Latest / True Crime with Gavin Fish / New Polygraph Tests Done in Missing Lilly & Jack Sullivan Case. The Results Raise More Questions.
Transcript
- 0:01Lily and Jack Sullivan went missing on May 2nd of 2025 and
- 0:06you'd think in the modern era it wouldn't be possible for two
- 0:12kiddos to just drop off the edge of the earth.
- 0:15We have no idea where they went. There were all of like 2 pieces
- 0:20of evidence they left behind. We don't know if they wandered
- 0:24off, if they were taken by animals, if they were taken by
- 0:28strangers, if they were taken by family.
- 0:30We don't know what happened to them.
- 0:34But this week, thanks to some very, very good reporting up
- 0:39there in Canada, we've got some new information.
- 0:42And I know. This is a case where we're we've
- 0:44kind of lost track of it, right? We are.
- 0:48We've moved on to other important cases like Nancy
- 0:51Guthrie, like the trial of Cory Richins in the murder of her
- 0:55husband, Eric Richins. We're going to talk both in the
- 0:58headlines tonight. We're going to talk about both
- 0:59those cases, but it's still an important case.
- 1:02We still want to get to the bottom of this.
- 1:05Children just can't disappear in 2025.
- 1:09S Stick with me, we'll get into it.
- 1:24This video contains mature themes and discussions intended
- 1:27only for adult audiences. Viewer discretion is advised.
- 1:33Hello there, my friend. Welcome back to another true
- 1:35crime conversation with me, Gavin Fish.
- 1:38Thank you so much for being here.
- 1:39Thanks for checking in wherever you're checking in from.
- 1:42I deeply appreciate it. I deeply appreciate.
- 1:45It and Gavin. Hey Javi, can we have a take to
- 1:48goodness? I need to slow down.
- 1:51Maybe I'm just. Excited.
- 1:53Today's been a good day for me. Today has been a very, very good
- 1:56day for me first of all. Do you see this shirt that I'm
- 2:00wearing right here? If you're watching the video, if
- 2:02you're on the podcast, you're not seeing this, but it is AI
- 2:04don't even know what color it is.
- 2:06I'm I'm severely color blind, but a textured kind of a cable
- 2:09knit kind of a texture. This shirt my wife got for me
- 2:13last night at Marshalls and. It is a large and it fits
- 2:19beautifully. Back in August I was wearing A3
- 2:24XL. OK, so that's pretty great.
- 2:29And secondly, I got a phone call today from a friend that we have
- 2:32not talked in. Maybe a year.
- 2:36And it was just so good to hear from her.
- 2:39She is. She's somebody I deeply admire
- 2:42and love to chat with. I don't know why I hadn't
- 2:44reached out before. I'm glad she reached out to me.
- 2:46So it's been a good day and I hope it's been a good day where
- 2:49you are. Hey, wherever you're checking in
- 2:50from, tell me in the live stream or in the comments where you are
- 2:55coming from. And if you 2 are having a
- 3:00terrific day, tell us why. What happened in your life that
- 3:04made it so great? Did you fit into a shirt that
- 3:07you never thought you'd be into that size ever again?
- 3:09Guys, it's kind of baggy, I mean.
- 3:11I don't think I'll ever get into a medium.
- 3:13I mean, I'm 6 foot 2. I don't think, I don't think
- 3:16guys of my stature like fit into mediums.
- 3:21But man, it feels good. OK, Gavin, what are you doing?
- 3:25Javi, you really should keep me. You should keep me in check,
- 3:27buddy. Let's let's let's keep this on
- 3:32track guys. Lily and Jack Sullivan were two
- 3:37little kiddos out in Nova Scotia.
- 3:40Lily 6, Jack four. And they just up and disappeared
- 3:46from this house right here living with their mother, Malia
- 3:51Brooks Murray pictured here. And I, I would say I don't want
- 3:57to split hairs, but self-titled stepdad David Martel.
- 4:03I I stepped out whatever OK, you can tell by I guess the state of
- 4:11things. This is a maybe a poverty
- 4:15stricken family. They are out in the middle of
- 4:18Podunk Nowhere, Canada. I say that with a deep amount of
- 4:22love. I live in Podunk Nowhere,
- 4:24Pennsylvania, so they're out in the sticks and what the parents
- 4:31say is they heard the kids playing and then then they
- 4:34didn't and they went outside and just couldn't find them.
- 4:43Called emergency services who have done a herculean task of
- 4:50looking for these kids. I almost said, guys, these kids
- 4:55and we haven't seen them anywhere.
- 4:58Haven't seen them anywhere. Now, the last we heard, Mr.
- 5:02Martell, pictured here, had just been in court for an assault.
- 5:11I I think it was an essay. Right of an adult, not of a
- 5:15child and not. Of his his children or Malia
- 5:18Brooks Murray's children. But we're starting to see smoke,
- 5:24right? And is it true Where there's
- 5:26smoke, there's fire? Could be, could be.
- 5:30I was. I was kind of.
- 5:35Well, I try to remain neutral when it comes to my opinions on
- 5:40on the parents. I try to follow the facts as we
- 5:43are given them. And of course, we are not
- 5:45investigators. We are sideline citizen
- 5:48detectives. We don't know what's really
- 5:51going on, especially in Canada where they keep everything so
- 5:54close to the vest. Anyway, I tried to stay neutral
- 6:01about this, but in the beginning I was like.
- 6:04Why did the Why did the mother disappear from view, and why did
- 6:09Mr. Martel keep looking? And I was kind of taken in by
- 6:13the guy like, hey, wait a minute.
- 6:14This doesn't remind me of like a Scott Peterson.
- 6:17This doesn't remind me of a Chris Watts.
- 6:18This reminds me of somebody who's deeply concerned about
- 6:22his. Kids.
- 6:23And now I'm not so sure now that he's facing charges.
- 6:27Of the essay of an adult. Oh, that is hard to ignore.
- 6:34But the news that came out today from the CBC, written by Allie
- 6:42Thompson, who has done terrific work reporting on this case, is
- 6:47that a new round of polygraphs, a second round let's say, were
- 6:52conducted in the disappearance of Lily and Jack.
- 6:57And we've got an article published in the CBC.
- 7:00We're going to, I think we're probably going to read the whole
- 7:02thing. We got time for it.
- 7:04It's going to rehash some things, but it's been a while
- 7:06since we've covered the case and so it's probably appropriate
- 7:09that we do. So you know what?
- 7:11Before we do though, let's bring Lily and Jack back up.
- 7:14Let's see where you guys are checking in from.
- 7:18Let's see. Nicki, always happy from
- 7:22Bermuda, happy Bermudiful Wednesday.
- 7:25Gavin, I love your lullaby short.
- 7:27Yes. If you guys did not see, it's
- 7:30not a sponsor, it is a spoof. Should we do it?
- 7:34Should we do it? I think maybe.
- 7:37OK. All right.
- 7:39When you investigate crime, you learn something important.
- 7:43Every strand tells a story. Some stories fall apart under
- 7:48pressure. But great hair, Great hair holds
- 7:52up under questioning. That's why I trust Lullaby,
- 7:58because great hair never pleads the 5th Lalibi when the evidence
- 8:05is in your favor. Hashtag not sponsored.
