Latest / Rounding Up / Supporting Neurodiverse Students in Elementary Mathematics Classrooms with Dr. Cathery Yeh
Transcript
- 0:03What meaning does the term neurodiverse convey and how might that language
- 0:08impact a student's learning experience? In this episode,
- 0:11we'll explore those questions and we'll think about ways that educators can
- 0:16design learning environments that support all of their students.
- 0:20Joining us for this conversation is Dr. Catherine Yay,
- 0:23a professor in STEM education from the University of Texas at Austin.
- 0:30Welcome to the podcast C. It's really exciting to have you with us today.
- 0:33Thank you, Mike. Honored to be invited.
- 0:36So I wonder if we can start by offering listeners a common understanding of
- 0:41language that we'll use from time to time throughout the episode.
- 0:44How do you think about the meaning of neurodiversity?
- 0:48Thank you for this thoughtful question.
- 0:51Language matters a lot for me.
- 0:54Neurodiversity refers to the natural variation in our human brains and our
- 0:59neurocognition challenging this idea that there's a normal brain.
- 1:03I always think of in Texas, we just had a snow day two days ago,
- 1:07and I think of just as, there's no two snowflakes that are the same.
- 1:11There's no two brain. That's exactly the same too.
- 1:15I also think of its meaning from a personal perspective.
- 1:18I am not a special educator.
- 1:20I was a bilingual teacher and taught in inclusive settings,
- 1:24and my first exposure to the meaning of neurodiversity came from my own child
- 1:28who she openly blogs about it.
- 1:31As a Chinese-American girl,
- 1:34it was actually really hard for her to be diagnosed. Asian Americans,
- 1:39one out of 10 are diagnosed. That's why I'm lowest on any ethnic racial group,
- 1:43and I'll often think about when she's proud of her disabled identity,
- 1:48it is who she is.
- 1:49But what she noticed that when she tells people about her disabled identity,
- 1:53what do you think is the first thing people say when she says,
- 1:55I'm neurodivergent. I have a DHD, I have autism.
- 1:58What do you think folks usually say to her? The most common response.
- 2:02I'm going to guess that they express some level of surprise and it might be
- 2:06associated with her ethnic background or racial identity.
- 2:10She doesn't get that as much.
- 2:12The first thing people say is they apologize to her. They say,
- 2:16I'm sorry.
- 2:18Wow.
- 2:19And that happens quite a lot. And I say that because,
- 2:22and then it connected back to the Termin neurodiversity because I think it's
- 2:25important to know its origins. It came about by Judy Singer,
- 2:29she's a sociologist, and about 30 years ago,
- 2:31she coined the term neurodiversity as an opposition to the medical model of
- 2:36understanding people and human differences deficits.
- 2:40And her understanding is that difference is beautiful.
- 2:44All of us think and learn and process differently,
- 2:48and that's part of human diversity.
- 2:50So that original definition of neurodiversity was tied to the autism rights
- 2:53movement. But now when we think about the term,
- 2:56it's expanded to include folks with a DHD, dyslexia,
- 3:01dyscalculia mental health conditions like depression, anxiety,
- 3:05and other neuro minorities like Tourette syndrome and even memory loss.
- 3:10I wanted to name out all these things because sometimes we're looking for a
- 3:13really clean definition and definitions are messy.
- 3:17There's a personal one.
- 3:19There's a societal one of how we position neurodiversity as something that's
- 3:23deficit that needs to be fixed, but it's part of who one is,
- 3:27but it's also socially constructed because how do you decide when a difference
- 3:32becomes a difference that counts where you qualify as being neurodiverse.
- 3:36So I think there's a lot to consider around that.
- 3:40The answer that you shared is really a good segue because the question I was
- 3:45going to ask you involves something that I suspect you hear quite often is
- 3:49people asking you,
- 3:51what are the best ways that I can support my neurodiverse students?
- 3:54And it occurs to me that part of the challenge of that question is it assumes
- 3:58that there's this narrow range of things that you do for this
- 4:03narrow range of students who are different.
- 4:07The way that you just talked about the meaning of neurodiversity probably means
- 4:11that you have a different kind of answer to that question when people ask it.
