Latest / Industrial Advisors / Shipping, Supply Chains, and Global Risk: What Every Industrial Investor Needs to Know
Transcript
- 0:00One of the things as a, as a college professor, I do, I
- 0:01make very complicated subjects.
- 0:03I don't dumb 'em down, but I make 'em so that people can understand them.
- 0:06And I think that's part of what I do is really make it a very
- 0:09complex system like supply chain, understandable to the common person.
- 0:13And I've been very fortunate, you know, my audience runs from the person living
- 0:16in the middle of Kansas, you know, who's, who's never seen a ship in their life
- 0:19to, you know, executives in the C-suite.
- 0:36Welcome to our Industrial Advisors podcast.
- 0:39You have Bill Condon and and Matt McGregor.
- 0:41We have a true expert in the shipping and logistics space.
- 0:44Uh, with us today, Sal Murano, Sal's a, a true expert in the shipping space.
- 0:50He serves as an associate professor of history at Campbell University
- 0:54in North Carolina, where he is based and an adjunct professor at the US
- 0:57Merchant Marine Academy, where he teaches maritime industry policy,
- 1:02PhD in military and naval history.
- 1:05Tell us a little bit about your background, your expertise, so the
- 1:08listeners can, uh, do a much deeper dive than what I just went into there, Sal.
- 1:12Sure.
- 1:12So, uh, I sailed.
- 1:13I graduated from New York Maritime, sailed in the merch Marine and worked
- 1:17in the industry for about seven years.
- 1:18Both float as shore swallowed the anchor came ashore, decided
- 1:21to go the history route.
- 1:23I got myself master's in maritime history in nor archeology.
- 1:26So did a little work, you know, in the underwater side of shipping.
- 1:30Did, uh, PhD over in Alabama.
- 1:31Got my military history, uh, degree there.
- 1:34And then started teaching.
- 1:35And one of the things that I had an opportunity to do was, uh, start teaching
- 1:39a graduate level maritime industry policy course for the US Merchant Marine Academy.
- 1:45So I've been doing that since 2008 and started writing about it.
- 1:48Started, you know, commenting on policy, did some pieces in g Captain
- 1:52and of a variety of other areas.
- 1:53And then five years ago, this month started, uh, what's going on with shipping
- 1:57on YouTube when the ever given went?
- 1:59Sideways in the Suez.
- 2:01Mm-hmm.
- 2:01Started it just to kind of talk about the, the ship getting stuck and, and
- 2:05it has morphed from a 137 subscribers.
- 2:08I think I had the day I started the, the channel to just
- 2:11over 610,000 subscribers now.
- 2:14Yeah.
- 2:14It's insane.
- 2:14We saw that.
- 2:15That's impressive.
- 2:16Yeah.
- 2:16It's like 500,000 views per, you know, kind of.
- 2:20YouTube episode, which is insane.
- 2:22I mean, for shipping, honestly.
- 2:23I mean, I've watched a lot of 'em.
- 2:24You're great.
- 2:25But that's insane numbers for YouTube channel and shipping.
- 2:28Don't ask me to explain it, Matt.
- 2:29I have no, I have no idea.
- 2:31I, I, I, I, I mean, I know I'm good looking.
- 2:33I know that that's, that's, I mean, that's.
- 2:36But I don't understand the rest of it.
- 2:38And it's just, it, it is just, you know, one of the things I think it is, is
- 2:41timing, number one and number two, hitting a niche that no one else is covering.
- 2:45And I think people have an interest in this.
- 2:48I mean, you know, the global supply chain crisis hit everybody.
- 2:51And, and, and I think, you know, whether it was the toilet paper shortage or how
- 2:56precarious our supply chain actually is at time that disturbed people
- 3:00about this and, you know, making it.
- 3:02So that people can understand it.
- 3:04You know, one of the things as a, as a college professor, I do, I
- 3:06make very complicated subjects.
- 3:07I don't dumb 'em down, but I make 'em so that people can understand them.
- 3:10And I think that's part of what I do is really make it a very
- 3:13complex system like supply chain, understandable to the common person.
- 3:17And I've been very fortunate, you know, my audience runs from the
- 3:20person living in the middle of.
- 3:21Kansas, you know, who, who's never seen a ship in their life to, you
- 3:24know, executives in the C-suite.
