folks, sensitive and kind.
- 14:20That's what we're going to do tonight.
- 14:21And, and mods, thank you very much for for keeping track of
- 14:26everybody and everybody. Thank you for keeping our
- 14:30conversations classy. OK, I found this article and it
- 14:36touched me because we're starting to learn a little bit
- 14:42more about Celeste because she is a minor and because the
- 14:46family has kind of stayed out of the limelight, which I
- 14:50completely respect and understand.
- 14:52We don't know much about Celeste.
- 14:55So I thought with thanks to CNN, Ray Sanchez, Quinn Law, thank
- 15:01you for writing this up. Let's learn a little bit about
- 15:05Celeste. OK, this just came out today.
- 15:09The tight knit and family friendly city of Lake Elsinore
- 15:14in Riverside County is about 70 miles southeast and a world
- 15:18apart from the glitz and glamour of the Hollywood Hills.
- 15:23Oh, that's, that's a that's a facet of this that I hadn't
- 15:27considered. Right.
- 15:28I mean, it's, it's an obvious one.
- 15:30They started it out in their lead.
- 15:33But not only, you know, recently.
- 15:39Let's bring Celeste up recently, over the last few days, I've
- 15:42been going through elementary school, middle school, and high
- 15:49school newspapers that were sent to me by a classmate that I met
- 15:55in 4th grade. She and I have remained friendly
- 16:02for I mean, we met in 1984. Been a while, right?
- 16:10And so I've been looking at and, and reading the kinds of things
- 16:15that we wrote as newsworthy and important to us when we were
- 16:21eleven. Well, yeah, starting in 6th
- 16:24grade, 11-12 years old, 1314 years old.
- 16:27So I've been really kind of in a pubescent mindset of myself, you
- 16:37know, remembering who I was. And in fact, just today, she
- 16:41might be watching right now. She's awesome.
- 16:43The girl that I just, I fell in love with in the 6th grade.
- 16:47We, we even had a little like ceremony out on the playground.
- 16:51We committed ourselves to one another and that lasted for
- 16:55about two minutes. But anyway, we recently
- 16:58connected and we've been talking about the old days, right?
- 17:01And this is the age that Celeste was that we're talking about.
- 17:09She was in the Inland Empire, Riverside County, Lake Elsinore.
- 17:14The idea of somebody as important and glamorous to an
- 17:1911/12/13 year old as a musician, somebody with some some cachet,
- 17:30Oh my goodness, that would be that would be bait.
- 17:36Impossible not to at least try to nibble on.
- 17:40Right? And And So what a terrific way
- 17:43to open up this article. Mr. Sanchez, Ray Sanchez and Kun
- 17:51Law, the tight knit and family friendly city of Lake Elsinore
- 17:55in Riverside County, is about 70 miles SE and a world apart from
- 17:59the glitz and glamour of the Hollywood Hills.
- 18:03Celeste Rivas Hernandez grew up in Lake Elsinore where she was a
- 18:07regular at the corner store down the street from her home.
- 18:10Neighbors still recall her strolling around with her
- 18:13backpack and long curly hair atop her 5 foot 2 inch frame.
- 18:18Kaylee Cortez, a neighbor, remembered her first time, or
- 18:22the first time she saw Celeste three years ago.
- 18:25Quote, I'm like, oh, look at that girl.
- 18:28She had big beautiful curls. That's a beautiful little girl,
- 18:31Cortez recalled. The next time Cortez saw Celeste
- 18:37was when her picture appeared in the news after her dismembered
- 18:40and decomposed body was discovered in the trunk of a
- 18:43Tesla owned by the all pop singer who goes by the name De
- 18:47Forvida. The car was parked on a street
- 18:51in the upscale Hollywood Hills neighborhood where the artist,
- 18:54whose legal name is David Anthony Burke, had rented A
- 18:58multimillion dollar home in the hills under the iconic Hollywood
- 19:01sign. Her body was found a day after
- 19:04what would have been her 15th birthday.
- 19:10Quote. Hollywood will always entice
- 19:12kids, said Cortez, 36, who has a 14 year old daughter, continuing
- 19:19the quote. Getting to meet a celebrity or
- 19:21doing something out of the norm is cool for any young teen.
- 19:25Lake Elsinore is small. It's kind of quiet.
- 19:28It's not like hustle and bustle. Yeah, again, just a shiny, shiny
- 19:34bait. And predators.
- 19:37Predators know how to bait their prey, right?
- 19:40They know how to bring them out of the safety of of their
- 19:44communities and their homes and their families.
- 19:47They're practiced at this. And I think that Mister David
- 19:54Anthony Burke is just such a predator, OK?
- 20:00About a year after Cortez first saw Celeste on the street,
- 20:04family and friends began to report the girl is missing.
- 20:07Starting as in early 2024, she and Deforevida appeared together
- 20:12in a Twitch live stream that January.
- 20:15Between then and March 2024, he was photographed getting out of
- 20:20a black Tesla near the 7th graders home.
- 20:27Dude, that is, listen, you are exhibiting a real illness if as
- 20:34a person and, and I'm telling you, like if, if your prey is
- 20:411/7 grader, if you were any older than like an eighth
- 20:48grader, it's it's weird. It's out of the ordinary.
- 20:53Now, I know that there are exceptions to rules.
- 20:56You know, somebody being in 7th grade, a little older, somebody
- 20:59being in 9th grade. Wait, like skipped a grade or
- 21:01two. I get it, I get it.
- 21:02Don't come after me. But you guys know what I mean,
- 21:05right? This is not age appropriate.
- 21:07He was in 2024. He would have been what, 19
- 21:11years old, a 19 year old and a 13 year old.
- 21:17Come on, right? Oh my goodness.
- 21:23Celeste was also photographed backstage at one of his Los
- 21:27Angeles shows in June 2024. She was last seen alive going
- 21:31into David Burke's home. I'm just going to say Burke's
- 21:35home in April 2025. She was 13 at the time, a
- 21:41teenager seen in widely circulated photos with thick,
- 21:45dark curls that highlight her soft smile.
- 21:49I mean, look at that beautiful child.
- 21:52Think of your own children or grandchildren or your little
- 21:55sister, right? The, the, the world ahead of
- 22:00them, the, all, the, the entire life ahead of them.
- 22:07And just so much potential, just so much potential.
- 22:17She loved Hello Kitty, and the missing persons poster in Lake
- 22:21Elsinore said she was last seen wearing Hello Kitty slippers.
