Shows / Sugar Coated Murder
Sugar Coated Murder
Two sisters discussing true crime murders while baking in the kitchen and sharing recipes in a True Crime Comedy Improv podcast.
Episodes
- Sugar Coated Murder
Slaying in the Kitchen with Leo and Lemon Cooler Cookies and victims Simonson and Gamez
This is a special episode of Slaying in the Kitchen! We welcome Leo Allen to bake with us. Leo is a fellow-podcaster who hosts Voluntary Input, which you can…
- Sugar Coated Murder
Recipe for Skinny Strawberry Chocolate Muffins and the victimology of Janet and Lauren
This episode brings us a skinny muffin recipe, more laughs, and a new word for the Sugar Coated Dictionary. Karen bakes up Skinny Strawberry Chocolate muffins…
- Sugar Coated Murder
Guest Appearance on Casting Views
This week, because Karen is fighting the Carolina Crud, we have replaced our episode with our guest appearance on the Casting Views podcast. Dan and Lou host a…
- Sugar Coated Murder
The victimology of Lori and Berfield while baking a Strawberry Pop Tarts recipe
Anne bakes up delicious Homemade Strawberry Pop Tarts that include homemade strawberry jam and buttery pastry. These are what childhood memories taste like!…
- Sugar Coated Murder
A recipe for Ted Lasso Biscuits and who killed victims Armstrong and McLaughlin
In this episode, Karen bakes proper English biscuits from the show Ted Lasso. Anne gives an account of a harrowing murder between co-workers in Virginia Beach…
- Sugar Coated Murder
Recipe for Strawberry Swirl Pound Cake murder case of Haysom and a study of the Dating Game Killer
In this episode, Anne bakes up a delicious Strawberry Swirl Pound Cake. The recipe calls for Almond Extract and Kill Vanilla. Anne deviates and uses yummy…
- Sugar Coated Murder
100th Episode! [case updates]
Happy 100th Episode! The sisters get out of the kitchen, pour some bourbon, and give updates on some of the episodes they have covered over the years. Sit…
- Sugar Coated Murder
Double Layer Chocolate Chip Cake Recipe and victim cases of Fuss and Perry
In this episode, the sisters have gotten into the bourbon again. Karen misses the mark on this recipe for Double Layer Chocolate Chip cake that turns out more…
- Sugar Coated Murder
Baking a Fat Tuesday King Cake Recipe and the murder cases of Ryan, Dehahn, and Mahan
In this episode, Anne Varner bakes up a festive and delicious Mardi Gras King Cake in celebration of Fat Tuesday. Karen covers a senseless triple murder out of…
- Sugar Coated Murder
Who killed Barbara, where is young Sarah, and a Recipe for delicate Lemon Lavendar Sable Cookies
This episode finds Karen in the kitchen, baking up delicate Lemon Lavendar Sable Cookies from http://www.casualfoodlist.com. Both cases this week come out of…
- Sugar Coated Murder
Baking a Brandied Apple Cake Recipe and victims Harris and McCoy
In this episode, there is great debate on the term "blouse". Anne thinks it is out-dated and old fashioned, while Karen feels that it is a current term used…
- Sugar Coated Murder
Recipe for Red Velvet Cupcakes and victims Ross, Critchley, Pangburn
In this episode, Karen bakes a recipe for Red Velvet Cupcakes using beets instead of food coloring. Then, the sisters discuss the victimology of murder victims…
- Sugar Coated Murder
Recipe for Oatmeal Cream Pies [Hayes & Beard]
The sisters are excited to finally be back in 2022. Anne bakes up easy, delicious Oatmeal Cream Pies that put Little Debbie's to shame. Karen recounts the…
- Sugar Coated Murder
SCM Bonus Episode Gingerbread Cheesecake Dip [Stevens]
There is a mental health trigger warning for this story as well as a trigger for the gruesomeness of the crime. #mentalhealth #cannibalfratboy #jupiterfl…
