Shows / Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
Pink Shade, hosted by Mary Payne Gilbert, has the best breakdowns and takedowns of your favorite reality TV. Mary Payne recaps the shows we all love (and love to hate) three times a week with rotating co-hosts. Popular topics include:
WeTV's Love After Lockup franchise (including Love During Lockup, Life After Lockup and more)
TLC's 90 Day Fiance franchise including Before the 90 Days (BT90Days), 90 Day The Other Way (90DayTOW), 90 Day Happily Ever After (90DayHEA) and more
BravoTV's Real…
Episodes
Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne478 - Best of Patreon with Mary Payne and Erin!
On this week’s Best of Patreon, Mary Payne and Erin talk about the Plath family! And the brand new dance class sweeping nation, Pole GLANCING! Please check out…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
477 - 90 Day Fiance (Season 9, Ep 13): Elephant In The Womb w/ Erin & Mary Payne
Erin & Mary Payne recap Season 9, episode 13 of 90DF "Elephant In The Womb.” Emily & Kobe plan their family in a drugstore. Guillermo gets a haircut and some…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
476 - RHOBH, S12E9 “Calamity Jayne”
Mary Payne and Erin talk about RHOBH, S12E9 “Calamity Jayne." Druncle really steps in it this week as she clings to Dorit and tries to hit on Garcelle’s oldest…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
475 - Best of Patreon with Erin/Mary Payne: RHUGT (Season 2, Ep 1)
On this week’s “Best Of Patreon” clip - Erin & Mary Payne Erin chat about RHUGT, season 2: Ex-Wives Club. It takes place at BLUESTONE MANOR and you WILL…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
474 - 90 Day Fiance (Season 9, Ep 12): Different Ex-pectations w/ Erin & Keisha
Erin is joined by Keisha from The Libra Lounge With Keisha podcast to talk about Season 9, episode 12 of 90DF "Different Ex-pectations.” Kara & Guillermo enjoy…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
473 - RHOBH (s12, e 8) “It Takes a Villain”
Mary Payne chats with Margo Donohue of What a Creep podcast about RHOBH episode “It takes a Villain." The meat of this episode focuses on Garcelle’s 55th…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
472 - Best of Patreon! Welcome to Plathville with Erin and MP
On this week’s Best of Patreon, Erin and MP talk about one of their all-time favorite shows, Welcome to Plathville! We want to know… why can’t Ethan be a…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
471 - 90 Day Fiance (Season 9, Ep 11): How To Marry A Stripper with Erin & Mary Payne
Mary Payne and Erin talk about Season 9, episode 11 of 90DF “How To Marry A Stripper.” Every single couple was featured this week, and all of them are…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
470 - Real Housewives of Beverly Hills (s12, e7 “Ship Faced”) with Erin and Mary Payne
Mary Payne and Erin discuss Real Housewives of Beverly Hills (s12, e7 “Ship Faced”) and today we have a great story for our new segment, “What’s Happening Next…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
469 - Best of Patreon! MP and Erin chat about Welcome to Plathville and Seeking Sister Wife
This weekend on Patreon (Andrei’s Rage tier / Family Pink Shade tier and above), MP and Erin talk about The Family Chantel, Welcome to Plathville, and Seeking…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
468 - 90 Day Fiance (Season 9, Ep 10): In The Ring with Erin & Mary Payne
Mary Payne and Erin talk about Season 9, episode 10 of 90DF “In The Ring.” Bini goes full MATRIX in his first MMA fight. Bilal takes Shaeeda on a "romantic"…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
467 - Real Housewives of Beverly Hills (s12, e6 “High Cries and Misty Demeanors”) with Erin and Mary Payne
Mary Payne and Erin discuss Real Housewives of Beverly Hills (s12, e6 “High Cries and Misty Demeanors”). We are not sure if we are Team Sutton or Team Crystal…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
466 - Best of Patreon with Erin/Mary Payne: Seeking Sister Wife (Season 4, Ep 1)
On this week’s “Best Of Patreon” clip - Erin & Mary Payne begin their coverage of Seeking Sister Wife, Season 4, Episode 1 (TLC / Discovery+). Take a listen to…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
465 - 90 Day Fiance (Season 9, Ep 9): Poison In The Honey with Erin & Mary Payne
Mary Payne and Erin talk about Season 9, episode 9 of 90DF “Poison In The Honey.” Mohammed gives Yvette an ultimatum. Shaeeda washes a chicken in the most…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
464 - Real Housewives of Beverly Hills “In Hot Water” S12, E5 with Erin and MP
Mary Payne and Erin talk about Season 12, episode 5 of RHOBH “In Hot Water." First, we have to say RIP to Lois. Next we have to say that Druncle is giving us…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
463 - Best of Patreon “Erin and MP talk about Welcome to Plathville!”
