Shows / Talking Talmud

Talking Talmud
Learning the daf? We have something for you to think about. Not learning the daf? We have something for you to think about! (Along with a taste of the daf...) Join the conversation with us!
The show, from its episodes
No episode notes yet. Recurring topics, people and starter picks will appear when notes are available.
Typical episode length
18m · median of 2509 episodes with a known length
Solo / guest format
Unknown — existing notes name people mentioned, but do not identify hosts or guests.
Recurring topics
No recurring topics established yet.
Recurring people
No recurring people established yet.
Start here
No starter picks yet — no published episodes with audio and a recorded notes hook.
Episodes
Talking TalmudBekhorot 58: Counting Ten
More on the 3x/year of tithing animals, and the debate over "2 weeks before Pesach" vs. the 29th of Adar, which may turn out to be the same day or may be a day…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 57: Coming Together to Be Tithed
Another 2 mishnayot! 1 - All the animals are gathered in a pen to be tithed. Except for those that are not -- for example, those that are exempt from being…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 56: Gifts, Inheritance, and the Animal Tithe
2 mishnayot! 1 - Someone who buys an untithed animal or is given one as a gift does not need to include that animal in his own tithing. Plus, the case of one…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 55: The Jordan River and the Source of Blood
If the animals are grazing on different sides of the Jordan River, they cannot be combined for the purpose of tithing. Which leads the Gemara to a long detour…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 54: Mixing and Matching
More on not combining most species for tithing -- with the explicit exception of sheep and goats. The biblical source for this brings us back to terumah (and…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 53: Tithing the Flocks
Chapter 9! On tithing animals... and the verses from the Torah that prescribe this fairly broad mitzvah, throughout the world and regardless of whether the…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 52: A Double-Portion
2 mishnayot: 1 - A first-born son receives a double-inheritance from his father's property, though not his mother's property. (Note: The potential modern will…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 51: Rabbi Tarfon Gave Back the Money
2 mishnayot! 1 - Redemption of the first-born son has to be done via the 5 silver coins (not via objects or land or promissory notes). Rabbi Yehudah HaNasi…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 50: Mathing the Math (with Unholy Coins)
On the 5 silver coins for the redemption of the first-born son, and how they were valuated in other currencies. Which meant getting the math exactly right --…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 49: 30 Days to Redemption, Right?
More mishnayot! 1 - If the first-born son dies within 30 days of birth, there's no redemption to pay and the kohen would return any payment that was already…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 48: Redeeming Twins
Two mishnayot! 1 - A woman gives birth to male twins, and it's not known which of them is the first born, the father gives the coins to the kohen, because one…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 47: Who Need Redemption?
More on the human first-borns -- who is exempt from the need to redeem the first born. The son of a woman from the Tribe of Levi -- but if her husband a kohen…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 46: Opening the Womb
Finishing out the 7th chapter, about the blemishes among human beings: kohanim need to commit to not making themselves come in contact with a dead body. How is…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 45: If a Blemish Is Corrected, Is It Still a Blemish?
More blemishes, but some of them are the kind of things that, nowadays, we correct fairly easily (bowleggedness, for example). Or a kohen with an extra digit…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 44: When You Gotta Go, You Gotta Go
Cases of disqualification of kohanim from doing the Temple service for all kinds of eye blemishes, from blindness to pale spots on the eyes or excess tears --…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 43: From Animal Blemishes to Priestly Blemishes
Blemishes that disqualify kohanim from doing the Temple service -- derived from the verses in Leviticus. There are 3 categories of blemishes -- 1. appear in…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 42: Different in One Way, Different in Another Way
With regard to an animal that is an androgynos, with both male and female sexual organs, is not considered for a first-born status, because it's not uniquely…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 41: Tumtum and Androgynous: Animal Edition
Beginning with a couple of mishnayot -- on a calf whose tail doesn't reach down to the upper leg joint, which is considered to be a blemish. Imagine a camel to…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 40: A Mishnayot Festival on Blemishes
There are 7 mishnayot on this daf! (though we'll save the last one for tomorrow). 1 - On testicles and the nature of testicular blemishes. 2 - On the fact that…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 39: Gums, Teeth, and Tails
3 mishnayot! Rabbi Hanina bar Antignos on various blemish, specifically the pale spots that constitute a blemish. Note the requirement of an even amount of…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 38: Some Blemishes Are Temporary: Eyes
Determining the capacity of an earthenware vessel to become impure on both its inside and outside -- as long as it's a receptacle, with a "middle," such as it…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 37: Torah-level Blemishes
Finishing chapter 5 and starting chapter 6, with a mishnah in each chapter, and attention to the requirement of an experts to sign off on a first-born animal's…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 36: The Wisdom of Rabbi Tzadok
The case of hearsay testimony - and when it's acceptable (not often!). Also, the opinion of Rabbi Tzadok on a first-born that split its lip while eating. But…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 35: Intent, Testimony, and Expertise
3 mishnayot! 1 - Beginning with a story about a Roman soldier intentionally blemishing a first-born ram, and how the sages approved that case as a blemish, but…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 34: Written or Read?
