Latest / The Retail Podcast / AI, Tasks & Culture: How The CoOp Is Redefining Frontline Retail
Transcript
- 0:00The key thing about AI is a genetic AI is the ability to
- 0:03have multiple agents that can connect, talk to one another and
- 0:07execute intelligent processes. So do things for us, right?
- 0:11So there is a real benefit there.
- 0:24Hello and welcome back to the Retail Podcast.
- 0:26Now, I'm always spoilt when we have a retailer and partner on
- 0:30the call with us or on the episode with us.
- 0:33And today is one of those episodes.
- 0:35So Chris, why don't you start us off?
- 0:38Why don't you give us a quick one minute on who you are and
- 0:41what you do? Yeah.
- 0:43Hi, Alex. So I'm Head of Store Support for
- 0:45the Mid Counties Corp. I've been working for Mid
- 0:48Counties for 28 years now and over half of that time was I was
- 0:53either a store manager or a district manager running stores
- 0:57for our food business. So in my role today, I really
- 1:00feel that I'm best placed now to support those stores with what I
- 1:03know and I hold responsibility for a loss prevention team, our
- 1:08communications team, our manager operating model, also
- 1:11simplification and continuous improvement.
- 1:13So we counties is one of the leading independent cooperatives
- 1:17in the UK, got over 750,000 members, 6 1/2 thousand
- 1:22colleagues. We operate across food, travel,
- 1:25early years, childcare and also utilities.
- 1:28But from a food perspective, we mainly operate out of our core
- 1:31counties have gone up lost to share Worcestershire, Wiltshire
- 1:34to Shropshire and sort of West Midlands.
- 1:36And yeah, so really kind of mixed estate lots, lots of
- 1:41interesting things going on and that's why we were really keen
- 1:44to look at this kind of solution.
- 1:46That's fantastic. Thank you.
- 1:47Mark. Why don't you give us an
- 1:49overview of who you are and what you do?
- 1:51Hi. Thanks, Alex and hello
- 1:52everybody. So Mark Williams, Managing
- 1:54Director for Workjam EMEA, been with Work Jam for four years
- 1:58now, brought in to set up and lead our European expansion.
- 2:03Prior to that 16 years with Shell in global retail
- 2:07operations. I've got a passion for kind of
- 2:09where technology meets kind of business process and how we
- 2:13extend that to the all important frontline because for me that's
- 2:16where it really matters. That's where the rubber hits the
- 2:18road. They're the individuals who are
- 2:20dealing with the front line customers coming into the store
- 2:24or into the operation day in, day out.
- 2:27So without engaging them, without communicating them and
- 2:30providing them with digital tools to do their job, you don't
- 2:33tend to get the productivity that you need off what is a very
- 2:36cost sensitive, cost conscious, typically operating environment.
- 2:41It's perfect. Chris, I want to start by
- 2:44casting your mind back because obviously you've been in the
- 2:47business a long time. When you were looking at the
- 2:49problem, there must have been early signals or early signs
- 2:53that the existing system for frontline communication.
- 2:57And being someone who's come from that world, I understand
- 3:01that sometimes there is nothing apart from, you know, pen and
- 3:04paper when people are talking to each other.
- 3:06But I was, I'm curious in, in what were those signals that you
- 3:10saw when prior to all of the transformation that you've gone
- 3:13through that this way of working is no longer fit for purpose?
- 3:18And then if you, if you don't mind, how did that conversation
- 3:21evolve into a partnership with with Workjam?
- 3:25Yeah. So what we started to see was a
- 3:26really sort of disparate frontline that we're just
- 3:29overloaded with tasks and activities and communications
- 3:33coming up them in all kinds of different manners, none of which
- 3:37were particularly productive. And they had to go and search
- 3:39for those communications. So we really were trying to
- 3:42start a journey of understand how do we put communications and
- 3:46tasks into the hand of our frontline colleagues at the time
- 3:48that they need them for the right people at the right time.
- 3:51This really started as a bit of a task journey for us.
- 3:54We were really trying to find a vendor that could support us in
- 3:57terms of managing our tasks of frontline.
