Latest / Saigalseatrade Podcast / Beyond the Headlines: The Real Story Behind OPEC+, Sanctions & Seaborne Stratergy
Transcript
- 0:07Hello, everyone, and welcome to the Cycle Sea Trade podcast,
- 0:09where we decode the undercurrents of global shipping
- 0:12and energy markets. I'm Trisha Mohite, Research
- 0:15Analyst, and I'll be your host for today's episode.
- 0:17Today, I'm joined by shipping expert, Mr. Sandesh Khandat.
- 0:20So welcome to the episode Sandesh.
- 0:22Thank you, Trisha. It's a real pleasure to be here.
- 0:25And I will tell you what, this conversation couldn't be more
- 0:28timely. Now, Sandesh, let's start at the
- 0:31heart of the storm. OPEC announced an increase post
- 0:35which the headlines has been completely wild, so much so that
- 0:38they haven't just called it a declaration of war on US shale,
- 0:42but also a market flood and a shock move.
- 0:45So I see you have been saying quite adamantly that things are
- 0:49not quite like that. So could you tell us what is it
- 0:52that we are missing here? Well, Trisha, I'm really glad
- 0:55you opened with that because this is right here is the
- 0:59perfect example of what happens when the market noise downs out
- 1:03of substance. So we are witnessing one of the
- 1:06most misunderstood and kind of a misrepresented moves in the oil
- 1:11market history and what the headlines are showing is only
- 1:15the surface. So what we are about to unpack
- 1:17today, it goes into the strategy, the seasonality, the
- 1:21politics, the energy security concerns and then the broader
- 1:26macroeconomic ecosystem that I use.
- 1:29Every barrel that gets ships and sold.
- 1:31Now, Trisha, a lot of people look at oil at just the number,
- 1:36Brent is here, WTI is here. But that number is the end point
- 1:41of a huge chain reaction of decision made in Riyadh.
- 1:45It made the, you know, the decision made in Moscow,
- 1:48decision made in Washington and then in Beijing and even in New
- 1:52Delhi. So it reflects what tankers are
- 1:55doing, what refineries are planning and then what H funds
- 1:59are anticipating and then what politicians are trying to
- 2:02downplay or, you know, sometimes exaggerate for their own
- 2:06narratives. And if you don't understand the
- 2:08layers underneath that price tag, you are selling blind.
- 2:12So what the media and even some analysts have been pushing is
- 2:15this, you know, kind of a dramatic narrative that OPEC
- 2:19Plus suddenly decided to pump more oil to crash prices.
- 2:23And, you know, then eventually they're going to hurt American
- 2:26Shell. But that couldn't be a farther
- 2:28from the truth. And this isn't just aggressive
- 2:31supply surge and it is not coming out of nowhere.
- 2:34So let me paint a clear and clearer picture here.
- 2:37So OPEC Plus announced that they will increase production by
- 2:41411,000 barrels per day. And that figure, it's not an
- 2:45injection, it's a recognition. OPEC Plus didn't just say that
- 2:49OK, let's add some more barrels in the market and let's move on
- 2:53with that. What they said was and what the
- 2:56real analysis from their production growth is that we see
- 3:01that some of our members, that means some of OPEC members,
- 3:06notably Iraq and Kazakhstan have already producing over a quota.
- 3:10So rather than penalize them and risk internal dissent, let's
- 3:14adjust the official ceiling to reflect that reality.
- 3:17So this is what they have said in their recent meeting and the
- 3:22main shoes from that they OPEC Plus wants to contain or wants
- 3:27to remain their unique sentiments.
- 3:30And their unique sentiments is that their own unity when it
- 3:34comes to the production and price relativity.
- 3:38Now think of it like this. If you're hosting a dinner party
- 3:41and one of the guest shows up with a friend, so you didn't
- 3:44don't kick them out halfway through, right?
- 3:47You just pull up an extra chair and then call it part of the
- 3:50plan. And that's what this is.
- 3:52It's an accommodation formalization of what was
- 3:55already happening. And this wasn't kind of a
- 3:58spontaneous either. The group it had already
- 4:01announced months earlier that they were going to start rolling
- 4:05back 2.2 million barrels per day in a voluntary cuts over the 18
- 4:09months. So this wasn't some, you know,
- 4:11market shock. So this was a pre signaled.
- 4:15So anyone who was actually followed during the group's
- 4:18December statement would have seen these increases coming from
- 4:22a mile away. Now, having said that, here is
- 4:24the irony. Even with this so-called
- 4:26increases, actual export numbers from April shows that OPEC Plus
- 4:32exports are actually declined. So we are talking about a paper
- 4:36increase that doesn't even translate into a physical supply
- 4:40boost. And that's a critical to
- 4:42understand because, you know, it shows that the move is more
- 4:45about optics and policies than the barrels.
- 4:48And then there is a seasonal demand angle, which, you know,
- 4:51kind of a barely anyone in the mainstream media has been picked
- 4:55up on. So in summer in the Middle East
- 4:58isn't just hot, it's brutal. The climatic conditions in that
- 5:03particular area is way more haywire.
