Latest / Distillations | Science History Institute / Poison Booze
Transcript
- 0:02From the Science History Institute, I'm Alexis Patrick, and this is
- 0:07Distillations: American Vice: Risk, Science, and the American Experience.
- 0:15The roaring '20s.
- 0:18It was a time of huge political, scientific, and cultural transformation
- 0:23in the US, a time that many consider to be the beginning of the modern era.
- 0:28It was a decade packed with big historical moments.
- 0:32There were major political shifts, like when the 19th Amendment was
- 0:35ratified on August 18th, 1920, finally giving women the right to vote.
- 0:41Alice Paul, suffrage leader, is first to vote by mail in New Jersey.
- 0:46Ms. Paul, a dramatic campaigner, had gone on a hunger strike earlier in an
- 0:50effort to force congressional action.
- 0:54There were some big scientific moments, too.
- 0:57In 1922, we got insulin.
- 0:59In 1927, we got the first nonstop transatlantic flight.
- 1:0433 and a half hours after takeoff in New York, Charles Lindbergh on the
- 1:09Spirit of St. Louis landed at Le Bourget Airport near Paris on May 21st, 1927
- 1:17In 1928, penicillin
- 1:19Fleming noticed that some mold, such as appears on decaying
- 1:23food, had begun to grow.
- 1:24And also cultural shifts, like in fashion.
- 1:28That's it, the all-over look.
- 1:29No waistline, no curves, and no worries about vital statistics
- 1:35And of course, there was the music.
- 1:38I wanna be loved by you, just you.
- 1:43Nobody else but you.
- 1:46I wanna be loved by you alone.
- 1:52Boo boo ba doo.
- 1:54And in the background of all of this, a small thing was taking place, a
- 1:58thing that led to gin-soaked tap rooms that required secret passwords.
- 2:03I'm talking about Prohibition.
- 2:07Boo boo ba doo.
- 2:09On January 16th, 1919, the 18th Amendment to the US Constitution was
- 2:15ratified, banning the production, importation, transportation,
- 2:19and sale of alcoholic beverages.
- 2:22Nine months later, Congress passed the Volstead Act, a federal law which
- 2:27established the legal definition of intoxicating liquors and
- 2:31introduced penalties for production.
- 2:34Twice in a few weeks, the government has struck.
- 2:37This time, a brewery on South State Street said to belong to Al Capone.
- 2:42It's a scene of joy or sorrow, depending on how you feel about it.
- 2:48There was a lot going on.
- 2:51As Nick Carraway says in The Great Gatsby, quote, "I was within and
- 2:55without, simultaneously enchanted and repelled by the inexhaustible
- 3:00variety of life," unquote.
- 3:03And I haven't even mentioned the social turmoil.
- 3:06In the backwash of war, depression, and a rising hysteria.
- 3:10In a single year, 61 murders by lynching.
- 3:15Revolution in Russia touching off panic at home.
- 3:19And through it all, despite what the law said, Americans kept drinking.
- 3:25Now, maybe you're thinking, "Okay, that's interesting.
- 3:29But how is Prohibition a science story?" And that's what we thought,
- 3:33too, until we stumbled across a shocking piece of information.
- 3:38During Prohibition, government scientists were tasked with helping
- 3:42to enforce the law, and they did it by poisoning the liquor supply.
- 3:50It was six years into the prohibition experiment and things weren't going great.
- 3:55It was like, well, prohibition is failing.
- 3:58People are still drinking.
- 4:00What if we use chemical enforcement?
- 4:02This is Deborah Blum, a toxicology journalist and author
- 4:06of several books about poison.
- 4:08If the fact that the government poisoned the alcohol supply didn't
- 4:12shock you enough, maybe this will.
- 4:15They poisoned it and people drank it anyway.
- 4:18It's baffling.
- 4:21But as we so often say, the reason was also complicated.
- 4:25And to understand it, we have to start with poison itself.
- 4:32Chapter one: The Inheritance Powder.
- 4:36To understand how prohibition, chemistry, and poison became strange
- 4:41bedfellows, we need to go back to the 1800s, when apparently a lot of people
- 4:46were, well, poisoning each other.
- 4:50If people who were poisoned would put their hands up in cemeteries,
- 4:54you would see hands rising out of graves all over the cemetery.
- 4:58Right?
- 5:00Arsenic was a popular poison because it was tasteless, odorless, and colorless.
- 5:06It's a broad spectrum cellular poison that mimics the symptoms of a natural illness.
- 5:11So you're poisoned with arsenic.
- 5:13You get an upset stomach.
- 5:14You get a sore throat.
- 5:15Your muscles ache, right?