- 22:25Quote, I don't want her remembered as a rebellious kid
- 22:28or a runaway, said Cortez, who started and tends to a makeshift
- 22:33memorial outside the home where Celeste lived with her family
- 22:37Continuing continuing the quote. She was a daughter, a sister, a
- 22:41friend. She was a young girl just trying
- 22:44to figure out life and she doesn't get to grow up, Cortez
- 22:46said. She doesn't get to get married
- 22:49or have any children because someone took that away from her.
- 22:52And that is a a mature way of looking at these things.
- 22:56When a person's life is cut short, it's taken away,
- 23:01especially in youth. You, you're not only are
- 23:06snatching that life away from them and their parents, their
- 23:11loved ones, but you're snatching their future possible
- 23:17grandchildren that you know, like you're snatching
- 23:21generations off of the earth. It's, and I can't understate
- 23:25this, I'm sorry, I can't overstate this.
- 23:30You're, you're killing thousands, maybe millions of
- 23:36people when you take one life. And I love that, Miss Cortez
- 23:42said. You know, I don't want her
- 23:45thought, thought of as a rebellious kid or a runaway.
- 23:50She was just, she was just a young kid who was lured out by
- 23:58AII would characterize him, in my opinion, as a professional
- 24:03predator. It could happen to any of our
- 24:07children, OK? A victim's life cut short on
- 24:18Monday following a month long investigation.
- 24:20Mr. Burke, 21, pleaded not guilty to 1st degree murder.
- 24:25The LA District Attorney added special circumstances to the
- 24:28charge, which makes the sentence eligible for the DP.
- 24:33Prosecutors say that he had a well, this is YouTube.
- 24:39We're going to try real hard. We're going to say an SA
- 24:44relationship with the young girl because it's not a relationship,
- 24:50right? I mean, I understand, I
- 24:52understand the descriptor here, but we know that there is a
- 24:55difference, right? It's not a relationship.
- 24:57It's not a relationship, it is SA.
- 25:02But anyway, he S he had a SA relationship, let's say with the
- 25:07young girl and killed her after she threatened to expose it.
- 25:11He allegedly engaged in continuous essay of Celeste
- 25:15starting in September 2023 until September 2024, according to the
- 25:21criminal complaint. Now Blair Burke, one of Mr.
- 25:27Burke's attorneys, wrote in a statement on Monday.
- 25:31Quote, the actual evidence in this case will show that David
- 25:34Burke did not murder Celeste Rivas Hernandez and he was not
- 25:38the cause of her death. We will vigorously defend
- 25:40David's innocence. And I know some of you disagree
- 25:44with my position on this, but I am grateful for Miss Burke and
- 25:48her legal team for for defending Mr. Burke spelled differently,
- 25:54Tony Burke's here. Maybe I need to go back to De
- 25:57Forvida. But anyway, I, I want a
- 26:02vigorous, competent, good defense and I expect nothing
- 26:06less. I want, I want the prosecution
- 26:11and police, all investigators, everybody involved in this case
- 26:15to have dotted every, I crossed every T, every little single
- 26:21detail, buttoned up all 40 terabytes of it.
- 26:25And I have faith that that has been the case.
- 26:28OK? Celeste died of multiple
- 26:30penetrating injuries, according to an autopsy report released
- 26:33Wednesday. We went over that.
- 26:35It is available on my Patreon for you to download.
- 26:39If you there are other places you can get it too.
- 26:43And you can watch, you can read the entire thing by watching the
- 26:46video from a couple of days ago. She had wounds on her chest and
- 26:50abdomen that may represent sharp force injuries, the Los Angeles
- 26:53County Medical Examiner's Office said in a report.
- 26:56Of course, she had been dead for months and so it's very
- 27:00difficult to know for sure. A tattoo reading was found on
- 27:06the inside of her right index finger, the autopsy report said,
- 27:10similar to the tattoo Mr. Burke had on his finger.
- 27:15Guys, OK, Am I just old fashioned?
- 27:17Am I old fashioned? Should 14 year olds have
- 27:21tattoos? Maybe I'm, I mean, I, I don't
- 27:25feel like I'm a total prude. My wife and I gave our then, you
- 27:30know, 17 year old son a a Christmas gift.
- 27:34That was his first tattoo. I just like I'm not, I'm not
- 27:39anti them, not pro them, but 14 year olds, What what tattoo
- 27:45artists are doing that please? Oh my.
- 27:48OK, that's a tangent. That's a tangent, guys.
- 27:52What was it? It was a tangent.
- 27:54It was different. A tangent.
- 27:59OK. So it was found on the inside of
- 28:02her right index finger. The autopsy report said similar
- 28:05to the tattoo Mr. Burke has on his finger, 2 fingers were
- 28:09severed and missing from her other hand.
- 28:12To my knowledge that they've not been found since Celeste
- 28:16dismembered body was discovered in Burke's Tesla.
- 28:18Most news coverage of the cases focused on the budding musical
- 28:21sensation known to his legion of mostly young fans as
- 28:25deformative, but Celeste's brief life has drawn relatively little
- 28:29notice. I'm so glad that CNN wrote this.
- 28:33And here is a photo of her parents.
- 28:40This poor family. I mean, look at them, they, they
- 28:45could be any one of us. They could be any one of us.
- 28:49This could have happened to any one of us because of the
- 28:53professional predator, the practiced predator that that did
- 29:01this OK Community mourns teen who never returned home
- 29:06Celeste's family has largely stayed out of the public view
- 29:09since her body was discovered. In a statement, the family's
- 29:13attorney said the parents, Jesus Rivas and Mercedes Martinez,
- 29:17asked for privacy as they grieve the loss of their daughter.
- 29:20Quote. The Rivas Hernandez family is
- 29:23committed to ensuring that Celeste's voice is heard and her
- 29:28memory is honored throughout the process.
- 29:30Family attorney Patrick Steinfeld said Celeste was a
- 29:33beautiful, strong girl who loved to sing and dance.
- 29:37Oh, that, that just gave me chills, right?
- 29:41For a predator with musical ability, being able to tug at
- 29:45those strings, man to a little girl who just the, the music got
- 29:50her right. It got her, it spoke to her.
- 29:53It, it penetrated her, penetrated her deeply into her
- 29:58soul. She loved it.
- 30:00And he had that, he, he and he could grasp onto it and he
- 30:04could, he could tickle those strings, right?