- 8:16Miss Chivos Dragon says the shirt is periwinkle.
- 8:21Oh well, thank you very much. Emmy is checking in from San
- 8:24Jose. Cindy is from Ontario.
- 8:26We got Boise in the house, We got Missouri in the house, we
- 8:29got Wyoming. Northern California.
- 8:30Doylestown, PA also loves the shirt.
- 8:34Kansas City. Kimberly and I are planning a
- 8:38trip to Kansas City this summer. I'm looking forward to it.
- 8:40Texas is in the house. Boston's in the house.
- 8:43Austin, TX. Sudbury is here.
- 8:46Rose City, Portland is here. Who else we got?
- 8:49Redding, CA Wow, there we go. Redding, CA Thank you very much.
- 8:55And Karen Hawley says your wife has great taste.
- 8:59Very nice looking shirt. Congratulations on the weight
- 9:01loss. I am.
- 9:03I'm feeling good today, guys. Like I have to say, I'm in the
- 9:06last 10 weeks of the loss. If I follow the schedule, I'm in
- 9:11the last 10 weeks of the weight loss.
- 9:13Part of my journey, I continue to be able to lift more weight
- 9:18and do more reps I'm I'm getting stronger and stronger.
- 9:22Yeah. But I'm really looking forward
- 9:24to this phase of it being over. And just continuing on with what
- 9:31will be Phase 2 of maintaining a healthy lifestyle.
- 9:34But thank you all for coming along this journey with me and
- 9:39giving me so much encouragement. Ontario's in the house,
- 9:42Michigan's in the house, jerseys in the house.
- 9:43Thank you very much for being here.
- 9:45Okie, Dokie, come with me, if you will, over to this article
- 9:50by Ali Thompson at. Cbc.ca second round of
- 9:55polygraphs conducted in disappearance of Nova Scotia
- 9:58children Nova Scotia Royal Canadian Mounted Police have
- 10:03conducted a second round of polygraph examinations in the
- 10:06disappearance of Jack and Lily Sullivan, with two of those
- 10:10tests focused on one of the only pieces of physical evidence in
- 10:15the case, a light. Pink blanket found hanging in
- 10:18the tree and you can see that in this photo.
- 10:21Let's see if I can. That's about as big as I can get
- 10:24right? But OK.
- 10:27Lily, 6, and Jack, then four, were reported missing on the
- 10:32morning of May 2nd, 2025 from Lansdowne, Nova Scotia, a spar
- 10:37sparsely populated area about 140 kilometers northeast of
- 10:42Halifax. Their disappearance sparked a
- 10:45massive grid search in the of the thick woods surrounding
- 10:50their home, where they lived with their mother, Malia Brooks
- 10:53Murray, stepfather. I'm sorry, Daniel Martel.
- 10:57I think I said David Martel. Sorry about that guys and their
- 11:01younger sister. A piece of Lily's blanket found
- 11:05on the first day of the search tangled in a tree's twigs, has
- 11:10been the subject of much speculation fueled by a lack of
- 11:14answers in the case. I have noticed and maybe I'm
- 11:19just. Maybe I'm tuning into this more.
- 11:24And how do I want to say this without sounding like a total
- 11:28dill hole, total jerk? There is a segment of the true
- 11:34crime aficionado community that is really not doing anybody any.
- 11:42Favors with their speculations and accusations.
- 11:49I I'm trying really hard not to be that guy.
- 11:52I don't want to be that guy, right?
- 11:54I want to. I want to keep.
- 11:56I want to. Keep right down the middle.
- 11:58And I want to be I, I want to temper everything that we do
- 12:01with humanity and with compassion.
- 12:03As was so beautifully stated by the Reiner children.
- 12:07We we don't want to be those people, especially in light of
- 12:10the comments that we heard from Monique Tepi's.
- 12:16I think brother-in-law about how one person's speculation turns
- 12:21into another person's fact, right?
- 12:23So we do not want to be those people that are just trading in
- 12:31rampant speculation though I mean it.
- 12:34Is. Natural to to question things,
- 12:38right? Family members on all sides have
- 12:42suggested online and in media interviews that it was planted.
- 12:47Haley Ferdinand Brooks, Murray's step sister, was one of the
- 12:50people who came upon the piece of tattered blanket off
- 12:53Lansdowne Station Road, a kilometer from the children's
- 12:56home, as they scoured for Jack and Lily alongside dozens of
- 13:00search and rescue members. Quote, we went down one side of
- 13:05the road and came back up the other, said Ferdinand, adding
- 13:09that Brooks Murray's half brother, Hayden Murray Smith,
- 13:13was with her at the time. We came back up the other side
- 13:18and all of a sudden there was this pink thing in the tree.
- 13:21Here is Haley Ferdinand, pictured here, the step sister
- 13:27of Malia. Ferdinand said it was
- 13:30intertwined in branches roughly a meter off the ground.
- 13:34She described its position as odd.
- 13:36Let's look at this picture again.
- 13:38Right? Yeah, It it does seem rather
- 13:40placed there rather than have fallen in there, especially if
- 13:44these little kiddos are only about a meter tall themselves.
- 13:47Right? They're little ones.
- 13:50OK, let's see. Quote.
- 13:54Emotions were very high that day already.
- 13:57And sure enough, we sent the picture to Malia and she Ided it
- 14:01as being Lily's, said Ferdinand in a recent interview at her
- 14:05home outside Truro, NS. It was just very emotional to
- 14:09see, she said. Ferdinand said she was asked 4
- 14:14questions during a polygraph examination on February 20th.
- 14:17So we're just three weeks ago. Not even right We're 19 days
- 14:24ago. Did you plant the blanket in the
- 14:28tree? Did you place the blanket in the
- 14:31tree? Did you put the blanket in the
- 14:33tree? Did you leave the blanket in the
- 14:36tree? She said she responded no to
- 14:39each question and at the end she was told she passed the
- 14:42examination. I want to pause here and chat
- 14:45about this just a little bit. The only person who truly knows
- 14:51whether somebody, quote UN quote, passed a polygraph
- 14:56examination would be the polygraph examiner right now.
- 15:03I I mean, do police lie to suspects and to interviewees and
- 15:11to persons of interest? Yes, they do all the time.
- 15:15We don't know if she did pass the examination.
- 15:19What we know is that she said, they said she passed the
- 15:23examination and that, I mean, that's, that's a distinction
- 15:26with a huge difference, right? So maybe, maybe the RCMP is
- 15:32holding it close to their polite and red and white vest.
- 15:37I don't know, maybe they are, maybe they aren't.
- 15:42Hayden Murray Smith confirmed to CBC News that he was asked the
- 15:46same 4 questions during a polygraph examination on
- 15:50February 19th. He said he responded.
- 15:52No to each. Question and was told by the
- 15:55examiner at the end that he passed.
- 15:59There's another picture of Jack and Lily I actually haven't seen
- 16:02before. How adorable is that?
- 16:05Oh my goodness, this is what is so heartbreaking about this
- 16:08case, man. Let's just zoom up on it real
- 16:11quick. Look at those little, beautiful
- 16:15little creatures that we don't know.