- 5:17So especially in the 19th century when they were barely figuring out how to find
- 5:22it in a corpse, it just got diagnosed as all kinds of natural illnesses.
- 5:30Arsenic was nicknamed the inheritance powder.
- 5:33Your rich aunt isn't dying quickly enough for your liking?
- 5:37Arsenic to the rescue.
- 5:39And it was widely available.
- 5:41I mean, it used to be super easy to get your hands on arsenic.
- 5:44It was in cosmetics.
- 5:45It was in tonics.
- 5:48And because it was hanging out in your average medicine cabinet and in household
- 5:52goods, women especially had access to arsenic, and they put it to use.
- 5:58Women choose poison as a weapon about seven times as often as men.
- 6:02That's another FBI statistic, actually.
- 6:06And it suits us.
- 6:07We're planners.
- 6:12But don't get me wrong, we're not trying to say Victorian era women were just
- 6:16going around murdering people for fun.
- 6:23In the 19th century in particular, women had very little power, surprise, surprise.
- 6:29If you were married, you couldn't own property, et cetera.
- 6:33And so if you were in an abusive situation, arsenic was
- 6:38one of your ways out of it.
- 6:40And there was a really famous science historian from Caltech, Dan Kevles,
- 6:45who called poison the great equalizer for women of the 19th century.
- 6:49It was the one thing they could use to get themselves out of a bad situation.
- 6:54So you saw a lot of that, too.
- 6:56It wasn't just inheritance, it was escape.
- 6:59But soon, poisons like arsenic would stop being so hard to detect.
- 7:04Scientists had been working on isolating and identifying the chemical compounds
- 7:09and basic elements that make up our world.
- 7:12In 1804, the culmination of all that research was published.
- 7:16Maybe you've heard of it: the Periodic Table of Elements.
- 7:21It became a crucial tool for chemists working on poisons.
- 7:25There was a quite famous Spanish chemist based in Paris named Orfila who wrote
- 7:33the first textbook on detecting poison.
- 7:37Given that Orfila was such a fan of short book titles, like Directions
- 7:42for the Treatments of Persons Who Have Taken Poison, and Those in a
- 7:45State of Apparent Death, Together with the Means of Detecting Poisons
- 7:48and Adulterations in Wine, Also of Distinguishing Real from Apparent
- 7:51Death, we trust this was a short one.
- 7:57If you look at that book, which I have in my very nerdy way, um, you know, he
- 8:03basically acknowledges that we can't detect almost any poison in a corpse,
- 8:08but, you know, we're figuring it out.
- 8:13Matthew Orphea thought that metallic poisons like arsenic would be the
- 8:17easiest to detect in the body's tissues, so that's where he focused his
- 8:22research, and he was on the right track.
- 8:27By the late 1830s, we had the first test for isolating arsenic.
- 8:32Over the next 10 years, scientists developed reliable tests that could
- 8:36be used in criminal prosecutions.
- 8:39Arsenic is a metalloid poison.
- 8:41The elemental arsenic shares qualities with metal.
- 8:44It's not a true metal like, say, a lead, but it has some metallic
- 8:48qualities and it's, so it's classified as a metalloid poison.
- 8:52Once they could detect that in a corpse, they figured out how to
- 8:55identify other metallic poisons.
- 8:58Plant poisons were more difficult.
- 9:00That was a very different chemistry.
- 9:03It wasn't until a French chemist, Jean Servais Stas, figured out
- 9:07how to isolate nicotine from a corpse that we made progress.
- 9:13So you start seeing in the 19th century this kind of bedrock of all
- 9:18the natural occurring poisons, the arsenics and the antimonies, which
- 9:22are found in the Earth's crust, and the cyanides and the strychnines,
- 9:26which are found in plants, all of them now kind of revealing their secrets.
- 9:31But as fast as scientists figured out how to detect a poison, poisoners would
- 9:36find new ways to disguise their crimes.
- 9:39In her book, The Poisoner's Handbook: Murder and the Birth of Forensic
- 9:43Medicine in Jazz Age New York, Deborah calls it a deadly cat and mouse game.
- 9:49Poisoner's Handbook is really about the invention of forensic toxicology
- 9:53in the United States and, you know, by implication everywhere.
- 9:59In 1918, New York City got its first trained medical examiner,
- 10:04Charles Norris, and boy did he have his work cut out for him.
- 10:09It wasn't just the intentional poisonings, but also the unintentional ones too.
- 10:15This stuff was just around.
- 10:18It wasn't just arsenic in cosmetics.
- 10:20Cyanide used to be in every household.
- 10:22It was used in silver polish.