On last weekend’s patreon episode, MP and Erin break down the latest episode of Welcome to Plathville. We talk about Moriah’s new hit single “Missed Myself,"…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
462 - 90 Day Fiance (Season 9, Ep 8): Get Off Your High Horse with Erin & Mary Payne
Mary Payne and Erin talk about Season 9, episode 8 of 90DF “Get Off Your High Horse.” Mohammed thinks Yvette is going to convert to Islam. Yve is not on board…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
461 - Real Housewives of Beverly Hills “The Crystal Conundrum” S12, E3 with Erin and MP
Mary Payne and Erin talk about Season 12, episode 4 of RHOBH “The Crystal Conundrum." Wow, Crystal has really stirred up some drama by saying that Sutton said…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
460 - Best of Patreon with Erin and Mary Payne: Welcome to Plathville
On this week’s “Best Of Patreon” clip - Erin and Mary Payne continue their coverage of Welcome To Plathville, Season 4 (TLC). We've been covering this show…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
459 - 90 Day Fiance (Season 9, Ep 7): It's Me Or The Bikini with Erin & Mary Payne
Mary Payne and Erin talk about Season 9, episode 7 of 90DF “It's Me Or The Bikini.” Mohammed meets Yvette's "Squad," which is not a term her friends are going…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
458 - Real Housewives of Beverly Hills, Season 12, ep 3 “There’s Something About Crystal"
Mary Payne and Erin talk about Season 12, episode 3 of RHOBH “There’s Something About Crystal." We are Team Crystal and we are here for our favorite Druncle in…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
457 - Best of Patreon "Temptation Island, Bonfire Part 1”
On last weekend’s Patreon, Erin and Mary Payne continue to talk about Temptation Island and start covering one of our all time favorite shows, Welcome to…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
456 - 90 Day Fiance (Season 9, Ep 6): If I Have To Turn This Car Around with Erin & Mary Payne
Mary Payne and Erin talk about Season 9, episode 6 of 90DF “If I Have To Turn This Car Around.” Bilal reaches a new level of Evil A$$hole this week, if you can…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
455 - Real Housewives of Beverly Hills, Season 12, episode 2 “Receipt Offender"
Mary Payne and Erin talk about Season 12, episode 2 of RHOBH “Receipt Offender." We are HERE for this new Sutton! We want to know why Rinna is doing so much…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
454 - Best of Patreon with Erin/Mary Payne: Temptation Island
On this week’s “Best Of Patreon” clip - Erin and Mary Payne recap the (almost) tail end of Temptation Island, the show you need in your lives but never thought…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
453 - 90 Day Fiance (Season 9, Ep 5): Breast Intentions with Erin & Mary Payne
Mary Payne & Erin recap Episode 5 of 90 Day Fiance, Season 9: Breast Intentions. Despite the nonsense Kobe was spouting this week aboutEmily's breastfeeding…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
452 - Real Housewives of Beverly Hills, Season 12, episode 1
Mary Payne and Erin talk about Season 12, episode 1 of Real Housewives of Beverly Hills. Wowza, this was an epic first episode. We get the whole story behind…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
451 - Best of Patreon “Temptation Island” with Erin and Mary Payne
On this week’s "Best of Patreon” MP and Erin talk about Temptation Island, the creme de la creme of trash television! Do you like extra content? Do you want to…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
450 - 90 Day Fiance (Season 9, Ep 4): Pasta La Vista with Erin & Mary Payne
Mary Payne & Erin recap Episode 4 of 90 Day Fiance, Season 9: Pasta La Vista. We cry actual tears (well, Erin does) this week when Kobe finally meets his son…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
449 - Love After Lockup Season Finale
Mary Payne and Erin talk about the season finale of LALU, where we find out that RayDean will keep Rick on the hook forever (or as long as she can be on this…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
448 - Patreon Bonus! Erin and MP talk about The Queen of Versailles Reigns Again, Ep. 3
On last weekend’s Patreon - Erin and MP talked about The Queen of Versailles Reigns Again, along with the latest episode of the trashtastic Temptation Island!…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
447 - 90 Day Fiance (Season 9, Ep 3): Pinot You Didn't with Erin & Mary Payne
Mary Payne & Erin recap Episode 3 of 90 Day Fiance, Season 9: Pinot You Didn't. Ariella gets wine thrown in her face, which MP & Erin don't think she deserved…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
446 - Love After Lockup (s4, ep9) “What’s Love Got To Do With It?”
