Latest / Bitcoin for Financial Services Podcast / What Regulators Actually Think About Bitcoin: A Compliance Chief on RIAs, Cold Card, and Debanking
Transcript
- 0:00Yeah, I think, you know, when these cases come up, you know, generally it's a reactive response from a regulator.
- 0:10You know, I know this is not the same way, but like FTX, et cetera, when there is a large kind of public event, they're going to kind of look at if there is any kind of like first thing is they're going to try to find like retail client harm, right?
- 0:25Like were there assets that you potentially managed that were impacted and clients were impacted and obviously they lost money.
- 0:35If there's no general loss of funds, they may kind of go for the bigger fish, right?
- 0:42You know, for that area.
- 0:44So I think, you know, once they dig in, they're going to look at, is there a way that you could have reasonably identified the issue?
- 0:52So looking at your kind of vendor due diligence program.
- 1:22Everything is bullish for Bitcoin.
- 1:24Immoral.
- 1:25It's going up forever, Laura.
- 1:27Fix the money.
- 1:28Fix the world.
- 1:52Be convinced from a qualified tax legal or investment advisor to determine whether any information presented may be suitable for their specific situation.
- 1:56Past performance is not indicative of future performance.
- 1:57Any statements or opinions are subject to change without notice.
- 2:04Welcome back to Big Mark Financial Services podcast.
- 2:09Joined by special friend, Mark Dempsey, founder of Crypto Regulatory Solutions.
- 2:14Thanks for joining us, Mark.
- 2:16Thank you, Wyatt.
- 2:16And thank you, Jordan, as well.
- 2:18Looking forward to the conversation.
- 2:22Yeah, and for exciting conversation today, it's a pleasure of getting to know you over
- 2:30the last summer by a mutual friend, Eric Runge.
- 2:38He's also going to be out at the summit.
- 2:41We started working together in August.
- 2:43It's been awesome.
- 2:44I always joke that I have to have been, I don't know if I've ever actually told you this,
- 2:48but I tell other people that I had to have been your easiest sell ever.
- 2:55No, yeah, they, I won't, you know, you're, you're not,
- 2:58I won't give you that, but it was, it was a great conversation.
- 3:04It flowed really well. And I think, you know,
- 3:07it comes down to like when you come across when there's a right place at the
- 3:10right time and you got need and you have, you kick it off. It kind of,
- 3:15you know, it moves a little faster, I think.
- 3:18Yeah.
- 3:20I was excited to get to meet you in Columbus, right?
- 3:24Being on the panel together, that was fun.
- 3:27And yeah, I don't think we had crossed paths before that.
- 3:30So that was good.
- 3:31And like Wyatt, I'm also excited for this conversation because, you know, we were speaking about it right before we hit record.
- 3:38But a lot of people sleep on this specific side of financial services landscape, especially in the Bitcoin space.
- 3:46but in order for us to actually achieve the goals that we're working towards,
- 3:51like this is very important.
- 3:53And if we could nail some of the stuff that we're going to talk about today
- 3:56with regulators and having them understand things more clearly
- 4:01and then legislate that way, that would kind of propel us into the future.
- 4:06So looking forward to it.
- 4:08Wyatt, you want to kick us off with the first question for Mr. Mark?
- 4:11Yeah. And so framing this in the context of, you know, I get, this isn't very Christian. I try to find it, fight it, but I do get envious of Jordan sometimes not only because of his good looks and, you know, successful business, but how much lighter the CPA compliance seems to be than the RIA compliance.
- 4:33compliance. And I know you have a lot of history in the compliance and regulatory space. So I would
- 4:40love to hear about some of your background, different parts of your career, where you worked,
- 4:46how you got in the space, and ultimately how you ended up kind of pivoting out of it and starting
- 4:52crypto regulatory solutions and working. Do you exclusively work with RIAs or is it other
- 4:57professional service providers? And maybe just how you started the business, the services you offer,
- 5:01and how those two seemingly despair worlds in Bitcoin land seem to overlap in your work Yeah no happy to Yeah my first kind of entrance in the compliance regulatory side as I worked at FINRA who regulates broker dealers This was a little bit after the financial
- 5:20crisis. So I was on the mortgage-backed security, asset-backed security team. So
- 5:24they launched a team after the fact, right? But it was a great, obviously a great learning
- 5:35experience this is outside of dc so i'm originally from delaware lived in baltimore for about five
- 5:41years i've been in the dc area ever since 15 plus years jordan's a ravens fan i don't know if you
- 5:47knew that dude did anyone catch the game i know we're that's a meme in the bitcoin space but the
- 5:52game last night actually was crazy yeah i watched it mark so given that i grew up in northern
- 5:59Delaware I'm an Eagles fan by okay so it was tough we had a rough weekend yeah yeah we had two two the
- 6:07last two weekends were kind of rough for both games I would say that we probably should have won but
- 6:12yeah yeah no so the so at Fenra from there I served in the when I was in college served in the
- 6:23in the Marine Corps Reserves. And at that time, I came across the AB Federal Credit Union.
- 6:31They're based, like headquartered outside of DC in Vienna, Virginia. So worked on their compliance
- 6:36side. They have an RIA broker dealer and worked out to be their chief compliance officer. So was
- 6:43there for about five to six years. So that was really my entrance into kind of wealth management
- 6:49side. They have financial advisors across, you know, across the country and many of the Navy
- 6:54federal branches, as well as, you know, some digital offerings as well, kind of direct,
- 7:00direct to clients. And that's where I got my, you know, certainly my experience of running a
- 7:05client's team, SEC, you know, examinations, et cetera. And then from there, I was in-house at
- 7:12Mission Square, which runs like private sector retirement plans in DC, and then got into the
- 7:18consulting side about six years back, well, five plus years back. And that's right around the time
- 7:27where I discovered Bitcoin. And, you know, obviously being, you know, involved in financial
- 7:34services, I'm not, I'm not the one giving advice, I'm giving it our investment advice, I'm giving,
- 7:40you know, more compliance regulatory advice and came across Bitcoin, as well as obviously some of
- 7:47the other digital assets and was interested and kind of wanted to learn more about it.