- 10:23It was used in photo processing.
- 10:25Morphine went into teething medicines for infants.
- 10:29Opium was in sedatives.
- 10:31All of this made discerning intention very hard for New York's new medical examiner.
- 10:37The year that Norris came into office, New York City had actually published a report
- 10:42that stated that the clever poisoner could operate with impunity in New York City.
- 10:48They did not know how to catch a poisoner.
- 10:53But Norris was up for the job.
- 10:56Despite his charming public persona, he was a deeply intense man with a
- 11:01perfectionist streak a mile long.
- 11:04He was fascinated by science and had a commitment to public
- 11:07service, and importantly for the corruption the city was battling
- 11:12at the time, he was insanely rich.
- 11:15He didn't need the money that came with the job.
- 11:17Norris did it because he was committed to the ideals.
- 11:22And he hired Alexander Gettler, who was the first forensic
- 11:27toxicologist ever to work in the city medical examiner's office.
- 11:32Norris and Gettler were operating in a difficult environment.
- 11:36Historically, the coroner's office had been politically appointed in
- 11:40the United States, and New York was run by a corrupt political
- 11:44machine in the early 20th century.
- 11:46So the nascent field of toxicology was contending not only with rapidly
- 11:50developing science, it was also struggling with cases that were lost
- 11:54because of negligence and corruption.
- 11:57And this is the other thing that is going on with the politically
- 12:01appointed coroner system, is a lot of times they just don't show up.
- 12:06And when they do show up, they don't know what they're doing, and
- 12:10they were fine with just guessing.
- 12:14Could be diabetes or possibly an auto accident
- 12:21Norris and Gettler had to rebuild a lot of relationships.
- 12:25Norris even sent Gettler and his other forensic experts to do trainings
- 12:29at police departments so they could understand how things worked.
- 12:33And the effort paid off.
- 12:35By the 1930s, you can find defense lawyers complaining that, you know,
- 12:42if Alexander Gettler testifies, they've already lost the case.
- 12:46He's gotten such a reputation for being really good at what he does.
- 12:55Alexander Gettler was a very talented chemist.
- 12:58In her book, Blum describes him as a, quote, "cigar-smoking gambling enthusiast
- 13:03from Brooklyn." His background was very different from Charles Norris.
- 13:08He emigrated to the US at the age of seven with his father and sister.
- 13:12He went to the City College of New York, got his PhD in biochemistry
- 13:16from Columbia, and was a clinical chemist at Bellevue Hospital.
- 13:21He got along with Norris, though, because when it came to the work
- 13:24of the medical examiner's office, he also believed in perfection.
- 13:29He was a Hungarian immigrant who married into a fairly rowdy Irish family who
- 13:36made bootleg whiskey during all of Prohibition in their home in Brooklyn,
- 13:40and he bet every day on the horse races.
- 13:44You know, in his private life, he was kind of a fun guy, but in the
- 13:48laboratory, he was deadly serious.
- 13:53I actually saw one interview, some magazine interviewed him at one
- 13:57point, and they described him as having the personality of table
- 14:01salt, which is definitely an insult.
- 14:04But I think, like, when he was talking about chemistry, he
- 14:08was so precise and so careful.
- 14:11He had to be.
- 14:12Remember?
- 14:13The office needed to be above reproach.
- 14:17Gettler was dedicated.
- 14:19He created new tests to isolate poisons, including regularly
- 14:23experimenting by poisoning raw liver and attempting to isolate increasingly
- 14:28smaller amounts of poison from it.
- 14:31And it was that attention to detail, that familiarity with poisonings both
- 14:36purposeful and accidental, that made Gettler the exact right person to notice
- 14:41a problem brewing with the amendment that was about to pass, the one that
- 14:45was about to establish the prohibition of all alcohol in the United States.
- 14:55Chapter two Hide the liquor, hide the beer
- 14:59World War I is over and so are America's days of legal alcoholic drink.
- 15:04Convinced self-sacrifice and sobriety will bring prosperity and peace as
- 15:08it won victory and war, Americans praise passing of the dry law.
- 15:12And
- 15:12then- Prohibition was the result of a decades-long campaign that was organized,
- 15:17politically active, and dedicated to the mission of outlawing alcohol.
- 15:22And the temperance movement, as it was called, brought together a huge
- 15:26coalition of people, a big part being women fighting against domestic violence.
- 15:31Here's women's rights activist Eleanor Smeal on a PBS documentary called
- 15:36Prohibition and the Suffrage Movement.
- 15:40I don't think that many people realize that Susan B.
- 15:43Anthony was a leader in the temperance movement
- 15:48The temperance movement was all about men's behavior, by the way.
