Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul #20: Should SCOTUS Justices Have Term Limits?
Transcript
- 0:00It's the most wonderful time of the week.
- 0:06Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast with your host, Paul Raider.
- 0:10Merry Christmas to all of you who celebrate.
- 0:14Today, we're going to talk about potential term limits on the Supreme Court of the United
- 0:20States or SCOTUS for short.
- 0:23So earlier this month, December 2024, US senators Joe Manchin of West Virginia, who's
- 0:31leaving office at the end of his term in January, and Peter Welch of Vermont issued a or
- 0:38introduced, excuse me, a resolution that calls for nonrenewable 18 year terms for new US
- 0:46Supreme Court justices with each new term starting every 2 years, and current justices
- 0:52would be exempt from these terms.
- 0:55They called they being Joe Manchin and Peter Welch, called the current lifetime appointment
- 1:02structure polarizing and political posturing, and they also cited plummeting public
- 1:08confidence in the institution of SCOTUS itself.
- 1:12And now this is a resolution, not a bill, so passage wouldn't outright implement term
- 1:18limits, but rather be a formal call for amendment to the US constitution.
- 1:22More about how that process works.
- 1:26Now calls for term limits on Scottish justices are nothing new, but there is arguably more
- 1:33clamoring for it to happen more recently.
- 1:37So should we have term limits on SCOTUS justices?
- 1:42What are the arguments made for and against giving them term limits?
- 1:47What are the considerations that go into potentially implementing term limits?
- 1:53All of that and more is good, what we're gonna talk about today.
- 1:56So let's dive right in.
- 1:59First of all, why do Scottish justices have lifetime appointments?
- 2:03Why don't they have a fixed term?
- 2:06As article 3, section 1 of the US constitution says, the judges both of the supreme and
- 2:11inferior courts, those are other federal courts that are not the supreme court, shall hold
- 2:16their offices during good behavior, good behavior basically being as long as they're not
- 2:22doing something that's an impeachable offense.
- 2:25And the insight into why the framers of the constitution ultimately decided on this is
- 2:31provided by Alexander Hamilton in his writing of Federalist Paper number 78.
- 2:37And the Federalist Papers were a series of documents from the framers.
- 2:41Well, actually, Alexander Hamilton, James Madison, and in a few cases, John Jay
- 2:46specifically, detailing to the public why the US constitution should be ratified to replace
- 2:53what was then the governing document of the United States, the articles of confederation.
- 2:59And in federalist paper number 78, there's a couple of quotes in particular I wanna
- 3:04highlight.
- 3:05In a republic, it is a no less excellent barrier to the encroachments and oppressions of
- 3:10the representative body, and it is the best expedient which can be devised in any
- 3:15government to secure a steady, upright, and impartial administration of the laws.
- 3:22In other words, according to Alexander Hamilton, lifetime terms would allow the
- 3:27Supreme Court to be impartial and resistant to any attempts at influence by congress or the
- 3:33president.
- 3:34And then the other quote I'm gonna cite here, the judiciary from the nature of its functions
- 3:40will always be the least dangerous of the political rights of the constitution because it
- 3:45will be least in a capacity to annoy or injure them.
- 3:49The executive not only dispenses the honors but holds the sword of the community.
- 3:53The legislature not only commands the purse but prescribes the rules by which the duties and
- 3:58rights of every citizen are to be regulated.
- 4:01The judiciary, on the contrary, has no influence over either the sword or the purse.
- 4:07And in other words, that just means the judiciary is naturally the least powerful of
- 4:11the 3 branches.
- 4:12It doesn't have any sort of capability to enforce its rulings.
- 4:18It really has to rely on the executive and legislative branches to abide by what the court
- 4:24says.
- 4:25The executive branch has the power to execute laws while the legislative branch has the power
- 4:30to appropriate money, hence the executive having the power of the sword and the
- 4:36legislative branch having the power of the purse.
- 4:39But the judiciary has no power over either of these things or anything comparable.
- 4:44So that's the idea of the lifetime terms would be bit of a balance to give some power over to
- 4:52the judiciary, the judicial branch, and try to keep the balance in the separation of powers
- 4:59and checks and balances.
- 5:02But now more and more people these days question whether the judiciary still has that
- 5:07insulation from partisan politics and whether they are even accountable enough for any
- 5:14rulings that they administer.
- 5:17And some political observers have been questioning it for a lot longer.