- 7:53So kind of went down some of the rabbit holes, definitely listened to some of the Michael
- 7:57Saylor videos, et cetera.
- 7:59They kind of got into that.
- 8:01I'm actually going to see him.
- 8:03He speaks tomorrow at DC FinTech Week.
- 8:06And, you know, what I wanted to kind of understand is a way that I can have a pathway to kind
- 8:13of get into the Bitcoin space and then still kind of stay in my lane, like with regards
- 8:19to my background on investment advisor compliance and, you know, worked at a consulting firm
- 8:25that focused in that area.
- 8:27So worked on like wealth managers and hedge funds, VC firms that were kind of in the space
- 8:34maybe earlier on.
- 8:36And I like being in the gray area because I think, you know, there's definitely on the
- 8:41compliance end, it's not always like the, you know, the most fun and exciting role. So having that
- 8:49kind of daily kind of gray area kind of experience was exciting to me and still is. And we've
- 8:57obviously gone a long way in the last, you know, even five years, but we still have a little ways
- 9:02to go from clear rules and regulations. And I started about back in February, so just about
- 9:13eight plus months back. I really wanted to, always had a desire to kind of go out on my own,
- 9:20develop, you know, be an entrepreneur and focus my business on helping primarily investment advisors.
- 9:28I do, you know, I, you know, given my background, you know, I can, you know, have the ability to work with like broker dealers and, and other projects, but primarily with investment advisors in the space.
- 9:40And those are both state registered and SEC registered investment advisors.
- 9:44Today's episode is brought to you by Falcon, Rappaport & Bergman, a full-service law firm
- 9:56with one of the most respected digital asset practices in the country. FRB works on digital
- 10:01asset, tax and IRS matters, fund formation, estate and trust planning, and regulatory guidance for
- 10:08RAs and fintech services. As Bitcoin moves deeper into wealth management, their legal partner,
- 10:13advisors and family offices turn to when questions get complicated Learn more at frvlaw Very nice Yeah I mean i think uh why did i you know we spent some time in vegas talking
- 10:32specifically on like the de minimis tax law we could go like i'd be curious i'm just gonna throw
- 10:38some of these out there i don't know why it has specific things so we don't have to go here
- 10:42immediately but another one i'll throw out there beyond the you know maybe clarity act and like
- 10:48crypto tax legislation is the the mining the mining revenue recognition I don't know if you've
- 10:55ever had any clients or looked into that but at some point I don't want to hop on this off of this
- 11:01podcast without discussing your thoughts on on basically how Bitcoin is being singled out as a
- 11:08commodity with its tax treatment right now and if you see any uh have you seen any creative ways to
- 11:14to kind of circumvent that in the near term while we let the legislators do their thing
- 11:18or if you uh if you're bullish on bitcoin being treated similarly to like gold binding so i'll
- 11:26just throw all those out there because those are some like three things that i want to make sure
- 11:29that we talk about but i know why it likes why it has a structure and he's like yeah to this i'm
- 11:35gonna get to that so why you i'm gonna let you jump in and you ask a question i just want to
- 11:40make sure I got that off my chest. No, I appreciate it. I mean, we have cold notes for a reason. I
- 11:46know you don't really look at them or read them, but we might as well start there, Mark. I'm curious
- 11:52in your thoughts and opinions too. Yeah, I think on the, I mean, one of the lucky things of being
- 11:59right in DC, so we're in Capitol Hill. And I know that the, like PubKey has their, like a number of,
- 12:07you know, Bitcoin focused events. I think the Bitcoin Policy Institute's based there. Some
- 12:11folks have kind of definitely run into a lot of the areas. And I know that all the things that are
- 12:16items that you're mentioning with regards to tax legislation, you know, and, you know, mining
- 12:23revenue recognition have come up and they're definitely fighting for Bitcoin. You know,
- 12:30I think one thing that I've learned, especially through this and through the clarity act is this
- 12:35legislation takes a lot of time. So even if we're not in where we want to be today,
- 12:43there is some opportunity to get there. I think what's been clear on the legislation side and on
- 12:50the regulatory front is education has helped definitely paint the picture and understand,
- 12:59because I think there was a lot of misunderstanding or lack of understanding for many years.
- 13:04And now it's, you know, Bitcoin's, you know, it's not going, you know, it's here. It's not going away. So it is an area that has to be dealt with. And I think some of the legislation with the de minimis tax, I think to me makes a lot of sense, especially if you're just using, you know, the asset for small purchases.
- 13:27And then with regards to, I know that how the revenue recognition and singling out Bitcoin compared to other assets is not fair.
- 13:42So I think we're moving towards that direction.
- 13:46Unfortunately, I don't know if there's going to be a lot of material movement in the short
- 13:52term just because midterms and then we have other areas.
- 13:58What I do believe is it does give an opportunity for states to step in in some areas.
- 14:04I know that obviously from a tax perspective, you want to have a federal kind of mandate.
- 14:09But with regards to Bitcoin across the board, I think there's some opportunities to make
- 14:14headway in the states and say the coming year where there may not be a lot of activity or
- 14:20opportunity on the federal level yeah we've definitely gotten a lot less announcements
- 14:26in all caps from our our boy i'm forgetting his name right now but you guys know i'm talking about
- 14:32yeah mr porter yeah yeah mr porter so yeah that was we've looked through an interesting time
- 14:39on the regulatory side right there was at the beginning of the trump administration it was like
- 14:43every week another state was announcing that they're going to buy bitcoin and it seems like
- 14:49a lot of that is fizzled i guess in your in your conversations and what you've seen
- 14:54and especially with how things are probably trending on the midterm side i mean are we
- 15:01are we like walking right back into uh like a desert time where we're just going to be wandering
- 15:07in the desert for 40 years?
- 15:10Or do you think that it's bipartisan enough
- 15:14on the Bitcoin-specific side
- 15:16that we can still make headway,
- 15:19even with a divided Congress?
- 15:23Yeah, I think there's a lot of different ways
- 15:28you can kind of look at that.