- 5:05So in summer, domestic demand for the electricity, it surges,
- 5:10particularly for air condition. So we are looking at an extra
- 5:131.2 million barrels per day being burned just to keep
- 5:17household and public spaces cool.
- 5:19And that is just in the Middle East area.
- 5:22You know if you closely see the OPEC Plus structure, the nations
- 5:26of the OPEC Plus has been distributed widely over the
- 5:29globe and we are only talking about the OPEC nations or OPEC
- 5:33Plus nations, those are present in the Middle East.
- 5:36Now having said that, another important point that has been
- 5:40out of box or that has no one think of is the Hull pilgrimage
- 5:44in Saudi Arabia. You know, it drowns millions of
- 5:48people from around the world. And then when they are coming
- 5:51into the country in the Saudi Arabia, in the Mecca, you then
- 5:55have to think about the higher demand aviation fuel, diesel for
- 5:59transport, gas for buses, power generation for the massive
- 6:03infrastructure which required to support the pilgrimage.
- 6:06And that demand spike is real and it's a domestic.
- 6:09So the most of the oil that being added in theory is never
- 6:15even leaving the region. And I have been already said in
- 6:19our previous podcast, higher production doesn't necessarily
- 6:22mean lead to the higher exports. So this is the domestic growth
- 6:27or domestic increase in the consumption of crude oil.
- 6:31It is staying at home. It's not going to depress the
- 6:34global market. So if anything, it helps tighten
- 6:37the international supply picture because those barrels aren't
- 6:41available for the exports. And at the last piece of puzzle
- 6:45is the group's cohesion. You know, OPEC Plus is a
- 6:48coalition and coalition survive not by rigid enforcement but by
- 6:53flexibility and trust. So if the leadership had tried
- 6:56to enforce strict curse on Iraq and Kazakhstan, you know, as a
- 7:00part of the punishment they risk splintering the group and
- 7:04instead they acknowledge what was happening and adjusted the
- 7:08rules to fit the reality. So what tells you that that this
- 7:13particular move, it's a strategy, it's a stabilizing and
- 7:17it's completely misunderstood. So when people say that this is
- 7:20about the price war with US shale, just look at the data,
- 7:24look at the export, look at the domestic consumption pattern,
- 7:27and most of all, look at the long game.
- 7:30This is about sustainability, not the sabotage.
- 7:34Now, Sandesh, I couldn't help but notice you saying that it
- 7:37isn't just about oil, it's about geopolitics.
- 7:40And you know that Saudi Arabia in particular has strategic
- 7:44motives beyond the barrels. So could you tell us more?
- 7:47What did you mean by that? And now we are moving into the
- 7:50real theatre of global energy politics because, you know,
- 7:54previously it was about the mechanics of oil flows and
- 7:58quotas. And so here I want to say about
- 8:02stage, which widens and, you know, oil becomes not just a
- 8:06resource, but it kind of a becomes tool of influence,
- 8:09leverage and even sometimes silence.
- 8:12So when I say Saudi Arabia is being strategic here, So what I
- 8:16mean is that they are kind no longer operating in, you know,
- 8:21in the 70s model because of oil diplomacy.
- 8:25It was a kind of a used as a production level as a blunt
- 8:29weapon at that time. Now talking about today, their
- 8:32use of oil is subtle often, you know kind of a preemptive and it
- 8:37is a deeply interwined with their foreign policy.
- 8:40Think of oil as a silencer and not a megaphone.
- 8:44And that's what happening right now.
- 8:46So let's look at the calendar. In the run up to this so-called
- 8:49production increases, the Kingdom had an extraordinary
- 8:53string of high level diplomatic engagements lined up.
- 8:57And this is I want to be very apolitical.
- 9:01So meeting with American officials, meeting with
- 9:04different countries, diplomats, strategic dialogues with UAE and
- 9:09Qatar, then the conversation with the European counterparts
- 9:13about Yemen and Sudan and more. And what's common thread among
- 9:17all those conversations, They are incredibly sensitive.
- 9:21And if oil prices had been a soaring, spiking through our
- 9:26skis or even hundreds, you can bet your last barrel that it
- 9:30would have been dominated the agenda.
- 9:33And that's the last thing Saudi Arabia wanted.
- 9:36So what did they do? They took oil off the table.
- 9:39And this is not the bold statement we can see from the
- 9:43recent interviews, from the all the diplomats you can analyze
- 9:47that oil is completely off the table.
- 9:50And it was not by undercutting their own interest, but by
- 9:53managing expectations, guiding price sentiment, and yes, even
- 9:57allowing a little extra production on a paper.
- 10:00So it's a elegant and by normalizing an increase, they
- 10:04kind of signal the price stability.
- 10:06And once you take oil volatility out of the room, those diplomats
- 10:11and then the negotiators, they can focus on security issues,
- 10:15conflict resolutions, deals and take operation.