- 3:59As we went through the process, we realised there was lots of
- 4:01opportunity to try and bring in a much more sort of virtuous
- 4:05circle of bringing communications and tasks and all
- 4:08the kind of things that colleagues would need to find or
- 4:10to sort 11 place. We realised quite early on that
- 4:13actually we were really, really tasked hungry as a as a food
- 4:17retailer in particular, and trying to find a way that
- 4:21converted tasks and communications in a simple form
- 4:25to to the frontline colleagues was absolutely vital for us.
- 4:28So I think that piece of work that we realised quite early on
- 4:32was that we needed something more than a task provider.
- 4:35We need something that brought it all together and would
- 4:38surface to all colleagues at all times.
- 4:40I. Got you.
- 4:42I'm just curious, how much of the sort of feedback did you get
- 4:46from the shop floor? How much were they involved in
- 4:49the process? Yeah.
- 4:50A lot. So we've done some early, this
- 4:52was quite early in odds of what we call our simple store
- 4:56journey. And we were really trying to
- 4:58understand the kind of complications of for frontline
- 5:01colleagues, both in food but also in our travel and early
- 5:04years nurseries. And so we do regular pulse
- 5:07surveys with our colleagues. So that was a key part of the
- 5:11information we get back. We hold colleague council
- 5:14meetings. So this is kind of tends to be
- 5:15more of our frontline colleagues rather than managers who would
- 5:19give us regular feedback as to what was stopping them being
- 5:21productive. But most importantly, my team
- 5:24were out there on the ground in the field being side by side
- 5:27with the team just to really understand what were the the
- 5:30points of friction, what was causing them issues?
- 5:31What was stopping them being as productive as they possibly
- 5:34could be. I.
- 5:35Got you. Mark, in terms of when you
- 5:37obviously look at customers that are similar to sorry yeah to
- 5:42customers who've had the same challenges as Chris and mid
- 5:45counties Co-op. What do you feel are some of the
- 5:48sort of the things that have gone sort of silently by people
- 5:52haven't really understood what's going on or or the need for
- 5:55transformation? What was unappreciated by
- 5:59retailers that have gone on this journey?
- 6:01Yeah. So I think it's two things.
- 6:03It's it's helping them initially understand that the frontline is
- 6:07kind of forgotten in any digital transformation.
- 6:09So in the head office, we all have teams, we all have
- 6:13solutions and tools that help us do our day job better or more
- 6:17effectively and more efficiently.
- 6:19But that never really penetrated down to the frontline.
- 6:22There still tended to be dated standards, dated approaches, Pen
- 6:26and paper and and a lot of retailers can kind of miss that
- 6:31or perhaps they hear it, but are a little bit in denial.
- 6:34It's only the forward thinking kind of retailers like like
- 6:37Chris and the mid counties Co-op that that really say, OK, I
- 6:40understand I have a problem here.
- 6:41I'm I'm going to own that problem and how can I go about
- 6:44fixing it? And when they get into the how,
- 6:47how am I going to fix that? That's when the pocket of
- 6:49values, pockets of value appear, right.
- 6:52So, you know, yes, there's a productivity gain there.
- 6:55Oh, look, there's, you know, some time liberation there,
- 6:58which I can redeploy for more customer facing time, perhaps
- 7:02talking about an upsell, perhaps increasing that basket spend, or
- 7:05perhaps it might be the other way.
- 7:06Perhaps it might be more efficient and effective
- 7:09compliance procedures and audits, making sure things like
- 7:12Natasha's law, health and safety requirements are met in a more
- 7:16timely way and a more controllable way and reportable
- 7:19way. Again, liberating time.
- 7:22That time then is kind of of redeployed and, and let's face
- 7:26it, we're in a particular period of, you know, of, of almost
- 7:29chaos, aren't we? I mean, there's been so much
- 7:32disruption in retail and other industry verticals which we
- 7:36serve as well over the last sort of 18 to 24 months, months that,
- 7:39you know, people are now looking for that kind of that
- 7:41productivity gain, that cost saving, that value add, where
- 7:44they can get it. I got it.
- 7:46Thank you. Chris.