- 15:29I think from a general, you know,
- 15:32given if the midterms obviously if flips in the midterms the head of the regulatory agencies are not going to change at least for the next two years So the SEC CFTC et cetera
- 15:44However, there's definitely going to be certainly a focus.
- 15:50Maxine Waters heads the financial services from consumer protection.
- 15:57I think, and then this is my opinion, right?
- 15:59is I think if you look at it from an investment advisor perspective, you're offering Bitcoins,
- 16:07you know, or advice to investors, potential investors. Bitcoin's like clearly a commodity
- 16:13from that aspect. So it's going to be not directly related by the SEC. In the States,
- 16:20obviously, if you're a regulated entity under theirs, you know, they could definitely look into
- 16:25that activity. But I think from the altcoin perspective, I think there's a lot more risk,
- 16:32right? That there is maybe a flush out of some of these projects. I think from, in my opinion,
- 16:43I think there's more bipartisan support on the Bitcoin side. It's obviously been around the
- 16:50the longest, it's easier to have that conversation with regards to regulators from a Bitcoin
- 17:01perspective.
- 17:06Yeah, it's interesting, Mark, because kind of how I see the regulatory compliance landscape
- 17:14shaped up.
- 17:15And this is specifically from my chair, my point of view.
- 17:19But I'm curious on how you kind of tell the story from your point of view,
- 17:23because when we look at the federal level, and we try not to use this word,
- 17:28but crypto has kind of been like this hot potato.
- 17:32It's like, is the SEC going to regulate it?
- 17:34Is the CFTC going to regulate it?
- 17:35Is this like random altcoin, a security?
- 17:39And so there's all this murkiness that like grabs the headlines
- 17:43and what people talk about.
- 17:45But what I found is a state regulated RIA and, you know, for its ill wills.
- 17:54I think Colorado has been pretty good on this where I was actually really nervous when I got registered if they were going to like pepper me about Bitcoin.
- 18:03It's like, hey, this is what I want to do.
- 18:04But it's actually been like pretty laxed, you know, I would say from my perspective.
- 18:10And so do we kind of have like this disparity between like, okay, flashy headlines, all
- 18:18of a sudden certainly at the federal level, but ultimately like when I'm doing my day-to-day
- 18:22work and helping with clients, like the state regulators, and I know obviously all the state
- 18:27regulators are going to be a little different, but they've actually been like pretty hands
- 18:30off.
- 18:31Let us do what we want to do.
- 18:32You know, don't interfere with like what we're talking to our clients about.
- 18:35So is it kind of like the tale of two stories?
- 18:38Is there some way you tie this together?
- 18:40Like, how are you talking to clients about this?
- 18:43Yeah, I think I think from the regulator, from the state side and the SEC, they they have generally come across other firms that are often, you know, that are advising on Bitcoin.
- 18:55They're they're more comfortable.
- 18:56They understand the asset more.
- 18:58They're definitely going to look at from the volatility perspective.
- 19:02So, you know, as obviously as an RA, you have that fiduciary responsibility to your clients.
- 19:07So the the and as I know that you do, you document that why, you know, that investment in the best interest of the client and the client understands, you know, the risk and the volatility.
- 19:22And with that, you know, you're you're acting in your fiduciary capacity.
- 19:27And from that perspective, the regulators, you know, they treat they just look at it as another asset class.
- 19:36You know, you have bonds, stocks, alternatives. It's kind of in that bucket of, you know, they potentially look at it as a riskier alternative asset.
- 19:47But they're going to look at how you allocate, you know, across your clients.
- 19:53And then also every client's different, right? So every circumstance comes down to that, like facts and circumstances.
- 19:58So I think from that perspective, it's not as scary.
- 20:02I think the first conversations that I had with regulators, they kind of they they they push the brakes a lot more.
- 20:10So it took a lot longer to get registered.
- 20:12And and they kind of they were like, let's maybe we push it down the road a little bit longer and and the federal level will take care of it.
- 20:21Now they're kind of taking that responsibility.
- 20:24The states are as well as the SEC and CFTC are putting out proposed rules and guidance almost on a daily, weekly basis.
- 20:31to help inform the community with regards to the rules of the roads in absence of true legislation like the Clarity Act.
- 20:42So I think from a perspective of timely guidance, I think that's...
- 20:50Although some people would want to see the Clarity Act pass, I think you're actually seeing more material involvement with the regulators now than you probably would have if the Clarity Act did not pass.
- 21:03In the short term, that's, I think, beneficial.
- 21:05Obviously, long term, you want to have that legislation to fall back on.
- 21:10Thank you.
- 21:40funds.com. Yeah, I mean, I'm, I'm curious for the mix of advisors and like fund managers that
- 21:52you're speaking with. I mean, are you, since you started, you know, earlier this year, like,
- 21:58have you been reaching out to advisors to help in that effort on education? Or are you more
- 22:03fielding inbound from people who are saying, Hey, we're, you know, we already understand the basics.
- 22:09we're looking to build a product on top of this and we're like, well, why it's doing.
- 22:14I'm just kind of curious what that mix is.
- 22:16And then especially if you've had conversations with folks who are like, we feel like we're
- 22:21being forced to go down this path because clients are pushing us to do so.
- 22:27What questions are you running into consistently and how are you communicating things to the
- 22:32folks that are like, I don't get Bitcoin, but it seems it won't die.
- 22:36And so I have to, I guess I have to learn about it or talk to someone like you about it.
- 22:43Yeah, I think my clients kind of sit in two buckets, whether that's that Bitcoin native or they've been working in the space for a number of years, whether it's managing client assets through a pulled investment vehicle or through separately managed accounts.
- 23:01So I think in that perspective, their clients are maybe more informed. They're used to, they understand the asset class, the volatility. And then there are some clients that are kind of looking at more traditional that they're looking to add in that asset class.
- 23:19And I think that's, it's kind of a different, as you know, from talking to your clients, it's a much different conversation.