- 5:22But do term limits actually lead to a more independent judiciary?
- 5:28Does it really actually insulate them from these partisan politics that we're talking
- 5:32about?
- 5:32Does it actually make them salable?
- 5:35Well, let's first compare SCOTUS with state supreme courts because every state has their
- 5:43own supreme court that has a similar function to the US Supreme Court, but, of course, the US
- 5:49Supreme Court SCOTUS is the highest court in the land.
- 5:52So for SCOTUS, when a justice leaves office for any reason or they're about to leave office, so
- 5:59if they pass away, they get impeached, they are otherwise physically or mentally incapable of
- 6:05performing their duties, a president picks a new justice to replace them, and nominated
- 6:12justices must get a majority of the US senate to support their nomination to be confirmed to
- 6:19the bench.
- 6:20Now unlike SCOTUS, however, almost all state supreme court justices have fixed terms, and
- 6:26most at least have what we call a mandatory retirement age.
- 6:30So when they hit that that age, they have to leave office regardless of whether they finish
- 6:36their term.
- 6:36Although in some cases, some states actually do let that justice finish out their term even
- 6:41when they hit that mandatory retirement age.
- 6:43They just can't run or be appointed to it again.
- 6:48In most cases, terms are 6, 8, or 10 year terms, and 33 states have a mandatory
- 6:54retirement age.
- 6:55But some states have both fixed terms and a mandatory retirement age.
- 6:59Rhode Island is similar to SCOTUS in that it's the only state with lifetime appointments and
- 7:06no mandatory retirement age.
- 7:08Massachusetts, New Hampshire, and New Jersey don't have fixed terms, but they do require
- 7:15retirement by age 70.
- 7:17So not quite a lifetime appointment, but fairly close to it.
- 7:24And there's also a lot of variety in how state supreme court justices are chosen and or kept
- 7:30on past their first term.
- 7:32So you have partisan elections where the justices actually run as Democrat, Republican,
- 7:38libertarian, green, whatever the case may be.
- 7:41There are nonpartisan elections where they're listed on there, but they don't have any sort
- 7:45of party affiliation.
- 7:47Also have legislative elections where and this is not a very common one, where the state's
- 7:54legislature actually chooses the supreme court justices.
- 8:00You also have gubernatorial appointments that are confirmed by another government body where
- 8:05the governor can just choose whoever they want.
- 8:07And then there's also an assisted appointment method where the governor picks from a list,
- 8:12and they have to pick from that list.
- 8:14Although, they can't say in some cases, they can say, I don't want any of those candidates.
- 8:18Get them get them out of my face.
- 8:20And then whatever body it is that gives them that list would have to come up with another
- 8:26list.
- 8:26It it may it depends on on the state.
- 8:28They all have little nuances that are different from each other, but those are the 5 basic ways
- 8:35that state supreme court justices are chosen.
- 8:38And 38 states require the justice to reappear on the ballot at the end of their term for
- 8:45elections.
- 8:45So 19 states have retention elections, and that is you might be familiar with it, voting on it
- 8:52yourself where it's simply, do you want to retain this justice for this next term of
- 8:59however many years?
- 9:01You say yes or no.
- 9:02They're not actually running against anybody.
- 9:05You're just choosing, I want this person to come back, or, nope.
- 9:09Get him out of here.
- 9:10They're a bunch of bums.
- 9:1112 states have them these justices participate in nonpartisan elections in order to get
- 9:18reelected to the bench.
- 9:205 of states have them participate in partisan elections.
- 9:25Michigan has a specific method method called the Michigan method, very aptly named, where
- 9:31they combine a partisan candidate selection process akin to a primary, but then the general
- 9:36election is nonpartisan.
- 9:39And then Montana runs justices in a nonpartisan election if they have an opponent, but if they
- 9:45don't have an opponent, then it becomes a retention election.
- 9:47So yes or no.
- 9:50And then in 8 states, justices do not stand for an election to earn a subsequent term.
- 9:58So that's comparing SCOTUS to supreme court justices.
- 10:03Well, now let's look back at SCOTUS again specifically.
- 10:07What are some of the arguments made for and against SCOTUS term limits?
- 10:12So just general general camps here will have lifetime terms versus fixed terms.
- 10:18They don't necessarily the people who support fixed terms don't necessarily all agree on the
- 10:24same exact specifications.