- 7:48Coming back to you when what's interesting when I read about
- 7:51this is something that retailers try to achieve, but not
- 7:55necessarily through this type of transformation.
- 7:58And that's basically looking at the culture.
- 8:01And so when you've got such a disparate business, when you
- 8:04mentioned earlier you've got you've got stores, you've got
- 8:06nurseries, you've got travel branches, how intentional was it
- 8:10to sort of achieve A cultural outcome?
- 8:13And what lessons would you share with other retailers who are
- 8:16actually trying to build community at scale?
- 8:21I think you're quite right. I think culture was something
- 8:24that we really, I don't think we grasped initially.
- 8:28It's something that we built on over time as we, as we
- 8:31established work jam into the business.
- 8:33I think the mistake a lot of businesses make is they think
- 8:36the technology is going to drive the culture, but actually the
- 8:39business drives the culture, that the technology supports the
- 8:42culture. And I think everyone was looking
- 8:44for that golden bullet, that work jam would just coming to
- 8:46the business and suddenly the culture would be exactly how we
- 8:48wanted it to be. And actually, that's not how it
- 8:50works at all. It's, it's that tool to enable
- 8:53us to drive a different type of culture within our within our
- 8:56business. And I think it was little steps,
- 8:59you know, understanding, for example, the difference between
- 9:01what is a task and what is a communication, I think is a
- 9:03great example. So, you know, the communications
- 9:05team that worked for me when we actually really analysed it,
- 9:08when we started putting it through the funnel of work, Yam
- 9:10was actually 95% of what we sent out was a task.
- 9:13It wasn't a communication, it was a task.
- 9:14And we were telling people to do things all the time.
- 9:16So we started to break things into buckets of what is a tell
- 9:19and what is an advice and what is a comms.
- 9:21And we started to change that. And where it was kind of
- 9:24borderline, we're trying to tweak it towards the comms
- 9:26because the comms is more engaging than a tell.
- 9:29But then when there's a clear, you must do this by this time,
- 9:32then that would be a task. And then we'd use that
- 9:34functionality so that that really slowly but surely sort of
- 9:38changed that, that that cultural direction of the business where
- 9:41we tried to make more things more communicated using its
- 9:44communication rather than the task wherever possible.
- 9:46And but then also it's really important to try and find
- 9:50something that worked across central support teams, across
- 9:53the different trading groups and all the kind of like disparate
- 9:56outposts of the of the business, I guess.
- 9:59How does that, I mean, I'm just curious in terms of
- 10:01prioritisation then in terms of how that has an impact on how
- 10:07managers are prioritising work or or measuring in what, what
- 10:12gets sent to stores from head office.
- 10:15Has that had an impact on that or or not?
- 10:17Because obviously 95% what was called communication is that is
- 10:21a huge number. Yeah.
- 10:22So what it what it's done is allowed us to very much
- 10:25streamline those activities over over multiple years now.
- 10:29So it's not been something that we did straight away.
- 10:32Initially we effectively replicated our paper based
- 10:35system into digital form and we didn't really change too much.
- 10:39But that immediately had a lot of upside in terms of being able
- 10:41to remotely see performance, remotely see things are being
- 10:44done without having to send people to a store to see that
- 10:47that work had been completed. Over time, it's allowed us to
- 10:50really effectively understand when and where people are
- 10:54completing tasks, why they're and also the sort of the
- 10:57validity and the value in those tasks being completed because
- 11:01now we've got better data. If we're not really doing
- 11:03anything with that data, why did we ever ask them to do it?
- 11:06So that really helped us to question that over time.
- 11:08And actually, we've probably halved our tasks now over the
- 11:11last year. In fact, we've taken over 3/4 of
- 11:14a million tasks, annual tasks out of our business.
- 11:16Is it in the last 12 months? Wow.
- 11:18OK. That's so I don't know if this
- 11:21sort of follows on from that point.
- 11:24But when you when you're when you're both looking at AI
- 11:27integration and how you're helping colleagues find answers
- 11:31to questions faster and then to be able to act with confidence.
- 11:35How do you envision AI sort of in the future?
- 11:39Or can you talk through what that experience is from the
- 11:42frontline in terms of how how this is helping frontline
- 11:46employees with with their query, sorry, with their queries.