Sugar Coated MurderSCM Bonus Episode [Murder Incorporated Take-over]
Happy Holidays to the Sugar Squad from Karen & Anne! As a bonus episode, the sisters allow the Murder Incorporated Podcast to take over an episode! Two best…
Sugar Coated MurderSCM EPI# 91 Bourbon Balls [interview with Joni West]
Anne & Karen welcome true crime author, Joni West, to the show. Joni has written a thrilling book called Full Frontal Murder Memoir. She talks about what is…
Sugar Coated MurderRecipe for Almond Crescent Cookies [Rojas & Shakespeare]
In this week's episode, the Sugar Sisters are talking about Ladies Gone Bad! While Anne makes Almond Crescent Cookies for Momma's goodie box (these are Momma's…
Sugar Coated MurderSCM EPI# 89 Slaying in the Kitchen with Liz [Apple Pie Tacos]
In this Slaying in the Kitchen episode, we welcome Liz from Coffee Convos with Liz Podcast. We discuss the unsolved mystery of the disappearance of Jennifer…
Sugar Coated MurderBaking a Bourbon Banana Cake [Smith & Brantley]
Yummy Bourbon Banana Cake with Bourbon Caramel Frosting is the recipe on tap for this episode. Anne recounts the tragic murder of Jack Smith, a well-respected…
Sugar Coated MurderSCM EPI #87 Apple Pie Bars [Towler_Ferguson & Snyder]
The sisters are back in the kitchen and back into the bourbon! Anne Varner uses Killa Vanilla as she bakes incredible Apple Pie Bars with have a shortbread…
Sugar Coated MurderSCM EPI #86 OctoBoo 2021 Series Downtown Haunts with Andrea
In this OctoBoo episode, the sisters are joined by their favorite storyteller, Andrea St. Amand. Andrea takes them through some downtown Charleston haunts and…
Sugar Coated MurderSCM EPI #85 OctoBoo 2021 [Angel Oak SC]
In this special episode of the OctoBoo series, the sisters drag Noah out to the Angel Oak tree on John's Island, SC at night. Spookiness occurs and ends with…
Sugar Coated MurderSCM EPI #84 OctoBoo 2021 [Jacksonboro Lights]
In this introductory episode to the 2021 OctoBoo series, the sisters take a nighttime field trip to hunt for a ghostly light. Needless to say, Anne nor Karen…
Sugar Coated MurderBaking Italian Cherry Pound Cake [Landowski & Staton_Castro]
In this episode, Karen bakes a tasty Italian Cherry Pound Cake that is baked in a loaf pan for easy slicing and serving. Anne informs us about the tragic…
Sugar Coated MurderRecipe for Dreamy Chocolate Cupcakes [Cosby_Jackson & Parsons]
In this episode the vodka drinks are flowing. There is talk of how Kenny Chesney's chest might taste as the sisters sip/guzzle on a tropical drink after a…
Sugar Coated MurderSCM Key Lime Cupcakes [Dumbiya & Binion]
Karen is in the kitchen this week and she baked up some yummy Key Lime Cupcakes. Instead of buttercream, she opted for a Key Lime Glaze with a crushed Graham…
Sugar Coated MurderSCM Slaying in the Kitchen with Debbie Q [Bananas Foster Muffins]
The sisters welcome Debbie Q from The Right Shoe Podcast in another episode of Slaying in the Kitchen. In this episode, Anne helps Debbie slay a yummy recipe…
Sugar Coated MurderSCM Recycled Episode [Rona Dating & Suzi's Balls]
The sisters are still on vacation having their Hot Podcasters Summer. They have recycled 2 Shorty episode, combining them to make 1 Biggie. Please enjoy 'Rona…
Sugar Coated MurderSCM Recycled Episode [Roundy_Gray & Tiner_Steele]
Enjoy this recycled episode. The sisters have repurposed 2 cases that they each handpicked. Stitched together are the Roundy murder case and the Tiner murder…
Sugar Coated MurderSCM EPI#67 Cookies & Cream Pie [Roman & Staton]
Anne chooses a no-bake option due to the heat of the Lowcountry Summer. She whips up a cool recipe for Cookies & Cream Pie. Karen unpacks the troubling Boston…