- 23:26conversation. But I think the majority, you know, from whether it's the hedge fund space or the VC
- 23:34or the wealth management space, you know, have been in the space for a number of years, and it
- 23:41kind of weathered the storm with regards to the asset classes as a whole. And then you have
- 23:52kind of the new larger institutions that I've obviously leaned in like Charles Schwab,
- 23:59Fidelity, Morgan Stanley that offer some investment products that offer Bitcoin exposure
- 24:05and other exposure that clients can use in addition to like, you know, more,
- 24:10you know, holding the actual asset of the underlying asset.
- 24:17yeah are you seeing a lot of folks that like go down the rabbit hole and then they're like
- 24:24maybe i want to hold it in self-custody versus an etf and and especially on the lending side i know
- 24:31i mean why and you could probably talk a lot about this but this whole being able to lend against
- 24:37your or take a loan against your bitcoin but still have eyes on where it is from a self-custody
- 24:42standpoint um and then maybe at some point we can we can talk about regulations on obviously
- 24:49everyone doesn't want regulation on self-custody but after what we saw with cold card from a consumer
- 24:56protection standpoint alone right i mean i think that that's probably a conversation that has to be
- 25:01had so but i'm curious on the lending side specifically be it you got to hand over all
- 25:07all the control versus, hey, can we have some shared control over the asset?
- 25:13Yeah, I would say that on the wealth management side, whereas RAs are managing assets,
- 25:21in case where they potentially don't have custody of client assets, the assets are held at a qualified custodian or self-custody,
- 25:29You know, they that qualified custodian, whether that's Anchorage or whether that's, you know, Coinbase for et cetera, they generally would have the assets.
- 25:41And I would say that that's typically on the pulled investment vehicle side is generally pulled investment vehicles.
- 25:49Depending on the state, you have to have an annual audit.
- 25:52So the audit is looking at the custody and the control with regards to the storage and the custody of those assets So that audit is looking at where those assets are custody
- 26:09what's the process to initiate a transaction.
- 26:13And getting to the cold card, obviously, I think you both probably know the instance
- 26:18probably even a little bit better than me, but I think it definitely kind of opened the eyes
- 26:22like with regards to the risk related to self-custody,
- 26:27making sure that your clients understand the potential risk.
- 26:33And then I think there has been a movement since then
- 26:36to kind of multi-sig as well as qualified custodians
- 26:42or other custodians.
- 26:44But I think there's always going to be a portion of the community
- 26:49that chooses to self-custody, right?
- 26:51So I think that's not going to change, at least in my opinion.
- 26:58And I think there was definitely areas that it opened up from, I guess, a third party kind of due diligence perspective with regards to the wallets and et cetera.
- 27:15But I think that's kind of a bump in the road.
- 27:18And I think self-custody is going to improve.
- 27:21I think cryptology, it has not failed, right?
- 27:27It's just some, there's been, there were some areas,
- 27:29and I think there was a bug back in what, 2021,
- 27:32that just gave the ability that the actual keys that were being,
- 27:40it was, you were able to back into that.
- 27:44It was not truly random.
- 27:46So I think, I don't think AI played a role in this,
- 27:49But I think with AI, there's going to be a lot more attempts with regards to trying to crack some of these or infiltrate and have some additional cyber breaches.
- 28:01So it just really emphasizes the need for how important from a cyber perspective your controls and security is now.
- 28:12and it almost has to exponentially increase over time with,
- 28:15with like the increased risk that we see on a, on a, uh,
- 28:20almost daily and weekly basis.
- 28:22Yeah. Yeah. And just, just to say it for the record, right.
- 28:26It was a bug in a specific vendor's software,
- 28:29not a bug in Bitcoin core software,
- 28:33just for any newbie that's listening to this, like what the heck? Um, so.
- 28:42This episode is brought to you by SoundHSA, a Bitcoin native health savings account.
- 28:50SoundHSA lets Americans hold Bitcoin inside an HSA with compliant custody and Bitcoin only investment option.
- 28:57They support employer, individual and family plans designed for long duration saving.
- 29:02Learn more at SoundHSA.com.
- 29:05yeah well i'm curious mark i know you're not a lawyer but just you know having spent a lot of
- 29:15time on like the regulatory and compliance breach with the cold card situation itself
- 29:20you know maybe we can kind of take this in two parts like do you see any regulatory compliance
- 29:28and then if you want to put like your lawyer hat like legal breach on the terms of like
- 29:31cold card specifically themselves. And then, you know, when things like this happen and inevitably
- 29:38there'll be something else that happens, like what regulatory or compliance protections are in place
- 29:45for like the end consumer and then like professionals like engaging with different
- 29:50vendors, you know, you know, there is a breach of some sort of whatever, like what are like the
- 29:55appropriate courses of actions you should take to address and correct the situation. And then like
- 30:01what kind of internal policies and procedures should you have in place to, you know, be able
- 30:06to act accordingly? Yeah, I think, you know, when these cases come up, you know, generally,
- 30:15it's a reactive response from a regulator, you know, I know this is not the same way, but like
- 30:21FTX, etc., when there is a large kind of public event, they're going to kind of look at if there
- 30:29is any kind of like first thing is they're going to try to find like retail client harm right like
- 30:35were there assets that that you potentially manage that were impacted and clients were impacted and
- 30:42obviously they lost money um if there's no if there's no general loss of funds they may kind of
- 30:48go for the bigger fish right uh you know for that area so i think you know once they dig in they're
- 30:56going to look at, is there a way that you could have reasonably identified the issue?
- 31:02So looking at your vendor due diligence program initially and on an ongoing basis reviewing for for example the methodology with regards to the private keys is there ways that you could have identified it In some cases it would have been really hard
- 31:23you know, to identify that prior to actually that bug being identified. So in those cases,
- 31:31I think the regulators generally understand, but they want to see that,
- 31:36A, have you disclosed if you do have clients that have self-custody, do they understand that there is risk of loss of those assets?
- 31:48And some of this may come from complaints that come from those clients or customers across the industry.
- 31:56And they may say, I thought this was 100% protected.
- 32:01I could never lose my assets, which is obviously not the case.
- 32:05But, you know, it's coming it's coming down to this like education.
- 32:08And I think if you have a reasonable basis to like to identify and vet your vendors and then also adequately disclose the risk to your clients and to your investors.