- 15:52It wasn't not just alcohol, it was the abuse of alcohol and the
- 15:56beating of women, uh, by drunken men.
- 16:01And they would also spend an inordinate amount of money on it, and on pay day,
- 16:05they'd go to the bars, and what would be left for the wife and the kids?
- 16:14The movement also included Christian groups, people who were anti-immigrant,
- 16:18particularly anti-German immigrants, and people who wanted income taxes.
- 16:25Yeah, that might seem out of left field.
- 16:29The question of taxation touches every home in America.
- 16:32The question of taxation touches every home in America.
- 16:36There is no man, woman, or child who can escape the relentless tax law.
- 16:42There is no man, woman, or child who can escape the relentless tax law.
- 16:47That's William McAdoo giving his famous revised taxes speech in 1919.
- 16:53He was criticizing Congress, which was Republican-controlled at the time,
- 16:58for not reducing the burden of wartime taxes after World War I had ended.
- 17:03Between the high cost of living and the high load of taxation, the masses
- 17:08are carrying a heavy burden these days.
- 17:10Between the high cost of living and the high load of taxation, the masses
- 17:14are carrying a heavy burden these days.
- 17:17And they have a right to demand that the Republican majority in Congress
- 17:22carry out its promises to give relief.
- 17:24And they have a right to demand that the Republican majority in Congress
- 17:28carry out its promises to give relief.
- 17:34There was something relatively new in that taxation load income tax the sixteenth
- 17:41amendment, which made it possible for the government to levy a national income tax
- 17:46had only been ratified a few years earlier in nineteen thirteen the temperance
- 17:51movement was in favor of it because it helped break the government's reliance on
- 17:54the alcohol excise tax which was bringing in more than two hundred million a year
- 18:00by nineteen ten they were joined by progressives who wanted a way to make the
- 18:04government more effective and increase its power and racially motivated southerners
- 18:09who wanted to exact some revenge for reconstruction like we said huge coalition
- 18:16big tent or as daniel okrent says in his book last call the rise and fall of
- 18:22prohibition quote the various factions of the growing anti-alcohol alliance
- 18:28could be encompassed by no imaginable organization billy sunday meet jane addams
- 18:34you may never realize it but you'll be working together now industrial workers
- 18:38of the world shake hands with the ku klux klan you're on the same team unquote
- 18:46Anyway, the national income tax paved the way for prohibition because it made
- 18:51the loss of revenue less of a concern.
- 18:54It was a huge win for the temperance movement, which had
- 18:57been steadily gaining steam.
- 18:59Prohibition had already been passed by some states before the amendment,
- 19:03and there was even a temporary restriction on alcohol in 1918 as
- 19:08part of a wartime act to save grain.
- 19:10All of that is to say the 18th Amendment was not a surprise,
- 19:15and people were preparing for it the best way they knew how.
- 19:19So once we start easing into prohibition, Getler actually wrote an article
- 19:23in 1918 saying, "We are starting to see people distilling whatever
- 19:31they can to get alcohol," you know, preparing for the alcohol apocalypse.
- 19:37You can distill almost anything, and frankly, people did.
- 19:42They would distill their shoes.
- 19:45There was some shiners, I think they were in Tennessee, who ran out of an
- 19:50easy availability of other products and pulled poison ivy vines off
- 19:55trees and distilled the poison ivy.
- 19:58People distilled their furniture.
- 20:00People would, like, distill their kitchen table.
- 20:03But if you're distilling products related to wood, you're gonna get wood alcohol.
- 20:08And this made Alexander Getler worried.
- 20:11He said, "This is really dangerous because wood alcohol is really poisonous."
- 20:18Wood alcohol is methyl alcohol.
- 20:20It had a lot of practical uses as a solvent, to make varnish.
- 20:25It was even an ingredient in dyes and used as a fuel.
- 20:28So you can distill wood, it's called destructive distillation
- 20:33of wood, a- and make a form of alcohol that we call methanol today.
- 20:38And at one point in the United States, they had wood alcohol
- 20:42factories all along the East Coast.
- 20:44Just thousands of trees were sacrificed because y- this alcohol could be used
- 20:49in all kinds of industrial processes.
- 20:52But now that alcohol was illegal, some people were willing to
- 20:56drink pretty much anything.
- 20:59And you see people starting to die from wood alcohol poisoning or going blind.
- 21:06This is what happens.
- 21:08So really quickly, if you went home tonight and had a cocktail
- 21:15There's an enzyme that breaks down alcohol.
- 21:18It's called alcohol dehydrogenase, and it starts this metabolic pathway
- 21:24that eventually turns the ethanol into carbon dioxide and water.