- 16:17What happened to them? Where are they?
- 16:20Where could they be? It's.
- 16:24Just heartbreaking. RCMP declined a request for an
- 16:29interview but confirmed in an e-mail that more polygraph
- 16:32examinations have taken place as part of an extension extensive
- 16:37investigation being led by Major Crimes.
- 16:41The Mounties also confirmed the blanket, one of two pieces of
- 16:45physical evidence in the case that the public is aware of, is
- 16:50still at the RCMP lab for forensic examination.
- 16:55What kind of forensics could be left on that blanket?
- 17:00I mean, certainly there would be DNA from Lily, right?
- 17:05There'd be touch DNA, some kind of there would be.
- 17:09I mean, if it was out in the out in the wilderness, I don't know.
- 17:12It was in May up in Nova Scotia, still technically the spring.
- 17:21Yeah, probably cool. I mean, I think DNA probably
- 17:24would survive there. But even if it had DNA of like
- 17:27Mr. Martel, then I mean, all that proves is that it's been in
- 17:33the house, right? So what kind of forensics are we
- 17:37looking? I think the most powerful thing
- 17:39would be is if there was some sort of forensic evidence that
- 17:43did not belong to Malia Brooks Murray, to Daniel Martel, to
- 17:47Jack, or to Lily Sullivan or to Daniel's mom, can't remember her
- 17:54name right now. There's so many names in this
- 17:56and they all have different last names.
- 17:57It's just, it's just hard. The second piece is a boot print
- 18:02consistent with Lily's foot size, found on the pipeline
- 18:05trail near the family home in Canada.
- 18:09Polygraph tests are used. Uh oh, uh oh, guys, I've got to
- 18:13yawn. OK?
- 18:21Yeah, we're clear. We're clear.
- 18:24Man, I hate that. I'm not tired.
- 18:26I'm not tired at all. But sometimes I just, I need to
- 18:29breathe more deeply, get more air in me, get more oxygen.
- 18:36OK? In Canada, polygraph tests are
- 18:38used as an investigative tool and are not admissible in court.
- 18:43Michelle Genus maybe Jeanie, I don't know how to pronounce that
- 18:48name. An associate professor in the
- 18:51criminal Justice Department at the University of Louisiana at
- 18:53Lafayette said police conduct polygraphs to help shape
- 18:57interviews, narrow down suspect pools and to guide who they
- 19:01should be speaking with as part of an investigation.
- 19:04Polygraphs are powerful. Speaking of Chris Watts, right?
- 19:08You can actually go on on my channel, you, you can search and
- 19:11see the polygraph examination of Chris Watts.
- 19:14What an idiot, man. First of all, what are you doing
- 19:18now? I'm glad he did.
- 19:20Don't get me wrong, I'm glad he did.
- 19:21What are you doing? Submitting yourself to an
- 19:23interview, to a polygraph examination, and then when they
- 19:27tell you you failed, you immediately cave?
- 19:30I mean, I'm glad that I'm glad that Chris Watts and other
- 19:34criminals like him are stupid, but it does show the power of
- 19:41the polygraph, right? Because I could be strapped into
- 19:45a polygraph machine next to an examiner with the little dials
- 19:49going back and forth, the laptop and the whole shebang, and I
- 19:53would have no clue, no clue whether I quote UN quote passed
- 19:58or not. But it is it is a powerful
- 20:02psychological tool, right? Definitely.
- 20:07Okie, Dokie. So they can police conduct
- 20:10polygraphs to help shape interviews, narrow down suspect
- 20:13pools and to guide who they think who they think, narrow
- 20:23down suspect pools and to guide who they should be speaking with
- 20:26as part of an investigation. And this is Michelle right here.
- 20:32I'm just going to say genus I, I'm sorry if I'm butchering your
- 20:35name, whose areas of expertise include best practices for
- 20:39recovering missing persons, Said she feels the fact that police
- 20:43are conducting a second round of polygraphs signals that RCMP
- 20:47have exhausted all immediate leads.
- 20:51Dang it, that is disappointing. Can't take it as gospel.
- 20:55This is her opinion, her educated opinion.
- 21:00Here we go. Quote The best thing to do when
- 21:02you have a long term missing persons case would be to go back
- 21:06from the beginning and start over with fresh eyes and look
- 21:15for anything they might have missed before.
- 21:17You know, what's happening is now I'm thinking about yawning
- 21:20and it's coming on. Gavin, you are a professional.
- 21:23You should be. Maybe you're more of an amateur,
- 21:26but I don't know. I don't know.
- 21:29I don't know. Javi, is there anything you can
- 21:31think of? Wanda, is there anything that
- 21:33you can think of? No.
- 21:35Playing sleepy music is going to make me sleepier.
- 21:38Wanda, it's OK, It's OK, OK. The best thing to do when you
- 21:45have a long term missing persons case would be to go back from
- 21:49the beginning and start over with fresh eyes and look for
- 21:52anything that they might have missed before, said Genus, who
- 21:56has been following the case closely.
- 21:59It is absolutely concerning that the investigation has gone on
- 22:03for this long and we still have no recovery.
- 22:06All missing persons cases are usually resolved very quickly,
- 22:10so this in and of itself is very abnormal and concerning, she
- 22:14said. Details about the blankets
- 22:17discovery are laid out in search warrant applications sought by
- 22:20RCMP early on in the investigation.
- 22:23And you know what I think I have I think I have some of those.
- 22:29Let me just take a look. You guys hummed to yourselves
- 22:32for a moment while I just browse over here to my case file.
- 22:37I, I know that I have a few things ullivan, Lily, and Jack
- 22:42documents. Let's see OK, record access
- 22:52order. I want to see if.
- 22:57I might be able to share any of this with you.
- 22:59Let me let me do a search for blanket inside this documents
- 23:05folder. No, I guess I don't have those
- 23:11those search warrants, OK, the document The document said the
- 23:16blanket was discovered around 4:00 PM Atlantic time on May
- 23:202nd, 2025. And police.
- 23:22Dogs were brought to the location, but no.
- 23:24Scent was picked up two days later.
- 23:31Another piece of the same blanket was seized from inside a
- 23:34trash bag at the end of the driveway at the children's home,
- 23:37said the documents, which lay out an officer's summary of the
- 23:40investigation. To that point, why would they
- 23:43throw? Wait a minute, Why would they
- 23:46throw away? Guys, think about this.
- 23:50You have a missing child. I would hold on to absolutely
- 23:56everything that that child ever touched, looked at, walked near,
- 24:03or expressed interest in at all. I maybe I'm just super
- 24:07sentimental, which I am, but I wouldn't throw away a piece of
- 24:14of a blanket of the of that same blanket.
- 24:17I wouldn't throw away anything. It belonged to my child.
- 24:21What is that an indicator? Tell me in the comments.
- 24:24Tell me in the comments what you think.
- 24:26Put GF in it. Don't forget, put GF in it and
- 24:30start it with like, blankets. So I know what you're talking
- 24:32about. There's a delay between when you
- 24:35hear me talk and I see your comments.
- 24:38But yeah, tell me what you think.
- 24:40Why would they throw away a piece of that blanket?
- 24:43I wouldn't throw away anything. Nothing.