- 30:07He could tug on those strings. Anyway.
- 30:11Celeste was a beautiful, strong girl who loved to sing and
- 30:14dance, the family said in a statement.
- 30:16We love her very much and she always told us that she loved
- 30:19us, they added. We miss her deeply.
- 30:22All we want is justice for Celeste.
- 30:26After the release of the autopsy report on Wednesday, Steinfeld
- 30:29said the findings have caused profound emotional pain for
- 30:34Celeste loved ones. Of course they have.
- 30:37Quote. The Rivas Hernandez family is
- 30:40absolutely devastated by the findings contained in the
- 30:44medical examiner's report involving the horrible and
- 30:47gruesome death of their beloved daughter.
- 30:49They respectfully ask for privacy, understanding and
- 30:52patience as they process the this information. close quote
- 30:57For now, friends and neighbors honor Celeste's memory at the
- 31:01memorial that Cortez started with a lone photo of the girl
- 31:04and some flowers. It now includes fresh flowers,
- 31:07stuffed animals, toys, candles and a huge sign saying justice
- 31:11for Celeste Rivas. Let me there was a photo of it
- 31:15up here, right? I mean, this is just this is a
- 31:22sign. This is a, this is, I mean, it's
- 31:25literally a sign, but it is an end sign to all of us.
- 31:31Just how much pain the community feels over the death of this
- 31:36little one, OK? Neighbors stop by to pay their
- 31:46respects, often leaving flowers and other mementos.
- 31:49Quote, every holiday I make something for her, like for
- 31:52Valentine's Day, for Christmas and I just put it out there.
- 31:55It's kind of become like a labor of love for me, Cortez said.
- 31:59One day, a man who Cortez believes is an uncle of Celeste
- 32:02emerged from the teens home and knelt before the memorial
- 32:06sobbing uncontrollably, she said family members always mount the
- 32:12words thank you to Cortez when they drive by.
- 32:15Quote, this memorial is about Celeste and her legacy and her
- 32:18impact. Cortez said her brief life has
- 32:23had an impact on many residents of Lake Elsinore, including
- 32:28Ellie Nad Off Nad Off, who owns a corner store a few doors down
- 32:34from where Celeste lived. Quote, I feel like I know her
- 32:37forever for 11 years here and Nad Off said Takis and soda were
- 32:43her favorite afternoon snacks. He recalled on rainy days Nad
- 32:46Off would make hot chocolate for Celeste and other kids waiting
- 32:50for the school bus. It's, you know, I grew up in
- 32:55Orangevale, CA, which is a suburb of Sacramento.
- 33:02It's, it's probably half of it is suburbia and the other half
- 33:07is pretty rural. You know, they're they're horse
- 33:10farms and still remnants of old orange Groves and things like
- 33:16that. It's a beautiful little spot
- 33:19placed along the American River in on the east side of the
- 33:22Sacramento Valley. It's beautiful.
- 33:24We lived in the the suburb part of Orangevale and there was a
- 33:30711. It's still there in it's on wood
- 33:37more Oaks Drive in Orangevale and it's just a little store
- 33:43right in the middle of a neighborhood.
- 33:46It's the only thing like it anywhere nearby.
- 33:48I'd I have no idea how a little commercial store was built in
- 33:53this in this little suburban neighborhood.
- 33:58My mom worked at that 711. Both of my older brothers worked
- 34:02at that 711 friends worked at that 711, right.
- 34:05And like, I could still talk to my mom or to my brothers about
- 34:11specific people that we grew up with or were in the neighborhood
- 34:15or whatever. And they would be able to tell
- 34:16you right now what their regular thing was right when when they
- 34:23came in, what their regular thing was.
- 34:25And I think that this is just adorable and sweet.
- 34:29You know the that this business owner remembers Celeste
- 34:34remembers that she liked Takis. She liked grabbing a soda.
- 34:40That's awfully sweet quote. You don't know the future, where
- 34:44it's going with this girl, He lamented.
- 34:46You don't know what her dream, all this taken from her, from
- 34:50her family, not of said he kept his 17 year old daughter out of
- 34:54school for about a week after he learned of Celeste's death.
- 34:58He wanted to, quote, just spend time with her and talk to her
- 35:02close quote about the many risks teenagers face.
- 35:05Yeah. If there's anything that we can
- 35:07take from this is that we need to work.
- 35:11We don't, guys. We live in a safer world today
- 35:14than the world that I grew up in.
- 35:16Our children are growing up in a safer place.
- 35:19However, they, they there's danger and it's there.
- 35:23We know where it is. We know that it's in Roblox and
- 35:27places like that. We know where it is.
- 35:31We've boy, do we have to get vigilant about that with our
- 35:36kids. OK, Like Mr. Nut off here.
- 35:40Let's, let's learn from from this case, OK?
- 35:45Cortez said she and her daughter talk about Celeste nearly
- 35:48everyday. Quote, her friends are very
- 35:50protective of Celeste and her name because she's not here to
- 35:54defend herself, she said. And that does I'm going to bring
- 35:59this up. Actually, I think I've got a
- 36:01think I've got that photo here. I'll bring up.
- 36:08There has been quite a bit of victim blaming and victim family
- 36:14blaming that I've even seen in my comments on my on my videos,
- 36:19which has been disheartening. We need to understand that this,
- 36:29if he did what prosecutors and police say he did, which I
- 36:33believe they, I believe them. If he did those things, then he
- 36:37is a practiced and professional at doing, at luring out and
- 36:44abusing the sweet girl. And there's there was nothing
- 36:51that she could have done about it.
- 36:53She was just just wasn't. She was a kiddo.
- 36:59She was just a kid. When we were that age, we could
- 37:04have just as easily fallen prey to a predator like this.
- 37:10And right now, you and I, we could be family members of a
- 37:17kiddo that we love in our life that could fall prey to a
- 37:20predator like that. Let's let's be compassionate and
- 37:24human about this and real. I'm not, I'm not just like
- 37:28spitting rainbows here, right? Let's be real about it.
- 37:33Any of our children, our grandchildren could be a victim
- 37:37like Celeste was to a predator was practiced and and good and
- 37:44adept at their predation. OK, Thank you to CNN for writing
- 37:53that story, for talking to people who know the Rivas family
- 37:59who were in the neighborhood, and thank you to those people
- 38:03who did speak to those reporters.
- 38:06I think that that I think those precious few little details
- 38:12helped us understand who who Celeste was.