- 21:29Completely harmless.
- 21:30But when the same thing happens and alcohol dehydrogenase starts
- 21:35breaking down methanol, this turns into formaldehyde and formic acid.
- 21:41So th- eventually what happens is that formic acid metabolizes to formate, and
- 21:47that is taken up by the optic nerve.
- 21:49Your optic nerve is a really busy nerve because it's always processing images,
- 21:54and it, so it takes up a lot of this formate, and th- that destroys the optic
- 21:59nerve, and that was why you started seeing so much blindness during this period.
- 22:04And it wasn't just the blindness.
- 22:07It also caused so many deaths.
- 22:09When you first drink methanol, you get the buzz.
- 22:12Y- sure, you feel dizzy, but you also get that kind of happy
- 22:15little buzz you get from drinking, you know, a normal cocktail.
- 22:20But then gradually, the poison builds up in your body.
- 22:24It's not a reversible process.
- 22:26Because it's such an internal chemical cascade, there's really nothing you can do
- 22:31to stop this process, and so people died.
- 22:36When you go and you look at some of the things that are going on then in
- 22:39New York City, you find that almost every day, the coroner's office or
- 22:45the medical examiner's office i- is collecting bodies from around the city,
- 22:49especially in the poorer neighborhoods where the only alcohol people had access
- 22:54to were wood alcohol kind of products.
- 22:57Gettler knew these deaths were caused by alcohol because of that
- 23:01same attention to detail he used to develop his liver test for poisons.
- 23:06And he was the first person in the world to figure out how you could tell
- 23:10someone was drunk at time of death, which is harder than you think because
- 23:14our body naturally makes ethanol.
- 23:16You're always gonna have some amount of ethanol in the brain.
- 23:19So if you die and you find ethanol, big whoop.
- 23:23Our body makes it.
- 23:24But how much is in there that actually can be tied to intoxication?
- 23:30He looked at 8,000 brains to figure that out.
- 23:35Plenty of people made themselves sick from accidental alcohol poisoning,
- 23:39but they kept drinking anyway.
- 23:41I mean, there was a cocktail called Smoke that was Sterno mixed with alcohol.
- 23:48So people were drinking these terrible things, and that was killing them.
- 23:52I think it says something about the American character that nobody
- 23:56wanted the US government telling them they couldn't have a glass of
- 23:59wine after dinner if they wanted one.
- 24:02And I would feel that way today.
- 24:03Please, this is my bad habit.
- 24:05I get to have it.
- 24:06But the thing that Gettler and Norris had to deal with next
- 24:10was not accidental at all.
- 24:18Chapter 3: Surely They'll Stop.
- 24:24Enforcing Prohibition across the entire country was a massive undertaking,
- 24:30and the government did not have the manpower or resources to support it.
- 24:35Congressman Fiorello La Guardia says that to enforce Prohibition, the
- 24:38city of New York alone would need…
- 24:41250,000 police and another 200,000 to police the policemen.
- 24:47The most respectable citizens frequent illegal speakeasies.
- 24:51There is a growing breakdown of respect for the law.
- 24:57Not only had people kept on drinking, but Prohibition had led to some
- 25:02unintended consequences, including the proliferation of organized crime.
- 25:08And this seedy underbelly of society wasn't hiding in dark alleys.
- 25:13It was seeping into everyday life, mingling with polite society, because
- 25:19organized crime controlled the majority of bootlegging operations.
- 25:23It's against the law to drink, so drinking is suddenly smart.
- 25:27There's bootleg liquor on every American lip, shiny flask on every hip.
- 25:31By the middle of 1920s, nightlife is having its heyday,
- 25:35for America's dry and high.
- 25:39Six years into Prohibition, the writing was on the wall.
- 25:43Prohibition is failing.
- 25:45People are still drinking.
- 25:46And some of them are drinking things that were never meant for human consumption.
- 25:52Since the Pure Food and Drug Act of 1906, the government had required
- 25:56businesses to denature industrial alcohol or else pay liquor taxes on it.
- 26:02This meant that if you wanted to sell ethanol as a solvent, first you had to
- 26:06add chemicals to it to make it smell bad, taste bad, or even make it poisonous
- 26:11to discourage people from consuming it.
- 26:14By the 1920s, somewhere around 70 denaturing formulas existed.
- 26:19Some of them used wood alcohol, which we now know was deadly, but other formulas
- 26:24were mostly made up of contaminants that made them awful to drink.
- 26:28But during Prohibition, this denatured industrial alcohol became a target.