- 10:18That's the real play here. And it's not the first time they
- 10:21have done this. During the Jinping's visit in
- 10:25Riyadh in 2022, you will notice something fascinating.
- 10:28So energy was not the centerpiece of the conversation,
- 10:32and that wasn't by accident. That was a strategic exclusion.
- 10:36So the Saudis, they didn't want oil politics muddying up deeper
- 10:39cooperation on tech, trade and infrastructure.
- 10:42And kind of a same thing with the Prime Minister Modi's visit
- 10:46in early 2024. Even in this visit, oil was
- 10:50step. The focus was mainly on
- 10:52renewable tech, collaboration, AI initiation issues and
- 10:56military trade. So Saudi Arabia has evolved.
- 10:59You no longer see, you know, oil as just a commodity they export.
- 11:04They see it as a chase piece. They can move sometimes
- 11:07assertively and then the sometimes just by not moving it
- 11:10at all. So now bring term back into the
- 11:13mix. So his second term is kind of
- 11:16unfolding and one of his corners to status is to rebuild American
- 11:21manufacturing and, you know, the energy independence.
- 11:25So the MAGA, that particular sentiment is revolved around
- 11:29these two only. So what does that mean for the
- 11:32Saudis? So, you know, it means they need
- 11:35to secure their seat at the US economic table.
- 11:38And they are doing exactly like that.
- 11:42Aramco's expansion of the Motiva refinery in Texas and when
- 11:46Aramco signs Mous with the companies like Sempra and Next
- 11:50Decade for LNG access, it's not just about the diversifying
- 11:54their portfolio, it's about embedding themselves into the US
- 11:59energy architecture. So you can, you cannot talk
- 12:02about the LNG exports from America without Saudi Arabia.
- 12:06You know being in the room that's a long term leverage.
- 12:09And you know what, we haven't even touch on the dollar 600
- 12:13billion investment place that we have seen yesterday and that's a
- 12:17massive signal to Washington. We are not just a supplier.
- 12:20We are a stakeholder. So when I say oil is being used
- 12:23by diplomatically, I mean exactly that, not through
- 12:27bombast, but through orchestration, through planning,
- 12:30through timely silence. So they are neutralizing oil as
- 12:34a disruptive topic so they can have bigger, more consequent
- 12:38conversation and, you know, conversations that shape not
- 12:42just the energy market but the global order.
- 12:44A lot of people in the oil business or oil industry, they
- 12:47kind of assume that, you know, Trump has real significance over
- 12:51OPEC. And you know, with the just one
- 12:53call, he can ask MBS to decrease oil and decrease oil production
- 12:59and, you know, kind of have a significant impact on the oil
- 13:02prices because terms always want oil prices to be lower.
- 13:06And that is the something which he kind of plays even in his
- 13:11previous term as a president. And that's what he wants to try
- 13:15that the try to renegotiate the same thing with the the global
- 13:19industry leaders. But oil is significantly absent
- 13:23from these talks because when the US president is meeting with
- 13:28Saudi Arabian, they're not just discussing about oil.
- 13:34Oil is off the topic because when the US president is, you
- 13:38know, getting in touch with the MBS, they discuss about the
- 13:42global politics, they discuss about the energy, they discuss
- 13:45about AI, they discuss about all those things.
- 13:49Then they discuss about all the topics that related to the
- 13:53future growth from the Syrian perspective, future from from
- 13:57the Lebanese perspective, then the ongoing war in South Sudan.
- 14:01So oil is just sidelined here because they don't want to mess
- 14:05up all those discussions with respect to oil.
- 14:08And the other point of view is that there are lot of important
- 14:14topics there. Those are there and there is
- 14:16utter no necessity to discuss oil at all.
- 14:19Oil can be only discussed when the there is a price.
- 14:23Those are reaching to the ceiling.
- 14:25If the price are going beyond $100, then the world leaders
- 14:29must have coming into the Saudi Arabia discussing about the oil
- 14:33and oil prices. But that is not happening.
- 14:36The other important point is this whenever a political person
- 14:40or diplomat is speaking about he always have a three type of
- 14:44thoughts or three type of weightage.
- 14:47I can say 1 is political weightage, 1 is economic
- 14:50weightage and one is financial weightage.
- 14:52So when we talk about or when, if whenever U.S.
- 14:56President talk about the about the oil, he can lose all three
- 15:01weightage in a single conversation.
- 15:03So he has to protect those weightage.
- 15:06That's why oil is now sidelined. Oil today is not just about the
- 15:10flows and prices. It's about the agendas.
- 15:12It's about the optics. It's about what you don't say as
- 15:16much as what you do. And that in my view, is one of
- 15:20the most sophisticated energy strategies being deployed
- 15:24anywhere in the world right now. Another important point is this.
- 15:28Whenever U.S. President, I mean in earlier
- 15:30terms, whenever U.S. President is going to Saudi
- 15:33Arabia, they don't just lecture about how the policies has to be
- 15:37governed and how the world should run.
- 15:40But this time, this particular scenario is completely changed.
