Latest / The CMO Podcast with Fexingo: Marketing Leadership, Budgets, and Executive Strategy / The Stubborn Dollar Cost of Customer Acquisition
Transcript
- Lucas: Alright, let's start with a number that should terrify every CMO listening. The median cost to acquire a customer in DTC—the simple, per-order CAC—has doubled since 2020. Not up twenty percent. Doubled. Luna: Okay, that's a big claim. Where are you seeing that data? Lucas: It's from a mid-2025 benchmarking report that pooled data from roughly four hundred DTC brands. The median blended CAC—across paid social, search, and affiliates—went from about twenty-two dollars in early 2020 to forty-four dollars by late 2025. That's nominal, not inflation-adjusted. Luna: And I'm guessing revenue per customer hasn't kept pace. Lucas: Not even close. Average order value grew maybe fifteen percent over that same window. So the unit economics have compressed badly. The old rule of thumb was that you wanted your LTV to be at least three times your CAC. A lot of brands that hit three-to-one in 2020 are now hovering around one-point-eight or one-point-nine. Luna: That's the danger zone. Below one-point-five and you're basically losing money on every new customer. And you can't always make it up on the back end. Lucas: Right. And that's exactly what happened with a specific brand I want to talk about today. A mid-market skincare line that, a few years ago, was a poster child for efficient DTC growth. Luna: Can you name it? Lucas: I can't—they shared this confidentially. But I can describe the numbers. They're in that sweet spot of doing about thirty million dollars in annual revenue. And their CAC went from eighteen dollars in 2021 to forty-seven dollars by early this year. Meanwhile, their average order value only crept from fifty-two to sixty-one dollars. Luna: So their ltv to cac ratio probably went from something like four-to-one down to about one-point-eight-to-one. Lucas: Exactly. And that's before you account for the cost of returns, fulfillment, and the free samples they throw in to hit those AOV numbers. Their gross margin after fulfillment is around sixty-two percent. So on a forty-seven-dollar CAC, they need roughly seventy-six dollars in gross profit per customer just to break even on acquisition. Luna: And their AOV is sixty-one. So they're underwater on the first purchase. They're praying that the second purchase comes fast. Lucas: And here's the thing—their repeat purchase rate within ninety days fell from thirty-four percent in 2021 to twenty-two percent. So that second purchase is less likely. The whole flywheel is grinding. Luna: I've heard a lot of CMOs blame Apple's privacy changes, and iOS attribution loss certainly didn't help. But doubling in four years suggests something deeper. Lucas: It's structural. There's more capital chasing the same consumer attention. Private equity and venture money poured into DTC for years, and that funded a bidding war on Meta and Google. The cost per thousand impressions on Meta is up about seventy percent since 2020. And the click-through rates haven't improved. So more money for fewer results. Luna: But the usual answer to rising CAC is: invest in brand. Build awareness so that your direct response campaigns become more efficient. Is that actually working for anyone? Lucas: It works—but on a longer timeline than most CMOs have. I've been looking at a bootstrapped outdoor gear company that took a completely different approach. They barely spent on performance marketing. Instead, they put their budget into a single, highly specific content play. Luna: What kind of content? Lucas: They created a series of hyper-detailed, narrated trail guides for obscure hiking routes in the Pacific Northwest. No product placement. Just genuinely useful information. Each guide took about six weeks to produce—mapping, photography, audio. They released one every two months. Luna: And that drove sales? Lucas: It drove organic search traffic that converted at nearly three times the rate of their paid ads. Their CAC from that content stream is around twelve dollars. And those customers have an LTV that's about forty percent higher than the paid-acquired ones. Luna: So the lesson is: spend less on targeting and more on making something people actually want to find. Lucas: That's the theory. But it only works if you have the patience not to scale fast. The outdoor brand grew revenue about twenty percent a year—steadily, not exponentially. Most boards and VCs want to see forty or fifty percent year-one growth. That puts you on the performance marketing treadmill. Luna: So we're back to the tension between efficiency and growth. You can have one or the other, but not both, unless you're very lucky. Lucas: Or unless you have a genuinely differentiated product. The skincare brand I mentioned—their products are good, but they're not meaningfully different from what you'd find at Sephora for a similar price. So their only lever is price promotion or more ad spend. Neither works long-term. Luna: That's why we're seeing a lot of DTC brands pivot to wholesale. They trade margin for volume and hope the retail shelf creates brand awareness that lowers their digital CAC. Lucas: But wholesale has its own math. The skincare brand tried a small Target test. Their wholesale revenue