- 32:21Those are the areas that the regulators seem to focus on.
- 32:31Thanks to River for supporting this episode.
- 32:33River is a Bitcoin-only financial institution, a brokerage and cash management platform that's full reserve and proof of reserves verified.
- 32:41They offer recurring buys, corporate treasury rails, and white glove services for private clients and advisors with a single asset focus.
- 32:48Learn more at river.com.
- 32:56Yeah, I mean, it brings up two interesting points.
- 32:59I mean, the first one I would say is just like, I think Coldcard would have been in, or CoinKot, I should say, their parent company, like, would have been in a difficult position, even if they had discovered it, right?
- 33:12Because they didn't collect emails, apparently, right?
- 33:16I think that maybe that's come out to be that they said that, but that was not totally true.
- 33:21um so they identify and say they don't have the emails how do you even communicate with
- 33:26with your customers that hey that that random number generator yeah they're our only job yeah
- 33:32we failed on that so you need to go move your funds you can't say that publicly because then
- 33:37everyone then you just uh tip off the bad guys yeah so that's kind of interesting not really a
- 33:42question just kind of interesting thought uh the main question would be like with coin kite being
- 33:47a Canadian-based company, and I know you deal, like, since Bitcoin and this whole world is so
- 33:53international and global, I mean, how do the regulators in the United States even approach
- 33:59a situation where the failure and loss of funds was all due to, you know, a company that's outside
- 34:06of the borders of the United States, or at least domiciled outside the United States, but has major
- 34:12operations in the United States? I'm just curious how they normally would go about that.
- 34:17Yeah, I think, you know, I think the, you know, like, I think the FTX is an example where they was it was a BBI, Bermuda, I think it was, but there was obviously a lot of operations in the US.
- 34:32You know, when there are those large cases, it kind of identifies the areas of their gaps, right? So I think it does speak to the need to have kind of that legislation and the sharing of information across jurisdictions.
- 34:48But I think that they probably are obviously more comfortable with working with U.S.-based companies that are regulated and you get a certain, especially ones that are audited.
- 35:01In the absence of that, they're definitely looking at the firm's kind of like, do they have a SOC 2? Are there other SOC reports that they have? They're reviewing, have you reviewed the return of control reports, et cetera, coming back to that due diligence.
- 35:18So I think in cases where assets are held at an offshore exchange, for example, that may have lax regulations compared to the US, that's where some of the red flags kind of tip at from the regulator perspective.
- 35:38But, you know, since it's that, I mean, the wall is just a hardware. It's not like they're, you're not transacting activities. It's obviously a lower risk, right?
- 35:49And I think in regulators, I think there's no per se AML obligation for investment advisors today.
- 36:00There was a proposed rule that got finalized.
- 36:02I expect that that will probably be pushed forward in the coming years.
- 36:09So I think the kind of anti-money laundering, know your customer framework is going to continue to kind of move into what it already is.
- 36:21But I think that going to just be and continue to be like a new normal with regards to you know with that kind of tracing of transactions and once the regulators have access to that they
- 36:35obviously want to be able to trace back those bad actors or their sanctioned wallets etc
- 36:44Thanks to Revolution Mortgage for supporting the show.
- 36:53Revolution is a technology-driven mortgage lender built around speed, transparency, and low overhead
- 36:58with loan officers who understand clients whose balance sheet includes Bitcoin.
- 37:03Purchase, refinance, and jumbo lending across the U.S.
- 37:07Learn more at revolutionmortgage.com.
- 37:14Well, let's double click on that a little bit, Mark, because I believe it was Jameson Lopp
- 37:23that originally made this argument.
- 37:26At least I heard it from him, but founder of Casa, very similar to Unchained.
- 37:30We're seeing more and more of these businesses developing, which I think is a good thing,
- 37:35developing tools for folks like myself, folks like Jordan to utilize with their clients,
- 37:40their clients, you know, the development of self-custody, like all good stuff.
- 37:45And Mr. Lopp's case is with all this KYC information, you know,
- 37:51and you set up, you know, strike or unchained account,
- 37:54and you got to pull out your phone and scan your face.
- 37:56And like, I'm a pretty conservative libertarian guy, you know.
- 37:59I'm not like a big government folk over here.
- 38:03And his main argument is like, dude, you are creating via your regulations,
- 38:09like honeypots for bad actors.
- 38:12And I mean, it really, really puts a lot of strain
- 38:15on the entrepreneurial startup space
- 38:18because you have like, I mean,
- 38:21like we kind of touched on too, you know,
- 38:22with the AI and everybody's scanning
- 38:25everybody else's software.
- 38:26I mean, you have to have like legal compliance,
- 38:30security compliance, like, and not that they,
- 38:32you know, shouldn't, but you're just adding
- 38:33like a very large burden on them.
- 38:36So I do kind of push back against like the KYC argument
- 38:39a lot of the times AML argument because it feels like security theater to me and it's actually
- 38:44creating more risks and harm do you think I have a leg to stand on there do you kind of see it from
- 38:49a different angle yeah I think the um so the there has been like I think of the FinCEN had a
- 38:56beneficial ownership uh rule that was rescinded I guess probably the last year or so after the
- 39:02administration that required beneficial ownership of basically every U.S. based company
- 39:08and talking about a honeypot of information that could be leaked out that you could obviously argue
- 39:15that would be the case. So I think there has been movement with regards to understanding
- 39:20cases that are like overburdensome, especially for a small entrepreneur, small companies.
- 39:30But looking at, you know, looking at where, again, the Clarity Act didn't pass. So obviously,
- 39:38Lord knows what it's going to look like when and if it does.
- 39:43But they did, to try to get bipartisan support across the board, they did strengthen a lot of the AML KYC piece.
- 39:53And that would have, it generally would put the requirement on like the exchange side, you know, and the broker dealer side.
- 40:02So it may not go all the way down to like self-custody, wallets, et cetera.
- 40:08And so I think there's an understanding of like right size regulation and appears to
- 40:18be putting the burden on kind of the higher risk areas, like with regards to where there's
- 40:24a lot of transacting, the exchanges, et cetera.