Mary Payne and Erin break down the latest episode of Love After Lockup, which is aptly titled “What’s Love Got to Do With It?” Yolanda triumphantly returns to…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
445 - Patreon bonus: Erin and MP talk about Hillsong: A Megachurch Exposed
For this week’s Patreon bonus episode, Erin and Mary Payne talk about the 3 part Discovery+ documentary, Hillsong: A Megachurch Exposed. We talk about the Carl…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
444 - 90 Day Fiance (Season 9, Ep 2): Home Sweet Hoax with Erin & Stefanie Wilder-Taylor!
Erin is joined by the hilarious, whip smart, soul sister that is Stefanie Wilder-Taylor! You know her from Rose Pricks, For Crying Out Loud & Bored AF podcasts…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
443 - Love After Lockup “Deny Deny Deny” (s4, e8)
This week’s LALU was full of grossness and we aren’t even talking about Chazz’s lizard tongue. We had “perfect D” Rick drooling all over RayDean, wife of Kay…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
442 - Best of Patreon with Erin/Mary Payne: Queen Of Versailles Reigns Again
On this week’s “Best Of Patreon” clip - Erin and Mary Payne begin their recap of the new Discovery+ series, "Queen of Versailles Reigns Again." We are just as…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
441 - 90 Day Fiance (Season 9 Premiere): Ketchup To My Mustard with Erin & Mary Payne
Are we ready to ride a new 90 Day trainwreck all the way off of a cliff? Yes... Yes, we are. Mary Payne & Erin recap the first episode of Season 9's 90 Day…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
440 - Love After Lockup (s4, ep7) “What are you hiding?”
Mary Payne and Erin break down the latest episode of Love After Lockup, the greatest show on television! Chazz and his magical tongue roll allllll over BranWin…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
439 - Patreon Bonus: Erin & Mary Payne dish IN PERSON!
if you want to hear some rambling, you've come to the right place! WE TALK SO MUCH TALK! We are gonna tell you all about Erin's visit to Casa Mary Payne and…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
438 - 90 Day Fiance: Before The 90 Days Tell All (part 2) with Erin & Mary Payne
Mary Payne & Erin wrap up this season of 90 Day Fiance: Before The 90 Days by recapping one of the WORST Reunions ever. What the hell was happening on this…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
437 - Love After Lockup “EX-tra Stress (s4, ep6)
This week, Erin and MP are reunited and it feels so good! We chat about Chazzzzz and Branwin and her baby voice that comes and goes. We also wonder - why is…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
436 - Patreon Bonus: 60 Days In (season 1) with Mary Payne and KIMBERLY of ADWD
Patreon Bonus! Mary Payne talks with Kimberly of A Date With Dateline about 60 Days In, Season 1. To listen to the whole episode and for more exclusive…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
435 - 90 Day Fiance: Before The 90 Days “Unfinished Business” & Tell All (part 1) with Erin & Kim from 90 Day Cray Cray!
Erin talks to Kim (not to be confused with Kimbaaaaly) from the 90 Day Fiance Cray Cray podcast about the final episode of this season's 90 Day: Before The 90…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
434 - Love After Lockup (Season 4, Ep 5) “Get Right Or Get Left” with Erin & Keisha from The Libra Lounge!