- 4:15I do get this question quite a lot.
- 4:18People email it to me or they'll ask me.
- 4:20That's usually the first thing people ask.
- 4:22I think my response kind of matches my pink hair question.
- 4:25When they ask me the question, I often ask a question back and I go,
- 4:29how would you best educate Chinese children in math? And they're like,
- 4:33why would you ask that?
- 4:34The underlining assumption is that all Chinese children are the
- 4:38same and they learn the same ways,
- 4:41they have the same needs and also that their needs are different than the
- 4:46research base equity math practices. We know and have done 50,
- 4:5160 years of research that we've highlighted our effective teaching practices for
- 4:55all children. We've been part of NCTM for 20 years.
- 4:58We know that tasks that promote reasoning and problem solving has been
- 5:02effectively shown to be good for all. Using a connecting math representations
- 5:07across math representations in a lesson is good for all multimodal math
- 5:11discourse, not just verbal, written,
- 5:14but embodied in part who we are and in building on student thinking and
- 5:19all those things we know, and those are often the recommendations we should ask.
- 5:24But I think an important question is how often are our questions
- 5:28connecting to that? Instead, how often are we seeing that?
- 5:33We assume that certain students cannot engage in these practices,
- 5:39and I think that's something we should traumatize more.
- 5:42I'm not saying that there are not specific struggles or difficulties that the
- 5:46neurodiversity umbrella includes, which includes A DHD, dyslexia, autism,
- 5:50bipolar disorder, on and on. So many things.
- 5:53I'm not saying that they don't experience difficulties in our school
- 5:55environment, but it's also understanding that if one neurodiverse student,
- 5:59you know me or my child, you only know one. That's all.
- 6:04And by assuming we're all the same,
- 6:07it ignores the other social identities and live experiences that
- 6:11students have that impact their learning. So I'm going to ask you a question.
- 6:15Fire away.
- 6:16Okay. What comes to your mind when you hear the term NEURODIVERSE student?
- 6:21What does that student look like, sound like, appear like to you?
- 6:26I think that's a really great question.
- 6:28There's a version of me not long ago that would have thought of that student.
- 6:33As someone who's been categorized as special education,
- 6:36receiving special education services,
- 6:38perhaps a student that has A-D-H-D-I might've used language like
- 6:43students who have sensory needs or processing.
- 6:47And I think as I hear myself say,
- 6:50some of those things that I would've previously said,
- 6:53what jumps out is two things.
- 6:56One is I'm painting with a really broad brush as opposed to looking at
- 7:01the individual student and the things that they need.
- 7:04And two is the extent to which painting with a broad brush or trying to
- 7:09find a bucket of strategies that's for a particular group of students,
- 7:13that really limits my thinking around what they can do or all the
- 7:18brilliance that they may have inside them.
- 7:20Thank you for sharing that because that's a reflection I often do.
- 7:24I think about when I learned about my child, I learned about myself,
- 7:28how I automatically went to a deficit lens of like, oh, no,
- 7:32how are we going to function in the world?
- 7:33How's she going to function in the world?
- 7:35But I also do this prompt quite a lot with teachers and others,
- 7:39and I ask 'em to draw it. When you draw someone, what do you see?
- 7:44And I'll be honest, kind of like drawing a scientist.
- 7:46We often draw Albert Einstein.
- 7:49When I ask folks to draw what a neurodiverse student looks like,
- 7:52they're predominantly white boys, to be honest with you,
- 7:56and I want to name that out, is because students of color,
- 7:59especially black brown native students,
- 8:01they're disproportionately over and under-identified as disabled in our
- 8:05schooling.
- 8:06Like we think about this idea that when most of us associate autism or A
- 8:10DHD mainly as part of the neurodiversity branch and as entirely
- 8:15within as white boys,
- 8:17which often happens with many of the teachers that I talk to and parents,
- 8:22we see them as needing services. But in contrast,
- 8:25when we think about particularly our students of color and our boys,
- 8:29these young men,
- 8:30there's often a contrast of criminalization in being deprived of
- 8:35services for them. And this is not even what I'm saying.