- 24:47But OK. So here's Mr. Martel.
- 24:53Martel had been using the blanket to stop a draft from a
- 24:56door, it said. About a week before the
- 24:59disappearance, Brooks Murray took it from the door because
- 25:02the weather was getting nicer and she threw it in the garbage.
- 25:07There was already a piece missing from it when she did
- 25:09that because Daniel ripped it off when he put it up, the
- 25:13document said, summarizing Brooks Murray's statement to
- 25:15police. That's suspicious, man.
- 25:21That is so suspicious. Oh, I don't know, maybe I've
- 25:27been living in a hole. I, I forgot this little piece of
- 25:30information. Martel told CBC News in a
- 25:34January interview that he had voluntarily provided ADNA sample
- 25:38to investigators the month prior.
- 25:40He said it was his understanding that his DNA was taken in
- 25:43connection with the blanket, but RCMP have not confirmed that.
- 25:48According to the court documents, a number of people
- 25:51underwent polygraphs in the weeks and months immediately
- 25:54following the disappearance, including Martel and Brooks.
- 25:56Murray Ferdinand and Murray Smith were not polygraph during
- 26:00the first round of tests. Martel previously told CBC News
- 26:06that all the questions he was asked during his first polygraph
- 26:09were presumptive that the children were no longer alive.
- 26:12Such as, did you kill Lily and Jack Markell?
- 26:17Martell set take two Javi, we're going to edit this out in post.
- 26:23Martell did not respond to a request for comment from CBC
- 26:27News on the second round of polygraphs.
- 26:30Brooks Murray confirmed to CBC News that she has undergone a
- 26:34second polygraph examination and that she was told she passed.
- 26:38Again, we don't know that she passed.
- 26:41We just know that she said that she was told that she passed.
- 26:44It's very important that we remember these things.
- 26:46She would not elaborate on the questions she was asked.
- 26:51During an interview in January, RCMP Staff Sergeant Rob Mccammon
- 26:55said there were, quote, Oh my goodness, quote, a number of
- 27:04different areas investigators were following up on in
- 27:07connection with the blanket. Quote, we'll make decisions on
- 27:11that once we have all that we need, but right now we're not in
- 27:15a position to really comment on that.
- 27:17For Ferdinand, that was a quote from Sergeant Mccammon.
- 27:21For Ferdinand, her polygraph was simply another box to tick.
- 27:27I knew that I went into the test being.
- 27:29Truthful and I knew my result was going to be truthful, so it
- 27:33was really just another normal day.
- 27:35Another task to complete in the pursuit of finding out what
- 27:38happened to them, said Ferdinand, becoming emotional at
- 27:41times. Good for her.
- 27:43It hurts the longer time goes. We just want answers and we want
- 27:47Lily and Jack home. And that is what we have learned
- 27:53in this latest latest bit of information and the
- 28:00investigation into the disappearance of Lily and Jack
- 28:02Sullivan. Now let me see what you guys are
- 28:05saying on the old live chat hidden in the shadows, harkening
- 28:12back to my comment. About Kansas City, says Gavin.
- 28:16If you come to Kansas City, World Cup will be here this
- 28:19summer. It's going to be crazy.
- 28:24I don't think that we're going to go check out any, any World
- 28:26Cup. I'm going to see friends.
- 28:30Kimberly and I are visiting an old friend.
- 28:32As you guys know, I'm a sentimental guy and I'm going
- 28:34through a bit of a post midlife crisis, getting very close to
- 28:38finding the car that I'm going to buy for this post midlife
- 28:41crisis. By the way.
- 28:42And what is most important to me in my life, second only to my
- 28:47family, are my friends and especially at the long term ones
- 28:51and especially the ones that I haven't seen in a long time.
- 28:54So Kimberly are Kimberly and I are going to visit a friend and
- 29:01her spouse and then I've got another friend that is coming
- 29:05into town. We all grew up together.
- 29:06We've known each other since we were about 8 years old.
- 29:09So 8-9 I think. I think she came in in the year
- 29:12after we did so. So I'm really looking forward
- 29:16to, I don't think we're going to catch any soccer while we're
- 29:19there. Oh I still don't know the dog
- 29:24would blossom trees cause the Dogwood is a tree and a flower I
- 29:30can't remember. Gary PA is in the house joining
- 29:33from Fukuoka, Japan. Thank you for being here.
- 29:36I am making you young fourth opinion and I'm so sorry.
- 29:40I am so sorry Autumn Doyle Gavin Blankets.
- 29:45I would keep everything. You never know if they will come
- 29:48back and need that for something.
- 29:51Yeah, well, I would. Keep everything just for just
- 29:55for the sentimental value of it. If if my children went missing
- 30:02and I didn't know what happened to them now.
- 30:06Now I would behave differently, I think.
- 30:09Again, just putting on the devil's advocate hat here.
- 30:13If I were responsible for their disappearance or their death.
- 30:20Or their abuse perhaps then maybe I wouldn't want a reminder
- 30:26of them in my life and I would get rid of everything that I
- 30:29could of theirs. But being a person that doesn't
- 30:32do that and being a person who is super sentimental, Oh my
- 30:38goodness, I, I would keep, I would hold on to everything.
- 30:43I would sleep with it. I would hold on to it.
- 30:46And I think that is a normal, I think that would be a normal
- 30:52response. Autumn says Gavin, I get holding
- 30:57on to items, but at the same time, I think it would make it
- 31:00much harder to grieve and move on.
- 31:02See, but I think that's the thing Autumn is I don't think
- 31:06it's possible to move on. I just just the same way that I
- 31:11don't think it's possible to really have justice ever.
- 31:17I I That's not to say that the. The idea of justice and the
- 31:22seeking of justice isn't a noble thing and we should do it.
- 31:25I I just don't think that we can have justice for a lot of crimes
- 31:29in in this life. I think that for example, how do
- 31:35you how do you make? Restitution for murder or for SA
- 31:38or for other abuse, How do you do that?
- 31:40You can't, right? In that same way, I just don't
- 31:45think there's moving on from losing children.
- 31:48I just don't. But I mean, that's just, that's
- 31:52just me quibbling. What am I guys?
- 31:55What am I? Professional quibbler here.
- 32:06That's exactly what I am. Let's see, Arctic Cat says I
- 32:13have 12 blessings and I keep everything hoping and praying
- 32:17that they'll be found and returned safely and should come
- 32:20back home to do something familiar.
- 32:23It's beautiful. Me too.
- 32:25Me too. Just Ducky.
- 32:27I kept all my son's baby blankets and then gave them to
- 32:29him when he had his son. Well, that is beautiful.
- 32:33I love it. The children have not been
- 32:37found, says Nancy. Why would anyone think about
- 32:40moving on? I.
- 32:41I honestly think they would only be thinking about moving on
- 32:44respectfully to Autumn's comment.
- 32:45Like I think it was a thought provoking comment.
- 32:48And have good comment. I think the only people thinking
- 32:52about moving on would be the the kind of people that that might
- 32:59be guilty of being the. The perpetrators of the crime
- 33:06and Autumn, you're right. Yeah, it's it, that is not how
- 33:09you meant it. I know, I know you personally
- 33:11and I and I get it. I I'm just being a quibbler,
- 33:13right? That's what I do.