- 10:26They might not necessarily agree on how long that term should be.
- 10:29But just for the sake of making this not complicated, just lifetime term camps versus
- 10:36fixed term camps.
- 10:37So some of the debates that are had about this whole topic, what would lead to less
- 10:44politicization of SCOTUS?
- 10:46Would lifetime terms make it be less political than these proposed fixed terms, or would these
- 10:53these fixed terms alleviate some of that political posturing?
- 10:57Because, ideally, obviously, we'd all like to have well, most of us at least would like to
- 11:03have a judiciary that is not beholden to partisan politics.
- 11:08Now some people think that justices are beholden to it, while some people don't
- 11:15necessarily think that.
- 11:16And some of that is partially based on local views.
- 11:20For some people, if you, have a similar ideology to whatever the ideological majority
- 11:27on the court is, you might think that they're not being political because, yeah, they share
- 11:30my opinion.
- 11:31Of course, they're they're they're they're just being unbiased.
- 11:33They they're just following the law.
- 11:35And if your ideology does not comport with theirs, then you're probably gonna see them as
- 11:42more political.
- 11:42But in any case, what would lead to less politicization of SCOTUS?
- 11:51So for lifetime terms, according to the framers of the constitution like Alexander Hamilton,
- 11:56Lifetime terms insulated justices from political consider considerations.
- 12:00They didn't have to worry about, oh, my my reappointment year is coming up.
- 12:06I I have to make sure that I do what the president and congress, would prefer for me to
- 12:12do so that I get back on the bench.
- 12:14That's the rationale there.
- 12:17Fixed terms, though, in the eyes of these term limit advocates, cuts down on the
- 12:21politicization that we've seen recently because these confirmation battles have inarguably been
- 12:29very politically charged whether you support one side or the other.
- 12:36Now lifetime terms might make these appointment battles more of an ex existential issue because
- 12:43if it's lifetime terms, you can't do anything about them being in office unless you actually
- 12:47impeach them.
- 12:48And is impeachment necessarily a viable route, or are they doing something that's an
- 12:54impeachable offense?
- 12:56You have those kinds of issues to consider, but it's it's it's more it becomes more of an
- 13:02existential crisis for people who have a vested interest in in whether a supreme court justice
- 13:09gets nominated or not.
- 13:11You saw, for example, with the Brett Kavanaugh, confirmation battle or and when Merrick Garland
- 13:19who didn't actually come up for a vote, but when he was not being the whole time when he
- 13:26was not being able to actually get up for a confirmation vote, that was another, example of
- 13:34this being an existential issue for a lot of people.
- 13:38But on the other hand, fixed terms might make political battles over confirmation more
- 13:43common.
- 13:44Clearly, lifetime terms don't actually insulate judges from from political wheeling and dealing
- 13:51and battles and all that.
- 13:52But does that mean that term limits would make those less common?
- 13:56That's for you to decide.
- 13:58Obviously, I have my own opinion on the matter, but I'm just trying to lay out everything for
- 14:03you so you can come up with your own opinion.
- 14:06Another debate, what would make SCOTUS more accountable?
- 14:10So for lifetime terms, in their eyes, lifetime terms allow for more deliberation by presidents
- 14:19over who to pick because it is a lifetime term.
- 14:22So, theoretically, you're gonna be picking better candidates and ones that are more
- 14:27accountable because you're thinking hard about, okay.
- 14:30This person is going to be a lifetime appointment, so I really need to think hard
- 14:35about what they believe.
- 14:37At least that's the idea.
- 14:39And, also, if they truly are just that bad of a judge, they can just be impeached in the eyes
- 14:44of lifetime term advocates.
- 14:47Now for those who advocate for term limits, in their eyes, these judges, they eventually have
- 14:53to face a set end to their tenure.
- 14:56And impeachment is not a reliable mechanism to get rid of the judges, and that process would
- 15:02be politicized anyways.
- 15:04So you still have those issues with accountability and politicization.
- 15:10So, again, those lifetime terms make SCOTUS more accountable, or do term limits do that?
- 15:16Up to you to decide.
- 15:18What is the best way to uphold separation of powers and checks and balances?
- 15:22What is the best way to keep that balance between powers that the executive branch has,
- 15:29that the legislative branch has, and that the judicial branch has?
- 15:33Would lifetime terms or keeping lifetime terms upset that balance, or would term limits make
- 15:42those issues more apparent?