- 38:17OK, the next thing that I want to bring to you, actually what I
- 38:22want to do is I want to pause for a second and see what you
- 38:24guys are saying over in the live chat.
- 38:29And it just refreshed on me. So I may miss some and I'm very
- 38:33sorry, Jackie, I'm going to put it up.
- 38:43I'm I'm going to put up this comment after what I just said.
- 38:46I'm going to put up the comment. And Jackie, just know that I'm
- 38:49not attacking you. I'm not attacking you.
- 38:54What you're saying is a natural response, but we need to fight
- 38:59against this part of our nature, Jackie says.
- 39:02It's horrible what happened, but why are we overlooking the
- 39:05parents, family life and its role in this?
- 39:08The man is guilty, but there has to be reasons to why all the
- 39:11running away, etcetera. Here's The thing is that she
- 39:14wasn't a runaway. She was only a runaway when it
- 39:17came to Mr. Burke. That's the thing.
- 39:22OK, Now I, I understand what you're saying.
- 39:25Like, for example, one of the things that I, I think about all
- 39:28the time is as Kimberly and I are raising our children and we
- 39:31lived on a street where cars would drive, right?
- 39:35We would tell our children, do not go into the street, do not
- 39:41go into the street. But if a ball accidentally went
- 39:45off into the street, guess what they would do?
- 39:48They would run into the street. And I mean, it takes practice
- 39:53and practice and practice to keep your children from doing
- 39:56that right. Vigilance stuff.
- 39:59It is the nature of a child to be childlike.
- 40:04I don't think anywhere inside me that that family was driving
- 40:10their daughter to run away. I I don't think so.
- 40:15Could I be wrong? I could be wrong, but I don't
- 40:18think so. I think what we need to do
- 40:21though, is focus. She wasn't doing all that
- 40:26running away. She was running to him, just to
- 40:29him. That's my understanding.
- 40:32And we need to be, we need to be super understanding about that.
- 40:36OK, Real happy is giving me the 100%.
- 40:39Oh, thank you very much. Let me keep on going.
- 40:45Yeah. Archangel Marici.
- 40:47No, they should not after they're 18.
- 40:49I think we're talking about age disparities there.
- 40:51Oh, we're talking about tattoos. Yeah.
- 40:54Scotch's mom. I didn't allow my daughter to
- 40:56get tattoos until she was 18 and in college.
- 40:58Yeah. My wife and I, we have a son
- 41:02who's a type 1 diabetic, and he wanted a tattoo so he didn't
- 41:06have to wear a bracelet. And we thought that's, that's a
- 41:09good reason to get a tattoo. And when he turned, you know,
- 41:14the Christmas after he was 17, we were we were happy to to do
- 41:17that. I personally think that nobody
- 41:20should get tattoos till their brain is formed.
- 41:22And I think that's about 50. But you know what?
- 41:25But to each their own. To each their own.
- 41:31Debbie says some kids have tattoos done by friends.
- 41:34Yeah, that's true. Sometimes they do it to
- 41:36themselves. You can.
- 41:37You can easily buy the stuff. Let me keep on scrolling here.
- 41:46Just checking your cabling. My aunt and uncle lived in
- 41:52Orangevale on Cherry Creek. It's still kind of small, but
- 41:56growing. Yeah, it is.
- 41:58It's developing out. Yeah, I know where Cherry Creek
- 42:02is. Thank you for your comment.
- 42:05I loved growing up in Orangevale.
- 42:07I loved it, Miss B says. Fortunately there was no
- 42:14Internet in my childhood. Yeah, fortunate for me too.
- 42:18Phoenix Rising. There are already two or three
- 42:21other young girls that have come forward.
- 42:22Steve Fisher has spoken with at least one of them.
- 42:25Yeah. Sensei Wackadoodle, your mods
- 42:31are doing a great job tonight. Much love to the mods.
- 42:33My mods are awesome. Thank you for recognizing them.
- 42:40Sky Elizabeth saying Gavin, I thought he already pleaded not
- 42:42guilty. Do they get a chance to change
- 42:44their plea? That's a great comment.
- 42:47Yes, you can change your plea at any time.
- 42:50Once you can change your plea at the like, like during a trial,
- 43:00you can change your plea. So and that's that's what
- 43:03usually happens. Typically somebody pleads not
- 43:06guilty until they plead guilty. And that's like 90% of cases.
- 43:11That's usually what happens. Great question.
- 43:15Glad that, glad that you brought that up.
- 43:19Robin says, I think you're a bit off of total brain formation, at
- 43:22least sixty. Yeah, Rita Morris says.
- 43:25I had an older sister that started running away when she
- 43:28was 12. My brother and I never ran away,
- 43:30and we couldn't figure out why she did.
- 43:32My parents bent over backwards to help her.
- 43:34Didn't work. Yeah.
- 43:40Yeah. Well, I remember at 11 or 12, I
- 43:42would run away for all of about half an hour before I had
- 43:45realized, oh, I'm going to get hungry and I'm going to be get
- 43:47cold and I'm all that stuff, right.
- 43:49Just not being able to. And I've already described my
- 43:54childhood as, like, idyllic. I won the parent lottery when I
- 43:58was born into my family, but still, at age 1112, you get
- 44:04confused, you get sad, you think life is unfair, You think nobody
- 44:08loves me. Right.
- 44:10And none of it is rational. Yeah.
- 44:14Great. Thank you for that comment,
- 44:16Rita. I really appreciate that.
- 44:20AC says there are some cultures where young girls dating older
- 44:23men is acceptable. This is sick and a crime.
- 44:27But I wonder if her family didn't see the relationship as a
- 44:29problem. I And I don't think so.
- 44:34I don't think so. Montana Sunshine said I had a
- 44:39many tattoos at age 14 but had them all removed at 17.
- 44:44Wow, wow. OK thank you guys.
- 44:48Thank you, thank you, thank you for your comments.
- 44:50Let me go to the next thing that I wanted to share with you.
- 44:56Find the right place, Gavin. This is a this isn't this is
- 45:04more like A blog post from a law firm called Crowder criminal
- 45:11firm in in Plano, TX. But they talk about plea
- 45:15bargains for CA types of crimes. And I thought that it was
- 45:20important to to read a little bit about about it.
- 45:24They talk about it in terms of federal cases.
- 45:27But just just so that we all understand, I think this is
- 45:31worth going through for, not all of it, but part of it.
- 45:34OK, again, this is this is a law firm out of Texas.
