Shows / Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
Welcome to your cozy corner of the internet, where movies are merry, commentary is cheeky, and holiday spirit lasts all year long! We’re Jennifer and Josh, two TV movie fanatics working to create your favorite Hallmark hangout! We're diving deep into very sleigh bell-worthy (and sometimes cringe-worthy) movie, one episode at a time. From hot cocoa takes to heartfelt debates, this is your go-to channel for festive fun and sharp-witted reviews! (Not affiliated with Hallmark Media!)
Episodes
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
"Because of Cupid": A Sweet Surprise from Hallmark Channel!
In this episode of Do You Watch What I Watch?, we’re recapping and reviewing Hallmark Channel’s “Because of Cupid,” starring Evan Roderick and Amy Groening!…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
We Didn’t Expect to Love Hallmark's "The Way to You"… But Kim Matula & Aaron O’Connell Won Us Over!
Did Hallmark Channel just deliver one of its most heartfelt romances of the year? In this episode of Do You Watch What I Watch?, we’re breaking down “The Way…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
The Best (& Worst) of 2025's Christmas Movies! The 4th Annual DYWWIW Watchies!
The votes have been tallied! Now, let's gab about it!Jennifer and Josh are back to hand out awards in this year's 'Do You Watch What I Watch' Watchies! From…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
'The Christmas Baby' | Hallmark Channel Recap & Review
We're wrapping up the 'Countdown to Christmas' season with a full recap and review of a new Hallmark Channel movie starring Ali Liebert and Katherine Barrell…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
'Christmas With The Knightlys' | UPTV Recap & Review
What do a small-town teacher, the 9th richest family in America, and a sleazy news reporter have in common? We're back -- and STILL WAITING -- to be uplifted…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
An interview with (a Hallmark Channel) Santa! Getting to know Trevor Lerner!
We're excited to bring you a heartfelt and candid conversation with friend of the podcast and all-around great guy, Trevor Lerner! You may know him as Dusty…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
'A Make Or Break Holiday' | Hallmark Channel Recap & Review
What do a bunch of Nutella, a front yard obstacle course, and the winner of 'Finding Mr. Christmas Season 2' have in common? We are back with another fun recap…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
'Christmas In Big Sky Country' | UPTV Recap & Review
What do a struggling yarn shop, a shady waiver, and a sleezy oil company have in common? We're back and still waiting to be uplifted by UPTV. Will our third…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
'A Suite Holiday Romance' | Hallmark Channel Recap & Review
What do a bougie hotel, an impulsive royal, and children's literature have in common? Hallmark Channel's 'Countdown to Christmas' rolls on and so do we, with a…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E58 - 'Finding Mr. Christmas - EPISODE 8'
Old-timey trains and a big winner! We're back to recap and review the finale of Hallmark's "Finding Mr. Christmas". This one has Rustin, Angel, and Craig…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E57: 'A Christmas Murder Mystery'
What do a high-society murder, crossword puzzles, and a dysfunctional family have in common? We're back to recap and review a rather BONKERS movie from UPTV…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E56: 'She's Making A List'
What do a high-tech Naughty or Nice list, a pizza shop, and an aspiring young magician have in common?
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E55 'Finding Mr. Christmas - EPISODE 7'
Cards to Mom and plenty of tears! We're back to recap the latest episode of 'Finding Mr. Christmas', as Hallmark Channel continues the search for their next…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E54: 'My Secret Santa'
What do a ski resort, makeup prosthetics, and a lonely landlord have in common? We're back with another fun recap and review! This time, we're checking out a…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E53: 'Finding Mr. Christmas - EPISODE 6'
Silent Santas and Ashley Williams!! We're back to recap another fun episode of Hallmark's reality TV search for the network's next leading man! We're…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E52: 'The More The Merrier'
What do a snowstorm, a whole lotta Christmas cookies, and a baby boom have in common?
