Shows / Crit & Fumble

Crit & Fumble
Join this band of D&D neophytes as we bumble our way through adventure-laden tales on a weekly, in-person actual-play Dungeons & Dragons podcast.
The show, from its episodes
No episode notes yet. Recurring topics, people and starter picks will appear when notes are available.
Typical episode length
2h 25m · median of 145 episodes with a known length
Solo / guest format
Unknown — existing notes name people mentioned, but do not identify hosts or guests.
Recurring topics
No recurring topics established yet.
Recurring people
No recurring people established yet.
Start here
No starter picks yet — no published episodes with audio and a recorded notes hook.
Episodes
Crit & FumbleUnderworld "Your Own Worst Enemy" (D&D) S5:E7
The battle for Bloodhearth reaches its brutal peak as the party faces a monstrous champion in a trial of strength, fire, and resolve. But victory is only the…
Crit & FumbleUnderworld "Lava & Ash" (D&D) S5:E6
In Bloodhearth, the air hangs heavy with smoke and heat. Blades clash. A cursed weapon is dragged from the fire and gripped with shaking resolve. Statues…
Crit & FumbleUnderworld "Bloodhearth" (D&D) S5:E5
The cracks are starting to show. Whispers. Side glances. A quiet shove that nearly becomes a blade. The weight of what they’ve done, and what they’ve hidden…
Crit & FumbleUnderworld "Young At Heart" (D&D) S5:E4
They say you’re only as young as you feel. After battling a demon and watching a friend vanish into death, the weight of the Underworld begins to show. Bastion…
Crit & FumbleUnderworld "A Chilling Betrayal" (D&D) S5:E3
In the bleak heart of the Underworld, where every step echoes with the weight of the past, the party finds themselves surrounded by smiles that hide daggers…
Crit & FumbleUnderworld "Behind The Veil" (D&D) S5:E2
The party pushes deeper into the 𝖀𝖓𝖉𝖊𝖗𝖜𝖔𝖗𝖑𝖉… and things only get stranger. A floating corpse, soul-sucking leeches, and a cursed trinket are just the…
Crit & FumbleUnderworld "Throwing Stones" (D&D) S5:E1
As we kick off this new campaign, our adventurers find themselves trapped in the unsettling Underworld of Ashmourn. Stripped of their gear and confronted by…
Crit & FumbleTales from the Table "Pirates Of The Lost Fleet Wrap Up"
In this episode of Tales from the Table, we take you behind the scenes of our last arc in the Pirates of the Lost Fleet campaign. Join the crew as we break…
Crit & FumbleONE SHOT "The Hunt For Astin Sean" (Goblin Quest) 1 of 1
With one player missing, the crew jumps into a one-shot using Goblin Quest, the chaotically hilarious RPG by Grant Howitt. What follow is pure goblin mayhem…
Crit & FumbleTales from the Table "Vaesen Prelude Wrap Up"
Join us around the table as Sean, the GM for our Vaesen prelude, gets relentlessly pelted by questions from Chelsea! (The rest of us ask some questions too).
Crit & FumbleONE SHOT "Prelude: Down the hatch" (Vaesen) 2 of 2
Our investigators uncover the truth behind the death of Archibald Prescott, but just as things are looking up, the mystery takes a deadly turn. Join the Crit…
Crit & FumbleONE SHOT "Prelude: Bittersweets" (Vaesen) 1 of 2
Part 1 of a two part VAESEN adventure, DMed by Sean Murray. Join the investigators of the Society as they unravel a truly sticky situation. When a body is…
Crit & FumblePirates Of The Lost Fleet "Battle for Sargasso" (D&D) S4:E12
The crew of the Scurvy Lady face off against the Tide Sovereign and fight to save Sargasso. Played on D&D.
Crit & FumblePirates Of The Lost Fleet "Cliffside Romance and Floury Forrays" (D&D) S4:E11
The crew of the Scurvy Lady prepare for the coming battle with the Tide Sovereign. Played on D&D.
Crit & FumblePirates Of The Lost Fleet "Not Jennifer" (D&D) S4:E10
Su, Warbles, Darvin and Eldric pursue the Heart of the Tides with their band of merry, and mostly willing, crew. Played on D&D.
Crit & FumblePirates Of The Lost Fleet "Jumping Ship" (D&D) S4:E9
Su, Darvin, Warbles, and Eldric fight to get their ship and crew back, Mawrow bides his time in the dungeon with his new cell mate. Played on D&D.
Crit & FumbleTales from the Table "Pirates of the Lost Fleet Episodes 6, 7 & 8"
Join us around the table as we chat about our first community night and get another behind the scenes look with Chelsea, our Dungeon Mistress for the Pirates…
Crit & FumblePirates Of The Lost Fleet "Heart Of The Tides" (D&D) S4:E8
Eldric learns more about the source of his magic and makes a choice. The crew finds the Heart of the Tides. Played on D&D.