- 11:50Yeah. I mean, I can probably take the
- 11:51AI question here. So, so yeah, I mean, AI is, you
- 11:56know, it's I'd say it's in its people would say it's maturing
- 12:00and that's been around for a little while, but I would say
- 12:02it's still in its infancy. The key thing about AI is a
- 12:06gentic AI. It's the ability to have
- 12:08multiple agents that can connect, talk to one another and
- 12:11execute intelligent processes. So do things for us, right?
- 12:15So there is a real benefit there.
- 12:16In the example that you gave something like work jams AI
- 12:20agent, it is there solely for the front line.
- 12:23And that is exactly to do what you said.
- 12:24It's to give them access to something immediately.
- 12:28They might not know what it is that they're looking for, but a
- 12:31few keywords, a couple of asks into the AI agent and they can
- 12:35link directly to it. It might be a manual, it might
- 12:38be a process, it might be a follow on education, it might be
- 12:42a learning management fast track programme and all of that is
- 12:45great. What's coming next from Work Jam
- 12:47are all of those other agents as well.
- 12:49So when they ask that question about a management referral
- 12:52programme, it automatically enrols them and unlocks the
- 12:55training for them to, to start on that particular journey.
- 12:59And it also unlocks the HR agent, which perhaps flags them
- 13:02for a fast track or additional increment or a reward and
- 13:06recognition coming from the HR team.
- 13:08So AI is going to touch the frontline, I think in a big way.
- 13:12It's, it's, it's going to blow up in the next 12 to 18 months.
- 13:15The other key side to frontline AI is all of the VMS, all of the
- 13:20visual merchandising, all of the visual merchandising standards,
- 13:24some of the, you know, optical recognition capability that's
- 13:28out there today looking products, are they accurate on
- 13:31the shelf? Do we need to restock?
- 13:34Can that agent then speak to a stocking agent which will then,
- 13:38you know, get to the distribution house to send more
- 13:40stock into that store? Now we're really getting
- 13:43intelligent and automated processes as a result of a
- 13:46genetic AI working well together.
- 13:47That's how I see it evolving. And as I say, we're, we're
- 13:50starting and leading with our kind of AI agent and then that
- 13:53will connect out into into other capabilities.
- 13:56Chris, I know it's something that you're looking at from from
- 13:58Work Jam to support you with as. Well, yeah, I think it's the how
- 14:01it takes it to the next level. So we very much built our
- 14:04initial rollout of Work Jam with every core knowledge centre for
- 14:08example. But it's quite practical, you
- 14:10know, encyclopaedia of information, but it's quite hard
- 14:13to maybe pull some of that information out really easily.
- 14:16So we want to make it incredibly easy for the frontline
- 14:18colleagues just to be able to ask a very simple question and
- 14:21go directly to the right solution or answer for them, the
- 14:24right policy, whatever it might be.
- 14:25I think it's also how it enables our central teams to be able to
- 14:29analyse data quick, more quickly.
- 14:31So for example, quite as retailers, we've got often ask
- 14:35stores to submit a photo to show, you know, adherence to
- 14:38some display or something like that.
- 14:40Then the exciting bit for me is how the AI can analyse the
- 14:43photos that come in, for example, and just say every
- 14:45store's compliant with immediate effect rather than someone
- 14:48having to sort of have a look and through all that
- 14:50information, try and understand this.
- 14:52Some real gains for us there, both in productivity at the
- 14:54front and done, but also essentially as well.
- 14:56Looking at the final two questions, when you when you're
- 14:59looking let's go from the frontline in terms of privacy
- 15:04and frontline colleagues being worried about their privacy, was
- 15:08that Chris, is that I'm trying to sort of separate fact from
- 15:11fiction. What what was, what's the
- 15:13reality in in the real world where it's been deployed?
- 15:16Yeah. Yeah, yeah.