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E51: 'A Grand Ole Opry Christmas'
What do a songwriting journal, a magical church pew, and a whole lotta sequins and fringe have in common? We're back with a full recap and review of the…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E50: 'We Met In December'
What do a chance encounter, a sewing hobby, and Silent Night by candlelight have in common? We're back with another fun recap and review! This one centers on…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E49: 'Finding Mr. Christmas - EPISODE 5'
Inflatable ornaments and a team acting challenge! We're back to recap and review the latest episode of Hallmark Channel's 'Finding Mr. Christmas'! This one…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E48: 'Tidings For The Season'
What do a big-city news anchor, his #1 child fan, and the company Thrivant have in common? We're back to recap and review another new Hallmark 'Countdown to…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E47: 'Holiday Touchdown: A Bills Love Story'
What do Bills Nation, a secret santa, and the hottest hot wings have in common? We're back to recap and review the highly-anticipated 'Holiday Touchdown: A…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E46: 'Gilmore Girls' (PART 2)
Although we typically talk about made-for-TV movies on our channel, Jennifer kicked Josh out for this very special episode of Do You Watch What I Watch? ! The…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E45: 'Finding Mr. Christmas - EPISODE 4'
Slip & Slide and a Talent Show! We're back to recap the latest chapter in Hallmark's search for the network's newest leading man! This one had the guys…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E44: 'A Keller Christmas Vacation'
What do a European cruise, ice skating, and lederhosen have in common? We're back to recap and review Hallmark's 'A Keller Christmas Vacation', starring…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E43: 'Three Wisest Men'
What do a a forgotten anniversary, a missing bird, and a new job offer have in common? We love a good trilogy and we're back to recap and review the third…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E42: 'The Great Christmas Snow-In'
What do a struggling songwriter, a knitting obsession, and a WHOLE lot of fictional fantasies have in common?
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E41: 'Finding Mr. Christmas - EPISODE 3'
Gingerbread houses and horse rides?? We're back with a shorter -- SPOILER-FREE -- recap of the latest episode of Season 2 of Finding Mr. Christmas, brand-new…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E40: 'Christmas Above The Clouds'
What do an overseas flight, a set of three ghosts, and a Scroogy CEO have in common? We're back to recap this highly-anticipated 'Countdown to Christmas'…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E39: 'Gilmore Girls' (PART 1)
Although we typically talk about made-for-TV movies on our channel, Jennifer kicked Josh out for this very special episode of Do You Watch What I Watch? The…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E38: 'A Newport Christmas'
What do time travel, a magical comet, and an early 1900s New England socialite have in common?We're back to recap and review this highly-anticipated 'Countdown…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E37: 'Finding Mr. Christmas - EPISODE 2'
Slingshots and a crane?? We're back with a shorter -- SPOILER-FREE -- recap of the second episode of Season 2 of Finding Mr. Christmas, brand-new on Hallmark…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E36: 'Christmas On Duty'
What do a toy train, two career-driven Marines, and two angry dads with grudges have in common? We're back with another fun recap and review from Hallmark's…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E35: 'Merry Christmas, Ted Cooper!'
What does a track suit-wearing walking group, a rogue box of Christmas lights, and a mayonnaise-y pub burger have in common? We're back to recap another new…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E34: 'Finding Mr. Christmas - EPISODE 1'
We're back with a shorter -- SPOILER-FREE -- recap of the first episode of Season 2 of Finding Mr. Christmas, brand-new on Hallmark Channel. As the network…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E33: 'A Christmas Angel Match'
What do Heavenly yoga, magical feathers, and a Christmas flash mob have in common? We're back, as Hallmark's "Countdown to Christmas" rolls on. This time…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E32: BONUS EPISODE: Hallmark Channel's "Joy To Your World" Producer (& Our Friend) Nick Schwarz!
How cool is this?!? Our good friend, Nick Schwarz -- who wrote, produced, and sang our theme song -- produced Hallmark Channel's new promo hit for this year's…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E31: 'Haul Out The Halloween'
What do a crooked portrait, a new children’s book, and a spooky cul-de-sac have in common? So, is this one more trick or more treat. Listen for a full plot…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E30: 'A Royal Montana Christmas'
What does a hand-carved horse, a firefighter fundraiser, and the fictional country of Zelarnia have in common?