- 3:26So it's, it's, it's really impressive.
- 3:27I was just literally this morning on a conversation with this, uh, congressional
- 3:30staff, uh, about some legislation.
- 3:33So it's, it's crazy.
- 3:34Yeah.
- 3:34You kind of remind me of exploding like Peter Zion did, right?
- 3:38I mean, who was watching geopolitical stuff and then all of a sudden
- 3:42through COVID, he just exploded.
- 3:43Right.
- 3:44I don't know if you follow him.
- 3:45You probably do.
- 3:46If I do, I would have to get myself a ponytail and be walking
- 3:48around in the woods somewhere.
- 3:50Exactly.
- 3:50And doing, doing my, my, my Pure Peter, uh, thing.
- 3:53I, I know Pete, I, I joke as Peter sometimes talks about
- 3:55shipping, so I do these episodes called, uh, better Call Sal.
- 3:58And a lot of times it involves Peter.
- 4:00Uh, so it, it's fun.
- 4:01I've done a few episodes where I kind of emulate Peter in some ways.
- 4:04By the way, I, I really enjoy some of your references bill's too young
- 4:07to, to, to catch some of these.
- 4:09But your dire strait stuff.
- 4:11One of the best concerts I ever seen was brothers and Arms.
- 4:13When I was 14 years old that I, so I really enjoyed your commentary about that.
- 4:17Yeah.
- 4:18So Bill, my Don't even know who that is, bill.
- 4:20Well, Matt, I was four when you were 14, so, uh, no, I, yeah, I don't, yeah, yeah.
- 4:25See, yeah, some of my references will go over some people's heads, but for
- 4:29me, you know, one of the things I always joke about is if I don't make myself
- 4:31laugh, what's the purpose of doing this?
- 4:33So every now and then, that's right.
- 4:34I've come up with some very interesting, uh, titles for my videos.
- 4:38I had one where Pleasure Boat ran into the side of the museum ship Midway
- 4:42'cause the, the captain was drunk.
- 4:43And I think a title of that was called Ship Faced.
- 4:45And so, you know, you gotta have some fun with it every now and then.
- 4:49That's great.
- 4:50That's great.
- 4:50Good stuff.
- 4:51Well, let's yeah, get a little technical.
- 4:53The first question I have for you is, obviously with
- 4:56everything going on, uh, in Iran.
- 4:59How is that war affecting shipping?
- 5:03I'm imagining there's not much, uh, affecting the Venezuela situation,
- 5:07but maybe touch on both, but specifically the conflict in Iran.
- 5:10Yeah, so I, I mean, you've got a couple of issues that it's affecting it.
- 5:14Number one, obviously the energy sector is a big one right now.
- 5:16We're seeing that with 20% of global crude oil, uh, liquified natural
- 5:21gas come outta the Persian Gulf.
- 5:22And right now.
- 5:23That's largely on hold because of insurance issues and needing
- 5:27to have the insurance necessary to sail through the straits.
- 5:29Second, we're seeing container ships.
- 5:31I mean, we don't think about this at all, but actually there's a large container
- 5:35sector that goes into the Persian Gulf and anytime you choke off a piece of
- 5:39that trade, it sends back is kind of ripples through the entire supply chain.
- 5:44Jeremy Nixon, the CEO of ONE.
- 5:46Ocean Network Express just said over at the TPM conference, you know, this
- 5:50is, you know, a big Black Swan event.
- 5:51We weren't envisioning this.
- 5:52And what we're gonna see is backlog happen in the East Asia ports
- 5:56and that's gonna spill over to trade coming to the United States.
- 5:59We're already seeing ships further, we were hoping to
- 6:01see the Red Sea open back up.
- 6:03MAs could announce that they were sending ships back through and now
- 6:06all of a sudden they said, nope.
- 6:07Not doing that.
- 6:07We're gonna keep going around Africa, so that's gonna cause problems.
- 6:11You're gonna divert more ships through the Panama Canal now, which means increased
- 6:14traffic to go through the Panama Canal.
- 6:16We were fortunate that the water levels are back up in the canal.
- 6:19I mean, anytime you create a disruption, whenever I throw a map of marine
- 6:22traffic up and I show you where all the ships are and everything, I always.
