Shows / Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
A short Machshava on the Daf Yomi. Each Daf in Shas has Machshava depth to it, in some it's easy to find - the Agadata of the Shas, but in some it takes some research. Short Machshava shiur aims to discover, discuss in short, and attempt to give somewhat of an understanding of parts of the Machshava of each Daf. Given by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman, a Talmid of Rabbi Moshe Shapiro zt"l.
Episodes
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 68: Repeated Offense
The severity of "Shanah B'Chet". Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah pdf/mdjiarhzc1tg5rgh4hfm.pdf
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 67: The Payments of Four and Five
Why do they apply only and an ox and a sheep? Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah pdf/w9xscncvi92e6ljrfn4g.pdf
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 66: The 22 Year Question
Why did it take so long to answer it? Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah pdf/bcznjnog1ckrpacywoqk.pdf
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 65: An Adam is Full of Potential
The main difference between and Adam and a Behemah. Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah pdf/fwn1bspgazbgoczo9gvt.pdf
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 64: Modeh B'Knas and Then Came Eidim
The beautiful Remazim regarding this Machlokes. Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah pdf/jrmnsycujbm8bplkbugx.pdf
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 63: To'en Ta'ans Ganav
Where is this hinted in the Pasuk? Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah pdf/gkpjfti1smd8fgyjyqra.pdf
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 62: The Chanukah Miracle is Not Mentioned in the Mishnah
Why? Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah pdf/mlajutfp9sp8rtqtj9x9.pdf
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 61: One Who Sacrifices his Life for Divrei Torah
The deep explanation of Rav Bunim of Peshischa. Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah pdf/de64f6niqiawsptstaag.pdf
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 60-3: The Derashos of Fire
The connection between the Halacha and the Agada Derashos of the same Pasuk. Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah…
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 60-2: Collateral Damage?
Does one die for no reason? Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah pdf/gigtm9ezqjhb5jgro6e4.pdf
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 60-1: Was there a Mashchis doing Makas Bechoros?
How can the Gemarah mention a Mashchis if we say the HKBH himself did the plague? Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah…
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 59: Why only Talmidei Chachomim Fully Mourn the Churban?
Explaining the story of Eliezer Ze'ira. Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah pdf/j4fwzsuov9yayyzral4b.pdf
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 58: The Number Six/Sixty
And the difference between six and seven.
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 57: Hashavas Aveida
The deep meaning of it, and the reason there is no need for Daas. Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah…
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 56: Chayav in Dinei Shamayim
Why would one be Chayav in Shamayim only?
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 55-2: Rabbi Tzadok's Concept of The First Time Mentioned in the Torah
Based on our Gemarah. Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah pdf/nmyugx9yneyyio2jmptf.pdf
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 55-1: The Tov of the Second Luchos
And the explanation in the Gemarah's discussion. Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah pdf/m4hj7grzrdeuktyrmfxr.pdf
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 54: The First and Second Commandments
Are they the same one, or two separate ones? Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah pdf/d30lvaxmejmsbkjpaajp.pdf
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 53: Shor to Exclude an Adam, Chamor to Exclude Kelim
The amazing explanation of the Beis Yaakov. Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah pdf/ojw4feehdgevlirfza7q.pdf
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 52: Hashem Makes the Leaders Blind
Different ways to explain the Gemarah. Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah pdf/kflkwgmc8bzt5wspsimo.pdf
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 51: Love Every Yid, Even a Roshoh?
The Mitzva of V'Ahavta L'Reacha Kamocha by a Roshoh. Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah pdf/ua432akrq6qndvvidlbi.pdf
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 50-2: Rav Moshe Shapiro TZ"L on Midas Hadin
The fascinating understanding that comes out from the two meimros, 1. Hashem punishes the Tzadikim, 2. The prohibition to say Hashem is a Vatran. Source Sheet…
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 50-1: The Ram That Saved the Girl
The connection of Akeidas Yitzachak to the story of the one who dug pits for the Rabim. Source Sheet…
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 49: Moshe and Moshiach Come on a Donkey
Is Donkey a negative? Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah pdf/ejpgwif30xtsvas10ig1.pdf
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 48: Velados Payment Goes to the Father
How do we determine who is the father? Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah pdf/n4kaarn06vzq498pytql.pdf
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 47: When Rav Was Sleeping
The deep meaning of this statement. Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah pdf/z5pjbnslvx5sy5zeqq2w.pdf
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 46-2: Moshe Rabeinu's Judgement
The great Chidush of the Chasam Sofer. Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah pdf/fih5zbhdvmh5fxm44cpy.pdf
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 46-1: Logic by Monetary Dinim
The definition of Rav Shimon Shkop in the difference between Mamonos and Issurim. Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah…
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 45: Ribui Achar Ribui
The reason it means a Mi'ut according to Pshat and Drash. Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah pdf/ahzyxqyapt2stxnupfa9.pdf
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 44: An Ox the Gores Children
The reason a Pasuk is needed because they are not obligated in Mitzvos.