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E29: 'In Merry Measure'
What do a high school choir, a fading pop star, and a beatbox version of ‘Hark The Herald Angels Sing’ have in common?We're back -- with special guest Mary!!…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S428: The 4th Annual 'Do You Watch What I Watch' Draft Spectacular
You guys, it's time! We're back to draft -- in splendidly low-key fashion -- the holiday movies we'll be recapping and reviewing this season. Which ones will…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E27: 'Small Town Christmas'
What do Kringlefest, a town-wide Secret Santa, and a letter that was never received have in common? We're back to recap and review another fan favorite from…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E26: 'Next Stop Christmas'
What do a magical train, a special jewelry box, and time travel have in common? We're back with another fun recap and review with a special guest, Carley, a…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E25: 'Time For Us To Come Home For Christmas'
What does a mystery red invitation, the Blue Note Trio, and a really bad Blake Shelton song have in common? We're back with another fun recap and review, this…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E24: Reacting To The 2025 Hallmark Christmas Movie Lineup: Surprises & Predictions!
Join us as we unwrap Hallmark's 2025 "Countdown to Christmas" Movie Lineup! 🎄 Dive into the festive cheer as we share our reactions to the 24 new holiday…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E23: 'The Christmas Ornament'
What do a butterfly ornament, early-morning ice skating, and a bike shop have in common? We're back to continue our '12 Pods of Christmas' Summer series with…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E22: 'A Dickens Of A Holiday!"
What do a mix tape, a chicken pot pie, and Ace Hardware have in common? We're back with an all-new recap and review! This time, it's 2021's "A Dickens of a…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E21: 'Once Upon A Christmas Miracle'
What do a liver transplant, a wreath-making hobby, and more than a few glasses of egg nog have in common? Our '12 Pods of Christmas' series continues with this…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E20: 'Cranberry Christmas'
What does Pamela Franks, a farm real estate acquisition and hand-made ornaments have in common? So much to unpack in this one, guys! Jennifer has BREAKING NEWS…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E19: 'Deliver By Christmas'
What do a lot of baked goods, a single father, and the most festive of small town tree lightings have in common? Jennifer has technical difficulties and one of…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E18: 'Five Star Christmas'
What does a sassafras candy cane, a breaker box, and the Ralston Inn have in common? We're back to continue our '12 Pods of Christmas' series with this fun one…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E17: 'The Mistletoe Secret'
What do a small town in Utah, a celebrity travel writer with a secret, and a symbolic ornament have in common?
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E16: Cozy Up With Hallmark Actor Tyler Hynes: A Heartfelt Fireside Chat!
Join us fireside for an intimate, wide-ranging conversation with Hallmark star Tyler Hynes! In this cozy and candid episode, Tyler opens up about what Hallmark…
Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie ReviewsS4E15: 'Christmas By Starlight'
What do a family cafe, a sentimental snowglobe, and a BBQ food truck have in common? We are back to wrap up our 'Christmas in July' series with a fan favorite…
Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie ReviewsS4E14: 'Rescuing Christmas'
What do a radio contest, a narcissist photographer, and a Christmas fox have in common? We're rolling on with our 'Christmas in July' series and recapping and…
Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie ReviewsS4E13: 'Holiday Hotline'
What do a set of turkey mishaps, a few dollops of Daisy-brand dairy products, and a fake American accent have in common?
Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie ReviewsS4E12: 'Ghosts Of Christmas Always'
What does Bill Murray’s “Scrooged”, "The Great Unknown", and a Christmas carousel have in common? Jennifer + Josh are back to kick off 'Christmas In July'! All…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E11: 'Every Christmas Has A Story'
What do a live TV news blunder, the most Christmas-y of small towns, and a mystery surrounding a Christmas tree have in common? Jennifer + Josh are back to…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E10: 'A Christmas Melody'
What do a janitor Santa, a Folgers product placement, and MARIAH CAREY have in common? Our special 'Coal For Christmas?' series continues in June, as Jennifer…
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E9: 'Family For Christmas'
What do a sidewalk Santa, Channel 8 News, and a falling gigantic candy cane have in common?
- Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
S4E8: 'Christmas Bedtime Stories'
What does a malfunctioned Build a Bear, a military toy drive and a whole slew of unprocessed grief have in common?Jennifer and Josh are back with a special…