- 45:39I have a link, the Crowder criminal firm.
- 45:41There's a link down in the description.
- 45:43According to the Department of Justice's Bureau of Justice
- 45:46Assistance, the overwhelming majority of criminal cases, 90
- 45:50to 95%, result in a plea bargain.
- 45:53And this is answering that question that we got earlier,
- 45:56right. And this is true.
- 45:59It's pretty much true throughout the fruited plain.
- 46:01Sea to shining sea, sea to shining sea.
- 46:05Can we do a take two on that one, Javi Sea to shining sea, 90
- 46:09to 95%. And in a plea bargain, Plea
- 46:13bargaining is one of the most fundamental elements in the
- 46:16federal criminal justice system. Also the state system when it
- 46:20comes to let's say CA cases, including C Sam, all all these
- 46:27things, OK. A negotiated agreement between
- 46:31the defense and prosecution aims for a guilty plea in return for
- 46:34reduced charges or lighter sentencing.
- 46:37That's what it boils down to. The government has spared the
- 46:40time and expense of a trial while the defendant receives a
- 46:43more beneficial outcome. The stakes for the defendant in
- 46:47these kinds of cases are exceptionally high, including
- 46:56the DP in Mr. Burke's case. The charges are serious.
- 47:00A conviction brings long term consequences in addition to
- 47:04severe judicial penalties. A defense attorney plays a
- 47:07crucial role in plea bargain plea bargains.
- 47:10He or she must have a comprehensive understanding of
- 47:13the strengths and weaknesses of each After metealistly analyzing
- 47:16all the evidence. OK real quick, what are the
- 47:21primary components of the plea bargain?
- 47:23Well, a guilty plea is #1 #2 are mitigating factors from the
- 47:29defense are presented. OK was, was Mr. Burke himself a,
- 47:35a victim of CA or SA, you know, those kinds of things A sentence
- 47:42is proposed, conditions or stipulations are negotiated and
- 47:47then ultimately the judge doesn't have to accept all of
- 47:51them. They just do.
- 47:52So, you know, just so you guys know that the, the overwhelming,
- 48:03the overwhelming odds are that Mister Burke will never see
- 48:07trial as long as the prosecution is willing to give up certain
- 48:19things. The prosecution has other
- 48:21incentives as well. That incentive is to spare the
- 48:27family the details. That's the main one.
- 48:31Spare the family, the community, the details.
- 48:35And that is a strong incentive because ultimately we're all
- 48:39people, right, Including prosecutors are all people.
- 48:43So I and and I remember this is not, and I told you so, but for
- 48:50example, this is just an example during the Madeline Soto case,
- 48:55as we were, you know, Mr. Stearns had been arrested and
- 49:03things were coming out right? You know, badge Cam videos and
- 49:10police reports and stuff like that.
- 49:12I remember saying he's going to plead this.
- 49:16He's definitely going to plead this.
- 49:19And duty Ron came on and he said in a comment, I would wager my
- 49:26pension that he doesn't. And duty Ron is somebody who I
- 49:30really, really admire and has a, a, a deeper set of bona fides
- 49:37than I do. I have, I have none.
- 49:39He has his CV is long, right? He said I would bet my pension
- 49:46that he doesn't. And sure enough, Stephen Stern's
- 49:50plea, because 92% in my in, in the Commonwealth of
- 49:57Pennsylvania, it's 92% of people plea.
- 50:00They never make it to a a trial. And federal, it's 90 to 95%.
- 50:07California, it's probably about the same.
- 50:09It's about the same everywhere. So don't be surprised, don't be
- 50:12disappointed if we don't see a a trial here.
- 50:21And I honestly hope, I honestly hope we don't see a trial just
- 50:27for the Rivas family. I hope we don't see a trial.
- 50:32Let's see. Is there anything else that I
- 50:33want to show you guys? Let's see.
- 50:39LK says that she saw me or he saw me on Lawn Crime Network a
- 50:45few days ago. I did an amazing job that that
- 50:47was a while back. Yeah.
- 50:48Thank you. Cabling, says Gavin.
- 50:51Did you see the forensic medical examiner on duty, Ron?
- 50:53He said the pregnancy issue could be ruled out as the blood
- 50:57and urine tests could not be done.
- 50:59The uterus would not show signs of early on.
- 51:02I I hadn't seen that. I hadn't seen that.
- 51:07Keys by Rena says I'm T1D2. Never thought about a tattoo but
- 51:11love the idea. Would you mind sharing what your
- 51:14son picked? Yeah, it is a tattoo that I
- 51:16designed. I I could ask him if if he is
- 51:24willing to let me take a picture of it and and share it.
- 51:27Maybe I'll do it in the tank. If if you guys don't know, the
- 51:31fish tank is where we hang out on Facebook.
- 51:33You're always welcome over there.
- 51:37We talk about all sorts of things.
- 51:40Easiest way to get there is from my website, gavinfish.com.
- 51:44If you click on this little fishy icon that will take you to
- 51:47the tank. So if I get his permission, I
- 51:49will share it. But it is a it's on the inside
- 51:51of his wrist and it is basically an identification.
- 51:54An identification showing that he has type 1 diabetes.
- 52:00That's that's what it is. Oh, I love this picture of
- 52:04Celeste. This is something that her
- 52:07family shared. What a cutie, sweetie.
- 52:15Yeah, I'm going to skip over anything that that is about
- 52:19Celeste's family. Like I, I respect your opinions
- 52:25and your comments. I'm just, but I'm skipping over
- 52:27them. I just don't think, I just don't
- 52:32think that it's, it adds to the conversation in a, in a positive
- 52:36way. OK, so that's what we have in
- 52:40Celeste's case, guys. But there's more to come.
- 52:43Don't you fret. We, we have some more
- 52:47information. Where do I have that?
- 52:50We have more information in the Nancy Guthrie case.
- 52:52We've got some commentary out of the Reiner family in the wake,
- 52:56obviously, of the murder of Rob and Michelle Reiner.
- 53:00And we've got some news, some good news coming up.
- 53:03We like to, we, we've been doing this lately.
- 53:05We like to end our show with some good news, but before we do
- 53:12that, how about we get into three questions?
- 53:15It's three questions with Gavinfish.
- 53:22OK? In this segment, guys, I answer
- 53:253 questions that you sent to me at threequestions@gavinfish.com.
- 53:28Three questions at gavinfish.com.