- 33:15It's what I do. Yeah.
- 33:19I mean, that's, that's what we have on the case right now.
- 33:24Got more polygraph tests. We they're asking about the
- 33:28blankie. They're saying that they have it
- 33:32in their possession for forensics, you know, examination
- 33:36and. That's it.
- 33:40This is a tough case, man. This is a tough, tough case,
- 33:43'cause there's just again, how in 2025 or later, I know we're
- 33:51in 2026 now, does or or do children or does a child just
- 34:00disappear even in the middle of nowheresville, Nova Scotia?
- 34:05How does it happen? It's just.
- 34:07It's just. Hard to fathom.
- 34:11Jennifer, chiming in, says I wouldn't be able to let go of
- 34:15anything associated with my missing kids.
- 34:17I'm also a sentimental sort. In fact, I have my daughter's
- 34:20baby blankets and special outfits from over 27 years ago.
- 34:23Yeah, us too. One of the cool.
- 34:25Things about this house that we bought is we have we we have a
- 34:31cedar closet. It's.
- 34:34The its only. Purpose is to have a place to
- 34:37store clothes out of season. And it has been perfect because
- 34:43all of our special clothes, like the the little outfits they were
- 34:48blessed in when they were babies, their first blankets,
- 34:50their, you know, their, their special little Halloween
- 34:55costumes and stuff like that can all be kept safe.
- 34:57And, and I go in there sometimes just to see them and just to
- 35:00feel them because, because I love them so much.
- 35:03My wife's wedding dress I think is in there and things like
- 35:06that. So anyway, yeah, Jules and me
- 35:10wasn't the other half of the blanket in the trash.
- 35:12Yeah, I was. They they they put it out in the
- 35:14trash. Oh, Susie Q, I'm so sorry to
- 35:19hear this. My family lost a 2 year old
- 35:21drowned in a koi pond. Grief lasts.
- 35:24Yeah. Doesn't go away ever.
- 35:26I mean, I was just back in California, what, a week ago,
- 35:30two weeks ago, something like that, and met up with friends of
- 35:36my, I'm sorry, the parents of my friend who passed away when we
- 35:40were teenagers and and I was just his friend.
- 35:44I wasn't his parents, right? And it's been 36 years and I
- 35:50still grieve it. So yeah, it's doesn't make sense
- 35:56they would throw that away. To me, that is telling that
- 36:00there's some emotional disconnection happening, and I
- 36:06can't imagine that that emotional disconnection would
- 36:09happen without some sort of guilt.
- 36:12Connected to it. And here I am.
- 36:14I mean, this is speculation. This is rather sensationalism
- 36:18too. Don't take this as gospel, guys.
- 36:21This is just, this is just me thinking out loud, right?
- 36:24This is not a theory. It's just, it's just suspicious
- 36:27to me. Super, super, super suspicious.
- 36:31But I mean, that's what all we've got on the case.
- 36:34We will continue to keep our eye on it.
- 36:37Boy, man, the time pass so fast. Let's hop into three questions,
- 36:40shall we? OK.
- 36:49In this segment I answer 3 questions that you sent to me.
- 36:55I got to say, I'm down to like my last half a dozen questions
- 36:58that are in the queue. So sending those questions, any
- 37:03question will do as long as long as you.
- 37:05Ask it right my you just sent it.
- 37:08Three questions at gavinfish.com.
- 37:10Three questions at gavinfish.com.
- 37:11It is spelled out. THREE questions at
- 37:14gavinfish.com. Please do me a favor, make your
- 37:19question maybe a sentence or a phrase, not like 3 or 4
- 37:23paragraphs long. Let's let's make him, let's make
- 37:30him pithy, shall we? Let's make him brief to the
- 37:32point. But I promise that I will answer
- 37:36each one of your questions to the best of my ability.
- 37:39If I ever have a guest on during a three question segment that
- 37:42they apply to, I will definitely ask my guest too.
- 37:48But. I get to choose the order in
- 37:50which I answer them that. That's that's the deal.
- 37:53That is the deal. Question number one, there was
- 37:57no context from Colleen about this question.
- 38:00It just asked. Are you aware of the YouTube
- 38:03John Lardon at Lardon Arts? Colleen yes, I am John Lardon.
- 38:10I became acquainted with through the Elisa Lamb case.
- 38:14Man, talk about a roller coaster of a case.
- 38:17And also talk about maybe a a case study and how not to be.
- 38:24I'm not saying John, just saying a case study and how not to
- 38:28behave as members of the. Public as members of the true
- 38:32crime community. Man, there was so much rampant
- 38:35speculation and it turns out that she had fallen into the
- 38:39water tower. Oh my goodness.
- 38:41But yeah, I saw John first on. The documentary series on the
- 38:47Elisa Lamb case, can't remember the name of that.
- 38:49If you guys remember, tell me, tell me the name of that.
- 38:52It's really good. And I, I actually chatted with
- 38:57him back, not not on the phone or anything.
- 38:59We texted back and forth a couple times.
- 39:01Seems like a real great guy. And he's got a good YouTube
- 39:05channel. He's going strong.
- 39:08Yeah. If you guys I I would suggest
- 39:10subscribing to John Lord for sure.
- 39:13Question number two, favorite painter from Rua asking me who
- 39:18is my favorite painter. Now I am assuming by painter you
- 39:22mean artist, not somebody who paints.
- 39:26Houses or is a professional, you know, applier of of color to
- 39:32walls and such. Rua, I am quite a fan of the
- 39:37Impressionists. Now I also am not a billionaire.
- 39:46Therefore man, something just happened to my headphones.
- 39:50What just happened to my headphones?
- 39:51There we go there we go hearing better.
- 39:53Now I am not a wealthy person and therefore I don't own any of
- 40:01the artwork that I am a huge fan of, but I do love the
- 40:06impressionists. I love Renoir.
- 40:08I love Bizarro, I love Van Gogh. I love.
- 40:11Serrat. I love Serrat.
- 40:12In fact, everybody knows maybe what would be his masterpiece
- 40:19right Sunday on the island of Lajat, or LaGrange yacht, which
- 40:26hangs in the Museum of Art in Chicago.
- 40:29It's beautiful. It is the beginning of the
- 40:32pointless movement. It is so great.
- 40:38Anyway, the first time I went to Paris on business, you guys know
- 40:42that I traveled extensively, but often times I just didn't have a
- 40:45lot of time when I was in a particular place.
- 40:48I was working, right? So rather than go to the Louvre
- 40:54or to the Eiffel Tower or something like that, I just went
- 40:59to Lajat, which is an island in just an island in the river.
- 41:06What is the name of the river? It's an island in the Seine.
- 41:08And I just walked around and I thought Sarat spent time on this
- 41:15island, you know, painting. People as they.
- 41:19Came and went and that's how big of a nerd I am about
- 41:24impressionism. I like Degas.
- 41:27So, yeah, the, the 19th century impressionists are my favorite.
- 41:30When I was back in California for, you know, for business and
- 41:36visiting family, I actually a, a modern impressionist who I
- 41:43really love by the name of Gary Simonton was selling some work
- 41:48and I, I had considered buying some prints of his.