Crit & FumblePirates Of The Lost Fleet "Turning Tables" (D&D) S4:E7
A long awaited meeting with the leader of Sargasso brings unexpected revelations, Warbles meets with a face from his past, Eldric takes a trip, the crew find a…
Crit & FumbleS4:E6 - The Captain's Feast
The party scrambles to save a fallen crew member. Su faces a new foe. Darvin exercises his brain cells. Warbles finds that part of his past has followed him to…
Crit & FumbleTales from the Table "Pirates of the Lost Fleet Episodes 3, 4 & 5"
Another behind the DM screen look with Chelsea, our DM for the Pirates of the Lost Fleet campaign.
Crit & FumblePirates Of The Lost Fleet "Parlay" (D&D) S4:E5
The crew of the Scurvy Lady battle to save their First Mate from the clutches of the Ironquill Fleet. Meanwhile, Eldric learns the truth of the great evil…
Crit & FumbleONE SHOT "The Polar Distress" (D&D) 1 of 1
Our Christmas 2024 special!!! On this year's All Hallows Eve, those nasty little do-gooders from the North Pole dared to sneak in and string up garlands…
Crit & FumblePirates Of The Lost Fleet "Strange Tides" (D&D) S4:E4
With Eldric kidnapped, the crew of "The Scurvy Lady” races against time to uncover his whereabouts. As tensions rise, a mysterious new crewmate joins the…
Crit & FumblePirates Of The Lost Fleet "Murky Waters" (D&D) S4:E3
Captain Mawrow, Su, and Darvin pursue the elusive Ironquils to a mysterious island. The locals speak of eerie nighttime cries, unexplained fires, and a secret…
Crit & FumbleTales from the Table "Pirates of the Lost Fleet Episodes 1 & 2"
Join us as we chat about some behind the scenes details of Pirates of the Lost Fleet, DM'd by Chelsea!
Crit & FumblePirates Of The Lost Fleet "The Salted Kraken" (D&D) S4:E2
The crew arrives in Sargasso, only to find more questions than answers. Will Darvin kill their tour guide? Will Su’s bisque turn a profit? Will Eldric finally…
Crit & FumblePirates Of The Lost Fleet "Shadows Over Saiya" (D&D) S4:E1
The journey begins! The crew of The Scurvy Lady sets sail on a mission to uncover the fabled Heart of the Tides—a legendary weapon that could turn the tide…
Crit & FumbleONE SHOT "Dreyor Valley: At Death's Door" (D&D)
The town of Galdur in the Dreyor Valley has seen it’s share of adventurers come and go but the motley crew that bands together to investigate the mystery of…
Crit & FumbleONE SHOT - "Inner System Blues" (2400)
In this cyberpunk one-shot using the 2400: Inner System Blues system, a group of scrappy teens takes on the megacorp NovaGen to rescue their missing parents…
Crit & FumbleONE SHOT - "Viper Of Fathom Hold" (D&D) 2 of 2
The party finds themselves at a stand still when their new employer is arrested in the eve before their great adventure. No employer, no big pay day. The key…
Crit & FumbleONE SHOT - "Valkur's Dungeon" (D&D) 1 of 2
Chelsea takes on the role of our DM for this evenings one shot while we celebrate a birthday (Neils!) and a new guest, Rus Morland. In this little adventure…
Crit & FumbleONE SHOT - "Scratch & Sniff" (D&D) 2 of 2
The continuation of our "Scratch & Sniff" episode DM'd by Chelsea where each of our character sheets are akin to a lottery ticket; key info is covered with a…
Crit & FumbleONE SHOT - "The Aunt Hill" (Goblin Quest) 2 of 2
More Aunts. More Goblin Quest. More chaos.
Crit & FumbleONE SHOT - "The Aunt Hill" (Goblin Quest) 1 of 1
It's Goblin Quest. It's chaos. Not much else to say.
Crit & FumbleONE SHOT - "Oh Dang, Bigfoot!" (Lasers & Feelings) 2 of 2
Well this is a weird and wonderful two-shot!!! Played using "Oh Dang! Bigfoot Stole My Car With My Friend's Birthday Present Inside" (yes, that's the name of…
Crit & FumbleONE SHOT - "Rivers End" (Vaesen) 2 of 2
The saga continues as we figure our way through the Vaesen system, GM'ed by Sean.
Crit & FumbleONE SHOT - "Up The Creek" (Vaesen) 1 of 1
Our first go of playing on the Vaesen system, GM'ed by Sean!!!





