Erin is joined by the hilarious Keisha from The Libra Lounge With Keisha podcast to recap the glorious garbage heap of LALU. Tiffany (and, ahem, Keisha) have a…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
433 - Patreon Bonus re: Temptation Island!
In this week’s Patreon bonus clip, MP talks to all-star bunkie Amye Archer about Temptation Island! To RSVP to our DC area Bunkie meetup - click here Bunkie…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
432 - Before the 90 Days “Cold and Calculated” (s3, ep15) with Katie of A Date with Dateline
Erin is still in Belize searching for her 27 year old fiancé Ryan and his cousin Harris so MP is chatting with Katie of A Date With Dateline about s3, ep 15…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
431 - Love After Lockup (s4, ep4) “Rule Breakers and Love Makers” with Kimberly of A Date with Dateline
Erin is still in Belize searching for her 27 year old fiancé Ryan and his cousin Harris so MP is chatting with Kimberly of A Date With Dateline about S4, ep4…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
430 - Patreon bonus “Temptation Island” premiere episode!
On this week’s bonus Patreon clip, Mary Payne and Erin talk about the premiere episode of Temptation Island. We are just getting to know these 4 couples but we…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
429 - Before the 90 Days recap with Katie of A Date With Dateline “Disappearing Act” (s3e14)
Erin is in on spring break in Belize searching for Ryan and Harris, so Katie of A Date with Dateline is helping MP cover Before the 90 Days! Well, this was…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
428 - Love After Lockup (S4E3) recap with Keisha!
Erin is in Belize searching for Ryan and Harris so MP is talking Love After Lockup with Keisha. This episode “Don’t Track Me” (S4,E3) was a doozy! We got to…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
427 - Best of Patreon with Erin and Mary Payne
On this week’s BEST OF PATREON, Mary Payne and Erin talk about some real old lady shit… sun damage and dermatologist appointments! That subject leads us right…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
426 - 90 Day Fiance: Before The 90 Days “There Is No Fear In Love” with Erin & Mary Payne
This week, Erin & Mary Payne accept the fact that there is literally no one to root for on 90 Day Fiance: Before the 90 Days. Why is everyone such a garbage…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
425 - Love After Lockup “P.O. Problems” with Erin and Mary Payne
Erin and Mary Payne are back together to talk about S4, Ep 2 of Love After Lockup! Wow, we have some real mouth hole situations to talk about this week…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
424 - Best of Patreon with Erin & Amye Archer
Last week on Patreon, Amye Archer of the 'Gen X This is Why' AND 'Six Degrees of Reality' podcasts joined Erin to discuss season two of Love Is Blind - and the…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
423 - 90 Day Fiance: Before The 90 Days “Head Games” with Erin & Kimberly from A Date With Dateline!
Erin is joined again by our buddy, Kimberly, from A Date With Dateline podcast to recap 90DF Before The 90 Days: Head Games. Kimberly & Erin can no longer…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
422 - Love After Lockup (Season 4 Premiere) “Happily Ever After?” with Erin & Keisha from The Libra Lounge!
Erin is joined by our fabulous friend Keisha from The Libra Lounge With Keisha podcast. Our dream of recapping a new season of LALU has finally come true! It's…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
421 - Best of Patreon with Erin and Mary Payne Recapping the Darcey & Stacey Finale
Mary Payne & Erin recap the finale of Darcey & Stacey (TLC). There was a lot of Georgi pretending to be "in love" with our girl Darce last week, but we are…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
420 - 90 Day Fiance: Before The 90 Days “Back To Square One” with Erin & Kimberly from A Date With Dateline!
Erin is joined by Kimbaaaaaaaly from A Date With Dateline podcast to recap the burning hot trashcan fire that is Before The 90 Days. Kimberly & Erin cringe at…
- Pink Shade: Reality TV with Mary Payne
419 - Love During Lockup “The Boy Is Mine” with Erin & Mattie from Reality Gays!
Matt Marr from the Reality Gays podcast joins Erin to recap the season finale of Love During Lockup! We bond over our shared loathing of Gabby and Max, both of…