- 26:33Everyone wants illegal alcohol, so the Al Capones of the world are organizing to
- 26:39get illegal alcohol into the system, and they start stealing industrial alcohol.
- 26:44But even if it didn't kill you, it was nasty stuff.
- 26:48I've never talked to a single person who was sitting around
- 26:51drinking isopropyl alcohol out of their rubbing alcohol bottle.
- 26:54We all know it's gonna be bad.
- 26:56And so what the bootleggers hired chemists to take the contaminants
- 27:01out and make it taste better again.
- 27:06Right.
- 27:07Rather than denaturing alcohol, these bootlegger scientists were working through
- 27:12the list of formulas and renaturing it.
- 27:15Formula 39B was a favorite because it was used for the production of
- 27:20alcohol in perfume and cosmetics.
- 27:22Since it wasn't particularly dangerous, the scientists found it was pretty
- 27:27easy to make it drinkable again.
- 27:29Eventually, bootlegger scientists were able to work their way
- 27:32through a huge portion of the list.
- 27:35Even formula number six, which included mercury bichloride,
- 27:39was able to be renatured.
- 27:41As all of this was going on, the government didn't give up.
- 27:45It doubled down.
- 27:46What if we use chemical enforcement?
- 27:50You see, Alexander Gettler heard a rumor that government chemists were
- 27:54working on a secret project to create new denaturing agents, formulas that
- 28:00would require much more methyl alcohol and would even add new poisons to
- 28:04the mix like kerosene and benzene.
- 28:07In other words, they made the industrial alcohol supply even more dangerous.
- 28:12The industrial alcohol supply they knew people were drinking, and so was
- 28:17born a lethal game of cat and mouse.
- 28:22To the government, it was a simple solution to a straightforward problem.
- 28:26They wanted people to not drink.
- 28:29Eventually, they just asked the makers of industrial alcohol to put wood alcohol in
- 28:34the mix so that it would be so dangerous that people would be afraid to drink it.
- 28:39You can actually go find these government formulas where the government
- 28:43keeps inching up the amount of wood alcohol because getting wood alcohol
- 28:48out of the mix is almost impossible.
- 28:50Instead of forensic toxicologists versus poisoners, it was government
- 28:56scientists versus those that were working for bootleggers.
- 28:59The government saw using wood alcohol to poison the liquor supply as
- 29:04striking a decisive blow and fixing Prohibition, but this solution
- 29:10was putting people in danger.
- 29:12People were calling them the Borgia government by this time,
- 29:16but their intention was not murder.
- 29:19I'm trying to be really fair here.
- 29:21Their intention was they would poison the alcohol, they would get that information
- 29:25out, and people would go, "Oh, I shouldn't touch this because it might kill me."
- 29:31And so they held press conferences.
- 29:33They invited reporters to the Treasury Department headquarters in Washington,
- 29:37DC, showed them the different formulas, talked about what was going in it.
- 29:43Get the word out, people should not be drinking this.
- 29:47People drank it anyway.
- 29:56Norris and Getler began sounding the alarm.
- 30:00Norris and Getler now are going out and saying, "You're poisoning Americans."
- 30:05I, I mean, I told this whole story of, like, a particular Christmas where people
- 30:11just start dropping dead or hallucinating because they have accidentally drunk
- 30:17this government-contaminated alcohol.
- 30:20She's talking about the Christmas of 1926.
- 30:23In her book, Blum describes a man running drunkenly into Bellevue's emergency room,
- 30:29claiming that Santa Claus had chased him from Fifth Avenue with a baseball bat.
- 30:34And he wasn't the only one confused.
- 30:37He was one of 65 people who had come into the hospital over the last
- 30:40two days, sick from celebrations that had poisoned liquor.
- 30:45By the time the holiday was over, 23 people were dead, 89 were hospitalized,
- 30:51most of them vomiting and hallucinating.
- 30:54Some had gone blind.
- 30:58Norris wrote an article called Our National Essay in Extermination
- 31:03based on the government policies.
- 31:05And you can see this in newspapers of the time.
- 31:08The Chicago Tribune said that the amendment was the only amendment carried
- 31:13the death penalty with it because of the government poisoning its own citizens.
- 31:17Norris did not mince words.
- 31:19Quote, "The government knows it is not stopping drinking by putting poison in
- 31:24the alcohol. It knows what the bootleggers are doing with it, and yet it continues
- 31:30its poisoning processes, heedless of the fact that people determined to
- 31:34drink are daily absorbing that poison."
- 31:37Unquote.
- 31:41Which brings up a really important question.
- 31:44Why in the heck did people keep drinking it?
- 31:48Chapter 4: Informed Decision Making.
- 31:55It's a really good question.