- 41:53And I, I mean, I actually know Gary and had gone to all sorts
- 41:59of, of exhibitions that he did in Sacramento and the Foothill
- 42:05areas of, of Northern California.
- 42:09And I even was with him once when he was doing some
- 42:11photography, some trains that he eventually did into a, into a
- 42:15series. But I love, love, love his work.
- 42:19And, and I purchased a couple pieces.
- 42:22I ended up with three pieces and all in the impressionist.
- 42:26Well, no, two in the Impressionist style and one in
- 42:30the Cubist style that he did in College in the 70s.
- 42:33And so I bought those three paintings.
- 42:35Well, yeah, I got those three paintings and they haven't
- 42:40arrived back in California yet. They were all very large and
- 42:45needed shipping. So I, I got something a little
- 42:50more contemporary, but still in that Impressionist style.
- 42:54I just, well, two of them in the Impressionist style.
- 42:57I haven't really been a fan of Cubism.
- 43:01I'm really not a fan, you know, like classically Speaking of oh,
- 43:08Picasso and stuff like that, right?
- 43:10But because it was. Painted by Gary and because my,
- 43:13my wife really loved the painting, we bought that piece
- 43:17that he did back in the 70s and I'm, I'm really excited to have
- 43:21it here and hang it in the house.
- 43:23Thanks for the question, guys. Tell me what your favorite kind
- 43:26of art style is. Doesn't have to be painting.
- 43:27I'd love to hear it. I also really love black and
- 43:31white photography. I'm actually going to reach out
- 43:35to an artist that I really admire.
- 43:39Also Northern Californian, also a living artist to see about
- 43:43purchasing some of his work for the house.
- 43:45I'm, I'm, yeah, I, I, I love black and white photography.
- 43:51OK, Kelly asks. What makes you delve deeper or
- 43:56revisit a case? Or is it just what's relevant or
- 43:59something deeper? So for the channel, I try to
- 44:04talk about whatever is happening in the current zeitgeist because
- 44:09that's how, I mean, that's how you stay relevant and that's
- 44:13how. You get views and honestly, this
- 44:17is a job for me that I get paid for and I want to, I want to
- 44:21present information on cases that people care about.
- 44:26So that's one thing. But then there is a deeper
- 44:29level, right, of cases that I really are at the top of my list
- 44:35in order of importance, right? Some of those cases have been
- 44:40Amanda Winkowski. And if you go over to my
- 44:43website, let me bring that up for you guys.
- 44:45Go over to my website. This is the Support me page, all
- 44:49the different ways that you can support me financially.
- 44:51And thank you, thank you, thank you to all of you, to my
- 44:52patrons, to my members. Speaking of which, Speaking of
- 44:57which, Autumn remind me reminded me that I have the ability.
- 45:05To gift memberships. And here's the button.
- 45:11Let's see if it works. There we are.
- 45:14There we are. Yeah.
- 45:17OK, going to do that. OK, so.
- 45:20But thank you to my members, to my patrons, to those of you who
- 45:25send me tips and Paypal's and all that stuff, thank you so
- 45:29much. But if you also if you go to
- 45:31cases. You will find a list of cases
- 45:35that I have compiled pretty deep files on.
- 45:39Amanda Winkowski is an important one to me.
- 45:44She is one who was murdered in December of 2008.
- 45:51Her frozen solid body was found in January of 2009.
- 45:57And this is a big case file, guys.
- 46:00Go check it out. Big, big, big, big, big case
- 46:02file. Another one that obviously I'm
- 46:06very invested in. I mean, the Ellen Greenberg
- 46:09family is a family who I deeply love.
- 46:13And there is a deep case file including, I mean, all sorts of
- 46:18stuff on the Ellen Greenberg case.
- 46:21Another one that I am well actually Father Joe, Father Joe
- 46:25Marino is a case that I am very invested in.
- 46:29This is another one where authorities say that he did it
- 46:34to himself. I am.
- 46:35I do not believe that. I believe that he was murdered.
- 46:40David Elmquist is one that is very important to me.
- 46:43Where's David? I just passed him.
- 46:45Just saw him right there. David Elmquist.
- 46:47So there these cases all have something in common and that is
- 46:51that the investigating agencies or the prosecuting agencies all
- 46:57say they this was an accident or this was self-inflicted.
- 47:03And I say on these ones now I've seen some that have come to me.
- 47:07That is that where people said my son, my brother, whomever
- 47:10didn't do this to themselves. And I've had to say, I've had to
- 47:15look at the evidence and say I'm, I'm leaning toward they
- 47:19did. But these case, another one is
- 47:22Sarah, where is Sarah? Sarah Easton, right here, right?
- 47:28Friend of my sister's who her husband says that she did it to
- 47:33herself with his service revolver.
- 47:35He was the chief of police. I say I do not believe that for
- 47:39one second, not for one second, having looked at the evidence.
- 47:44So getting back to the question at hand, what makes me dig
- 47:48deeper into cases? Well, if there is obvious, what
- 47:55is the word that I'm looking for?
- 47:56If there hold on, I will look up this word.
- 48:03I blank sometimes obvious corruption.
- 48:06If there's obvious corruption, I I am pulled into those cases.
- 48:13If there is an injustice, I am, I am pulled into the cases.
- 48:18If there is acrimony, if people, if the authorities are just
- 48:21like, you know. What?
- 48:23She was doing dangerous things. She was.
- 48:25She was an addict. She kind of had this coming.
- 48:28That's why it happened to her. Then I am upset about it.
- 48:33It kills me. Yeah.
- 48:36And also cases where you know. The.
- 48:44The victim may remind me of a sister or a daughter or my mom
- 48:49or something like that. Those are the ones that speak to
- 48:51me most. What are the cases that speak to
- 48:54you guys? And then question number, let's
- 48:57see, that was question number three.
- 48:58That is all of them. So those are your three
- 49:01questions. Please don't forget to send in
- 49:04your questions to three questions.
- 49:05At Gavin fish dot. Com I love them as prompts to
- 49:09discuss. With you guys, what what you
- 49:14think? So let's go over to your
- 49:16comments. Actually, no, Gavin, you're
- 49:19getting ahead of yourself. We're going to do the headline
- 49:21segment. While while you guys.
- 49:23Are typing in what you want to tell me about your favorite
- 49:26painter, the cases that are important to you, and so forth.
- 49:29The channels that you love. Let's dig into some headlines.
- 49:40True crime headlines. Okie Dokie, I've got three
- 49:44headlines that I want to bring to you on cases that we are
- 49:47following that are important to us.
- 49:49Obviously maybe #1 on our list is the Nancy Guthrie case.
- 49:56This from the New York Post earlier today written by Emily
- 49:58Crane. It features our friend Jen.
- 50:02Headline Key reason ex FBI agent Thinks a Nancy Guthrie arrest
- 50:05could be close A former FBI agent believes that the decision
- 50:11not to call in civilian search experts in the hunt for Nancy
- 50:14Guthrie could signal that authorities are close to making
- 50:17an arrest. Again, we're not taking this as
- 50:20gospel. We're taking this as the opinion
- 50:22of Jennifer Coffendafer, not as a fact.