- 15:17Reality was there was some concerns about that in the early
- 15:19stages, no doubt at all, because it's the first time we'd really
- 15:22asked other colleagues to join a sort of central application on a
- 15:27on a on mask on a basis. However, the reality was that we
- 15:31had every individual site, every individual travel branch
- 15:34probably had their own and WhatsApp group, Facebook group
- 15:37that was completely unmonitored on police from a central
- 15:40perspective. And you know, anything went on
- 15:43those. The beauty of being integrated
- 15:46with work, we have our messaging facility that works within the
- 15:49application and we now get thousands and thousands of
- 15:52colleagues talking to each other on a monthly basis within
- 15:55Workjam. And that means it's controlled
- 15:57as in it won't let them. We don't monitor it, we don't
- 15:59watch it, we don't need to, but the philtres within it stop
- 16:02certain things being discussed but also our open in channels.
- 16:05It means that colleagues are sort of self policing
- 16:07themselves. So when colleagues talk to
- 16:09colleagues, they tend to answer each other's questions, they
- 16:11tend to police each other. We don't very, very rarely get
- 16:14involved in any discussions that are going on.
- 16:17On the application. There was obviously a level of
- 16:18concern around sort of the bring your own device conversations of
- 16:23the stores of concerns that we're going to walk into shops
- 16:26and everyone's walking around with their phone in their hand
- 16:28and they're staying at the screen and not talking to
- 16:30customers. But actually we found completely
- 16:32the opposite because it's about freeing colleagues up to have
- 16:34more time to deliver that customer experience.
- 16:37And, you know, we've really seen that benefit.
- 16:40Mark, do you have anything on that?
- 16:42No, just it's a very familiar story, Chris is kind of, we call
- 16:45it shadow IT. So we talk about those WhatsApp
- 16:48channels, we talk about those Facebook pages, unsecure,
- 16:52unsanctioned with, with with our products and putting everything
- 16:56into work jam. Now we take care of all of that
- 16:59in the back end with the data privacy, with all of the
- 17:02philtres, that profanity philtres and everything else
- 17:05that's built into that as as well.
- 17:06So it we actually see see the opposite and people learn more
- 17:10towards it, thinking I feel a little bit safer and I feel more
- 17:13secure now. Perfect.
- 17:14Thanks, Chris. Final, final question and just
- 17:17my chaotic brain can't sort of break it into two, so I'll throw
- 17:20it out. That's one question and let you
- 17:22decide which way you want to answer it in terms of looking at
- 17:26the future of Frontline and what what they have on their belt as
- 17:30they used to call it. I'm really curious on on your
- 17:33thoughts of the future and what that looks like.
- 17:36And then in the mix, what was the biggest surprise that the
- 17:39business sort of said that? I don't know.
- 17:41Was there an unexpected consequence of this
- 17:44transformation? Yeah.
- 17:46So in terms of in many ways I see us refining and refining
- 17:50Work Jam over time, there'll be certain other things that we
- 17:53bring in. So there'll be we want to bring
- 17:55in more integration. We want, we want Work Jam to be
- 17:57the front door for our colleagues for everything in our
- 18:00in our business. So in fact, they know they log
- 18:02into Work Jam, they can find out about where that helpdesk job
- 18:06has got to. When's that engineer coming to
- 18:08fix this in my store, you know, where can I get access my
- 18:12colleague pulse survey? Where can I access any
- 18:14information that I want to get to?
- 18:16So there are some more integrations and more work we
- 18:18want to do, but that's actually reducing the amount of separate
- 18:21platforms into one hopefully. So it feels it's all under in
- 18:24one place. But we do want to refine and
- 18:27refine tasks and communication. So it's really the critical
- 18:30information at the critical time for that frontline colleague.
- 18:33So certainly in the past, you know, you, you would have to
- 18:35send that everything to everyone rather than it saying this is
- 18:39relevant to a colleague who has got post office in their shop.
- 18:41This is relevant to a colleague who has got, you know, every
- 18:44parcel service in their shop. So only that relevant group of
- 18:47people would get that relevant piece of information.
- 18:50And then in terms of the sort of unintended consequences, I think
- 18:53that the, the messaging piece I just mentioned, I think was the
- 18:56big one for us because what we found, and we had a, a couple of
- 18:59examples where, you know, we had a system crash on a Sunday on a
- 19:02particular system. And before you know it, there's
- 19:06a couple of 100 conversations going on within the channels and
- 19:09all the colleagues are helping each other and fixing it.