- 15:44Trump has been viewed as a negotiated, has been viewed as a
- 15:48deal maker, has been viewed as a peacemaker.
- 15:51So it is evident that because we have seen yesterday U.S.
- 15:56President has, you know, removed the sanctions on Russia.
- 15:59And he also said that he wants to have a positive talks with
- 16:04the Iran so that you know the both the countries they can play
- 16:08a significant important role in the global markets and
- 16:12specifically in the oil markets. Now Sandesh, there's another
- 16:16story bubbling beneath all of this, which is none other than
- 16:19the sanctions and the so-called Dark Fleet.
- 16:22We see over 1100 ships operating outside the rules.
- 16:26So could you tell us what's really happening over here?
- 16:29Well, Trisha, I'm so glad you brought this up because you know
- 16:32the rise of the dark fleet is one of the most consequent and
- 16:36under appreciated shifts in the modern maritime logistics.
- 16:40And you know what? It's not just about law breaking
- 16:42ships. Those are sneaking through the,
- 16:45it's kind of about a parallel universe of oil trade that's
- 16:49grown large enough to influence the global flows.
- 16:52It is kind of a distorting prices and create massive
- 16:56systematic risk. And this isn't the subplot, it's
- 16:59kind of the hidden main event. So let's start with the what we
- 17:03know on a paper. We have analyzed the data today,
- 17:06there are about 72 tankers that are categories as sanctions
- 17:12violators to some degree and that's a massive number.
- 17:17To put in the perspective, that's nearly 1/5 of the global
- 17:21dirty tanker fleet. Now within that group or within
- 17:25that 11172 tankers, 573 tankers, those are blacklisted by the US
- 17:33Treasury of the UK's EPCDO has blacklisted 245 and then
- 17:39European Union has targeted 141. But and here is the twist, only
- 17:4634 of these ships are blacklisted by all the three.
- 17:50So what does that tell you? Out of 111 out of 100 and 172
- 17:55ships, only 34 ships sanction by all three uniquely and in
- 18:01percentage that is less than 3%. So the rest they are operating
- 18:06in a regulatory twilight zone one countries rogue is another
- 18:10regular. Now what does that mean in the
- 18:12practice? So it means that if you are a
- 18:15sanctioned Iranian tanker that has been blacked by us, but you
- 18:19have a cleverly reflect in Panama or Tanzania, you might
- 18:23still be able to load crude from Russia's the eastern ports and
- 18:27then sell it to the buyer in India or China and kind of a
- 18:31settle a transaction in yuan while all dodging the global
- 18:35financial system. And nobody, not the banks, not
- 18:39the ports, not the tracking software can easily catch you
- 18:43unless there is a serious coordination.
- 18:45And you know what, the players, those are in the place they are
- 18:48kind of actually have grown in the system that they can easily
- 18:53avoided these trackings because the coordination end to end is
- 18:59so good that you're not catch one another.
- 19:02And when even if you are trying to reach to the end of entity,
- 19:06the funds are already gone in the market.
- 19:09But it gets even more complex because these particular ships
- 19:13often operate under the forged documentation.
- 19:16So they spook their AI signals, meaning that they can disappear
- 19:20from satellite tracking for hours and even days.
- 19:23And then the swap identities in the mid ocean, conduct ship to
- 19:27ship transport in the international waters and even
- 19:30carry out their business in places where enforcement is
- 19:33almost impossible. So the Eastern Mediterranean
- 19:36Sea, the South China Sea, part of the Indian Ocean, these are
- 19:41all hotbeds for the dark activity.
- 19:43So this plate has grown not just because of because of poor
- 19:47enforcement, but because of demand exist countries that are
- 19:51under energy strain like Syria, like Venezuela's customer, like
- 19:55even some EU buyers, they are desperate, desperate for the
- 19:58discounted food stock and have looked the other way or kind of
- 20:03outright participations. And because the world's
- 20:05regulatory bodies aren't so coordinated, the dark feet
- 20:09thrives and they are kind of a thriving now and then.
- 20:13But here is what things kind of a concerning.
- 20:16We have older ships, we have single hull vessels.
- 20:20We have kind of a minimal maintained poorly crude vessels
- 20:25with the flag of convenience. There is a safety risk, there is
- 20:29a risk of oil spill, grounding on board fire pollution.
- 20:33And if you collectively see that, that's the global shipping
- 20:37crisis and we haven't even touch on insurance.
- 20:40So these ships, they are either under insured or entirely
- 20:44uninsured. So they don't carry proper
- 20:46protection and indemnity cover from any of the reputable club.
- 20:50So if something goes wrong, there is no one to foot the
- 20:53bill, no compensation, no clean up funds, nothing and nothing.
- 20:58And this has a knock on effect across the legitimate market
- 21:01because insurance they've kind of a become warrior.
- 21:05Charters have to scrutinize vessel histories more
- 21:07aggressively and rates start to reflect risk premium.
- 21:11So even innocent actors get caught in the wash because
- 21:15insurers and the financial don't want to get burned.