- 15:46For lifetime term advocates, in their eyes, it insulates justices from the machinations of
- 15:52president and congress post confirmation.
- 15:54As soon as they're in in office, they don't have to worry about president or congress
- 15:59trying to get rid of them simply because of disagreements over ideology and court rulings.
- 16:06And like Alexander Hamilton said in Federalist paper number 78, the judicial branch has the
- 16:12lowest ability to uphold its powers compared to the executive and legislative branch, and
- 16:18lifetime terms help balance that power more evenly in that separation of powers and checks
- 16:24and balances aspect.
- 16:26But on the other hand, term limits advocates argue that because of the considerable power
- 16:32that judicial rollings hold, a lifetime term gives too much power to these judges to shape
- 16:38public policy for a long time compared to fixed term presidents and congress.
- 16:44We've heard in previous cases when a when the court makes a certain ruling that either the
- 16:52president or certain members of congress say, well, they're basically making laws because
- 16:57they're interpret interpreting the constitution incorrectly.
- 17:01In their in their eyes, when they disagree with a judicial ruling, they're basically becoming
- 17:07the legislative and executive branch where they're, right, they they're, in effect,
- 17:13writing laws themselves and and making others execute the laws as they interpret.
- 17:21Obviously, a lot of that is based on your personal political views or the or congress's
- 17:28personal political views as to whether they're interpreting the constitution correctly or
- 17:36incorrectly.
- 17:36But in their eyes, when they disagree with something, it is in effect writing laws as they
- 17:42see fit.
- 17:43Also, term limit advocates argue that judges have just become an arm for the president to
- 17:49have undue influence over policy, and future presidents should have the ability to blunt
- 17:55that by replacing other justices on fixed terms.
- 17:59So, yes, post confirmation, presidents and congress can't do anything, but term limit
- 18:08advocates argue that there's already basically a litmus test for these judges where they have
- 18:13to meet certain ideological requirements from a president for them to pick that judge and for
- 18:20congress to confirm that judge.
- 18:22They're basically saying, if they don't meet these specific requirements of how they view
- 18:29things like abortion or or gun laws or any anything else that is very controversial by
- 18:37nature based the the the president and congress are already having a prior influence on what
- 18:46judicial rulings are in the first place.
- 18:49And then real quick, just one last debate to talk about.
- 18:53And these aren't the only debates to be had when arguing about whether we should have term
- 18:58limits on the supreme court, but touched on a little bit just a moment ago.
- 19:03It's good every president have an opportunity to appoint a justice.
- 19:08Obviously, lifetime term advocates don't see it that way.
- 19:13Fixed term advocates do think that supreme court justices or, excuse me, that president
- 19:20should be able to, each president should have an opportunity to appoint a justice.
- 19:25So are these presidents is every president entitled to being able to select a judge as a
- 19:32result of being the chief executive of the United States?
- 19:36All these things are for you to decide.
- 19:37I just wanna lay them out for everybody to be able to think about.
- 19:42But, again, there's all sorts of other debates that can be had about whether we should have
- 19:48term limits for SCOTUS.
- 19:50Now other practical considerations for supreme court term limits.
- 19:57How long should these terms be for?
- 20:00What is too short and what is too long?
- 20:02Should these be 9 year terms where every justice is getting is starting a new term every
- 20:09every year where it's justice 1 is starting 2025 and then going to 2034?
- 20:16Justice 2 is starting in 2026 and then going to 2035, so on and so forth.
- 20:21Should these be 18 year terms?
- 20:25What is what is considered is 9 years too short?
- 20:27Is 18 years too long?
- 20:29Is there a different way that you can do it?
- 20:33Does and, really, does every justice have their own term dates, or would multiple justices
- 20:39start in a given year?
- 20:41What if you started what if 3 of them had a start date in 2026, and then the next 3 had a
- 20:48start date in 2028.
- 20:50And then there'll be 6 year terms for these supreme court justices.
- 20:54How exactly do you figure all these things out?
- 20:59Should should justices only be allowed one term, or can they serve multiple?
- 21:04That's part of the consideration for term lengths as well.
- 21:07If these are 18 year terms, then should it just be one term for the Supreme Court justices?
- 21:13If these are 9 year terms, should they be able to serve a second term?
- 21:20And what if we made it possible for multiple terms, but they have to be nonconsecutive?