- 8:38It's been 50 years of documented research from the depart Ed from annual civil
- 8:43rights that repeatedly shows for 50 years now extreme disproportionality
- 8:48for disabled black and Latinx boys,
- 8:51in particular from suspension expulsion and in school arrests.
- 8:55I think one of the most surprising statistics for me that I had learned recently
- 8:59was African-American youth are five times more likely to be
- 9:03misdiagnosed with chronic disorder before receiving the proper diagnosis of
- 9:08autism spectrum disorder.
- 9:10And I appreciate going back to that termin neural neurodiversity because I think
- 9:14it's really important for us to realize that neurodiversity is an asset-based
- 9:18perspective that makes us shift from looking as the student that needs to be
- 9:22fixed, that neurodiversity is the norm,
- 9:25but for us to look at the environment. And I really believe that we cannot have
- 9:29conversations about disability without fully having conversations about race
- 9:34language and the need to question what needs to be fixed,
- 9:38particularly not just our teaching, but our assessment practices. For example,
- 9:42we talk about neurodiversity around what we consider normal or abnormal,
- 9:45which is based on how we make expectations around what society thinks.
- 9:50One, the things that showed up in our own household when we think about
- 9:53neurodiversity or assessments for autism is this idea of maintaining eye
- 9:58contact.
- 9:59That's one of the wily considered autistic traits in the Chinese and an
- 10:04Asian household and also in African communities making eye contact to an
- 10:08adult or somebody with authority. It is considered rude,
- 10:12but we consider that as one of the characteristics when we engage in
- 10:17diagnostic tools.
- 10:19This is where I think there needs to be more deep reflection around how one is
- 10:23diagnosed,
- 10:24how conversations of disability is not separate from our understanding of
- 10:29students and their language practices, their cultural practices.
- 10:32What do we consider normative because normative is highly situated in culture
- 10:37and context.
- 10:38I would love to stay on this theme because one of the things that stands out in
- 10:42that last portion of our conversation was this notion that rather than thinking
- 10:46about we need to change the child,
- 10:49part of what we really want to think about is what is the work that we might do
- 10:53to change the learning environment?
- 10:54And I wonder if you could talk a bit about how educators go about that and what
- 10:58maybe some of the tools could be in their toolbox if they were trying to think
- 11:01in that way.
- 11:03I love that question of what can we as teachers do?
- 11:07What's some actionable things?
- 11:09I really appreciate Universal Design for Learning framework,
- 11:13particularly their revised updated version or 3.0 version that just came out,
- 11:18I think it was June or July of this year.
- 11:21Let me give you a little bit of background about universal design.
- 11:24And I'm sure you probably already know,
- 11:26I've been reading a lot around its origins. It came about 1980s.
- 11:30We know from cast.org, but I want to go further back,
- 11:34and it really builds from universal design and the work of architecture.
- 11:39So Universal design was coined by a disabled architect. His name was Ronald May.
- 11:44And as I was reading his words,
- 11:46it really helped me better understand what UDL is.
- 11:50We know that UDL Universal designed for learning and universal design is about
- 11:54access. Everybody should have access to curriculum and that sounds great,
- 11:59but I've also seen classrooms where access to curriculum meant doing a
- 12:04different worksheet while everybody else is engaging in small group,
- 12:08whole group. Problem-based learning access might mean your desk
- 12:13is in the front of the room where you're self isolated,
- 12:16where you're really close to the friend of the board.
- 12:18So you can see it really well, but you can't talk to your peers.
- 12:20Or that access might mean you're in a whole different classroom doing the same
- 12:26set of worksheets or problems, but you're not with your grade level peers.
- 12:31And when Ronald Mays talks about access,
- 12:34he explained that access in architecture had already been a focus in the late
- 12:3919 hundreds around 1998 I think.
- 12:42But he said that universal design is really about the longing,
- 12:47and I think that really shifted the framing.
- 12:49And his argument was that we need to design a place,
- 12:52an environment where folks across a range of bodies and
- 12:57minds feel a sense of belonging there that we don't need to
- 13:01adapt. The space was already designed for you,
- 13:07and that has been such a transformative perspective that it shouldn't be going a
- 13:11different route or doing something different because by doing that,
- 13:15you don't feel like you belong.