- 21:18So now the legitimate trades are being priced as if they are
- 21:21risky because they are sailing in the same waters as the ghost
- 21:25tankers. And having said that, it also
- 21:27kind of a was market data. If a fifth of the fleet is
- 21:32invisible or operating with the fake logs, then your supply
- 21:36estimates, your void durations, your port call data, all of it.
- 21:41Some suspect analyst can't trust the numbers.
- 21:45That makes hedging harder, that makes forecasting unreliable and
- 21:49it's like trying to trade in a fog.
- 21:52But then what is the solution that you might ask?
- 21:54The sole only solution to this is international cooperation.
- 21:58We need to harmonize the sanction list and shared
- 22:01databases. Then we have AI power tracking
- 22:05system that can spot identity fraud and transponders pooping
- 22:08in the real time. Then we need some and we need
- 22:12shipping registries, they could talk to each other and then we
- 22:16need to start holding the enables of accountable.
- 22:20And those are the banks, lawyers, the insurers who look
- 22:23the other way because the profits are too good.
- 22:26So this isn't just about morality or legality anymore,
- 22:30it's about the market functionality.
- 22:33So Dark Fleet isn't just dodging A sanction, it's distorting the
- 22:36very frack break of global oil trade.
- 22:40And the longer we let it go go uncheck, the harder it's going
- 22:44to be untangle its impact from the real economy.
- 22:48Now, Sandesh, zooming out again, how is the macroeconomic picture
- 22:53influencing all of this, right from tariffs, currency shifts,
- 22:57policy volatility? I'd like to ask, is this a new
- 23:01era? It absolutely is because we are
- 23:04living through the fragmentation of the global economy as we knew
- 23:08it for the nearly 5 decades. And what's fascinating and
- 23:12frankly disorienting for many is that we are no longer talking
- 23:16about a single global system. We are watching the emergence of
- 23:20two distinct but overlapping ecosystem and that I can call
- 23:25them as a dual energy worlds. So on one side, we have, well,
- 23:29you might call as A1 energy world.
- 23:32It's a dollar dominated, fossil fuel dominant, shaped up by
- 23:37legacy institutions like the IMF, the World Bank and decade
- 23:41of US foreign policy. This is the world where Brent
- 23:45crude prices move markets, where the energy settlements happen in
- 23:50dollars and where US interest rates hikes still ripple through
- 23:54the oil importing economies. And that's the familiar terrain
- 23:57for most traders and analysts. But now on the other side,
- 24:01something new is growing and we can call it as a new energy
- 24:05world. And you know what?
- 24:06It's yuan influenced. It's built on a solar panels,
- 24:10lithium batteries, electric vehicles and wind turbines.
- 24:14And it's deeply interwined with China's export driven industrial
- 24:18policy. And what's more, this system
- 24:21isn't just technological, it's a financial, it's a geopolitical,
- 24:25it's an industry driven. So China has spent the last
- 24:29decade locking in kind of a rare earth materials, expanding Belt
- 24:34and Road infrastructure and then creating trade agreements that,
- 24:38you know, don't depend on the dollar at all.
- 24:41So and the result is for the first time since 1970's, the
- 24:45energy market are kind of a bifurcating, not fully, not yet,
- 24:50but undeniably so. We are watching some countries,
- 24:53they haze their bets. Let me give one example, that is
- 24:57Japan. So it is buying AUSLNG and crude
- 25:00to maintain ties with the Washington while at the same
- 25:04time simultaneously investing billions into Chinese solar
- 25:08supply chains. India is also doing joint energy
- 25:11ventures with different crude and energy suppliers in the over
- 25:16the globe. But at the same time, they are
- 25:18also attending the climate summit in Brussels.
- 25:20And then let's add the Trump's economic policy to that.
- 25:24So it's a volatile cocktail of tariffs and dollar devaluation
- 25:28and then the interest rate pressures on the Fed.
- 25:31So what's it's doing, intentionally or not, is shaking
- 25:35the foundation of the dollar as the world's reserve currency.
- 25:39April 2025 was a wake up call. The dollar fell, the Treasury
- 25:44has dropped, and the equity markets tremble at the same
- 25:47time. And that's that.
- 25:48Not the normal. That's the systemic stress.
- 25:52So why does this matter for energy and shipping?
- 25:54Because the way we price and move energy is directly tied to
- 25:58the financial system. So if the dollar is under
- 26:01stress, that's affect the hedging.
- 26:03If it affects the future markets, it impacts insurance
- 26:07contracts, and then it eventually impacts the shipping
- 26:10loans. And if the country's
- 26:12increasingly settled trades in yuan, you need an entirely
- 26:15different infrastructure to manage those flood.
- 26:18Yes, we are already seeing that Sandesh.
- 26:20More LNG contracts out of China are being priced in yuan and
- 26:25even the Russian oil going to India is increasingly settled in
- 26:28Rs or UAE dirhams. And even the Chinese banks,
- 26:32they're also quietly expanding their reach into commodity
- 26:35financing. Now that means that the old
- 26:38brand Dubai spread isn't the only story anymore.