- 6:25Called, that's the, the world's, uh, kind of circulatory system for trade.
- 6:28Mm-hmm.
- 6:29And, and anytime you pinch off some of the blood vessels, you
- 6:32know, you can cause damage.
- 6:33If it's a major blood vessel, you can kill it.
- 6:35If it's a, a smaller one, well you're gonna hurt a limb, but
- 6:37it's gonna hurt and now, and it's gonna cause impact throughout.
- 6:40And that's what we're seeing right now.
- 6:41And is that mainly affecting the East Coast?
- 6:44I would imagine the West coast, Seattle, Tacoma, long Beach, LA
- 6:48would be mainly coming from Asia.
- 6:50So is that mainly affecting the Eastern seaboard?
- 6:53So, so, you know, one of the things we saw come out, you know, this started
- 6:55back in 2016 when we opened up that new lane of the Panama Canal is, you
- 6:59know, back when the West coast was the dominant area, you know, LA and Long
- 7:02Beach were sucking up 60% of trade.
- 7:04That's not the case anymore.
- 7:05Things go through the Panama Canal.
- 7:07Things go around Africa now, and, and what's really interesting, one
- 7:10of the things that the, the global supply chain crisis caused in 21
- 7:13and 22 was a lot of brokers, a lot of shippers, really diversified
- 7:18their ability to bring cargo in.
- 7:19They just weren't going a hundred percent into LA and Long Beach.
- 7:22Anymore.
- 7:23And so you see a lot of people shifting.
- 7:25So, you know, Savannah, Houston, New York, New Jersey, develop, I mean,
- 7:28we see other ports, Charleston, uh, Virginia, all developing here majorly.
- 7:32So you can't sit there and say, well, you know, this, this is in the Middle East.
- 7:35This is not gonna affect our trade at all.
- 7:37It does because a lot of cargo gets trans shipped, moved over.
- 7:42Uh, you know, yes, you close off 15% of trade when you go through the Red Sea.
- 7:46But you know, a good chunk of that was going into the big terminals
- 7:49in Europe and being transload onto smaller ships to come across to the
- 7:53East coast and Gulf coast of the us.
- 7:55So yeah, this does have an impact and we're gonna see it.
- 7:57We're gonna see the impact.
- 7:58We're already seeing it 'cause we're seeing surcharges being leveled.
- 8:01We're having cancellations of routes and we were already seeing that
- 8:04because of blank sailings 'cause of over capacity in the fleet.
- 8:08The ocean carriers, the big ones.
- 8:10Haven't gotten rid of their ships.
- 8:12They, they, they're holding onto them.
- 8:14And, and that was leading to the freight rates kind of spiraling down.
- 8:17I will expect to see freight rates going back up again
- 8:20here, uh, because of all this.
- 8:22And are you seeing, uh, talk to us a little bit about the shift
- 8:25to, uh, a little bit out of China after the, you know, post
- 8:29COVID where everybody said, Hey.
- 8:31We're relying too much on China.
- 8:33Certainly Trump has had that, uh, initiative.
- 8:36But talk to us about the change.
- 8:37Are you seeing less activity outta China into the United
- 8:41States, or is that political talk?
- 8:43No, no.
- 8:43You're definitely seeing that, but I, I think we were seeing that beforehand.
- 8:46I think what we, what happened here was a magnification of that, and you
- 8:48gotta be careful because some of that.
- 8:50Was being moved trans, you know, internally within Asia and to
- 8:54come out of different countries.
- 8:55So Vietnam, there was trade across the Chinese Vietnamese border.
- 8:59But you are seeing it, I mean, Cambodia, Thailand, uh, Indonesia, India.
- 9:02You're definitely seeing that.
- 9:04The issue we saw, especially when we saw the tariffs, when you come
- 9:07back in the tariffs, I mean, I was talking the shippers, you know, some
- 9:10of them were looking at 145% tariffs outta China and sat there and said,
- 9:14it's still cheaper for me to go to China to get some of these things.
- 9:16You know?
- 9:16Right.
- 9:17That was the issue's like.
- 9:18And that was my big comment during the whole tariff crisis.
- 9:22It's like, we're not gonna see the massive drop that everybody did.