- 13:17But if the space is one where you can take part equally and access
- 13:22across the ways may you may engage, then you feel a sense of belonging.
- 13:26The piece of what you said that I'm really contemplating right now is this
- 13:31notion of belonging.
- 13:33What occurs to me is that approaching design principles for a
- 13:37learning environment or a learning experience with belonging in mind is a
- 13:42really profound shift. Like asking the question,
- 13:45what would it mean to feel a sense of belonging in this classroom or
- 13:50during this activity that's happening that really changes
- 13:55the kinds of things that an educator might consider going through a planning
- 14:00process.
- 14:01I'm wondering if you think you might be able to share an example or two of how
- 14:06you've seen educators apply universal design principles in their
- 14:10classrooms in ways that remove barriers in the environment and support
- 14:15students' mathematical learning.
- 14:18Oh gosh, I feel so blessed. I spend tomorrow,
- 14:22I'm going to be at a school site all day doing this.
- 14:25UDL is about being responsive to our students and knowing that the best
- 14:29teaching requires us to listen deeply to who they are,
- 14:33honor their mathematical brilliance and their agency.
- 14:36It's about honoring who they are.
- 14:38I think where UDL ups it to another level is it asks us to consider
- 14:43who makes the decision.
- 14:45If we are making all the decisions of what is best for that student,
- 14:49that's not fully aligned with UDL, the heart of UDL,
- 14:53it's around multiple ways for me to engage, to represent and express,
- 14:58and then students are given choice.
- 15:00So one of the things that's an important part of UDL is honoring students'
- 15:04agency. So we do something called access needs. At the start of a lesson,
- 15:09we might go,
- 15:10what do you need to be able to fully participate in math today?
- 15:15And kids from kindergarten to high school or even my college students will just
- 15:20write out what they need. And usually it's pretty stereotypical,
- 15:23I want to talk to someone when I'm learning,
- 15:26I would like to see it and not just hear it.
- 15:29And then you continually go back and you ask, what are your access needs?
- 15:34What do you need to fully participate?
- 15:35So students are reflecting on their own what they need to be fully
- 15:40present and what they believe is helpful to create a
- 15:45successful learning environment.
- 15:47So that's a very strong UDL principle that instead of us coming
- 15:52up with a set of norms for our students, we co-develop that,
- 15:55but we're co-developing it based on students reflecting on their experience in
- 15:59their environment. In kindergarten,
- 16:01we have children draw pictures as they get older. They can draw, they can write,
- 16:05but it's this idea that it's an ongoing process for me to name out
- 16:10what I need to be fully present. And oftentimes they're going to say
- 16:15things that are pretty critical.
- 16:18It's almost always critical to be honest with you,
- 16:21but I would say that's a core component of UDL.
- 16:24We're allowing students to reflect on what they need so they can name it for
- 16:29themselves, and then we can then design that space together.
- 16:34And along the way, we have kids that name, you know what?
- 16:36I need the manipulatives to be closer.
- 16:39That will not come about at the start of me asking about access needs,
- 16:42but we did a lesson and it was not close by. They'll tell me.
- 16:45So it's really around designing an environment where they can fully participate
- 16:50and be their full selves and feel a sense of belonging. So that's one example.
- 16:55Another one that we've been doing is teachers and kids who have
- 16:59traditionally not participated the most in our classrooms or have even engaged
- 17:04in pullout intervention. And we'll have them walk around school telling us
- 17:09about their day.
- 17:10Will you walk me through your day and tell me how you feel in each of these
- 17:14spaces and what are your experiences like? And again,
- 17:17we're allowing the students to name out what they need,
- 17:20and then they're naming out.
- 17:21Oftentimes with the students that we're at where I'm working in mostly
- 17:23multilingual spaces, they'll say, oh, I love this teacher.
- 17:26She allows us to speak in Spanish in the room. Okay,
- 17:29so that's going back to ideas of action expression engagement,
- 17:34where students are allowed to trans language.