- 19:11And we never had to get involved in anytime.
- 19:13And, you know, people telling each other solutions, they've
- 19:15worked it out for themselves. It's, it's so much quicker and
- 19:18more efficient than actually our central teams getting involved
- 19:21in the conversation. So some of those wins have been
- 19:23really fantastic. That's.
- 19:24Wonderful. Yeah.
- 19:25Anything that impact when you see natural conversation from
- 19:29your frontline, you can't. I'm going to talk fast because
- 19:31we're going over time and I promise that we'll get it.
- 19:33Mark your thoughts on the on the front line of the future.
- 19:37What's your vision of that? Yeah.
- 19:39So I think fully informed, I think being able to get what
- 19:45they need to do their job in the most effective and efficient way
- 19:49possible within seconds, almost instantaneous, remove burden,
- 19:54remove noise and get them focusing more on the on the
- 19:57customer. You know, as retail moves more
- 20:00and more touchless, we want to make sure that those experiences
- 20:04when customers actually are face to face are the best that they
- 20:08possibly can be. So the more time that we can
- 20:10liberate, more processes we can automate, and the more human
- 20:13interaction we can have. The better that's that's it for
- 20:17me, I think no. That's wonderful.
- 20:18Thank you. No, the only the reason I
- 20:20brought you all in is because I'm always curious.
- 20:22I always have to ask a closing question.
- 20:25Is there a question I should have asked that I didn't ask
- 20:27because you know, is it like I'm not a specialist in all elements
- 20:30of frontline and I'm just curious, is there is there
- 20:34something that normally people ask you that I've totally
- 20:36missed? If not fantastic.
- 20:39Thank you so much. But I'm just, I, I have to
- 20:41finish off with like making sure I've captured everything.
- 20:45Is there, Chris may be with you? Is there, is there a question
- 20:48that people always ask you that I've not asked you?
- 20:49Yeah. The question I get typically
- 20:51asked is, is the level of activations, how many colleagues
- 20:54are actually involved in in the platform and things like that.
- 20:56So I'm glad. I asked the question, why don't
- 20:58you tell us the level of? Yeah.
- 21:01So typically we're seeing now kind of about 92% activation
- 21:05level across across the business across 6 1/2 thousand colleagues
- 21:09and on a we track then are kind of what we call our active
- 21:12users. That's colleagues that log into
- 21:14work jam more than a week. And we're averaging about 50%
- 21:17on, on that, that now. So really pleased with the
- 21:20progress we're making. This isn't it takes time.
- 21:22It does take time to get particularly frontline
- 21:24colleagues. You've got to give them a reason
- 21:26why. Why do I want to log in this
- 21:27week? You know, we have 100% active
- 21:30users when it comes to our store management levels, but it's the
- 21:33frontline colleagues who sat on a checkout on a Saturday
- 21:35evening. Why do they want to log into
- 21:36work jam and see what's what's going on?
- 21:38And we're on that journey and it's really growing.
- 21:41That's. Fantastic.
- 21:41Mark, is there anything from your side?
- 21:44I think typically I get Mark, that sounds great, but where and
- 21:48how do we start? It's, you know, it's yeah, we're
- 21:51a frontline platform that that does a lot, lots of modules that
- 21:55interoperate seamlessly and then people go blind.
- 21:58Me, it's comms. Is it task?
- 22:00Do I look at shift? Do I look at learning?
- 22:02So, you know, we have to unpack that and simplify it and say,
- 22:05look in, you know, 6 to 8 weeks, we can have you up and running
- 22:08communicating with, in Chris's case, 92% of of his workforce.
- 22:12It's just and we can use, we can use that as a change enabler for
- 22:16what comes next. And that's what I say in
- 22:18response to to that question. That's fantastic, Chris.
- 22:21Mark, thank you so much for giving up your time and I look
- 22:24forward to seeing how maybe if you're at NRF US catching up and
- 22:28seeing how how are you both getting on?
- 22:30Thanks. Alex.
- 22:31Good to talk to you. Thanks, Alex.
- 22:33Thanks.