Latest / Inflation and Your Money with Fexingo: Protecting Purchasing Power and Beating Inflation / How Inflation Is Quietly Eating Your Homeowners Insurance Deductible
Transcript
- Lucas: So we talk a lot on this show about how inflation quietly eats at the things you own, and today I want to get specific about something that rarely gets the attention it deserves: your homeowners insurance deductible. Not your premium, not your coverage limit, but the number you pay out of pocket before the insurance company writes a check. Luna: I feel like most people never even look at that number. They just see the premium go up every year and assume it's all about replacement costs. Lucas: Right, and that's understandable because the premium is the thing that hits your bank account every month. But the deductible is a sleeping landmine. Over the last few years, as construction costs spiked and then partially came down, insurers have been quietly pushing deductibles higher. They don't lower them when inflation cools, and they often tie them to a percentage of the dwelling coverage rather than a fixed dollar amount. Luna: A percentage-based deductible sounds like it could be a nasty surprise. If your home is insured for four hundred thousand and the deductible is two percent, that's eight thousand dollars out of pocket. Lucas: Exactly, and that's before we even get to the fact that the dwelling coverage itself has been creeping up. So even if the percentage stays the same, the dollar amount climbs as your home's replacement value rises. We saw the ten-year breakeven inflation rate tick up to 2.28 percent this week, and core CPI is still running hotter than the headline number. So the pressure on replacement costs is not going away. Luna: So what's the actual mechanism here? Is this just insurers being greedy, or is there something structural going on? Lucas: I think it's a little of both, but there's a real structural piece. After the big hurricane seasons and wildfire events of the past few years, reinsurers have been demanding higher rates. So primary insurers are passing that down. But they're also being smarter about how they price risk. A higher deductible means you're less likely to file small claims, and that saves them money on processing and on the hassle factor. Luna: And it saves them on the claims that are just barely above the old deductible too. That's a huge part of the margin. Lucas: That's the key. The average claim is not a total loss. It's a wind-damaged fence, a leaking roof, a burst pipe. Those are exactly the claims that a higher deductible filters out. So you end up paying for the first several thousand dollars of damage yourself, and if you don't have a healthy emergency fund, that's a real problem. Luna: And we've done a whole episode on how inflation eats your emergency fund, so this is like a double whammy. If your fund hasn't kept up, you're stuck. Lucas: Look, if today's conversation is worth a coffee to you, the smallest thing you can do is buy me a coffee at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It keeps the show ad-free and we genuinely appreciate it. Luna: Yeah, it's a tiny ask and it lets us keep digging into these overlooked corners of personal finance. Lucas: So, back to the deductible. When I say this is a sleeping landmine, I mean it in a very concrete way. Let me walk you through a typical scenario. Say your home was insured for three hundred thousand dollars back in 2020, with a one-percent deductible. That's three thousand dollars. Fast forward to 2026, and with the run-up in construction costs, your dwelling coverage is now four hundred thousand. If your deductible is still one percent, it's now four thousand. That's a thirty-three percent increase in your out-of-pocket risk, and your premium is higher too. Luna: And that assumes the insurer hasn't already moved you to a two-percent deductible. Which they do, often without making a big deal about it in the renewal paperwork. Lucas: Right. So what can you actually do? The first thing is to pull out your policy declaration page and look at the deductible section. Is it a flat dollar amount or a percentage? If it's a percentage, what is it based on? And has it changed since you bought the policy? You'd be surprised how many people don't know the answer to that last question. Luna: I'm guilty of that. I think I know my deductible, but I haven't checked in a couple years. Time to go dig through the files. Lucas: The second thing is to question whether a higher deductible actually makes sense for you. There's a lot of conventional advice that says you should raise your deductible to lower your premium. And that can be smart if you have the cash on hand to cover the worst case. But if you'd be forced to put a four-thousand-dollar repair on a credit card, that savings on premium is a false economy. Luna: Because you're effectively taking on more risk to save maybe a couple hundred bucks a year. It's not a balanced trade if you can't absorb the hit. Lucas: Exactly. So the third thing is to have a conversation with your agent about what's driving your specific deductible and premium. Ask them for a breakdown of how much of your premium increase is due to inflation in replacement cost versus your claims history versus the broader reinsurance market. If they can't give you a straight answer, that's a red flag. Luna: And you can also shop around. The market is still competitive in most states, and a new policy might come with a lower deductible for the same premium. Lucas: That's true, but be careful about switching carriers just to get a lower deductible. You want to make sure the new policy has the same coverage quality, especially for things like water damage and liability. A cheap policy with a low deductible but terrible exclusions is not a win. Luna: So what's the takeaway for someone who's listening and thinking, okay, I need to do something about this? Lucas: Start by getting clear on your current numbers. Then decide whether a higher deductible is a risk you can actually take. And if you've had to file a claim in the last year or two, take a hard look at how the payout was calculated. Did the insurer use a replacement cost that reflected the higher construction prices? Or did they try to lowball you based on outdated figures? Luna: That's a really important point, because even with a deductible, if the replacement cost is too low, you're eating the difference on top of the deductible. Lucas: Right. And that's where the policy limits come in. If your dwelling coverage hasn't kept pace with inflation, you're underinsured. Many policies have an inflation guard endorsement that automatically raises your limit, but not all do. And if you've made renovations or added a deck or a finished basement, your old limit is even more out of date. Luna: So it's really a two-part problem: the deductible is eating you from the front end, and the coverage limit is eating you from the back end. Lucas: That's a great way to put it. And I think the broader lesson here is that inflation doesn't just affect your grocery bill or your rent. It seeps into the fine print of every financial product you own. The insurance company is not your enemy, but they're also not looking out for your out-of-pocket exposure. That's on you. Luna: And it's a perfect example of why you need to review your insurance at least once a year, not just when you get the renewal notice. Lucas: Absolutely. So to bring it all together: check your deductible, understand what it's based on, make sure your coverage limit is in line with today's replacement costs, and only raise your deductible if you can genuinely afford the worst-case scenario. Because the worst case isn't a statistic. It's a tree through your roof on a Tuesday night. Luna: And that tree doesn't care what the CPI did last month. It's going to cost what it costs. Lucas: Exactly. And the good news is that fixing this is within your control. It's not like trying to beat the stock market. It's just a matter of spending thirty minutes with your policy documents and maybe a phone call to your agent. That's a pretty cheap way to protect your house. Luna: And your peace of mind. I know I'm going to go check my deductible tonight. Thanks for pushing this one, Lucas. Lucas: Happy to. If you found this useful, we'll be back tomorrow with another angle on how inflation keeps showing up in places you don't expect. Until then, keep an eye on the fine print.