- 17:36That's when the language principles,
- 17:38but we're allowing students and providing spaces and really paying
- 17:43close attention to how do we decide how to maximize participation for our
- 17:47students With these set of UL guidelines,
- 17:50how we are able to listen and make certain decisions on how we can strengthen
- 17:54their participation, their sense of belonging in our classrooms.
- 17:58I think what's lovely about both of those examples,
- 18:00asking them to write or draw what they need or the
- 18:05description of, let's walk through the day,
- 18:07let's walk through the different spaces that you learn in or the humans that you
- 18:10learn with is one.
- 18:13It really is listening to them and trying to make meaning of that and using that
- 18:18as your starting point.
- 18:19I think the other piece is that it makes me think that it's something that
- 18:23happens over time. It might shift,
- 18:26you might gain more clarity around the things that students need or they might
- 18:30gain more clarity around the things that they need over time,
- 18:33and those might shift a little bit, or it might come into greater focus like,
- 18:38I thought I needed this, or I think I needed this,
- 18:41but what I really meant was this.
- 18:43There's this opportunity for kids to refine their needs and for
- 18:48educators to think about that and the designs that they create.
- 18:52I really appreciate you naming that because it's all of that.
- 18:55It's an ongoing process where we're building a relationship with our students
- 19:00for us to co-design what effective teaching looks like,
- 19:03that it's not a one size fits all.
- 19:04It's disrupting this idea that what works for one works for all.
- 19:09It's around supporting our students to name out what they need.
- 19:13I'm almost 50. I struggle to name out what I need sometimes,
- 19:17so it's not going to happen in one time. It's an ongoing process,
- 19:21and in what we need is linked to context, so it has to be ongoing,
- 19:26but there's also in the moments as well,
- 19:28and it's the heart of good teaching and math.
- 19:30When you allow students to solve problems in the ways that make sense to them,
- 19:33that's UDL by design that's honoring the ideas of multiplicity and action
- 19:38expression.
- 19:39When you might give context based problem and you take the numbers away and you
- 19:44give a set of number choices that students get to choose from.
- 19:47That is also this idea of UDL because there's multiple ways for them to engage.
- 19:52So there are also little things that we do that note how they're just
- 19:57effective teaching,
- 19:58but we're honoring this idea that children should have agency,
- 20:03all children can engage in doing mathematics,
- 20:05and part of learning mathematics is also supporting our students to see the
- 20:10brilliance in themselves and to leverage that in their own teaching and
- 20:14learning.
- 20:16Something else that really occurred to me as we've been talking is the
- 20:20difference between the way we've been talking about centering students
- 20:25needs and asking them to help us understand them and the process
- 20:29that kind of kicks off.
- 20:32I think what strikes me is that it's actually opening up the possibilities of
- 20:36what might happen or the ways that a student could be successful as opposed
- 20:41to this notion that you're neurodiverse, you fit in this bucket.
- 20:45There's a set of strategies that going to do just for you,
- 20:49and those strategies might actually limit or constrict the options you have.
- 20:53For example, in terms of mathematics,
- 20:56what I remember happening very often when I was teaching is I would create an
- 21:00open space for students to think about ways that they could solve problems.
- 21:04And at the time,
- 21:06often what would happen is kids who were characterized as neurodiverse wouldn't
- 21:10get access to those same strategies.
- 21:12It would be kind of the idea that this is the way we should show them how to do
- 21:16it. It just strikes me how different that experience is.
- 21:20I suspect that that was done with the best of intentions,
- 21:23but I think the impact unfortunately probably really didn't match the
- 21:28intent.
- 21:29I love how you're being honest. As I did the same thing when I was teaching too,
- 21:33because we were often instructed to engage in whole group instruction and
- 21:38probably do a small group pullout. That was how I was taught.
- 21:42And when the same kids are repeatedly pulled out because we're saying that
- 21:47they're not able to engage in the instruction,
- 21:50I think the part of uud L is uud L as a process,
- 21:53realizing that if students are not engaging fully in the ways that we had hoped,
- 21:58instead of trying to fix the child,
- 22:00we look at the environment and think about what changes we need to make in tier
- 22:04one. So whole group instruction,
- 22:07whole group participation first to see how we can maximize their participation.