- 21:25So if we had a 9 year term, they serve from 2025 to 2034.
- 21:31They may have to sit out for the for another 9 years, but then they can be pointed to the
- 21:36bench again 9 years later.
- 21:39Should that be part of the equation?
- 21:42Our current justice is exempt from would be term limits.
- 21:46So the nine justices we have now, they can serve as long as they want, but as soon as they
- 21:52leave office, then that's when a term would start for the next justice, or or the current
- 21:57justice is also going to be subject to these fixed terms.
- 22:04If we implement term limits, do we change anything about how Scottish justices are
- 22:09chosen?
- 22:10Does congress have a bigger role in how they are chosen?
- 22:14Do voters have a larger role?
- 22:17If you compare it to, like, we talked about for the state supreme court justices, how some of
- 22:21them are partisan elections, some of them are nonpartisan elections.
- 22:25There are some that are an assisted appointment method.
- 22:28So does the president just get to pick whoever he wants, or can or should congress be able to
- 22:33send them a list sort of like the judicial nominating commissions for certain states where
- 22:38they say you have to pick a person from this list?
- 22:41Does that come into play?
- 22:43Do we change how that works?
- 22:46And or or should we have a mandatory retirement age instead?
- 22:50For example, should they be able to if they get to 70, then they have to leave, or 75, 72,
- 22:57whatever the case may be.
- 22:58Or should a mandatory retirement age be a supplement to term limits like some states do
- 23:03where some states have a 6 or 8 or 10 year term, and they can keep serving those until
- 23:10they hit that mandatory retirement age, then either have to leave office immediately, or
- 23:15they can serve the rest of that term, but then have to leave office after that.
- 23:19All sorts of these practical considerations that you have to account for, and it's not a
- 23:24straightforward, conversation.
- 23:27So you can it's it's all well and good to say it it's easy to say that, we should have fixed
- 23:33terms.
- 23:34If even if we all agreed that we should have fixed terms for SCOTUS, you had to think about
- 23:42all these other little nooks and crannies to say, okay.
- 23:46We want fixed terms, but it needs to look like this.
- 23:49And then there's might be some disagreement there.
- 23:52For lifetime terms, it's it's pretty straightforward because they already have
- 23:57lifetime terms.
- 23:58They either have lifetime terms or they don't.
- 24:00But if you were to implement fixed terms, then there might be some disagreement as to how
- 24:05exactly those look.
- 24:07So all sorts of considerations for SCOTUS justices and how term limits would actually
- 24:15look for them.
- 24:17But let's go to the joint resolution by senators Manchin and Welch to talk about how
- 24:24they address some of those practical considerations.
- 24:28So I'll have the 2 of the those 2 senators address these considerations.
- 24:33So this is a joint resolution, not a bill.
- 24:38Congress passing a resolution, not actually implementing a policy or a law of some sort in
- 24:44a lot of cases.
- 24:44Typically, there's not a whole lot of practical difference between bills and resolutions.
- 24:52But in this case, a joint resolution is needed.
- 24:57SCOTUS SCOTUS term limits is not a change that congress can simply make through a bill because
- 25:01it fundamentally changes a part of the constitution.
- 25:06And when a joint resolution proposed when a joint resolution proposes an amendment to the
- 25:13constitution, 2 thirds of both chambers of congress need to approve.
- 25:17And instead of sending the resolution to the president for approval like you would normally
- 25:22do for a bill, it is sent directly to the archivist of the United States, and then that
- 25:27archivist then submits that prospective amendment to the state legislatures or special
- 25:32conventions called by the states.
- 25:35More on this later as we talk about what actual implementation of term limits looks like or the
- 25:42actual process of implementing these term limits.
- 25:45We're gonna talk about that in a little bit.
- 25:48But as for this joint resolution, it's a short resolution that has 8 sections.
- 25:53So the key points are that it would keep SCOTUS at 9 justices.
- 25:58Early on, the supreme court fluctuated between 510 justices until the judiciary act of 1869
- 26:05fixed it at 9 justices.
- 26:07Now there have been attempts to change that in the past, like with FDR and what was called the
- 26:12court packing bill, which would have allowed him to appoint justices for every current
- 26:18justice that was above, I wanna say, was 70 years old.
- 26:21And at the time, that would have added another 6 justices, I believe.
- 26:27So there have been attempts like that before to change the number of supreme court justices,
- 26:32but the judiciary act of 18/69 has fixed it at 9 justices since then.