- 9:25We did see a drop.
- 9:26And what made that drop unique was it was outta sequence
- 9:29from when we usually see it.
- 9:30We saw it in May and June where it was typically, may and June are pretty
- 9:33high months, but the first quarter was stacked, you know, and even at
- 9:36the end, even in the fourth quarter of 2025, we were pretty stacked.
- 9:40But yeah, we're definitely seeing that shift go on there.
- 9:43But.
- 9:43Nowhere near, I think the level people thought it was gonna be.
- 9:47I still think we're pulling a a heck of a lot outta China right now.
- 9:50For sure.
- 9:51And if I could ask specifically, a lot of the listeners to this podcast are
- 9:55in the Greater Pacific Northwest or invest here on industrial real estate.
- 10:00What's your opinion on the, the port system here between
- 10:03Tacoma, Seattle, the future of it shipping seems to be down here.
- 10:07What's your overall opinion of our port system here?
- 10:10Well, I think a couple of things.
- 10:12Obviously Seattle was a big focus during the tariff issue
- 10:15'cause Seattle was focused a lot.
- 10:16I mean, the amount of stories I saw where Seattle's empty is
- 10:20was, was a lot during that time.
- 10:21But that has to do with a couple of things.
- 10:22Number one, you shifted a lot of cargo outta Seattle down to Tacoma,
- 10:25but the Canadian ports, I would argue, are really the competition.
- 10:28Vancouver and print, uh, prince Rupert.
- 10:30Are really some of the big competitors right now for Seattle Tacoma and Seattle.
- 10:36Tacoma suffers a little bit because of the rail situation.
- 10:39It's difficult, uh, because what you see going into, for example,
- 10:42Vancouver, is because of the alliance system that exists on the rail
- 10:46system between Canadian Pacific and Canadian National and Kansas City.
- 10:51You know, if I'm gonna ship into Chicago, for example, I'm
- 10:53probably gonna go into Vancouver.
- 10:54'cause it's, it's, it's, the rail system is a little bit better.
- 10:57It's flatter.
- 10:58I don't gotta go over the Rockies.
- 10:59It's a little bit of a better system.
- 11:01What Seattle Tacoma tends to do is handle the population up there in the northwest.
- 11:06And I think one of the things that really need to be done, uh, Tacoma
- 11:10has, has, has really advanced its port.
- 11:12I think the alliance system there is, is key.
- 11:14I think that's helped bring back a lot of business and trade.
- 11:18I think.
- 11:19The other element here is the fact that LA and Long Beach don't
- 11:22quite have their act together yet.
- 11:24I, I mean, did they play a good game?
- 11:25They're really big on it.
- 11:27I mean, no one beats Gene Soroka in the port of LA to get the job.
- 11:30The story of LA out there.
- 11:32And I think Seattle and Tacoma have gotta get a little bit more
- 11:35leaning into that a little bit.
- 11:36They be, need to be a little bit more proactive.
- 11:38They need to be talking about what Seattle Tacoma goes a huge population up
- 11:42in the Pacific Northwest to hit mm-hmm.
- 11:45Where LA and Long Beach make their money is two thirds of that cargo goes into the.
- 11:49Inland empire on the rail across the United States.
- 11:51That's where it goes.
- 11:53And I think what Seattle Tacoma needs to do is really fixate on how good that
- 11:57distribution system is in that area.
- 11:59Update the ports in that, the ability to go in and out of the gates faster.
- 12:04That's part of the automation that we see.
- 12:06LA and, and Long Beach invested heavily in automation.
- 12:09So you go to a port, like the Long Beach container terminal, you go to
- 12:12the a PM terminal down in la, you know, that's what makes productivity go.
- 12:16If you can produce a productive port.
- 12:19That's gonna attract you a lot of business right there.
- 12:21And I think that's one of the key things.
- 12:24You're not gonna see the development of a port like at COOs Bay because
- 12:27there's not the population there.
- 12:28There's not the road or rail system there, but Seattle Tacoma has that,
- 12:31and I think that's the element that needs to be kinda leaned into more.
- 12:35That's a really good point, Sal.
- 12:36We deal with a lot of.
- 12:39Three PL companies, right, that, that have locations across the US and I
- 12:44imagine that, that they value your expertise in the shipping space.