- 22:12And it's not one strategy because it depends. It really depends. I think of,
- 22:16for example, with a group of teachers in California and Texas now,
- 22:21we've been looking at how we can track participation in whole group
- 22:26settings, and we look at them across social demographics,
- 22:30and then we started to notice that when we promote multimodal whole group
- 22:34participation,
- 22:35like kids have access to manipulatives even during whole group share out,
- 22:39or they have visuals that they can point to their participation and who gets to
- 22:44participate drastically increase. So there's many ways in which
- 22:49by nature, we engage in some narrow practices because too,
- 22:54oftentimes whole group discussion is almost completely verbal and at times
- 22:58written and usually the teacher's writing.
- 23:01So it's going back to the idea of can we look at what we want our students to do
- 23:05at that moment? So starting on the math concept and practices,
- 23:08but then looking at our students and when they're not participating fully,
- 23:13it's not them.
- 23:15What are the UDL principles and things that I know and strategies that I have
- 23:19with my colleagues that I can make some small shifts.
- 23:23One of the things that I enjoy most about the podcast is that we really can take
- 23:27a deep dive into some big ideas,
- 23:30and the limitation is we have 20 minutes to perhaps a half hour,
- 23:34and I suspect there are a lot of people who are trying to make meaning of what
- 23:38we're talking about and thinking about how might I follow up?
- 23:41How might I take action on some of the ideas?
- 23:43So I want to turn just for a little while to resources,
- 23:46and I'm wondering if there are resources that you would suggest for a listener
- 23:50who wants to continue learning about universal design in a mathematics
- 23:53classroom?
- 23:54Oh my goodness, that's such a hard question. So many, some good ones. Overall,
- 23:58I would definitely encourage folks to dive into the UDL guidelines.
- 24:02The 3.0 updates. They're amazing.
- 24:06They're so joyful and transformative that they even have,
- 24:10one of the principles is centering joy in play, and for us to imagine that,
- 24:15right?
- 24:15Yes.
- 24:16What does that mean to do that in a math classroom?
- 24:18We can name out 50 different ways. So how often do we get to see that?
- 24:23I would highly encourage folks to download that,
- 24:27engage in deep discussion because it was a 2.2 version for I think quite a few
- 24:31years.
- 24:32I would also lean into a resource that I'm glad to email later on.
- 24:37It's more easily accessible. I talked about access needs,
- 24:40this idea of asking students, asking community members,
- 24:44asking folks to give this opportunity to name out what they need.
- 24:49It's written by a colleague,
- 24:51Dr. Daniel Reinhold and Dr. Samantha Richway.
- 24:54It's a lovely reading and it focuses specifically in STEM that I think it's a
- 24:58great place to read.
- 25:00I would say that Dr. Rachel Lambert's new book on UD L Math is an excellent
- 25:03read.
- 25:04It's a great joyful read to think about. I'm going to give one shout out to the
- 25:09book called The Year of the Tiger and Activist Life. It's by Alice Wong.
- 25:13I encourage that because how often do we put the word activism next to
- 25:18disability? And Alice Wong is one of the most amazing humans in the world,
- 25:22and it's a graphic novel. So it's just joyful.
- 25:24It's words with poetry and graphic novel mixed together to see the
- 25:29life of what it means to be a disabled activist and how activism and disability
- 25:33goes hand in hand. Because when you are disabled and multi marginalized,
- 25:38you are often advocating for yourself and others. It's amazing.
- 25:43So I'll stop there. There's endless amounts.
- 25:46So for listeners,
- 25:47we'll link the resources that C was talking about in our show notes.
- 25:51I could keep going, but I think this is probably a great place to stop.
- 25:55I want to thank you so much for joining us.
- 25:57It's really been a pleasure talking with you.
- 25:59Thank you. Thank you.
- 26:03This podcast is brought to you by the Math Learning Center and the Meyer Math
- 26:07Foundation dedicated to inspiring and enabling all individuals to discover
- 26:12and develop their mathematical confidence and ability.