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 43: Modeh B'Kenas, Hoda'ah of Chanukah
The understanding of Mode in Kenas, Vidui, and the Hodaah of Chanukah. Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah…
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 42: The Correct Way to Retain One's Learning
The Fisherman Mashal. Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah pdf/tbywxbjmstbdhulfetol.pdf
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 41: The Power Of Talmidei Chachomim, Chanukah
The Chidush of Rabbi Akivah.
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 40: The Pesulim of the Animal to the Mizbeach
What they reference. Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah pdf/mlg9rjivs3nk7zq6o95w.pdf
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 39: Rabbi Yaakov Pays Half?
The meaning of these words in the Gemarah. Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah pdf/nuzz0oohhqqhekv4q42b.pdf
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 38-2: Chanukah: The Yevanim's Demand to Write on the Ox's Horn
The fascinating idea of the Bnei Yissachar, that brings Chanukah into our Sugiyah. Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah…
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 38-1: Seven Mitzvos vs 613 Mitzvos
The fundamental idea of the Beis Halevi explaining the Sugiyah. Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah…
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 37: Nature Changes Every Rosh Chodesh
The reason why an ox can establish a pattern based on the date of the month. Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah…
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 36: Kesef Medinah, Chanukah
The special connection of the Daf to Chanukah. Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah pdf/mzbmxauyzjbcwdeg3uwr.pdf
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 35: Admitting with no Claim
Din may be initiated only with a plaintiff. Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah pdf/nokjyysqqsjeyfuabrsi.pdf
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 34: Chatzi and Machatzis, Two Types of Splits
The Malbim's definition, and a beautiful vort of the Tiferes Shelomo. Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah…
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 33: The Source of the Machlokes of Rabbi Yishmael and Rabbi Akiva
The fascinating explanation of the Rogatchover in their schools of thought throughout Torah. Source Sheet…
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 32: Kabolas Shabbos
The three aspects of Shabbos. Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah pdf/ltsdixbekomsnbuobi0n.pdf
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 31: Can the Word "Kol" Refer to Two?
A discussion in Klalei Hatalmud. Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah pdf/soebeoltzedvjsmqgcq0.pdf
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 30: Becoming a Chosid
The meaning of the three-way discussion. Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah pdf/kfdfikvzdtws3seyz9us.pdf
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 29: Two Things Which are Not in One's Possession
The deep explanation of the Imrei Emes. Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah pdf/rasmzt5zws6f8ipcs8v8.pdf
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kamma 28: Preventing One From Doing an Issur
Why doesn't this apply to monetary Dinim? Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah pdf/nkh8l3ibkfq2ssuvl9nh.pdf
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 27: The Neshamah as a Mashkon
The one time the Ktzos quotes a Zohar. Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah pdf/lhkzciofbfx4zbqnaxaz.pdf
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 26: Adam Muad L'Olam
Three He'aros. Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah pdf/ohgpnkdhd0dynar1nvjv.pdf
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 25: Dayo
The deep explanation of the Kedushas Levi. Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah pdf/dsgv83zaviwzzvk8jiev.pdf
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 24: In Doubt if Forgot Morid Hageshem
Learning from Shor Ha'Muad. Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah pdf/czhgwl878u3sxrt30tfd.pdf
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 23: Divrei Rabbeinu Chananel Divrei Kabalah
The meaning of this. Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah pdf/x6rfmcnupodv5wkzkyyz.pdf
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 22: Ner Chanukah Outside
The message of the only Mishna in Shas that discusses Ner Chanukah. Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah…
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
BK 21: Sha'iyah Looks like an Ox
The deep meaning of this Sheid. Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah pdf/gjasttr6ca0swawt1uze.pdf
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 20: One Surrounds His Friend on Three Sides
The beautiful vort of the Vilna Gaon, and the Mashsal of the Duvna Magid. https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah…
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 19: Does an Animal have a Yetzer Harah?
The fascinating discussion of Rav Yosef Eingel. Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah pdf/hivhdcmzeq9rawslzbty.pdf
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 18: A Machlokes in Halacha L'Moshe M'Sinai
How can there be a Machlokes regarding Tzroros, if it is Halacha L'Moshe M'Sinai? Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah…
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 17: Yosef and Yissachar, Shor and Chamor
Torah and Chesed are the antidotes for the powers of Eisav and Yishmael. Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah…
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 16-2: Yirmiyah's Davening
The reason why he Davened that the Reshaim should give Tzdakah to the wrong person. Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah…
- Short Machshava On The Daf by Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman
Bava Kama 16-1: Spine Turns to Snake
The deep meaning of this. Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah pdf/wrxrfnjam5lw9j1wljpb.pdf