Sugar Coated MurderSlaying in the Kitchen with Bigfoot Anonymous
In this special episode of Slaying in the Kitchen, the ladies welcome Connor Flynn of Bigfoot Anonymous to discuss his explorations, findings, and sightings of…
Sugar Coated MurderSCM EPI#65 Pecan Spinwheels Bread Pudding [Tu & Westbrook]
In this episode, Anne creates magic with a recipe for Pecan Spinwheels Bread Pudding. Who knew you could elevate a gas station snack food? Karen reveals the…
Sugar Coated MurderSCM EPI#64 Bananas Foster [MacIvor & Schnabel]
In this zany episode Karen DeVanie cooks up some delicious Bananas Foster and serves it over decadent vanilla ice cream. Yummy! While Karen cooks Anne Varner…
Sugar Coated MurderBaking Strawberry Muffins [Steinert & Acid Bath Murderer]
In this episode, Anne Varner bakes scrumptious recipe of Strawberry Muffins. Karen DeVanie describes the horrifying details of the Tammy Jo Steinert murder in…
Sugar Coated MurderCopycat Butterscotch Krimpet Cake [Jandreau & Alvarez]
In this episode, Karen bakes a delicious Butterscoth Krimpet Cake. The recipe mimics the Tasty Cake Butterscotch Krimpets. Anne unravels the fan-sent murder…
Sugar Coated MurderSlaying in the Kitchen [with Lyndon]
In this episode, the Broads introduce a new series called Slaying in the Kitchen. They welcome their first slayer, Lyndon, who has a great true crime podcast…
Sugar Coated MurderSCM EPI#60 Mexican Hot Chocolate Cookies [Mullis & Taco Bell Strangler]
Hey yall! In this episode Karen bakes up Mexican Hot Chocolate Cookies while Anne Varner tells the ridiculous story of the Corn Rake Killer. While the girls…
Sugar Coated MurderBaking Honey Butter Love Rolls [Hatcher & Soham Murders]
In this episode, Anne bakes Honey Butter Rolls that turn out to be pillows of love. Karen unravels the craziness of the murder of Kendra Hatcher in Dallas, TX…
Sugar Coated MurderDainty Lady Finger Cake, the victimology of Robby Mast, and the Lady Killer Mataviejitas
This episode is dedicated to CJ at the Beyond the Rainbow Podcast for helping Karen with her Twittering. Tonight, Karen assembles a Lady Finger Cake to…
Sugar Coated MurderRecipe for Microwave Bread & Butter Pickles and victims Lewis & Porco
In this episode, Anne Varner makes Bread & Butter Pickles in the microwave, which turns out to be quite amazing!! Karen presents the senseless murder of…
Sugar Coated MurderVictims Simeonette Mapes-Crupi & The Parkers and Pecan Divinity Candy
Karen bakes up a favorite of Momma's, Pecan Divinity, which gets re-named DeVanie's Divine Divinity. Anne presents the murder of Simeonette Mapes-Crupi in…
Sugar Coated MurderRecipe for Gluten-free Chocolate Torte, the San Francisco Witch Killers & the case of Kathy Chou]
In this episode, Anne tries a gluten-free recipe for fan, Julie, and bakes up a delicious, gooey flourless chocolate torte. Karen takes us on the wild ride of…
Sugar Coated MurderRecipe for other worldly Marshmallow Peanut Butter Brownies and the cases of Frank Hilley & the Groene Family
In this episode, Karen bakes delicious, warm Marshmallow Peanut butter Brownies from wwww.beyondthebutter.com. The sisters highlight the cold case of missing…
Sugar Coated MurderRecipe for easy, tasty Egg Roll in a Bowl and the cases Aldridge & Graham
Anne cooks up Egg Roll in a Bowl while Karen unravels a double homicide in Charlottesville, VA, then Anne presents the lunacy of a murder in Phenix City, AL…
Sugar Coated MurderBaked Soft Pretzels and the mothers of victims Alyssa Otremba & Tammy Tracey
Soft Pretzels are on special for this new episode. Karen tries a recipe from Sally's Baking Addiction for Easy Homemade Soft Pretzels. Anne presents the tragic…
Sugar Coated MurderThe crazy cases of Lizzi Marriott & Leesa Shaner and a Special Peanut Pie recipe