- 12:48I guess my que my question to you would be, what advice do you have
- 12:51for those companies when they're looking at planning facilities
- 12:53across the US and and downsizing in some areas and growing in others?
- 12:57What are you telling them in today's environment?
- 13:00I think a couple of things.
- 13:00I think if you are a hundred percent in on one route, one
- 13:04system, you're going to get hit.
- 13:06I mean, it's only a matter of time.
- 13:07I, I, that's what we saw happen.
- 13:09I mean, the reason LA Long Beach had 109 ships off them was not
- 13:13because we had a shipping shortage.
- 13:14We had plenty of ships.
- 13:15We had 109 ships.
- 13:16There was no shortage of ships.
- 13:17What we had was the system got overloaded and we came in, you know,
- 13:21basically we took an eight lane highway into a. Four lane highway.
- 13:24And, and, and what you did is you c clogged that system up and the problem you
- 13:27had is, listen, if you had versatility, if I had a ship that was going into
- 13:31Tacoma and LA that worked great.
- 13:33'cause I can get my cargo off in Tacoma and I can sit there and wait to get
- 13:37into LA and, and, and, and deal with it.
- 13:39But what you had.
- 13:40Was a lot of problems like, okay, I need to get in LA and do I
- 13:44wanna spend the time in Tacoma?
- 13:45So I'm just gonna jump, I'm gonna dump Tacoma and I'm just gonna go into la.
- 13:49I think what we need to do is really demonstrate, listen,
- 13:51Tacoma provides you this.
- 13:52You know, you can get into the system, you can get ahead of when
- 13:55the system crashes or clogs up.
- 13:57I can get you again.
- 13:59I think what we saw happen is like, listen, are you willing to pay a
- 14:02little bit more for better results?
- 14:04Because if you look at that classic graph of reliability, in other words, I
- 14:08ship a container, what's the chance of it arriving on time during periods of
- 14:11low cost to go across on ocean shipping, the reliability is through the roof.
- 14:16When the cost is high, reliability drops like to 20, 30%.
- 14:20And what I saw and what I tell people all the time is, listen, if you're
- 14:23willing to pay a little bit extra, you can guarantee that you shift.
- 14:26By coming into different ports.
- 14:27Mm-hmm.
- 14:28And that's where a port like Seattle, Tacoma, and the Northwest comes in very
- 14:32importantly, because you know, if we play the four corner strategy, if we
- 14:36play la Long Beach, Savannah Houston, New York, New Jersey, well that.
- 14:41What we saw from Dolly in Baltimore is you can shut a US port down.
- 14:44I mean, you can close it.
- 14:45I mean, you can shut it down for months.
- 14:46Mm-hmm.
- 14:47Sure.
- 14:47And for, and the vulnerability is there.
- 14:49And listen, LA and Long Beach, they can add more terminals,
- 14:52they can increase their rate.
- 14:54You're still in downtown LA and Long Beach to get out of.
- 14:57That's, you still got that issue about getting out.
- 14:59So what I would tell people is, listen, look at that.
- 15:01I mean, one of the most interesting discussions I saw were, you know,
- 15:04basically data companies that were basically data warehouses along routes
- 15:10to determine where I can store goods, I can bring 'em into Seattle, Tacoma,
- 15:14maybe warehouse 'em in, in Butte, Montana, off a railhead somewhere,
- 15:18and then I could pull it when I need.
- 15:20To get to me in Indianapolis.
- 15:22You know, I don't have to go into just Ontario, California anymore.
- 15:26There are options out there for me, and that's what I would do.
- 15:28I mean, that, that's what I tell them all the time.
- 15:30Now that takes time.
- 15:31It takes money and it takes some resources, but it pays off at the
- 15:36point when there are disruptions, and I think the one thing we can say is
- 15:39there's going to be disruptions there.
- 15:40The, the period of things flowing perfectly anymore are not there.
- 15:45And if you are involving with anything that touches the ocean.
- 15:48Get ready for a disruption, whether it's a natural disruption
- 15:50or it's a geopolitical one.
- 15:52Speaking of disruption, and the last question we have for you is.
- 15:57Tell us about the biggest risk to the US supply chain over the next year
- 16:00and kind of what your prediction is.