- 40:28yeah yeah i mean we've even had some clients that you know they're considering bringing a certain
- 40:37part of their business on shore and but in order to do so they'd have to require kyc
- 40:44and that's honestly like one of their moats right is we don't you know we don't take your
- 40:51information and so for whatever part of the bitcoin network that they're operating in
- 40:56they get more customers because they're able to do that. I mean, I saw that you, um, that you do
- 41:03like part of your business model is consulting on the anti money laundering stuff and then helping
- 41:10companies set up in Bermuda, uh, or BVI. And just kind of curious if you could talk through,
- 41:16you know, are you still seeing like a good amount of activity where you have part of your business
- 41:22like operating out of that jurisdiction
- 41:25versus other parts in the United States or elsewhere
- 41:29and how they can all talk to each other,
- 41:32transact together, stay within compliance of US law?
- 41:38Yeah, I think from my experience
- 41:39came in and bvi side is typically on like pulled investment vehicles where those vehicles are
- 41:44domiciled in those entities and i think i think there's many reasons why like a hedge fund or
- 41:50vc fund would be domiciled there part of that's like tax related um the the actual aml requirements
- 41:58there in in some cases are actually more or stricter and more stringent than even the us side
- 42:05Obviously, there are certainly a perception that there are additional requirements on if you domicile your funds there than in the US, like from an AML KYC perspective that are stricter.
- 42:25I think, you know, from an operating company perspective, yeah, I'm definitely, again, that's not really my wheel.
- 42:33I wouldn't go to death and say that that's my wheelhouse.
- 42:35But I think it's been very common that the entities have been domiciled offshore with regards to, you know, mitigating some of the U.S. risk.
- 42:46And certainly firms have had cases where they chose not to have U.S. customers because it was unclear with regards to where the U.S. regulators were and still are.
- 43:00And so I think there is opportunity for jurisdiction review from a lawyer that would kind of look at the pros and cons and obviously your product, your offering, where your clients are, et cetera.
- 43:15so I think
- 43:17there has been a general trend
- 43:19to move on shore for some of these
- 43:21companies that did move offshore
- 43:23when you
- 43:25had a lot of the kind of
- 43:27regulation by enforcement
- 43:29where you only learned
- 43:31about what you should do
- 43:32when a new enforcement action
- 43:35came through
- 43:36and
- 43:39but I
- 43:40think that trend
- 43:42you know
- 43:43is going to continue to probably move on shore.
- 43:48But I think what's going to put the brakes on a little bit is I think some of the legislation,
- 43:57like you said, the tax side, as well as the Clarity Act side,
- 44:00they're potentially not going to have a lot of movement in the next six months or a year.
- 44:08So I think a lot of the firms that have gone on shore,
- 44:11you know they're probably still assessing where the best place is though um that the best place
- 44:17for their business um obviously to mitigate the risk and then from a cost perspective um and
- 44:24you know so i think it's kind of like a fact again coming back to facts and circumstances
- 44:30of your business and where and where where is best suited yeah it's uh it's interesting yeah
- 44:38Because we considered for PAX partners kind of doing a dual fund structure,
- 44:46that master feeder and having an offshore entity.
- 44:49So I was getting into the Cayman weeds a couple months ago.
- 44:53I was like, oh, my goodness.
- 44:55I was like, yeah, I think, you know, you correct me if I'm wrong here,
- 44:57but they have some sort of like global AML system or whatever that they, you know, opted into.
- 45:02I was like, wow, this is a real rabbit hole.
- 45:04I do want to get your opinion on choke point 1.0, choke point 2.0, and some of the fallout before that because of that.
- 45:15But before we do, I want to circle back to one thing you said about fiduciary duty because I've been kind of workshopping this idea and I want to get your take on it.
- 45:24I feel like, and I've discussed a lot of them on the pod here, but there's a lot of ill wills, I think, with the traditional wealth management industry.
- 45:32And specifically when it comes to Bitcoin, when I do talk to some skeptical, you know, RIAs, you know, my peers in the traditional finance world, it almost seems like they're actually hiding behind.
- 45:45This is my opinion. They're hiding behind a misinterpretation of the fiduciary responsibility they have to clients.
- 45:53And what I hear a lot is like, yeah, you have bigger shops. Like I think Fidelity is up to like a 10 percent Bitcoin allocation.
- 46:00But then when an advisor interprets like their fiduciary duty, they hide behind like one, the word itself.
- 46:07I'm not sure they actually understand their fiduciary duty.
- 46:09And then to like this broad, overly broad diversification of clients assets.
- 46:16So they don't feel like they can ever get like in trouble from a fiduciary standpoint.
- 46:21But when I read and interpret the fiduciary standard rules, it's incumbent on me to understand what my client wants, their level of understanding with their portfolio, and then make recommendations from there, what we already talked on.
- 46:38So are you seeing any of that Do you sit down with advisors and they regurgitate some BS understanding of fiduciary guidelines and diversification you like dude you totally wrong here Do you think my theory is like total BS and I should just stay in my lane No no I think I think there a lot
- 46:58of opinions, you know, from, from, from advisors. So I think, yeah, I think, I think, you know,
- 47:05the way that I look at it is, yeah, like the, you have to look at where you, where your client was
- 47:12was before you started managing their money, if you've documented all of their net worth,
- 47:21their risk tolerance, their time horizon. I think liquidity comes into a big part of that.
- 47:28With regards to, in many cases, they hold Bitcoin, maybe they had a pretty high percentage when they
- 47:35came to an advisor. And potentially you've trimmed some of that for liquidity purposes.
- 47:40But I think the old 60-40 allocation is kind of a little bit out the window.
- 47:49And I think even a lot of the traditional advisors will say that.
- 47:53I think that from advisors that advise and kind of focus on the Bitcoin space, in my experience, it is obviously, they're going to have probably higher exposure to Bitcoin compared to other traditional advisors, right?
- 48:15So maybe some of the Morgan Stanley's or Charles Schwab, they're like 2%, right?
- 48:21But some of the clients that you come across or some other advisors that are in the space, maybe they came to you and they have 80% of their assets, 90% of their assets in Bitcoin, right?
