Shows / Talking Talmud

Talking Talmud
Learning the daf? We have something for you to think about. Not learning the daf? We have something for you to think about! (Along with a taste of the daf...) Join the conversation with us!
The show, from its episodes
No episode notes yet. Recurring topics, people and starter picks will appear when notes are available.
Typical episode length
18m · median of 2509 episodes with a known length
Solo / guest format
Unknown — existing notes name people mentioned, but do not identify hosts or guests.
Recurring topics
No recurring topics established yet.
Recurring people
No recurring people established yet.
Start here
No starter picks yet — no published episodes with audio and a recorded notes hook.
Episodes
Talking TalmudYevamot 34: Getting Pregnant the First Time
More on two women who marry two men, and get switched before the nisuin part.... Which leads to a broader discussion of one trying to do a mitzvah who ends up…
Talking TalmudYevamot 33: Talmudic Clarity? Bait and Switch
More on simultaneous prohibitions. How the dispute between R. Hiya and Bar Kappara seems to ride on two different teachings by R. Yehudah HaNasi, respectively…
Talking TalmudYevamot 32: Once Forbidden, Always Forbidden
If a brother did ma'amar with his brother's yibum, and then divorced that Levirate betrothed, leaves the possibility of yibum for the third brother, with the…
Talking TalmudYevamot 31: An Absence of Real Life Yibum Stories
When it's not clear that a couple has either gotten married or (a different couple) divorced... where witnesses are essential. Plus, the case of Bar Shtaya and…
Talking TalmudYevamot 30: Adding a Non-Sister to the Mix
5 mishnayot, with templates of 3 brothers, two of whom marry two sisters, and the third brother marries an unrelated woman. The cases play out the different…
Talking TalmudYevamot 29: The Strength (and Weakness) of Ma'amar
A new mishnah - that facilitates a deeper dive into ma'amar, the Levirate betrothal. Via a case of 3 brothers, and the complications there that get in the way…
Talking TalmudYevamot 28: Abaye Didn’t Really Rape That Woman
Trigger warning there is a discussion about rape in today’s daf. In today’s daf we learn who can decide what is in the canon of Mishnah and who can argue with…
Talking TalmudYevamot 27: The Strength of Bonds
A case where chalitzah is expected, but the man gives a get instead -- or where there's a yibum betrothal (ma'amar). Consider the layering of procedure and…
Talking TalmudYevamot 26: Yibum Word Problems
Finishing chapter 2, and starting chapter 3, with a mishnah apiece. First, a case where a woman was able to leave her marriage - are any of the people involved…
Talking TalmudYevamot 25: Permitting and Forbidding
The daf discusses a few different scenarios where a woman is released from her marriage but someone involved with the end of her marriage may not marry her…
Talking TalmudYevamot 24: Converting for the Sake of Marriage
On the mitzvah that is on the eldest of brothers to do yibum. Plus, what is the purpose of yibum?! (Finally?) What does it mean to carry on a dead brother's…
Talking TalmudYevamot 23: When You're Not Sure Whom You Betrothed
A study of the divergent opinions of R. Yosi and the sages on the progeny of a non-Jewish maidservant, or of an idolatress. The child apparently inherits the…
Talking TalmudYevamot 22: Not My Brother, Not My Father Either
On the status of converts, particularly with regard to the secondary forbidden relationships. Also, a mishnah: how different statuses of one's brother have…
Talking TalmudYevamot 21: The Family Compound
King Solomon and his proverbs and the way he gave "handles" to the "basket" of Yevamot (among other details of halakhah. Note also the list of the secondary…
Talking TalmudYevamot 20: The Mitzvah of Halitzah
A new mishnah that establishes some principles about a yevamah... which is established by means of hypothetical examples that can be head-spinning, to be…
Talking TalmudYevamot 19: With or Without Consent: Ma'amar
The kind of case we've been dealing with, but with ma'amar, not full yibum - with an entrance to probe R. Shimon's opinion further. Also, more on ma'amar -…
Talking TalmudYevamot 18: 5 Sages and Their Approaches
A lengthy discussion on how to understand the mishnah: R. Huna, R. Yehudah, R. Yehudah Ben Beteira, R. Meir, and Rabban Gamliel. So first, a view of each of…
Talking TalmudYevamot 17: Matrilineal Descent - Talmud-style
Concerns about those with questionable lineage, which sparks a discussion about the 10 Tribes that were exiled in the era of the prophets. Including the…
Talking TalmudYevamot 16: Jewish Geography, Talmud-style
The question of whether the co-wives of a daughter would be permitted to the brothers... As answered in the time of R. Dosa ben Hyrcanus, in accord with Beit…
Talking TalmudYevamot 15: How D'Ya Like Them Olives?