- 16:02I think it has to be just literally the uncertainty.
- 16:05I mean, again, you know, on the Bingo card for 2026, you know, did, did was
- 16:10straight of horror moves on there.
- 16:11Yeah, it was on there.
- 16:12I don't think anybody quite had the level of disruption.
- 16:16That we're seeing right now, and I don't think everyone
- 16:18appreciates what this, this happens.
- 16:21I, I'll give you the perfect example is, is you reopen the Red Sea tomorrow.
- 16:24Tomorrow the Houthis, you know, everything's done.
- 16:26And we're gonna reopen the Red Sea.
- 16:28That's gonna cause three months of disruption.
- 16:29Everyone, no one understands how much that's going to clog ports
- 16:33all of a sudden and cause it.
- 16:34So even positive things can cause this issue.
- 16:37And I, I think.
- 16:38The big prediction I would say is really being, you know,
- 16:41quick and nimble on your feet.
- 16:43Being able to do it, it's very difficult.
- 16:44I mean, we, we get so focused on the immediate shipment, you know, Hey, I
- 16:48gotta get this load from here to here.
- 16:49I gotta provide this.
- 16:50I'm not looking at big picture, I gotta look at small term.
- 16:53But if you've got your head in, in, in kind of the hood there,
- 16:55and you're not looking up around.
- 16:57You're gonna get hit, you are gonna get hit hard because what you need to be able
- 17:00to do is very quickly adapt to a system.
- 17:03You know, I, I ran around last year with an app on my phone that gave me the, the,
- 17:07the water levels in the Panama Canal.
- 17:09I, I, I'm, I'm such a loser.
- 17:10I, I really am.
- 17:11You know, I, I, I, I should have, I should be looking at ESPN results instead.
- 17:15I'm like, oh, look at the Katoon Lake, because that's, that was
- 17:18driving shipping, uh, to such a level.
- 17:20And, and not everyone does that.
- 17:22And I think.
- 17:23One of the things I think a alliances and groups do all the time and and
- 17:27podcasts, like what you guys do is very important for regionally to
- 17:30give people the idea of, Hey, listen, this is what's on the horizon.
- 17:33This is what we're seeing and here, and more importantly, this is what we learn
- 17:36from this event, what you need to be thinking about for the next time around.
- 17:40I would argue that one of the things that I think the tariffs weren't as bad.
- 17:46Impact on everyone.
- 17:47I'm not talking economically, but I mean in disruption, because we'd learned that
- 17:50in 20 21, 20 22, a lot of people were.
- 17:53Okay, I'm gonna get a disruption.
- 17:54Now.
- 17:55How am I prepared for this?
- 17:56I'm gonna front load, I'm gonna, you know, if I got the ability, I'm gonna
- 17:59get some cargo in here real fast.
- 18:00I'm gonna build up my supplies.
- 18:02I'm gonna build an alternative route system.
- 18:04I'm gonna look at different suppliers overseas.
- 18:07Maybe I don't wanna be just in China.
- 18:08Maybe I wanna be in a few places.
- 18:10To me, that's it.
- 18:11But again, it takes a lot to be able to do that and, and my focus
- 18:14is, like I said, watching the water because guaranteed ship's gonna happen
- 18:18somewhere, and it happens quite a lot.
- 18:20That's right.
- 18:20Well, we're gonna put all your, uh, information so you
- 18:23get some, uh, more followers.
- 18:25Uh, we're gonna put that in the, in the footnotes so
- 18:27everybody knows where you're at.
- 18:28We greatly appreciate this.
- 18:30This has been fascinating and congratulations on all your success.
- 18:33I mean, like I said at the beginning, it's insane how many people
- 18:37watch, watch you, but you truly are the world expert in shipping.
- 18:40We greatly appreciate you being on the show.
- 18:43Well, I appreciate it.
- 18:44What gets me out there is guys like you promoting me, so I appreciate that a lot.
- 18:47Excellent.
- 18:47Yeah, I appreciate it and not ever knew shipping could be so interesting.
- 18:50So you did an excellent job.
- 18:51Thanks for joining us.
- 18:55Thanks a lot.
- 18:55Appreciate it.
- 18:56You did great.
- 18:57Thank you.
- 18:57Thanks guys.