- 53:29Just spell it all out. THREE 3 questions at
- 53:34gavinfish.com and I will put it on the list and I will endeavor
- 53:40my darndest to answer all questions.
- 53:42I got to say I'm running light on questions and it's the same
- 53:47like a handful of people that sending questions and that's
- 53:49cool, it's totally cool. But if you have a question that
- 53:53you would like me to answer, that could be it could run the
- 53:57gambit from my favorite color to the deepest mysteries of the
- 54:01universe or my opinion on them anyway, Send it to three
- 54:05questions at gavinfish.com. OK, question #1II especially
- 54:10like the questions that you guys can answer in in the chat from
- 54:16Angela, frequent correspondent. Gavin, I have to ask, do you
- 54:21believe there could be intelligent life outside our
- 54:24planet? I'm curious.
- 54:26Well, Angela, I think the more important question, and I'm not
- 54:32this isn't a dodge. This isn't a dodge.
- 54:34I'll answer your question, but I think the more important
- 54:38question is, is there intelligent life on this planet?
- 54:43And some days, some days I'm not convinced.
- 54:50Do I believe there could be intelligent life outside the
- 54:53planet? Yeah, I do.
- 54:54The Curiosity Rover found molecular structures on Mars
- 55:03that were described as molecules that are precursors to DNA.
- 55:07It's organic material. It's or it's least it's evidence
- 55:11of organic material on Mars that could have been there from
- 55:16millions of years ago, could have been transported there by
- 55:19meteorite. But I in in the vast universe
- 55:27where there are countless solar systems, countless planets
- 55:32orbiting around those Suns that are in the the, you know,
- 55:37so-called Green Zone. I just can't imagine that we are
- 55:41the only ones in the world now. I am not or in the universe I'm
- 55:47I'm aware of. I can't remember the what is the
- 55:51name of that paradox where it's like, well, if there is life out
- 55:55in the universe, how come we haven't heard from them?
- 55:59Yeah, I, I, I just, I I think there is intelligent life
- 56:04everywhere. And and that's not just, it's
- 56:09not just small organisms either. I think there is intelligent
- 56:14life. And if you want to read a
- 56:17terrific novel about the idea of finding intelligent life, let me
- 56:24I can't remember the name of the the writer, give me a second.
- 56:29It is Mary Doria Russell wrote a novel in 1996 called The
- 56:37Sparrow. It is such a good book and it
- 56:43deals with people on Earth dealing with being with first
- 56:51contact from another, from another planet.
- 56:56And and it specifically does it from the perspective of faith.
- 57:01And do you lose faith if you if there is life outside of just
- 57:09our little world? It, it, it's really thought
- 57:13provoking in a fun novel. I read it in a book club years
- 57:17ago with Kimberly. I'm not really a, a fiction
- 57:20reader, but I, I did. And it was so good and I loved,
- 57:24I loved that book club too, 'cause we were the only ones
- 57:26under the age of about 60 at the time and we were in our early
- 57:2920s. It was really fun.
- 57:31It was like having like 6 bonus sets of grandparents.
- 57:35It was, it was great. But yeah, that, that's my answer
- 57:39question #2 from Kelly. How far is the beach from your
- 57:44house? Yeah.
- 57:46So we talked about this. My wife is a beach girl.
- 57:49Let's see, the distance from our house to the, the last beach
- 57:54that we went to is like 3600 miles.
- 57:56It was in Portugal. The distance from our house to
- 58:00the next beach we will be going to is about 2800 miles.
- 58:07I, I guess 2600, something like that.
- 58:10It's on the other side. We're, we're, we'll be in
- 58:12California over the summer. The, the closest beach to us
- 58:19that is an ocean is about 400 miles.
- 58:24And the closest beach that we go to, which is on the Great Lakes
- 58:30is about 50 miles. So yeah, we, we get around, we
- 58:36get around a little bit. In fact, it was really fun when
- 58:40we were there in Porto last year.
- 58:44Was that just last year? I think it was.
- 58:47Kimberly and I were on the beach facing West at the same time.
- 58:53Our daughter and son-in-law were on a facing West across the
- 58:59Atlantic. At the same time, our daughter
- 59:01and son-in-law were facing east on a beach looking across the
- 59:06Atlantic. And we were on roughly the same
- 59:09latitude, looking across the ocean, somewhere out there
- 59:14beneath the pale moonlight. Do you guys remember that movie?
- 59:17Come on. Yeah.
- 59:20But my wife is a beach girl, and she's, she's looking forward to
- 59:23being back at the beach. And question #3 also from Kelly,
- 59:30it's a philosophical question. I want your answers to this in
- 59:34the chat. Does money buy happiness, Kelly?
- 59:39Money does not buy happiness, but money buys cameras, and
- 59:46cameras make me happy. That's my answer.
- 59:52No, money does not buy happiness.
- 59:55Money definitely buys cameras. Cameras make me happy.
- 1:00:00Those guys are your questions now while you are getting busy
- 1:00:04on your little keyboards with your fingers or your thumbs.
- 1:00:07And you're going to tell me the answer, your answers to these
- 1:00:11three questions. Let's get into some headlines
- 1:00:15around the world. Here we go.
- 1:00:16True POW Okie Dokie In the case of Nancy Guthrie, I found this
- 1:00:32interesting. This was published yesterday on
- 1:00:34News Nation. Headline is Profiler FBI
- 1:00:37profiler explains meaning of hollow blood spots on her porch
- 1:00:43Images of the blood found on Nancy Guthrie's front porch
- 1:00:46showed the drops appeared to have been smeared, retired FBI
- 1:00:50profiler Jim Clementi told News Nation's Brian Enten.
- 1:00:55Clementi looked at the video of the scene, analyzing the clips
- 1:00:59frame by frame and drawing conclusions based on key
- 1:01:02observations. Quote.
- 1:01:03That tells me a number of things, and it's very specific.
- 1:01:061 is that at this point, Nancy's face was very close to the
- 1:01:11ground, within a foot of the ground.
- 1:01:13This could be she was either on her knees, hunched over, or
- 1:01:17actually lying on the ground. Close quote Clementi expanded on
- 1:01:23the droplets, noting that some are low velocity blood spatter
- 1:01:26and others are medium velocity. Quote Medium velocity blood
- 1:01:31spatter can be created when someone actually aspirates blood
- 1:01:34and then coughs it up, he said. You can see 3 circular blood
- 1:01:39spots, but they are hollow. You see mainly the rings.