- 26:39Another key point is that it sets the term for the first justice to start on July 1st of the
- 26:45first odd numbered year following ratification of this article until June 30th, 18 years after
- 26:53that.
- 26:54And then each subsequent justice's term starts 2 years after the previous justice, which is
- 26:59the next odd numbered year for the 2nd justice.
- 27:02Then the next justice would be 2 years after that.
- 27:04So you'd have, theoretically, one justice starts the first justice starts in 2027.
- 27:11The second justice starts in 2029.
- 27:143rd one starts in 2031, so on through all the other justices there.
- 27:20Current justices serving before the ratification of the article would still be able
- 27:24to serve as long as they want until they are mentally or physically incapable, die, or
- 27:30impeach.
- 27:32However they leave office, they are not gonna the the current ones, the current nine are not
- 27:37going to be subject to the Supreme Court term limits if they were to be implemented.
- 27:44Terms, however, would begin every 2 years regardless of when they leave the bench.
- 27:48So for example, if Amy Coney Barrett's seats were to have a term start in 20 29, but she
- 28:01serves past that point, she serves into 2032 or whatever, and then she decides to retire.
- 28:10The justice that would be filling in her seat would finish that term.
- 28:15They would not get the full 18 years because, technically, that term for Amy Coney Barrett's
- 28:20seat started in 20 29, but they would finish out the rest of that term.
- 28:26And then 18 years after 20 29, 20 47, that's when the next justice would begin their term.
- 28:35So like I said, when a current justice retires, the newly appointed justice would serve the
- 28:41remainder of that 18 year term.
- 28:45Now what would it actually take to implement SCOTUS term limits?
- 28:51So, again, this has to be done through an amendment to the US constitution.
- 28:55Congress and president cannot ask a bill that fundamentally changes an aspect of the
- 29:01constitution like this.
- 29:03And even if congress and president could pass a bill, that would call into question whether
- 29:07checks and balances between them and the judiciary are being respected.
- 29:12And then if somebody doesn't like the bill and they try to challenge it and bring it to the
- 29:15Supreme Court, will the Supreme Court then strike it down and say it's unconstitutional?
- 29:22You have all these issues to consider.
- 29:25But in any case, it's not gonna be a bill.
- 29:27It can't be a bill.
- 29:29So it has to be this joint resolution that senators Manchin and Welch have proposed.
- 29:35Or if somebody else proposes, a joy resolution that would propose an amendment to the
- 29:41constitution.
- 29:42So how do you amend the US constitution?
- 29:44We had an early episode of the podcast that went over this.
- 29:47So an amendment has a formal method of proposal and then ratification that's much different
- 29:53from regular bills and resolutions.
- 29:55There's 2 methods for a proposal.
- 29:57You either have 2 thirds of the US house and the US senate agreed to the bill, or you have a
- 30:04national convention called by congress at the request of 2 thirds of the state legislatures.
- 30:10They can do it that way.
- 30:12So if you get past the proposal stage, then you have 2 methods for ratification.
- 30:16You either have 3 quarters of the state legislatures, 38 states, because you have to
- 30:22round it up because 37a half is 3 quarters of the states, and you can't really have half a
- 30:27state do it.
- 30:27So it has to be 38 states that ratify the amendments, or special conventions hold in 3
- 30:34quarters of the states have to agree to it.
- 30:39Now a survey by the University of Pennsylvania's Edinburg Public Policy Center
- 30:44back in May 2024 said that 69% of respondents supported a mandatory retirement age and that
- 30:5068% supported term limits.
- 30:53Again, what will those exactly look like?
- 30:55That's not what the survey was was trying to get at.
- 30:57It was just trying to gauge general opinion about those things.
- 31:00So the public may largely support term limits for SCOTUS, but that doesn't mean that congress
- 31:07and state legislatures support those term limits.
- 31:10Now it's not an inherently impart inherently a partisan issue per se, but potential partisan
- 31:17interests are at play.
- 31:18Whichever party whose ideology is more in line with the current current SCOTUS ideology could
- 31:25be a harder sell for term limits.
- 31:27So right now, SCOTUS is currently more ideologically conservative.
- 31:31It's more to the right, so Republicans may be more reluctant to support term limits.
- 31:35And that that's where this term limit exemption for current justices can allay some of that
- 31:41opposition.