- 50:24Jennifer Coffendafer. Speculated that it could be.
- 50:26Telling after United Cajun Navy, a volunteer LED search
- 50:30organization, revealed that it offered help to the Pima County
- 50:34Sheriff's Department last week as the search for the missing 84
- 50:37year old reached the month mark but never heard back.
- 50:40Quote Wondering why Sheriff Nanos keeps turning away proven,
- 50:45very capable civilian search experts like Equisearch and the
- 50:49real Cajun Navy Coffin Daffer wrote on X, continuing the quote
- 50:53Is law enforcement close to an arrest?
- 50:57And they know what happened to Nancy, so they don't want to
- 50:59waste the valuable resources of these groups.
- 51:03But why won't the sheriff at least acknowledge these groups?
- 51:06Half glass full. Hoping law enforcement is
- 51:08getting closer, she wrote. Is it possible?
- 51:13I mean, maybe. And Jen is certainly entitled to
- 51:16her opinion, and it is an educated opinion at that, and an
- 51:19experienced one too. The next headline I want to
- 51:22bring it to you is in the Quarry Richens trial, this one written
- 51:27by Carolina Hassett on FOX 13 State calls final witness in
- 51:33Cory Richins murder trial. I can't believe it.
- 51:35We're already kind of halfway through our third week of this
- 51:38trial. Can't believe that Dateline Park
- 51:40City, UT written by Carolina hassett again.
- 51:45The trial of Cory Richins resumed Wednesday after a
- 51:48strange day yesterday, which the jury was dismissed Tuesday
- 51:52following a debate over transcripts jurors would be able
- 51:55to see. When the jury returned to the
- 51:58courtroom at 1:00 PM, Richin's former housekeeper returned to
- 52:01the stand to give the defense a chance to cross examine her
- 52:05after finding out that she had violated a court probation in
- 52:092023 when she was seen with an alcoholic beverage.
- 52:13Carmen Lobber had previously testified that she obtained the
- 52:16drugs for Corey that were allegedly.
- 52:18Used in Eric Richin's death. During Lobber's testimony, she
- 52:25said that she had gone to a concert with a friend and
- 52:28instead of paying her back, agreed to buy food and drinks.
- 52:32Lobber confirmed that an officer saw her at the concert with a
- 52:36drink in her hand. But said she didn't drink.
- 52:38However, when told the probation officer saw saw her drinking,
- 52:44Lobber said that if the officer said that then it is true.
- 52:47OK, weird, weird, weird way to write that or to say it, OK.
- 52:55After Lobber left the stand, the state called Detective Jeff O
- 52:58Driscoll with the Summit County Sheriff's Office as its final
- 53:02witness. You know.
- 53:06I have O. Driscoll's in my extended family
- 53:09out there in Summit County. They are cousins to my mom and I
- 53:15know a couple of them like we interact with each other, but I
- 53:18do not know Detective O Driscoll.
- 53:21I, I don't know. O'Driscoll testified that during
- 53:24a search of Lobber's home, detectives found THC products as
- 53:28well as a firearm under the bed. Lobber is a winner here.
- 53:33In addition, a clipping of Eric Richins obituary was found in
- 53:36the middle of a mirror in the home.
- 53:38Oh my goodness. What a dill hole.
- 53:42What an idiot. Oh my goodness, you are an
- 53:45idiot. Idiots.
- 53:48Do I have a stupid criminal? Do I have a stupid?
- 53:50Criminal sound. I feel like I should.
- 53:53I need a stupid criminal sound. My goodness.
- 53:59OK. I think he will probably
- 54:02continue testifying tomorrow. Maybe.
- 54:06I don't know. I haven't looked it up since we
- 54:07started. And court didn't end by the time
- 54:10we started tonight. All right.
- 54:12Third and final. Do you guys remember the case of
- 54:15Lake and Snelling? Let's see, I think I have do do
- 54:21do do do do I? Do some pictures of Miss
- 54:25Snelling. This was this is the former
- 54:29University of Kentucky beauty queen.
- 54:33And I don't know, she was a cheerleader or stunt team,
- 54:37whatever you call members of the cheerleading stunt team,
- 54:41whatever she is the one who was pregnant, allegedly gave birth
- 54:49to her own child and took that child's life, if you guys
- 54:52remember this. And of course, she looks
- 54:55pregnant when she was. Oh, my goodness.
- 54:58Yeah. Look at this.
- 54:59Pictures of everybody knew she was pregnant.
- 55:01Come on. Okie, dokie.
- 55:03Anyway coming from KOMO News written by Jessica A Botello
- 55:11former cheerleader indicted on 1st degree manslaughter charge
- 55:14and newborn baby's death. This is just just came out
- 55:18today. Lexington KY is our dateline.
- 55:22A grand jury in Kentucky indicted 22 year old Lakin
- 55:25Snelling on a first degree manslaughter charge in
- 55:28connection with the death of her newborn baby boy, according to
- 55:33authorities. The Lexington Police Department
- 55:36announced the update in the case on Tuesday.
- 55:39Snelling, a former University of Kentucky student and
- 55:42cheerleader, had previously faced charges that included
- 55:46abuse of a corpse, tampering with physical evidence and
- 55:49concealing the birth of an infant after police found a
- 55:53newborns body in her closet on August 31st, 2025.
- 55:57It's just horrifying and, and I, it's not lost on me the the
- 56:06perhaps mental illness or emotional illness that might
- 56:12have been taking place in Miss Snelling's heart and mind.
- 56:18Still, she needs to be held responsible if this is true,
- 56:21right? And I believe it is.
- 56:24Police said the infant, who was wrapped in a towel and hidden in
- 56:27a trash bag, was found after roommates reported hearing
- 56:30strange noises and seeing blood in Snelling's off campus room.
- 56:35According to authorities, an autopsy later determined the
- 56:38baby was born alive with asphyxia by undetermined means
- 56:42listed as the cause of death, prompting the grand jury's
- 56:45decision to add the more serious manslaughter charge.
- 56:49Quote, they were given the information about homicide, the
- 56:52four levels of homicide and then deliberated and decided that
- 56:55manslaughter first degree was the charge that should come out
- 56:59of the grand jury, Fayette Commonwealth's Attorney Kimberly
- 57:02Baird said of the grand jury, per WKYT.
- 57:05During questioning after her arrest, Snelling admitted she
- 57:09gave birth alone, fell asleep beside the newborn and later
- 57:13placed the baby's body and placenta in a trash bag before
- 57:16trying to clean the scene, according to court filings.
- 57:20Snelling was released on house arrest at her father's home in
- 57:23Tennessee after posting bond and has since withdrawn from UK.
- 57:29If convicted of first degree manslaughter, she could face 10
- 57:32to 20 years in prison under Kentucky law, with additional
- 57:36prison time possible for the other charges, according to
- 57:40WKYT. Baird said Snelling's next
- 57:42appearance in court will likely come within the next few weeks.
- 57:46And we will keep an eye on that. I think the most likely thing
- 57:50that will happen here is some sort of a plea that would keep
- 57:54her out of prison for one to two decades.
- 57:57I think that's probably what's going to happen there.
- 58:01And those guys are your headlines.