- 1:01:42This definitely came from her. She coughed it out.
- 1:01:45It kind of went out in different directions where that blood
- 1:01:49pattern disappears. I believe she was likely picked
- 1:01:52up and carried the rest of the way, perhaps with her face up,
- 1:01:56so there was no more blood deposited on that walkway.
- 1:02:00I find that very interesting. I want to find the right button.
- 1:02:05Here we go. These are the, the, this is the
- 1:02:12blood spatter that Mister Clementi is talking about now.
- 1:02:15He goes on and says Clementi was adamant the Guthrie's kidnapping
- 1:02:20only involved one person. Which is interesting to me
- 1:02:23because I think not, but I am a formerly fat, getting thinner
- 1:02:31nobody sitting in my office in western Pennsylvania.
- 1:02:34This is an FBI profiler, right? Clementi was adamant the
- 1:02:38Guthrie's kidnapping only involved one person.
- 1:02:40Why? He says there is no indication
- 1:02:43of multiple steps taken in or around the blood splatter
- 1:02:46evidence. Quote, if there were two people,
- 1:02:48you would think one of them would have control of her,
- 1:02:51complete control of her inside the house and brought her
- 1:02:53outside and would not have lost that control, he stated.
- 1:02:57But here she's clearly on the ground coughing this blood up.
- 1:03:02There's no evidence to me that there are more than one offender
- 1:03:05here. If there was three different
- 1:03:07shoe print patterns in the blood stains, that would tell me
- 1:03:10something. I don't see it.
- 1:03:11I'm not aware of that evidence. Asked about the suspect
- 1:03:16attacking a woman of Guthrie's age, Clementi thinks the
- 1:03:19individual clearly had a goal in mind to do whatever it takes.
- 1:03:23Here, it appears that that goal had to do with getting Nancy out
- 1:03:27of her home in the middle of the night, he acknowledged.
- 1:03:30I do believe this motivation was strong enough that he carried
- 1:03:32this out even despite the fact that at some point she did not
- 1:03:36actually cooperate. And you can read the rest of
- 1:03:39that article. Link is in the description
- 1:03:43below. And then the next headline I
- 1:03:46want to bring to you is from Deadline.
- 1:03:49This is written by Greg Evans. It came out today.
- 1:03:53I'm not going to read the whole thing.
- 1:03:55There is a link in the description below that you guys
- 1:03:57can read. The headline says Jake Reiner
- 1:04:02says his world collapsed with news of parents murders, which
- 1:04:06of course did. Jake Reiner, the 34 year old son
- 1:04:10of slain filmmaker, actor Rob Reiner and Michelle Reiner,
- 1:04:14recalled his parents in the horrific aftermath of their
- 1:04:17murders in an emotional Substack post on the afternoon of
- 1:04:23December 14th, Jake writes. I was in Union Station at a
- 1:04:27celebration of life for one of my best friends, Christian
- 1:04:31Anderson, who died in October. It was at that moment I received
- 1:04:34a call from my sister Romy telling me our father was dead.
- 1:04:38Minutes later she called back telling me our mother was also
- 1:04:41dead. The 45 minute lift ride from
- 1:04:45downtown to the West side was unendurable.
- 1:04:48My world as I knew it had collapsed.
- 1:04:50I was in a trance. The only thing I could focus on
- 1:04:53was that I needed to get to my childhood home.
- 1:04:56I needed to get to my sister. I needed to figure out what the
- 1:05:00hell just happened. Of course.
- 1:05:06Nick Reiner has pleaded not guilty.
- 1:05:07OK. Jake does not use Nick's name in
- 1:05:09the Substat column, which published Friday, referring Tim
- 1:05:13to him only as his brother. Quote.
- 1:05:16I was robbed of so many things that day, Jake writes.
- 1:05:18My parents won't be at my wedding.
- 1:05:21They won't get to hold their future grandchild.
- 1:05:23They won't get to see me have the successful career I'm still
- 1:05:26seeking. It simultaneously breaks my
- 1:05:28heart and enrages me. Nothing, he continues, can
- 1:05:32prepare you for what feels like to lose, for what it feels like
- 1:05:36to lose both parents instantly at the same time.
- 1:05:39It's too devastating to comprehend.
- 1:05:41I still wake up every morning having to convince myself that
- 1:05:44no, it's not a dream. This truly is my living
- 1:05:48nightmare. And I invite you to check out
- 1:05:52the link in the description. That will also take you to his
- 1:05:56sub stack article where you can check that out.
- 1:05:59Such A and that's why we do our best to temper our speculation
- 1:06:05with compassion and humanity because families are broken by
- 1:06:11the news that we follow. OK, last headline.
- 1:06:15It's a little bit of good news. Maybe not if you're a ferret
- 1:06:19lover. Maybe if you are a ferret level
- 1:06:23lover from the Good News Network.
- 1:06:25Eradication of invasive ferrets within N Ireland's largest
- 1:06:30seabird colony is a world first. I think that's Northern Ireland.
- 1:06:34Why would they? Why would why would they
- 1:06:37abbreviate it doesn't matter. OK, in a world first
- 1:06:41conservation achievement, Have you guys noticed how I am drawn
- 1:06:44to the conservation stuff? To the animal stuff?
- 1:06:46I love it. OK.
- 1:06:48In a world first conservation achievement, Northern Ireland
- 1:06:51has successfully eradicated an invasive population of ferrets
- 1:06:56on Rathlin Island, host of the Commonwealth nation's largest
- 1:07:00seabird colony. One of the most effective
- 1:07:03conservation strategies currently employed on a wide
- 1:07:06scale, invasive animal elimination has allowed hundreds
- 1:07:09of islands worldwide to recover their native wildlife
- 1:07:13populations. Typical invasive targets are
- 1:07:16rats or rabbits, but in the case of Ratlin, it's the first time
- 1:07:20anywhere in the world that a population of feral ferrets was
- 1:07:23eradicated from an island. They'd overtaken the life raft.
- 1:07:28Ratlin Acting for Tomorrow project, which was established
- 1:07:31in 2021 and led by the Northern Ireland Chapter of the UK's
- 1:07:35Royal Society for the Protection of Birds along the Local and
- 1:07:38government, along with local and government partners, aim to
- 1:07:41remove these predators and give the seabird population a chance
- 1:07:45to recover. And it's off the coast of blah
- 1:07:48blah blah blah blah blah blah, OK.