More on Beit Shammai and Beit Hillel... Specifically, did the members of Beit Shammai actually follow the approaches of Beit Shammai. Note also the affinity of…
Talking TalmudYevamot 14: Not So Kumbaya
More on the disputes of Beit Hillel and Beit Shammai, with the serious implications of a potential "mamzer" status for a child of a forbidden relationship (or…
Talking TalmudYevamot 13: Disagreements without Factions
How we derive the exemption of the co-wives with regard to the yavam. Plus, a new mishnah! The 6 cases that are more stringent than the original mishnah's 15…
Talking TalmudYevamot 12: Birth Control, Talmud-style
More cases of yibum, of course, including that of the eylonit. Also, 3 cases where an attempt, such as it was, at contraception was recommended - including…
Talking TalmudYevamot 11: The Case of the Inadvertent Adulteress and the Case of the Divorcee's Remarriage
Two complicated yibum situations, with regard to the co-wife, and whether there are other relationships that would exempt the co-wife. Say, the sotah. Or a…
Talking TalmudYevamot 10: Six Brothers and a Double Yibum
Another yibum case - including when one brother dies before the other is born leads to a mnemonic how to keep this particular complication straight: "died, was…
Talking TalmudYevamot 9: How Rape Can Affect Yibum
Disturbing daf: Warning - discussion of rape. The question if the strange case of a wife who is raped by her father-in-law, which yields all kinds of…
Talking TalmudYevamot 8: Better to Be Stringent (ahem)
The way yibum is pulled out of the category of "arayot," the illicit sexual relationships. Where the prohibitions seem to add up, until we realize how narrow a…
Talking TalmudYevamot 7: When the Extreme Case Is Practical
More on the contradictory cases where a positive commandment overrides a negative commandment that has a punishment of karet - until that very line of inquiry…
Talking TalmudYevamot 6: The Temple Is Not for Practice
What specific mitzvot can override Shabbat? Shouldn't one fear the Beit HaMikdash itself? That would theoretically have impact on what you can/have to do…
Talking TalmudYevamot 5: Shaatnez as a Classic Contradiction
When the mitzvah and the prohibition essentially come together, as with shaatnez and tzitzit - such that the positive commandment overrides the prohibition…
Talking TalmudYevamot 4: The Witch Must Die
How do we interpretation biblical verses that are juxtaposed, or simply in proximity to each other? Do we extrapolate details from one verse and apply to the…
Talking TalmudYevamot 3: When "Exempt" Means Forbidden
Why are the co-wives described as "exempting" one another from yibum, when really those potential cases of yibum are prohibited? One suggestion is that that…
Talking TalmudYevamot 2: Ervah by Association
Diving right in... Introducing Masekhet Yevamot and Seder Nashim! Defining the case of yibum, the Levirate marriage. Defining halitzah. Defining tzarot. Also…
Talking TalmudChagigah 27: The Scholars, the Sinners, and the Fire of Gehenna
The backup vessels of the Beit HaMikdash did not include a backup mizbeach (altar). But they assumed everything was impure because of the kohanim who were amei…
Talking TalmudChagigah 26: Trusting the Am Ha’aretz
The daf discusses a variety of different scenarios where an Am Ha’areaz can or cannot be trusted. What happens to all the Keilim in the Beit HaMikdash after…
Talking TalmudChagigah 25: Navigating Purity Diversity at Home
Why the Galileans weren't considered reliable with regard to purity and impurity. And possible solutions that would have enabled them to bring their goods to…
Talking TalmudChagigah 24: When One Hand Isn't Relevant to What the Other Hand Is Doing
4 more stringencies for kodesh over terumah, including what happens when only one hand is pure and the other hand impure, and how consecrated foods that are…
Talking TalmudChagigah 23: The Shoe-Bomber and Ritual Impurity
More on the purity/impurity stringencies... Trying to make sense of the list of them, by their numbers. One who carries something that has impurity because of…
Talking TalmudChagigah 22: Who Can You Trust?
The daf discusses how the Chaver and Am HaAretz interact with each other. How many different parts of a klei are there?