- 31:57Why did we keep drinking?
- 31:59The government didn't make what they were doing a secret.
- 32:02They tried to get the word out.
- 32:04And to dry advocates, those who were in favor of not drinking,
- 32:08the answer seemed obvious.
- 32:10You see the dry politicians saying, "Are you gonna go into a hardware
- 32:16store and gamble that if you drink pesticide it won't kill you?"
- 32:19These people are making a choice.
- 32:21They're making a choice to drink this when we have done everything
- 32:25we can to get this information out.
- 32:29Remember, as far as the temperance movement was concerned, alcohol
- 32:33was the true public health crisis.
- 32:36So Getler and Norris' many op-eds, their railing against this policy
- 32:41fell on deaf ears, in part because of where they were calling it out from.
- 32:48If you look at kind of the origins of the prohibition movement, some of
- 32:53it is based in organizations like the Women's Christian Temperance Union.
- 32:59There's the Anti-Saloon League.
- 33:01And they really grow not out of big urban areas like New York.
- 33:06I think the Anti-Saloon League was Columbus, Ohio.
- 33:10And so you have in the politics of this, again, you have what I think today we
- 33:19would sometimes call the redder states looking at these lefty liberal urban
- 33:24areas and saying, "Uh, yeah, you know, New York is really unhappy, but you
- 33:32know, New York is the den of inequity."
- 33:37The head of the Anti-Saloon League was a man named Wayne Wheeler, and he didn't
- 33:42buy Norris and Gettler's arguments at all.
- 33:46Wayne Wheeler was just like, "Well, you've always been New York scum.
- 33:50New York, you sold its soul to the drinking devil a long time ago, and
- 33:54you're just representative of that."
- 33:58" New York sold its soul to the drinking devil" isn't really a satisfactory
- 34:03answer to why people kept drinking, not least of all because people
- 34:08weren't only dying in New York.
- 34:11People are being poisoned around the country.
- 34:14You're seeing it, like I said, in places like Missouri and
- 34:17Southern Illinois and Arkansas.
- 34:19So why?
- 34:21Well, first of all, let's think about how information traveled in that day.
- 34:28It was newspapers, which if you were on Skid Row, you were probably not reading.
- 34:33Or it was the radio, which if you had no money, you were not
- 34:37necessarily having access to radio.
- 34:41I think the information got out there.
- 34:43There was certainly word of mouth about it.
- 34:46The medical examiner's office in New York City was doing
- 34:49constant messaging about this.
- 34:52So does everyone know this?
- 34:55No.
- 35:00That might be hard for us to wrap our head around, living in our modern era
- 35:04of the internet and news updates by your TV, radio, phone, Instagram feed.
- 35:11And also because our view of prohibition is probably a bit skewed.
- 35:15I realized that a lot of my idea of prohibition was like
- 35:20F. Scott Fitzgerald, right?
- 35:22Happy little parties.
- 35:24But, and, but the Fitzgeralds had money, and they partied with their bootlegger,
- 35:29and so they got the really good stuff.
- 35:31W- whereas the people who really suffered in this period were people who couldn't
- 35:36afford to get the good stuff, and they got the Russian roulette forms of alcohol.
- 35:41It might kill you, it might not.
- 35:45Determining risk is crucial to our survival, but sometimes we're
- 35:50not that great at it, even when we have the information we need.
- 35:55But in this case, even that wasn't a given.
- 35:58So in their desperate attempt to solve a problem, the government made a
- 36:02miscalculation, not just about how people would react, but about how much they knew.
- 36:09Busting up stills wasn't working.
- 36:11Closing down speakeasies wasn't working.
- 36:14But if you could just scare people enough, they wouldn't drink, and you would
- 36:17now succeed in creating a dry America.
- 36:21Some people knew it and drank anyway.
- 36:25That's also human.
- 36:27And, and people who didn't really have access to information,
- 36:32they were just out of luck.
- 36:34Norris especially believed it was easy for those in power to discount the
- 36:38people who were out of luck because they were working class or poor.
- 36:43And he pretty much said this directly, that you had people in
- 36:47government of wealth and power who didn't care about those people.
- 36:51They were collateral damage in this particular holy war.
- 36:55And it's interesting because if you actually look at that period,
- 36:59so many people died in New York.
- 37:01So many, like homeless or struggling people were killed by alcohol, wood
- 37:06alcohol, or, you know, government poisoned alcohol in New York.
- 37:11They were digging these mass graves in, y- you know, in the paupers
- 37:15fields, cemeteries, because they had nowhere else to put them.
- 37:23And then there's perhaps a sentiment that feels more recognizable to us.