For a case of certainly pure terumah vs. uncertain terumah (whether it's pure or not) - in light of the plural of the word "terumotai" in the Torah. Or is it…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 33: Blemishes
The Gemara picks up on Beit Hillel's leniency from the previous day's mishnah, and Rabbi Akiva's opinion on "the gazelle and the hart" - which are permitted to…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 32: Revisiting Gezarah Shavah
A discussion here compares the first-born with tithed animals. For a firstborn, it cannot be redeemed, but it can be sold. And tithed animals are the reverse…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 31: In the Name of the Speaker
Finishing the 4th chapter - with the series of baraitot about the "chaver" - with a focus here on the last one. That is, specifically, a kohen can examine…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 30: Localized Wrong and Generalized Right
A new mishnah! A person who is suspected or known to not be careful about the laws of the shemitah year may or may not be careful about tithing, and likewise…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 29: Dishonest Is as Dishonest Does
Another day of mishnayot: 1 - One who takes wages to be a judge or give testimony or a kohen who does so to facilitate a red heifer -- all of those efforts…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 28: Ethical Blemish-Checking
4 mishnayot! 1 - On determining that an animal has a blemish - after slaughtering, and the tension of having non-experts involved in determining whether the…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 27: Year by Year
If the kohen demands the first-born before the prescribed time, the owner does not need to provide it, because it seems that such a kohen would look too close…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 26: Handing Over the First-borns
To close the 3rd chapter: What if wool were plucked from an unblemished burnt-offering? What would the halakhah be regarding benefiting from that detached…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 25: Spotlighting the Red Heifer
If you're slaughtering the first-born, you can part the hair and even pluck a hair for the sake of smoother slaughtering. That is, plucking is not considered…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 24: Nursing without Bearing Offspring?
One who purchases a nursing female animal from a non-Jew - and the question is whether that animal can conclusively be said to have born progeny before, or…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 23: A Meta-Discussion on a Mishnah's Structure
Coming in the middle of a long discussion with a focus on a mix of sacred and regular ashes -- where impurity would be nullified via the mixture. Also, a new…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 22: Purifying Fish Brine
NOTE: This daf talks about animal miscarriage and extends the conversation to human miscarriage. Please be forewarned. A new mishnah! With various status…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 21: Making Assumptions about Animals' Prior Offspring
More on the female triplet goats who each have triplets to lead into a discussion of Rabbi Shimon's position, as compared to the tanna kama. Specifically about…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 20: Questions of First-born Status and Tithing Triplets x3
More on buying an animal from a non-Jew, with the question of whether the animal has given birth before. A goat that has offspring during its first year -…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 19: Questionable First-borns
2 mishnayot to close out chapter 2! Two ewes bear 2 male lambs -- both are first-born. One male, one female - the kohen gets the male. But with twins, what…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 18: Twin Lambs, Seen Narrowly
More on the case of the male twins whose heads emerged simultaneously -- where Rabbi Tarfon and Rabbi Akiva disagree. Also, delving in deeper, in terms of…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 17: True Simultaneity (or Not)
If a ewe gives birth to animal that looks like a goat, or vice versa, but also looks a little like its mother... Rabbi Meir says it is subject to the laws of…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 16: Sin-offerings and Partnerships
The 5 sin-offerings that are left to die that are left to die (if they cannot be offered on the altar). How we know this, and how it works -- including the…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 15: A Gazelle, a Hart, and the Limits of Permission
More on the consecration vs. blemish and their implications for practice, in terms of order: where is all this derived? From the different animals mentioned in…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 14: Private Altars
A new mishnah! Consecrated animals that acquire a blemish -- so they cannot be used for a regular sacrifice, what happens when they're then used for other…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 13: Yevamot and Avodah Zarah - Revisited
Summary/description to follow after shabbat/chag, with apologies.
Talking TalmudBekhorot 12: Redemption Lambs and Other Animals
Two mishnayot! First - How you cannot redeem the first-born donkey (a list of the animals that don't work for this redemption). Who's opinion is represented in…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 11: Two Zuzim
Our first story in the tractate! Meaning, an actual case and discussion between the sages. On how much a person pays to redeem an animal from the kohanim…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 10: Food Impurity and Shechitah Practice
A debate between Rabbi Shimon and Rabbi Meir, as to whether a first-born donkey is permitted for benefit. Whether the animal is decapitated is a relevant…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 9: A Lamb for the First-Born Donkey
A new mishnah! When two donkeys are born at the same time, and it's not clear which one should be offered as a first-born (or a male and female and not clear…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 8: Dolphins, Mermaids, and Greek Philosophy
Non-kosher fish "spawn" their offspring and nurse, where kosher fish lay eggs - with the exception of a bat, which lays eggs and also nurses, with many more…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 7: Can Kosher and Non-Kosher Animals Mate?
When an impure animal appears to be born to a pure animal, the animal can be consumed if and only if its head and more resembles the kosher mother. But can a…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 6: Milk from Meat
When the progeny of an animal doesn't quite resemble the mother animal, but has some similar traits, will it require the first-born status? Note the…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 5: Wilderness Accounting
Rabbi Yochanan came to Rabbi Elazar in a dream, and it was a harbinger for a good day. And the sanctification of the first-borns would not end, because of his…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 4: Wilderness First-borns
A new mishnah! Establishing additional exemptions for the first-born donkey offerings. The initial exemptions took place in the wilderness, and exempted the…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 3: Blemishes and Their Discontents
If one sold a first-born, and had to buy it back, the question is whether that's buying it back for 10x the value of the animal specifically, or just some…
Talking TalmudBekhorot 2: Beginning with Donkeys
A new tractate, taking the first-born animals as its major focus: including human first-born sons, first male domesticated animals, and first-born donkeys…
Talking TalmudHullin 142: The Reward of Long Life in the World-to-Come
A new mishnah! The last one, to be sure. Taking the mother bird for the fledglings or eggs -- you take the mother bird for the sake of the purification of the…
Talking TalmudHullin 141: Acquiring the Mother Bird
New mishnayot! 1 - If you send away the mother bird, and she comes back (even several times), you still have to send her away, if you want the eggs. Plus, when…
Talking TalmudHullin 140: Sometimes, You Don't Send Away the Mother Bird
More on the mitzvah of sending away the mother bird from sitting on her eggs or fledgling birds. If someone approached the nest with a knife, and began…