- 26:41Now we are tracking alternative benchmarks, shadow flows and off
- 26:45Ledger financing. Then the shipping routes we see
- 26:48the change take, the rerouting of the LNG cargoes which are
- 26:51away from the red seed due to the how the threats.
- 26:54Some cargoes are now rounding the Cape of Good Hope, and
- 26:58that's not just a detour, it's a signal that old assumptions
- 27:02about the choke points like Suez and Panama, they no longer hold.
- 27:06And the climate change, geopolitics and economic
- 27:09fragmentations are rewriting the map.
- 27:12And you know what, that's was the real sentiment here.
- 27:15So this new dual energy system will create winners and losers,
- 27:20Trisha. So traders who understand both
- 27:22sides of the coin or who can model dollar and non dollar
- 27:26flows or you know, who can track sanction and unsanctioned volume
- 27:31and follow not just the vessel routes but also policy
- 27:34pipelines, those traders will thrive.
- 27:36The rest they will kind of a blindsided.
- 27:39So yes, Trisha, we are in a new era.
- 27:41It's a it's uncertain, but it's also, it's also full of
- 27:45opportunity. So if you are willing to unlearn
- 27:48some of the new old rules and start reading the new ones being
- 27:51written right now, that would be a kind of a good thing from the
- 27:55market perspective. Now, Sandesh, everyone's been
- 27:58talking about the oil inventory levels these days.
- 28:01So, you know, could you maybe highlight some of the possible
- 28:05implications for the tanker market?
- 28:07Well, Trisha, you have identified another crucial
- 28:10factor and you know what that often flies under the radar in
- 28:13the mainstream market analysis, but it has a profound
- 28:17implication for shipping dynamics.
- 28:19So the current situation with distillate inventories is indeed
- 28:23concerning. Last few weeks back this
- 28:26inventories they hit 103.6 million barrels in the US and
- 28:31you know what, that was the lowest level since early May
- 28:342008 and it was a period when oil prices when approached
- 28:38record highs. So this isn't just a statistical
- 28:41anomaly, it's a warning signal with a serious implication for
- 28:44multiple sectors. Then we have a distillate which
- 28:48includes diesel fuel, heating oil and jet fuel are kind of a
- 28:51lifeblood of the industrial activity and the transportation.
- 28:55So when inventories falls this low, it indicates the potential
- 28:59supply constraint and you know what that could impact
- 29:02everything from the trucking of operations to agricultural
- 29:05equipment to maritime bunk fuels.
- 29:08So the timing is particularly problematic as we approach
- 29:12harvest season in the Northern hemisphere and when agriculture
- 29:16demand for diesel typically spikes during this.
- 29:19And at the same time we also have the travel season is coming
- 29:22and therefore there will be a significant increase in demand
- 29:27which every year we notice it's a seasonal demand pattern.
- 29:30So this both for both the reasons the diesel or the
- 29:34distillate overall demand is significantly higher.
- 29:39Now from a shipping perspective inventory situation kind of a
- 29:42create multi faceted impacts and you know it pushes scrubbers or
- 29:47the scrubber fitted vessel owners to you know to use high
- 29:51sulphur alternatives and then it can directly impact voyage
- 29:55economics and you know the overall economics of the vessel
- 29:59It will be under kind of a, we will kind of a question entire
- 30:05the fuel efficiency of that particular vessel.
- 30:08And another factor here is the tight distillate markets.
- 30:12They often trigger changes in the refinery operation as you
- 30:15know the operator adjust the crude slates and the processing
- 30:19configurations, you know, to maximize distillate yields.
- 30:23So this adjustment can alter demand patterns for different
- 30:26crude grades and then eventually impact tanker deployment
- 30:29strategies. We know that from the actual
- 30:32procurement to to until the processing in the refinery,
- 30:36there is significant gap almost six to seven months gap is there
- 30:40for the utilization of that actual crude because the supply
- 30:45chain process and then the storage kind of takes a time.
- 30:48But eventually refiner has to adjust these strategies and then
- 30:53it has a significant impact on the tanker market.
- 30:56Then we have a regional imbalance in the distillatory
- 30:59availability in the different parts of the world.
- 31:01So, so the pricing sentiments that prevails in around the
- 31:05product market creates arbitrage for some traders and importers.
- 31:10So due to that sometimes the prices are so favourable for
- 31:15them that the entire tanker product tanker movement that
- 31:19shifts around those particular traders and importers and it can
- 31:23drive the tanker market movements.
- 31:25So we have seen there has been a particularly evident in the
- 31:29transatlantic movements with you know European refiners
- 31:32increasing diesel export to the US East Coast to capitalize on
- 31:36attractive pricing differentials.