Talking TalmudChagigah 21: Inside Outside
The starts the delve into the maalot. Why does kodesh have extra stringencies over terumah?
Talking TalmudChagigah 20: Paying Attention for Purity's Sake
More on the purity/impurity issues with regard to clothing. What does it mean to have a constant awareness of your garments? And how little inattention it…
Talking TalmudChagigah 19: The Wave
More on intent when immersing in a mikveh -- and just how far that goes. Specifically, will dunking one hands in a mikveh, for example, render one's hands…
Talking TalmudChagigah 18: When Purification Requires Intent
A new mishnah: Washing hands prior to eating non-kodesh food, for ma'aserot, for terumot; and for kodesh (korbanot) or for a chatat, you need to dunk. But what…
Talking TalmudChagigah 17: Keep Your Goals Modest
A new mishnah! With a dispute between Beit Hillel and Beit Shammai (with some background on their disputes), over whether semichah - the laying of hands on the…
Talking TalmudChagigah 16: It Was What It Was
On demons, angels, human beings, and animals. Also, on how people should not attempt to look in the prohibited 4 directions, or aspects of the functioning of…
Talking TalmudChagigah 15: "From Him I Will Learn": Rabbi Meir and Acher
Such a rich daf! First, the story of "Pardes," the four who entered the Pardes and came out with very different reactions (Ben Azzai, Ben Zoma, Elisha ben…
Talking TalmudChagigah 14: Creating Angels
How angels were created, daily, for the purpose of singing the praises of God... Or via the utterances of God. Plus, R. Akiva's foray into aggadic…
Talking TalmudChagigah 13: A Select Few
Delving into Ma'aseh Merkavah, when we're not supposed to learn it at all... Who should not be studying Ma'aseh Merkavah? Perhaps everyone, but broad strokes…
Talking TalmudChagigah 12: The Taboo Topic of Creation
Delving into "Ma'aseh Bereishit" - including the order of creation, heavens or earth first? It's debatable, by Beit Shammai and Beit Hillel: top down or bottom…
Talking TalmudChagigah 11: A Discussion of Those Topics That Should Not Be Discussed
On the illicit sexual relationships bring explicitly listed in the Torah - even that list leaves out some prohibited relationships. Plus, a statement by the…
Talking TalmudChagigah 10: When the Oral Law Is Hanging by a Thread
A range of mitzvot, beginning with hatarat nedarim, that the mishnah claims are not well sourced in the text of the Torah. The Gemara than contradicts this…
Talking TalmudChagigah 9: Second Chances - Sometimes
Tashlumin - making things up, from sacrifices and beyond. What happens if you can't make it up? Plus, how tashlumin play out after Sukkot, at the point when…
Talking TalmudChagigah 8: What If You Don't Have Money for a Lot of Sacrifices?
What monies can be used to pay for the korbanot of a festival, in particular, the Chagigah shelamim? And when you you need to lay out money, can you combine…
Talking TalmudChagigah 7: To Bring or Not to Bring a Hostess Gift
A dispute between R. Yochanan and Resh Lakish on the mitzvah here of seeing and being seen. Note the parallel passage to Masekhet Peah, on those mitzvot which…
Talking TalmudChagigah 6: Why Women Made Holiday Pilgrimages
Who is a minor? The Gemara follows the mishnah's discussion of the abilities of the child - to ride on his father's shoulders to the Temple, or to walk holding…
Talking TalmudChagigah 5: Seeing the Pain in God's Hidden Face
The story of R. Yochanan who encounters a man who is picking less ripe figs and leaving the ripe figs. And the rationale and value of picking the figs that…
Talking TalmudChagigah 4: To Be Seen by God
A halakhic discussion and an aggadic discussion. First, a study of why those who are excluded from the mitzvah of Re'eiah, even when the exclusions are rather…
Talking TalmudChagigah 3: Radical Empathy
On the list of people who are not obligated in the mitzvah of Re'eiah is the "deaf" person, a category which is expanded to include those who cannot hear but…
Talking TalmudChagigah 2: Making an Appearance
Introducing the closing, shortest tractate in Moed. On the holiday pilgrimages to Jerusalem with the specific sacrifices that were required for those days…
Talking TalmudMoed Katan 29: Going from Strength to Strength
Departing the body upon burial becomes the purview of the mourners and the deceased, both. We say: Go in peace, in contrast to the good wishes for the living…