- 48:33So they're coming to you to look at, I want to manage my wealth long term.
- 48:38I believe in this asset class.
- 48:42So it comes down to the documentation, any additional education kind of risk related to that.
- 48:49And then managing that portfolio based on, you know, those, that individual client circumstances, like when are those kind of liquidity, you know, whether it's college or large expenses that you have to work around.
- 49:05So I think with regards to having adequate documentation and a good framework and understanding your clients goes a long way.
- 49:16right and the other way the other area where like regulators um may jump in is they have a lot of
- 49:24client complaints but if you've done if your clients understand the asset class and they
- 49:30understand the ups and downs they are less likely probably to to complain a bit about you personally
- 49:36um and how you're managing the clients so i think it it does come that it is a little bit different
- 49:41if you're a traditional advisor and you're kind of coming up, getting them off zero.
- 49:47And, you know, that is probably a little different conversation.
- 49:52But I think the fiduciary definition is broader than, you know,
- 50:00potentially what other advisors tell you why.
- 50:02So I don't think you're off there.
- 50:04All right, great.
- 50:05No, thank you.
- 50:06I love having my own biases confirmed.
- 50:08So that's a win for me on the day.
- 50:10I do have one last question in this realm before we finish up the conversation with Chokepoint.
- 50:17But I'm part of the Bitcoin Financial Advisors Network.
- 50:21And, yeah, we have like a quarterly like brain trust meeting and we share ideas, case studies, etc.
- 50:27And a few of those folks were CFPs, in a sense, dropped their CFP designation because they started getting nasty letters from the CFP board about Bitcoin and talking to clients about Bitcoin.
- 50:43So I'm just curious if you have run across that, if you have any thoughts and opinions on the map.
- 50:49this episode is supported by sustain hash sustain hash is a one-stop solution for bitcoin miners
- 51:01offering custom site management for asic setups certified asic repair at individual and bulk
- 51:07rates and sales mining hardware and equipment they manage data centers and mining sites across
- 51:12alberta and the united states built to sustainable practices and dependable service learn more at
- 51:18sustainhash.com. Yeah, actually, I'm not going to lie, I have not directly heard about that. So,
- 51:31you know, a number of financial, a number of advisors, you know, could have CFP, some of them
- 51:36could even have a CFA if they were kind of in the asset management business before becoming an
- 51:41advisor. Yeah, I don't know if I can.
- 51:45I can't directly upon on that because I haven't had that direct experience.
- 51:51I do think that that is unfortunate if they're being forced to drop their
- 51:58designation just because they have a focus in the Bitcoin space I think that educating the CFP board and understanding the difference between investment advisors There like over 15 there like tens of
- 52:16thousands of investment advisors across the US. And some of them are very concentrated,
- 52:22especially on the alternative space where, you know, there is cases where,
- 52:28and there's some leveraged ETFs that two, three time leveraged ETFs of any asset you can think of.
- 52:34Right. So, yeah, I think, and some of those individuals have a CFP or CFA. So, yeah, I don't
- 52:42know. I don't know. I have not come across that. It's a, it is unfortunate that if that actually
- 52:48is occurring because I think if they understand that individual's business model and their clients,
- 52:56they might not come to that same conclusion. Right. Yeah. Interesting.
- 53:07This episode is brought to you by Abundant Minds. Abundant Minds makes it easy to own Bitcoin mining
- 53:12equipment without the complexity. They handle setup, maintenance, and daily operations while
- 53:18you own the miners. US-based infrastructure, real technicians, and 24-7 monitoring. If you
- 53:23rather produce Bitcoin than buy it, they'll walk you through whether it's a fit for your goals.
- 53:27Learn more at AbundantMines.com.
- 53:35Yeah, so I think, I'm assuming what you're talking about is like choke point one point,
- 53:40you know, where like it was like, um,
- 53:44it could kind of go back to like the payday lenders, you know,
- 53:48companies that were marijuana focus, um, also, um,
- 53:52Bitcoin digital asset focus where they were unable to, uh,
- 53:56set up like business accounts and really be able to like, uh, act in the,
- 54:00in the traditional system and the banking system. And that, I think that, um,
- 54:06that was, uh, you know,
- 54:07I had a number of like years back that that was real, that they,
- 54:10it was hard for them to set up a U S bank accounts, you know,
- 54:15integrate with certain vendors because of the, you know,
- 54:21where they kind of were what industry they're in or what area they were
- 54:25focused in. I think that that I,
- 54:32I, I, it does not appear that that issue is,
- 54:36has like, has gotten worse.
- 54:39I think it's gotten better, generally speaking, that,
- 54:43especially I think with you, with regards to at least,
- 54:46you talk about Bitcoin specifically,
- 54:48many of the large institutions are leaning into, you know, for good,
- 54:53you know so I think that's case.
- 54:57I think that that the checkpoint 2.0 and 3.0,
- 55:00hopefully it's not impacting the Bitcoin community as much as it did say five plus years in the past.
- 55:09That's, that's my view, I think. However, I think that,
- 55:13that, you know, I think the hard thing is like, for example, if you're, and again, this is not my
- 55:27But if you're a bank or a credit union, whatever the case may be, you have you choose like where like who you're in trend, like potentially who you're going to work with.
- 55:37And you may not like it comes down to the education. Right. And they may just choose.
- 55:42We don't know this risk. We don't really understand the risk. So they just choose to cut it off altogether.
- 55:49So I guess it's, you know, that they potentially have that ability.
- 55:55However, I know there was like an executive order that they could not do that.
- 56:00So I think that they I think institutions are being forced to kind of better understand the risk and those industries and then be able to like regurgitate and discuss with a regulator why they have chose not to do business with a certain company, for example.
- 56:20so I think for what that's worth I think there's been some some positive movement to
- 56:26on the education front to to not appear to have that choke point but I think you know I'm sure
- 56:36some of that still happens today yeah I mean for what it's worth we just had a client got
- 56:41debanked um pretty big account and they got debanked from jp morgan chase and and so you know
- 56:51i always i mean it's uh it's spicy take but i mean they weren't willing to do business with
- 56:56this client but of course they they did business with jeffrey epstein so i think
- 57:01But it does create a lot of opportunity at least from my seat for the smaller banks that don have as much capital under management to come in and say well we going to learn about this and we going to create a niche in this environment
- 57:24And we'll take on a Bitcoin mining company and do their banking activity with them.