- 31:38We have inventory in the Cushing, USA critical benchmark
- 31:42U.S. oil storage, which have also dropped below the five
- 31:45years average range. And while they are not yet at
- 31:48the crisis level, this tight knits, this tight knits may
- 31:52create some potential vulnerabilities, particularly if
- 31:55we see the disruption to the Canadian imports which typically
- 31:59feed these facilities. So what makes this inventory
- 32:02situation particularly noteworthy is that so it's
- 32:06occurring despite OPEC Plus decisions to increase the
- 32:09production. So this apparent contract
- 32:12prediction is resolved when we understand that production
- 32:16increases don't immediately translate into the inventory
- 32:19builds and there are significant lags in the system due to the
- 32:23transportation times, refinery processing and then the
- 32:26distribution logistic. So additionally, as we discussed
- 32:30earlier, much of the production increase is being absorbed by
- 32:34the domestic consumption in the producing countries rather than
- 32:38it's reaching the global market. So the market is beginning to
- 32:42recognize this fundamentals and which explains why oil prices
- 32:46have risen since the OPEC Plus announcement despite initial
- 32:50bearish reactions. So contrary to the predictions
- 32:53that prices would fall to the fees, the limited impact of the
- 32:57production adjustment and then the positive news regarding the
- 33:01tariff reduction has shifted with the market sentiments.
- 33:04Our audience should know that while we are recording, we have
- 33:08just came under news that there will be a dropping of sanctions
- 33:12in Syria and at the same times there is a there will be a
- 33:16reduction in tariff against China.
- 33:18So these two things it will be going to play very well in the
- 33:21global oil market if we have to see the future or if we can
- 33:27analyze the future market. Looking ahead, OPEC Plus latest
- 33:31monthly report provides the, you know, important context.
- 33:35So they have lowered their 2025 forecast for oil supply growth
- 33:39from non OPEC Plus producer to 800,000 barrels per day, down
- 33:45from 900,000 barrels per day previously.
- 33:48So this reduction reflects expected declines in the capital
- 33:52spending and it was mostly due to the falling oil prices and
- 33:56you know it could eventually help OPEC Plus stabilize the
- 33:58market over the medium term. And also I want to mention
- 34:02another important factor, OPEC anticipate a 5% drop in non OPEC
- 34:08Plus exploration and production investment in 2025 despite a $3
- 34:13billion rise in 2024. So this investment pattern will
- 34:18ultimately impact production capabilities with you know the
- 34:22implications they're kind of extending well beyond the
- 34:26current inventory situation. So the projected growth in non
- 34:30OPEC supply for 2025 and 2026, it shows the United States
- 34:37leading with the increase of with increase of 0.33 and 0.28
- 34:42million barrels per day respectively.
- 34:44And it is followed by countries like you know Brazil, Canada,
- 34:48Argentina, they are contributing smaller but eventually a
- 34:52significant volumes. So for shipping markets this
- 34:56supply projections, it create the planning framework for fleet
- 35:00deployment strategies. The geographic distribution of
- 35:04this particular production growth, it kind of a heavily
- 35:07weighed toward the Americas and it suggests that the continued
- 35:12strength in this specific trading routes, particularly
- 35:15those connecting North and South American production to the Asian
- 35:19consumption centers. So this has direct implications
- 35:23for the vessel segment performance with the two of the
- 35:27largest VLCC and Swizmax they likely benefiting from the these
- 35:32particular long haul movements. So while inventory levels might
- 35:35seem like a technical detail compared to the headline
- 35:39grabbing geopolitical developments, they provide a
- 35:42critical insight into underlying fundamentals.
- 35:45And you know what, this will drive both energy and shipping
- 35:49markets in the coming quarters. Savvy market participant are
- 35:54kind of a paying close attention to these inventory tents because
- 35:58they formulate their operation and investment strategy around
- 36:01that. So Sandesh, let's close out with
- 36:04what's next for our listeners, traders, owners, analysts and
- 36:09more. Could you tell us what's the
- 36:10next 6 to 12 month outlook? Well, Trisha, this is 1,000,000
- 36:15barrel question and I will say a friend, no one has a crystal
- 36:18ball. But what we can do is read the
- 36:21signs and if you know where to look, those signs are everywhere
- 36:26on the water, in the inventories, in the courtrooms
- 36:29and even in the ballot boxes. So let's begin with the US
- 36:32shell. For more than a decade, shale
- 36:35was the swing producer and it kind of a filled the gap when
- 36:39OPEC plus cut or you know, when demand spiked.
- 36:42That era is kind of a ending, not because shale is
- 36:45disappearing, it's still a giant, but because it's becoming
- 36:50constrained. The geology it's matching up
- 36:53shale as is having high decline rates specifically in the
- 36:57Permian mean that you have to constantly reinvest just to keep
- 37:01the production flat. But investor now are tired of
- 37:04that model and they won't returns not the volume.
- 37:07So the capital is kind of a drying up and this is this is
- 37:11specifically for the Shell, not for the traditional producing
- 37:15wells. And then there is a
- 37:17consolidation. We are seeing big mergers, Exxon
- 37:20buying pioneers, Chevron snapping up Hess.
- 37:24So when majors, because these are the big companies, we call
- 37:28them, they call them as oil majors.