- 31:42If you say the current, conservative majority is not going to be affected by this would be
- 31:50amendment, and you might get Republicans to go along more with it.
- 31:53And then it'd be the same way if it was a more ideologically liberal court.
- 31:58It might be harder to sell Democrats on firm limits for the court.
- 32:02But, again, if you exempt current justices, might be easier to get them to support it.
- 32:09And then even if congress supports it, will enough state legislatures fall in line, quote,
- 32:15unquote?
- 32:16Because 3 quarters of the state legislatures is an even arguably even higher bar to clear than
- 32:23the initial 2 thirds of congress that is needed to propose that amendment.
- 32:28Now you do have a a there's, in recent years, been more uniformity between state level
- 32:35Republicans and Democrats or or between state level Republicans and federal level Republicans
- 32:41and uniformity between state level Democrats and federal level Democrats, but there's still
- 32:46going to be disagreements here and there.
- 32:49And even if the public really supports this, these term, would be term limits and mandatory
- 32:58retirement age, does that mean that congress or state legislatures are going to listen to them?
- 33:05Because they might sure.
- 33:07The public might be really on board with these things, but if they don't, for lack of a better
- 33:14term, threaten congress and state legislative, members with, hey.
- 33:21If you don't pass supreme court term limits, we might not vote for you, They these
- 33:27congressional members and these state legislative members might not be responsive to
- 33:32that.
- 33:32They have a lot of other fish to fry, so to speak.
- 33:35So if pub the pub the public can be really supportive of something, but if they don't
- 33:41really pressure people that are in office to implement something, then these people in
- 33:48office might not really do anything about it, especially if they don't actually support these
- 33:54term limits for SCOTUS justices.
- 33:57So in any case, it's going to be a long road ahead to getting term limits ratified, however
- 34:04those look.
- 34:05So even if, even if Joe Manchin and Peter Welch are successful in getting 2 thirds of the US
- 34:13house and 2 thirds of the US senate on board with the amendment, then you still have to go
- 34:19through the state legislatures, and who knows how that will end up.
- 34:22So a lot of things to resolve there or if another potential amendment that deals with
- 34:30SCOTUS term limits gets proposed, that makes a little bit of change to what Manchin and Welch
- 34:37have proposed.
- 34:38So lots of things to think about.
- 34:42But in any case, that is the end of today's episode.
- 34:46And as always, thank you very much for listening in.
- 34:51Let's end off any random question of the day just like we always do.
- 34:56Random question of today is, what's common grammatical or pronunciation mistake really
- 35:03grinds your gears?
- 35:05I'll tell you something that really drives me up a wall.
- 35:08Nuclear and nucleus, for 1, people say nuclear and nucleus all the time.
- 35:13It's really not hard to say nuclear or nucleus, I don't think.
- 35:18But, actually, what really bothers me is when people say and, usually, it's typed up.
- 35:23So when they say should of, would of, could of.
- 35:27If you look at the contractions of could've, should've, would've, there's nothing about
- 35:32those that indicates that it's could of.
- 35:36It's should have, not would of.
- 35:38It's would have.
- 35:39Not could of.
- 35:40It's could have.
- 35:44It says I mean, there's a lot there's lots of, things that really aren't that important in the
- 35:49grand scheme of things that get on my nerves.
- 35:51But you know what?
- 35:53I probably do some things that seem rather innocuous that bother other people too.
- 35:59So I I don't know.
- 36:00But in any case, let me know what you think about that or what your answer to that question
- 36:04is, and and, Ackman, whatever you think about the, content of, today's episode.
- 36:11Please be nice, though.
- 36:12I I I don't like mean words being thrown at me.
- 36:15Be nice.
- 36:16It could all be a little bit nicer to to each other, but it might and that includes includes
- 36:21myself.
- 36:22So, in any case, once again, thank you for listening.
- 36:27Links in the show notes for Facebook, LinkedIn, matchmakerfn profile if you wanna be a guest on
- 36:33this podcast or if you want me as a guest on your podcast.
- 36:38Email at Paul Raiderwrites@gmail.com.
- 36:44My book on Amazon, why independents rarely win elections, and how they could become more
- 36:48competitive.
- 36:50And I'll leave you on that.
- 36:52Merry Christmas to all of you who celebrate, or any other holidays that you celebrate around
- 36:59this time of year.
- 37:00And until then, take care.