- 37:28It's really an interesting study in human behavior, and I do think
- 37:32some of it is that they didn't know.
- 37:34And I think some of it is, you know, they didn't trust the government, so the
- 37:40government might be telling you this, but do you really trust the government?
- 37:46So how devastating was this policy?
- 37:51This is a very rough calculation because no one ever really tallied up which
- 37:57deaths were caused by just you drank from the wrong still, and which deaths
- 38:02were caused by government poisoning.
- 38:04But when you look at the outbreaks that followed the government poisoning, you
- 38:08can pretty much find by going from at least major city to major city, that
- 38:13a good 10,000 people were killed by this government poisoning program.
- 38:19That's a lot of loss of life, and it brought the government a lot of ill will.
- 38:26One of the things that's interesting about the period is that you also
- 38:30saw newspapers labeled as wet newspapers and dry newspapers.
- 38:35And so some of the newspapers from, you know, states that were sort of holy roller
- 38:41states had been very for prohibition.
- 38:43They start changing.
- 38:45And so you start seeing some of those newspapers coming out and saying, "Listen,
- 38:50this is not worth killing Americans. Yes, we want a more sober country,
- 38:55but not at the cause of random death."
- 39:04It wasn't the only thing that led to the repeal of prohibition.
- 39:07Other factors, like the stock market crash, fed it too.
- 39:11And people aren't a monolith.
- 39:13Even as the legislation was clearly failing, there were still dry
- 39:17advocates who wanted to see it saved.
- 39:20There was lots of debate, which is, well, very American.
- 39:24And prohibition heads for doom.
- 39:27At Faneuil Hall, Boston, thousands demonstrate against
- 39:30the folly of the Volstead Act.
- 39:32Upon talk of repeal, champions of dry laws storm Senate headquarters in Washington.
- 39:36Leader of Women's Christian Temperance Union, Mrs. Ella
- 39:39R. Poole, has this to say.
- 39:42We call attention to the fact that women are not suffering from the blows
- 39:50of drunken husbands as in the days when the saloon had right of way.
- 39:57But the end was nigh.
- 39:59Everyone is waiting.
- 40:01You know, everyone by this time knows it's gonna happen.
- 40:04And, and if you look at New York, you know, people had been,
- 40:07like, secretly stockpiling.
- 40:10Even Macy's, the department store, set out, like, alcohol
- 40:14carts for their customers.
- 40:17It was like, yeah, people couldn't wait to drink openly, and freely,
- 40:23and on their own terms again.
- 40:25It was like one big national party, which I kinda love.
- 40:30The 21st Amendment was ratified on December 5th, 1933,
- 40:35officially repealing prohibition.
- 40:37The '20s were over, but the decade had a huge impact.
- 40:41I've always thought of the 1920s as one of the most anarchistic decades
- 40:46in US history because you pass a constitutional amendment, and the
- 40:51whole country rebels against it.
- 40:52I mean, New York wasn't the only state where people were drinking illegally.
- 40:57All of these different kind of cultural shifts, women smoke more
- 41:00openly, and all of this other stuff.
- 41:03So i- in ways that I think the people who started prohibition didn't intend,
- 41:09it shifted some of the ways that people behaved because they felt like
- 41:15they were rebelling anyway, and they could rebel against all these morays.
- 41:18Skirts got shorter famously during the 1920s.
- 41:22All of these things.
- 41:28And after all this time, seven episodes later, what have we learned about risk
- 41:34and science in the American experience?
- 41:37Is it just that we're stubborn, full of that indomitable American spirit, and
- 41:43we only want science to prop that up?
- 41:45This is the way I want to live my life, and by God, I'm gonna live it this way.
- 41:50Could be.
- 41:51But maybe our attraction to risk isn't American.
- 41:55Maybe it's just human.
- 42:08Distillations podcast is produced by the Science History Institute
- 42:12and recorded in the Laurie J. Landau Digital Production Studios.
- 42:17Our executive producer is Mariel Carr.
- 42:19Our senior producer is Rigoberto Hernandez.
- 42:23This episode was produced by me, Alexis Patrick.
- 42:27It was fact-checked by Alexandra Atia, and the sound design was by Seth Samuel.
- 42:32Support for Distillations has been provided by the Middleton Foundation
- 42:36and the Wyncote Foundation.
- 42:38You can find all of our podcasts, as well as our videos and articles, on
- 42:42our website at sciencehistory.org.
- 42:45And you can follow us on social media at scihistoryorg for news about our
- 42:50podcasts and everything else that goes on in our free museum and library.
- 42:56For Distillations, I'm Alexis Patrick.
- 42:59Thanks for listening.