- 37:29So when these majors they take over from independence, they
- 37:33bring a discipline. So they don't drill just to
- 37:36grow, they drill to deliver dividends.
- 37:39And you know that's why there is a change in the tempo which we
- 37:43feel across the entire industry in the shell business.
- 37:46So when we look at the forecast, US production is kind of a
- 37:50plateauing and that means the global market they can't rely on
- 37:55Texas to save days anymore. So the world has to look
- 37:58elsewhere. When we say the elsewhere it
- 38:01bring us to the new frontiers and three guys that could help
- 38:05this frontier will be Brazil, Guyana and Namibia.
- 38:09So Brazil, they have a kind of a pre salt field.
- 38:12They are producing some of the lowest cost offshore barrels on
- 38:17the planet. And then we have a Guyana is on
- 38:20kind of a meteoric crisis. Exxon and Hayes have unlocked a
- 38:24basic with over 11 billion barrels of reserves.
- 38:27And then Namibia, we are just scratching the surface, but
- 38:32early results are kind of a promising and then we could be
- 38:35looking at the next great deep water province.
- 38:38So these regions matter because they are kind of a shaping the
- 38:42future trade routes. So more S Atlantic oil means
- 38:46more tankers moving West to east, they kind of having longer
- 38:50voyages, they kind of adding greater demand for Aframax and
- 38:54VLCC and that is a good for shipping.
- 38:57But it also means that geopolitical events in Latin
- 39:01America specifically elections then the regulatory changes and
- 39:05environmental policies will start to have outsized impact on
- 39:10the global oil balances. Now zooming in on inventories
- 39:14pushing the key hub, it has been hovering below the five year
- 39:17average and which we have discussed earlier.
- 39:20So if we get a hot summer or a cold snap in Q4, we could see
- 39:24the price spikes that catch markets off guard.
- 39:28And then we have a LNG that's a kind of a wild card with, you
- 39:32know, Egypt, it flipping from exporter to importer with
- 39:35shipping routes dodging the Suez and Panama canals.
- 39:38And with countries like Ukraine, Iraq and Morocco emerging as a
- 39:42surprise importers. The LNG map is kind of a
- 39:45shifting fast. And add to that the delays in
- 39:48the North American projects and you get a setup where spot LNG
- 39:52prices could jump overnight if Asia has a hot summer or if
- 39:56Europe has faces pipeline disruptions.
- 39:59And then let's not let's not forget the politics.
- 40:02Yes, elections is already over. Trump is making a kind of a.
- 40:07Volatility in the market with his speeches and we don't know
- 40:11what he will be going to speak next day.
- 40:13Then we have a sanctions enforcement with OFAC and then
- 40:17the US, Iran diplomacy is again kind of a still shaky subject.
- 40:22We don't know whether it will be a fruitful conversation among
- 40:26Iran and US and Venezuela negotiation, they are still
- 40:29going on, still pending, not a significant deal enriched till
- 40:34date. So all of these have energy
- 40:36consequences and one shift in the Washington tone could add or
- 40:41remove 1 or 2 million barrels per day from the market.
- 40:44And the same with the India, Pakistan tensions, you know one
- 40:47mistake and you rerouting half of the region's trade.
- 40:51But let me leave the listeners with this.
- 40:54Volatility is here to stay and the age of predictability is
- 40:58behind us. New normal is kind of a
- 41:00disruption layered on top of transformation.
- 41:03But within that we can say that it lies the opportunity.
- 41:07So for this means reading not just the data, but the nuance.
- 41:12And for ship owners, it means watching not just the routes but
- 41:16regulations. And for analyst, it means
- 41:18throwing out the old models and building new ones.
- 41:21They should be flexible, they should be dynamic and they
- 41:24should be globally aware. To summarize, next 6 to 12
- 41:28months, expect surprises, expectation.
- 41:31But if you stay informed, if you stay agile and you want to see
- 41:35survive, you will thrive. Sandesh.
- 41:38There was nothing short of extraordinary.
- 41:40We started with what looked like a simple production headline and
- 41:44ended up navigating the full spectrum of global trade, energy
- 41:47diplomacy, and the maritime transformation.
- 41:50And that's exactly what we aim on Cycle C Trade Podcast, to
- 41:54take our audience beneath the surface, beyond the headline,
- 41:58and into the currents shaping the future.
- 42:00Thank you Trisha for inviting me.
- 42:02It's been an absolute pleasure. The coming days is going to test
- 42:06all of us, our models, our assumptions and even our nose.
- 42:10So, but it's also going to be reward those who adapt early
- 42:14because we are not just watching a market which is evolving, we
- 42:18are watching a world realign. Absolutely.
- 42:21And to all our listeners, thank you for sticking with us on this
- 42:24deep dive. If you found value in this
- 42:26episode, share it and do subscribe.
- 42:28We'll be back next time with more insights, more context, and
- 42:32more voices from the front lines of the global energy and
- 42:34shipping universe. Until next time, this is the
- 42:38Cycle Sea Trade podcast. Stay informed, stay sharp, and
- 42:41as always, sale smart.