Happy Birthday to Karen and all the other March babies! This episode is brought to you by the letter Z. Anne bakes an incredible peanut pie from the Virginia…
Sugar Coated MurderDiscussing True Crime Documentaries with Andy Gee
In this Shorty episode, the sisters welcome special guest, Andy Gee, from Mood For Days Cast. He is their Canadian brother from another mother. They cover…
Sugar Coated MurderBaking Chocolate Soufflé and the victimology of Bozza and Ord
First, the sisters get treated to Blackberry Mint Mojitos for Mixology Monday at Sweetwater Apartments. Then, Karen successfully tackles Chocolate Soufflé from…
Sugar Coated MurderRecipe for Cinnamon Crunch Bread, the Yorkshire Ripper & the mysterious case of Francis Craig
In this episode, the sisters sip on Bailey's and coffee as Anne bakes up sensational Cinnamon Crunch Bread from our addiction, Sally's Baking Blog. Karen takes…
Sugar Coated MurderMomma's Recipe for Key Lime Pie, a family annihilation the case of Kim Medlin
In this episode, Karen makes Momma's Key Lime Pie for her friends The Vicks. Anne covers the murder case of the Camm family in Georgetown, IN, and the…
Sugar Coated MurderBaked Spaghetti Squash Au Gratin, an international serial killer & the murder of the Potters
In this episode, the sisters record remotely from Sweetwater Apartments in Charleston, SC. Resident Mixologist, Anthony, mixes up Sinter Sister drinks made…
Sugar Coated MurderHow to make Caramel Frosting and the cases of Bosma & The Sodder Children
The zany sisters are back after a short break and there is much to cover! Anne unpacks the senseless murder of Tim Bosma in Ontario, Canada. Tim was just…
Sugar Coated MurderTipsy Apple Bourbon Bundt Cake and victims McPhatter & McIntyre
In this episode, Anne bakes up a scrumptious labor of love in for the form of an Apple Bourbon Bundt Cake. The sisters enjoy their bourbon hot toddies while…
Sugar Coated MurderRecipe for the very best Vanilla Cupcakes and the intriguing stories of Stinnett & Turney
In this episode, it's Karen's turn in the kitchen. She bakes up Very Vanilla Cupcakes while Anne gives us the story of a female whose crimes are so heinous…
Sugar Coated MurderAir Fryer Donuts Recipe and the cases of Galvin & Brown
In the first episode of 2021, Anne bakes up easy Air Fryer Donuts. Karen talks about the oldest US murder case to be solved using ancestral DNA. The ladies…
Sugar Coated MurderBaking Hot Chocolate Cookies Recipe, Sheila the Peeler, and the victimology of Silvonek
This episode is soaked in bourbon and spiked eggnog! Karen bakes yummy hot chocolate cookies while Anne breaks down the list of insane acts by Sheila from New…
Sugar Coated MurderRecipe for Festive Dog Treats, DE Serial Killer and the murder case of Pruit
In this episode the zany sisters talk about recent crafting adventures as well as a serial killer in DE and a killer in VA who was bad at hiding evidence. Anne…
Sugar Coated MurderAnything But Murder Thanksgiving at Tidal Grounds
In this Thanksgiving episode, Anne Varner and Karen DeVanie gather at a local coffee shop called Tidal Grounds in Mount Pleasant, SC, to discuss what they're…
Sugar Coated MurderRecipe for Honey Muffins, a Convenience Store Serial Killer the victimization of Sweeney
In this episode, Karen bakes warm, comforting Honey Muffins. Anne takes us on a wild and crazy ride in Idaho with a string of convenience store murders that…
Sugar Coated MurderBaking Memama's Recipe for Tea Cakes and the victimology of Eastburn and Huggins
In this episode Anne Varner bakes Memama's Tea Cake recipe. The recipe takes them back to their grandmother's kitchen where they remember "secret" recipes of…