- 1:07:52The ferret eradication is the culmination of years of
- 1:07:55meticulous planning, cutting edge techniques such as thermal
- 1:07:58drones and less cutting edge but no less important methods like
- 1:08:02the detection dog named Woody, as well as unwavering support
- 1:08:05from the Rathlin community. Quote This is an extraordinary
- 1:08:09moment for Rathlin, for Northern Ireland and for conservation
- 1:08:12globally, said Joanne Sherwood, a director, in a statement.
- 1:08:16The successful world first eradication of ferrets means
- 1:08:20that puffins and other seabirds can now nest and raise their
- 1:08:23young more safely on raplin for the first time in generations.
- 1:08:26We are already seeing encouraging signs of recovery
- 1:08:29and we expect to see populations rebound in the coming years.
- 1:08:33It doesn't say what did they do? The eradication work was carried
- 1:08:40out using internationally proven techniques adapted to
- 1:08:43accommodate and embrace raplin's unique circumstances and
- 1:08:45setting. Why doesn't it say how?
- 1:08:52It doesn't say how, but it but that it was used using
- 1:08:58techniques that I guess everybody's cool with anyway.
- 1:09:03There's an island full of seabirds that are no longer
- 1:09:06haunted from an invasive species, and I think that's
- 1:09:09great. I think that is really, really
- 1:09:11good news. And those guys are ye headlines,
- 1:09:17push the button gap true crime headlines.
- 1:09:27OK, let me just finish out the day with a couple of your final
- 1:09:32comments before we go. Let's see, Shay or Shanna
- 1:09:42Shanada. I don't, I don't know, says this
- 1:09:48case really goes to show just how much social, social media
- 1:09:51plays a role in cases with younger people.
- 1:09:53This is something I think we'll see more of.
- 1:09:56I think you're probably right. Probably right.
- 1:10:02Lori, Why aren't we talking about the Predators family?
- 1:10:07You know, sometimes, sometimes these predators are
- 1:10:13Frankenstein's monster created by parents, sometimes sometimes
- 1:10:19not though. And I don't, I guess I'm not
- 1:10:22talking about them because I don't see any evidence that they
- 1:10:24created this monster. I will reserve the right to
- 1:10:28change my mind I guess. I guess.
- 1:10:31Great comment, Debbie says. Thanks, Gavin.
- 1:10:36Our fantastic mods and all the fishies in the deep blue sea.
- 1:10:39Yeah, thanks for staying classy, everybody, Robin says.
- 1:10:43I think it's Fermi's paradox. I think you're right.
- 1:10:45If there's other life in the universe, where is everyone?
- 1:10:48I think that is correct. Let's see if there are any more
- 1:10:54here, Mooney says. Question #3 Nope.
- 1:11:00Married twice. Neither time was for money.
- 1:11:04The second time worked out beautifully, though.
- 1:11:07And we are completely broke and happy.
- 1:11:09Well, good, good. Ohio Paw Mom says money does not
- 1:11:13buy happiness, but it's a lot easier to be happy when you're
- 1:11:15not so worried about having to pay the bills.
- 1:11:19Yeah, I mean, that has been my, that has been my experience,
- 1:11:23too. Charlotte says money doesn't buy
- 1:11:26happiness itself. However, it makes quelling any
- 1:11:29issue that may be troublesome so much easier to just handle.
- 1:11:33Indeed. Indeed.
- 1:11:37Debbie says Mr. Clementi's interview was interesting.
- 1:11:40Yes, indeed. And then Allison, thank you so
- 1:11:43much for the Super chat. She says thanks for all the
- 1:11:48great information and content. And then Allison also gave 5
- 1:11:54memberships. And Allison, thank you for doing
- 1:11:56that. You are awesome with that guys.
- 1:12:01Our our week is wrapped. My, my weekend is going to be
- 1:12:05filled with soccer and photography.
- 1:12:07So I'm excited about that. I have a line.
- 1:12:11I don't know that you guys care about this, but I am returning
- 1:12:15to the world of analog photography.
- 1:12:18It started with the purchase of this here Mamia RZ 67 medium
- 1:12:24format camera and it continued with well, thanks to people like
- 1:12:29Autumn and people like my dad I I have obtained a couple of 35mm
- 1:12:35cameras. Plus I have a whole I have a
- 1:12:37whole camera collection of 35mm mostly and medium format some 6
- 1:12:41by 6 stuff. But I've got a line on and
- 1:12:45enlarger A Bezler 23 CXL because I'm putting together a dark room
- 1:12:52and I'm hopefully I'm going to go pick that up and continue
- 1:12:59out, continue building this, this little hobby of mine back
- 1:13:03out. I, I can't tell you what a
- 1:13:06difference, what a change my life experienced when I
- 1:13:09discovered photography and, and I'm just so looking forward to
- 1:13:18the smell of the chemicals and the, the fun part of doing what
- 1:13:24we now do in Photoshop in a dark room.
- 1:13:26I'm, I'm really looking forward to that.
- 1:13:28Just, you know, at one time I was, I was pretty darn good
- 1:13:35clinician in the, in the lab. I, I was, I was good.
- 1:13:41And I'm looking forward to getting back into that.
- 1:13:43And I've been collecting gear to help me do that.
- 1:13:48And we'll be getting this this darkroom all finished up
- 1:13:52hopefully soon. So that's what my weekend's
- 1:13:55going to be. Hopefully your weekend is going
- 1:13:57to be awesome. Thank you, thank you, thank you,
- 1:14:00thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you for the Super chats
- 1:14:03tonight. I'm sure I'm going to get
- 1:14:05demonetized, but that made it way easier to swallow.
- 1:14:09Thanks for taking care of me, guys.
- 1:14:11Thanks to mods for Autumn and Mooney and Robin for for all the
- 1:14:18hard work. Thank you everybody for keeping
- 1:14:20it classy in the chat and thank you for those listening to the
- 1:14:24podcast or watching on Spotify. That really does help the
- 1:14:27channel. I do share the link to the
- 1:14:31Spotify video on the tank as soon as it is published, which
- 1:14:35we'll just be here in about 1/2 an hour.
- 1:14:38OK, with that, wishing you the most delightfulest of days.
- 1:14:43In the coming days, I bid you adieu and I will see you on the
- 1:14:48next one. Take care of yourself.
- 1:14:51Thank you very much for watching this video.
- 1:14:53If you liked what you saw, please consider subscribing.
- 1:14:57And if you have any questions or comments, please leave them
- 1:15:00below.