- 57:30So it's still kind of a weird world out there.
- 57:35If someone wants to go and set up a bank account with Mercury, generally speaking,
- 57:40It's like if they're a mining company, maybe just say you're a data center company.
- 57:44You know, don't get too specific with the wording there because we've still seen applications be denied just because you even have the word Bitcoin on your website versus, you know, of course, if it's crypto or, you know, some kind of scam altcoin.
- 58:02It's like I can understand that.
- 58:04I can get behind that.
- 58:05But Bitcoin is a totally different story.
- 58:07So I think you're right that it's just a complete lack of education or lack of curiosity from the big banks.
- 58:15Well, and building on that, Mark, I mean, I totally agree with Jordan.
- 58:21It's like, OK, in theory, you know, that free market dynamic should create opportunity for for somebody else.
- 58:26But, you know, we have Alan Lane, former CEO of Silvergate, coming out to the summit to talk about his time there.
- 58:33He just did, opened up quite a bit on what Bitcoin did and did an episode on his experience.
- 58:40And, you know, a lot of this is like post-mortem and understand like by legal decree from the president, which is my understanding, you know, executive orders kind of stop some of these antagonistic practices by the regulators.
- 58:57but you know it's not enshrined in laws so you know the next administration could you know
- 59:02overturn that but just in understanding this isn't wasn't your direct
- 59:08you line of regulations but just you know knowing folks that worked in that industry talking to
- 59:13folks like when we see this regulatory overstep like what how do you interpret that situation
- 59:21like and what is kind of like you're behind closed doors when you're talking to other
- 59:26the regulatory buddies, like what are people saying?
- 59:31Yeah, I don't know.
- 59:32I do think it was interesting.
- 59:34Silvergate was allowed to fail, but none of the other ones were, right?
- 59:38So like they, yeah, I mean, and again, this is my opinion, potentially because they were
- 59:46crypto focused, they kind of were SVB and obviously they were acquired.
- 59:54But, you know, again, I guess I think that comes, unfortunately, based on the, you know, the perception of risk, right, and perception of customers.
- 1:00:04um yeah yeah i think that's yeah i mean i think i think that i i agree with you i think that
- 1:00:15some of the larger institutions are going to have like they're very like if if you say you're in
- 1:00:21this industry then here's all the additional requirements that you're gonna have there's
- 1:00:25like there's they built that in their framework and there's no like getting around it so in that
- 1:00:29case, it's making it much harder. And it gives that opportunity, like, and that, you know,
- 1:00:34from capitalist perspective for smaller banks and credit unions to kind of lean in on the space
- 1:00:40and still operate within the regulatory framework and be able to provide, educate themselves on
- 1:00:48those industries and provide those services. So, you know, I think that's probably like you said,
- 1:00:53the win in this case,
- 1:00:56you may not be able to move
- 1:00:58some of these larger institutions.
- 1:01:01You may be able to push one or two of them
- 1:01:03but not across the board.
- 1:01:08Interesting.
- 1:01:10I appreciate that, Mark.
- 1:01:11Do you want to wrap it up now, Jordan?
- 1:01:15I was going to let you after my fumble.
- 1:01:19Dude, well...
- 1:01:21We've done, I've done that like three or four different times.
- 1:01:24So I apologize.
- 1:01:26Yeah, it's gotta be more than that, but it's fine.
- 1:01:28We worked through it anyway, but no, Mark,
- 1:01:31thank you for coming on, man.
- 1:01:31You're a plethora of information.
- 1:01:33Excited to be working with you.
- 1:01:35Excited to have you at the summit.
- 1:01:37I really appreciate your support and participation
- 1:01:40in BFFS land.
- 1:01:41But yeah, you know, if folks are interested
- 1:01:43in working with you, they want to ask you questions,
- 1:01:45pick your brain, kind of navigate the landscape,
- 1:01:47how do they get ahold of you?
- 1:01:48Yeah, again, really looking forward to
- 1:01:50going out to the summit as well
- 1:01:52in Denver. It's only about a week
- 1:01:55and a half away.
- 1:01:57Yeah, so get a hold of me at
- 1:02:01cryptoregulatory solutions.com
- 1:02:03my link to my socials
- 1:02:07and email and phone number
- 1:02:09right there. So feel free to reach
- 1:02:11out. Again, primarily work with
- 1:02:13investment advisors in the space
- 1:02:15as well as other
- 1:02:17institutions that are
- 1:02:19focus in the Bitcoin space, digital asset space.
- 1:02:22So, yeah, happy to be aware.
- 1:02:26Looking forward to seeing you both here at the summit.
- 1:02:29and see where we can go.
- 1:02:32Beautiful.
- 1:02:33Thanks so much for your time today, Mark.
- 1:02:35We'll see you very soon.
- 1:02:35Yeah, thanks, Mark.
- 1:02:36Thank you.
- 1:02:38Have a good one.
- 1:02:44We appreciate you joining us.
- 1:02:46If you want to help build a future of Bitcoin financial services,
- 1:02:48hit subscribe, leave a review, sign up for a newsletter,
- 1:02:51and share this with someone in your network
- 1:02:53who's integrating Bitcoin into their practice.
- 1:02:55If you work in finance and want to understand
- 1:02:57how Bitcoin is changing wealth management,
- 1:02:58lending, custody, retirement planning, and capital formation, you need to be at the Bitcoin
- 1:03:04Financial Services Summit October 20th through 22nd in Denver at the space. We're bringing
- 1:03:09together some of the smartest operators in the industry for practical conversations focused on
- 1:03:13what's actually working today. Register now at bffs.media.com. The more professionals we reach,
- 1:03:21the stronger this ecosystem becomes and our clients are better served. Stay sharp, stay sovereign,
- 1:03:25keep lean from the front.
- 1:03:28Thank you.