- 58:11Okie, Dokie, let's go on to what you guys are telling me over in
- 58:17the live chat. Cooler by the Lake says.
- 58:23Always thought the Daniel was shady.
- 58:25I hope this case gets resolutions.
- 58:26So sad. It is indeed.
- 58:31Oh autumn found another camera that you'll never.
- 58:35Yes I am always up, especially if it's a film camera.
- 58:41My collection is growing and autumn.
- 58:44I have. I have.
- 58:46Put. About half a roll through the
- 58:48last Canon camera that that you that you gave me.
- 58:53It's been fun. Been a lot of fun.
- 58:55Just Ducky says Ansel Adams is my favorite.
- 58:57Yeah. Fun fact, I have a contact print
- 59:02an original Ansel Adams contact prints an 8 by 10 of his
- 59:08moonrise over Hernandez. Love me some Ansel Adams.
- 59:15Let's see. Yeah.
- 59:17Welcome to the family. New fishies.
- 59:18Yeah. I'm glad I remembered.
- 59:20I can gift memberships. Autumn.
- 59:22Autumn's keeping me honest here, guys.
- 59:25I forgot that I can do that. Crystal says Vincent van Gogh is
- 59:29her favorite. Yeah, I started.
- 59:31To fall in love with the Impressionists after doing a a
- 59:36play in high school that was an original piece written by my
- 59:41high school theater teacher that we titled Van Gogh and it was
- 59:45about the life of Vincent and I started to really fall in love
- 59:50with Impressionism. Then pretty fun runs with
- 59:55scissors. That reminds me of that scene in
- 1:00:00Cheers where Frazier was talking about I can, I'm a dangerous
- 1:00:03man. And then he grabbed scissors and
- 1:00:05he ran around the bar. I am running with scissors.
- 1:00:08It's one of the best scenes in television history.
- 1:00:11OK, Gavin, are the mom and stepdad still together?
- 1:00:14Did they ever turn on each other?
- 1:00:15The blanket piece is really suspicious.
- 1:00:18To my understanding, and I don't know this, they have split.
- 1:00:22I mean, Mr. Martell said in an interview that she left.
- 1:00:27I don't know if they're back together or anything like that,
- 1:00:29But the last information I had was they're not together
- 1:00:33anymore. I have not seen any evidence
- 1:00:36that they've turned on each other.
- 1:00:37But again, the caveat there is that in Canada, man, they just
- 1:00:43do not release a lot of information.
- 1:00:44So there's a lot of stuff that we don't know, right?
- 1:00:47Did have they testified against each other or given interviews
- 1:00:50to the police, you know, making accusations against the other?
- 1:00:55I don't know. I don't know.
- 1:00:59All right, let's see. Oh, yes.
- 1:01:03Sky Ricky knew what the word was.
- 1:01:05Corruption was the word Alan Greenberg.
- 1:01:08That case is synonymous with corruption in my opinion.
- 1:01:12Yeah, Dan Markell is another case that Sky Ricky cares about.
- 1:01:18Let's see. Diane says I love Dolly.
- 1:01:21Visited the museum in Sarasota, FL Spent the entire day there.
- 1:01:26That's all. I I've never been really taken
- 1:01:29in with Salvador Dali, though I recognize his value to to the
- 1:01:35history of art. Speaking of other channels here
- 1:01:38on YouTube that are just awesome.
- 1:01:41I don't know if you guys subscribe to Baumgartner
- 1:01:43Restorations. He is based in Chicago and he is
- 1:01:47a master conservator of fine art.
- 1:01:52He did. Let's see.
- 1:01:54Actually, now I'm second guessing myself.
- 1:01:57I think it was a Dolly that he did, but now I can't remember.
- 1:02:02I can't remember. But pretty awesome.
- 1:02:05Pretty awesome. Anything else?
- 1:02:10Do do do do do do do. Do let's.
- 1:02:14See, Robert the Ruse says. I love Degas and Van Gogh too.
- 1:02:19I also don't like Cubism or surrealism or Dada.
- 1:02:23I do like Impressionism and Fauveism, although the latter
- 1:02:27can be a little dicey. Yes.
- 1:02:31Ramona asks. Gavin, what are you drinking in
- 1:02:34your pickle cup? In my dill hole cup, you mean?
- 1:02:37Which is available at gavinfish.com in the swag shop,
- 1:02:43which includes a definition of what a dill hole is.
- 1:02:48Let me get it in the right spot there.
- 1:02:49It's a mildly insulting term. Turn that off.
- 1:02:54Used to describe someone acting foolish, annoying or clueless.
- 1:03:01As in you, Mr. Stearns, are a dill hole.
- 1:03:04I am drinking. Delicious water I get.
- 1:03:08Parched as I as I speak to you all.
- 1:03:13Oh my goodness, I should have turned on do not Disturb on my
- 1:03:17phone. Guys, thank you so much for
- 1:03:19spending some time with me tonight.
- 1:03:21I'm glad that we have at least a little bit of an update on the
- 1:03:24case of Lily and Jack Sullivan. I'm hoping that something is
- 1:03:28going to happen here soon. Oh my goodness, Crystal saying
- 1:03:34the Pascal show is is that's one that I subscribe to and check in
- 1:03:37on every single day as well. I love Pascal show.
- 1:03:43And Scotch's mom says, so glad I was able to catch the tail end
- 1:03:46of the life tonight. Cory Richins just ended a few
- 1:03:49minutes ago. Thank you very much for that
- 1:03:51update, guys. I'm glad that we do have this
- 1:03:53update. On the Sullivan Kiddos, I hope
- 1:03:56that we have resolution soon. Remember that you can always
- 1:04:01reach out to me on my website, gavinfish.com.
- 1:04:03It is always, there's always a link to it down in the
- 1:04:06description below. You're always invited to join us
- 1:04:09in the fish tank on Facebook. That is where we hang out.
- 1:04:14Just search the fish tank or fans of Gavin Fish or whatever.
- 1:04:17You will find it there. About 6000 of us in there.
- 1:04:20We talk about all things true crime and some personal things
- 1:04:23here as well. So yeah, you're invited.
- 1:04:27And we will be back tomorrow at 6:00 PM Eastern Time.
- 1:04:31Wrong button. Gavin, what are you doing at
- 1:04:336:00 PM Eastern Time to continue another true crime conversation
- 1:04:38with me. I hope that you join me then.
- 1:04:41I don't know what case we're going to be on.
- 1:04:43It could be Corey Richins, could be Nancy Guthrie.
- 1:04:46It just really depends on, there are lots of cases that we are
- 1:04:50following right. I, I keep wondering when we're
- 1:04:52going to get an update on Nick Reiner on Spencer Monique Tepe
- 1:04:58on Caitlin Tracy. I, I'm keeping my eye on all of
- 1:05:01those and I will bring you the latest news as we get it.
- 1:05:05Until then, I bid you, I do. Thank you very much for being
- 1:05:09here and I'll catch you on the next one.
- 1:05:11Bye, bye. Thank you very much for watching
- 1:05:14this video. If you liked what you saw,
- 1:05:16please consider subscribing. And if you have any questions or
- 1:05:20comments, please leave them below.