was decent, but the cost of trade promotions, slotting fees, and retailer chargebacks ate up most of the margin. Their net profit from that channel was negative for the first eight months. Luna: So there's no easy escape. What about the zero-party data push? Every marketing conference I've been to this year has a session on how collecting preference data directly from customers lowers CAC because you can target them without relying on third-party cookies. Lucas: It helps at the margin. The brands that do it well see a ten to fifteen percent improvement in their cost per acquisition on email and SMS campaigns. But the setup cost is real. You need a quiz or a preference center, and you need to maintain it. For a thirty-million-dollar brand, that might be a hundred and fifty thousand dollars a year in tech and personnel. Luna: And the CAC improvement only applies to the subset of customers who actually fill out the quiz. Usually less than twenty percent of new customers. Lucas: Right. So the overall impact on blended CAC is maybe three to five percent. Useful, but not a solution to doubling. Luna: I want to push back a little. You're saying CAC has doubled, but some categories have fared better. For example, high-consideration purchases—like mattresses or furniture—have actually seen their CAC stabilize because the ad platforms got better at reaching in-market buyers. Lucas: That's a fair point. The doubling is most acute in impulse and low-consideration categories: beauty, snacks, apparel. For high-ticket items, the CAC is high to begin with—fifty to a hundred dollars—but it hasn't doubled. It's gone up maybe thirty percent. Because the conversion rates on those products are actually improving as targeting gets smarter. Luna: So the real question for a CMO in 2026 isn't 'how do I lower my CAC?' It's 'what is the right CAC for my business model?' Lucas: Exactly. The skincare brand's problem wasn't that their CAC was forty-seven dollars. It was that their LTV was only eighty-five. If they could get LTV to a hundred and forty, that forty-seven-dollar CAC would be fine. So the focus shifts to retention, not just acquisition. Luna: But retention is hard to move quickly. Subscription models help, but not every product works as a subscription. The outdoor gear company's retention is high because their customers are genuinely loyal to the brand, not because they're locked into a monthly box. Lucas: That's the gold standard. And it's worth noting that the outdoor brand's marketing mix is almost entirely non-paid. They have a small retargeting budget, but the bulk of their traffic comes from that content. Their blended CAC is under fifteen dollars. They're profitable on the first purchase. Luna: They're also an outlier. Most CMOs can't get their CEO to sign off on a six-week content production cycle that might not pay off for a year. Lucas: No, but they can shift ten percent of their budget to test something similar. The skincare brand redirected about seven percent of their paid social budget into a series of ingredient-education articles and short videos. After nine months, that content channel was generating five percent of their new customers with a CAC of twenty-two dollars—half their blended average. Luna: So the math works if you give it enough time. But that requires a CMO who has the trust of the board and the CFO to wait. Lucas: And that trust is earned by showing the unit economics with brutal honesty. The best CMOs I've seen this year go into board meetings with a slide that shows their CAC trend, their LTV trend, and the payback period. They don't hide the deterioration. They present it as a problem they're solving. Luna: And they have a plan. Not a vague 'we'll build our brand' plan, but specific channel shifts and retention experiments with clear success metrics. Lucas: Right. The skincare brand's plan includes a loyalty program redesign, a referral incentive that's actually generous, and a content investment that targets the top ten percent of their repeat customers. They project that by the end of 2027, their blended CAC will be back to thirty-five dollars and their LTV will be a hundred and ten. Luna: That's a realistic target. And if they hit it, they'll be in a healthy place. Lucas: But it requires discipline. No chasing the hot new ad platform. No panic discounting. Just steady execution on a multi-year plan. That's hard when every quarter you're asked, 'Why didn't we grow faster?' Luna: I think that's the real challenge for CMOs today. The tools have changed, the costs have changed, but the board's expectations haven't always caught up. Lucas: So the job is partly education. Teaching the rest of the executive team that the old efficiency metrics don't apply. That a dollar spent on acquisition today might take eighteen months to pay back, but that's okay if the unit economics are sound. Luna: It's a different kind of marketing leadership. Less about the creative, more about the math and the narrative around it. Lucas: And that's where we'll leave it. Because the numbers are only going to get more attention as margins stay compressed. The CMOs who can tell that story clearly will keep their budgets. The ones who can't will keep explaining why their costs are up. Luna: And hoping the board doesn't ask the follow-up questions.